Barkley better off staying Blue

, 21 May, 64comments  |  Jump to most recent
Martinez has no interest in selling rising star
Responding to the 20 year-old's call-up to the England squad and the inevitable speculation about his future after an explosive first full season in the Premier League, Roberto Martinez has re-stated his commitment to keeping Ross Barkley at Everton, irrespective of what kind of money the club might be offered for him should he take Brazil by storm this summer.

Fresh reports of interest from Chelsea in the past few days — likely more media mischief than evidence of any impending concrete bid — have raised the prospect of the Blues being put in the position of having to consider a huge cash offer for their precocious young talent but Martinez is adamant that Barkley is going nowhere.

"Ross is a phenomenal talent, probably the best English talent I have ever seen," the Spaniard says, "but he is not the finished article yet and you need to be very careful.

"It's our duty to protect him and Everton is the perfect place for him for the next 12 months."

Martinez is under no illusions that he will need to bring success to Goodison in order to keep young diamonds like Barkley and John Stones at Goodison Park long term but he believes that the stability on offer at Everton is vital for their current development.

"In football obviously you can never speak about the future," he continues. "We need to come along and try to get into the top four positions to offer players like Ross the next stage of their development.

"But Ross is delighted at Everton and feels very much in the right place at the right time of his career."

The manager is confident that, based on the way in which he has risen the big occasion for the Blues this past season, his young charge can make a difference for England in Brazil next month if called upon:

"Ross is the only footballer who I know for a fact just loves the game. Put him on a football pitch and he will just be himself, nothing is going to faze him.

"There are certain types of games that will suit him better than others, but he is ready now to fulfil whatever role the England manager wants to give him.

"If you analyse Ross's season it's been against the top teams when he's excelled. For us he's a star and whatever happens in the World Cup is not going to change that perception."

Quotes sourced from The Express



Reader Comments (64)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Daniel Lawrence
1 Posted 21/05/2014 at 07:06:48
"The next 12 months" looks like we may get a year off from selling to loan...

Well in, Kenwright.

Kunal Desai
2 Posted 21/05/2014 at 07:23:34
Everyone knows he would be better off staying at Everton especially if we want to win something, sadly BK and his buddies have no ambition to progress this club further and only money talks for them. I wouldn’t be surprised if we go through another Rooney scenario.
Steven Telford
3 Posted 21/05/2014 at 07:21:50
Come on, he can’t be "the only" footballer who Martinez knows for a fact just loves the game.

Aye, and that "for the next 12 months comment" doesn’t exactly reek of what we wanted to hear.

But seriously, the game is full of wankers these days, Tevez who can’t find a restaurant in Manchester, Addy-bi-whore, Ashley Cole who feels he is a slave and Yaya who spits the cake out and cries because Roberto Carlos got a car for his birthday... cringe-worthy stuff really.

I’m glad we seem to have a much more decent lot at Everton, starting with the manger. We seem to have well spirited team, and hanging on to Ross is key to our chances for cracking the glass ceiling.

The clubs should work together to try to marginalise the sort of agents who pollute the players’ minds and have them forget that they really need to be enjoying the game and appreciating how lucky they are to be able to earn their living this way.

Colin Glassar
4 Posted 21/05/2014 at 07:55:49
If Ross goes we should get Yaya Toure to replace him. A cake and a couple of candles should do the trick.
Andrew Ellams
5 Posted 21/05/2014 at 08:45:43
Exactly Steven, and add Gerrard, Suarez, Terry and Rooney to that list... and I do wonder sometimes if we are better where we are rather than have some of those horrible individuals at our club if that is what is required for success.
Graham Mockford
6 Posted 21/05/2014 at 09:18:00
I’m with you, Steven Telford. Roberto’s comments are over the top. However, I think they point to the real issue here.

The club don’t need to cash in and I’d be amazed if they want to sell. The question is: Will Ross want to stay if a suitor comes along with a mega contract and the potential of lots of medals?

I suspect Roberto is doing everything to make the lad feel wanted with his public pronouncements. My gut feeling assuming his progression continues is one more season. Not a pleasant feeling but reflective of how big a gulf there is financially between us and a number of other clubs.

Ken Buckley
7 Posted 21/05/2014 at 09:30:04
As ever, at any level, the best players will get the chance to follow the medals and the money that goes with success. Most do.

Here’s hoping we get some success soon.

Jimmy Hill
8 Posted 21/05/2014 at 10:22:23
Winning will make him stay, eg, Atletico Madrid: one Barcelona player cost more than the whole Atletico Madrid team.

It can be done, let’s hope we win the CL too and stop this money madness. Or maybe we should start baking birthday cakes to attract players.

Andrew Hawes
9 Posted 21/05/2014 at 10:13:17
I think Roberto should think more about how his words can be interpreted.

"Perfect place for the next 12 months"??

How about "We see Ross as a future captain and lynchpin of the side and no amount of money would persuade us to sell"???

It’s okay saying we’re not a selling club, that we only sell for astronomical fees... most of the clubs we are now competing with DO have astronomical fees to take any of our major players!

Ross has to become our Gerrard, a one-club man and talisman — no amount of money should interfere with that, if we are serious about being a top 4 club.

Danny Broderick
10 Posted 21/05/2014 at 10:53:42
This is a big faux pas from Martinez. He’s normally very media savvy. I don’t know what he was thinking with his "12 months" thing. It’s like he’s inviting clubs to come in for him next year, or hinting that Ross doesn’t need to stay beyond next summer.

That is not the sort of comment I expect from the Everton manager. I expect him to say he’s an Everton player, an Everton fan & he’s going nowhere.

I really am baffled by that comment.

Denis Richardson
11 Posted 21/05/2014 at 10:46:22
"It’s our duty to protect him and Everton is the perfect place for him for the next 12 months."

That line doesn’t fill me with great hope of keeping him long term.....does he not have just two years left on his current contract, ie, next summer if no new contract is signed we’re basically fooked if he wants to go.

The club said in February that they wanted to give him a new contract ’to reward his progress’ (ie, stop him leaving). However, it’s now May and the club is saying they want to sort it out in the summer. Surely it would be better to do it now, before the World Cup. If he has a blinder I can see a £30m-£40m bids coming in this summer and the club will say that the offers were ’too good to turn down’.

He’s supposed to be on £15k/week at the moment, wonder what the new offer will end up being, £30k, £40k maybe £50k/week? After the World Cup, his agent is going to try and squeeze as much out of us as possible... he may even end up being one of our top earners on around £60k-£70k/week.

Adam Luszniak
12 Posted 21/05/2014 at 10:57:26
I would be gutted if we lost Barkley. His moments of real magic this season have made up for some truly heart-wrenching defeats. We have a great team but Ross is an exceptional talent.
Karl Parsons
13 Posted 21/05/2014 at 11:02:11
Good shout, Jimmy. Stay, Ross, and we will build you a statue when you eventually leave us as the best ever Everton player.
Charles Cook
14 Posted 21/05/2014 at 11:03:21
I’m less concerned about the "12 months" comments than others. He has spoken previously of need to review situations and the inference I take is that we’re working to make the club one that players like Ross would want to stay at, and I’m convinced that is the aim. The ’going nowhere’ line for me sounds hollow and a bit chest thumping – especially if the player goes on to leave.

Having said all that, the role of the media has been interesting and they’re approaching it very differently to the Rooney situation. There appears to be recognition that he is better off where he is – partly because of the litany of disastrous moves of young players to sit on star-studded benches – and, I’m glad to say, because of recognition that he’s already at a club that is very good for him.

We’ve been known for our stability in recent years but Roberto has established us as a club that knows what to do with top talent.

Mike Childs
15 Posted 21/05/2014 at 10:54:36
I agree with Jimmy Hill that an Atletico victory in the CL would be huge for us. Positive reinforcement that it can be done if a group plays together as one. The way they work together, covering for one another, their all out effort is beautiful to watch. The path from the Europa League to where they are now, the possible parallels for us are endless.
Sue Brown
16 Posted 21/05/2014 at 11:10:52
Strange comment from Roberto! I agree with Denis, the club are being very slow "rewarding him with a new contract", maybe Bill’s having trouble opening his piggy bank?

I have a feeling though that Ross will show more loyalty to the club than Rooney did; he seems altogether more grounded and clearly loves Everton.

As much as I can’t stand Stevie G, if reports were right a few months ago re him talking to Ross about committing to the club he loves, then he will have done something useful in his miserable life!

Geoff Evans
17 Posted 21/05/2014 at 11:47:27
It’s important to teams like Everton that Atlético do the business against Real; it will enforce what Roberto said when he joined us: ’’You can attain success without spending huge amounts of money, it just takes longer’’.

Let’s be honest with ourselves, big money signings are never going to be an option at Goodison, so we’re going to have to do it the hard way... as usual!

Paul Withe
18 Posted 21/05/2014 at 11:59:14
Calm down! RM has subsequently clarified he didn’t mean he should be staying with us for the next 12 months, but that the next year is key for him. He’s said he isn’t for sale and will be here for the long term and I believe him. I trust him more than I ever trusted Moyes, although I do accept that it’s not always RM’s decision!
Kevin Tully
19 Posted 21/05/2014 at 11:56:37
It’s easy to get caught up in the financial rewards the Premier League may have to offer these young players, but I do think there are myths surrounding what other clubs would offer young Mr Barkley.

Players his age are not offered £100k a week contracts. I bet Lukaku is on no more than £40k a week at moneybags Chelsea and look at his potential. Rooney was twice the player Ross is at 20, so that’s not a fair comparison either. We can certainly match any wage offers he would receive in the Premier League.

The point is, would Spurs, Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea, Man City or Man Utd be selling this lad in the next 5 years? Absolutely not. If we do sell him, it will be a statement of intent (again) that Everton FC are nothing more than a feeder club, who sell their finest players to survive. We may as well roll over now, before the competition gets underway.

My only concern is who would conduct negotiations now poor Mrs Kenwright is no longer with us? The extract below is from Fergie’s book:

"It was Aug 2004 and we had just played Everton. Bill Kenwright was crying. As we studied the Everton chairman in his sorrow, he announced that he would like to make a call. Through his tears, Bill said: "I’ll need to phone my mother."

"They’re stealing our boy, they’re stealing our boy,"  he said down the line.

Then he passed the phone to me: "Don’t you dare think you’re getting that boy for nothing. That boy’s worth £50 million,"  said a female voice.

Graham Mockford
20 Posted 21/05/2014 at 11:50:58
It’s strange how everyone automatically assumes it is the club stalling on the new contract rather than the player himself.

If I was the player’s agent with no allegiance to the club, I would have been advising him to wait until after the World Cup to negotiate a new deal. He will be in a stronger bargaining position with only two years of his current deal remaining.

After all, it makes commercial sense for the club to tie him into a longer contract because even if he does want to leave in the next few years his value is greater with three or four years than just one.

Phil Sammon
21 Posted 21/05/2014 at 12:20:05
Kevin

That extract really creased me over. It read like a 5-year-old crying because a bigger boy took his toy. No wonder Man Utd offered 27 million for Fellaini and Baines if that is an example of BK at the negotiating table.

Eugene Ruane
22 Posted 21/05/2014 at 12:35:36
Graham (20) - "It’s strange how everyone automatically assumes it is the club stalling on the new contract rather than the player himself."

I think it’s strange that when a pride of hungry lions appear out of the Serengeti bush, loads of small furry things run like fuck.

Strange that is... VERY strange.

Trevor Lynes
23 Posted 21/05/2014 at 13:17:10
I want any player we develop to think that his best place remains with us. We were once the top club in the league and players did not aspire to improve themselves by going elsewhere.

Unfortunately our club has a history of dismantling potentially great sides in exchange for filthy lucre. That is why we have never been able to sustain a winning sequence season after season. Shankley and Paisley did at Liverpool and we should have done exactly the same because we had the same ingredients. Catterick got rid of John Carey’s stars and even though he had a successful time whilst he was our manager he left no legacy.

The only manager since Shankley to establish a winning sequence that compared to the Shankley/ Paisley era is Ferguson at UTD but even that is wavering due to not continuing the improvement that had been established.

If we are to become a club with real ambition then we must keep ALL our young stars and build on them ! Our club has always been a selling club and it would be a shame if the base that has been built last season was allowed to be dismantled for monetary reasons.

Financially we are in really great shape and there is no need to cash in on our young assets.

Kevin Gillen
24 Posted 21/05/2014 at 12:33:41
Colin Glassar at 04 - that cracked me up mate! Just what I was looking for this morning.

On the Ross front, it’s all win-win as far as I can see. I would love him to stay but if he goes we get a shedload of cash to front new signings or rebuild/relocate to a new stadium.

No sign of our production line of exceptional talent stopping. It’s been really enjoyable watching Ledson and Kenny and Garbutt in England shirts in the last few weeks, they are all really exciting young talents.

I trust Martinez to do the right thing, so far he has proved more successful than Moyes in his transfer dealings, not to denigrate Moyes because he did an exceptional job too in the transfer market, in my opinion.

Paul Andrews
25 Posted 21/05/2014 at 13:40:37
Kevin,

Bale, Torres, Van Persie,
They all sell if the money is right.
And they are all financially stable clubs

I am with you 100% re keeping Ross, but we both know the Chairman’s modus operandi.

Paul Smith
26 Posted 21/05/2014 at 13:51:32
Ross will stay if we progress and show ambition. Why wouldn’t he?

If we don’t! Then you can’t blame him now, can you?

Phil Bellis
27 Posted 21/05/2014 at 14:02:05
There’s nothing Bill loves more than being loved; it’s in his lovey makeup.

He’s got away with so much over the years of his "stewardship" but I’d hope even his "realist", post-Sky fans would fucking lynch him if he lost Ross.

James Marshall
28 Posted 21/05/2014 at 14:27:55
Atlético don’t need to win the CL to reinforce anything – they’ve already won La Liga and proved it can be done. Interestingly though, all this talk of how competitive the Premier League is versus other European leagues is actually bullshit.

There’s an interesting article English top flight more predictable than on continent which talks about how the Engliash league has actually got less competitive.

Atletico are already the watermark.

Kevin Tully
29 Posted 21/05/2014 at 14:14:34
Paul, There’s one glaring difference — the proceeds from those sales didn’t go to pay off the banks (Arteta) to pay running costs, or to keep a board in-situ who refuse to invest in their own business.

I would also add every penny of those sales you mention was invested back into purchasing players and in some cases, millions more were added.

I’ve no problem selling players, it’s how the game operates, but how long do we keep on selling our best so Bill & Co can carry on happily waving to the crowd? Are we selling players so Robert Earl can decide when the time is right to cash in, without dipping into his £300m fortune?

20 years without a trophy, are we just happy to plod along potless for another 20 years?

Dave Cook
30 Posted 21/05/2014 at 14:46:04
Ross is going to fund the new stadium all by himself, clearly.

12 months is enough time for the board to make plans that will never work out for us surely.

Anto Byrne
31 Posted 21/05/2014 at 12:17:26
I don’t think we can compare Rooney with Ross. Ross is a year behind due to a bad leg injury and was further held back by Moyes’s reluctance to give him games.

He would have been a far better option in midfield than Neville, learning the game with the elite instead of Sheffield or Leeds where everyone could see he was miles ahead in terms of ability and playing the game. I doubt very much he would be going to the World Cup if that former Man Utd manager had stuck around.

Bill Gall
32 Posted 21/05/2014 at 14:19:33
All this talk and speculation brings to light the biggest problem in the game: that, to me, is the reason that young players are getting their heads turned... and that is the agents.

These people state that they are hired to protect their client’s interest but they are a business that want to make money and, by getting their clients a transfer (the largest fee possible), make themselves rich.

The sad thing about the Barkley rumors are the only person that should state that he will not be sold at any price to squash the rumors is the Chairman and unfortunately to most supporters his word is not worth the paper it is written on.

Sports writers seem to be able to pick the name of players who are getting transfered out of a hat and so far the number of players we are signing is going to cost over £100mill so I don’t believe one word they write and will only believe who Everton are going to sign after they sign a contract.

Steavey Buckley
33 Posted 21/05/2014 at 14:53:45
Roberto is going to take Everton to a new level that the rest of the Premier League are not doing. The key to the success is having a production line of young and exciting talent by changing the way Everton have done things in the past.

He will create a footballing village for young players to live, work and play without having to be distracted by the bright lights of the city centre once they have left Finch Farm.

Malcolm Joyner
34 Posted 21/05/2014 at 15:13:17
Don’t bet on it, Steavey!

BK still holds the purse strings and unless he has a personality transplant he won’t let Bobby get carried away with fanciful ideas !

As for Barkley, no doubt he will be persuaded to persuade the club to grant him the transfer to enable him to play in ’Europe proper’. Then we can all slag him off for being a shitface whilst praising BPB for trying to hang onto him !

This is Everton we’re talking about !

Malcolm Joyner
35 Posted 21/05/2014 at 15:29:33
I meant to add that the worst thing that can happen for the lad to be on his way is for him to have the super World Cup we all want for him.

If he comes home a star, his agent, the media .......and probably BK will make sure he’s sold whilst he’s hot!

Steavey Buckley
36 Posted 21/05/2014 at 15:31:15
It’s in Everton’s best interest to create a football village for the benefit of new, young and exciting talent that do not come from Merseyside.

Let’s be honest, Everton cannot compete with teams who can spend £50 million on one player. The amounts are obscene, that a very good manager can spend at a top club to make them successful in the short term.

Yet, what they are doing is souless, by ripping the heart out of the club, which is based on the lives of ordinary fans, who don’t have lots of money to spend, but do love their football club.

Denis Richardson
37 Posted 21/05/2014 at 15:25:35
Eugene 22, no idea what you meant by that statement but it made me spit my tea out. hilarious.
Paul Andrews
38 Posted 21/05/2014 at 15:40:35
Kevin,

I am 100% on your side. Complete agreement with your point. If you have ever read any of my previous posts you will know my take on the chairman and his board.

We all know what happens when we bring a star through the ranks. The greatest ever Evertonian (self-appointed) can’t wait to cash in. A complete phoney, in my opinion.

Graham Mockford
39 Posted 21/05/2014 at 15:59:50
Kevin #29

You’re right in some ways. The transfer of players over the last 5 years ( a net inflow of £35m) has effectively supported the business.

But that’s the business model that has been decided on, if we hadn’t generated income through transfers we would have either had to reduce wages (75% of our revenue) or incurred more debt.

The rise in TV income is a short term shot in the arm which means we are currently less dependent on transfer profits, however what the last 20 years has shown us that an increase in Sky money normally ends up inflating the player wage market and there is every chance we will be back in that position in a couple of years.

Eugene #22 in your rush to provide us one of your pithy quips I think you’re missing my point. We don’t know what’s going on behind the scenes and to assume it’s the club that is stalling is to paraphrase yourself ’ er assuming’. The club could well be planning to cash in, I doubt it personally because I think they would have put a new contract in place to give themselves a stronger bargaining position and there is less financial necessity than in previous years.

Si Cooper
40 Posted 21/05/2014 at 15:59:46
"It’s our duty to protect him and Everton is the perfect place for him for the next 12 months. "In football obviously you can never speak about the future," he continues. "We need to come along and try to get into the top four positions to offer players like Ross the next stage of their development."

Taking the statements as a whole I can’t see anything wrong with what he has said. In fact, I would view it as realistic and an open challenge to the Board. If they just view it as another opportunity to keep their wallets tightly closed, secure in the knowledge that they will have a valuable asset to sell in the future, then there is little he can do about it.

I am not sure why any young player with two years left on his contract would feel the need to stall on signing an improved one. It should be obvious to everyone that agents aren’t shy of asking for more money at every opportunity, even while the ink is still drying on the last contract, so he is likely to lose money or even the opportunity to sign for someone else should he want to.

Denis (37) - I think Eugene is suggesting that our Board have form for appearing to do everything possible to save money, such as procrastinating when new deals are in the offing, and he is surprised more people aren’t aware of it.

Si Cooper
41 Posted 21/05/2014 at 16:47:03
...... unlikely to lose money or even the opportunity to sign for someone else should he want to.
Si Cooper
42 Posted 21/05/2014 at 16:58:30
Graham (39) - I think it is debatable that even doubling the length of his contract really strengthens the clubs bargaining position. You could give the lad an extra 20 grand a week and still see him heading for pastures new if someone stumps up £30+ million in August. To the board that may represent a wasted £240,000.

I don’t think the club would sell him for less no matter if he had 2 years left on his contract or 4, but I need to be convinced they have a ’not at any price’ policy on our current hot properties.

Kevin Day
43 Posted 21/05/2014 at 18:52:26
I keep reading posts that mentions Barkley's agent. I may be wrong but isn't his agent his mum, who's also an Evertonian?

I'm sure I read it somewhere.

Carl Sanderson
44 Posted 21/05/2014 at 19:34:27
I read somewhere that Barkley was represented by a company in which Moyes's brother has some involvement.
Carl Sanderson
45 Posted 21/05/2014 at 19:36:58
"It's our duty to protect him and Everton is the perfect place for him for the next 12 months."

The writing is on the wall for all who care to read it.

Mike Hughes
46 Posted 21/05/2014 at 19:52:51
Colin #4 - classic. I've been on the road all day listening to that story. Unbelievable! I bet Bill's stocking up on frozen cheesecakes as we speak. Don't be surprised at a cheeky bid from us.

Now in a pub in Romsey (near Southampton) listening to a discussion between an Arsenal and Man Utd fan and how shit Fellaini has been. £27 million. Hilarious. I'm keeping low profile.

Malcolm Joyner
47 Posted 21/05/2014 at 20:13:29
I'm sure you are right, Carl. Moyesy obviously got a piece of Ross via his brother before he left us. Let's hope for the players' sake that said Mr Moyes guides him along less troubled lanes than his brother has had to endure since recently!
Christopher Kelly
48 Posted 22/05/2014 at 00:32:17
Nice backstroke, Mr. Martinez.

http://www.goal.com/en-gb/news/2892/transfer-zone/2014/05/21/4832814/-?

Stu Smith
50 Posted 22/05/2014 at 07:44:03
Just been listening to TalkSport on my way to work and I don't know if anyone else heard it but... they were discussing if Everton would sell Barkley but then they dropped in that we may have to because due to us missing out on CL football we have missed out on a takeover as it was based on us achieving CL football next season???

Also on the Ross front, remember he confirmed that Stevie G had spoken to him about staying with us if he is happy.

Peter Howard
51 Posted 22/05/2014 at 07:40:30
I thought Ross was currently in the process of changing his agent.
Thomas Lennon
52 Posted 22/05/2014 at 08:32:33
Atlético don't seem like a model we should follow when you scratch below the surface – 13 fold more in debt than Everton but in CL final, they must be on the brink of disappearing at the stroke of a creditors pen – which would you choose?

http://www.businessweek.com/news/2014-05-13/atletico-madrid-ceo-s-home-as-collateral-shows-team-cash-crunch.

Phil Sammon
53 Posted 22/05/2014 at 09:39:51
I sometimes wonder if only I (and a few fellow Blues) watched Ross Barkley last season. He is a wonderful talent but he had maybe 5 good games all season.

He is perhaps worthy of a Wold Cup place because he does have the ability to change games, but at the moment he doesn't do it nearly enough.

I almost felt his star was fading at one point in the season and only the solo effort, in an otherwise forgettable performance, against Newcastle thrust him back in the limelight. He should have passed by the way.

I really like the lad and I hope he becomes a top player with us...but right now I think there is a little too much hype.

Iain Love
54 Posted 22/05/2014 at 10:17:29
Agreed Phil Sammon, I was always of the opinion that 1 player doesn't make the team. When Rooney was sold that money improved the overall side, if I was offered £50mill for Ross i'd take it and invest in our weaker areas ie Strikers. Imagine what we could have done with Bony & Remy in our squad last season. That would still leave £20mill plus what we already had.
Malcolm Joyner
55 Posted 22/05/2014 at 10:43:42
£50million, Iain? I think he will go for half of that ......plus Jack Rodwell.

Of course, it will be because he wants to leave........!!!

Iain Love
57 Posted 22/05/2014 at 10:54:51
I was merely repeating prices mentioned, I fail to understand half a decent season and those sort of prices, but I would sell at that.

As for wanting to leave, I'm sure if we could offer close to what he could get elsewhere, he'll stay.

But Everton is a business. Albeit a healthier business than this time last decade.

John Daley
58 Posted 22/05/2014 at 12:01:16
"I sometimes wonder if only I (and a few fellow Blues) watched Ross Barkley last season. .... he had maybe 5 good games all season."

Only five good games? 'Maybe'! Like he only, really, performed in four but you'll grant him another because you're feeling generous.Talk about being a harsh task master.

His form dipped when he returned from injury and he struggled to get back up to speed but he was never the 'embarrassment' some blues tried to paint him as in those games. To make out he had, basically, a shoddy season producing piss poor/half-arsed performances in every game bar a handful is just total over the top bollocks.

Jim Potter
60 Posted 22/05/2014 at 13:32:51
The biggest single reason I want him to stay is that kids will identify with him being Everton through and through. If he stays and is the success he promises to be – then local kids will latch onto us rather than the dark side.

We have a great academy and the more home grown youngsters coming through, the happier I am. Just because Shrek sold out doesn't mean Ross will be an overweight granny shagger too.

Phil Sammon
62 Posted 22/05/2014 at 18:50:17
John Daley (and I presume Tony Draper is talking about me).

I'm not being harsh, I'm being honest. He wasn't a shambles by any means. He performed to a 6/10 standard most games with a few standout showings.

I want nothing more than Barkley to succeed at Everton. He is a really good kid and has talent that you might find once a decade. However the boy wonder is still young and has lots to learn. I hope we see some big strides made next year.

Darren Hind
63 Posted 22/05/2014 at 18:44:09
"I sometimes wonder if only I (and a few fellow blues) watched Ross Barkley last season " . . . " He only had maybe five good games"

Personally I sometimes wonder what the fuck people were watching when they said they were watching the games.

Phil Sammon, It wasn't just you and "a few fellow blues" who saw his inconsistency, we all did, The difference being, that the rest of us understood it... and if you only saw him have five good games, that's your own fault, you could have watched the rest.

Are you sure this footy lark is for you?

Phil Sammon
64 Posted 22/05/2014 at 22:58:21
Quite sure, Darren.

I won't bother myself with the site's resident laughing stock.

Si Cooper
65 Posted 22/05/2014 at 23:48:50
Phil, what do you mean by hype? You use the words 'wonderful talent', 'talent you might find once a decade', 'ability to change games' but say you don't understand what people are excited about.

We all know it is still mainly potential but it is potential that is there for all to see, and that is why people want him to stay.

Iain Love, you profess to agree with Phil but if you cannot understand that the wealthy clubs will meet a high asking price to land 'once a decade' talent even before it has peaked then I would hate to be considered as being 'on the same page' with you!

Selling the likes of Rooney and Barkley may enable you to buy enough players to strengthen the team overall but that works best when the supporting cast is generally quite poor and when that is the only option you have of raising funds. Selling your best players just does not make sense in any other circumstances. It would be undeniably better to retain exceptional players and improve the team around them whenever possible, which is what we would like to happen this year because of the improved income the club has received this year.

Patrick Murphy
66 Posted 23/05/2014 at 00:19:29
We could always buy back Felliani for £15m with the proceeds from any sales... now that would certainly test the patience of those of us who want to see Everton progress.

Admittedly, as always, the player and his agent have the final word on what happens next – but, if Barkley has an ounce of sense in his head and a touch of loyalty to Everton, he will extend his contract and stay for at least another 18 months or two years which should be long enough to help him develop and to see what shape Everton FC will be in by that time. Anything else and he joins the rest of the prima donnas who only look out for themselves.

Darren Hind
67 Posted 23/05/2014 at 04:48:25
Phil Salmon

It comes as considerable relief to me to find you feel that way. I would hate to think I had the approval of somebody who cant tell the difference between a deeply unpopular post and an incredibly stupid one.

You want to attack the constancy of a kid, who despite already suffering career-threatening injuries, has, to seemingly universal praise, forced his way into the World Cup squad in his FIRST full season... yet you cry like a schoolgirl when somebody dares to criticise the guy who consistently picked him.

Perhaps the object of your desire should cash in on our "6/10", " only 5 good games a season", "overhyped" local boy and replace with a good old 7/10, won't let you down workhorse.

I've rejected this "relative success" malarky; I've also drawn attention to what I believe are the shortcomings of possibly Everton's most popular and charismatic manger... how did YOUR stock get to be so high?

Phil Sammon
68 Posted 23/05/2014 at 07:31:10
Si

I'm by no means slagging Barkley off. I'm just saying that this season he has lacked consistency. That is almost certainly because he's young. Perhaps 'hype' was the wrong word. The kind of talent he is, he deserves hype. He just needs to bring that hype to fruition. Drive past players more, make the appropriate pass and generally become a more polished player.

Believe me, nobody wants Barkley to succeed at Everton more than I do.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb