Moyes wants to manage in the Champions League

, 6 June, 80comments  |  Jump to most recent
The Guardian caught up with David Moyes in Miami and the Scot says that he has already turned down two offers to go back into management and could be looking outside England for his next role:
“I have had a couple of opportunities to go back in and chosen not to do anything just now,” Moyes, currently on holiday in Florida, said. “I am going to look for what I feel is the right opportunity. I would like to think I proved myself over the 11-year period at Everton and what I am capable of, and the level at which I want to manage.”

“I got my real first taste of the Champions League this year and I thought I showed I can manage at that level,” he added. “I would like somewhere that would give me a chance of being in the Champions League or a club that has ambitions of being in the Champions League.

“It could be at home or abroad. I have always liked the thought of broadening my horizons and learning a bit more and at the moment I am quite comfortable watching and learning. I will go away and learn and look again to see what is happening.”

» Read the full article at The Guardian



Reader Comments (80)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Eugene Ruane
1 Posted 06/06/2014 at 14:16:04
A lot of these manager types exist in a fantasy world.

I mean..

"I would like somewhere that would give me a chance of being in the Champions League or a club that has ambitions of being in the Champions League."

Paul Andrews
3 Posted 06/06/2014 at 14:39:53
A Champions League club?

A FUCKIN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE CLUB???

Deluded Mingebag springs to mind.

Andrew Ellams
4 Posted 06/06/2014 at 14:48:54
What Moyes didn’t say is the Champions League clubs in question are Linfield and Rhyl.
Kevin Tully
5 Posted 06/06/2014 at 14:48:46
You have just had the bullet after breaking all records for shitness, most of the players wanted him gone, and he STILL believes he is one the best out there.

He was blessed at Everton, blessed with no targets and blessed with a chairman who more interested in Coronation fucking Street than if we would ever win a trophy again.

Message to DM – you will not find another Everton you foolish, foolish man. Go back to your level, the Championship or League One, where you can make the players run up hills until they vomit. Mug.

Paul Andrews
6 Posted 06/06/2014 at 15:18:55
He’s missed his only chance of getting CL football in the future with the Celtic job being filled today.
Tony McNulty
7 Posted 06/06/2014 at 15:35:25
Sounds like he’s just missed a wonderful opportunity to say nothing.
Shane Corcoran
8 Posted 06/06/2014 at 15:35:51
Paul, your second post sort of contradicts your first doesn’t it?

He got a job with a non-Champions League team and got them into it once.

Peter Bell
9 Posted 06/06/2014 at 15:44:30
Shane, Paul says Champions League in the future.
Eugene Ruane
10 Posted 06/06/2014 at 15:30:14
’Broadening my horizons’

I’m impressed!

Goodbye dull brass-rubbing holidays in Peebles, from now on it’ll be the glamour of bloater fishing in Arbroath harbour.

Sorry but as that poor Hungarian peasant girl Magna Carta said to King John when he signed the pledge at Runnymede, forcing the boozers to close at half past ten "As fucking if!"

Can anyone (Entwistle aside) really see it?

"Moyes Wanderers 4 Barcelona 0"

After the game, the Barcelona manager, Señor Plumz said..

"We were... cckkkow you say... kkkout-thought. They were attackink us from all of the angles. I kkk-ave been a football manakkker for 40 yeerss, yet have never been out-of-the-foxed by anyone like I was today by theess man, Daveed Moyss"

As I say, fantasy.

Reality – The dull presbo was spoilt rotten at Everton and out there in the real world has been found out as a dull uninspiring man with no imagination – traits I believe are needed to compete at the highest level.

Danny Kewley
13 Posted 06/06/2014 at 16:15:06
Maybe we should take plenty of no notice of the Simpsonesque Moysee and leave him be in his side show paradise..........
Shane Corcoran
14 Posted 06/06/2014 at 16:25:13
Peter #8, what I meant was that he laughed at Moyes saying he wanted to manage a CL team but then followed it up by saying he had just missed out on his chance with Celtic.

My second point was just a general one not aimed at anyone.

Matt Traynor
17 Posted 06/06/2014 at 16:44:17
Moyes was hard done to by Man Utd, but his bank balance didn’t suffer and, whilst I have no fucks to give after the way he treated Everton, I think he’ll end up trying to rebuild his reputation on the continent a la Schteve McClaren after England did for him.

McLaren won cups and titles in the lesser leagues in Europe, and he’s now managing a Championship team.

FWIW I also think Moyes will fail on the continent. Even if he doesn’t, his Man Utd experience will always haunt him.

Jim Knightley
19 Posted 06/06/2014 at 16:48:18
Really, what do you think he is going to say? He just left one of the biggest clubs in the world, so of course he wants a club with Champions League football. He will not get one in England, but he will get one abroad. I hope he does go abroad because I expect he will be mentioned on here a lot less when he does.

He did well for us. He is gone. Some of us hate him. Some of us like him. Most of us are in between. We’ve got a younger more vibrant manager now, and we are the better for it. When our form drops, the spectre of Moyes will return, just as it will when Martinez is successful.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
22 Posted 06/06/2014 at 16:59:47
Usual posting caveat applies: if the subject is of no interest to you, then you personally don’t need to post.

The thread originated with someone putting this story up under another subject*; we have a thing about going off-topic, so took the story about this former Everton manager (obviously of interest to some of our readers, needless to say) and put it here. No biggie.

Again, if it’s not your cup of tea...

* If you do find some news of (potential) interest to (some of) our readers, please use the new link up above: Send us News.

Brent Stephens
24 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:08:12
Ah, I see, Michael! Didn’t realise it had been moved from another thread to declutter (been away for a while). As you say, no biggie!
Peter Foy
25 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:01:30
I wanted him to get the Celtic job.

Watching him fail in Scotland would have been delightful. Aberdeen winning the league in his first year would have been great for Scottish football. He could have claimed to have single-handedly saved the Scottish league, dragging it back into the 21st century. He would have been a legend.

Michael Kenrick
26 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:11:27
No problem, Brent.

By the way, the "Heading" under which it seems to be posted is meant to be a navigation bar we are trying to include toward the top of most pages. It's meant to show which part of the site the current page resides in... and provide you (by way of a mouse click or fat finger poke) a way back to something perhaps of more interest.

I agree, it looks like a heading, rather than a series of links; let's take this up with the Webmeister and see if he will agree to them being nice blue underlined links that everyone would recognise.

I know the Season 13-14 has effectively ended; we make the break at end of June / First of July, mainly for convenience / simplicity.

Paul Andrews
27 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:19:11
He will wait for Ancelotti, Mourinho et al to fail ......then swoop in like an eagle to lift the clubs back to their former glory!!!
Ray Roche
28 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:47:19
#27 Swoop like a Beagle.

With a Capstain Full Strength habit.

John Daley
29 Posted 06/06/2014 at 17:58:38
What? He wants to be given the 'chance' at a Champions League club? He was given the god damn keys to the kingdom, a free pass to dining at the top table, and fucked it up by freezing like 'Wee' Jimmy Krankie when he heard the sound of Rolf Harris's footsteps stop dead right outside 'his' dressing room door.

The most telling thing to come out of the Moyes's mouth of late was this:

"It was unfortunate I wasn't given more time to succeed. It could well be that gone are the days of long-term planning at United."

Unfortunate? How can he possibly talk like United prematurely pulled the trigger? What did he want? The chance to turn things round? His shortcomings sunk the fucking ship in the first place so how could he possibly expect all the survivors to simply hold their breath and wait patiently at the bottom of the sea while he attempts to coerce a couple of porpoises into pulling them back to the surface?

He talks like he was just an unfortunate victim of circumstance. The right man, in the right place, at the wrong time. A bit like Buck Rogers....but with a more useless sidekick than fat tin-can Twiki in the shape of Steve Round.
...................
David Moyes: "Nani! Nani! Ah'm sending yae oan son. Roondy will brief yae oan how yae can help us tae get back intae the game. Och, some cunt that man is. Light years aheed of his time. Mind yae listen tae the man the noo Nani because ayvry word's fookin gold dust, ah'm telling yae. SHHHH! Here it come's. Here it comes..."

Steve Round: "Biddie, Biddie, Biddie, Biddie"

Moyes: "Fooking brilliant! Och, some cunt yae are Roondy son."
...............

If Moyes truly wants to continue to 'learn', he first needs to admit that that he himself fell a long way short of the standard required to succeed at the top level, instead of making pathetic excuses about being passed a poisoned chalice.

Fittingly, seeing as though he's currently fannying about over in Florida, a quote from a former US President seems to suit Moyes and his whole 'mistreated by Man United' mindset:

"A pessimist is one who makes difficulties of his opportunities and an optimist is one who makes opportunities of his difficulties."

Keith Glazzard
30 Posted 06/06/2014 at 18:40:40
When I saw the headline I thought it said 'In the Championship'.

Fair enough, thought I, start again, build up from solid defence but this time with speed and penetration in attack, down both flanks with guile in the middle. Then the Prem!

But it said Champions League.. Good luck mate. I'll bring me boots.

Colin Glassar
31 Posted 06/06/2014 at 19:05:09
I'm sure teams in the CL are falling over themselves trying to get the genius that is ginger minge in as manager. Who wouldn't? Exciting football, progressive tactics, bold use of youth, amazing substitutions etc...... Nurse!!!
Mike Childs
32 Posted 06/06/2014 at 20:22:30
And I thought I had a good laugh earlier today thinking about Stevie Me's slip. Talk about a delusional man.
Peter Warren
33 Posted 06/06/2014 at 20:53:01
"I thought I showed I can manage at that level."

Foolish statement – by that rationale, he showed he can't manage a team of champions. I know he can't but why he says he can't seems either very honest (like Keegan when managing England) or (more likely) daft.

Dave Long
35 Posted 06/06/2014 at 22:43:25
Champions League?? A defensive coach is your limit. Fair play, he developed a bunch of players into internationals.... but attacking flair? Nah... never!!!
Ian Tunstead
36 Posted 07/06/2014 at 02:55:22
Didn't everyone mock and laugh at Brian Clough after his Leeds experience and then he went on to win two European Cups back-to-back?

I suppose all you know-it-alls and jokers have never failed at anything in your lives. All you armchair managers know far better clearly.

As for Moyes being spoiled at Everton, if that's what you call spoilt what would you call the managers at Man City and Chelsea? Never mind Liverpool, Spurs and Man Utd. Relying on £60,000 Irish full backs like Coleman, bargain basement Championship players like Cahill, Lescott and Jagielka and failed has-beens like Arteta and Pienaar wouldn't be what I called spoilt.

Jim Lloyd
38 Posted 07/06/2014 at 06:42:58
I can't remember laughing at Brian Clough but then my memory's dodgy. Moyes was spoilt at Everton, he was spoilt by our Chairman who would never have sacked him. We would never have got Roberto if Moyes hadn't decided to go, so I thank him for leaving.

I think it's going to be very difficult for him to get a top manager's job in England now, so he'd have to go abroad but I can't see any top European club taking him on either. After his tenure at Man Utd, top clubs are going to look at his record and not take him on. Maybe that's being unfair to him but he chose to go and I think the main memory of his time there, is that he didn't do well in the transfer market. He also, reputedly, lost the support of some senior players.

I'd have thought the Celtic job would have been his best bet because, barring a total calamity, they're virtually guaranteed European football every season. He'll have to go to a club with "Champion's League ambitions" – and that could be any middling club in Europe.

Paul Andrews
39 Posted 07/06/2014 at 07:18:26
Ian,

Are you suggesting Moyes will win a CL trophy in the future?

Paul Andrews
40 Posted 07/06/2014 at 07:21:39
Jim,

He's good at calamities

Darren Hind
41 Posted 07/06/2014 at 06:17:16
Ian

Moyes never enjoyed the level of adoration we now see heaped on Martinez, but despite his cautious approach and and ever growing feeling that the "glass ceiling" was of his own creation, he was given enormous backing by the fans.

Goodison afforded him a very warm send off, despite knowing he had become the Man Utd manager... in return, he shat on them. As betrayals go, this one was up there.

I once saw Moyes at a Lisbon airport trying to justify his selections and tactics to a group of angry Evertonians after a battering. I couldn't escape the feeling that every single one of them understood what had gone wrong better than he did. That was it for me. As far as I'm concerned, his limitations had been exposed long before he left.

The mocking is inevitable, but I too feel slightly uneasy at its intensity, not because I feel any sympathy towards Moyes, but because I know what Moyes is good at. If he was to get the gigg at a Newcastle, or a Villa, I have no doubt at all that he would be pushing them well into top half.

Off the pitch, Martinez is light years ahead of Moyes – he is charismatic and has clearly seduced Evertonia with his positive blue sky approach. But is he any better tactically? Will his players give him as much? I have my doubts.

Robbie will always TRY to to play a prettier brand of football, but his teams often fail to do it more than they succeed. I don't think I could bear to see Moyes's smug gob if he ever finishes above us again... but I wouldn't bet a penny against it happening.

Jim Lloyd
42 Posted 07/06/2014 at 07:50:26
Paul, :)
Mark Frere
44 Posted 07/06/2014 at 12:52:51
Ian (36)

Clough took Derby County from the old 2nd division and turned them into champions of England by playing good attractive football and also took them to the semi-final of the European Cup. This was before he joined Leeds... so, a little more impressive than what Moyes achieved with us before he got the Man Utd job, don't you agree?

Moyes took us from being bottom 8 team to being a top 8 team - no more, no less.

As Darren points out, he received a warm send off and left with most of our fans best wishes for his future at heart. But his disrespectful conduct afterwards was unacceptable... so, I really don't know why you feel the need to keep defending him... unless its a case of you just not being man enough to admit you were wrong all along?

Peter Bell
45 Posted 07/06/2014 at 13:12:59
Before and after Leeds, Cloughie had a track recordo f winning things. OFM never won anything before his tenure at OT and never will win anything after.

I believe by winning the European Cup with Forest, Cloughie holds the record for the city to have won it with the lowest population.

Sam Hoare
46 Posted 07/06/2014 at 13:17:34
Schadenfreude overload.
Dennis Stevens
47 Posted 07/06/2014 at 13:18:47
To compare Moyes with Clough is somewhat an insult to the great man's memory. I don't recall many people laughing at Clough back in the day, at least not beyond a wry "what the fuck was he thinking of?" It was a bad fit, everybody knew it apart from, it seems, Brian Clough & the Leeds United Board.

I'm not remotely arsed about David Moyes & his future whereabouts. Just so long as we never see him back as manager of Everton, I'll be quite happy.

Peter Bell
48 Posted 07/06/2014 at 13:48:52
I'm looking forward to hearing:

"Stuck with Moyes, stuck with Moyes, Ayr United...."

Patrick Murphy
49 Posted 07/06/2014 at 13:49:01
Darren,

DM never got the level of adoration because although the fans respected him and admired his style they didn't love him. I wrote a piece about it the Christmas before he upped and left. Different people receive differing responses depending upon their unique qualities.

At Everton the fans on the whole either like you or they don't and if ex-employees behave properly they retain their respect; if they fail to do that, they can do one – a pretty basic response from people from this neck of the woods if not throughout the football fraternity.

Brian Denton
50 Posted 07/06/2014 at 14:05:18
Nailed it, Patrick!
Brian Harrison
51 Posted 07/06/2014 at 13:58:53
I think we should move on as regards OFM I don't think he will be giving us any second thoughts. What I find a bit hypocritical is OFM tries to buy 2 of our better players which he brought to our club and his CEO offers derisory money for them. So OFM is castigated by our fans yet his replacement buys Kone, Robles, Alcaraz and McCarthy from his previous club and that's OK.
Kevin Tully
52 Posted 07/06/2014 at 14:07:09
Ah come on Ian T, she left us for another fella. She was overweight, snippy, and only let you have some on your birthday (if SHE was in the mood). She sat there all day thinking she was lovely, and you should be the one who was grateful to her. You were bringing home all the money and handing it over without question, while she begrudgingly looked down on you thinking she should be with someone better.

Then we met our new love – a Miss World who loved nothing better than to please you. This one looked at you like YOU were the finest they could ever wish for, and she had her own money! She can spoil you with nice things even though they were borrowed from her friends. She spoke to you lovingly at every opportunity, and wanted to take you on jaunts around Europe without moaning about what her friends had to spend.

You should cherish this one mate, forget about the old slapper you were with. She ended up with an abusive partner who even flew a plane over their new house telling her to sling her hook. Good riddance, I say!

Paul Andrews
53 Posted 07/06/2014 at 14:17:35
Brian,

Far from Moyes not giving us a second thought, in my opinion he will be gutted how well we have done. His ego will have expected the club to drop in league position after he jumped off the throne he constructed for himself.

Brian Waring
54 Posted 07/06/2014 at 15:07:33
Ian Tunstead, Moyes was spoilt with us, he was paid a fucking huge wad of cash that made made him one of the highest paid managers in Europe, to me, that was being spoilt.
Tony Abrahams
56 Posted 07/06/2014 at 17:21:07
Good post Darren 41, especially the bit about Lisbon, but that doesn't surprise me because a lot of knowledgable, passionate people follow the Toffees.

Moyes is a pragmatist but he didn't get many players fighting for him at Man Utd though, probably because of a mix between his limitations and his demeanor. Martinez doesn't appear nowhere near as pragmatic but the players seem to respond, which is the most important thing.

Not being funny, Darren, but tactics and Moyes? I honestly never thought he had many. Element of surprise? Not until he made a fool of himself, offering £26 million for Baines and Fellaini.

Good luck to Moyes but, as John Daley says, how can you improve when it's everyone else's fault? When Everton put the final nail in David Moyes's coffin, I personally thought that, for the first time in over 25 years, we were light years ahead of Man Utd tactically.

Si Cooper
57 Posted 07/06/2014 at 22:11:10
Nice post Darren.

I know you won't believe it but I too think RM has something to prove if we are indeed to get back to the level we all want to be at.

I think I get what you mean about getting players who will give everything. Moyes was definitely accomplished at identifying this trait in players and recruiting them, and there must be question-marks against a manager whose previous team didn't seem capable of sustaining an adequate level of performance over a whole season. I am maybe a bit more hopeful than you that Martinez has some steel to go with his obvious charm and enough intelligence to quickly learn, if he hasn't already, which players will respond to his brand of persuasiveness with fully committed performances.

Moyes would bring stability and consistency to the likes of Villa and Newcastle but I would be surprised if he could fashion them into Champions League contenders because I believe he lacks the flair to breach the money gap. His best bet may well be the continent where his no nonsense approach may be enough.

Jim Lloyd
58 Posted 08/06/2014 at 09:23:02
Brian Harrison,

I don't see anything whatsoever wrong with our Manager going back to his former club to buy players. As I understand it, he acted with total integrity towards Wigan and their owner said as much.

I think the difference between his approach and Moyes's towards our club, was very telling. No need to go through the saga again but it is blindingly obvious to me that his public utterances throughout his move for Baines and Fellaini turned many Evertonians, who probably took part in that rousing farewell, against him. What was it – "Never stop a player going to a better club"?

As for his wish to manage a club in the Champions League, I wish him well and I agree that he would almost certainly do a decent job at Villa or Newcastle. Whether he is able to get them into the Champions League is another matter.

As for our manager, someone posted that he has his doubts regarding Roberto's ability to get as much from our players as Moyes did. I would say he has already proved that he has. As for the comment that Roberto's teams will always try to play prettier football but often fail to do it more than they succeed, I fail to understand it. He was successful before Wigan and this last season I would say he was successful much more than he failed. When Wigan battered us off the park at our place, I thought then that he would be a manager I'd love to see at EFC and so far, I'm thrilled at the football we are producing.

As for David Moyes, he's gone. I thought he did a decent job for us but I'd given my season ticket up two seasons before he left, as to me, it was like living in groundhog day.

Paul Andrews
59 Posted 08/06/2014 at 11:43:50
Jim Lloyd,

He got as much and more out of his players than Moyes ever did. Highest Premier League points total, highest amount of wins, won at Old Trafford. AND played some of the best football seen at Goodison for many a year.

Groundhog Day... Yeh.

Trevor Powell
60 Posted 08/06/2014 at 15:19:42
According to the Sunday times, OFM – chewed up and spat out by the Red Devils – is on his way to join the most over-rated fucker in football... no make that life,

"David Beckham wants former Manchester United manager David Moyes to manage the Major League Soccer franchise he is establishing in Miami. Former United and England midfielder Beckham is reported to have floated the idea to Moyes via a third party."

Ste Traverse
61 Posted 08/06/2014 at 15:21:39
Laughable someone is trying to compare a loser like Moyes with the late, great Brian Clough.

Cloughie was one of the greatest managers the world has ever seen. As for Moyes, he will never get anywhere near the trophy haul Clough could boast.

Darren Hind
63 Posted 08/06/2014 at 15:16:16
Jim Lloyd

"As for the comment that Roberto's teams always try to play pretty football, but fail to do it more often than they succeed, I fail to understand it."

Let me simplify it, Jim. For every game you can name when our play had the crowd off their feet applauding the rebirth of the School of Science, I can name three when we err... didn't.

Now I understand no team can dazzle every week, but we served up some pretty poor stuff last season and although I understand people applauding what he was trying to do, I can't understand people pretending denying what happened.

As for getting more out of players? Well that's easily explained too: Moyes's teams often made up for their lack of talent and his lack of adventure by sheer bloody minded effort. We qualified for CL place with players like Hibbert, Stubbs, Weir and Pistone... Marcus Bent led the line for fuck's sake? People like Cahill, Carsley and Neville would often win at places like WHL or The Etihad, but would they have even made the first eleven had they played for the home team?

I feel slightly embarrassed at the way some of the fans have treated our victory at Old Trafford like a Champions League victory, not because it wasn't a great night – it was – but, given the disarray Man Utd were in and how many other teams won there this season, victory hardly carried the same kudos as it would have done previously...

If you take that win out of the equation, our results and points returns at the grounds of other teams in the top nine are frankly shaming... and hardly suggests the players are ready to run through a brick wall for Robbie just yet.

Paul Andrews
64 Posted 08/06/2014 at 16:18:15
Darren,

Would you swap Roberto to have Moyes back as manager?

Phil Sammon
65 Posted 08/06/2014 at 16:37:03
Darren

Do you ever stop and think you may be overly negative?

I take some of your points, but it really is hard to fathom how a person can be so consistently negative about everything Everton baring in mind the enjoyable season we have just witnessed.

Colin Glassar
66 Posted 08/06/2014 at 16:48:57
Cheer up, Darren, it's summer and the skies are blue. Oh, and we had a great season IMO. Admittedly lots of work still to do but, overall, more positives than negatives.
Darren Hind
67 Posted 08/06/2014 at 16:44:50
I take great joy in all things Everton, Phil, but I get frustrated by happy clapping.

On the other hand, I've received texts from both my boys who have seen my latest post and on balance I guess I may be forced to consider the possibility that I could be turning into a miserable arl bastard.

Paul Ferry
68 Posted 08/06/2014 at 18:13:40
Phil mate - 65 - too many words; this would have nailed it:

"Darren, Do you ever stop and think???"

Trevor Powell
69 Posted 08/06/2014 at 22:31:54
David Beckham wants former Manchester United manager David Moyes to manage the Major League Soccer franchise he is establishing in Miami. Former United and England midfielder Beckham is reported to have floated the idea to Moyes via a third party. Sunday Times
Jim Lloyd
70 Posted 08/06/2014 at 22:41:05
Paul (59)

Are you sure your reading my post right? Mind you my English ain't that good but what you appear to have criticised me for, is saying exactly what you have said.

I'll say it again. Roberto has got players playing good football and playing the football that I want to see. The Groundhog Day was a reference to the football I was watching the seasons BEFORE he came.

Paul Andrews
71 Posted 08/06/2014 at 22:54:35
Jim,

I was agreeing with and emphasising your point.
I am with you 100%

Jim Lloyd
72 Posted 08/06/2014 at 22:48:24
Darren,

Thanks for simplifying things. I can only say that I think you're simply wrong. What on earth are you on about with your comment of "happy clapping?" Unless you mean that we shouldn't laud our manager for his achievement this season, I can't really figure what you're on about. The best points total we've had since Dick docked and the 3rd best defensive record in the division.

The "pretty football" you refer to is what I would prefer to call positive, School of Science football and I think the majority of fans like what they see. I look at Naismith and he's a player reborn, look at Barkley and he's becoming a fine young player, as is Stones. Jagielka can actually pass a ball now...

If you mean he has not been successful often enough in trying to play pretty football, I disagree. If you mean he has not been successful, whilst trying to play pretty football, the facts speak differently.

Still, it's a game of opinions and I don't wish to be accused of happy clapping here but I'd just like to state that I am glad Moyes went and even gladder Roberto came. I don't believe we will get into the Champions League but there again, I thought we'd do well to get to 7th last season!

Jim Lloyd
73 Posted 08/06/2014 at 23:05:00
Sorry Paul, my apologies mate for not reading proper English... properly! Think three pints of Abbot might have summat to do with that!

All the best.

Jay Harris
74 Posted 08/06/2014 at 22:52:05
Darren, as someone who was opposed to the appointment of Roberto, I feel qualified to say he has transformed our club from top to bottom and made it a happy and united place to be.

Quality players achieve things and whether he will be allowed to get the necessary quality is down to the board but as someone who respected Moyes even in the dark times, I would say I trust Roberto far more than Moyes to handle world class personalities.

Paul Andrews
75 Posted 08/06/2014 at 23:26:16
Jim,

No worries, mate. Enjoy your pint. You and Jay are in the vast majority of Blues who think Roberto has improved the club since he took over. One or two dissenters, they are entitled to their opinion.

Jim Lloyd
76 Posted 08/06/2014 at 23:33:51
True enough, Paul, a good point you make.
Darren Hind
77 Posted 09/06/2014 at 06:21:21
Jim

The term 'happy clapping' was not directed at you. You put together a decent post but you questioned how I could make my points. I gave clarity by backing my argument with two incontestable facts. Moyes did get 4th place with a group of players many people (including the bookies) thought were relegation fodder... and if my point about our record at the grounds of top nine teams is untrue, why do you suppose people like Paul Andrews and Paul Ferry haven't contested it? I'll tell you why: because they can't.

The happy clappers don't want to hear anything that doesn't portray Martinez in the brightest light. Facts are discounted and dismissed as negativity (see above) and when they get REALLY desperate, they will put their fingers in their ears and make the pathetic claim that you must want the last manager back because you criticise the current one.

The idea that somebody could identify serious flaws in both our current manager and the previous one just doesn't compute with some. You have to love one or the other. Why? I'm on board the love train but I don't have to love the fucking driver.

I answered your question because I respected it, Jim, I don't have an issue with anybody who lauds our manager for the things he has done. It's those who want to credit him with stuff he didn't do or get all angry when you point to a few unpalatable facts.

Pointing out our dismal away record against the top nine teams kinda contradicts the boast that we are now swaggering in and standing eyeball to eyeball at the grounds of the big boys... That's why it upsets the happy clappers so much.

Paul Andrews
78 Posted 09/06/2014 at 07:41:52
Morning Darren,

I haven't contested it as I considered it to be an irrelevant point.

Denis Richardson
79 Posted 09/06/2014 at 08:05:36
Jeez Darren - you really need to smile a bit....

Granted Roberto didn't tick all the boxes with every game and there were a few crap performances and lucky wins but the season is 38 games long. NO team plays great every single game (ask Man City about Sunderland away or Chelsea fans about Sunderland at home...).

However, you need to keep things in perspective. Even though this was his first season as Everton manager, taking over a previous manager who had been at the helm for over a decade, he still managed to far exceed everyone's expectations. Anyone on TW saying they thought we would be in with a shout of 4th going into the last couple of games of the season is simply a liar. Many were glad Roberto joined but were expecting a period of transition, even more were expecting us to sink like a stone. However, Martinez has surprised everyone to date and his demeanor is an added bonus.

Look at our squad last season, the whole first team was so so much better balanced than the majority of the teams put out by Moyes. Also the players (more than one) have publicly come out and said they are happier under Martinez and are tactically more aware and enjoying their football more. We also finally have no deadwood players on massive wages doing fuck all at the club, like Heitinga or Anichebe. (Please don't bring up Kone, the guy was injured all season so cannot be used as an example (yet) of a bad transfer, as some people keep doing.)

Admittedly Martinez has so far won as many trophies at Everton as Moyes ever did; however, I am a hell of a lot more hopeful of winning something in the future with him than I ever was under Moyes. In his first season, he has knocked Moyes out of the park imo (and I bet Moyes is gutted by that as he thought he was our 'saviour'). Granted, second-season syndrome may kick in (hopefully not) but for now the whole club and its fans are in a much happier and better place — and we are a shitload better to watch! I now watch our games EXPECTING us to give it a good go and to win, whereas under Moyes for the last few seasons, I'd be shitting it most of the game, even if we had the ball!

Moyes reached his limit with us around 2009 and for the last 3-4 years stunk the place out waiting for his 'big move' and his £4M-a-year contract to run down. Martinez has come in and brought a smile back to Everton and, although each result is not perfect, at least we now have HOPE of getting better, playing better, and finally winning something.

That alone is something to be grateful for and should put a smile on every Everton face....

Phil Bellis
81 Posted 09/06/2014 at 10:06:59
Ian Tunstead (36) — "Didn't everyone mock and laugh..."

Er, no. Not those of us who recognise talent and genius

Our conservative board doing an England and passing up the opportunity to have Clough as our manager goes down as another in a long, long line of atrocious boardroom decisions.

Ste Traverse
83 Posted 09/06/2014 at 19:48:30
Phil.

Wasn't it when Gordon Lee got job the job that Cloughie was supposed to have been seriously interested in taking over as manager at Goodison?

Colin Glassar
84 Posted 09/06/2014 at 19:55:09
Ste, Ian, Phil, we missed out big time when Bobby Robson turned us down after the board 'leaked' his appointment before he had a chance to talk to the Ipswich board.

I'm not sure about the Cloughie link but the future Sir Bobby was in the bag until some bigmouth started blabbering. How different the '70s could've turned out to be if we could've signed him up?

Peter Bell
85 Posted 09/06/2014 at 20:04:11
Colin Glassar, absolutely spot on.

After Catterick we had Robson in the bag. cocked up big time and ended up with Bingham. After Bingham, we nearly had Robson again, but did the same and ended up with Gordon Lee.

Two monumental fuck-ups in our history at a time when the other lot were just getting into their stride.

Patrick Murphy
86 Posted 09/06/2014 at 20:09:53
Was it the Club or the ever helpful Liverpool Echo who as far as I'm concerned, remain to this day devoted to the other side of the park?

Or can we blame a younger BK? Did he gush to all and sundry what was going to happen? If it was he, then that could be another in his litany of errors of judgements.

Peter Bell
87 Posted 09/06/2014 at 20:15:36
Patrick, someone off the board told the press about the Robson appointment before he could tell the Cobbald family and Robson pulled the deal.
He said, "How can you trust people who let you down on the very first day?"
Colin Glassar
88 Posted 09/06/2014 at 20:17:05
Patrick, I'm inclined to blame BK but surely he was still in his flannel shorts in the boys pen at the time?

The Liverpool Echo is a possible candidate for being the whistle blower as they've always done their best to scupper us as a club. I believe it was a board member who was slightly pissed and started yapping shit to an RS journo who then printed the story.

Sir Bobby, being a gent, felt betrayed by the leak and publicly, and humiliatingly, turned us down only for the nightmare years of Bingham and Co to start a dismal decade.

Patrick Murphy
89 Posted 09/06/2014 at 20:19:39
Peter,

If only we as supporters could have learned that lesson earlier in our lives, then those disappointments would have been easier to take. I understand what you are saying but I seem to have some memory or story that the Echo ran with it almost before Robson had left the City – something they probably wouldn't have done if it had been the other club in the city.

There are a lot of similarities with our current manager and Bobby Robson, did anyone see Robson on some World Cup clip show trying to order tea and toast for his Ipswich Town team from a local hotel prior to a derby game with Norwich – who had already booked-in to the hotel that Robson was intending to use.

Ste Traverse
90 Posted 09/06/2014 at 23:19:59
Patrick.

I dislike BK as much as any in his vast army of critics, but no way can you blame him for any cock up with Bobby Robson.

Simply because he didn't join the board until 1989, years after Robson had rejected the job.

Kevin Tully
91 Posted 09/06/2014 at 23:50:03
I see David Beckham was commissioned to present a programme about his 'Amazon Adventure' on BBC tonight.

Apparently, he was last seen wandering around a large warehouse in Dagenham looking at DVD's.

Patrick Murphy
92 Posted 09/06/2014 at 23:57:02
Ste, I wasn't being serious!

But just because he wasn't on the board doesn't mean that it wasn't him – you know how excited he gets when he has an audience.

Raymond Fox
93 Posted 09/06/2014 at 23:57:29
Darren, I don't believe anyone is disputing that Moyes did a very good job in keeping us in the top 6 or 7 for a good number of seasons.

I do find it difficult to understand though, why you can't concede that Martinez has done an excellent job in his first season in charge.

You accuse us of 'happy clapping' but it seems that you have taken the opposite tack and grasp onto every down side however small. Martinez gets praise from all past and present who have come in contact with him, I don't think they can all be wrong!

Phil Bellis
94 Posted 10/06/2014 at 00:20:43
No Ian,

Just didn't need to be a genius or Nostradamus to know that Clough was special.

I'm also convinced our myopic management, selling Bally for club profit, put us in the wilderness for 14 years.

Bobby Thomas
96 Posted 10/06/2014 at 03:07:49
As usual when Cloughie is discussd, Peter Taylor is mentioned nowhere. Clough was nowhere near as good without him. Indeed they were nowhere near as good without each other.

He was the shade to Cloughie's light. He probably would have been an enormous help with the players at Leeds.

Darren Hind
97 Posted 10/06/2014 at 03:08:56
Raymond

Martinez first came to my attention when he very publically labled some of his want-away Swansea players "disloyal" for wanting to better themselves... only to jump ship himself when Whelan came in and offered him the chance to manage in the Premier League. Now before anybody accuses me of criticising him – yet again – let me say I'd have done exactly the same myself... but the suggestion that everyone who has ever come into contact with Martinez only has praise for him is miles away; many Swansea fans feel the same sense of betrayal as we do towards Moyes.

You recently told me to just admit I was wrong in my early season prediction about Martinez, but you had no clue as to what that prediction was, or even if I'd made one. You knew you had an argument but you didn't know what it was... and so it goes with a certain group of people on these pages: IMO, your loyalty to our current manager is blind and unquestioning.

I've praised Martinez many a time on these pages, I loved the "Olé" football that we sometimes played and always attempted to play. I love the way he lifted the mood of the whole club, I credit him with the upturn in our profile, I even love the sound of an alehouse full of Evertonians singing "Roberto had a dream"... but you guys don't see the praise, you will only ever notice the criticism, no matter how justified; every point is contested, even the incontestable ones.

I'm done Raymond.

I no longer see the point in arguing with people who will boast that we now puff our chest out and go toe-to-toe at the grounds of the big boys, but then dismiss the fact that our record at these places is shite, as "irrelevant" (post 78). There's no point in contradicting people who say our manager's signed players who were here before HE was. I give up on pointing out that we played really uninspiring stuff for much of last season, because these people will deny the evidence of their own eyes.

I 've stopped contesting the claim Martinez has fucked off all the deadwood like Jelavic and Big Vic even though I know all parties have told us he did his utmost to persuade them to stay... I could go on all day about this, but what's the point?

I'm gonna try to stay away from Martinez-related threads in future as I now believe my comments really upset some people, they only want to hear good things said about him, it's clear they do not welcome an alternative point of view, unpalatable facts seem to annoy them and everytime I'm challenged to justify a point it, its construed as another dig at a manager who I "don't like".

I like Martinez, hard not to, but I think he screwed up a few times last season, particularly at the business end of it. I have high hopes of him coming back next season, older, wiser and better; however, (for me at least) this is not a puppy love.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb