Barkley impresses in first England start

, 4 June, 134comments  |  Jump to most recent
Ecuador 2 - 2 England
Ross Barkley enjoyed a hugely promising outing in his first start and John Stones made another late cameo for England in a 2-2 draw with Ecuador in Miami's Sun Life Stadium.

Barkley showed some lovely touches and flashed a low drive wide in the first half before laying up England's second goal for Ricky Lambert to lash home early in the second half.

Leighton Baines and Phil Jagielka were rested but Stones was again included on the bench hoping to earn his second England cap with a substitute's appearance.

Deployed in his favoured "number 10" role behind the striker, Barkley sparkled at times for England and might have got himself on the scoresheet inside six minutes but Ricky Lambert delayed the pass and the Everton man was flagged a yard offside.

A surging counter-attack and a delicious back-heel that almost carved the Ecuadorians open when Wayne Rooney teased the ball across the face of Ecuador's goal provided more evidence of what Barkley could do before he drove past his marker and lined up a long-range drive that arrowed not far wide eight minutes before the break.

Better was to come from Barkley, though, who skinned his marker with a deft touch and then feigned to shoot before laying up Lambert to drive into the far corner from the angle and make it 2-1 to England with 51 minutes gone after Rooney had cancelled out Enner Valencia's headed opener in the first period.

Stones made his entrance in the 74th minute, replacing Luke Shaw, entering an increasingly open game as the South American side, having equalised through Michael Arroyo's terrific 20-yard shot, began pressing for a winner.

After 83 minutes, Barkley was withdrawn in favour of Danny Welbeck while Stones made a couple of strong forays down the right after switching to that flank following Raheem Sterling's dismissal for a rash tackle on Antonio Valencia.

Barkley's showing drew praise from almost all quarters, with Oliver Holt in The Mirror saying that "there were positives [for England]. Most of all, that means the performance of Ross Barkley who was England's best player and produced a series of surging runs that pressed his case for inclusion in Hodgson's starting line-up against Italy in Manaus."

Meanwhile, the Daily Mail evoked comparisons with Paul Gascoigne, saying that the "Everton midfielder was brilliant for England in Ecuador [and] appeared quite at home in his first start for the Three Lions."

Hodgson, though, was less effusive and appeared positively defensive in his post-match interview. He singled out Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Phil Jones as being "outstanding" but criticised Barkley for losing the ball too much, even though his Opta Stats revealed a pass-completion rate of 91%.

Asked whether Barkley would be among the starters against Italy in Manaus in 10 days' time, the England manager said: "There always seems to be an enormous obsession with one player...

"I will be prepared to start any of the players in any game, but I'm not prepared to address your obsession with Ross Barkley.

"If he's going to be the player we want him to be, he has to make better decisions when he turns with the ball.

"That's not a criticism, but there were other performances out there today. Oxlade-Chamberlain and Phil Jones were outstanding, as was Jack Wilshere in the middle of the park, while Rickie Lambert scored a magnificent goal."

 

Reader Comments (134)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Hewitt
1 Posted 04/06/2014 at 19:16:30
Let’s hope he gets a full 90 minutes.
Dick Brady
2 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:09:47
I don't know why John Stones is on the bench. I wouldn't pick Phil Jones or Chris Smalling over Stones.
Mike Gaynes
3 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:16:40
Ross looks absolutely confident and in full command. Just played a backheel to Rooney that was a work of art.
Paul Hewitt
4 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:17:45
After that goal, I don’t know either.
Chris Wilson
5 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:18:00
Yeah, Ross playing forward. Did just kinda bail out on a defensive challenge though.
Eugene Ruane
6 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:20:46
That England defence is looking very... iffy.
Chris Wilson
7 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:21:04
Whew! Some Barkley magic there!
Colin Glassar
8 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:22:40
Townsend has had a pop at Ross about three times now. What a gobshyte he is.
Chris Wilson
9 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:26:48
Has Rooney dyed his hair? It seem darker on my feed.
Eugene Ruane
10 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:30:32
After the goal, Lampard gave Rooney's hair a little celebratory tousle and he almost shat (slapped it back into place dead quick). Guaranteed that within three months of young Wayne retiring, he'll look like Stan Ogden (one for the teenagers there).
Kevin Tully
11 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:32:47
It goes that colour when you have your arse hair transplanted onto your head Chris.

On the subject of Rooney, he looks like a 45-year-old when playing International football.

Chris Wilson
12 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:36:05
Are you sure it's "arse" hair, Kevin? There are a few other options on the human body. ; )
Paul Hewitt
13 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:40:43
I hope Ross comes out second half and is not taken off for Stevie G...
Colin Glassar
14 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:46:11
I think Andy Townsend has done Ross's head in. He's been hiding ever since Townsend started having a go at him.
Paul Hewitt
15 Posted 04/06/2014 at 20:48:36
I think Ross had a decent half.
Tony McNulty
16 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:09:16
To borrow some of Billy Connolly's script, when Townsend is speaking it's a great opportunity to practise your "Fuck offs."
Mike Gaynes
17 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:10:57
Ross just ripped Ecuador apart and served up a goal for Lambert. Add another £5 million to his value, folks.
Rob Halligan
18 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:10:24
A brilliant run by Barkley to set Lambert up and all Townsend has gone on about for about 2 minutes is the new shite forward. No credit at all given by Townsend about Barkley's run. Gobshite!!!
Patrick Murphy
19 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:14:00
Yeah, Rob... but according to Townsend the pass to Lambert from which he scored wasn't really good enough. I like Oxlade-Chamberlain but you would think that he is head and shoulders above Ross listening to the commentators.
Dick Brady
21 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:19:03
I must be watching another game. I think Barkley has been okay and had a couple of promising moments but Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain has been terrific and is really playing his way into Roy's thoughts.
Patrick Murphy
22 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:21:48
Good one Dick - you are always fair with your assessments of all things Everton. I'm not saying that Oxlade-Chamberlain hasn't had a good game but he has lost the ball as much as Ross but I don't hear Townsend mentioning that in his commentary.

They have both done well and both could play more than a bit-part in the World Cup Finals.

Rob Halligan
23 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:18:27
He's done quite well, Chamberlain. Had a few decent runs. I don't think Wilshere has done much though. he's been caught in possession a few times. A decent player but, for me, he is vastly overrated.
Patrick Murphy
24 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:27:03
Can we buy that lad? He can hit a ball.
Dick Brady
25 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:25:19
I think both Oxlade-Chamberlain and Barkley will be substitutes for the World Cup and both will probably be used as an impact player late into games. Possibly Oxlade-Chamberlain is playing his way into the 'first substitute' role although Barkley has done okay and shouldn't be overlooked.

Annoyingly it looks like Raheem Stirling is playing his way into the starting 11 and that will make it even harder for me to support England. The more RS players they add to the starting 11 the harder it is for me to truly get behind them.

Must be annoying for Oxlade-Chamberlain and Barkley too because Stirling is actually younger than both of them.

Mike Gaynes
26 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:32:59
And now Stones is in to win it!
Dick Brady
27 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:32:14
It's so good to see John Stones get a second cap. I think Roy has really been impressed with Stones's attitude and application; hopefully it's the start of a very long and successful International career for Stones.
Chris Wilson
29 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:36:13
Ewwww... double red card. What's Townsend saying now?
Patrick Murphy
30 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:35:31
That made Townsend look a prick seeing as they both got sent-off, it was a poor challenge and a poor reaction by Valencia. But I am getting sick and tired of this anything that a RS player does is valid regardless of the evidence in front of their eyes.
Dick Brady
31 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:36:55
Commentator suggesting that's there's a national clamour to get Raheem Stirling in the starting 11 and Roy's been fighting that temptation and protecting him.

Really??? Is the nation really clamouring to get Stirling into the starting 11?

Personally I couldn't care less if Raheem Stirling starts.

Charles Brewer
32 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:39:49
It's a friendly and Sterling went in with a typical Redshite tackle. Valencia would have been perfectly justified in snapping his leg after that one.

Dick Brady
33 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:41:03
Rickie Lambert goes off. Yay! One less RS player in the team.

Jordan Henderson replaces him. Bollox.

The highs and lows of being an Everton England supporter.

Mike Gaynes
34 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:39:47
Stones getting forward from RB with a couple of lovely touches. So COOL to see him out there. Probably won't play in Brazil, but what an experience for him anyway.
Paul Hewitt
35 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:42:34
Ross did okay, I think.
Chris Wilson
36 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:41:11
A challenge like he made (Stirling) does not get you in the starting 11. Makes you a liability.
Colin Glassar
37 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:41:15
I'm glad Ross went off, Townsend was persecuting him all game. England have played okay but that kid Shaw was useless. If he's worth £30m then Stones must be worth £50m at least.
Eugene Ruane
38 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:43:00
Have a feeling Valencia didn't react to the tackle, my mate speaks Spanish and was able to lip-read something along the lines of "Don't you DARE come near me with that twat of a haircut... EVER!"
Dick Brady
39 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:45:13
Agree with Colin. I was worried that Baines might have serious competition in Shaw and, after finally seeing off Cashley Cole, his position as the first choice starting left back might be short-lived. But Shaw has looked very rough tonight and it doesn't look like Leighton need worry too much.
Charles Brewer
40 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:43:55
Lambert looked like a complete cart horse. Presumably he has some DNA evidence on the Gerrard family, and that's why he was bought.

If Jagielka, Baines or Cahill are injured, England have a truly shit defence.

Dick Brady
41 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:50:35
I want to like Adam Lallana. He seems like the sort of player I should like.

But every time I see him play now, all I can think is, 'I know where you're playing next season'.

Tosser.

Colin Glassar
42 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:50:53
Charles, I thought Lambert did well. Ross needs to show a bit more self belief. Too many times he went for the easy pass. But with Townsend on his back all evening who wouldn't lose a bit of confidence?
Ian Bennett
43 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:53:36
The back 7 looked awful.
Rob Halligan
44 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:50:40
I agree Charles. There are only 7 defenders in the squad. The 3 that started tonight plus Milner. So not one of the regular back four anywhere near the game tonight.

I can see something similar on Saturday. As you say, if any of Baines, Jagielka, Cahill or Glen Johnson get injured, we will really be up against it. Think Hodgson needs to keep Stones and ditch Wilshere.

Patrick Murphy
45 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:57:16
Colin - That would be interesting if the players were linked directly to the commentators. Imagine some of the hand signals towards the commentary position from those who were getting unfair criticism.
James Stewart
46 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:57:07
Townsend = Idiot

England poor as usual. Neutral when it comes to internationals, so I don't care. Pundits bizarre in defence of Sterling. Red all day long, lucky not to break Valencia's leg.

Red Roy, tactical genius putting Stones at LB then realises it was wrong side. England won't get out of the group stage.

Dick Brady
47 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:57:54
I don't know why Roy didn't play Jagielka. It's pretty clear by now Cahill and Jagielka are the first choice centre backs; after his injury lay-off, what Jagielka needs now is games.

Jagielka should play every minute of the friendlies in an attempt to get some match sharpness.

Going into the World Cup having only played three games in the last four months will be tough on Jagielka. He needs to shake off the rust and he can only do that by playing. Did we really need another look at Chris Smalling, Roy?

James Stewart
48 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:02:38
Smalling is truly woeful. How on earth is he a Man Utd and England player?!
Colin Glassar
49 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:00:20
Patrick, I hope Ross watches the game and then goes out and flattens Townsend. What's he got against the lad? Wilshere was rubbish, so was Fat Frank and Shaw but he didn't say anything negative about them.
Charles Brewer
50 Posted 04/06/2014 at 21:54:06
Colin, there was one player on that pitch who was a candidate for the Cruyff / Pele level, and it was Ross. The back heel, the destruction of the Ecuador defence for the second goal. That was real football class.

Rooney may have been that good, but he went for the money and corruption of Man Utd and never achieved what he was capable of.

Lambert looked like the typical RS purchase – low on talent, looked confused about what was going on.

Oops, I think I have turned into Ian Wright. He's just said the same thing (apart from the Lambert bit).

John Hughes
51 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:01:08
Note that Lee Dixon gave Ross huge credit for Lambert's goal and Hoddle spoke very highly of his performance. Ian Wright now saying what a positive RB was. So bollocks to Townsend – just showed himself up as the twat he is.
Patrick Murphy
52 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:04:14
Colin - Townsend is either annoyed that the lad is going to stay with Everton or he is trying to lower his fee if another club is interested in him. We really should know not to listen to these guys but it is so obvious that they have an agenda when giving their opinion; Some of them could be seen as players' agents and, of course, if they believe that particular clubs provide them with more viewers, they will pander to that demographic.

The only real thing lacking from Ross's game is tackling and I don't suppose he will ever develop that aspect of the game – he could also be a bit more demanding of those around him as, when Oxlade-Chamberlain went off, he saw a great deal less of the ball. An impact substitute when tired limbs and minds are in play will see him at his best I think.

Charles Brewer
53 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:05:51
Colin, spot on. Shaw had a stinker, Lampard got one shot on goal (again superb identification of a man in the right spot by Ross), Milner (whom I like, but was in the wrong place) nearly gave away 3 or 4 goals. Wilshere was OK but Jones and Smalling? Why would you waste the airfare?
Chris Wilson
54 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:12:14
Just to echo what John Hughes was saying – I'm watching the ITV feed, and Ian Wright, Glen Hoddle, and Lee Dixon have nothing but praise for Ross, stating that he looks so comfortable, it looks like he's playing for his club (meaning us). Dixon feels Ross has put himself in the conversation to start.

I don't know what Townsend has been saying, but it makes me wonder if he's one of those guys who hates a player because that player is compared to someone whom in his eyes is legendary and untouchable; ie, Ross is the next Gascoigne? It's not fair and isn't Ross's fault, but there are fans that think that way.

Here in the US, Lebron James was being hailed as the next Michael Jordan. Well, this pissed off a lot of Michael Jordan fans who felt it was sacrilegious to compare the two; and there were/are media pundits who have gone out of their way to discredit everything Lebron James has done. (Skip Bayless, I'm looking at you.)

And I'm giving Townsend the benefit of the doubt, but maybe he dislikes Ross because he's been hailed as the next Gascoigne or the next Ballack (interesting, because Ross has said his game has been influenced a great deal by Zidane)? Or, maybe Andy is just a penis. Can I say 'penis' on the air?

Colin Glassar
55 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:09:23
John Hughes, you're right, the three touchline pundits gave Ross the thumbs-up, unlike Townsend who was on his case all night.

Ross needs to believe he's there on merit and not to supply the ball to Rooney and Co. Another thing I've noticed is that Wilshere never passes the ball to an Everton player. Against Peru, he completely ignored Bainsey's run (as he always does) and tonight he either gave Ross poor balls or just ignored him.

Craig Mills
56 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:13:16
I've watched both warm-up games now and have to say how poor Rooney looks, he just doesn't look up for it playing for England. He played off Sturridge at the weekend, hardly got a touch; left wing tonight, utter rubbish, and celebrated his tap in from 10 cm as though he hit a 30-yard screamer.

Where do we play him next – right back???

Paul Hewitt
57 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:18:20
Barkley is everything Townsend wasn't. That is the problem: jealousy.
Mike Allison
58 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:17:47
Townsend is simply a terrible football pundit, he always has been. He's an unintelligent man who somehow has been cast in the role of 'analyst' and is expected to make insightful comments that increase our understanding of the game.

About 10% of the time he says something correct by chance, the rest of the time it is utter drivel. This is why people hate watching football on ITV. ITV is basically a TV channel for idiots, and this is clearly reflected in their TV coverage.

Patrick Murphy
59 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:15:53
Chris I think you nailed it in your final sentence, If Ross belonged to the usual suspects, the media hype would be overkill, which would be detrimental to Ross as a player of his age... but, because he belongs to one of the 'lesser' clubs, they sometimes feel the need to point out their errors. Townsend has a pretty long history of this type of behaviour with Everton players – Jags and Baines have both been criticised by him up until the final squad was announced.
Ernie Baywood
60 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:20:25
Well BBC gave Ross Man of the Match.
Charles Brewer
61 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:21:37
The Telegraph has Barklay as the highest rated England player with an 8, and amusingly gives the RS disgrace Sterling a 3. Haha, haha, haha.

Given that the new RS centre-carthorse's main contribution was a blatant handball which the ref "missed", I'd have thought the best thing Roy Hodgson could do is dump the RS contingent.

Kevin Tully
62 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:18:17
As per, Ross will only be brought on in the last 20 minutes to save any game we are behind in when the tournament proper starts... Hodgson, and dinosaur managers like him (mentioning no names), haven't got the balls to put him in from the start in case they are vilified by the press if they go out in the group stages. The poor lad will be trying to save all their skins at this point, and will have a stinker because he is trying too hard.

Ross is the player Rooney used to be, which means our board are safe in the knowledge their tenure is confirmed for another 10 years if they want to stay on.

£50m worth of investment is not required, the cheque is running around on the pitch and it's cost them nothing. Philip Green will 'advise' Bill when to sell.

Colin Glassar
63 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:22:47
Mike Allison, you're right. Between Adrian Chiles and Andy Townsend, watching footy on ITV is painful.

I think Townsend's problem is, he was such a below-average player that he had to lie about having an Irish Nan to get into the Irish team. He obviously hates talented players who don't play for one of his favourite teams.

Paul Mackie
64 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:34:29
I can't stand watching footy on ITV. For the Sterling 'tackle', both commentators were saying how it was a fair challenge and how he won the ball. Was I watching a completely different match or something? I'm not surprised Valencia reacted the way he did!
Sue Brown
65 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:37:38
I tend to get so angry listening to some of the drivel piss-poor ex-players come out with, Townsend can go and do one! I thought Ross certainly earned his place tonight.

But, on another note, BTSports 1 did a ½-hour interview with Roberto earlier, it was good. They did 4 managers: Roberto was 2nd on. It's repeated midnight BTSports 2 if anyone is interested.

Iain Love
66 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:48:23
Sterling's was a yellow at most. Oxlade-Chamblain was England's best player and should make the first team. Ross did well and I would have him in instead of Rooney . Right back is England's big problem, Milner was awful and I'd keep Stones and play him there for our last warm-up game.
Phil Sammon
67 Posted 04/06/2014 at 22:55:31
Milner was awful at right back... but why was he playing there?! He never has before for club or country and here we are, 10 days before the World Cup, and we're trying a 28-year-old in a position he's never played.

I didn't listen to any commentary but here's my view on the game:

1. Oxlade-Chamberlain was MotM. Runs with purpose and has an end product.

2. Barkley. Good performance but he does frustrate at times. We all know he has the talent, he just needs to learn when to pass/shoot/take a man on. I'm being harsh though. 20 years old in an England shirt. Well done, Ross.

3. Smalling and Jones are not good enough. Both have superb potential but you need to be first choice for your club to warrant a place in the England team.

4. Lampard is not, and never has been, a holding midfielder. Get rid.

Brian Wilkinson
68 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:07:43
I really do not know what problem Townsend has with Everton players.

Even after laying the pass to Lambert, he had to have a dig at the ball being a bit short. Has big Dunc been playing away with his Mrs or something? I'm struggling to find why he has such negative views on any Everton player.

Trevor Lynes
69 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:07:45
I cannot listen to Townsend or Motson so I turn the sound down and watch the players when they do NOT have the ball. Barkley is still learning and does not close down. This tiny fault needs correcting. The lad should take players on more as Chamberlain does, this lifts the team and excites the crowd.

Lampard and Wilshere are both poor without the ball and both are very slow. Wilshere has not improved since he was a kid and should have made a better effort at blocking the shot that gave Ecuador the equalizer.

I was not impressed by England and the best players were from Ecuador. Their left winger ran rings around our right sided defence. Barkley was OK but his best asset is in running at players.

He needs to take the initiative and the crowd will love him ! He is as strong as Rooney and just needs to rise to the occasion.

Sam Hoare
70 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:09:33
I thought Ross looked like he did when playing for us; infuriating for ten moments and then magical for one.

Trouble is that I don't believe Hodgson is brave enough to drop Rooney from that 'hole' position behind Sturridge – no matter how well Ross or indeed Oxlade-Chamberlain had played tonight.

Ste Traverse
71 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:13:01
Poor tackle by Sterling but a harsh red card. I think those on here saying it was would be saying something rather different if an Everton player was sent off for that.

And as for Townsend, he always seems so negative towards many players in the England side who don't play for 'Big 4' clubs.

Martin Farrington
72 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:21:51
Ross can be a liability – losing the ball too easily. Not making the right pass. The positives are there to be seen. But he will get better and in a year or two won't lose the ball, and will make that killer pass. He is with the right manager at Everton to fully develop. He is the best prospect England have.

John Stones is potentially the greatest centre half we have ever had. (Although I have compared him to Mick Lyons on occasions – but I forget how young he is.) Now with two caps! Good lad.

Now we need the longest pockets in the Premier League to get some balls and back these lads!!!

Paul Andrews
73 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:30:26
Ross needs to fuck Wilshere right off.

My opinion is Wilshere is not happy that Ross has took his mantle as the next big thing. He pushed Ross off the ball on Saturday when on the counter attack and ended up going square. Ross hit an under-paced ball in the first 10 minutes; the body language from Wilshere stunk.

Phil Sammon
74 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:41:36
Not siding with Wilshere, Paul, but that was a dead easy pass for Ross and he did fuck it up.
James Martin
75 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:34:55
It's annoying watching England games just because of the punditry. Shaw – one of the worst defensive performances I've seen from an England left back, he was all over the shop, was he mentioned at all – no.

Jones and Smalling, the pundits kept saying the defense looked nervous but refused to single out two woeful performances, they even finished up giving Jones praise. Rooney virtually anonymous apparently had a good game but then Barkley, who laid one goal on a plate and should have done the same with another one, got nothing but 'He should be hanging onto that' even if the Ecuador player wiped him out with a foul.

It was just like when Baines was breaking into the squad. Gerrard and Lampard would just be blasting balls all over the show out of play. Baines would misplace one intricate one-two and it was all 'You can see why he's not ready for this level yet' etc. The same as when David Villa ran past half the England team including Gerrard and Terry yet all the commentators blamed Jagielka for giving it away 5 minutes earlier despite the fact that in that 45 he was England's best player and had Torres and Villa in his pocket.

The media are still calling for Terry back now, that same international standard defender who was undone by a couple of long balls against Germany at the last World Cup, everyone's forgotten that though and just blamed Barry instead. Gerrard, Lampard, Cole and Rooney were also apparently in no way responsible for that game either.

The England team deserve exactly what they get because they cannot shake off their devotion to their beloved media darlings. They wouldn't know a good player if it hit them in the face. The fact that Barkley and Wilshere are being kept out of the side by Henderson, Lallana and Milner tells you all you need to know.

We'll struggle to get out of the group because yet again we've picked a squad on temporary form and media adulation rather than sustained performance at the top level. We've also got no idea how to put them together as a team and still have a culture running through the squad of the established players taking no responsibility for anything whilst the outsiders in the squad take the blame.

Jimmy Page
76 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:27:08
Phil 67, Smalling and Jones superb potential..... you are not serious are you?

Both of them shouldn't be in the squad, ask any Man Utd supporter, they are not good enough, for club or country.

As far as Sterling's tackle goes, any RS tackle is a foul.

Clive Lewis
77 Posted 05/06/2014 at 00:02:23
You are forgetting that Woy was a Wed. Obviously he will play Henderson, Sterling and Sturridge and the other red old blokes against Italy.
Raymond Fox
78 Posted 04/06/2014 at 23:41:06
England faded in the last third of the game, but I thought they passed the ball around well early doors.

Saying that, it was nothing like the first team out there, and at least we didn't give the ball away every 10 seconds, like usual. I agree about no legs Wilshere being rubbish, closely followed by Lampard.

Ross will no doubt learn when to pass the ball sometimes, instead of always trying to do the spectacular. He's going to be a truly great player in a couple of years though, he aint too bad now mind, because he has tons of natural ability.

God knows what price Man City and Chelsea will be prepared to pay... because, as sure as night follows day, they will be in for Ross; what the outcome will be is anybody's guess.

For a change, I'm quite optimistic that we will have a decent World Cup this time.

Pete Gunby
79 Posted 05/06/2014 at 00:21:02
Hope to be proved wrong but Roy will go conservative as nearly always happens with England. The youth will be back on the bench and we'll be playing in fear as per usual. Already, Hodgson is critizising Barkley's decision-making whilst trying to tell us that "Wayne Rooney was very very good, as was Phil Jones" – Watching a different game I think.

In the game I saw, Smalling and Jones are in to meet the required Man Utd allocation, Lampard is no longer able, Milner is not a right back, Shaw is not quite ready and Wilshere has stagnated. Otherwise, we look the the finished article.

Chris Wilson
80 Posted 05/06/2014 at 00:57:45
Wilshere's game isn't as good in international competitions because, when he whines to the referees; they don't care. I think thanks to Arsene's crying, and the general benefit of the doubt that Arsenal players get, Jack has become a tad dependent upon favorable referee decisions. Plus, it wouldn't surprise me if he doesn't like Ross. Ross has him for breakfast almost every time they play.
Patrick Murphy
81 Posted 05/06/2014 at 01:08:55
Hodgson speaking after the game as reported in the Evening Standard:

Asked whether Barkley would be among the starters against Italy, Hodgson added: "There always seems to be an enormous obsession with one player...

"I will be prepared to start any of the players in any game, but I'm not prepared to address your obsession with Ross Barkley."

"If he's going to be the player we want him to be, he has to make better decisions when he turns with the ball.

"That's not a criticism, but there were other performances out there today. Oxlade-Chamberlain and Phil Jones were outstanding, as was Jack Wilshere in the middle of the park, while Rickie Lambert scored a magnificent goal."

Now Uncle Roy may have a point but what will that do to Barkley's confidence will he react by playing more conservative in his next outing or will he continue to make the same errors but provide much needed opportunities for his team-mates?

I'm sorry but if that wasn't a criticism, Roy, you could have fooled me. As has been stated, he will go for experience over flamboyance — the same as every England Boss save perhaps Terry Venables — and Eng-er-Land will return after three dull draws... unbeaten but out of the tournament.

Si Cooper
82 Posted 05/06/2014 at 02:17:00
All players have to be able to take on-board constructive criticism if they are to develop, and I think Ross Barkley is thick-skinned enough to understand that he still needs to improve some aspects of his game. Hodgson comes across as a bit too sensitive in these remarks but I do not disagree with his assessment of where Ross is currently in terms of indispensability. More worried that he thinks Wilshere and Jones were outstanding.

Oxlade-Chamberlain was the outstanding performer in that game, and I think if he does not start (if he is fit) then worries about ultra-conservatism will be well founded. I wouldn't be concerned to the same degree if Ross isn't starting against Italy, but I think he has shown enough in his performances to be used unhesitatingly from the bench if the starting eleven is not making any headway.

Phil Smith
83 Posted 05/06/2014 at 03:07:12
Don't know what all the fuss was about for that tackle – it wasn't that bad. Valencia totally over-reacted and they both should have got yellow – this was a friendly after all! In a competitive game, however, the Manc lad would have got his marching orders good and proper. Disgraceful behaviour! Think the ref should get an acting award though. Talk about over-the-top! Pure panto, that!!
Ian Bennett
84 Posted 05/06/2014 at 07:44:08
Pete 79 - totally agree. Ecuador ran past Lampard and that weak Wilshere at will, god help them against a Brazil or Spain. Ecuador are hardly world heavyweights, but made England look like they are – average.

Jones and Smalling were all over the place. Milner is never a right back, whilst Rooney looks bereft of fitness and pace. World class, not a patch, looks like the Pillsbury doughboy.

Lambert did alright, whilst Oxlade-Chamberlain and Barkley shone although will be dumped on the bench by an old-skool manager so out of touch.

Yes, Barkley gave it away, and made some poor decisions. But he did make things happen. How often can someone say that of a player in white? This is more than Wilshere produced, who did a great impression of Victor and Ossie at their worst, sitting on the turf or watching their man run past him. Oh, he was quite good apparently, the mind boggles...

Micky Norman
85 Posted 05/06/2014 at 08:16:24
Hodgson must be gutted that on Saturday Stonesy leaves the squad whilst England take at least 3 inferior defenders to the tournament.
Steve Pugh
86 Posted 05/06/2014 at 08:08:53
The Ox (as Ian Wright calls him) was superb with Ross not far behind.

People need to stop worrying about that defence because they will not play in the tournament, it was just a chance for the reserves to get a game; expect the proper defence to be out next time.

I also expect to see Gerrard and Lallana in for Lampard and Wilshere (who goes to ground far too easily) but would love to see the Rooney, Ox, Barkley trio starting again with Sturridge or Welbeck in for Lambert.

With that team, we may not win the World cup but it would be more fun to watch.

James Martin
87 Posted 05/06/2014 at 08:33:20
Shaw looked awful, nowhere near Baines's level yet. I would have taken Cole or Gibbs. I guess being young English and fast makes up for not having a clue where to be on the pitch.
Tony Smith
88 Posted 05/06/2014 at 08:30:22
I must have watched a different game... where exactly did Ross continually give the ball away and make the wrong decision? Always looking for the ball, completing passes, nice touches, backheel, set up the goal, ran the whole length of the pitch beating 3 opponents. He looked totally comfortable at this level all night compared to Wilshere who looked totally out of his depth, losing the ball continually, getting knocked off the ball with ease and yet received little criticism from the "expert pundits".

Speaking of pundits, I have always picked up on Townsend's anti-Everton player sentiments with Baines and Jagielka but last night had me swearing at the telly, so obvious were his negative comments against Barkley. He made a great run in the first half running the length of the pitch, beating 3 men before slipping in Lambert, no mention of this run from Townsend other than he underhit the pass?

I was quite prepared to support Roy Hodgson during this World Cup but I am totally bemused by his post-match comments re Barkley; god help us if that his true opinion rather than a case of protecting him against hype.

At least the touchline pundits gave credit where it is due and the papers also give Ross a good rating, but I suspect that we will see the usual media darlings picked rather than exciting raw talent.

Charles Brewer
89 Posted 05/06/2014 at 08:32:26
Good point, Micky. It's hard to see why Jones, Smalling, Shaw and Milner (as a defender) would be ahead of Stones. But at least Rio the Retard won't be there to cause trouble.

I wonder if the RS contingent can manage a red card every match. With proper refereeing it's a decent bet.

The real tragedy is that one of the world's best right backs will not be playing at all, while rubbish like Johnson will.

Andrew Ellams
90 Posted 05/06/2014 at 08:40:08
Oxlade-Chamberlain and Barkley have left Wilshere so far behind, he is a dot on the landscape. He has gone from next big thing to squad player in a heartbeat.
Sam Hoare
91 Posted 05/06/2014 at 08:55:45
Central midfield is where England will struggle. Gerrard will take one slot and probably deserves to after a good season though he has lost a great deal of dynamism in the last year or two.

Who beside him? Henderson? Wilshere? Fat Frank? Uninspiring options. I think Barry might have been a better option to be honest. Or drop the Ox back?

I suspect Henderson will get the nod for his 'energy'. Yikes...

Andy Meighan
92 Posted 05/06/2014 at 09:14:24
Imagine the antics out of that wanker 'Irish' Andy Townsend (yeah sure) if Barkley had made that tackle on Valencia that little Richard done. He'd have been screaming for him to be banned for the World Cup. What a pathetic petty gobshite the man is.

As for old snood-neck Woy... Reading between the lines in his post-match comments, there's not a chance Barkley's starting – in fact, now that Oxlade-Chamberlain is injured, expect the midfield against Italy to be slippy feet Lampard, Cleverley and Carlton Palmer as a late replacement for the Ox... I hope they get walloped.

Andrew Ellams
93 Posted 05/06/2014 at 09:02:56
The pundits are quick to tell us that Barkley offers something different, the back heel to Rooney in the first half would have had Townsend in bits if Gerrard had done that. But the thing about trying something different is that it doesn't always come off. If you want nice, safe, short passes to feet then play Henderson and Wilshere but you won't score many goals.
James Marshall
94 Posted 05/06/2014 at 09:38:01
I agree that Ross does give the ball away a fair bit, but that's the one thing that he does which is a negative – that said, it's also to be expected given the nature of his game. He often receives the ball deep in our half with his back to the opposition, and players right behind him and sometimes when he turns he loses it.

This is one reason why playing him as the number 10 is the right position for him, because he's more likely to be further up the pitch and not lose it in such dangerous areas. Having said that, I wouldn't start him against Italy because they're too good in possession in midfield with Pirlo & De Rossi in there and we could get punished – that would not be good for his or the teams confidence and you need a result in your first game, even if it's a point.

Ross should start from the bench in the first game, and start the other two group games I reckon. The fact he gives the ball away (and he does) will be (and probably should be) deemed too big a risk in the first game of a World Cup against a pedigree side like Italy.

Aside from all that, the kid is a Rolls Royce and can be the driving force in this team if he wants to be. His power and skill bursting through midfield are unmatched by any other England player (although Oxlade-Chamberlain played well too, now possibly out of the tournament) and without him England lack that dynamic midfielder when Gerrard plays alongside Henderson.

The Italy game will be played at a pretty slow pace and in such extreme heat, so bringing Ross on later in the game, say on the hour, could be a master-stroke. The same can be said of Sterling who could rip teams to shreds when they're tired in the heat.

I know a lot of people hate and complain about International football, but personally I love the World Cup and can't wait to see Ross on the world stage.

James Newcombe
95 Posted 05/06/2014 at 10:17:04
ITV is generally awful, but somehow they always stuff football coverage up. Andy Townsend and Clive Tyldesley are terrible commentators, who manage to double my blood pressure with every "Cor, tell you wot Clive..." and, for example, the endless fawning over Arsenal in the FA Cup Final.
Danny Kewley
96 Posted 05/06/2014 at 08:44:00
Ecuador scored two crackers and we got one plus a scramble from the feller with the syrup. Not a bad return from our boy Woy against such dominance!

Forgetting the Charlatan Townsend's views, I thought young Ross was by far the best player on the pitch and was followed by Oxlade-Chamberlain.

The worst thing that came out of the match for me though was that the World Cup I am really looking forward to is going to have half the coverage by IT-Fucking-V!

COYToffeeeeeees.........

Steavey Buckley
97 Posted 05/06/2014 at 10:22:36
"The post-match statistics showed that Barkley, who played 84 minutes of England's penultimate pre-World Cup friendly, embarked on seven dribbles forward and had a 91 per cent pass completion rate." — EFC.
Paul Andrews
98 Posted 05/06/2014 at 10:26:25
James Marshall,

It depends what you are looking for. A player like Ross who looks for the positive option every time will inevitably give the ball away.

Or someone like Henderson, who rarely gives the ball away because he passes to full backs or plays square balls. Joe Allen is the same, the stats tell you he completes a high percentage of passes, both of them never take a risk.

James Marshall
99 Posted 05/06/2014 at 10:47:11
Paul (#98),

Absolutely agree. I just think that the issue of needing a solid start against Italy should be taken into account. If we lose that game, we put ourselves under immense pressure.

Malcolm Joyner
100 Posted 05/06/2014 at 10:47:06
I love to see the kid doing well and bridled at Hodgson's picking him out for admonishment. Totally unfair when more senior payers were crap but that's the manager's misguided prerogative, I guess.

In reality, I do see 'our kid' as slightly behind the unlucky Oxlade-Chamberlain in the pecking order but way ahead of the likes of Cleverley, Redmond and Huddlestone who are being suggested as the injured boy's replacement.

That's always provided Ross is played in a forward midfield role as last night.

Paul Andrews
103 Posted 05/06/2014 at 10:58:39
James,

I see where you are coming from there re Italy game. Hodgson will play to keep it tight and look for a set-piece goal. Barkley on the bench probably.

Nightmare scenario is he asks Henderson to get tight to Pirlo. Now that would be a schooling for Henderson if it happens...

Malcolm Joyner
104 Posted 05/06/2014 at 10:56:48
I meant to say that, on last night's showing, Stones is already way ahead of Milner, Jones, Shaw and the awful Smalling as a defender and the squad will be the poorer when he's sent home this weekend.

But then I'm biased, of course and not impartial like those knowledgeable ITV commentators!

Paul Thompson
105 Posted 05/06/2014 at 10:51:39
I think we should cut Woy some slack. He obviously gets fed up with being bombarded by questions from the press pack that focus just on one player. It's normally Rooney and after this match it was Barkley. He did let it get the better of him a bit, but I can understand the frustration.

Woy knows Barkley's value – that's why he started him. That performance will have propelled him higher up the ranks, but probably first off the bench rather than starting. In my view, that's fair enough at the moment.

Some of the above comments are missing the point a little. Yes, Smalling, Jones, Milner and Lampard etc were poor, but they won't start. We'll probably not get out of the group, but we do have some players, Barkley included, who can change the game. It will be a real shame if Oxlade-Chamberlain is injured because he was superb last night.

Sam Hoare
107 Posted 05/06/2014 at 11:26:24
I don't see why we can't out of the group. Italy drew with Luxembourg last night and also did with Ireland; hardly on fire. Uruguay will have very little if Suarez is not fit and are ageing in defence; Cavani has been underwhelming this season though is admittedly a threat. Costa Rica are surely large underdogs –especially without Oviedo!

Maybe its World Cup fever but I really believe that, if we can get Barkley and Co running at old man Pirlo and the likes, then we can beat Italy and win the group. Most likely it will be tight either way and hang on a moment of genius or disaster.

Derek Thomas
109 Posted 05/06/2014 at 11:23:10
If Woy gets rid of Stones and keeps Smalling, well I just 'kin well give up... He hasn't got a decent right back and I don't even know who Johnson's 'deputy' is, if indeed there is another RB in the squad. It will never happen this late in the day (at least I don't think so).

There are three problems: Stones is ace, Smalling isn't and Johnson is behind Hibbo in the RB stakes. Solve all three 'problems' with three at the back: GK; Stones, Jagielka, Cahill: Stevie me: Baines, LWB, Barkley – where he plays for us... the rest, take your pick.

I used to worry about England but most of these tossers are not the stuff of Kenneth Wolstenholme's 'Some people are on the pitch' etc So long as the Everton Lads a) do well; b) don't get injured; c) don't get tapped up – that's me sorted and I'll just surf the games as the time difference allows.

Andrew Clare
110 Posted 05/06/2014 at 11:44:48
Firstly, ITV is a dreadful TV Channel. It always has been for any type of viewing and it always has had awful football coverage. Andy Townsend etc just haven't got a clue and get on my wick.

Secondly, I will be most surprised if England get out of the Group.

Thirdly, Barkley is undoubtedly a rare talent but, knowing the cautious safety first approach of England, he will probably only feature as a substitute.

Kieran Riding
111 Posted 05/06/2014 at 12:16:00
I agree with all of your points above, Andrew. If Roy has the bollocks to just go for it, he may well surprise a few. Doubt it like...
Peter Foy
112 Posted 05/06/2014 at 12:07:02
Surely the 91% pass completion from Ross totally contradicts the 'gives the ball away' theory. I mean, he gains possession, and 91% of the time, passes to an England player, leaving 9% of the time for misplaced passes.

So what were the stats for the rest of the team? I don't know because I can't be arsed checking but I'm pretty sure nobody lost possession less times than Ross.

This pisses me off no end. People commenting on players that don't have a fucking clue. This is now the media default statement. Ross loses the ball and needs to make better decisions. Bollocks.

Daniel A Johnson
113 Posted 05/06/2014 at 12:25:51
It's detestable that the best, most adaptable English defender (John Stones) is not even in the first-team squad. Especially when, outside of Baines, Jags and Cahill, the options are absolute gash.

As for the criticisms of Barkley, Red Woy is way out of his depth: he's snappy, nervy and on edge especially in interviews.

At the World Cup we can expect the opposition to have a lot of the ball so ball retention and to not give it away is crucial. BUT the flipside is also true: when you do get your opportunities, you need players who can produce that single moment of match-winning brilliance.

I put it this way: 85 mins to go against Spain, a ball lands to a player in space just outside the box, do you want that player to be Barkley, or a pick of Fat Frank, Geriatric Gerrard, Henderson, Wilshere, or Milner?

I think it's a travesty that Stones is not even going and Barkley will be a 15-10 min sub at best.

It will be the usual England tournament: slow, well organised workmanlike England undone by teams with youthful energy and young brilliance.

Sam Hoare
114 Posted 05/06/2014 at 12:34:35
I see the RS have agreed £10m for a new midfielder Emre Can, useful player too from what I've seen. It's galling that for the bigger clubs a £10m signing isn't even a big deal! Hopefully he goes the way of Aspas and Alberto.
Tom Bowers
115 Posted 05/06/2014 at 12:48:12
Ross is not perfect and never will be... neither is Messi! He is still learning and is ready for England but it seems Hodgson has his starting eleven already in mind. That's fine but you know Ross will get playing time and will prove he is starting quality.

It wasn't a bad performance by England yesterday but one that was expected given the unusual line-up. Ecuador are no slouches and should have been despatched early but poor performances by Lampard and Wilshere didn't help, particularly in the first half.

Wilshere looks out of sorts still and was easily pushed off the ball too many times whereas Lampard, apart from one good shot, looks past it. I hope he doesn't start against Italy.

Stones should have started at right back but Hodgson does some quirky things doesn't he?

Richard Lyons
116 Posted 05/06/2014 at 12:55:53
I got the feeling, both yesterday and in the Peru game, that Jack Wilshere was employing an "I'm not going to pass to Barkley" strategy... Did anyone else notice that?

And blimey, if Hodgson thought Barkley lost possession too much, and Wilshere was "outstanding... in the middle of the park", I think I must have been watching a different game.

Kevin Jones
117 Posted 05/06/2014 at 12:29:20
With Ross being a good forward skilful midfielder he'll be lucky to get 50 caps. His defensive work isn't quite good enough for the stuck-in-the-mud England managers. He doesn't work hard enough for the team, you'll hear them say, fuck the fact he'll light up a game with some sublime skill.

Yes, he'll make mistakes but so did Maradona, Baggio, Pele, Platini, Zidane, Eder, Gerd Muller, and all the rest of the great players. Do you think any of the Countries these players played for would have dreamt of leaving them out, no because they knew they could change a game in the blink of an eye. They put players around them to do the leg work to let the Stars Shine.

Just been on the England website to look at appearances:

Gazza, probably the best England player of his Generation – 57 Caps
Hoddle, sublime footballer who seemed to glide across a pitch – 53 Caps
Paul Merson, great player bit of a piss head –21 Caps
Gerry Francis, good player worst haircut in football and still hanging onto it – 12 Caps
Matt Le Tissier, football genius – 8 caps

Phil Neville, yes Phil Neville the same Phil Neville who played for Man Utd and Everton, the same Phil Neville who has a brother called Gary who was a very good player, the same Phil Neville who's Dad's named Neville Neville, slipped up filling a passport form in and didn't have a spare one. How many??? – 59 Caps!!! Yes, more than Gazza, Hoddle, in fact more than Li Tiss, Merson and Gerry Francis put together.

And that's why Henderson will win more caps than young Ross...

Bill Griffiths
118 Posted 05/06/2014 at 13:17:28
Kevin, you could include Tony Currie in that list, he only got 17 caps.
Patrick Murphy
119 Posted 05/06/2014 at 13:19:26
And John Stones can claim to have twice as many England caps – already – than Howard Kendall and Colin Harvey have between them.
Iain Johnston
120 Posted 05/06/2014 at 12:54:33
Tyldesley was never that positive about us when he worked for Radio City in the days of second-half commentaries, Gary Bloom was far more pro EFC... Townsend is still pissed off that we never signed him and he went Villa.

I'd definitely keep Stones and send Smalling packing, confident in two defensive positions and comfortable on the ball... He's going to have a huge career. I'd keep Jones for the same reason, remember when he had Fellaini in his pocket? He'd make decent DM cover...

On Saturday the Miami temperatures for the early evening will be very similar to Manaus, start Lampard again and if he struggles, put him on the bloody plane too. I'd have Milner in there...

Kieran Riding
121 Posted 05/06/2014 at 13:39:17
Lampard was actually awful last night, lost possession loads.

No way would the media have the bottle to give him stick in his final start though.

Andrew Ellams
122 Posted 05/06/2014 at 13:40:13
Kevin, you could also add Rod Marsh, Frank Worthington and Peter Beardsley to that list. All massively undervalued by England because they were genuises with the ball at their feet but not too keen to graft (although you could maybe leave Beardsley out of that last bit).
Mike Childs
123 Posted 05/06/2014 at 13:40:15
Well one positive is, the less Ross plays, the better for us... but it certainly will be at the expense of England's chances.

Kev (62) I sure hope hell freezes over so your assessment of the boards ideas are wrong. Only one more week to wait, can't wait after all it was World Cup 10 that attracted me to the game. I started watching the EPL occasionally that fall usually back in the States it was Man Utd or Man City. Finally January and I got to see Everton in back-to-back weeks against Arsenal and Man City and the love affair was born.

Drew O'Neall
124 Posted 05/06/2014 at 14:01:32
I suspect Woy might be trying to either keep a lid on the hype around Ross Barkley, as has been requested by Bobby M, and/or keeping him off the Italian's/other radar.

I've never liked Towsend's commentary "on the half turn" (twat!) but Woy may have had a word in his shell-like, too.

Be interesting to see if the media has been manipulated in other ways in the run up to the World Cup.

Exciting times for Ross and the other Blue Lions.

Steavey Buckley
125 Posted 05/06/2014 at 14:09:41
If England do lose the excellent Oxlade-Chamberlain, then there is only Sterling who can really play wide. And without wide players against the likes of Italy, it is very hard to break down compact defenses; without getting behind them and providing crosses to score from.

What is so disappointing, the aging Lampard (very poor against Ecuador) is in the England squad but the excellent Aaron Lennon (wide player from Spurs) is probably on some beach sunning himself right now.

Carl Peters
126 Posted 05/06/2014 at 14:28:50
Can someone please start a petition to get Andy Townsend kicked off the ITV panel, as I for one do not want to listen to this gobshite for 4 weeks.
Chris Leyland
127 Posted 05/06/2014 at 14:25:39
Just been for a coffee and read the free copy of the Daily Mail (forgive me). That reknowned 'expert' Martin Samuelson gave Man of the Match to Wayne Rooney. He also rated Lampard, Shaw and Wilshere highly. What a tit.
James Marshall
128 Posted 05/06/2014 at 15:00:37
Peter Foy #112

The stat you quoted may well be true, but giving the ball away also means being caught in possession. Nobody said Ross makes loose passes, but he does get caught in possession. It's a minor gripe and of course he'll improve as he matures, but it does happen purely because of his total attacking intent.

It's not a criticism, it's an observation and one that does matter when you're talking about him potentially being up against Pirlo and De Rossi.

I would start him in the other two group games though. We need a result against Italy. I also believe we'll get out of the group.

Anthony Jones
129 Posted 05/06/2014 at 15:21:05
Woy turns out to be no better than any of England's other recent managers then. He criticises the media for being negative and obsessed with this and that, and then he publicly criticises his star player, whilst reserving praise for uninspiring performances. The media will always favour the players of the Sky Elite, but if the manager follows suit we might as well not follow England.

Sterling should have been sent off. Barkley was great. Rooney was shite. Wilshere is a prick. That is all.

James Marshall
130 Posted 05/06/2014 at 15:55:15
Wilshere has been injured for long periods this season. Look at the bigger picture. Your Everton bias is painful.

Hodgson is playing things down, all England managers do it – and rightly so. What do you want him to do? Shout from the rooftops about how amazing Barkley is just before his first World Cup? Have a word.

Paul Andrews
131 Posted 05/06/2014 at 15:55:44
Richard Lyons 116,

That is what happened in both games; Wilshere upset at losing "the next big thing" title. Ross is a far better player, and a far better ball-carrier than Wilshere.

Steavey Buckley,

I don't think Hodgson will be looking to play Sterling or indeed any wide players against Italy. And he is right not to.

The quality Italy have in midfield, I would pack the England midfield centrally and look for the width from the full backs. I am almost certain that is the way he will play v Italy

Mike Powell
132 Posted 05/06/2014 at 16:25:52
I turned the sound down watching the England game couldn't take anymore of that idiot townsend. I thought Wilshere was poor... always on his arse. Milner, Jones and Smalling were also piss poor. The rest did okay, Oxlade-Chamberlain and Barkley were the best players on the pitch.
David Holroyd
133 Posted 05/06/2014 at 16:44:16
It's not what Barkley cannot do; it's what he can do that Roy should be thinking about. Barkley, Sterling, Oxlade-Chamberlain run at defenders with pace. Ditch the old guard... Come on, Roy, if you really want to go try and win it.
Raymond Fox
134 Posted 05/06/2014 at 16:11:44
As far as Townsend's concerned and all the so called 'experts' doing the commentary, turn the sound off. If you go to a match, you've not got some jerk giving their 'expert' views all match. Okay... sometimes!

Also, do we as Everton supporters want Ross and young John playing in this tournament? I can imagine what the response on here will be if they were to get seriously injured and out for the season!

Ross is going to be a world star on par with the very very best players, but at the moment although he can produce flashes of superb quality he does lose the ball in the tackle quite a lot and his work rate and tackling is below par.
Its a trade off between, he is likely to score a brilliant goal out of nothing and lacking in certain areas of the game.

I want England to do well and I think we have enough quality to surprise some of the 'better' teams but I don't think I will be devastated if they fail.

Malcolm Joyner
135 Posted 05/06/2014 at 17:39:36
Hodgson comes over all Moyesish at times and always seems to focus on the strengths of the opposition and the limitations of his own side.

Thank God we've now got a manager of the opposite inclination even if the more outlandish aspects of his positivity are a bit cringe-making at times!

Paul Hewitt
136 Posted 05/06/2014 at 18:54:30
How did Roy Hodgson get the England job? The guy's an idiot.

Talk about giving your players confidence. How must Ross Barkley feel listening to his manager talking so much crap about him?

Eugene Ruane
137 Posted 05/06/2014 at 21:59:32
James Marshall - a couple of thoughts

1) Re "Hodgson is playing things down, all England managers do it – and rightly so"

RIGHTLY so?

I'm guessing you're basing that on the incredible success of England managers over the years?

2) Re "What do you want him to do? Shout from the rooftops about how amazing Barkley is just before his first World Cup? Have a word"

Well in the past season, Martinez has praised Barkley long and loud and it doesn't seem to have put any undue pressure on him, quite the opposite it appears to me.

Just a crazy, mad thought – maybe he responds to it.

Chris Leyland
138 Posted 05/06/2014 at 22:13:51
I'm with Eugene on this one. A Novotel of positivity from Roy wouldn't go amiss. How about "Ross was excellent tonight and if I was the Italy manager I'd be shitting it."
David Ellis
139 Posted 06/06/2014 at 02:31:16
Kevin Jones 117. Great analysis.

Hoddle was kept out of the England side by the side ways passing Ray Wilkins of Chelsea (and later Man Utd) who liked to go by the nick name "Butch" Wilkins. Or as we use to call him at school the more appropriate "Wutch Bilkins". Fortunately he got himself sent off in the 1986 group matches which forced Bobby Robson to play Peter Reid in central midfield – resulting in Everton (sorry England) sweep the group and only go out to the "hand of God" goal in the quarters.

Genius in England is only recognised if drenched in sweat. Add Stan Bowles to the list of skillful players kept out of the England team by carthorses.

Eugene Ruane
140 Posted 06/06/2014 at 12:53:28
David Ellis (139) - "Genius in England is only recognised if drenched in sweat."

Very nicely summed up.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb