Barkley named in England's World Cup squad

, 12 May, 81comments  |  Jump to most recent
Stones on standby for Brazil

The inclusion of Ross Barkley in Roy Hodgson's 23-man England squad alongside Everton teammates Phil Jagielka and Leighton Baines has been confirmed this afternoon.

The 20 year-old told evertontv of his delight at the decision saying it means "everything" to him and that it would be the best thing to have happened to him should he get to play in Brazil this summer.

John Stones has been ear-marked on the reserve list as a potential replacement for Manchester United's Phil Jones but will play for England U21s this summer if he isn't needed by the senior squad.

Jones, who injured his shoulder last week, will be given two weeks to prove his fitness.

Barkley's selection by Hodgson caps a remarkable transformation in the player's fortunes — last season he returned early from an unsuccessful loan spell at Leeds United after being frozen out of the first team by David Moyes and was overlooked for England U21s by Stuart Pearce, playing instead for England at the U20 World Cup.

Now, having enjoyed an explosive season for Everton under Roberto Martinez and won both the club's Young Player of the Season award and Goal of the Season awards, the local-born prodigy has booked his place for the game's showpiece tournament.

"I'd never have dreamed of [this]," Barkley said. "A year ago I was starting games. It's happened through hard work and I'm grateful for it.

"I've been pleased [with my form for Everton]. I've been progressing and I'm hoping that continues for a long time."

Martinez has no doubt that Barkley is ready for the world stage but although he says Ross "is already a star" following his meteoric rise this season, the Spaniard suggests that he isn't capable yet of transforming England into a World Cup-winning outfit on his own.

We need to protect a young man who, for me, is the best young English talent I've seen and worked with.

Roberto Martinez

"I don't think there is another English player that can do what Ross does," Martinez says in The Guardian. "Will we expect to win the World Cup because of Ross Barkley? No. That is what we need to be clear on. He has the potential to be one of the best midfielders in world football at the age of 25, 26, 27 but not now.

"If the role in the World Cup is to carry England, that is not Ross Barkley. But if it is to have someone that is ready to help the team and will be ready mentally, then yes he has that character. We need to be more sensible than to say Ross Barkley is the man who can win the World Cup for England. We need to protect a young man who, for me, is the best young English talent I've seen and worked with. I hope we can fulfil his potential and give him what he needs over the years."

Full Squad List: BBC Sport



Reader Comments (81)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


James Stewart
1 Posted 12/05/2014 at 02:07:28
Phil Jones against the likes of Cavani and Co should be amusing.
Kieran Riding
2 Posted 12/05/2014 at 02:20:36
Boss Everton players and the World Cup don't sit well with me.

I'm still scarred by Lineker in '86.

Chris Donnelly
3 Posted 12/05/2014 at 07:35:49
Good luck to all Everton players that go to the World Cup. I feel sorry for Brian Oviedo, can't wait to have him back.
Bill Griffiths
4 Posted 12/05/2014 at 08:48:17
I’d prefer our lads to stay at home and recharge their batteries and come out fresh next season. As far as I’m concerned, The Blues come before any national sides.
Len Hawkins
5 Posted 12/05/2014 at 09:30:49
The first and only time we won the World Cup was with an Everton left back, the Great Raymondo. Hope Leighton comes back with a medal.
Drew Shortis
6 Posted 12/05/2014 at 09:44:42
Sounds about right to me. I think Jags and Baines have both earned their places and Barkley could be England's wildcard option if things are not going according to plan (which is pretty much guaranteed). I think this tournament is too soon for Stones who needs to keep his focus on nailing down a first choice spot at Everton. Hopefully by the 2016 Euros Stones will be a regular for both club an country.

I wish them all the best of luck but I really can't see England doing much in this tournament. They always look so awkward, like pale shadows of their Premier League selves. The last time I felt confident about an England team was 1996 with Shearer and Sheringham up front.

Oscar Huglin
7 Posted 12/05/2014 at 10:33:09
Good. Happy with Stones being a reserve as well, let him develop at his own rate, don't thrust him on to the biggest stage so soon.
Chris Gould
8 Posted 12/05/2014 at 10:42:28
I am praying Bill doesn't let Ross get on that plane before he signs a 5-year contract on big money. I know he will be reluctant to offer him a massive hike in wages given his age and relative inexperience, but if he doesn't and Ross sets the World Cup alight, there will be a long queue of clubs willing to tempt him with huge sums of money and champions league football. We've been here before.
Matt Traynor
9 Posted 12/05/2014 at 11:06:14
Chris #306, I get what you're saying, but a pay hike and 5-year deal won't stop them calling. Even if he has a shit tournament, it'll just mean the opening bid is lower. As ever, every player has a price, and if Barkley's trigger point is reached, the PR spin machine will go into overdrive with stories of his head having been turned etc, culminating in a sale, but weirdly without him requesting a transfer cos players never do that these days.
Denis Richardson
10 Posted 12/05/2014 at 11:24:00
Matt, problem is I think Ross only has another 2 years left on his contract so we need to tie him down anyway.

Doing that now, before he potentially has a good World Cup, would at least mean his agent won't be trying to get a massive pay hike for him, trying to blackmail us.

We cannot allow him to get to say January next year with no new contract. Personally if the fee is massive, I would not be against him leaving, every player has a price after all. That is however only if the fee went into either a new stadium or RM's transfer kitty, or both. (I would expect min £40m, if not more tho)

Brent Stephens
11 Posted 12/05/2014 at 12:21:58
James #269, problem is, if Jones isn't fit and Stones goes, then others might find it amusing.
Mike Manchester
12 Posted 12/05/2014 at 14:32:32
I bet Johnny "Bones" Stones is buzzing, because I'm buzzing for him. Well done John.
Ray Roche
13 Posted 12/05/2014 at 14:37:22
So, Barkley is in the squad, then, and Stones in the Stand By list.
James Stewart
14 Posted 12/05/2014 at 14:49:37
Brent, why would they? Stones is top class and there isn't another English CB like him. Jones, and Smalling even more so, are average at best. Neither would get a game here.
Brian Waring
15 Posted 12/05/2014 at 15:48:24
Stones as stand by after making 15 appearances, does that show how short the national team are of good centre backs, or how good Stones has been?
Paul Thompson
16 Posted 12/05/2014 at 15:52:19
Regardless of what any of us think of the English team, this will be a huge confidence boost for Barkley and Stones, and well deserved recognition for our two senior pros too.
Tommy Coleman
17 Posted 12/05/2014 at 15:59:11
I'd have Stones over Smalling and Jones any day. I hope he goes, he'll be a better player for it.
James Marshall
18 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:05:34
I don't get why people don't want our players playing the world cup. If I was a player I'd be desperate to take part. What an amazing experience for a young man like Ross, and hopefully Stones as well. Good on them.

3 Everton players in the squad, possibly 4 is brilliant news for us, and fantastic endorsement of our club.

Colin Glassar
19 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:16:48
I'm made up for Stones. I hope he's the star of the show.
Stuart Eaton
20 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:20:10
The last time we had 3 or more players in an England World Cup squad was 86 and we know what happened then with the hand of god.
Sam Morrison
21 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:24:36
I understand people not wanting our players to go, but don't agree. Having players getting international recognition reflects well on the club as a place for players to be both developed and recognized. We attract better players to the club. And with three of them in the squad - maybe four - the idea that one gets tapped up lessens, because he's there with his 'gang' - if that makes sense.
Shane Corcoran
22 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:25:08
Stones has done well for us and he's a rare talent in that he brings the ball out of defence well but he's been very dodgy defensively at times.

I'd definitely start either of the two Man Utd boys ahead of him if I was England manager. The only caveat being that both of their confidence wouldn't be as high as Stones at the minute.

Is it not Jags & Cahill at CB in any case?

Mark Johnson
23 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:28:48
They should've taken Stones just for the penalty taking!
Tony McNulty
24 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:28:29
James (18) - I think you do get it. Think "Wayne Rooney", whose head was turned once he went to the World Cup.

By the way, I hear he will be handing back his passport in July ... along with his fellow Manure players. He must be feeling so pleased he extended his contract. Barnsley away in the Mickey Mouse Cup next year. Happy days.

Colin Glassar
25 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:34:41
I meant, I'm made up for Barkley.
Andrew Ellams
26 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:44:01
Everton's club captain will be there... making sure the whisperers stay well away from the young lads!
James Marshall
27 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:47:23
Tony#24

Do you honestly think it was going to the world cup that pushed Rooney out of Everton? Seriously?

Come off it, we all know there was a lot more to it than that.

If Ross (assuming he's your worry) is ever going to leave Everton, going to a world cup will have nothing to do with it. I really don't see your rationale.

Ian Burns
28 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:51:53
Obviously I am delighted for Jags and Bainsey - also hugely delighted for Barks - well done to all 3 - they are their on merit, no doubt.

However, I really hope Stones goes as well because in simple footballing terms he is already a better CB than both Jones and Smalling. I don't wish Jones any harm but if he's not fit - then Stones would deserve the honour.

Alastair Donaldson
29 Posted 12/05/2014 at 16:47:23
Barkley was nailed on, Stones maybe a bit too soon but if he does go then he's got plenty of decent company to help him fit in. He is a rare talent, Beckenbauer-esque...how many other CBs bring the ball out??? Cahill is quite good at it but they're like hens teeth.

It would be lovely to think we could see their best years at Everton.... the vultures seem to be circling Southampton so far.. but it won't be long.

86 was a great tournament, our four guys were central to how well we did.

Iain Love
30 Posted 12/05/2014 at 17:02:33
It just shows you don't have to play for the Sky 4 to get to go to the World Cup. If a player who we're looking at sees we have 3 or 4 players in the England squad that will definitely help.
Steavey Buckley
31 Posted 12/05/2014 at 17:07:14
The England manager must be deluded to believe England can win the World Cup. This is a selected England 23 squad in the making, but there is real lack of quality upfront and wide on the wings, with Lambert and Lampard below what is expected from a top international team.
Tony McNulty
32 Posted 12/05/2014 at 17:02:50
James – you said you did not "get" why people did not want our players appearing in the World Cup. I have given you one reason, but of course agree there seem to have been many factors around Rooney.

You say you don't see the rationale. Are you saying that performing well on a world stage (as Lineker did), with the exposure it brings to other clubs as well as to all sorts of other influences (such as players from other clubs), could never be a factor in the premature departure from Everton of a player? I am sure I read somewhere that Ferguson, for instance, would ask Manure players to sound out those in whom he was interested.

As it happens, I am delighted Ross is there as well as the others (gives me more of a reason to watch England games, many of which have been pretty dire down the years). But along with some others, on balance I don't think it will contribute towards helping us retain our better players. If anything, the opposite.

Sam Hoare
33 Posted 12/05/2014 at 17:35:31
Great news! It heightens my interest in the tournament this Summer and it is a sign to any young player that Everton is a club able to support your international ambitions. It boosts Everton as a brand to have representatives there and it is an experience to develop for the players. The only downside for me (as tapping up happens irrelevant) is that the players will not get their Summer rest ahead of a long season.
Raymond Fox
34 Posted 12/05/2014 at 17:16:07
Going back to the point where Barkley or Stones if he actually goes, getting their head turned by all the high earners on the England team.

It can't help can it, but just as relevant is who they have as agents + what their home influence is like.

Must be a hell of a job for young players such as Barkley and Stones to keep their feet on the ground and try to figure out what is best for their long term careers!

Alan McGuffog
35 Posted 12/05/2014 at 17:53:41
Should Barkley and Stones start to realise their true potential over a period of time then they will be off. Simple as. The season has hardly ended and look what is happening already at Southampton, with Lallana and Shaw likely to be on their merry ways.

We can include Seamus in the group of players that will be coveted by our "bigger" competitors. This has always been the way in professional football....remember when we used to be a predator ?

But assuming we get top dollar for these players can we not please have any more bullshit about how broke we are.

James Marshall
36 Posted 12/05/2014 at 18:03:00
Fair enough Tony, thanks for qualifying it a bit better.
James Martin
37 Posted 12/05/2014 at 18:01:10
Hopefully with Jags and Baines there as well there won't be any tapping up going on. After all none of the United lads will be at it. Half the squad is from Liverpool anyway so that's off the cards as well.

If Stones makes it in the four of them should have a look around and realise they're better of staying where they are because they are four of England's better players and that's no joke. If you cut through all the hype this is a very weak squad in comparison to what some countries are taking. Some teams are leaving out players who would walk into our starting 11.

Dick Brady
38 Posted 12/05/2014 at 18:28:03
Before Stones even thinks about a big-money move he should ask himself one simple question. Did Jack Rodwell make the World Cup squad?
Jamie Barlow
39 Posted 12/05/2014 at 19:06:37
I was going to say that with 4 players in the squad, maybe it should be our lads who do the tapping up. Then I seen the squad and maybe they shouldn't bother.
Colin Glassar
40 Posted 12/05/2014 at 19:21:22
I can't believe Hibbo didn't make the squad. Probably Ossie's fault.
Peter Bell
41 Posted 12/05/2014 at 19:24:15
Tony @24&32 you need to get research your facts.

Firstly, the Lineker deal to Barcelona was sealed well before he went to the World Cup. Kendall says he wishes it wasn't as he could have gone for a bigger fee after his performance in Mexico 86.

Secondly, Rooney never played in the World Cup before he left Everton. Rooney left Everton after he was deliberately unsettled by OFM after Smith, Ferguson and Stretford put the wheels in motion.

Dennis Stevens
42 Posted 12/05/2014 at 19:29:44
I don't recall Rooney going to the World Cup Finals when he was at Everton - in 2002 he hadn't even made his first team debut prior to the Finals & by 2006 he was no longer an Everton player. I presume the previous references should really be to the Euros in 2004.
Gary Reeves
43 Posted 12/05/2014 at 19:28:13
Let's be honest here. Barkley making the squad tells us more about England's chances than it does about the lad's potential, because that's all it is - potential.

We've all watched him and we've all had a lot more frustrating moments than magic ones, so far. I'm just not totally convinced yet.

Still, puts a few quid on his value!

Peter Bell
44 Posted 12/05/2014 at 19:52:46
Dennis, you are correct, he never appeared in World Cup on 2002, but Tony thinking that Rooney left after being tapped up at Euro 2004 is wrong. He had been well knobbled before that.

Players can be tapped up anywhere these days, if anyone thinks it only happens whilst they are away with the national team they are being delusional.

Mark Dunford
45 Posted 12/05/2014 at 20:20:45
Yes, Rooney's star shone at Euro 2004 and then he disappeared the following transfer window - after a series of minor tabloid scandals and a weird change of agent allegedly involving small time crooks.

Sure, I'm not the only Evertonian hoping Phil Jones goes to Brazil.

Dick's Rodwell question makes a good point

Ian Bennett
46 Posted 12/05/2014 at 20:22:53
I think you can make a decent starting X1 from that squad, although not sure about Forster, Smalling, Jones, Welbeck, Lampard and Wilshire. They are either over the hill, or still to see what the hill looks like.
Johnny Rainford
47 Posted 12/05/2014 at 20:27:49
... Then you get the likes of Pienaar using it as a shop window.

Still, at least common sense prevailed with that one.

Must say, the feeling of elation when an Evertonian (Lineker.. although I use the term very loosely) scored a hattrick at the world cup, followed by seeing him sign for Barca a few days later was devastating for this Evertonian, and I've been wary of it ever since. Irrational, but true.

Paul Rimmer
48 Posted 12/05/2014 at 20:45:44
Wilshere is the most overrated player in the Premier League. I envisage a frustrating World Cup with the crab like Henderson starting and Woy bringing on Wilshere - with Ross watching on. Sterling diving to win pens and free kicks. They should just have a team of scousers.
Kevin Tully
49 Posted 12/05/2014 at 20:53:26
Paul - I would definitely have Scousers taking the penno's.

Rooney, Baines, Lambert, Gerrard and Barkley.

Albert Perkins
50 Posted 12/05/2014 at 20:58:33
As to whether we can win it..... In 66 I was supporting Brazil at Goodison because England didn't stand a chance.

We still have no chance, but so glad Ross will be there.

Paul Rimmer
51 Posted 12/05/2014 at 21:08:00
Agreed Kevin. Honorary scousers include jags and lallana in case it goes to sudden death!
Ian Bennett
52 Posted 12/05/2014 at 21:12:50
You need Stones if it goes to pens.
Andy Fino
53 Posted 12/05/2014 at 20:47:30
In my mind I think Wayne Rooney regrets leaving us. He is now mature enough to know that he would of been rich if he would have stayed with us. Maybe he would not have his winning medals but he now knows that playing for your boy idols and what that stands for as one growing up in Everton and the love towards him that he would get from us, outweighs playing for a team that shouts that they hate scousers.

So I have no doubt when he speaks to Ross he will put him straight. So just relax and enjoy the summer.

Eugene Ruane
54 Posted 12/05/2014 at 22:10:44
Brian Denton
55 Posted 12/05/2014 at 22:54:58
Eugene, pity there's no 'drill-down' facility - I'm racking my brains to work out where our 19 English goals have come from. If you knock out Lukaku, Mirallas, and Naismith, it doesn't leave you with much!
Andrew Grey
56 Posted 12/05/2014 at 23:21:14
Brian 55 -

Barkley 6
Baines 5
Osman 3
Barry 3
+ Stockdale o/g Fulham
+ Brown o/g Sunderland

Ernie Baywood
58 Posted 12/05/2014 at 23:29:38
Haven't supported England for years but I might just take a bit of an interest with Leighton, Jags and Ross there.

I'm of the view that Stones needs the time off to be built up over the summer but if he's going to playing at some level anyway then hopefully it's at the World Cup. Great recognition of both what he's done to date and what he could be.

Dennis Stevens
59 Posted 13/05/2014 at 00:06:49
I think Osman would have been of greater benefit to the squad than Lampard - which isn't to say that little Leon should be in the squad.
Mark Andersson
60 Posted 13/05/2014 at 05:54:45
Eugene, after reading the hypothetical article which was flawed, any excuse to say Man City din't deserve to win but Liverpool did. What if they took it a step further and only counted goals that were not assisted by foreign players too.

Two day's running now and the Mail online has Liverpool or United as headline news before Man City's deserved crowning as Champions. If you search really hard, there might be something about Everton. Roberto Martinez should have coveted the Manager of the Year award before that Muppet Brenda RS.

Max Wilson
61 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:15:14
The England team choice-provisional, is a heck of a compliment to us. And Stones already on the fringes. It just goes to show what people in the know think of us.Only potential problem will be players coming home injured or knackered or both, as has been said by my cautious Toffee friends above.It is now worth watching on the box!
Brian Baker
62 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:38:34
It's one thing picking the kids, will Roy have the courage to play them??
Jack Plant
63 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:15:27
Very pleased with how this is being covered on the BBC, makes a change from typical Red Shite and Man Utd dominated reports.
Brian Baker
64 Posted 13/05/2014 at 14:29:54
Is there a Pannini sticker for Ross?
Dick Fearon
66 Posted 13/05/2014 at 22:11:40
I wish the England squad the best of luck yet I expect the usual complaints about the number of foreigners in the PL.

What happened to the suggestion that PL teams must include a certain percentage of home growns.

Kunal Desai
67 Posted 14/05/2014 at 05:04:52
Cast you mind back to nearly 10 years ago. A young Wayne Rooney had just finished playing his first full season at Everton, he stared in Euro 2004 and made a huge impact which led to Man Utd signing him shortly before the transfer window shut, despite all the supposed efforts by the board that Wayne was not for sale.

Now fast-forward 10 years and we have another star in the making... Should he play a major role at the World Cup this year then will it be a repeat of a similar scenario of 10 years ago? Do not ruin it this time, BK and the board.

Matt Traynor
68 Posted 14/05/2014 at 06:25:01
Kunal #67 I'm afraid you're re-writing history a bit there.
There were strong rumours months before he was off, and his destination was well-known. The changing of his agent before was a prelude to it. People who stood to make money off his move wanted everything in place. Kenny Dalglish (who was a shareholder of Pro-active at the time) directly encouraged Rooney's parents to switch agents. Alan Stubbs also pretty much publicly told Rooney to go for the sake of his career. Alan Stubbs was also a shareholder of Pro-active at the time.

I was in Portugal at the match when Rooney did his foot, and as he left the field, I turned to my Everton-mate I was out there with, and we both knew that was the last we'd seen of him in a competitive match as an Everton player.

Also remember that summer was when Trevor Birch was the CEO for 5 minutes. A guy who has since built his reputation on facilitating the sale of distressed football clubs. He won't speak about his 6 weeks at Everton, but it is widely believed he saw the sale of Rooney as the only means of keeping the club afloat (remember the squad we had when Moyes took over - not much in the way of saleable assets was there?)

Walter Smith has since claimed that twice when he was at Everton they were close to Administration.

When Rooney was sold, he was sold to the richest club in Britain at that time (despite their debt), yet he was sold late on deadline day. Yes he was injured, but he'd started training again and I'm sure Man U would've rather had him in earlier. He was also sold on the drip. £10m then, £10m the year after, plus up to £7m in add-ons if clauses were fulfilled over the next five years. Why? Cos it suited Everton to have the money paid that way, so there was no clamour to reinvest.

The whole Newcastle bid was a smoke screen engineered by BK and his "good friend" Freddy Shepherd at Newcastle to give the perception of a bidding war. Didn't really look like one though, despite Fergie's half-hearted claim they were going to wait another year, but Newcastle "smoked them out".

Oh and by the way, in one of his books, Fergie pretty much blows that out of the water admitting they were aware of Rooney at a young age, and were always going to be signing him.

The difference now is the club isn't on the brink of administration. Not due to excellent commercial deals, but due to having a net negative transfer spend for several years, and a bumper new TV deal which boosts all clubs. Last summer Fellaini wanted to go, and was sold. I suspect Baines wouldn't have minded joining him, but wasn't going to agitate for a move, and has stayed.

This summer it will be the same. If Barkley wants to go, he'll go. If he wants to stay, he'll stay. Hopefully the days of selling players who weren't pushing to leave (Arteta, Speed, Ferguson) for financial reasons are over. (You can add Lineker and Ball to that list to show we've always done it, although these two were purely for the sake of making a good profit).

Shane Corcoran
69 Posted 14/05/2014 at 10:11:16
Matt, is there any doubt about anything you say?

I mean you're stating a hell of a lot as fact with very little, if any, back-up. At least not in your post.

Matt Traynor
70 Posted 14/05/2014 at 10:46:29
Shane #69, I've stated what I believed to have been the case. Some of those "facts" are easily verifiable, bordering on common knowledge amongst fans. In fact most of it is public utterances by others that, therefore, should be source-able if you have the time/inclination to search.

I'm not stating anything as fact, although there are a number of events that clearly took place. The whole purpose of my response to Kunal was I don't think the situation in 2014 is directly comparable to 2004. Maybe I should've left it at just that.

I was in Portugal in 2004 though. My mate who was with me doesn't use TWeb, so I can't get him to vouch for it.

Graham Mockford
71 Posted 14/05/2014 at 12:01:04
On the subject of international call ups Sylvan's tweet today was pretty funny.

@sylvaind15tin: I m retiring from France team. It was a wonderful experience and after a record of #0 cap it's time to say goodbye and focus on my club 😜

Eugene Ruane
72 Posted 14/05/2014 at 10:22:20
Here's an expression I've heard (from clubs/supporters) over the years. "It's good business." It's often said in a "and there's no arguing THAT" sort of way.

I think I first became aware of the expression (or something very similar) when Alan Ball was sold. I was 12 and the decision almost certainly changed me forever. Until that point, Everton FC could do no wrong. After the sale of Ball, I cried (real tears) for a week or two, then... was never the same again.

Regarding the club (and probably a whole lot more) I became less trusting and more cynical. Of course the 'good business' thing was probably spot-on from a purely financial perspective (bought for £100k, had him for 5/6 years, sold for £220k) but even at 12, I'm fairly sure I had some idea that there was more to life/sport/football than just cash.

Maybe some of that 60s hippy stuff had rubbed off on me without me being aware of it (although at about the same time Bally was sold, I read Richard Allen's 'Skinhead' which had a much bigger influence fashion-wise than say... um... the Peter Wyngarde look).

I now wonder was it ever considered what effect that transfer would have on thousands ('a generation') of Evertonians? Was it the final straw for some? Did we in the years following lose money in attendances? Did anyone at the club think 'how will they view us after this?'

Apparently not... and since then, as many times as I've been disappointed by the sale of certain players and/or by King's Dock-style fuck ups, I'm now conditioned to expect them. Simply put, I've never trusted those who 'run' the club since.

Kunal (67) you say - "Now fast-forward 10 years and we have another star in the making... Should he play a major role at the World Cup this year then will it be a repeat of a similar scenario of 10 years ago? Do not ruin it this time, BK and the board."

A few questions: Have we paid off all our debts? Has Bill said he or his board are going to put in millions of their money? Do we have a buyer? (or 'investor') Do Leopards change their spots?

No.

So my question is: Why WOULDN'T soft-arse and his mingebag cronies ruin it this time?

This all appears obvious and simple to me. We (all!) KNOW what the Everton model is – ie: we hope to produce the occasional Rooney, Rodwell or Barkley and then, when their value is thought sufficient to cash in on to help pay off our debts, they're sold. So, unless I missed a meeting, apart from more Sky money, nothing has changed at Everton since Rooney was sold.

And as for that increased revenue, yes it's a big jump, but with loans, wage increases and increasing squad size (not to mention new grounds) on top of our debts, it's obviously only enough to help keep the wolf a little further from the door (rather than say being able to blast it's head off with a shotgun).

Re Barkley and Stones, I fully expect them both to be sold in the next couple of years. If I'm wrong, great, but the sale of my favourite Everton player ever (ever ever ever) knocked wishful-thinking on the head for me... for good.

Patrick Murphy
73 Posted 14/05/2014 at 12:06:02
Just read that myself Graham; I hadn't realised he never gained a senior cap for France.

Somebody mentioned the BBC's favourable coverage about Ross Barkley — call me an old sceptic but I'm pretty sure that a similar outpouring of positive views took place in 2004 about Wayne Rooney and we never seen him in a Blue shirt again. Be warned and also beware that the Dark Side are in CL next season and they will undoubtedly covet the young lad.

Patrick Murphy
74 Posted 14/05/2014 at 12:10:17
Eugene – you are right to be mistrustful of our current board as their track record isn't one to fill us full of hope. As you say, it's not just the current board it has been like that for every season since I started attending Goodison Park.

Even the FA Cup winning team of 1984 very nearly broke up due to the board's reluctance to break the wage structure... Imagine if we had lost Southall, Sharp et al because we refused to give them the extra money? Roberto could do worse than to quiz Kendall about how the bean counters at Goodison truly operate.

Andrew Ellams
75 Posted 14/05/2014 at 12:16:14
The only thing I am almost certain about when it comes to Everton and selling off young stars is Barkley won't cross the park. (I hope!)
Shane Corcoran
76 Posted 14/05/2014 at 12:33:13
Matt, I was genuinely just checking as my ear is nowhere near the ground on any goings-on in the Premier League.

What doesn't sit right with me is that Rooney, regardless of who advised what, as an Everton fan, decided to go.

Maybe I'm naïve but could Rooney not have said, "I'm a Blue, this is my club, I have a contract and I'm staying"? – It's not like he was a bit-part player who'd have to sit on the bench with that attitude.

I know it's simplifying the matter greatly and I know he was young with a lot of people in his ear but surely some of those people were Blues too.

Or do you reckon he was fed the line that it was best for your club if you go?

Tony J Williams
77 Posted 14/05/2014 at 12:42:26
What a pointless wanky table that is Eugene.

I can't stand all these 'what if' specialists appearing when their team doesn't do what they want.

The table is as it is and won't change because some wankstain wants to make a point about how hard done shitty Liverpool are. Bellends.

Andrew Ellams
78 Posted 14/05/2014 at 13:01:19
The if you read below the table that Eugene posted the link two it states that Manchester City has won their second title since 1992, which as we all know is when football in England was born.
Matt Traynor
79 Posted 14/05/2014 at 13:04:19
Shane #76, I honestly don't think it matters who supports what team. Rooney had people in his ear all right, and for all of then I think money talks loudest – because of the value of any transfer, that was their one chance to make a lot of money. I think I heard Stretford got in the order of £1.5m out of that transfer – and that is how a lot of the agents would work back then, the way commodity traders ironically used to work – big commission to pay off all the other middle men you need to get the deal you want; even if you're giving half away, you're still quids in when it comes down to it. Especially if you were a former Hoover sales agent...

In the modern era, and by that I probably mean since Sky invented football, the only player I can think of who stayed true to his hometown club was Le Tissier. Gotta ask though, would he have "made it" at a Chelsea where he was no longer the big fish?

I don't blame Rooney for going. Don't forget, that Everton team had just finished fourth from bottom (albeit never in danger of actually going down, but the league was tragically bad that year). He may have been a blue and all, but probably thought that team – that Moyes was still trying to reshape – was closer to the Championship than the Premier League title, so why stay? Loyalty in football is only shown by some supporters – even a lot of overseas supporters are, by definition, transient.

Even Creasehead was all for leaving the RS until he was got at...

Eugene Ruane
80 Posted 14/05/2014 at 13:42:27
Tony (77) - "What a pointless wanky table that is, Eugene."

I wouldn't disagree... but there's a few months of no Everton games coming up and TW doesn't close for the summer.

(Presume you won't be interested in seeing the league table if you take out goals scored by players with a surname beginning with the letter 'S'?)

Dennis Stevens
81 Posted 14/05/2014 at 13:54:40
Matt Traynor #79: As I recall, Le Tissier said there was only one club he'd leave Southampton for. Presumably they never showed an interest & so he stayed where he was – I'm not sure how much of that was loyalty & how much was convenience.

The only real case of placing club loyalty ahead of personal ambition that I can think of goes all the way back to Steve Bull at Wolves. The soft git!

Shane Corcoran
82 Posted 14/05/2014 at 14:11:05
Matt, I disagree on the loyalty point.

Rooney was only 18. Surely he could have given Everton another year or two.

Off the top of my head Stewart Downing had opportunities to leave 'Boro but stuck with them for quite a few years before leaving.

The season before we bought Johnson from Palace he was in the Championship and agreed to give them another year to try to get back up rather than go to Everton. The following season both parties kept their word and off he went.

Like I said, it's not black and white, but for someone to proclaim themselves so blue he could have stuck with us until he was 21 say, and then fans would have been more forgiving.

Matt Traynor
83 Posted 15/05/2014 at 04:40:43
Shane #82, presumably you remember Rooney speaking then, and recall he probably couldn't decide what side of the bed to get out of.

He had 2 years left on his contract. Everton were going to offer him a deal "rising" to £50k a week. Man Utd offered him a deal starting on that. Also, as I said earlier, agents make more money when a player moves, rather than when he renews a contract. (That was at least largely true then.)

Basically he's being told by his advisers to move. Turned to his parents for advice, they see £ signs, and tell him to move – he's going to move. Remember he was just 18, thrust reluctantly into the media spotlight, and say what you like about money and privilege but it was a lot to handle. Plus the media wanted him gone – the granny hooker story (who leaked that? Probably someone who wanted him to move).

As I said at the outset, the die was cast when he changed agents the year before. There was no way he was staying at Everton, not for another year or 2. And of course, the club actually needed the money – something that shouldn't be overlooked.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb