Garbutt shines on U21s debut

, 19 May, 17comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton's Luke Garbutt played the full 90 minutes as England U21s beat their Wales counterparts 3-1 at Swansea's Liberty Stadium this evening to move a step closer to the European Championship Finals.

Norwich's Nathan Redmond scored a hat-trick as England retained their lead at the top of Group 1.

10 group winners and the four best runners-up will be paired off in two-legged play-offs to determine the seven sides that will join hosts the Czech Republic in the finals next month.

Garbutt, who made one senior appearance for Everton in the Premier League last month, had an outstanding game at left back in his first U21s appearance, evoking comparisons with Leighton Baines.

The Blues' other potential participant, John Stones, was not involved due to his involvement in the senior England team's training camp in Portugal. The 19-year-old is on standby for Manchester United defender Phil Jones for the World Cup in Brazil.  



Reader Comments (17)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dick Brady
1 Posted 19/05/2014 at 22:02:43
I know you all complain that I'm always going on about Garbutt but the truth is the lad is a superb talent.

At Colchester United he was easily their best player during his loan spell. In fact a few fans I know would have voted him player of the season had he stayed another month or so.

Garbutt is quick both with the ball and without, he has a sweet left foot which is dangerous on corners and clinical on free kicks just outside the box.

The best thing about Garbutt though is his style of play. He wants the ball at all times and he wants to beat the man in front of him and he wants to make something happen. And with his pace, control and crossing ability he normally can make something happen.

He really is like a younger Leighton Baines. The same sweet left foot, crossing ability and set pieces skill but just faster and more likely to beat a defender.

The lad needs a first team chance Roberto.

Trevor Lynes
2 Posted 19/05/2014 at 22:06:46
Garbutt has obviously been influenced by Baines as his game especially going forward is very similar to the blues number one.

The lad has pace and plenty of stamina with a distribution standard of a very high level. His dead ball crosses were first class and should have led to more England goals.

I would like to see the lad tested defensively before making my final verdict but he looks very composed and comfortable on the ball when going forward. I reckon he has a real chance of establishing himself at Everton.

Jay Harris
3 Posted 19/05/2014 at 22:13:25
Dick I haven't seen the lad as much as you but on the occasions I have seen him he "looks" good on the ball but was very weak defensively.

I cant remember who it was but the winger was going round him with ease.

I think he still has a lot to learn before he can be allowed anywhere near the first team.

Paul Ferry
4 Posted 19/05/2014 at 23:44:18
Having watched Garbutt closely tonight/this afternoon I have to say that he is miles away from a first-team spot with us although he might pop up on the bench now and then although even these opportunities might be far and few between with Bryan coming back.

Quite simply, his defensive game leaves a lot to desire. Yep, I like watching him going forwards, and I also think back to a few years ago when how many of us - a majority for sure - voiced deep concerns about Seamus and defending, but he has an awful lot of learning and development to do,a nd let's hope he makes it.

Mr. Brady/Brody in one glowing review after another does not quite seem to have taken on board that with all due respect to Colchester doing well at low-league Colchester hardly puts someone in the frame for a starting place at Everton.

Colin Glassar
5 Posted 20/05/2014 at 00:16:39
Brady/Brody, I'm with you on this one. He was superb tonight. He reminded me of a young Leighton Baines (who isn't a great defender btw).
Si Cooper
6 Posted 20/05/2014 at 01:52:43
I agree with Paul Ferry from what was shown in the highlights I have seen tonight.

He uses his pace well both offensively and defensively but did seem to be caught out positionally a few times against what has to be regarded as limited opposition (which has to be considered when assessing all the performances), though he was one of the stand-out players.

It may be a subtle difference but he actually reminded me more of Luke Shaw than Leighton. A definite prospect, with time on his side, but I am not yet convinced he is ready for regular Premier League duty.

Richard Lyons
7 Posted 20/05/2014 at 06:07:04
Is he a potential Sheedy rather than a Baines? A replacement for Pienaar perhaps?
Phil Sammon
8 Posted 20/05/2014 at 06:32:28
Paul Ferry

Completely agree Paul. I am on record as saying that he won't make it as anymore than a decent Championship full-back. He isn't quick, so I don't know what Brody is on about there. He is an elegant player with good technique, but I don't know how far that gets you as a full-back.

The only thing that makes me doubt my forecast is that Martinez is happy for him to be in and around the First Team...which means he must rate him.

Dick Brady
9 Posted 20/05/2014 at 07:04:45
Garbutt has an incredible turn of pace. He may not be the quickest over longer distance but he has a burst of pace which surprises defenders and carries him past them.

I completely agree with him not being good enough defensively. That is the one area Garbutt is let down. But he'll never improve defensively unless he's given a chance to learn. At Colchester he improved defensively with every game he played.

Garbutt will make mistakes and he will cost Everton goals but all young defenders are like that. John Stones gets caught out and sometimes is costly at the back. Young defenders are like that.

Trust me Garbutt will improve defensively with experience.

Peter Morris
10 Posted 20/05/2014 at 07:39:54
I think he is quite a different type to Bainesy, who is lithe and wiry, whereas on tonight's showing, Garbutt is a strong and upright lad. He looked very strong in the air, but I would worry about his liability to being turned quickly on the back foot. He was excellent in the Wales game, but you'd have to take account of the standard of opposition. He does look a great prospect, and possibly merits promotion to Bainesy's first deputy. I for one see Brian Oviedo more as a wing/back, filling in when our wingers( Mirallas and Mc Geady) are unfit/out of form or tactics dictate, possibly away from home in Europe. Another great youngster coming through from the junior ranks though.
Terence Leong
12 Posted 20/05/2014 at 07:59:35
Good to hear such news : )

The challenge will always be to blood young players early enough to get first team experience at a sufficiently high level.

With our European commitments, there will automatically be more opportunities for young players to get that precious game time.

As Martinez said, we don't just need better players – we need more players.

Ernie Baywood
13 Posted 20/05/2014 at 09:53:24
Without seeing the game I do recall watching a bit of Stones and being convinced he was too error prone. Likewise Ross; I was sure he needed to mature further before he could get in the first team.

Sometimes you just have to give these lads their chance, put them alongside and against better players. See if the confidence and technique holds up.

Hopefully Garbutt is seen as a realistic option after Baines gets a rest from the World Cup.

Wayne Smyth
14 Posted 20/05/2014 at 13:02:16
Garbutt probably needs a full season with a Championship club; I can't see him being good enough for us at the moment and it would be too costly to play him in premier league games regularly enough for him to gain experience.

Stones is a different prospect altogether. Although he does make errors occasionally, something all of our defenders do, his overall play is superb.

The fact that Stones is on standby for the World Cup tells you everything you need to know about the ability he has, not just potential.

Craig Harrison
15 Posted 20/05/2014 at 15:32:47
Maybe start him right wing and the move backwards to full back. Worked a treat for Seamus. Give the kid a chance before giving up on his defending.
Ian Tunstead
16 Posted 20/05/2014 at 15:51:14
Worked a treat for Bale too, he was a bit shite at the defensive side of his game but it doesn't seem to have done him any harm.
Sam Hoare
17 Posted 20/05/2014 at 16:34:52
If we weren't in Europe I would think a years loan to a good championship club would be the order of the day. Perhaps if Oviedo and Baines are both fit then we can allow this as I reckon 40 games for Wigan or Brighton etc would be the best thing for the lad rather than a few games and minutes here and there for us.

He's essentially where Seamus was 3 or 4 years ago. Hopefully he can develop at the same rate.

Sue Brown
19 Posted 22/05/2014 at 18:04:54
A chance to see Garbutt and Browning and the U21's in the Toulon Tournament... about to start on BTsports1

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb