Southall challenges FA's top-down approach

, 29 May, 16comments  |  Jump to most recent
Neville Southall says that the Football Association's proposals to boost the number of English players in the Premier League is fundamentally flawed without focusing first on the grassroots game.

FA chairman Greg Dyke revealed the recommendations of the England Commission this month which include the idea of creating a new Football League Three between the current League Two and the Conference made up partially of Premier League B teams.

The B sides would have a ceiling at the top of League One that would prevent them being promoted to the Championship but the suggestion has proved controversial.

Southall, whose route to the top started with his job as a binman, insists that any serious efforts to address the problems affecting the domestic game can't start from the top.

"You always start at the bottom and work your way up, you don't start at the top and work your way down," he told Press Association Sport.

"When they start building houses from the roof down, I'll agree with it but they never do."

"What we need are real facilities and ones that won't cost everyone a fortune to use.

"If we don't make football more accessible for the masses it won't matter how many B teams you've got because you won't have anybody to fill them."

The FA's aim through the proposals is to increase the number of English players in the top flight from 32% to 45% by the year 2022 and thereby strengthen the prospects of the England national team.

 

Reader Comments (16)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Peter Laing
1 Posted 29/05/2014 at 17:21:14
Spot on from Neville. My sons are involved in the grassroots game at junior level and the standard of coaching and facilities in general is diabolical. Too much emphasis on clubs picking kids up at 6-8 years and developing them in academies which generally fail to produce. Pitches covered in dogshite, unplayable for most of the winter months and coaches more often with the nous of Mike England.

The Premier League has got away with murder for the past 10 years and systematically failed to grant the agreed percentage of the revenue that should be given to grassroots football, although, with the likes of Scudamore and Dyke with their noses in the trough, I can't see it changing anytime soon.

James Flynn
2 Posted 29/05/2014 at 17:46:37
Yikes. Youth programs there sounds like youth programs over here.
Colin Glassar
3 Posted 29/05/2014 at 18:53:50
Mike England? Blast from the past.
Patrick Murphy
4 Posted 29/05/2014 at 18:58:41
I just read somewhere that the Crosby and District Sunday league is no more, due to a lack of sponsors - less Public House etc and teams unable to meet the fees to pay for renting a pitch which is £800 plus other fees. The League didn't get enough teams to register and decided to call it a day.

Globalisation means that there will always be enough players to recruit for the elite clubs but it won't do anything for England or any of the other home nations. All the money in the world and a football mad city like Liverpool loses one of it's leagues a sign of the times I suppose.

Paul Mackie
5 Posted 29/05/2014 at 19:26:59
Southall is spot about football matters *again*. That man talks the most sense of any ex-pro.
Howard Rowles
6 Posted 29/05/2014 at 20:07:02
Couldn't agree more with Nev. Kids have to be able to play for little money, the more people who, play the bigger the field, the more likely we will find the next Neville Southall.
Sean Kelly
7 Posted 29/05/2014 at 20:27:24
Spot on from Big Nev. He does talk a lot if sense. If international teams from the UK and Ireland want to develop their talent it has to start at grass root level. Over here in Ireland they have league competitions for kids. How daft is that?

Kids up to the age of 12 or 13 should be developed with technique first and not the shite they get from over ambititious gobshites pretending to be coaches. Most of these guys are failed low level league footballers that have had any form of coaching.

I have been on coaching courses here and everyone gets a cert after day 2 of the courses. Until the FAI or its equivalent bodies in the UK get real and give the coaches proper coaching sessions and take a proper interest at grass roots level it will never be sorted.

Over here the GAA and the Rugby clubs take roper care in developing young players and give them pitches that are a joy to play on. Having coaches in local league football for done years I have had the experience of chasing horses and sheep from football pitches. The most useful tool for a coach here is a shovel both for chasing the animals and getting rid of their shite from pitches.

Dick Fearon
8 Posted 29/05/2014 at 20:40:52
Local councils should be ashamed to price kids off playing a healthy sport.

I wonder how much it costs councils plus local shops due to kids with unsupervised activity and nothing to occupy their spare time.

Another thing to take into consideration is the value to the community of thousands of unpaid volunteers who also benefit from being outdoors instead of permanently staring at TV.

Brian Denton
9 Posted 29/05/2014 at 21:18:54
Quick heads up; according to the BBC web site Joey Barton is one of the panellists on Question Time tonight. Could be a bit more interesting than usual.
Niall MacDiarmada
10 Posted 29/05/2014 at 23:21:52
An interesting viewpoint on Belgium’s rise:

Belgium's rise began with humiliation. Sablon was an assistant coach at the 1986 World Cup for Belgium's last “golden generation.” Built on brilliant goalkeeper Jean-Marie Pfaff and midfielder Enzo Scifo, known as “Le Petit Pelé,” the team reached the semifinals. A decade and a half later, Sablon was asked to run the Belgian half of Euro 2000, which the country co-hosted with Holland. But the tournament was a disaster for the national team. Boring, slow and unimaginative — “talking instead of playing,” says Sablon — the Belgians scored two goals in four minutes in their first match against Sweden and did precisely nothing after that. Belgium lost its subsequent games and became the first-ever host of a European tournament to be knocked out in the first round.

Sablon became the technical director of the Belgian FA two years later. His first move was to tear up the existing system. “We started from scratch,” he explained. “We said, “What we're doing now, it doesn't work.” The national team was out of ideas. The youth teams coming through weren't getting any better. Coaching was mired in outdated soccer dogma — 8-year-old girls were being asked to play as liberos, sweepers in the Beckenbauer mold, because Belgium's professional teams had a thing for playing three central defenders at the time. It didn't make sense to teach the game that way. No one was having any fun.

Sablon worked like a maniac. He spent two years driving to Belgian youth competitions and studying what the French and Dutch national teams (at the time the strongest in the world) were up to. He commissioned researchers at the University of Leuven to analyze 1,600 hours of footage of young boys playing 11-on-11 to figure out how often they actually touched the ball (an average of four touches per player every 20 minutes). He convened People's Congress–style meetings with groups of coaches from various levels of Belgian football to discuss formations and training methods. “We were crazy, of course,” he told me. “We never stopped. We started in the morning and we finished in the night. Every day, Saturday and Sunday.”

The result, unveiled in 2004, was Belgium's master plan, called G-A-G — Global-Analytique-Global in French, or Globaal-Analytisch-Globaal in Dutch. The idea was to fuse the best of French soccer — its emphasis on physical power and tactical efficiency, hence “Analytique” — with the dreamy technique of the Dutch (“Global”), and invent a new kind of exciting, attacking soccer (“Global” again). “Our ultimate goal is deliberately utopian,” Sablon's successor, Bob Browaeys, said recently. (Sablon retired from the FA in 2012.) “One hundred percent possession of the ball.”

In practice, G-A-G means standardization. All over Belgium these days, boys and girls grow up playing soccer the same way. Every school, youth academy, and village team plays the same formation — 4-3-3, with classic, dribbling wingers — and follows the same progression up to the 11-on-a-side game. Kids under the age of 7 play 2-on-2; under-9s play 5-on-5; under-11s play 8-on-8. They never use more than half the field. It is only when they're 12 years old that boys and girls are finally introduced to a full-size pitch and the idea of a long pass.

It hasn't been easy. Amateur clubs grouse about change and squabble over money. Young Belgian teams also lose a lot. It's harder to be utopian than it is to play the offside trap. “It takes some five or six years for our youth teams,” Sablon said. “They play open. They are attacking all the time. They lose, but that is not our problem – The identity and the development of the players is much more important than that.”

Derek Thomas
11 Posted 30/05/2014 at 01:02:53
Nev nails it.

Q) But what will it take to fix it?

A) Money... and the will to use it properly

Q) How has the money?

A) Look in L4 (& L5)

1 Seamus Colman fee (£64k) per year (per club) will pay for 80 pitches per year = 160 teams per week @ 15 players per team =2400 players; take the top 1% = 24... you can see where this is going.

Simplistic? maybe?

But doing nothing is your other option...how good’s that going to be then?

What good are all your fancy finch farms with no kids for the scouts to scout?

Make the pitch size pro rata to age, so they can learn, at 8, 9 and 10 to pass it about.

Rant over.

Tommy Coleman
12 Posted 30/05/2014 at 07:59:26
100% correct again Big Nev.

Improve pitches so kids can learn to play properly.

Increase the number of qualified coaches, Spain has around 10 times the amount England does.

Improve scouting, how many footy mates do we all know that could have made it.

David Ellis
13 Posted 30/05/2014 at 08:12:07
Southall may be correct - but not sure he has read the FA report which fully acknowledges his point.
Phil Sammon
14 Posted 30/05/2014 at 08:18:55
My dad manages a junior team and the work that goes into it is unreal. The prices they pay for pitches on a Sunday, the prices they pay for 3G on a Wednesday night, the whole child protection scheme, the accounting, the insurance, the admin...just to get lads out on the pitch having a kickabout. My dad is a sucker for putting himself under undue stress, but I really don't know how people cope with it.
Tony Abrahams
15 Posted 30/05/2014 at 09:55:37
Good post, Niall. The FA seem to acknowledge most things but never get around to addressing them properly.

Improve conditions is all people go on about and do we know the easiest and most cost effective place to begin?

In the winter in England the pitches become heavy so we let our under-7s play on them? Not good for skill but fantastic for character building though, playing in the rain and the mud. The most effective players take the best throw-ins, or have the biggest kick, honestly.

Winter football should only start for kids when they go to senior school IMO. Senior pros struggle to play in the mud, but for most kids in England that is their introduction to football.

Andy Meighan
16 Posted 30/05/2014 at 11:05:03
"When they start building houses from the roof down..." — you can always rely on the greatest ever cat to come out with a classic quote! Classic, Nev!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb