Matthaus: England should put faith in Ross Barkley and Co

, 8 May, 26comments  |  Jump to most recent
Citing Ross Barkley as a classic example, Germany legend Lothar Matthaus argues that England should follow his country's example between 2000 and 2010 and focus on youth.
If England want to continue coming home from major tournaments after two weeks and watching the final on TV, there is a simple enough way. Keep ignoring top young talent like Ross Barkley and Luke Shaw.

» Read the full article at Daily Mail



Reader Comments (26)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Derek Thomas
1 Posted 08/05/2014 at 10:23:21
Always assuming that Hodson knows his best starting 11, that leaves 12 places, minus 2 for keepers gives us 10.

Plenty enough to fit in 3 or even 4 youngsters and still have enough experienced cover.

Barkley is in much the same position Re. Hodson & England as he was with Moyes & Everton 18 mths. back.

Martinez proved that you learn by doing and there's no learning like on the job learning...

Kids eh. Some say you win nothing with kids... but in some cases there is nothing to beat the arrogance (some might say ignorance) of youth... look at me you old arses, I'm bullet proof, I know everything, just gimme the ball à la Rooney 2004. Nothing terrifies defenders more than young fast unpredictable legs running the ball at them.

I doubt he will pick 4 or 5 of the players touted in the press and if he does there is no chance he will start with more than one. But to have Barkley and Sterling on the bench can't be bad They can't do any worse than some we've seen over the years.

And also, if I remember correctly, in the last (in a long line of) England penalty fails, the only 2 to score were Scousers (Steve Me and Rooney) add Baines and Barkley (and maybe Lambert) there's 4 or 5 certs.

Over to you, Roy.

Brian Harrison
2 Posted 08/05/2014 at 11:04:24
We have seen for the last few tournaments England failing miserably even though the managers have picked largely the squad that most expected. The so-called golden generation have delivered nothing, so maybe it is time to give the youngsters a go... let's face it: no European Country has ever won a World Cup in South America.

We never seem to learn; apparently Jones has injured his shoulder so some of the press are saying Roy should ask Terry to go to Brazil. This guy refused to play for his country and now they want to go cap in hand to him, for me John Stones would be a better option, at least he will learn from the experience and is still young enough to play in the next three World Cups.

Paul Smith
3 Posted 08/05/2014 at 11:57:15
If I was the England manager I would be looking to take as few over the age of 30 as possible due to the heat.

My team in a 4-3-2-1 formation would be as follows:

Hart; Clyne, Cahill, Jagielka, Baines; Gerrard, Henderson, Barkley; Rooney, Sterling; Sturridge.

This team (apart from Gerrard) have all got good legs and most will be available for the next couple of tournaments. In a couple of years, Stones will replace Jagielka and Gerrard will need replacing but with Lallana as backup as well, I think this is the way forward.

Dave Lynch
4 Posted 08/05/2014 at 11:56:46
No chance of England even getting out of the group, never mind winning the World Cup. Anyone who thinks we have a chance in the tournament is either deluded or plain stupid, Hodgson will take his tried and trusted failures and erm....... Fail.

I still smile when I remember Rooney walking off in South Africa moaning about being booed after another dismal display by the best England could offer.

Tom Bowers
5 Posted 08/05/2014 at 12:00:53
Regardless of the squad I cannot see England doing well. Gerrard is past his best and playing in defence is not going to help England. I do believe however that some youngsters should be persevered with as some of the experienced players are just not up to it.

I would have liked Kyle Walker to be fit and a fully fit Wilshere along with the third ''W'' Theo Walcott. John Stones could go along for the experience as he has been playing as well as any centre back and certainly Ross should go.
Sturridge is a shoe-in and I would have liked Welbeck but he hasn't really had a chance to shine during the Manure Moyes era. I think the offence area will be weak for England.

Norman Merrill
6 Posted 08/05/2014 at 17:17:20
Like Dave Lynch, I to feel that Roy Hodgson will go with tried & trusted, NOT tried & Successful?
I can't agree with taking Lampard, he looks well past his best, but press experts say it experience that counts.
"Stevie Me" although not past his best will struggle in the heat,
I would like to see Ross included in squad, his skill alone will benefit, as for John Stones, I don't think Hodgson will take a chance on two unknowns at International level, especially in a tournament, like World Cup.
But if the injury to Jones & Walker are not cleared up, then he may include John, because he is versatile.
As for the progressing, well England's group is tough, & even Costa Rica will give them a run.
I hope I'm wrong, but can't see us doing anything special.
Brian Waring
7 Posted 08/05/2014 at 17:48:42
I heard Luke Shaw isn't going to be picked, it's Cole and Baines. Barkley is borderline because if he goes Hodgson feels he would have to leave Lampard at home and he doesn't want to contemplate doing that.
Brian Hill
8 Posted 08/05/2014 at 18:42:31
Hodgson is no different to any other recent England manager. He will choose the same miserable failures as his predecessors, Gerrard included, and then lament after the inevitable humiliation, that "I picked the best players".
Colin Glassar
9 Posted 08/05/2014 at 19:02:06
We all know gerrard, Lampard and glass ankles Wilshere will go. It would be a great experience for Ross but I think I'd prefer him to stay home with his mum and get some decent kip after a long season.
James McPherson
10 Posted 08/05/2014 at 19:13:22
Each to their own is a fair principle. However, never ceases to astound me as to why any Everton fan shows the remotest interest in Ingurland. The track record is there for all to see.....Everton unearth a gem, or improve an existing player....fans talk player up....lazy journos on a backhander from dodgy agent talk player up even more...player gets in squad...player's head turned by fellow Ingurland players acting on behalf of dodgy agents...player leaves Everton...to be repeated endlessly. I want Baines, Barkley and Jagielka with their feet up and get raring to go come August. Sod England. Will not win the thing so what's the point?
Brian Hill
11 Posted 08/05/2014 at 19:07:26
I do not understand the concept of "going for the experience". Experience of what? Watching the same failures fail again? We can all experience that through TV. Does Barkley really need to spend two weeks in Brazil in order to understand that England has been failing as a football nation largely because of the likes of Me-la and Lamps rather than in spite of their legendary genius?
James McPherson
12 Posted 08/05/2014 at 19:23:13
See Lineker is at it now, proposing that Hodgson includes Stones in the squad. Interesting, just as Stones is in the transition of changing agents. I can see it now, as ToffeeWebbers get all excited as Atones dons the 3 Lions...."I would like to thank Roberto Martinez for giving me a chance...I will never forget the faith and trust he put in me...." cue Bentley disappearing down M1, east along the M62...then cue same Toffewebbers citing "scumbag"..."louse"...roll forward next world cup....cue clamour for more EFC players to go to the tournament....you could not make it up
Phil Sammon
13 Posted 08/05/2014 at 19:46:43
This is why the FA massively balls'd up when they picked Hodgson. I actually don't mind the guy but he has the here and now in mind, not the next 8 - 10 years. We should have gone for much younger manager with the vision and ability to implement a long-term plan.

Lampard, Gerrard, Cole and even Rooney would not get anywhere near an England team if I were in charge (which I obviously will be one day). Not because of a lack of ability, but because of their attitude. It's time we planned ahead and filled the team with the right characters (to use a Martinez term).

Eugene Ruane
14 Posted 08/05/2014 at 19:22:15
Really looking forward to the world cup as it kills a month of time between the end of the season and the start of the next (can't stand those football free summers).

Plus I love the idea of it being held in Brazil (not really sure why, it just seems more 'exotic' than France or Germany).

That said, some of the football at the last one was just...frustrating.

I remember one game, possibly Spain-Germany (memory goosed but certainly two of the better teams) when for about 10 minutes, nothing at all happened, other than two technically proficient sides cancelling each other out.

Ball rolled out by keeper, defender advances with ball, opposition front-line presses high, ball (eventually) goes back, keeper rolls ball out to different defender (continues indefinitely or until boot has gone through telly).

It was as though they were all too..um..fit or well-organised I suppose - very few of the mistakes that can make a game exciting.

You see it a lot now I suppose, every attacker receiving the ball with his back to goal has a defender glued to him, meaning no room to turn so ball has to go back.

I remember being really kind of narked watching it.

Seemed at times the only change would be the attacker turning in such a way as to tempt the foul and (deliberately try to) win a free kick

As for England, well as the world's least patriotic person, I couldn't give a flying fuck what they do as far as results go (and if I'm honest, cheering for any team with Gerrard in it just isn't in me).

I simply hope all the Everton players involved enjoy the experience and come back injury free.

Up the Toffees!

Graham Mockford
15 Posted 08/05/2014 at 20:13:57
The most depressing thing I've read was Stuart Pearce's preferred squad. He included Cole, Smalling, Jones, Lampard, Wellbeck and Henderson.

The man in charge of turning our young talent into future internationals doesn't trust young players. You couldn't make it up.

After 48 years of failure let's keep sticking with the old guard and good steady English players. They don't like it up 'em them foreign fancy dans. FFS !

David Bryant
16 Posted 08/05/2014 at 20:26:03
Eugene @ 14 - nail on head. Crease Head and the other 'Golden Generation' members are not who I want representing me thank you very much!
Nick Entwistle
17 Posted 08/05/2014 at 20:37:51
The boy Lineker here http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/27321845 is doing his best to promote the chances of John Stones to board the flight to Brazil.

I cannot see why players who have had so little time to prove themselves in the top flight should ever be called up into the national squad.

The debutantes over the last ten years who haven't fulfilled their potential make a long and sorry list. They would have already been rich beyond their dreams and an untimely England call-up only lets them know they've really made it!

Barkley and Sterling will probably make the plane because attacking players are few and far between for England, but to bring in Stones is as crazy as Walcott in 2006. At least he would have been free to play as he liked on the wing, not part of a defensive unit.

And that is something Stones hasn't always been able to do this season. Despite his obvious potential he's what you might call a highlights player.

Players shouldn't be called up for England before they've shown at least three solid seasons of top flight football. Make them earn their chance.

Lineker was 24, had already scored over 50 goals with two promotions and a relegation under his belt. Stones has brought the ball out of defence eight or nine times and that looks really really good on Match of the Day.

Mike Hughes
18 Posted 08/05/2014 at 20:45:33
International football bores me stupid - especially England.
Mind you, I still remember watching the 1974 World Cup in our house in Bootle when I was 8. The theme tune was great and still remember it - Johan Cruyff et al.

I'll take a passing interest in Costa Rica this year and will watch the occasional game for a few minutes.

The best thing about the last World Cup (for me) was listening to the after-match phone-ins on R5L in the evening with a beer or two. Almost as funny as a Lee Mack gig but unintentionally so.

Thankfully I haven't seen any England car flags yet - but it'll start to get ramped-up on Monday after the Premiership is all over.

Graham Mockford
19 Posted 08/05/2014 at 20:45:56
Nick

Spoken like a true Englishman, we have zero chance of achieving anything this World Cup so why not blood a few younger players who might actually be the future rather than sticking with the old guard.

You need some experience otherwise letting a team of youngsters get twatted by Italy and Uruguay would probably not be great for them.

But I would take Barkley, Stones, Shaw, Flanagan, Wilshere, Sterling as a minimum. Probably only Sterling makes the starting XI but at least it shows some fucking intent to progress.

It won't happen of course because Hodgson knows he gets destroyed if we don't make it through the group stages so he will play it safe. Serious lack of vision for me.

Sam Hoare
20 Posted 08/05/2014 at 21:12:07
Bizarrely I feel this England team might surprise a few people. Totally without evidence or any logical basis other than the liberation of such low expectations. Either way Hodgson really should take the likes of Barkley, Stones and Shaw as these players look most likely to be the ones capable of pushing England forward over the next decade.
Nick Entwistle
21 Posted 08/05/2014 at 21:29:17
Vision is need Graham. The old guard should have been done away with years ago!

Shaw has put in two excellent seasons but Stones would be called up on potential alone and that is wrong. Let the potential bare out.

Young talent for England means 22-24. Blood them at the start of qualifying. So Stones shouldn't be blooded until after the next Euros.

I don't get players needing to have 'tournament experience' so to be ready for the next tournament. Waste of a squad number. Would George Best have been rubbish at a world cup?

Raymond Fox
22 Posted 08/05/2014 at 21:18:51
Every World Cup or European Championship played since 1966 there has been optimism that England will do well.

What happens every time? — They're an embarrassment to watch... Why? Because they haven't the ball skills to keep hold of the ball.

Nothing much has changed in 48 years; prepare to be embarrassed once more!

There's a million-to-one chance, no-one would go skint laying them.

Nick Entwistle
23 Posted 08/05/2014 at 21:30:12
Sam, I don't think England will get as far the QF, but agree with you.

The old 'golden generation' went off to tournament after tournament (if they qualified) scared to play. Three reason.

1, The only time we'd play top seeds out of tournaments was in friendlies, so without taking them seriously people wondered why we'd lose in the QFs.

2, No England players were the main man for their club side (Only perhaps Lampard and the wee slip of a boy at Anfield but playing together negated their qualities). There were always better foreigners they could pass the ball off too so no England player was willing to grab the game by the balls. Infact it was only Rooney at Everton in 04 when you could say this happened.

3, The failed generation had their egos based around their celebrity. A reflection of that is something like Footballers' Wives wouldn't be made now as it isn't so relevant. When they became exposed to their own selves without a Drogba, Ronaldo or Alonso to create a spark they went into hiding.

Anyway, point being is that with only 4 at most remaining they need to be passed over, let the new mind set take place. The kids won't play scared.

Jon Ferguson
24 Posted 08/05/2014 at 21:42:34
We're not going to win this time and so give the players who'll be ready next time tournament experience.

Sterling
Llana Rooney Sterling
Henderson Barkley
Shaw Cahill Stones Walker
Hart

Kieran Riding
25 Posted 08/05/2014 at 21:52:41
Mr Matthaus.

I remember seeing you bossed all over Goodison in 85.

Why should we believe you over Peter Reid?

Brian Cleveland
26 Posted 09/05/2014 at 06:11:23
For me it's not about taking all the kids or all the old fogies, it's a balance. Take the best of the youngsters who are in good form, and put them next to one or two experienced players to help them...

and nobody has mentioned it here... but after the season he has had Barry would not be a bad bet. Cool head and if you want to take some young guns he is the right kind of player to put alongside them and direct them....

I really didn't get him before this season... but I do now

and so it is much to my own surprise that I find myself nominating Mr Gareth Barry. Anyone like to second the motion?.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb