This is the response I received having submitted my protest to the West Ham Stadium deal - for what it's worth.
The Government has responded to the petition you signed – “Hold public inquiry into West Ham & LLDC deal for rental of Olympic Stadium”.
Government responded:
West Ham United has a concession at the Stadium and their contributions reflect that status. The contract, awarded after an open public competition, has been widely scrutinised and tested in court.
Following the completion of its transformation programme the Stadium will be - unlike so many previous Olympic Stadiums - a world-class multi-use arena with a long-term future, and one that won’t require continuous support from the taxpayer. The stadium remains in public ownership (E20 Stadium LLP – a joint venture between the London Legacy Development Corporation and Newham Council) and the profits from its multiple uses will flow to the taxpayer.
As a long-term concessionaire West Ham United will only access the full stadium facilities for and shortly ahead of home matches, anticipated to be an average of 25 games a year. The stadium’s other anchor concession-holder, British Athletics, has a concession for one month a year. The stadium will be available for commercial and other uses at all times outside of these existing commitments.
The Stadium is a multi-use venue, which has already hosted a major athletics meet this year, the Sainsbury’s Anniversary Games, and will host a range of other events in 2015 including five matches during the Rugby World Cup this autumn, a Rugby League international between England and New Zealand and the Race of Champions motorsport event. In addition the Stadium will host elite athletics including the IAAF and IPC Athletics World Championships in 2017.
A world class stadium operator has been appointed and it is part of the operator agreement that the Stadium will host concerts and other events.
None of these events will financially benefit West Ham United. All revenues from these events will be shared by the operator and the Stadium owners. The stadium operator has a proven international track record of success in managing and maximising revenue from multi-use stadia and is contractually incentivised to generate maximum income.
The agreement with West Ham United, including their contribution to transformation costs and rent, followed an open competitive process, which was delivered under EU rules, conducted visibly and exposed to significant scrutiny. The outcome has been tested in the courts and upheld. As the winning bid this constituted the best available return for the taxpayer and secures the commercial viability of a national asset for the next 100 years.
The European Commission (EC) is responsible for assessing whether public investment distorts the competitive market. The EC has considered this issue on more than one occasion and has done so with full sight of the contractual terms, comprehensive detail of the tender exercise and in depth legal opinion on compliance with UK and EU law. It has found no case to answer. Therefore we do not believe that a public inquiry is necessary.
The detail of the rental agreement between the Stadium owners and West Ham United is commercially sensitive. Disclosing details of the contract would undermine the future negotiating position of the Stadium's operator, Vinci, who are working hard to bring in future events to get the greatest possible return and ensure that the Stadium is a commercial success.
It is important that the stadium owners and operator are able to negotiate future contracts in a way that derive maximum value and are not constrained by any one agreement. Such arrangements are standard practice and are designed to both protect the previous public expenditure and maximise the return on this investment.
Department for Culture, Media and Sport
Click this link to view the response online:
https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/106355?reveal_response=yes
The Petitions Committee will take a look at this petition and its response. They can press the government for action and gather evidence. If this petition reaches 100,000 signatures, the Committee will consider it for a debate.
The Committee is made up of 11 MPs, from political parties in government and in opposition. It is entirely independent of the Government. Find out more about the Committee: https://petition.parliament.uk/help#petitions-committee
Thanks,
The Petitions team
UK Government and Parliament
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Posted
05/09/2015 at
11:23:29
Part of the "cock-up" here is that EPL doesn't seem to allow clubs to groundshare. Example Spurs & Chelsea can't both rent Wembley at the same time to facilitate their ground changes (though I haven't looked into why). If that was possible then 2 clubs could both lease the converted stadium, and not necessarily just EPL clubs.
My issue isn't so much with West Ham (after all they didn't gain the facility by trickery, so far as we know) so much as the bloody waste of Public Money. The reported "conversion costs" for the brand new "multi user" stadium is comparable to the projected cost for a new football ground.
The Man City comparison is valid in some respects, but only some. As I recall the Commonwealth Stadium was designed with Man City's future occupancy in mind. The football pitch level is much lower than the athletic track level. This was done so that, following excavation, the perimeter could be much closer to pitch side.
Given that the Commonwealth Stadium conversion preceded the Olympic Stadium, why the fuck wasn't a similar common sense approach used in the design and subsequent occupancy?
Furthermore, Wembley sits bloody vacant having cost an astronomical amount but wasn't suitable for use for anything more than football during the Olympics. So there sit countless grass root football projects that will never ever see the light of day. Personally I thought that England played far far better in their matches played at EPL grounds anyway, plus many EPL grounds (with a painful exception) are more than capable of hosting Final, Semi-Final and Playoff ties admirably without a need for a "cash sink" standing bloody empty.
Now an EPL club stands to benefit from the Olympic legacy and had the FA not built the white elephant could easily have been one of the "leasees" of the converted ex-Olympic Stadium.
Rant over.
Cue Stealers Wheel "Stuck In The Middle With You".
Posted
05/09/2015 at
12:48:49
Some of the differences in the comparison between City and West Ham simply reflect the difference in status and size of the events these facilities were built for... and the consequently quite disproportionate difference in conversion costs.
The Commonwealth Games only required a 35-40k stadium, whereas an Olympic Stadium is usually double that size or more.
In the Man City case, there was never any intention of preserving the athletics function, and the smaller stand geometry lent itself to a simple dig down to generate their required extra capacity, within a traditional football stadium format.... and of course a temporary stand was used at one end for the games to allow the track layout to fit.
All-in-all, quite neat solution, although there are still some contentious issues regarding viewing distances and atmosphere etc. A similar temporary structure approach was adopted for both the Atlanta and Sydney games... but the demands of the post-games tenant were quite different.
There was far more political wrangling with the Olympic Stadium, which was probably envisaged with half a legacy view to preserving it's post-games athletics function throughout its design phase... and the result was a stadium that was supposedly almost a temporary structure in its entirety... which in itself, seems quite a bizarre compromise.
It isn't possible to repeat the simple dig-down trick given the format chosen, as the resultant capacity would be enormous..... and in this case the aim is to drastically reduce the capacity, not add to it. The other option would've been the use of expensive moving tiers... but again it would still involve major remodelling to fit any new tenant's football requirements.
Personally, from what I've seen of the remodelled scheme, in terms of simple stadium issues, I don't really envy the West Ham fans tbh.... as lucrative as this deal may appear.
Posted
08/09/2015 at
10:20:49
In the final part of last season someone here posted a theory that Everton must press for a prestigious location, the rationale being that it would guarantee subsidiary income whilst also having a real "Wow Factor" which would sell our football more widely.
There is bags of common sense in that line of reasoning, particularly the subsidiary income streams.
Sadly our potential to host concerts etc has evaporated because the Echo Arena (complete with its award winning reputation) now exists. The City Council would also not sanction another "stadium type" venue in the vicinity.
As I've stated on TW (in this thread and others) the Innovation Park location ticks every box as far as advantages are concerned.
Then look at Goodison itself, the car park (aka "Fanzone", oh how I cringe at the overambitious mega-labeling) has potential to both extend the Park End and introduce new commercial facilities.
All 4 sides of the ground need real improvements, some far more than the rest. Heavens above ('scuse the crap pun) the St Lukes corner could provide additional capacity with facilities and has been offered to us before now.
Should we relocate ? Well if we could get a prestigious location then yes, if not then continual development is the way forwards.
So additional capacity and new facilities can and should have been added before, and we know who has done bugger all on that score.
1 Posted 04/09/2015 at 22:21:27
Seems fair enough to me. They have to rent it out to pay for its upkeep. West Ham haven't been given it, like Man City were handed the Commonwealth Stadium.
Maybe Liverpool should bid to host the Commonwealth Games......