Lukaku worth the investment for Martinez

, 12 May, 90comments  |  Jump to most recent
Manager would not be put off by £20m+ fee

Roberto Martinez would not hesitate to splash out what would easily be Everton's record fee on Romelu Lukaku should the Belgian be available this summer for the £20m+ figure being bandied about by the media recently.

The Spaniard believes Lukaku, who scored 16 times in all competitions for the Blues this season, represents an excellent investment given the fact that, at just 21, the striker still has much to learn before he reaches his full potential.

A fee that large on one player would represent a sizable chunk of Everton's transfer budget this summer — although staggered payments would, obviously, make the move more manageable — but as Martinez told the Everton fan sites last week, the Chelsea man would be worth it.

"I think Romelu would be a worthwhile investment for a number 9 of his age," he said. "He is strong with his back to goal and is tremendous in one-on-on situations.

"He can finish with his right or left foot and he's only 20. He's played in different environments and he's already been through a big transfer fee."

Lukaku has enjoyed a terrific season at Goodison since arriving on loan at the start of September and finished the campaign as the Blues' top scorer, despite missing a month with an ankle injury and being ineligible for both matches against his parent club.

Even under normal circumstances, Everton would face challenges to sign him, not least because of any desire Chelsea may have to keep him but also because he has scored over 30 goals in two seasons in the Premier League before his 21st birthday today.

Tottenham Hotspur have been linked with his signature in the English press and there is also said to be strong interest from Serie A and the Bundesliga.

And the list of suitors will only grow if Lukaku enjoys a successful World Cup with dark horses Belgium, who have confirmed that he and Kevin Mirallas are in the squad for Brazil this summer. Indeed, should Lukaku take the tournament by storm, Everton could well be priced out of any ensuing bidding war and forced to look elsewhere for reinforcements.

"We don't know if signing him is a possibility," Martinez concluded. "There are many factors at play."

Irrespective of whether or not he does return, the manager has been highly satisfied with the way the player's loan spell has worked out for both parties.

"In any loan deal you do, all you want is for it to be a real success," he said after the win at Hull on Sunday. "I'm really pleased to say now that Romelu Lukaku has been a real success.

"I've seen him grow as a player, as a man and as a footballer and I think he has developed unique memories with Everton. I think you saw it today that the fans will always have great memories of Rom's footballing talent.

"Chelsea will be delighted with the progress of the player and we have benefited from having a player like Rom."

 

Reader Comments (90)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Colin Glassar
1 Posted 13/05/2014 at 08:04:13
IRIT. If Roberto wants him then I'm fine with that. All he has to do now is find billy boy before he leaves the country.
James Morgan
3 Posted 13/05/2014 at 08:30:53
Well our chances of keeping must have improved after Chelsea have agreed to buy Costa for 32m.
John Pickles
4 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:00:13
Manager would not be put off by £20m+ fee

Kenwright and our board will!

Brian Baker
5 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:16:23
I think the jury is out for most fans, as he is inconsistent, blows hot and cold. But given all that, if he does bang in 15+ goals a season then he will be worth the money.
Duncan McDine
6 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:18:03
Hope he doesn't turn out to be like most of the strikers we pay big money for (great for 1 or 2 seasons, then suddenly turn to shite!).
Eugene Ruane
7 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:45:09
BK: "Would I LIKE to keep Rom? I'd LOVE to keep Rom... I'd love TWENTY Roms! You see the great thing about this lad isn't his goals, which are fantastic by the way, it's the fact that he 'gets' Everton and you can't buy that. Unfortunately (begins peeling onion) the lad is contracted to - sniff - Chelsea and it's - waaaaiill - out of our hands (wipes eyes, smiles)

"So right now, I'd just say leave it to Roberto, because the great thing about Roberto is he..he 'gets' Everton and you can't buy that...isn't it? Mmmm?

"You know, small budgets, Traores for goalposts... wasn't it? Isn't it? Marvelous! Dixie, the Boys Pen, School of Scientology, Dave Thomas, turns on a sixpence wasn't it? Perfect cross - fat Latch, one nil! Nil Satis Nisi Gillespie, fish n' chips wrapped in newspaper...the pink wasn't it... Mmmm?"

Jamie Carroll
8 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:42:51
To all those people who are afraid of Everton blowing all their transfer kitty on one player, remember the quote from our chairman: "You don't need 10 million pounds to buy a 10-million-pound player." Anyone heard of installments?
Paul Roberts
9 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:21:04
I think we should be more confident about being able to secure big name signings – whether Rom signs or not. Comparatively speaking, we are in a reasonably healthy financial position and in footballing terms we are really on the up.

We are in Europe and we will undoubtedly be contending for CL next season. Why would we not be attractive to top names? In addition, Roberto WILL play you if you're in the squad. Who'd have suspected that Oviedo, Stones and Naismith, even Barkley, would become such key elements of our success?

RM values his personnel and gives them every opportunity to develop and succeed. I'd prefer to sign for the Blues – and play – rather than warm the bench, like Rodwell and many others have done this season at the richer clubs.

It needs to be said as well that we are, as fans, now having to get used to different expectations. We are contenders. We are no longer "let's get to 40 points and see what happens." We should no longer be afraid. COYB.

Jim Lloyd
10 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:50:46
If we can get him, I think he'd just keep on getting better. Some say he's inconsistent, well, he is but so is Ross Barkley and John Stones but they are all brilliant players and will only get better. Eugene is spot on, Rom loves Everton. It might be that he goes somewhere else but that's football and agents for you.

If we get, and I think we will, one or two creative midfielders, then we're just going to increase the supply line for our forwards. Roll on next season!

Drew Shortis
11 Posted 13/05/2014 at 09:52:36
Happy Birthday Romelu. 21 today!

I agree with Roberto that Lukaku would be worth £20m of investment. Yes his touch is a little heavy at times and he does blow hot and cold, but he has also scored 32 goals in the last two Premier League seasons before his 21st birthday as well as 31 goals in two Belgian Pro League before he was 19. He can only get better and better! As a point of interest Drogba didn't sign his first professional contract until he was 21.

We have been craving a 20 goal a season striker for years and I think we have finally found the man who can do it (had he not had the injury layoff that total seems obtainable). Under Martinez's guidance he can only go from strength to strength and at 21 we are looking at a very sound investment. Fingers crossed!

Sam Hoare
12 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:05:42
I'm still not totally convinced by Lukaku as an all round striker and I think that we will have many frustrating days of watching the ball bounce of him or his passes to no-one. On the other hand, he is a goalscorer and would likely get 15 a season minimum if played regularly.

Also, being young and well reputed, his value would probably not drop even if he had a poor season or two with us.

Either way I don't think it will happen.

Ross Hutchinson
13 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:07:18
This guy is the same age as Barkley and he's our top-scorer. I think it's a must to try and sign him. Like Barkley, he's only going to get better with week in, week out performances which he'll get with us and even if we were to sell him in the future, his transfer fee would increase.
Jim Bennings
14 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:04:41
As I have said before Lukaku's goal return at Everton reads 16 from 31 appearances, that's a very very good return.

Last season at West Brom he scored 17 goals, another very good return.

Let's also remember that he didn't make his debut until the West Ham away match on September 21 and also he missed a full month of football in February with the bruised ankle sustained at Anfield.

Just imagine what he could be like after a complete pre-season under Roberto Martinez??

Lukaku is also young and still learning the game and again what better place to do so than under Martinez at Everton.

I would hate to think Romelu could go to somewhere like Tottenham and then bang in 18-20 goals whilst we have failed to find a suitable replacement for him.

Let's face facts: whether Lukaku stays or not, we are going to need a considerable amount of cash to buy the goals that he gives you, be that Lukaku, or Wilfried Bony.

I just hope Martinez can make sure that Kenwright and the board know that to be sustaining any kind of push for the Champions League or trophies then you must show ambition and be willing to go toe to toe with our rivals for the best players we can possibly afford.

It would be a crying shame if we fail to keep progressing after this fine season.

Speculate to accumulate.

Andrew Hawes
15 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:00:39
After his very successful spell at West Brom and Mourinho falling out with him at the start of the season, why didn't we offer £10 million for him in August and he would have already doubled his transfer fee and would be our player?

Although I have said we will go all out for him, it is a shame that will represent most of our transfer activity this summer meaning we will not be taking the strides forward we need to make for Champions League. This and the Barry situation shows up the negatives of the loan market for a team with Everton's finances. Come here and fail to impress and we're stuck with a player and his wages (Traore)... or come here and perform, and suddenly we're talking about £20 million plus transfer fees! The wages the top 4 pay out or the lack of Champions League to feed their ambition.

I really hope we can still afford a midfield general in the Arteta mould; we can't go into a new season relying on an ageing Osman for this... or an injury-prone Gibson.

Jim Bennings
16 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:16:52
I must also add that I would rather us splash the cash on Lukaku, a player proven in the Premier League and perhaps more importantly at Everton, than take some big risk on a guy from abroad.

Yes, you can get some gems such as Bony but you can also pay nearly £10 million for players like Van Wolfswinkle, Lamela etc etc.

If we do look abroad, it should only be on loan deals or ones relatively risk free for smallish fees.

Peter Bell
17 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:21:45
The cost of our team that finished 5th, 12 points behind the Redshite and 14 points behind Man City, is £31M — plus £60k for the best right back in Premier League.

And Brenda gets Manager of the Year....

No wonder we are bitter.

Peter Bell
18 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:27:03
Howard – £3M
Coleman – £60k
Baines – £6M
Jagielka – £4M
Distin – £5M
Osman – £0M
McCarthy – £13M
Barry – Loan
McGeady – £1M
Naismith – Free
Lukaku – Loan
James Stewart
19 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:32:14
When you put it like that, Peter, it is some achievement. Most of those signings you have to give Moyes some credit for as well though.

Lukaku is a strange one. I don't actually think he played that well except for a handful of games, yet he got over 15 goals. If he improves his hold-up play, then he will improve drastically. In Martinez we trust on this one, I guess.

Dennis Stevens
20 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:45:05
Sadly, I think any offer Everton make is likely to be seen as merely the opening bid & he'll quickly move out of our price range. But if we could sign Lukaku for £20 million it would probably be a good investment, not only for what he provides on the field of play, but also for the likely profit when he eventually moves on for an even bigger fee.
Mike Childs
21 Posted 13/05/2014 at 11:00:58
Just can't see Chelsea selling him to us. Sure FFP rules may force them to sell him to balance the books but I just don't see them selling to a rival in the league. Despite his laziness and first touch, of course I'd still like to have him as clinical finisher of his calibre are hard to come by. While the goals were great he also chipped in with 6 or 7 assists which we can't afford to lose.
Spragg Johnson
22 Posted 13/05/2014 at 11:46:20
The problem will be wages. Money bags clubs can offer twice the wages we can. I'd be very surprised if we even come close to signing Lukaku. I suspect we'll start next season with Kone, Traore (on loan) and either another loanee or a striker more in the £10 mill rather than £20 mill bracket.
Eric Myles
23 Posted 13/05/2014 at 11:56:21
Jim #14 "I just hope Martinez can make sure that Kenwright and the board know that to be sustaining any kind of push for the Champions League or trophies then you must show ambition and be willing to go toe to toe with our rivals for the best players we can possibly afford."

They didn't listen to the last manager for the last 11 years, I don't have any expectations they will listen to Martinez either.

John Daley
24 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:01:47
I really hope we end up getting him on a permanent deal for a number of reasons.

Firstly, as a statement of intent to signal that the club is finally serious about wanting to challenge for the top places consistently and to silence all those red top shit spewers who seem to have been telling us all season that such a wanted player with sky high potential would only ever see parking his ambitious arse at Goodison as something of a stop gap on his journey towards 'bigger and better' things.

Secondly, I believe whoever he ends up playing for next season is going to reap huge benefits from the boy having played his first full season as a clubs main striker. Up until he joined us the number of times Lukaku had actually lasted a full 90 minutes was limited. At Anderlecht he was used sparingly at first. Chelsea saw him as no more than a bit part player for the present but with massive potential for the future. Quite often, at West Brom, he was used as a sub. At Everton however he was required to start every game, barring injury.

Thirdly, although he is not the finished article and still has much to learn, he is quite patently prepared to listen, take advice on board and put in hard work of his own accord to ensure that he does improve. He's not stupid. For a 20 year old he has his head screwed on and is firmly focused on fulfilling his potential. He speaks six languages and studies his own performances and those of other players as 'homework'.

Earlier in the season, not long after he arrived on loan, Martinez hailed him as "a thinker, a real knowledgeable man. He is someone who looks at games in a very different way and is like a manager in the way that he looks at movement".

Towards the end of the season nothing had happened to alter Roberto's reading of Romelu's attitude, appetite and aspirations: "Normally players want to play and that's it. They don't want to know what is around them. He is just a curious footballer, he likes to know about the movements, what teams get affected by different movements, what space there is. He watches football. He knows all the players around Europe. He knows after the weekend what has happened with certain strikers around the world. He has got a real passion for the game which is quite rare for a young man."

Yes, it would take a huge fee for Everton to make it happen but it's well worth pushing the boat out on this one, in my opinion. We might have an opening here to sign a potentially world class striker with his entire career in front of him. When was the last time that happened? Lineker maybe, at a push.

I see other options being put forward but I feel they represent more of a risk despite the reduced fee. Take Bony for example. He's six years older than Lukaku for a start. Bearing in mind that Swansea shelled out £13m for him and he's gone on to become their star man then his fee isn't going to be that much shy of what Chelsea will be looking for. You then have to hope that he will be able to fit in to the style of play Roberto is implementing and hit the ground running. There's also the question of whether you're paying way over the odds purely on the basis of a good, maiden, 'gimme' season in the Premier League where he was something of an unknown quantity. Look at the likes of Michu and Benteke and how the prices being quoted for them a year ago now seem ridiculously over-inflated after the way they subsequently stumbled and saw their form tail off during their second season.

With Lukaku we already know that it works, we know what we're getting and we know that there is a good chance it could get even better. That's about as good a guarantee as you're going to get when taking a punt on a player.

Craig Walker
25 Posted 13/05/2014 at 11:56:35
Peter Bell #17. I had a "discussion" with a RS fan at work this morning. "Brendan has done better than Pellegrini this season". I decided to look up the total transfer spend for each Premier League club both historically and for the season just gone.

The Total Purchased, Total Sold, Nett, Average Spend per Season figures are:-

Everton £266,745,500; £244,586,000; £22,159,500; £1,007,250
Liverpool £650,305,000; £362,470,000; £287,835,000; £13,083,409

The interesting thing for me is that in the PL era, the RS have spent £650m but sold £362m. Their total spend is bigger than MUFC's although they've recouped money slightly better. The RS have spent the 3rd most amount of money on players.

Everton in season 2013-14 had a nett spend of -£16.5m
LFC in season 2013-14 had a nett spend of +£20.3m

If anyone is interested then check out transferleague.co.uk. It's a useful resource for disproving RS propaganda.

Guy McEvoy
26 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:09:29
@Eugene Ruane @7

Whilst I think you're over-egging him and being a little unfair, I have to tip my hat and say: that sir, is the post of the day!

John Daley
27 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:28:02
Careful Eugene. The man has some powerful scary friends:

"I'd be the wealthiest producer living if it wasn't for one thing: Everton... and still I hear that I put all Everton's money into my shows. Michael Crawford (the actor) said to me that he overheard an Everton fan saying that on a phone-in. He was incensed."

Eric Myles
28 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:35:02
John #27, well he certainly hasn't put any money into the Club so I don't know where he gets the nerve to say "I'd be the wealthiest producer living if it wasn't for one thing: Everton."

More bullshit from the guy along the lines of the second mortgage on his house to save the Club.

James Flynn
29 Posted 13/05/2014 at 10:55:18
Over two seasons:
Three different managerial philosophies
Three different teams
Three completely different sets of teammates
Thirty-three goals before his 21st birthday

I can't see Chelsea selling him to Everton. But if they're open to it, splash away Roberto.

Paul Holmes
30 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:35:58
I trust Martinez in the loan and transfer market to get the right players. Lukaku is decent but, if he was that good, Chelsea (who have him watched every game) would keep him.

There will be some Spanish or South American (hopefully like Suarez) that Martinez will have lined up and every player is replaceable (bar Suarez – they would finish mid-table if he left !).

Martinez has convinced me that he knows what he is doing so let him get on with it – if he's going to manage Barcelona one day, he should be able to sort Everton out... right?

Paul Thompson
31 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:43:44
I would love to get him. Intelligent guy, intelligent footballer. Given our experience with strikers, I hesitate to say he can only get better, but I do believe he will. Odds are against us though.
Paul Holden
32 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:54:50
He was good, but I'd rather spend £12 million on Bony if possible!
Brian Harrison
33 Posted 13/05/2014 at 12:47:32
I think the Lukaku transfer highlights the problem at present. We have a young player on loan who by-and-large has done very well. Yet his ambitions are to play in the Champions League, either with his parent club or another club who can meet this criteria.

Sadly, as well as we have done this year, I don't think he can achieve his ambitions at Everton, just like Rooney before him. So the problem is how are we going to keep hold of any promising loan players – as well as our own players?

We have the nucleus of some very good youngsters: McCarthy, Coleman, Stones and Barkley... yet, if we have very little chance of Champions League football, how do we hope to keep them when bigger clubs come calling? We nearly lost Baines in the summer as well as Fellaini and, although I personally didn't think Fellaini was anything special, he had become a very integral part of our team.

So, whether Lukaku goes or stays, the real question is: If we don't get new owners, how long before our young stars are looking for pastures new? – as well as our new exciting manager?

Len Hawkins
34 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:01:36
Eugene #7

Have you thought of taking up scriptwriting full-time. Lol.

Peter Bell
35 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:26:38
Paul@32

We wont get Bony for £12M. That's what Swansea paid for him last season and his stock value will have doubled since then, given his performances last season.

Kevin Tully
36 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:26:34
Regarding the wages Lukaku may command, I doubt he'd be on much more than £50k per week at Chelsea. Don't forget, he isn't seen as a first choice striker and if you take his age into consideration, even the likes of Chelsea don't pay 20-year-old reserves fortunes.

Heitinga was on a reported £60k a week to sit on our bench (that's why he was content to run his contract down) so I am guessing we wouldn't be offering much more than that to Lukaku if he decided to join us, plus a great big signing-on fee of course

nb: Pricey now to get yer Bentley covered in gold leaf.

Dermot O'Brien
37 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:29:12
#7 Eugene... haha that made me laugh.

Chelsea are after Costa if you'd believe the red top toilet roll, which I do. It would surely mean Rom is surplus there, so maybe he's on the way out. Where to, is the question. If I wrote for the Sun I'd say "he hasn't ruled himself out of a move to _______." Ahh... it's going to be a long summer.

Mark Johnson
38 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:39:28
I think £6.7 million for Michy Batshuayi is better a option. As much as I would like to see us get Lukaku and/or Bony, we are in need of 5 or 6 players and the £25 million, if we have that, we are going to need it for other players – not just on one player.
James Marshall
39 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:41:10
According to the Daily Tory, Lukaku has been offered to Atletico as a make-weight in the Costa deal. Romelu is apparently reluctant to go to Spain due to the racism on show over there (who can blame him).

If true, this shows Chelsea don't want him, which I think we all knew anyway so could be a good sign. They also claim he wants/wanted to stay with us for another season on loan. If Everton have any sense they will simply slap in a bid for him and see what Chelsea say.

Drew Shortis
40 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:56:55
The latest rumour I have seen is that Liverpool are considering going in for Lukaku. Hopefully it's just the tabloids stirring but, if I were Rogers, I would probably consider such a mood. Their fans would probably love it as it would be a kick in the teeth for us.

I'm not sure Chelsea would be keen to sell to a top four rival and, with Suarez and Sturridge there, he wouldn't necessarily be first choice. Still a horrible idea!

Jim Bennings
41 Posted 13/05/2014 at 13:55:35
Eric

We can only hope that with the extra TV money coming in that we can spend more than usual.

We didn't really spend anything last summer did we?
Kone and Robles come in, Anichebe out, McCarthy signs with the money we got for Fellaini.

Then in January in come McGeady and Traore and out go Jelavic and Heitinga.

We should already have money to spend.

Paul

There is no way on earth we can get Bony for £12 million.
You are looking at st the very least £20 million after his exploits this season, plus I believe he will participate in the World Cup which usually hikes up any transfer value.

Peter Bell
42 Posted 13/05/2014 at 14:00:56
Drew, if he comes to Everton, he will also be going to a top four rival.
Nicholas Ryan
43 Posted 13/05/2014 at 14:22:35
The big plus factor with Lukaku; because of his age, is that we would be almost certain of getting our money back in the future.
David Graves
44 Posted 13/05/2014 at 14:50:51
"Jury is out".
"Hot and cold"
"Inconsistent"
"Shit first touch"

Really? Read what Masters Bennings and Daley posted above.
Nice Swan.

Eugene Ruane
45 Posted 13/05/2014 at 15:03:49
John Daley (27) - "Careful Eugene. The man has some powerful scary friends"

I don't think I'd be too intimidated by Frank Spencer (remember his catchphrase - "Oooh Betty the cat's just done a fucking big shite") but having seen a recent picture of 'Betty' (Michelle Dotrice), if she came after me I certainly WOULD be nervous.

http://www.contactmusic.com/pics/ln/20130226/260213_michele_dotrice_2/michele-dotrice-actress-michele-dotrice-is-seen_3529283.jpg

Nicholas Page
46 Posted 13/05/2014 at 15:39:31
Eugene #7, LOL. So you watched the awards evening then!
Jay Richo
47 Posted 13/05/2014 at 15:32:41
I ould love him. £20 million at 20 years old when he has hit double figures in the PL the last two seasons. His value will only grow so will be a great investment! But does anyone truly believe we will spend £20m? I don’t! We will be looking on the loan market and I will be left shell shocked if we spend more than £10m on a single player. Saving up for the new stadium, aren’t we, Bill?
Dennis Stevens
48 Posted 13/05/2014 at 15:54:22
Crikey! Are you sure that wasn't Freddie Starr, Eugene??
Paul Ferry
49 Posted 13/05/2014 at 16:16:33
Nice one, Eugene; yet another female crucial to my storm-tossed puberty whose image you have ruined – take a bow Una Stubbs, Jenny Hanley, Ayshea, Babs, and Lynn Dickinson whose dad owned Dicko's newsagent in Crosby. Thanks Eugene mate.

40: I don't think that Liverpool will be interested in Lukaku although it would be nice to see Lukaku and Lallana in the same side, all very telly-tubby-ish. Our criminal neighbours need to look back not forwards (they do that all the time anyway don't they) and spend sponds on defence. This is a team that conceded more goals than eleven other teams scored – 50.

I would like to see Lu signed up. Sixteen goals with a longish lay-off is not bad at all. He is a 20-goal-a-season striker and 21 today with years ahead of him to develop and resale value that will be high for a long while. To cap it all, he clearly enjoys his time at Everton and unless he is daffy duck daft – and he ain't – he knows that he is in a team with real bonding spirit with the promise of something big to come.

Question, then, is can we afford it and also would splashing so much on a single player however important undermine overall transfer strategies over the next window?

We need at least two strikers, a Xavi-like creative playmaker (yeah right!), a right back, and I know others will disagree but I would be so chuffed if we could get a very good goalie Marshall please because Tim is in my mind not good enough (there I said it) and Robies seems rusty and dodgy when we get to see him between the sticks.

And the other fuzzy area is exactly how much money Roberto will have to spend in the next window? I have a hunch that he will get better backing from this board than perhaps most of us on here think. No real support for this view I'm afraid except a sense that it's now blind-bleedingly-obvious that Roberto needs this sort of support to build on this last lovely year otherwise it will be adios and I for one would not blame him one bit if that happened.

Everton need to match Roberto's ambitions and aspirations and if he wants Lukaku, the Boys Pen impresario should work erm 24/7 to get him.

Patrick Murphy
50 Posted 13/05/2014 at 16:24:02
Eugene - you have spoiled my day - She was a favourite of mine when I was a teenager and people have the temerity to ask me why I don't own a mirror.
Ross Norman
51 Posted 13/05/2014 at 16:10:48
Considering what Jim (#41) said about Bony costing more in the region of around £20 million (at present) which is probably the same valuation attached to Lukaku (at present), there are different factors to consider with each player when considering which is worth the substantial transfer fee.

In Bony's case he is probably entering/already into his peak playing years as shown by his recent record at Vitesse and Swansea. By playing at Swansea he is accustomed to a similar playing style to what is being played at Goodison. However the one worrying point I would have if we were to purchase Bony is next year's African Cup of Nations in Morocco. If we had (for example) 1 striker out of 4 at Everton going we could probably cope during the 1-2 months of the competition, however the fact that we could have potentially 3 strikers (Bony, Kone and Traore) missing would be extremely worrying.

But with Lukaku he has shown massive potential from his early days at Anderlecht and has proven over the last 2 seasons he is capable of scoring in the Premier League. Yes certain aspects of his game need improving, but at 21 he can only improve and get better. Look at where Didier Drogba, the player Lukaku is constantly compared to, was at the same stage of his career. Hence if both himself and Bony are available for similar amounts I would be more inclined to recruit Lukaku.

Eugene Ruane
52 Posted 13/05/2014 at 16:59:05
Patrick (50) - I'm afraid I'll have to view all your opinions on Everton in a new and less favourable light, given the fact that Michelle Dotrice was a (70s) favourite of yours.

I mean even at her best, she was a bit of a puddin'

See pic of Frank Spencer with a bit of a puddin'..

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/0/0d/Some_Mothers_Do_Ave_Em_1.jpg

Anyway, MUCH worse for me, I had to watch my favourite, Madeline Smith (a REAL looker and the face that launched a thousand..er..tugs) go from this..

http://www.classichorrorcampaign.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/madeline-smith.jpg

To this...

http://i.ytimg.com/vi/w0eMD1Qvsnk/0.jpg

Cruel, just...cruel.


Raymond Fox
53 Posted 13/05/2014 at 17:02:01
Spot on Brian 33 I'm sorry to say, its the unpalatable truth!

As far as Lukaku is concerned, if he actually wanted to play for us, I would not hesitate to buy him for £20m-£25m.

If we are serious about challenging for the top he's a must buy.

Tony J Williams
54 Posted 13/05/2014 at 17:17:23
Ahhhhhh Madeline Smith........
Max Wilson
55 Posted 13/05/2014 at 17:08:02
This is a club with a history of having a striker who scored 60 goals in a season.
We have just as many players going to the world cup as any other club-more than most. Our standards should remain high. So less than 14 goals- this seasons top ten strikers total starts there, is not very exciting. This guy has been better than we've had for a while, that's all we can say. Yes, we like him. Can we afford better? If not, we're never going to set the world on fire and we'll always finish where we are now-just outside the big league. I think Roberto should keep looking around and see what he can find for us. Two good strikers up front is what we need, not one slightly better than average.
Bill Griffiths
56 Posted 13/05/2014 at 17:21:40
Personally I am like a lot of others who are undecided regarding Rom’s ability and potential to develop further. Saying that Roberto seems to value him highly so I guess if we do manage to sign him we will all have to trust in Roberto’s judgement, which is fine by me.
Simon Jones
57 Posted 13/05/2014 at 17:26:05
Surely any PL club that can afford him would make an offer for him. If the RS lose the diving whinger during the summer (who knows how many World Cup handballs this year?) then it wouldn't surprise me if Brenda or any of the "Big" clubs come in for Rom. He is a boss player with bags of potential, already proven himself at TWO clubs and probably 12 good years left in him barring injury.
Brent Stephens
58 Posted 13/05/2014 at 17:34:14
Some sobering "then and now" pics linked above. Good job we TWebbers don't age in the same way.
Sam Hoare
59 Posted 13/05/2014 at 17:35:38
At the max we will surely only have £25m to spend this Summer which will likely be around Lukaku's transfer fee. That would mean scraping around for loans and free signings for the other 5 to 6 players that we need.

Would people be happy if he was to be our only permanent signing?

Jack Cross
60 Posted 13/05/2014 at 17:40:35
Lukaku I'm not really sure whether I want him or not. 14 goals fine, but it don't set the world on fire when you look at Swarez, maybe a one off season I don't think, so do you? He will only get better but will Lukakau or have we seen his best? Bony as I've said numerous times is the striker for me and I wouldn't object paying 20 mil for him as I think he as more to his game than Lukaku. If he can score 14 for Swansea who knows what he maybe able to do with us.

But then look at Jelly, world beater for about 3 months and then a complete flop. So whoever we by as got some risk to it, I just feel better if it was to be Bony.

As for affordability well, its usually so much down and then instalments isn't it?

I suppose we have to take some kind of risk if we to push on, I just don't know if I'd risk 20 plus mil on Lukaku.

Ian Jones
61 Posted 13/05/2014 at 18:12:28
Hope any potential Lukaka (sorry Linda, couldn’t resist) deal doesn’t involve Barkley going the other way.
Jim Bennings
63 Posted 13/05/2014 at 18:32:51
It's also worth noting they Lukaku and Bony are both different players.

They are both strong men but Lukaku is possibly better running with the ball and driving towards goal, take the Arsenal goal for example or a similar tun against Cardiff at Goodison when a wonder strike was kept out by the very good Cardiff keeper.

Bony is perhaps stronger in the air than Romelu but in time thats something Lukaku can work on with age and experience.

We are all assuming that Bony will not have other potential suitors who could offer him more money than us, we can't use the fact that he wants to play in Europe, he had already played in the Europa League with Swansea.

That's why I strongly believe that Martinez will try to keep his word at forcing Chelsea's hand with a few offensive the region of 18-20 million.

It makes for a busy summer.

Jack Cross
64 Posted 13/05/2014 at 18:37:06
Ian. That's the problem with this club, were never really ever given any assurances that, that won't be the case. That's the problem with world cups. Their in the window for all to see. Now if Real or Barc came in with 50 mil what would you say? Because I think I know what the club would say Sell, Sell, Sell. To a certain extent were still a selling club. I mean we did sell Feli and get McCarthy right?

Andy Crooks
65 Posted 13/05/2014 at 19:12:10
Eugene, Madeline Smith was and is mine. Do not ever, ever since her name again.
Malcolm Kitchen
66 Posted 13/05/2014 at 18:15:24
Great post all, Jack (60) it was 24 goals for Bony and 16 for Lukaku!! Right, we have £20M plus from the January sales, burning a hole in EFC’s pockets, then £89M TV Money = £109 MILLION!!!!!!!!

SIMPLE, IF £40M CANT BE GIVEN TO ROBERTO, THERE IS SOMETHING VERY WRONG!!!!

I totally agree with everyone regard ambition, £69M to the club & Billy bullshit, surely that’s enough?? Lukaku, Drmic, Formini, McVilla, Tello, get em in Robero!!! Then we’ll piss it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! That’s Ambition!

Ian Jones
67 Posted 13/05/2014 at 18:56:21
Jack. Agree re selling club. Would be good to get at least one more year out of Ross but....who knows. Money does influence and if there is another player also coming through the ranks then its difficult. It would be great to have all the young players at the club at the same time rather than always thinking if only!
Steve Cotton
68 Posted 13/05/2014 at 20:15:10
http://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/en/spieler/vertragsende/basics_GB1_2014.html
every player listed here is free at the end of the season, some beauts, some shite and some old codgers but surely some potential...
Sean Patton
69 Posted 13/05/2014 at 20:54:55
One thing to consider about Lukaku is we should not put all our eggs into one basket as it is crucial we start the season with strikers. As of this moment we have no fit first team forward and we had to wait until the final half hour of the window to sign him last year.

Those first 3 games we played without a forward worthy of the name cost us dearly as we failed to win any of them. This time around we have to be ready from the off so if it is not possible to get him before the kick off Martinez must move on to other targets.

Raymond Fox
70 Posted 13/05/2014 at 21:47:11
There must be literally hundreds of thousands of fans of other teams that look at our club with admiration. Why, because once again were the only club that has seriously challenged 'the money clubs' this season.

Problem is we have once more hit the glass ceiling, and I think we all accept that given our clubs present structure it looks like 5th is the best we can hope for. The PL as a competition is really a disgrace, what difference this FFP rules will bring I wouldn't hazard a guess.

Three quarters of the teams in the PL start each season with no realistic chance of making the top 4 which is a disgrace.

Ian Hollingworth
71 Posted 13/05/2014 at 22:54:36
Manager would not be put off by £20m fee

Bobby, lad, you have a lot to learn about your bosses.

Anto Byrne
72 Posted 14/05/2014 at 03:14:26
He is a striker that scores goals. Okay his first touch and hold up play need work and I'm sure that will come in time. He formed a solid partnership with that poor excuse for a footballer Naismith (well we all slagged him off at one stage or another). We will effectively have 3 new signings in Kone, Gibson and to some extent Bryan Oviedo.

There are a few signs that the likes of Garbutt and McAleny will be brought through into first team reckoning. Shane Duffy had so much promise? There is the notion that we will bring back the kid from Man City although Milner would be a great addition if he was to replace Barry who may head off to Arsenal (£100k pw and CL).

I can't see us buying Lukaku for £20m unless we offload a Baines or Coleman to pay for it? My greatest concern will be keeping hold of Barkley who in time will become the club captain if he stays and probably England captain. Global shirt sales for this kid after the World Cup will more that pay for he £250k pw that he will earn.

Viv Sharma
73 Posted 14/05/2014 at 03:39:23
This summer I are be mostly... not spending any money.
Eugene Ruane
74 Posted 14/05/2014 at 08:54:48
Anto (72) - "I can't see us buying Lukaku for £20m unless we offload a Baines or Coleman to pay for it"

This is probably the case and it's an important point re Everton's ability to progress (further).

When we can buy someone decent WITHOUT letting someone decent go, that's when we'll have a good/better chance of top 4 or trophies.

Until then, it's likely that the best we'll be able to achieve is..where we are right this minute.

Andrew Hawes
75 Posted 14/05/2014 at 09:44:28
Eugene 74: we will spend between £20 & 30 million this season – do you not listen to what Martinez says?? All very well being negative but not even Bill can escape spending money after the season we have just had!

Roberto has already stated the money is in place, that he could invest it in Lukaku and he will bring in 4 or 5 players. Totally different rhetoric to what OFM said at this time of the year: "Looking to do something if possible..."??

This rubbish about selling Baines or Coleman only feeds the rumours that every rag in the country tries to fan every now and then. I am in no doubt for the first time in years we will have a better side next year than what we finished this season with. Easy to get that disillusioned with having very little money that your posts don't make sense!

Andrew Ellams
76 Posted 14/05/2014 at 09:59:06
Re Steve Cotton’s link, Larsson, Colback and Sidwell may be good squad additions to a club in Europe on a limited budget. Anyone know much about that Gosling lad, or maybe the two goalkeepers Nash & Wright?
James Marshall
77 Posted 14/05/2014 at 10:33:49
From further reading this morning regarding Lukaku, it seems that Mourinho is not keen for him to join another English club, so the Costa part-ex deal looks like more of a goer, although further rumblings that Atletico want Carlos Bacca to replace Costa so maybe not.

I'm becoming increasingly dubious that we'll ever see him in a Blue shirt again, regardless of whether we can afford him.

Sam Hoare
78 Posted 14/05/2014 at 10:52:42
One player we won't be signing is Drmic, who had been linked to us but has now signed for Leverkusen.

I only hope this thread is no longer going on transfer deadline day after a goal-shy start to next season.

Matthew Williams
79 Posted 14/05/2014 at 13:19:06
FFS... NO!
Paul Holden
80 Posted 14/05/2014 at 16:44:33
Forget it, go for Bony at Swansea - I reckon a £12 million bid might do the trick and then we can spend the other £8 million on a holding midfielder!
Darryl Ritchie
81 Posted 14/05/2014 at 17:23:45
If we somehow managed to buy Lukaku, I believe he would easily break the 20 goal mark next season. If RM could somehow get him to the energy and intensity levels of Naisy and Macca, he would score 40!
Tahir Abdullah
82 Posted 14/05/2014 at 22:04:19
Spanner in the works?

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2626946/Romelu-Lukaku-offered-Atletico-Madrid-exchange-deal-bring-Diego-Costa-Chelsea.html

Eugene Ruane
84 Posted 14/05/2014 at 22:43:31
Andrew Hawes - "Eugene 74: we will spend between £20 & 30 million this season – do you not listen to what Martinez says?? All very well being negative but not even Bill can escape spending money after the season we have just had!"

I don't really know how to respond, other than to say I find such innocence quite – (wipes eye) – moving.

Kieran Riding
86 Posted 15/05/2014 at 01:49:34
Chelsea to offer him a new deal... With the option of coming back to us on loan?

http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/chelsea-offer-romelu-lukaku-a-new-deal--with-loan-option-attached-9373109.html

I can actually see this happening TBF.

Mark Andersson
87 Posted 15/05/2014 at 02:36:46
Happy dreaming Kieran. What ever happens in the summer, I'm sure there will be lot's of debates here. I look forward to reading them.
Max Wilson
88 Posted 15/05/2014 at 09:21:06
15th May: Lukaku's contract is rumoured to be improved by Chelski. This will make him much more expensive. I feel sorry for him, being touted around as a commercial asset just to be exploited. At 21 he's got 7-8 more seasons at his best to give himself something to be proud of. Let's hope he's got the guts and brains to say No to his agent and to Mourhino. As for Chelsea's owner, he doesn't give a monkey's about players, does he? It's all business and ego.
Matthew Williams
89 Posted 15/05/2014 at 14:24:39
Try McCormack, Ings, Stokes, Zaha, Welbeck or even Bent to get us the goals. Young, hungry, promising players with a point to prove & won’t blow our budget.

£20 million would be a waste as we still need a creative CM & CB cover for Distin & Jags, but can we give the League Cup a real go this year, Bobby... for once!
Colin Glassar
90 Posted 17/05/2014 at 07:58:00
Just seen that our former captain, Phil gobshyte Neville, doesn't rate Lukaku. I'm sure Lukaku is heartbroken now that this giant of world football has delivered his final verdict.

I doubt captain gobby will ever get another job in football in the top two leagues in this country. Maybe swilling out the toilets at Anfield?

Gavin Ramejkis
91 Posted 17/05/2014 at 08:23:17
Colin, did you ever see the inside decor of his old house? Versace tat, money can't buy you a sense of style. Wouldn't be interested in anything Chuckle Brother rates.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/hi/newsbeat/newsid_7328000/7328197.stm

Richard O'Shea
92 Posted 17/05/2014 at 08:34:17
Lukuka is no risk purchase – spend £20-25 million and it will be returned 10 times over. He will guarantee you 20 goals a season for the next 10 years...

What would you prefer? Lukuka or Andy Johnson or James Beattie??? If you want quality, you have to pay for it; otherwise, we will continue to buy crap strikers for modest money.

All transfers are a risk but this is no risk as we already know he will fit into our style of play and score goals for fun. I can't believe people are even arguing we shouldn't pay the money. At the very least, we will make a profit from him in a few years, like we did with Fellaini. People were arguing the same with Fellaini, yet we bought him for £15M sold him for £27M.

Trevor Lynes
93 Posted 17/05/2014 at 09:14:00
It really annoys me to see Liverpool all over Lallana and planning double swoops for him and Lovren from Southampton. Lallana is a 'real' star of the future – plus he is an Evertonian! Why are we not trying for him? He is worth every penny of £20 million; if we are supposedly well off with the money made in the last transfer window plus the extra revenue from Sky, we should be investing at least £40 million in making our squad really strong and giving the fans a boost.

If we are still talking about lesser players and hoping they will improve then that prospect does not impress me a bit. Martinez at this stage needs all he can get in backing from a boardroom who have not shown the ambition the fans crave up to now, otherwise we could well be one-hit wonders.

Let BK and Co show their mettle and for once push for a trophy with this new manager.

Paul Andrews
94 Posted 17/05/2014 at 10:18:23
Colin,

Just read that now.
Sour grapes there from "Fizzer"

I suppose when you compare Lukaku against the loanee centre forward his mentor brought in, Stracqualursi, he may have a point... Ahem.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb