Blues' trio involved as England lose

, 14 June, 141comments  |  Jump to most recent
England 1 - 2 Italy
Phil Jagielka and Leighton Baines were named in the starting line-up for England's Group D opener in Manaus as Roy Hodgson went with a largely predictable but attacking XI to take on Italy.

Ross Barkley was kept in reserve, hopeful of making an impact from the substitutes' bench when he was introduced after an hour, but the Three Lions were chasing the game at 2-1 in energy-sapping conditions and couldn't find an equaliser.

Both Everton starters were heavily involved in the first half, Baines battling to cope with Darmian and Candreva revelling in the space behind Wayne Rooney and Jagielka having to come to England's rescue on the stroke of half time when he headed off his line to deny Mario Balotelli.

Before that, Claudio Marchesio had arrowed a 25-yard shot into the corner following Andrea Pirlo's slick dummy, only for Daniel Sturridge to convert Rooney's whipped cross from close range.

Hodgson swapped Rooney with Danny Welbeck for the second half but he too left Baines exposed on the left and Candreva was able to pick Balotelli out with a flighted ball from which the striker made no mistake to make it 2-1.

Barkley's first involvement was positive, the 20 year-old latching onto Jordan Henderson's long pass and testing the 'keeper with a low shot that was beaten away by Sirigu.

And it was Sirigu who later denied Baines from a direct free kick that didn't have the height that the Blues' left back would have wanted but the 'keeper had to push it behind for a corner.

England's best chance to grab a point fell to Rooney who screwed his shot wide of the near post from a great position.

England: Hart; Johnson, Cahill, Jagielka, Baines; Henderson, Gerrard; Sterling, Welbeck, Rooney; Sturridge.

 

Reader Comments (141)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Ferry
1 Posted 14/06/2014 at 20:55:53
Roy bottled it.
Lyndon Lloyd
2 Posted 14/06/2014 at 21:00:24
Not sure I agree, Paul. Of course, many wanted Barkley to start and Rooney’s never really lived up to his billing in the World Cup but that’s a pretty attacking line-up.

Roy would get reamed if he went with too much youth in the first game and they lost... and Ross would get caught up in the inquest. This way Ross can prove him wrong, although he was better as a starter for us last season than as an impact sub. Be interesting to see how it pans out...

Chris de Costa
3 Posted 14/06/2014 at 21:05:42
Roy had the balls to pick a really young attacking squad for this tournament, he should get some credit for that. His line up is never gonna please everyone, it’s a matter of personnel opinion. I think as a nation there has always been a negativity towards the England team, mainly down to the press who use every opportunity to slaughter the team and manager. It’s time change that mindset and really get behind them. It’s an exciting squad we have now and there’s no reason they can’t do well
Jon Withey
4 Posted 14/06/2014 at 21:18:24
He’ll regret not having Lallana in there, where is the playmaker???
Paul Ferry
5 Posted 14/06/2014 at 21:22:20
Fair Lyndon but Labanana should have started ahead of Wellbeck and quite frankly in terms of form who would you rather have had Rooney or Barkley? Sterling is a bolder move as he for me is an accident waiting to happen, zippy but nutty. The real weak area is defense. Johnson is a mare. Jags is simply not international star quality and his reading and positioning you would expect to be better by now. But unfortunately options are very limited back there.

Looking at the squad I would have played a fit Chamberlain - swapped Barks for Rooney - swapped Lababnana for Welbeck (lucky, very lucky to be playing) - Wilshire can play where Henderson is but on reflection lets see how henderson does as Wilshire did not look good last week at all.

So, as for bottle, not so much the intent as the selections.

Andy Amey
6 Posted 14/06/2014 at 21:42:03
Henderson wouldn’t even be there if he played for anyone else.
I’m sorry but I haven’t seen anything that makes me think he is good enough for this level.
Denis Richardson
7 Posted 14/06/2014 at 21:38:39
The heat and humidity will cause both teams a problem, however that England midfield doesn’t really inspire. Not sure what Henderson brings apart from 10 yard side passes to Gerard.
Lyndon Lloyd
8 Posted 14/06/2014 at 22:06:21
Agree regarding, Lallana, Paul – what Roy sees in Henderson is a mystery to me – but disagree re Jagielka. Glen Johnson is terrible; hopefully Italy don’t work that out but I’m sure they’ll be prepared!
Kunal Desai
9 Posted 14/06/2014 at 22:52:50
Back four is England’s great weakness. Baines is great going forward but he gets exposed defensively, just how many goals did Everton concede from the left last season? Not convinced by Jags, think he’s ordinary and made to look because he plays alongside a rock in Distin. As for Johnson, well I just don’t think there is anyone else above average in the PL
Michael Kenrick
10 Posted 14/06/2014 at 22:59:09
Fantastic Stadium... light just fading... nicely painted green ’grass’... fabulous sight.
Denis Richardson
11 Posted 14/06/2014 at 23:25:27
Regardless of the result, nice to see two Everton players in the starting line up in a World Cup game for England, been a long time since that happened. 1990?
James Flynn
12 Posted 14/06/2014 at 23:39:19
Yeah, over-the-hill Rooney. Perfectly placed cross for the goal.
Patrick Murphy
13 Posted 14/06/2014 at 23:48:30
Sterling outstanding? Welbeck was England’s best player first-half, great clearance from Jags and Gerrard should be taken off, he’s finished.
Tony Abrahams
14 Posted 14/06/2014 at 23:55:01
Agree Wilshere for Gerrard. Sad watching Rooney play on the wing. If he’d stayed at Everton, he wouldn’t have as many medals, but he would have become a true great.
Gerry Quinn
15 Posted 15/06/2014 at 01:07:26
Shite team, shite build-up, extremely average performance that deserved the result. They play their game very similar to the Manager's utterly boring demeanour! Bring on Uruguay and Costa Rica – we will be lucky to get a point from either...
James Flynn
16 Posted 15/06/2014 at 01:13:33
This is some sad, sorry shit. My comment here just doubles the Uruguay-Costa Rica game ones?

The game ended gents. Un-tuck your tails from between your legs and post your thoughts on what you saw during the game.

Patrick Murphy
17 Posted 15/06/2014 at 01:24:48
Did you agree with the pundits that England were unlucky to lose, James? I personally thought it was a very sorry performance against an ordinary Italian team.
Raymond Fox
18 Posted 15/06/2014 at 01:09:16
Well done England, you are past masters at losing. Caused me to waste another few hours of my life! Promise so much, but always fail. Rooney was garbage!

At least they played a lot better football than in the past and weren't an embarrassment. They passed the ball about well, Sterling was almost unplayable. We did not deserve to lose, but we managed to again!

Dennis Stevens
19 Posted 15/06/2014 at 01:26:57
A draw would have been a fair result, but Italy took their chances and England didn't - can't complain about the result. To be honest, I think Hodgson is already planning for 2 and 4 years ahead, hence all the youngsters in the squad.
Derek Knox
20 Posted 15/06/2014 at 01:26:36
Thought Henderson, Gerrard, Johnstone and Rooney were all well below what was required!

Sterling, Welbeck, Sturridge were really worth their places!

Ross, Wilshere and Lallana were brought on too late, but all did well, but the ship was already sinking by then!

The panel were blaming Baines for the crosses, but he was left without any help on the left!

It's a must-win now against Uruguay and Costa Rica!

Andy Finigan
21 Posted 15/06/2014 at 01:25:07
What's the point of putting Ross on when we are 2-1 down and there is no room to attack?

Playing Rooney on the wing is poor. Baines can't play without the cover needed to get forward.

Two more weeks and it will be over for our campaign. I am just glad we have the most positive manager as it really shows what we had and what England has.

Phil Sammon
22 Posted 15/06/2014 at 02:52:45
Dennis Stevens 19

No no no no no!

I am not having that one! If Roy is preparing for 2 - 4 years time (as I think he should be) then Gerrard, Johnson, Jagielka, Lampard etc don't even make the squad. He cannot have this one both ways. Everyone said this was a free pass. A time of no expectation. Why have we got a pensioner in charge who cares nothing for what England do in 10 years time?

Anyway I'm too tired to argue. My last point...20 minutes to go, we're a goal down...and we don't have a single striker on the pitch.If Lambert doesn't come on then....why bring him?

Dennis Stevens
23 Posted 15/06/2014 at 03:26:28
Tired and emotional, Phil?
Paul Ferry
24 Posted 15/06/2014 at 05:00:41
This is doing my head in:

LEIGHTON BAINES (LEFT-BACK) 5
England left-back Leighton Baines. Tough night for Everton’s left-back. Not afforded much protection and Italy took advantage.

(1) how can LB be blamed if hair-transplant it’s me hair honest is not doing his job! (2) he had a perfectly decent game – so lets give, for example, Jags 7 but LB 5, bollocks!!! (3) put through one of the best passes of the cup so far only for twat-head to screw it up!!

John Hughes
25 Posted 15/06/2014 at 06:29:23
Derek. Only Shearer came to Baines's defence and highlighted the lack of cover in front of him. What I found irritating though was that none of these so-called experts had the balls to comment on the "elephant in the room"' that is Gerrard. Gerrard has been a very good player, no doubt but he has never reached the heights in an England shirt and now he looks finished. Hodgson made a monumental error in appointing him Captain as he won't have the balls to drop him. Rooney is heading the same way.

Shite performance in midfield, questionable team selection so let's blame Baines. Wankers.

Derek Thomas
26 Posted 15/06/2014 at 06:26:18
Given the limited squad in both numbers and talent, what ya gonna do?

Hart – did enough
Johnson – a defender who can't defend and his replacements are two utility defenders who can't attack.
Jags & Cahill – did okay-ish. But the whole back four (minus Johnson, who had gone walkabout) were dragged over to the left for Ballotelli's headed tap in.
Baines - Hung out to dry as usual. FB's are only as good as the cover in front of them. If he has nobody to play his 1-2's and 2-3's with, why bother with him at all.
Rooney – except for one cross, virtually anonymous.
Henderson – no crosses, even more anonymous.
Gerrard – meh.
Sterling Sturridge and Wellbeck – did enough to keep their places.

Hodgson – he picked the squad, I just hope he can manage to make a silk purse out of his self-inflicted sows ear.

Short version: unless they get lucky, they won't get out of the group... which most of us knew when the draw was made.

Tahir Abdullah
27 Posted 15/06/2014 at 06:53:14
As a neutral, the result was most satisfying. Seeing the likes of Welbeck & Gerrard in particular trying to unsuccessfully con the referee was worth my satellite TV subscription fee; super Mario gesturing 2-1 & shut up at the final whistle... priceless.

On the night, even the overrated Lallana & Barkley had little impact when coming in as substitutions. English football is being shown up for the sham it is. Among the three blues, only Jags looked international class.

Raymond Fox
28 Posted 15/06/2014 at 07:30:31
Thanks for that Tahir, now just fuck off.

We played well, but didn't put the ball in the net when we had chances, which after all is the name of the game!

Gerrard puzzles me, he has always been lauded as a 'great player', but I've never watched a match with him involved, when I've thought he was special, good in spells. but great no way.
With true great players, you can see the class at all times.

Helen Mallon
29 Posted 15/06/2014 at 08:35:52
Okay, Rooney should be played as a striker and the difference on the night was Pirlo. He showed everything that Gerrard isn't. He was everywhere class player. Roy just got the formation wrong. Rooney is a striker – 19 goals in the Prem last season for a crap Man Utd side. Stirling left, Lallana or Welbeck right, Rooney & Sturridge up top.
Paul Andrews
30 Posted 15/06/2014 at 09:35:30
Pirlo.

Now that's what you call a quarterback, Mr Gerrard.

The hype over Stevie being one of the best in Europe in that position is put to bed.

Andy Meighan
31 Posted 15/06/2014 at 09:31:04
Like I said last week, they'll be home before the postcards hit the mat.
Spragg Johnson
32 Posted 15/06/2014 at 09:55:57
All the papers' 'player ratings charts' are slamming Baines ... Yet in a second half devoid of creativity ONLY HE created a clear cut chance (which Rooney butchered) AND he delivered the only set piece strike of any quality ... On target and forcing a decent save. The corners by Rooney and Gerrard were awful ... Get LB on the job!
Ian Bennett
33 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:03:25
Gerrard and Henderson should have swapped positions. Gerrard was way too slow to get across to help Baines, whilst Rooney looks so devoid of energy and pace, sulking on the left in the first half. Gerrard gets away with it from his media chums, whilst Rooney was poor and only the assist saved him from a complete shocker.

Johnson had a lot of the ball on the right, but his delivery was poor. Baines didn't have his best game, and allowed too many crosses coming in, but, he was offered very little protection at all.

Jon Withey
35 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:17:58
Countless Baines overlapping runs were ignored - don't know why they bothered putting him in the team if they don't use his most dangerous asset.

I'm not sure what left-back is going to be able to deal with two international class players running at them with no cover.

Feel Baines was let down all night to be honest.

Enjoyed watching Sterling (sorry), Sturridge (sorry) and Wellbeck play with ball at feet - but I think Lallana and Barkley create more telling passes - without them it was like we had no link-up in midfield at all - just counter-attacking.

Mike Allison
36 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:23:14
Every single pass Baines received was behind him not ahead, forcing him to stop and ultimately giving him no option but to go backwards.

In fact most of those passes were players trying to ignore him and do something themselves, before admitting defeat and dumping it off to him as a last resort.

If England want to get the best out of Baines, they need someone like Lallana on the left of midfield, he's the closest to replicating the way Pienaar plays and is more likely to play the one-twos that have brought so much success.

Mike Allison
37 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:26:31
"He showed everything that Gerrard isn't." Absolutely. I lost count of the number of times an England defender or midfielder had the ball and Gerrard was nowhere near, 30 yards away, looking in the other direction. Gerrard's job is to constantly be available for a pass, and he wasn't doing it.
Ian Bennett
38 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:25:57
I was looking at the last time Rooney performed in a major tournament. 2004, ten years ago when he had a great game against Switzerland and Croatia. Flat track bully?
Andy Codling
39 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:34:16
Rooney reminded me of Osman in the cup final when he offered fuck all protection to Hibbert. Criticism of Baines over the top.
Derek Knox
40 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:23:32
I too, feel Baines is getting slated for being exposed by those who should have been covering (Rooney, No 1 culprit).

Funny nobody mentions Glen Johnstone being constantly missing when defense was called upon, Jags also got slated, but if it wasn't for his goal line clearance, from Balotelli's brilliant chip, from the hole left by Johnstone by the way. the scoreline would have been worse!

Gerard and Henderson were woeful at best, maybe I am a bit biased but watching the replays have convinced myself, that those comments are justified!

Like a previous poster mentioned, giving Gobshite Gerrard the Captain's role was a mistake, so he is by virtue of that, almost undroppable!

All the young guns played well and showed most of the more senior players up as being not good enough!

Dave Williams
41 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:28:36
I thought Sturridge was very good and Sterling was excellent in first half but he tired badly in second. The main problem for me was Rooney who was dreadful; it was like playing with ten men. Gerrard has rarely if ever played well for England and, as someone posted above, Pirlo showed him how that role should be played. He was constantly moving into space whereas Gerrard was stood still. Jags was decent I thought and I felt sorry for Leighton who was left too exposed against class players.

If Roy is bold, he will drop Rooney and play Lallana and also drop Henderson and play Wilshere. I'd keep Ross on the bench for now and play him from the start if we have to win the third game.

Oh and maybe Milner for Johnson – can't be any worse!

Kevin Tully
42 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:36:45
Those 40 yard balls from Gerrard out to the wings may look good, but the receiving player is more often than not stranded so the play has to come back for others to catch up. Did Pirlo play this way? Did he fuck - incisive short balls through the middle that were actually effective because the ball never took an age to drop out of the Sky.

I told you what would happen with Barkley - typical English mentality, wait until you are behind before bringing him on to chase the game.

Baines was left exposed because potato head Rooney was blowing out of his arse after 10 minutes and Hodgson doesn't have the plums to drop him, or give him a fucking.

Anyway, feeling smug after backing Italy to win. Roy and his overhyped, overrated millionaires will soon be back on the plane.

Mike Green
43 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:38:33
If Baines wants to be classed the best left back in the country he shouldn't need protection, he's a defender FFS!

Two games to go, we'll be OK.

Kev Johnson
44 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:34:57
I'm with Jon (35) and Mike (36). Baines was badly let down by Rooney, who either could not be arsed to cover him or doesn't know how to. Put Lallana ahead of him and Baines will do the business. Even Welbeck or Milner will put in a shift, allowing him to get forward.

Henderson looked busy in the first half and did his job, but as Mike (37) says, Gerrard should have been showing for a pass all the time and he was absolutely effing nowhere. Glen Johnson should be shot. For their second goal, Ferdinand/Shearer (I forget which) made the good point that Cahill would have been expecting GJ to be behind him, disrupting Balloteli's leap, but he'd gone for a wander somewhere. Bloody awful defender. Sturridge and Sterling justified their selection. Jags generally did well.

All in all, we've played worse and won/drawn. I'm gutted, but hoping we can take Uruguay apart. The best case scenario is that a half-fit Suarez starts but then immediately aggravates whatever dickhead injury he's got and has to be substituted, causing him to cry like a little girl and watch as we stroll to an emphatic victory.

Er, then we lose to Costa Rica.

Ian Bennett
45 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:58:57
Mike - So when Baines was regularly picking up 2 players, what is he meant to do in that situation? I am sure Leighton would have asked Rooney and Gerrard to come across, but it looked like they were too big to do that role.
David Hallwood
46 Posted 15/06/2014 at 10:54:25
Can't agree with that Mike (#43). Everyone's having a go at either Baines or Rooney, but we've seen all season how 4-2-3-1 works, or supposed to work, and the onus is on the 2 holding midfielders to protect the back 4, as opposed to the old 2 banks of 4. How many times last season did you see McCarthy closing down or tracking back in wide areas.

The 3 in the middle are supposed to be attacking mids otherwise the lone striker gets isolated. I think given Gerrard's immobility – let's face it even though we all hate the bastard, he cannot be blamed for getting old – perhaps Hodgson needs to sacrifice an attacker and bring in Milner alongside Gerrard & Henderson, with 3 up front, with my preferred 3 being Sterling, Sturridge and the Ox.

Paul Gladwell
47 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:10:32
That gobshite Rio Ferdinand saying Baines should have been telling Rooney to track back!!! This is a £300k player we are talking about here, him and Steviela are untouchable, time and again when the big games come for England they dissapear and it's always others who the press decide to take it out on.
Kev Johnson
48 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:13:41
Phil Neville was the most boring co-commentator it's ever been my misfortune to encounter. Dismal, utterly dismal. I had to turn the sound down on occasions – and I don't even do that for the audio horror show that is Andy Townsend!
Patrick Murphy
49 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:31:38
All week we heard that England had a master plan to deal with Pirlo but, if they did, it didn't work as the Italian completed more passes (108) than any other player in any game in this tournament so far.
Peter Gorman
50 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:29:40
The inevitable 'Ashley Cole' question reared its ugly head – from the mouth of Gary Crisps about 2 mins after the final whistle. Do I not like that! At least Shearer came to the defence of Baines after Ferdinand meandered on about nothing.

What is the obsession with Cole? I hear it everywhere. It seems people have forgotten we can't actually win this tournament and it is about blooding a team for the future. If Baines needs dropping then Shaw is the name that should be on the pundits' lips FFS.

Patrick Murphy
51 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:54:55
As for the Baines debate – he didn't perform well last night but, as I said on the live forum, it just shows us as Evertonians how important Distin is to the Blues as he fills in on numerous occasions for Baines when he is caught out of position or too far up the pitch.
Mike Green
52 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:52:12
Ian – if you want to take that line argument you can extend it by asking WTF is Rooney doing playing left wing? He's not a winger, never mind a defensive midfielder.

Call me old-fashioned but Baines's job is to defend his goal, anything else is secondary.

Jamie Crowley
53 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:54:29
Watched the game with my son, wife, and another family. We all agreed England outplayed Italy and didn't deserve the loss.

Personally I think England has an excellent team. The fangs that come out from their faithful followers when they lose is baffling to me.

I'm sorry, but the criticism and negativity from English supporters weighs heavy on this team – and that seems to be the MO for England.

Phil Sammon
54 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:54:14
A quick scan of the papers and Baines seems to be getting quite a lot of grief. The funny thing is that they all use the same word, 'overloaded'. Now correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think there's much an individual can do if they are being overloaded. Surely Roy, Rooney and the defensive midfielders should be the ones getting the grief for allowing such a situation to occur.

I stupidly allowed myself a look at The Gruniad's website and found Jagielka reviewed at 5/10 'out of his depth' apparently, while Gary Cahill was afforded a 7/10. I know football is subjective and I know it shouldn't bother me... but Jesus Christ, what game were they watching?

Gerrard did nothing. A DM who can't break up play. His only weapon is the long ball, which for some reason he cannot pull off in an England shirt. I mean he's proved that for over a decade now... but let's persist with it, shall we. The man is undroppable sadly, and no amount of poor performances will change that.

Ian Bennett
55 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:03:29
Mike - agreed. He doesn't make my team, and I am shocked by how much he went down hill last season. His spark has gone.
Sam Hoare
56 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:00:50
Even though we lost I was pleasantly surprised at how well we played. Italy had very few chances and we should have had at least one more goal from some of the positions we got into.

Baines was exposed at time due to lack of covering mobility from gerrard and Rooney but he still did well going forward and served up what should have been the equaliser for Rooney.

If we carry on playing like that I think we should beat Uruguay (who are very ordinary without Suarez) and Costa Rica. Having said that I thought we would beat Italy so am obviously blinded by optimism!

Jamie Crowley
57 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:05:43
I agree 100% with Sam Hoare...
Richard Lyons
58 Posted 15/06/2014 at 11:51:57
Kev (#43), you're right - Phil Neville must have been on a valium drip feed (as he probably was while playing midfield for us). Constant inane comments delivered in monotone.

I think Henderson was mentioned by name about 3 times, the last of them being when he was replaced by Wilshere. I actually thought Johnson at least made attempts to create space and had some attacking intent, but of course he was being properly supported on the right by Sturridge (or was it maybe Henderson, which would make my earlier point less valid); and he was absolutely crap in defence.

Damian Halligan
59 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:14:59
Felt sorry for Leighton. He had the classic dilemma - do you take the wide man or the inside forward. Seemed to fall between the two and seems increasingly suspect against pace. Because of my age I can never figure out any of the modern systems but would have thought it should be worked out before hand. Also not helped by not having an old-fashioned proper left midfielder with who Baines is playing regularly.
Dennis Stevens
60 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:18:35
Apparently Neville has been slaughtered on Twatter - there's a piece in the Independent

www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/worldcup/if-a-wild-bean-cafe-pasty-could-talk-england-fans-hit-twitter-to-mock-phil-nevilles-commentary-debut-9538145.html

I rather liked : "If I was stranded on a desert island with a tin of corned beef and Phil Neville I would eat Phil Neville and talk to the corned beef."

Jamie Barlow
61 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:18:09
I'd rather have Neville, however bad he is, over Clarke Carlisle. He is one boring fucker. 10 minutes of him and I'm looking for the razor blades.
Patrick Murphy
62 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:26:27
I'm not sure I agree that Italy didn't create many chances - they scored twice, had one cleared off the line and twice hit the woodwork.
Kevin Tully
63 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:34:56
Anyone watching MotD on now? It's up to Baines to tell potato head how to play the fecking game!!

Speechless...

Phil Sammon
64 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:35:04
Jamie

What is it about Clark Carlisle that makes you want to shave so badly?

Jim Knightley
65 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:33:34
Italy had chances of course, but we were good value for a point, and dominated more in attacking areas even if we did not create enough clear cut chances.

I do not understand the consistent criticism of Rooney: he was played out of position, and still created the goal with a perfect pass. Why would Barkley start above him, when Rooney, even after a poor season by his standard, as consistently produced more goals and assists than his younger counterpart?

I also do not understand why Rooney was played on the left, with Welbeck in team. I would have thought it would have made more sense to play Welbeck there, if he is going to make the team, as he tracks back well. Then put Sterling right, and Rooney behind the striker.

I’d like to see Wilshere or Lallana in next match, as they give us more creativity. I also think this match exposed the lack of a genuine DM in our squad. Barry would have been preferable to Henderson in my opinion, even if he lacks mobility and is a poorer footballer.

Eugene Ruane
66 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:13:42
Always makes me laugh that at this (finals) level, England still think they don’t win games like this because of things like luck.

"Maybe if we’d just had a bit of..."

Had fucking what?

The ’rub of the green’, a little bit of ’luck in the final third’?

As long as the F.A and supporters continue to buy into this nonsense, nothing will change.

EVERY team can talk about luck and ’if only..’

If Pirlo’s shot hadn’t hit the bar, if Jags hadn’t cleared off the line, if...

To me Italy looked like they were playing well within themselves and they still could have scored 4/5 (nb: ’with a bit of luck’).

As for the youngsters, well I know this will sound biased but I think Barkley is a team player and Sterling looks like a dead good playground player.

How many blind alleys did he run down yesterday? (Same applies to Johnson.) First 20 mins the Italians had a few problems with pace but they soon adapted.

Winning in big games is about having a plan, England’s appeared to be blindly running at seasoned defenders, Italy’s was find a man, pass-move, find a man, and WORK an opening rather than hope an opening would appear.

Patrick Murphy
67 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:42:31
Eugene you’ll never get a job on the BBC panel but you make plenty of valid points.
Sam Hoare
68 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:31:09
Patrick, it’s all arguable of course but I would say their first goal was a half chance from a way out, pirlos free kick even more so as it was about 35 yards out and their other post shot was a tame one from an angle that Hart had well covered.

I really don’t think they had many good opportunities and I can’t remember Hart making a save all night unlike their keeper who made at least 2 or 3 good saves.

Chris Leyland
69 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:53:07
It seems to have become fashionable to say that England are weak at the back. Where England were weak last night was in the midfield with Gerrard and Henderson offering absolutely no protection in front of the back 4. If you contrast them with Everton last year, McCarthy and Barry gave plenty of protection to the defence, not least of which was their protection to the full backs.

Baines was left stark bollock naked by Gerrard and Henderson and Rooney last night time and time again. How the fuck the manager didn’t do anything about it sooner amazed me. Lallana on the left would have offered so much more protection and would not constantly have been drawn into the middle without one of Henderson or Gerrard bothering to cover.

Patrick Murphy
70 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:59:39
How lucky you are in the USA to have proper footballing people Ballack, Van Nistleroy and of course Roberto giving their opinions about the game.

I just saw a clip on the Echo website where Roberto is saying that too many times Baines was faced with two players and that it shouldn’t have been allowed to happen and that was in the main the reason Italy won.

Raymond Fox
71 Posted 15/06/2014 at 12:28:49
Where’s Tahir 27 gone, I want to know?

I agree with almost everything that’s been said since! I turned the commentary off in 2 minutes, who auditioned Neville?

I’ve watched England since and including 1966 and 95% of the time they have been a embarrassment and lacking in the basic skills!

If anyone is over-rated, it’s that ’great player’ Gerrard, he never was great and never will be great, he’s always moderate when I watch him.

This team wasn’t and didn’t in my opinion deserve to lose, we scared them to death for periods. You need to put the ball in the net though, but in no way was it a bad performance!

Jamie Crowley
72 Posted 15/06/2014 at 13:05:42
Patrick we have to suffer Alexi Lallas but in the main yes, the coverage is excellent.

It’s interesting - when Roberto talks everyone shuts up and listens. Even Ballack who’s very confident seems to not even think about was his opinion is when Roberto speaks. He commands a level of respect from some folks with pretty impressive football backgrounds.

And every point he makes is accurate and many are much "deeper" than the superficial analysis you get from others.

Kevin Tully
73 Posted 15/06/2014 at 13:08:37
Spot on Chris - the midfield were all looking after their own game and didn’t sacrifice a yard to protect the defence.

As soon as Gerrard got hold of it, the first thing on his mind was a ’Hollywood’ out to the wings. Fat arse Martin Samuel marked Gerrard a 7 - the joint highest mark for any English player. Incredible.

Damian Braithwaite
74 Posted 15/06/2014 at 13:11:41
Patrick Murphy 51# spot on about Baines and Distin, for a 35-year-old, Distin’s still got the legs and the brain to get us out of trouble and Baines really missed him last night. If he knew someone would be covering his arse, it would have been a different result.

Unfortunately Hodgson does not know how to utilise his skills. I lost count of how many times Darmean was out on his own and it looked like they always had an extra man, which leads me to believe someone was not doing their job in covering Baines but alas the media and the pundits all need a scapegoat.

I do think its time Rooney was either played in his best position or retired from international duty. If he and Sterling had swapped places, it might have given Baines some respite.

Paul Andrews
75 Posted 15/06/2014 at 13:28:13
Chris Leyland,

That’s exactly how it went. The commentator and experts on the panel blamed Baines at one time for not talking to Rooney. He was that far away from Baines he wouldn’t have heard him anyway.

Gerrard who was on the left of the two screening players never once tacked over to help Leighton out.

Kevin Tully, fat arse Samuels watches a different game to everyone else

Brian Hennessy
76 Posted 15/06/2014 at 13:56:11
On the TV coverage of last night’s game.

I switched between BBC and RTE (Ireland) a few times and I have to say there was no comparison. BBC coverage had no atmosphere from the crowd compared to RTE, it was like watching a different match.

Watching Dunphy Giles and Brady was 100 times more entertaining than Ferdinand, Henry and Shearer, and Ray Houghton a million times better than Phil Neville.

For those in the UK complaining about BBC not giving an honest analysis of Steven Gerrard’s performance, the three Irish pundits who seldom agree on anything, all slated Gerrard and all said he should not be picked again for England but all agreed that he will be the first name on Hodgson’s teamsheet.

I would be the first to complain about RTE but have to say their coverage of this World Cup is streets ahead of BBC or ITV

Eugene Ruane
77 Posted 15/06/2014 at 14:09:33
Sam (68) - "I really don’t think they had many good opportunities and I can’t remember Hart making a save all night unlike their keeper who made at least 2 or 3 good saves"

Again, this suggests just a matter of hard lines.

I believe hard luck doesn’t come into it.

You say you don’t think Italy had ’many’ good opportunities.

Well...they certainly weren’t leathering speculative shots every five minutes or charging about up blind alleys, but when you play a more thoughtful game and have a plan, you don’t need many ’opportunities’.

Instead you try and unlock a defence and work an opening.

And if you can keep possession while attempting this, and have players who can play to a (good/effective) plan, chances are you’ll create 5/6 good chances.

If you can do that and stick half of those chances away, you’ll more than likely get the three points.

I’ve been watching (not supporting) England for more than 40 years and if I had to choose one word to sum up 40 years of performances/tactics/support/the F.A/managers, it would be..dumb.

One more thing, this (imo) was (yet) another example of us producing too many ’athletes’ and not enough footballers.

Pirlo V Gerrard a good example, huff puff & sweat V brains touch & vision.

That for me is why Italy won and why I believe they would probably win 9 out of 10 times in games that mattered.

Mark Frere
78 Posted 15/06/2014 at 15:20:18
I agree with Eugene. Two European teams inparticular - Germany and Italy - have been so successful in tornaments because they both have an uncanny knack of being able to just do what’s required to win. Often the football hasn’t mezmorizing but both sides find a way to win when not at their best.

Teams such as Brazil, and more recently Spain have been successful because technically they were far superior to the rest.

England has never excelled in any of these departments. That’s why we have always been ’the nearly team’.

Sam Hoare
79 Posted 15/06/2014 at 16:02:22
Eugene, I know what you mean but I genuinely think England were the better team last night and I don’t think Italy did have 5/6 good chances. In fact their first goal and Pirlos free kick were ’speculative shots’ from where I was sitting.

Italy were clinical and well organised and have a knack of grinding out results in major tournaments that we do not. Pirlo is a master and they do have some great footballers but for once we have some decent technical players and I think there were many things to be positive about from an English point of view that there were not in the last few tournaments.

Paul Andrews
80 Posted 15/06/2014 at 16:16:42
Sam,

The first goal came from a training ground set piece, not a speculative shot.

The Pirlo free kick was a master class in how to strike a ball to make it dip and swerve.

Kevin Tully
81 Posted 15/06/2014 at 16:25:11
Feck England anyway, the likes of Baines & Jagielka have been hung out to dry because they don’t play for a moneyed club where press freebies are the order of the day.

The fixtures are out on Wednesday - that’s all I’m arsed about.

Peter Mills
82 Posted 15/06/2014 at 16:28:49
England Shmengland.
Linda Morrison
83 Posted 15/06/2014 at 16:36:13
Kevin’s right about the 2 Everton lads. To cheer you up I heard a discussion on Radio 5 this morning and they did mention the elephant in the room. Baines was exposed, not due to Rooney, but by the fact there was no effective midfield.

Most of the papers, with the exception of The Observer, put the two Everton players on 5 out of 20.
Jags cleared at least 1 definite, probably 2 goals, off the line what more are they expected to do?

It’s another goldfish bowl and, instead of looking at the positives from the two lads, they look for faults to blame the loss on them instead of where the fault lies, if there are any. I’ll be glad when it’s all over and I certainly think Baines will.

Bottom line is they don’t think the two lads should be there. God help the manager when the team comes home.

Guy Hastings
84 Posted 15/06/2014 at 16:43:08
Very surprised at Gerrard last night; as usually, he can’t wait to kick lumps out of anything in a blue shirt.
Craig Mills
85 Posted 15/06/2014 at 17:43:33
My opinion, I thought Jags did a good job at defending, ie, his job in the team, I didn’t think he lookede out of place and he didn’t let his team mates down; no cause for any concern there.

Ross also did well when he came on, he was confident and adapted with ease; no cause for concern with him either.

Baines to me looked like a fish out of water; yes, there was no cover; yes, Rooney didn’t help at all, nor did Gerrard etc but Baines had zero confidence on the ball. It looked to me as though he didn’t want it; when he did get it, 90% of the time it was passed straight back to whom he’d just received it from. There was no intent in his passing and he didn’t want to get forward. He should’ve been screaming at Rooney/Gerrard to organise some cover, but he didn’t, and now he’s taking the flak for it, I’m not sure he will start the next game...

Colin Glassar
86 Posted 15/06/2014 at 17:51:56
Is it any coincidence that the three worst English players last night (Gerard, Rooney and Johnson) are veterans of several failed campaigns? Does their negativity, and hesitancy, rub off on the rest of the players?
Patrick Murphy
87 Posted 15/06/2014 at 17:57:16
Going back to the Phil Neville co-commentator debacle Frankie Boyle tweeted "Phil Neville could make Zippity Doo Dah sound like a diagnosis for a terminal disease". Another supporter wrote "If the entire stadium burns down, Phil will mumble "Well, that’s what flames can do. If they’re not marked."
Sam Hoare
88 Posted 15/06/2014 at 18:13:12
Paul 80, stating the obvious there and since when do training ground moves or good ball strikes not mean it is speculative? For me any shot outside the area is probably speculative as they will miss more often than not. Pirlo would probably expect to score a free kick from that range 1 in 10 at best.
Raymond Fox
89 Posted 15/06/2014 at 18:07:22
Linda, it wont bother Roberto one jot.
He’ll tell them go out there and show any critics what jerks they are.
That’s assuming that there are still critics out there, there a lot football still to play.

Leighton is nailed on to start the next game, Woy is not daft enough to start with Shaw, if he is I give up altogether.
It was obvious that Baines was left to defend against 2 oncoming Italians on his own!

Raymond Fox
90 Posted 15/06/2014 at 18:43:09
It’s marvellous though isn’t it, Gerrard’s captain why isn’t HE shouting at Rooney to defend the left side, or equally as good, block the left side himself.

Its as if he’s bulletproof, someone started mistakenly calling him a great player and now nobody wants to disagree.

Colin Glassar
91 Posted 15/06/2014 at 18:58:05
Patrick, Pip’s ’commentary skills’ have become an instant legend on social media. His voice reflects his style of play I.e. dull, monotonous, boring, lacklustre, lifeless, clueless, moronic, dismal, abject, bland etc....... I can’t wait for the next installments but I doubt it will ever happen again.
Jamie Barlow
92 Posted 15/06/2014 at 19:00:13
Gerard and Baines both gave Rooney a mouthful for not doing his job.

Peter Knight
93 Posted 15/06/2014 at 18:58:38
I thought a draw was a fair result. Italy’s first goal, Sturridge was at fault and, if Johnson had been on the post, the goal would not have gone in.

The second goal, Cahill was at fault and Johnson was nowhere to be seen. Baines also had to take a corner from the right side and get back to mark two players on the left side. Baines gave a good pass to Rooney and you have to score in that position.

Brian Harrison
94 Posted 15/06/2014 at 19:20:04
I think last night’s game can be summed up as 2 very average teams neither will get past the quarter finals. Now you can see why there is so few Englishmen playing in the Premier League and the ones that are are distinctly average.
Brian Hennessy
95 Posted 15/06/2014 at 19:37:29
Pirlo must love playing against England, good as he is I can never remember any other team giving him so much space to control a game like he loves to do.

For those ToffeeWebers unlucky enough to only have the English media to listen to, Riche Sadlier and Ronnie Whelan have just torn shreds off Gerard on RTE tonight, adding to the panel’s thoughts on Stevie Me last night.

Helen Mallon
96 Posted 15/06/2014 at 19:52:29
Mike Green you must be so drunk
Paul Andrews
97 Posted 15/06/2014 at 21:50:52
Trainer to World Cup squad.

"I want you to practice this move from a corner for the next 20 minutes. If it all goes to plan we might end up with a speculative shot"

Obviously

Richard Reeves
99 Posted 15/06/2014 at 22:23:50
I don’t understand why Hodgson has to over-complicate things. As far as I can see, England are more creative and threatening when they play the right players in their best positions.

England are a better team with Barkley behind the striker; Sterling is better suited to the right side and Lallana is better on the left and would create far more problems for the opposition than what Rooney can do. Sturridge should play up front and Wilshere should definitely partner someone in that defensive midfield area, whether that is Gerrard or Henderson I don’t know but Wilshere should be first choice over either of those two as he is important to the build up play and links well with Barkley, one of the few that actually passed to him yesterday.

Iain Johnston
100 Posted 15/06/2014 at 22:39:12
I thought Leighton looked far more comfortable when an established left sided player was brought on... Lallana, he started to overlap and cross.

Thierry Henry summed it up well when he said " If you don’t play your best number 10 in that position, why play him at all...?"

Rooney needs to be in the middle with Sterling and Lallana either side, when they’ve run themselves into the ground, we’ve got Chamberlain Ross and Milner to replace them...

I’d rather see Leighton or Shaw at LM rather than Rooney or Welbeck.

Sam Hoare
101 Posted 15/06/2014 at 22:59:19
Trainer to World Cup squad.

"Let’s practice this move for 20 minutes that will end with a shot from 30 yards that will definitely go in and is in no way speculative. What? It might not go in? Oh. Yes, I do know what speculative means. I think. It’s to do with glasses right?"

Raymond Fox
102 Posted 16/06/2014 at 01:50:59
Linda, sorry that I misunderstood your post, I jumped to the conclusion that you meant that if Jags and Leighton came back to us with their confidence shattered/dented what would Roberto do.
Less scotch, and reading posts better will help!

Although I’ve no doubt you’ve noticed, how rivetingly special my posts usually are ! (In case anyones wondering that’s my attempt at humour!)

David Ellis
103 Posted 16/06/2014 at 02:05:04
I have watched a lot of England games at World Cups starting in ’82. This England team is technically stronger than for many years. Twenty years of having a quality domestic league is finally paying off. Italy were better, but then why would n’t they be? I think England will go through. I think Hodgson has been pretty brave with his selections. My beef is more with the English press than the manager.

I would go with Lallana on the left to get the best out of Baines (attacking and defending). Move Rooney to the middle behind the excellent Sturridge. Put Stirling on the right. This would be harsh on Welbeck who played well, but he was to make way. I do think Rooney remains our best bet at No.10.

Midfield - I wish Barry was there to play DCM on the left side. But I can see why Henderson is in the team, he is the England McCarthy and you need players like that. Gerard...Don’t think he should be there - cannot tackle, does not take enough responsibility, and has lost his engine. But Wilshire is off form and Barry is not on the plane so we seem to be struggling in that position.

Defenders are OK - apart from Johnson but I would stick with him. I don’t think he was at fault for the second goal because he was tracking another player into the centre. It was a perfect cross because the Italians had time to make the cross because Baines had a 2 on one to deal with. Cahill lost his man Balotelli and that was that.

However I think England have enough attacking juice to get them through. Expect a quarter final exit - which for a team ranked in the top 10 is about right.

James Peter
104 Posted 16/06/2014 at 05:51:41
Apologies if this has been covered as I never had the time to read all the comments. So pleased to come on and realise I’m not going mad.

Gerrard sweeping useless balls over to the flanks compared to Pirlo who ’drove’ their team forward. A true captain. Gerrard ’Didn’t wanna know’ as my arm fella used to say.

Rooney was awful and I agree with Henri, if you’re going to play someone, play him in position. A left mid may not have needed to have been as good a player as Rooney but he could have protected Barnes and snuffed out that easy 2nd goal conceded. He may have also linked up with Barnes more and given more attacking opportunities than one good ball.

On to my biggest bug bare. Did anybody notice Gerrard blatantly NOT giving the ball to Ross? Always feeding his team mates? Did it ever enter into his head why the Italians conceded space to Johnson, and THAT ball?? How much time was wasted in that area creating nothing.

Yes, I don’t like Liverpool but Sterling was excellent. Sturridge was good too. I can’t help feeling that if Gerrard would have fed Barks to come on and do what he was brought for we may have equalised.

Gerrard out. Nasty, sly, cheating git he is. Captain of our country by the way!

Paul Andrews
105 Posted 16/06/2014 at 06:14:54
Trainer to World Cup squad.... "Anyone seen my glasses? The shot was from 30 yards out?"
Sam Hoare
106 Posted 16/06/2014 at 08:37:54
World Cup squad to trainer.

"You don’t need glasses boss, you just need to know that the penalty box arc is 25 yards from goal and he was a couple of yards behind that. Have you actually played this game before gaffer? Who did you coach before this?"

Andrew Ellams
107 Posted 16/06/2014 at 08:56:56
David Ellis, England players may have improved technically but nowhere near as much as other teams. Every top team has playmakers that England could only dream of. Which other coach in this World Cup would play a below standard workhorse like Welbeck ahead of a player like Barkley? Absolutely clueless.
Paul Andrews
108 Posted 16/06/2014 at 10:00:35
"I don’t need glasses either gaffer,I do need an abacus though."

25 + 2 = 27

"Get the spray out, ref, they have pinched 3 yards"

Jim Bennings
109 Posted 16/06/2014 at 09:56:10
Rooney is way past his best, quite what United were thinking when handing him that mega deal is beyond me.

They could have used that to go towards a genuine World Class player rather than a sluggish player who had been at the same club too long and no longer has the sharpness or hunger. I wouldn’t pay more than £10 million for Rooney these days.

He is not the player that burst onto the scene at Everton, obviously at 17 he was a sharper, hungrier and more mobile player than now, but he just doesn’t really look that good anymore.

He has no pace, the turn of foot and sharpness has gone and I believe too much has been made of his effort and workrate, it’s taken something away from Wayne Rooney the goalscorer in my opinion, too much work on deep positions.

Jim Bennings
110 Posted 16/06/2014 at 10:42:32
Call me old fashioned but I just like to see my striker playing no more than 25 yards from goal, I just can’t subscribe to all this "oh he works so well for the team even though he doesn’t score many". It’s ridiculous.

Why do you need your striker doing what Rooney is doing? Double marking with the fullback?

There are other players in the team who can help defensively. Rooney is not the player he was but he has spent too long being wasted by playing too much defence-minded football and not enough where he can actually hurt the opposition.

Kevin Tully
111 Posted 16/06/2014 at 10:58:48
Until England managers can see through the hype that surround the big clubs, they are doomed to mediocrity. Do they ever wonder to themselves that maybe it’s the foreign players in their club sides that make these English lads look better than they actually are?

Look at Rooney, he looks awful every time he pulls on an England shirt, but his finest days were playing alongside Ronaldo. Van Persie pulls defenders everywhere which leaves him room to score for Man Utd. Add the fact the likes of City or Chelsea usually have 60-70% possession in games, and it’s no wonder they all look like world class players. The same goes for Gerrard & Lampard – I’m sure I could knock a long ball over the top for Suarez or Drogba to finish.

They are all good Premier League players, but they are hyped far beyond their capabilities, and the truth is exposed once they pull on an England shirt.

Sam Hoare
112 Posted 16/06/2014 at 11:20:35
Paul 108. Ha! One of the more trivial debates we’ve had. I’d still say a shot from 27 yards (or was it perhaps 27.5 which would round up to 30) could be legitamately described as speculative.
Eugene Ruane
113 Posted 16/06/2014 at 11:15:39
Start of a new series "Jim Bennings on..."

1) Van Gogh

"Shite, basically overrated, the stuff he paints looks all wobbly. Someone paid £100m for them flowers? Pfft! More money than sense"

Make your mind up Jim.

In post 110 (re Rooney) you say "he has spent too long being wasted by playing too much defence minded football and not enough where he can actually hurt the opposition".

Question, wherever he’s played, how is he going to hurt the opposition if he’s (as you state in 109) "way past his best" and "a sluggish player" and "no longer has the sharpness or hunger" and "has no pace" and "the turn of foot and sharpness has gone"???

Sorry, but contradictory nonsense.

By the way, for someone with ’no pace’, two Italian defenders couldn’t catch him to stop him getting his cross in for the goal.

Kev Johnson
114 Posted 16/06/2014 at 11:23:58
KT – when you say you’re "sure" that you knock a long ball over the top for Suarez or Drogba to finish, do you mean you could do it once out of every thousand attempts?

OK, while we’re playing hypothetical football, I am 100% certain that I could get on the end of one of your hoofs - er, sorry, long balls - and bang the ball into the onion net. That’s 100% as in 0.1%.

Who’s playing in goal, by the way? Ruane? No way - he’s a natural trequartista. Once you start playing people out of position you’re asking for trouble...

Andrew Ellams
115 Posted 16/06/2014 at 11:39:27
Why not play Rooney as the central striker and drop Sturridge. If you have Barkley, Sterling and Oxlade-Chamberlain running at the Uruguayan and Costa Rican back fours, you are going to get free kicks all day long and probably red cards too.

Tough on Sturridge, I know, but that’s life.

Tony Abrahams
116 Posted 16/06/2014 at 11:45:00
Henry is right, only the English would play THEIR BEST PLAYER on the flank to defend. I do think Rooney is struggling but he is under enormous pressure from The Media, so Woy puts him on the wing, to be hung out to dry.

Nobody should keep their place after a performance like Gerrard gave, but I expect him to play again.

England didn’t play badly, but the manager let them down badly, and yet the press are praising him for being brave? It was like Moyes’s last game in charge of Man Utd when every time Everton were in trouble, they just switched the play to Coleman, who always had 30 yards of space.

No flexibility cost England badly. some might say that’s dumb and who could argue? Hodgson one of the highest paid managers in the World Cup, got to half-time unscathed, and never changed anything!

It’s one thing having the players, but surely you should only earn top money if you know how to use them.

Derek Knox
117 Posted 16/06/2014 at 12:15:57
Hello fellow TW’ers.

Slightly off thread, but am rather curious as to the lack of postings during this World Cup, from Harold Matthews.

I do hope he is well and maybe just gone on holiday or something, but I do know Harold is an avid fan of Everton, first and foremost, but also football in general.

I am looking forward to the USA game for two reasons, the first being our obvious connection through Tim, but also to see Mix Diskerud if he plays! It was Harold who drew my attention to this player (he looks to be pretty skilful) and he also alerted Everton as one to look out for long before the World Cup started!

Anyone know of Harold’s wellbeing please let the site know, as he is a long-standing and respected Evertonian with a good football knowledge and input to this site!

Thanks in anticipation!

Craig Walker
118 Posted 16/06/2014 at 12:18:26
I’m not an England fan and always like watching the other nations play at World Cups. I have to say though that the performance on Saturday was the best I can remember by an England team. He picked youth over the old cronies. They kept the ball much better than we’ve seen.

Normally, England are caught in possession more times than Lindsay Lohan. They also attacked with speed. The main problem England have though is that they are unable to play at a different pace. They can’t slow the game down and play in bursts. All of the best teams can do this. I think a lot of that is because of the Premier League and the way the game is played here.

Pirlo deserves more plaudits than he gets. It’s amazing he isn’t in the running for World Player of the Year more often. He strolls about like he’s playing in his slippers but can do it all. A couple of times he got in situations where he had England players all around him and just majestically moved the ball past them or found a blue shirt instinctively. The whole team trust him with the ball anywhere on the pitch.

I don’t subscribe to the view that England gave him time and space. He finds time and space! He is constantly available and does more running than you think getting into areas and pulling away from opponents. His dummy for the opening goal was reminiscent of Brazil in ’82. Andrea Pirlo (note his forename Phil Neville) is one of the true greats in the modern game if you ask me.

Kev Johnson
119 Posted 16/06/2014 at 12:32:07
"England are caught in possession more times than Lindsay Lohan." Ha-ha! Quality quip, Craig.
Roger Helm
120 Posted 16/06/2014 at 12:10:40
To win the World Cup, you need a few players who would get in a World XI, like we had in Banks, Moore and Charlton. Italy have the about the best goalkeeper in Buffon, the best CM in Pirlo, and (when in the mood) one of the best CFs.

Italian defenders always do a good job, and doing just enough to win seems to be in the country’s DNA. So to lose narrowly to a team who may end up winning the trophy is no disgrace.

For England, it’s just a shame we have players either too inexperienced (Sturridge, Sterling, Barkley) or too over the hill (Rooney, Gerard, Lampard) to have a chance of doing well.

The media get worse and worse. Alan Hansen in the Telegraph today wrote a long article explaining why we should have had Cole at LB – not a word about Baines being left unprotected by our useless midfield.

Jim Bennings
121 Posted 16/06/2014 at 12:38:18
Eugenie

He is past his best but like with any player, even at Everton for example, Steven Naismith, a player can be limited but if you play him where he is meant to play, he will give you more than if you waste him by reducing what few powers he has by sticking him out of position.

Rooney is not the player of 5 years ago. But he could still have more impact playing behind the striker than being stuck on the wing.

Again, I refer to Everton. If we go back to playing Steven Naismith on the right of midfield next season you are going to see a player that the fan’s will quickly dislike, the effort will be there, the effect won’t be.

Shane Corcoran
122 Posted 16/06/2014 at 12:45:04
Derek, I may be wrong but I think I remember Harold announcing his retirement from ToffeeWeb. A few attempts were made to bring him back from the brink but alas they were met with silence.

Perhaps he’s still reading and can be reached out to.

Derek Knox
123 Posted 16/06/2014 at 12:50:44
Shane # 122

Thanks for that, mate! I must admit, I didn’t realise that our Harold "had hung up his boots from TW". I for one, and surely am not alone in that, do miss his input!

Let’s hope he comes out of retirement!

Thanks again, Shane!

Eugene Ruane
124 Posted 16/06/2014 at 13:35:38
Jim (121) - "He is past his best but like with any player, even at Everton for example, Steven Naismith, a player can be limited but if you play him where he is meant to play, he will give you more than if you waste him by reducing what few powers he has by sticking him out of position. Rooney is not the player of 5 years ago."

Well... fine but not sure the relevance of any of that as: a) I didn’t (and don’t) dispute he’s being played out of position; and b) I didn’t (and don’t) dispute the idea that he’s ’past his best’.

My point was that your posts were patently contradictory.

I repeat, I fail to see how a player, no matter where he’s played, can "actually hurt the opposition" if that player is "a sluggish player" and "no longer has the sharpness or hunger" and "has no pace" and "the turn of foot and sharpness has gone".

By the way, I think your reading of Rooney and his abilities are staggeringly wide of the mark – he may ’not be the player he was’ (nb: this can be applied at some stage to everyone who has ever played) but he’s still imo a great footballer and still better than most.

As for your less than £10m valuation, the market says that’s a 5th of a Torres and/or a 3rd of an Andy Carroll.

Yeah right.

Ste Traverse
125 Posted 16/06/2014 at 13:30:42
I’ve not read all this thread but so sorry if it’s been mentioned before but it’s unbelievable the bashing Baines is getting across the media.

The thing that keeps cropping up is that he has ’no CL experience’.

Oh so these press dickheads have suddenly decided you need CL experience to play in a World Cup? I wonder how many other players currently at the tournament haven’t got any?

Baines is getting it because 1) he got the nod over media darling Cashley Cole 2) he doesn’t play for a fashionable, moneyed club.

He got little protection from Rooney, but to be fair to him, he isn’t a left winger in a million years and doesn’t know that position. The manager needs to take his chunk of the blame.

That said, I didn’t think England deserved to lose. I’ve seen them play much worse than that in tournaments and nick wins.

Tony J Williams
126 Posted 16/06/2014 at 13:36:56
Rooney is not a winger, it’s as simple as that.

He is an attacking midfielder/striker.

Woy dropped a bollock by starting him on the wing and, as usual, the defender behind a player out of position suffers.

I am not saying I have the footballing nouse of The Special One, but even I know that if you put a forward on the wing, he isn’t going to play as well as, hmmmm let’s see? ... A winger!

Rooney is still a great player but he is being fucked by his managers of late in an attempt to placate him by giving him a starting spot no matter what or trying to placate another striker/attacking midfielder.

Baines was given no protection but that second goal has to be the blame of the fuckers in the middle not marking up, it’s not as if left/right backs are shite because a couple of crosses get by them, it’s going to happen quite often in a match. It’s then the job of the centre halves or opposite number to man up and get the ball away. The way Baines is getting raped in the papers and the other useless bags of shite are getting away with it is criminal.

As already said, Baines is getting criticised for not shouting at Rooney.... give me break! You shouldn’t need to tell a professional footballer to get into position.

I thought it was all set up wrong, as we were too deep and invited pressure, Johnston is cack but unfortunately there is no-one else and if Stevie Me laaaaa (No forehead) actually realised Baines is on the same side as him, he might actually deliver a decent pass to him. You know! One that is in front of him to run on to, not wait for the floated ball to travel 40 yards that he has to control on his chest and have the defender right in his face.

Rant over.... fucking Engerland... Fucking Redshites.

Patrick Murphy
127 Posted 16/06/2014 at 13:52:43
Perhaps Rooney thought he should be the captain of England given his medal haul compared to the rest of the squad?

Even if he didn’t, I would make him the captain and also play him down the middle where he belongs.

But all of this should really have been sorted out long before England arrived in Brazil.

Derek Knox
128 Posted 16/06/2014 at 14:18:51
I’d go along with that Patrick and agree that Rooney was well out of his best position, but also feel he would have made a better Captain than Captain Gobshite who, unfortunately by virtue of his undeserved role, becomes almost undroppable!
Andrew Ellams
129 Posted 16/06/2014 at 14:24:19
England don’t have a captain as far as I could see. No Robson, Adams or Butcher in the current side.
Roger Helm
130 Posted 16/06/2014 at 15:06:34
England will never win anything in all white. What happened to the navy blue shorts?
Kevin Tully
131 Posted 16/06/2014 at 14:49:13
Just watched a clip of the RTE pundits slating Gerrard. Funny how the press in this country are so deferential to that particular player and the club he plays for. He can do no wrong, one writer even marked him a seven out of ten – the same as Pirlo! At least the Telegraph writer was watching the same game as me.

Matt Law, The Telegraph ; Gerrard - 5 "The England captain was not as his best, as he struggled to keep up with Italy’s midfield and got caught in possession too often."

Matt Barlow, The Mail ; Gerrard - 7 "Strong and disciplined. Passed it as well as ever, and organised the team. Even shielded his centre-halves which is not always his strength."

How can two professional sports writers see 90 minutes of football so differently? Clear evidence some of them cannot bear to print a bad word about the dope.

Tony J Williams
132 Posted 16/06/2014 at 14:05:53
I agree Patrick, especially as the now Captain fantastic bottled it massively in the league.
Jim Knightley
133 Posted 16/06/2014 at 15:23:15
Jim..Rooney scored 17 goals, and made 10 assists, from 29 appearances this season. And he has managed those stats, despite his work rate.

Please explain how he is only worth 10million, and the nature of your criticism. Interestingly, Sturridge only scored four more goals, and made three less assists, in a much more attacking Liverpool side.

I think your comments typify a sensationalism which permeates the media, and stinks of a myopic perspective. Rooney is class, and he proves it every season in the Premier League to varying degrees. He is not world class, but he is the category below that, and if he was sold tomorrow, would fetch around £35million. I think England fans need to start supporting, and stop criticising, Rooney, because the pressure is getting to him. He was played completely out of position (how would RVP do on the left hand side of midfield? or Ibra?) for most of the match, and still produced a sublime assist for the Sturridge goal, and came within inches of equalising. Hodgson needs to put him behind the striker, or up top, to get the best from him, or else he might as well not be on the pitch.

Paul Andrews
134 Posted 16/06/2014 at 15:57:19
Sam,112

I hope you’re working my wages out this week.

Only a bit of fun, pal, no harm done.

Raymond Fox
135 Posted 16/06/2014 at 17:08:49
Gerrard will play every game while were in the tournament, unless he’s badly injured. Does not matter that he is shite, Woy made him captain! I’ve ranted about him in the thread already, so I wont go there again.

Criticising Baines is the presses soft option, because they would have be critical about Rooney or Stevie me otherwise. Added to the fact that few of them can come with an original judgement of their own, they would much prefer to follow the numb crowd!

Dennis Ng
136 Posted 16/06/2014 at 17:55:52
I was delighted to see RM talk about the game and as usual, he was spot on. Prandelli completely outwitted Hodgson. Sure, Rooney and Gerrard were average or below as were some others but nothing was done to help Baines from being attacked, player or manager wise.

Is Hodgson that naive to think that Italy will not keep attacking from the side that they have the most advantage? I remember the formation before the game and it was loaded on Baines’ side, right from the start! Not sure whether Prandelli prefer to pick off Baines more than Johnson or that the players operate way better on the right than the left but the main thing is, why didn’t Hodgson see that and make adjustments? It was like Prandelli played one way the whole game and Hodgson just didn’t do anything to try to beat that!

Rob Halligan
137 Posted 16/06/2014 at 17:49:51
Tony 126, how many times do you see Gerrard with an easy 10-15 yard pass to Baines on the left, totally ignored as Gerrard looks for one of his speculative 50-60 yard passes to his gobshite team mate Johnson on the right. Every game it happens.

It seems as if only there is no other pass possible will captain gobshite pass to bainesy. Felt really sorry for Baines on Saturday because he was given no protection at all. If Gerrard is such a fantastic captain, he should have been screaming at Rooney to track back, or do it himself as that where he seems to play now seeing as he’s lost all his pace.

Hopefully this will be his last tournament in an England shirt because he’s done fuck all in every other tournament!!

Colin Glassar
138 Posted 16/06/2014 at 18:09:18
If you want to know what went wrong just listen to what Cannavaro says on ITV. The man’s a genius.
Gerry Quinn
139 Posted 16/06/2014 at 19:08:32
Colin, a link would be appreciated - just chased up my own arse with that itv website
Colin Glassar
141 Posted 16/06/2014 at 19:41:23
Gerry, Cannavaro has said some hard truths about the England team. One of the things he said was that English players aren't prepared to leave everything on the pitch in tournaments. They are always trying to pace themselves, keeping something for the next game etc.... He said the top, top teams go out to win every game because lose one and you can be out of the competition. It's a chance of a lifetime and you have to grab it with both hands etc... According to Fabio the English players don't seem to understand this.
Danny Kewley
142 Posted 16/06/2014 at 19:51:06
Tim Cahill and everyone man jack of the Australian showed what you have got to do IE---put a fucking shift in!!
I mean not just a few but the whole team,especially the capitan!
Ant Dwyer
143 Posted 17/06/2014 at 01:55:10
In my view, Jags was England’s best defensive player by a mile! Baines didn’t exactly smother himself in glory, like... but I think he’s been harshly hung out to dry. For the goal, he did do some useless jump with his back turned like a schoolboy but at the same time he was left marking two men.

Although Rooney was also hammered for his lack of support of Baines, I can’t help but feel our defensive mid (Gerrard) was clearly the closest player available to help Baines and chose not too. His actions were typical of a player in an England side (and I say ’side’ and not ’team’ cos there’s no ’I’ in team), he was more interested in not being skinned than busting a gut to prevent a goal. I feel our midfield was torn apart and given a lesson by Pirlo. Gerrard and his minder (Henderson) were unable to stop him.

We need to be more dynamic if we want to make it out the group and bin Henderson or Gerrard (even both) and really go for it.

Anyways probably a waste of time discussing as Woy is a big shit house!!!!

Patrick Murphy
144 Posted 17/06/2014 at 16:34:40
Good to see that Roberto has paid his England players a visit and hopefully told them to ignore the negative press about them .

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb