ToffeeWeb Player of the Season

, 7 May, 34comments  |  Jump to most recent

The battle for whom TW readers felt was Everton's best player of the season predictably came down to two players who had outstanding campaigns: James McCarthy and Seamus Coleman, with the latter of the two Republic of Ireland internationals winning the poll handily.

The 25 year-old has weighed in with seven goals in all competitions from right back and has cemented his credentials as the best player in his position in the Premier League by being named in the PFA Team of the Year last week.

Costing just £60,000 when he joined the Blues from Sligo Rovers five years ago — a bargain not lost on Evertonians who have now enshrined that excellent piece of business in a terrace chant — Coleman has become an vital component in Roberto Martinez's more expansive Everton team and his consistency this term is reflected in the accolades now coming his way.

Coleman collected 48% of the 6,000+ votes in ToffeeWeb's Player of the Month vote, with McCarthy a solid runner up with 30%. Gareth Barry was third with 8%.

View full results



Reader Comments (34)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brian Murray
1 Posted 07/05/2014 at 19:02:47
Well done, Seamus... Is Seamus the first Irish player to win Player of the of Year?
Nick Entwistle
2 Posted 07/05/2014 at 19:36:41
Best player yes, but most important was Lukaku. Gave us the edge up front when we could have been stuck with Jelichebe.

Martin Handley
3 Posted 07/05/2014 at 19:50:27
Well deserved and a thoroughly nice bloke to boot!
Eugene Ruane
4 Posted 07/05/2014 at 19:40:32
Well done Seamus Coleman, he got my vote.

Not so long ago, I (like many) thought ’great attitude but he’ll never make a full-back’, so it’s been incredible to watch a player go from someone whose inclusion made me nervous to a player whose exclusion would now make me feel the same way.

I can’t really remember seeing an Everton player improve SO much.

(from from first appearance to peak - Ratcliffe maybe and/or Joe Parkinson).

Andy Crooks
5 Posted 07/05/2014 at 20:02:31
I knew he would make it. Never doubted it for one minute. Well done, Seamus.
Brian Denton
6 Posted 07/05/2014 at 20:02:12
Eugene, yes Ratcliffe was pretty dire when he started. But if I recall correctly he was mostly played at left back in those days.

I voted for Seamus too.

Steven Telford
7 Posted 07/05/2014 at 20:35:41
I voted twice, Once on my laptop, and once on my work PC. Once for Coleman, and once for McCarthy, because I felt it was close to a tie.

60,000 bargain of the century!
Cheaper than Cantona!

Brian Furey
8 Posted 07/05/2014 at 20:49:29
I hear he wants to come back to Sligo now that he proved to himself he could do it.
Peter Warren
9 Posted 07/05/2014 at 21:21:28
Was it last season when we played Leeds in the League Cup? I thought he will never be a full back.

I voted for him, what a terrific player and seems genuinely a good guy. In fact most our team seem down to earth genuine lads led by a iconic manager. Very happy & excited blue!

Tony Abrahams
10 Posted 07/05/2014 at 21:37:50
Good point, Nick (#2): people say that Lukaku is not worth the money and they wouldn’t buy him but am not so sure. For a 20-year-old to play up top by himself in a team that is chasing Champions League football is not easy. He also scored against all the top teams and won’t be easy to replace.

Coleman has been a revelation and now helps create a very solid backbone of fine young talent that Everton now possess. McCarthy will hopefully improve his offensive game, but that’s also not easy when you do so much doggy work for the team.

Let’s see how much the manager gets to spend because this team is not that far away from success at the moment!

Keith Glazzard
11 Posted 07/05/2014 at 22:31:16
Two very good players. I’m trying to remember which one I voted for now.

And they seem to be good guys, as well as winners, which is important.

Si Cooper
12 Posted 07/05/2014 at 22:49:56
Surely this season the system (Barry and McCarthy enabled) means that Seamus can flourish by attacking at every opportunity without having to worry overly much about his defensive duties - the role has been adjusted to suit him rather than he having to adjust to suit the role.

Personally, I have always thought he had enough natural defensive ability apart from a tendency to leap in when having to chase back. Has superb stamina, recovery pace and will mature even more. He (with the manager’s help?) has significantly improved his composure on the ball and decision making to become an important attacking threat (which is why he got my vote).

Colin Glassar
13 Posted 07/05/2014 at 23:08:33
I voted for McCarthy as this is his first season with us and it’s like he’s been here for years. Seamus was a very close second though.
James Carlisle
14 Posted 07/05/2014 at 23:22:24
I voted for "¾ of the earth is covered by water, the rest is covered by" James McCarthy. Whenever he hasn’t played we’ve really missed him. He’s more than just a headless chicken hard worker.

But if I’d have chosen anyone else it would’ve been Seamus. Easily been the best full back in the league this season. While in the past he just ran and relied heavily on his pace (often running the ball out), he’s developed a great touch and is unafraid to take defenders on with skill. Well done to him!

Mike Childs
15 Posted 07/05/2014 at 23:22:47
Well deserved. Some of his take-ons this season were so beautiful, they just about brought tears to my eyes. I must admit though, I voted for McCarthy. I didn’t keep count but I’d venture he saved about 5 plus sure goals inside the box besides his midfield duties.

Both of them have such fantastic motors and both give their all for the team. We’re so lucky to have them both. Hopefully we can poach McManaman from Wigan this year.

Kieran Riding
16 Posted 07/05/2014 at 23:38:04
Just seen MotD’s "Saves of the Season".

Our defence is so good Tim’s not even on it!!

Kieran Riding
18 Posted 08/05/2014 at 01:14:33
http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=SQzJRlT9FFw

Bobby’s montage..

Kieran Riding
19 Posted 08/05/2014 at 01:18:01
Player of the year...

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ii5WZPw_6gI

Eugene Ruane
20 Posted 08/05/2014 at 01:23:18
Funny YouTuber of the year?

Whoever put this together...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mfS5uumGu7Q&feature=youtube_gdata_player&app=desktop

Kieran Riding
21 Posted 08/05/2014 at 01:29:23
Saw that on Twitter last night, Eugene... Ace!

I’m loathed to laugh just yet like... As it’ll bite me right on the arsey playing it dead cool with the reds here.

(Did you see that lad with the massive head in their crowd though??)

Kieran Riding
22 Posted 08/05/2014 at 01:46:27
You may just giggle at this too..

https://vine.co/v/M6MtJ3gTePl

Andy Meighan
24 Posted 08/05/2014 at 07:44:35
Coleman's been a model of consistency all season apart from that abortion at Soton a couple of weeks back but we'll forgive him for that and he's a deserved winner.

Kieran (#21), yes I seen ol' big head and his cohorts in the crowd when Palace scored... in fact, I've watched it loads of times. Now I'm nothing to write home about myself but that crew make me look like George Clooney. My god, the dark side do attract some fanny magnets, don't they.

Tony J Williams
25 Posted 08/05/2014 at 12:34:36
Deserved it just for the confusion at which way to run after Oviedo scored at Old Trafford.
John Scott
26 Posted 08/05/2014 at 12:53:52
Tony, Yes that was an iconic Everton moment that gets funnier every time you watch it.
James Lauwervine
27 Posted 08/05/2014 at 13:42:04
The combined distance of Seamus's runs this season would reach the moon and back. A hard-working, honest and skilful player. I'm not a fan of the term 'great engine' but he's got the best I've ever seen. I love him even more when he fucks up because you can see what it means to him.

Having said all that, I voted for Distin.

James Marshall
28 Posted 08/05/2014 at 14:39:32
Sixty grand, sixty grand Seamus Coleman!

I don't really have anything further to add, other than that YouTube video Eugene posted is fucking gold :-)

Ian Burns
29 Posted 08/05/2014 at 15:19:53
Seamus got my vote and I am delighted he won the TW Vote. Having said that if McCarthy had won it, no complaints from me. Two great blues.

Love the YouTube Eugene!!

Trevor Lynes
30 Posted 08/05/2014 at 16:34:14
Congratulations to Mr Coleman for his well earned accolade.

I was particularly happy to see Collins voted into EFC history as a giant of our club. Catterick was totally out of order by letting him go so soon. Along with Vernon and Young, he was the one of that triangle of excellence. In reality, they were without any doubt the best inside forwards and strikers I have ever seen at the club.

Other players have had decent seasons but in actuality Vernon and Collins were ahead of Young to my mind because they both always enjoyed derby games and performed well in them.

Collins went to Leeds much too soon and the great Don Revie described him as his best ever signing. I think he left us just after the ’62 season in which we finished 4th and played the best sustained football I have ever seen from Everton.

Collins won the PFA Player of the Year in 1965. A small, barrel-chested man with a huge heart who dribbled well, tackled tenaciously and spread passes as well as Scholes. He also scored 47 goals which were about one in every three games he played.

I once saw him jump on the back of big Ron Yeats and pull him over (they each got up laughing). Collins was a fantastic player in any era!

Alex Jones
31 Posted 08/05/2014 at 20:34:08
Coleman for me was our most consistent performer this season and so was the deserved winner.

I cannot understand how McCarthy is second though? The primary aim of any football team is to score goals and a secondary aim is to not concede them. This is why the best players in the world are generally attacking players, as that job of scoring and making goals is harder and ultimately more important.

I'm not sure I've seen an Everton midfielder in recent years (besides perhaps Carsley) who has contributed so little to this primary aim of scoring than James McCarthy. The lad has had 4 shots on goal all season and yet some people think he's been our best player!

He has a fantastic engine and gets around the pitch a lot but he just does not contribute to us scoring goals ever and personally I'm a bit disappointed for £13 mill. Fitness and a 'hardworking' attitude is a given for a 23-year-old midfielder imo and you want a bit more for that kind of money. He takes the ball in space and lays it off backwards or sideways in a negative way and I just don't like to see that kind of passing. The best players relieve pressure by taking the ball under pressure and moving it forwards to players in space and he does the opposite of that.

I do think there is a more dynamic midfielder in there and hopefully he'll grow into that role more next season, but for £13 mill I want a more finished article.

Shane Corcoran
32 Posted 09/05/2014 at 15:33:17
What's the 60k Coleman song or what's the tune that it goes along to?
Eric Myles
33 Posted 09/05/2014 at 15:54:26
Alex #31, didn't we pay more for Fellaini to do exactly the same?
Andrew Ellams
34 Posted 09/05/2014 at 15:55:18
Alex, the best players in the world are attacking players only because the media tells you they are. There are goalkeepers and defenders out there who are as every bit of good in their positions as the some the best attackers are in theirs.
Tim Greeley
35 Posted 10/05/2014 at 04:08:18
Seamus is the shit. Almost inspirational if one were open to such sap. His highlight reel for this season must be awesome.

Distin was my 2nd choice and Lukaku 3rd.

Saw photos of the Awards dinner, looked a good time. Vellios was shotgunning Miller High Lifes like he was a month from deportation.

Steavey Buckley
36 Posted 13/05/2014 at 05:26:16
The stats showed that Lukaku was the most influential player during the 2013-14 season. Everton won far more games when he played than when he was injured or was not included for the first 3 games that were drawn. His goal return of 15 in 29 matches (ratio greater than 1:2) is the best return for an Everton striker for a long time.

I voted for him, but he only received 1% of the votes cast for ToffeeWeb Player of the season. Have Everton fans been watching a different player to the one I was watching? He will certainly be missed and the goals he scored if he does not return next season.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb