Korporal Klopp
By Mike Keating 08/10/2015
Now that the RS have engaged Klopp as Brenda's replacement, hopefully we can get a bit of fun out of it, especially if it goes tits up.
I know we should concentrate on all things Blue but the similarities to a certain dimwit from the pages of the Dandy got me thinking. Here's how Corporal Clott got promoted in the first place, 55 years ago:

I wondered if he might be recalled to the pages of ToffeeWeb in his German persona:

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Posted
09/10/2015 at
01:34:53
Kopites are Kloppites! Get yer banners out...
Posted
09/10/2015 at
01:36:14
Klop the flop has a ring to it.
On a more serious note, though, I've not seen the red shite have a buzz about them like this since the signing of Mario Balotelli! ;-)
Posted
09/10/2015 at
01:43:15
Alberto Aquilani...come on down
Posted
09/10/2015 at
02:40:16
I can't help feeling a tinge of envy that they got Klopp; the guy is the real deal and he will get them playing again.
At the end of last season, I was very much in the 'Martinez Out' group and admittedly he has gone some way to redeem the himself after the basket case of Sason 14-15 with his stance over Stones and the decent start we have made this season. However, I would love Klopp to be our boss.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
04:32:16
Before taking the mickey we should give Clot a chance.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
05:02:56
Colin #4, a lot of Blues have never, and will never, accept Martinez as he has a relegation on his CV.
As does Klopp.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
05:57:47
Relegation on your CV is not necessarily a bad thing. Often the worst experiences are part of a learning curve. I just hope Everton never go through that particular pain barrier.
I'm just relieved that the appointment is made and Auntie Beeb can give some reporting time to the other clubs in the division. FFS, they even invented a complete new column focussed on the Klop saga.
Oh shit wait a minute, old creasehead is being marketted again for some future role... Here we go again! Why I pay a bloody TV licence shit knows!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
07:26:46
Klippety Klopp gallops to the RS rescue.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
08:35:12
I've got a horrible feeling this guy will turn things round for the RS.
Watch this space...
Posted
09/10/2015 at
08:43:17
Having studied his record, I'm convinced they could've done better than Klopp, winning the German league doesn't make him a world class coach.
He does have charisma, hopefully that will soon wear a bit thin if he doesn't meet their expectations.
Glad to see the back of Rodgers, the guy was so deluded about his own ability, it must've come as a huge blow to his massive ego when he got the bullet. Bye, bye.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
09:10:23
I hope Klop Plops.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
09:37:15
I was gutted when Brenda took the bullet...
Posted
09/10/2015 at
09:38:35
Kop Flop Klopp
Posted
09/10/2015 at
09:42:34
Unfortunately, I will have to become anti-Klopp. I say unfortunately as I really like him as a person and coach but now he's gone over to the dark side I can only wish him all the worst.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
09:43:19
In Germany he had only one alpha club to contend with (Bayern). In England, he now has Man City, Man Utd, Chelsea and Arsenal, all better funded than LFC, all with better players.
His high energy game also burns his teams out – this is, I believe, what went wrong at Dortmund in the end, long before they lost Lewandowksi and Goetze to Bayern.
As far as I know, other top clubs were not keen on him because of his abrasive, manic personality and his dealings with club officials at Dortmund. He truly is a fans' manager, suited to any working class club fixated on its history and still convinced it has the world's greatest supporters. This is why I could never envisage him at Real, Bayern, or Chelsea, although he might just about have fitted Barca's profile or Roma's.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
09:44:45
Welcome to Liverpool, Jurgen. I hope all your good days are behind you.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:00:01
I'm not taking the piss based on his name - that might come back to bite us, though in certain photos he does look vaguely like Stephen Merchant (Ricky Gervais' oppo). I'd rather Rodgers had stayed as this new guy can't be worse, can he?
It's the off-field media love-in that irritates the crap out of me.
The same voices coming on local / national phone-ins claiming the New Messiah (just as previously).
Know-all gobshites, proclaiming a return to 'the Liverpool Way' and other assorted shite.
Then TV 'experts' self-importantly spouting more crap.
Anyway, at least I'll save on the leccy bill.
(By the way, I wonder how Brenda will be viewing that 'Being Liverpool' series now?)
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:00:07
£7m a year. They really know how to throw money around, don't they?
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:11:09
Jay (#15), I'm not saying you're wrong or right but they played in the CL final with Goetze so I don't think a lot had gone wrong "long before" he left.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:28:35
Apparently the BBC are making a new programme about the appointment and it will have a music theme. It is to be called.....
Klopp of the Flops
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:30:17
The Klopfest is well underway on Talk(insert pun opportunity)Shite.
Has another club had their new managers "Intro Press Conference", relayed live ? Don't even answer 'cos I'm not really interested.
Jurgen Klopp may well be an ambitious, opinionated young coach with a large chequebook available, however, that isn't the issue with "our loveable" neighbours, just wait for the "Our Year" claptrap (pun opportunity available) to get up to "Full Throttle".
A single point from the home derby was really disappointing for us, but FFS can you imagine the rivers of onanistic semen flowing from Norway and Devon, had his appointment been made prior ?
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:31:02
He seems like a really nice, down to earth guy. I wish him all the success in his next club.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:31:20
This is worth a look
Link
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:38:45
Doesn't matter (to me) who their manager is, they're simply not Liverpool anymore.
They had a model for success and they broke it themselves (main culprits Souness and the gangster's pal, King Kenny).
Okay, they have enough money to be able to guarantee (99.9%) they won't/can't be relegated but regarding 'success' (the PL), not a fucking chance.
If this feller is deemed a success, it will because he gets them 4th rather than wins them a title (nb: with their spend over 10 years, they should be regularly finishing 3rd).
By the way, if you want a Viz-style name, Jurgen's arl feller is the superbly named 'Nortbert Klopp.'
Jah, he iss az tight az ein gnat's chuff.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:46:09
I have to say that having watched his press conference he really impressed me. I know words are cheap but I like the guy, he exudes confidence without making out he is something special.
In fact when asked what he would describe himself as following Mourhino describing himself as the special one, he said "Then I am the ordinary one."
He said he likes his team to play at full throttle, something I would like to see our manager adapt our play to full throttle football on occasions.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
10:56:50
Remember how a few posters on here were lauding the 'genius' of Brenda after they had gone on what looked like a title-winning run only to fall short just as they prepared to celebrate; those same people were using the derby defeat at Anfield as a barometer as to how far Martinez was away from being a good or great manager and how superior his counterpart was in tactics etc.
I don't know whether the new guy will do a good or bad job at the other place, but I hope that Martinez is not bashed over the head if he proves to be a success, because the other lot have thrown money at every manager they have appointed in the last couple of decades and I mean real money and from that perspective it is an unfair contest.
I also believe that whilst a manager is important it is the players that a club has on its books that determine the outcomes of matches and hopefully their squad isn't good enough, whilst our own players might be able to use that oft heralded 'team spirit' to over-achieve this season – as always, time will tell.
The one area that Everton won't be able to compete with the other lot is the media frenzy surrounding them and their every move – I don't like soap-operas in general and I certainly have no love for the 24/7 production that is LFC, but it seems that I might be in a minority.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
11:04:44
Eugene (24). Totally agree, it doesn't matter who their manager is, the same ethos exists, sell an asset for top money and re-invest in shite.
They are now desperately trying to stop the rot, their owners don't give a fuck about tradition as long as the money rolls in. Speculation is starting with Coutinho to Barca already, Neymar has come out stating that he wants him there.
Liverpool are now just a slightly richer version of us, hoping for a top four finish once in a while.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
11:17:16
Colin G @22, sublime wording, flawless, so much so that your sentiments would probably be warmly welcomed in Norway & Devon. Very well done.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
11:17:18
Phil #1, let's keep it as Kloppites are Gobshites.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
11:31:05
I can see it now if they win anything with him:
"Klopp Clasps Cup as Kop Claps Klopp".
For the sake of avoiding such hideous headlines, never mind the intolerable borefest his success would bring, let's hope he's a resounding failure there.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
11:39:52
His first 5 fixtures: Tottenham, Southampton, Chelsea, Palace and Man City. Should be interesting.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
11:43:53
Jay W @30, FFS that genuinely made me laugh.
But no, let's not hope that he is a resounding failure there, let's hope that he noodles along with the unfulfilled promise of success continually beyond the grasp of their craptain as he grovels pitifully?
Brenda did an outstanding job in walking the shiterope betwixt overblown expectation and failure, Same again please.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
11:59:39
Got to say I am a little worried about this appointment. Let's hope Eugene is right and the club is so riddled with shite thinking that they do not progress. As for Coutinho to Barca, WTF? Really?
Anyway, welcome to the neighbouring cesspool Klippety, hope you hate it here and that it is always raining on your house. May the scallies torment you wherever you shop. May you return the Red Shite more broken than you found them.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
12:25:51
This guy is a very good manager by all accounts. Hopefully he has a bad start and they don't give him time to settle....
Posted
09/10/2015 at
12:28:25
It's not that we wish him any harm but we hope he makes a complete bollocks of his new job!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
12:47:08
I've been following the Bundesliga for years now, and have seen the rise of Klopp at minnows Mainz and later at Dortmund. He wants his team to play the match at full speed, going up and down the pitch in the highest gear all match long. Now compared to continental football the PL already plays in a higher gear so I'm not sure if his tactics will make the other lot stand out of the rest of the league. But he could be the real deal for them, tactically.
The one thing that I have my hopes on: at Mainz he had some wonderful seasons but blew it when he had to replace the best players of his team. He brought in the wrong players for too much money. At Dortmund, basically the same thing happened. He had success with a team full of players already at the club or coming through the youth ranks. As soon as he tried to buy players to have success again, it all went wrong slowly but surely.
Now, as has been pointed out before, this is exactly the thing in which that other lot has been failing miserably for years. In that respect they are a great combination and we could be in for some fun. Expect silly bids for unproven players.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
13:00:29
Erik @ 36, silly bids for unproven players... that's consistent with their modus operandi for years. I'm not at all convinced he'll prove a good hire... eccentric and entertaining but really what they needed? Either inspired or disastrous with my money on the latter.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
13:14:35
By the way, in case anyone was wondering about my reference of 'gangster's pal King Kenny', what I meant was...well, gangster's pal King Kenny.
Never forget or let them forget, (no matter how much they try to romanticise the miserable grunting twat) the following actually happened.
Link
I might add, can you imagine what the press would have done with - 'Former Everton Legend Joe Royle (or HK) arrived at the meeting with Liverpool gang boss Gibbon Ungisworth FitzWarren'? (whoever)
Posted
09/10/2015 at
13:18:32
Eugene #24 - I'm not so sure. Brendan spent 𧷤 million on players and wasted most of it. If Klopp has a better eye for a player and can attract a higher calibre of player then I do think the RS will improve.
I also think that there are no outstanding teams this season. Man Utd are average and are competing at the top. Chelsea are awful. Man City were looking good but then lost two on the bounce. Arsenal are not consistent. Neither are Spurs.
If the RS get some consistency then they'll be back in the mix and one of these seasons will be their year. They came close under Benitez once and under Rogers two seasons back. I genuinely think (but hope not) that they'll be contenders again next season.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
13:24:05
There's got to be scope to change the 'horsey' lyric to 'Jurgen'
http://youtu.be/nG8-6yfE6T8
Posted
09/10/2015 at
14:02:03
Craig (39) Brendan did spend circa 𧷜m but he recouped circa 𧵝m giving him a nett spend of circa 𧴷m Whilst our own manager has spent circa 㿸m recouped 㿕m giving a net spend of circa 㿏m. Brendan has spent 3.5 times the nett amount by Roberto...
Posted
09/10/2015 at
14:13:30
Thanks, Tony, you noticed? Patrick, Brendan's biggest downfall was selling high quality players for top dollar and replacing them with average joes.
Erik, interesting observations. Didn't Mainz beat the shite 5-0 in a friendly? Was Klopp the manager at the time?
Klopp's first job should be to put a muzzle on the dinosaurs e.g. Big Nose, Redcrap, Aldo etc..... They don't help, always harping on about their Jurassic days do they?
Posted
09/10/2015 at
14:28:00
Colin, yes, Klopp was managing at that time. One thing he is good at is firing a team up for a specific match. To be honest I fear that quality will cost us in derby matches. We really should have beaten them last week.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
14:29:21
Craig (39) - ' Man Utd are average and are competing at the top. Chelsea are awful. Man City were looking good but then lost two on the bounce. Arsenal are not consistent. Neither are Spurs. If the RS get some consistency then they'll be back in the mix and one of these seasons will be their year'
All true but relies on a lot of ifs.
Even if Herr Lipp improves them a lot, whatever Man City, Chelsea or Man Utd look like right now, the billionaire owners of those clubs, investing the sums they do, will only take not winning (or playing shite) for a very short space of time before change will be made.
For Liverpool 'to get the success we deserve lad' ('because... we just do lad') the following would have to happen.
Man Utd, Chelsea and Man City (all who can outspend 'them') would all have to fail and all not be able to address their failings for a couple of seasons
At the same time as these three are failing, Klippity (with less money and having no experience of the Premier League) would have to put together a side capable of taking advantage.
Possible?
Absolutely!
Probable?
In my opinion, absolutely not.
(I didn't include Spurs and Arsenal as they will do what they always do: Arsenal 3rd/4th; Spurs 5th/6th/7th).
Posted
09/10/2015 at
14:36:34
Almost 50 posts today on the Red Shite!
I'm as guilty as the next but it does seem we Evertonians are as obsessed with 'that lot' as SSN for whom there is no other topic!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
14:47:25
All good points Eugene. I'll sleep better tonight. Hee hee.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
14:53:24
Patrick (41).
I don't buy this argument that Brendan sold well and so we shouldn't look at how much money he spent. A RedShite fan that I work with was espousing this nonsense yesterday.
Alright, he made a big profit on Suarez (who somebody else bought). The fact is, he still went and blew the money on the likes of Lallana, Lovren, Markovic, Firminho etc.
It's like me buying a lottery ticket for ٠, winning the jackpot, wasting all the money and then saying "I only spent ٠ though". He still had that money in the club and wasted it.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
15:01:34
I would love to win the jackpot and waste all the money... Why else would you want to win it???
Posted
09/10/2015 at
15:16:21
Craig (47),
I wasn't defending the bloke's record or how he came up with the money – I'm just trying to show that comparing Everton and Liverpool at this moment in time, due to the different financial resources, is akin to comparing apples to oranges. Which is why I don't understand why we spend so much time using them as some sort of barometer to gauge how well or otherwise Everton are doing.
My favourite phrase to our friends over the park at the moment is to tell them they have lost seven out of their last 10 matches at Old Trafford... after all, that's their derby and their most important fixture, isn't it?
Posted
09/10/2015 at
16:35:38
Best part of 50 posts discussing THEM! We really don't do ourselves any favours at times, do we?
My view is quite simple but probably too old-fashioned for many on here – we should just ignore them... However, it's difficult to do so isn't it?
My family is split right down the middle: half blue; half red. I cringed when my brother called me today and said something that always riles me: 'If you want to know how Liverpool are doing, ask an Evertonian'.......
Would there be the same reaction if Roberto got the chop? Probably not; like it or not they are still a big hit for the football media world and sadly we are not. OFM and the Board turned us into 'plucky little Everton punching above our weight'.
Our kid tells me that Rogers had lost the fans and that watching them was painful this season. I told him that we had a season of that last year with Roberto. He thinks Klopp is just what's needed; time will tell!
All I know is that we are just 1 point ahead of them and they think it's been a terrible start to their season. Expectations eh?
Posted
09/10/2015 at
17:09:27
Pat, this has been going on forever and it ain't going to change until/unless we start winning things ourselves.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
17:52:10
Three things.
1) Re any 'Tut! We're always talking about them.' sentiment. No we aren't. I'd wager the percentage of TW threads devoted specifically to them as a lot less than one percent (maybe there are figures?)
2) It's an international week - there's no Everton game. So for those not into flags (or those who don't feel proud about being born in a place they didn't choose to be born in) surely it's fair enough to broaden the subject of threads (imo).
3) They are our oldest and (for most) most hated rivals. We are linked to them through history and geography. They are our bastard child (a fucking horrible ugly bastard too!). With all that in mind, them sacking a manager and getting a new one, doesn't (to me) seem like an out of place thread on an Everton website.
By the way, any blue who tells me 'I just ignore them' makes me think of a boy's name popular with Muslim's.
Asif.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
18:01:44
Like I said on another thread, Arsenal & Spurs fans talk about each other: Celtic & Rangers fans do the same as do Man City & Man Utd supporters. Are we so different?
Some seem to think we should somehow ignore our RS family, friends and neighbours who have been rubbing it in our noses for the last 20-odd fucken years!!! Never, never, NEVER!!!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
18:57:16
Colin, that's all very well if we are 'giving it them' but we're giving it ourselves on this thread, surely.
All my Red Shite co-workers are made up with Klopp; I bet they haven't given much space to us Blue Noses on their equivalents of ToffeeeWeb today!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
19:12:00
He's the most likeable manager they have had in my lifetime... Seems a genuine bloke. Real shame he has gone to Mordor!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
19:28:20
Is there any football manager more likeable than our very own Roberto? Doesn't help him when results aren't going our way does it?
As Eugene said we can't ignore them but I try really really hard to avoid them, and now I will watch England on ITV with the sound turned down for obvious reasons.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
20:04:40
Make fun of him now if you want but I'm really gutted. I would love to have Klopp as the Everton manager, the guy is really that good. Expect the RS to significantly improve.
I have lived in Germany for a while and seen what he did at Dortmund and Mainz before that... he will get the players up for every game and I expect them to shoot up the league. :-(
Posted
09/10/2015 at
20:24:43
Hey Pat,
"I don't like soap-operas in general and I certainly have no love for the 24/7 production that is LFC, but it seems that I might be in a minority."
No way, count me in mate!!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
20:30:08
Jay,
I prefer, Klopp Klasps the Klapp in Klamsterdam...
Posted
09/10/2015 at
20:35:05
Klopp kops the Klap in Kenny?
Posted
09/10/2015 at
20:40:27
Recently (on the dreaded FB) a schoolmate, Blueblood Evertonian and thoroughly decent chap Demmo, was tagged in an image from the '84 derby at "Our Old Ground". He was stood upon a barrier in "the popular end".
Graeme Sharp scored an exceptional goal that day.
Our connection with "the people who bought our old gaff" is permanent, oh how they may bleat and whine over that, yet they choose glorify certain times then deny hideous acts from the very same era. Our part in their birth is a documented fact. We are the parent club of football in our proud city.
Having seen my mate, Demmo, in the pic, I offered him and Jamie (who posted the pic) the following words:
Brings to mind the immense words by Rupert Brooke, except no real Blue could ever be christened Rupert...
"IF I should die, think only this of me;
That there's some corner of an foreign field
That is for ever Everton. There shall forever be
In that troubled earth a far older, far finer dust concealed;
A dust that noble Everton bore, shaped, made aware,
Gave, long before, with style, with victory, with dignity,
A body of Everton's breathing, most pure Blue air
The Royal Blue banks of that river, blest by sons of Goodison !
The days when we took, held and proudly stood Our Ground!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
20:50:45
Prince Rupert's Tower / Castle on the badge isn't it Tony?
Nothing wrong with Rupert... my favourite newspaper cartoon when I was growing-up.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
21:27:00
Denis (57) - 'Make fun of him now if you want but I'm really gutted. Would love to have Klopp as the Everton manager, the guy is really that good. Expect the RS to significantly improve'
You forgot to add..
Link
Posted
09/10/2015 at
23:41:13
I couldn't care less who manages Liverpool. Klopp and his team still have to do it on the pitch. And until January, with the same bunch of players that we were degrading on Sunday.
Now, I sense some fellow Evertonians are worried. WHY? Are we really that paranoid of the RS?
Let's see how Klopp copes with teams like Stoke and Swansea kicking lumps out of his players. Let's see how he copes with Palace and Leicester running all day long. And let's see how he copes with Man City's and Arsenal's undoubtable silky skills. He had a lot to prove. And I don't wish him well.
We also need to prove ourselves against those teams. And yes Martinez has a relegation on his CV. But my problem with him was last season, around November, December and early January he was clueless to stop that mini slump. No excuses... that was rubbish. He just about turned things around.
My point is, instead of worrying about Klopp, we should worry that our wee Bobby does not fall back into his old habits. But credit so far this season. He seems to have learnt lessons. Thank fook!
Posted
09/10/2015 at
23:50:45
And Big Sam has taken the Sunderland job. I know that he is a big plodder, and not everyone's cup of tea. But I expect (in the short term) Sunderland's results to improve. And they always seem to give us a hard game.
It's going to be a very interesting league this season. We need to be on our game, as any team can beat you at anytime.
Posted
09/10/2015 at
00:06:35
They're celebrating like they've won the league trophy they thought they'd won two seasons ago.Maybe we'll have a similarly amusing ending.
I just saw the trailer to the Kray movie 'Legend' and when threatened, Reggie says, "You won't mind if I fight back, will yer?" Sort of sums up what he's about to get hit with.
They are shit and other teams and managers are not just going to roll over.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
00:24:03
Tony # 58 what are you on about?
I've got a friend called O'Reilly
Oh Really?
No O'Reilly.
Now, that play on an Irish name really ought to be removed.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
08:22:43
Very good Eugene (64). Feels like that a bit. I really like Klopp so it's a shame he's gone there.
Still, life goes on and no team has really got going yet so all to play for.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
09:40:42
Hmmm... Klopp said, "If I sit here in four years, I am pretty confident we will have one title".
Now, not to be a smartypants or anything, but I have been a student of the German language for around 20 years, reading it every day, etc., etc. And while the Germans do indeed use the word "Titel" much as we use the word "title" in a sporting context, there is a subtle difference which I feel Klopp may have lost when speaking in English. For the Germans, ANY trophy is a "Titel", be that an FA Cup, a League Cup, or winning the league, whereas for us it's only winning the league.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
09:48:06
A good point, Jay. I guess I speak for all Evertonians when I say any 'titel' that comes OUR way will be a godsend !
Posted
10/10/2015 at
12:47:39
The "one title" he'll have in four years time is the one he already has with me:"Shithead".
Yeah he's charismatic – big deal. So was another German messiah. Klopp will end up likewise... in a little red bunker, insane and a failure.
If Ancellotti had gone, then I might have been a little concerned. Even then, after consideration, I'd have thought... "Nah, they're pants."
COYB!
Posted
10/10/2015 at
13:02:31
As with many a cultural or psychological phenomenon, the Germans coined the apt word to describe the latest Liverpool FC revelatory, messianic spectacle – KITSCH.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
14:26:49
Bad news this. Martinez had me fooled with his spin, and Klopp is also very much a media man, but I would love to see him managing our current squad. Sprints and shots are his priorities. Roberto's are controlling the ball and not defending corners.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
15:03:51
"The normal one"!
Big-nose Thompson started the wankfest on Sky Sports the other day: piercing expression, comparing him to Shankly, the best manager on the planet... Standard bullshit each time these cunts wheel out a new manager – wasn't cock-nose Rodgers the messiah three years ago?
I am not arsed about him or any of them bastards over there at all; like his predecessors, he will fail. He talks through his arse and these pricks are already lapping it up. He will soon go on about 5 European Cups, tell tales of being golden showered on the Kop while watching hard man Tommy Smith and his handsome mates when he was here no doubt on a Beatles trip in the '70s... so yes let's laugh our balls off at him!
Watching him sat next to Ayre the other day who looked like he was about to ejaculate each time Klop opened his wide gob – apple strudel doodle! I want to know what Stan Boardman has to say about the Germans now...
Posted
10/10/2015 at
16:44:52
A lot of foreign managers come to the Premier League with big reputations but have no idea just how tough a league it is. As we know, there are no easy games here, Jurgen, and he will be in for a shock.
I have read that he likes to train his players hard, twice a day? Hasn't this been done before in the Premier League! That's nothing new; also, you train them too hard and, due to the competitive nature of the league, the players burn out.
I expect an initial improvement in the Dark Side as always happens when a new manager takes over, but it will not be sustainable and that's when it will get interesting.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
16:55:48
This will be interesting. He will undoubtedly get some improvement out of them. Not sure he'll win anything without reinforcements.
Those with a selective memory of Moyes's 'all action' football will probably use Klopp as a stick to beat Martinez. No doubt they will run, run, run, tackle, tackle, run and run. I think they'll be shot to bits in a couple of years, unless he buys better players.
He did a great job at Dortmund, found some gems at a good price and got the best out of his players. He lost some of his best players to bigger clubs, but they also had that jaded look of a knackered 'high energy' team after a couple of years.
In the meantime we have a more settled squad with better players, led by a manager who is doing his job again this season. I prefer our position.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
18:08:33
Paul (77)
This!!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8Yf5B6GbYk
Posted
10/10/2015 at
18:45:45
I was pissing myself laughing at the gobshite supporter being interviewed on telly.
Quote... "I haven't been this excited since Shankly signed as our manager".
Fuck me, he was younger than me and I can't remember Shankly joining them!
They do talk bollocks.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
18:56:46
Someone mention Stan Boardman?
Link
Posted
10/10/2015 at
19:12:44
Jon (80),
The previous time in history when a German speaking bloke was in charge of so many Fokkers spelt big trouble for many of our grand-parents. Let's hope this one is stopped in his tracks sooner rather than later.
Posted
10/10/2015 at
19:13:58
AJ you can have him on football manager if you want. Let's see in May who's higher than who.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
13:14:22
Eugene, nobody should ever mention Stan Boardman. On the subject of Klopp, I reckon that the RS will drag him down to their level, rather than he elevating them above their current station.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
14:31:05
We now have Ringo Klopp singing all you need is Klopp. Well, it's a long and winding road for the fool on the hill. He says Hello, we say Goodbye. Kloppites love Klipperty Klopp. I hate the shite.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
16:45:10
Let's hope they play like the Keystone Klopps
Posted
11/10/2015 at
16:53:13
I hope he fails and fucks off, but I do seem to remember that quite a few on this site wanted him as our manager last time around so I also take the 'he's shite/we don't care' comments with a pinch of salt.
On a wider point, it's much easier to dislike Liverpool managers when they are arrogant (Benitez) or deluded (Rodgers). It might be harder with this guy, though I'll certainly try. I'm old enough to remember the Shankly era and I had huge respect for the guy as a manager and person (still hated the club mind you).
Posted
11/10/2015 at
17:21:20
Paul (88) I agree with your sentiments about the new fellah but I have to disagree with your view about Shankly, most of what he said about Everton started the divide between the two sets of fans, admittedly much of what he said was tongue in cheek, however, both sets of fans started to believe what he said as gospel. Just a selection of some of his statements about Everton FC:
"When I've nothing better to do, I look down the league table to see how Everton are getting along."
"If Everton were playing at the bottom of the garden, I'd pull the curtains."
"The difference between Everton and the Queen Mary is that Everton carry more passengers!"
When told he had never experienced playing in a derby... "Nonsense! I've kicked every ball, headed out every cross. I once scored a hat-trick; one was lucky, but the others were great goals."
After Everton boss Harry Catterick missed the 1971 cup semi-final vs Liverpool: "Sickness would not have kept me away from this one. If I'd been dead, I would have had them bring the casket to the ground, prop it up in the stands and cut a hole in the lid."
However, I do agree with one statement he made upon his appointment:
"If you'd seen Anfield when I came it was the biggest toilet in Liverpool. I had to bring water in from Oldfield Road. It cost 3,000 pounds. There was no water to flush the toilets.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
18:43:23
I saw Stan in New Brighton Morrisons the other week. His Missus was giving him a real hard time, he looked like the puppy that shit in her handbag.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
19:01:47
He could only say those things because Catterick was like a mute, Patrick. He'd mumble and look really uncomfortable when interviewed so Shankly had a field day with him.
Despite always hating LFC, I always felt a grudging admiration for Shanks.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
19:17:30
Shankley loved the press, never stopped talking to them. I don't know how much sense he made as a lot of it was about himself, a bit of an egomaniac to me, but the press certainly liked him as he always gave them a quote.
Catterick didn't like the press, never went out of his way to court them, and so the press didn't like Harry. I don't think it bothered him to any degree.
When it came to ability, they were both excellent managers, with Harry every bit as good as "fish and chips" Shankly the name given to the Liverpool manager because he was never out of the papers.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
19:23:47
23 comments about Stones, 93 about the Liverpool manager. No, we don't have an inferiority complex.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
19:57:22
Shankly was very much a type - the annoying overconfident-uncle type.
'Look son, I've knocked about the world a bit' (ie: did national service - spent 2 years in a barracks in Aldershot, pulling the stomach out of himself while looking at pics of Diana Dors).
'Shanks' was basically a saloon-bar lawyer, a sort of Scottish Rigsby - full of homespun philosophy (ie: shite) and repeating old gags as though he'd just come up with them.
"School and University? Yes son, I went to the school of hard knocks and the university of life." - etc bore.
That said, I couldn't hate the man and to give him his due, like few others, he understood completely that football is team game and totally bought into the power of 'the group.'
I remember him saying if you look at any very successful side, you will see a form of footballing socialism going on.
(Imagine getting Stevie Me to buy into the idea he's no bigger than any other member of the team, or Ballotelli.)
I think Klopp is probably a decent manager/feller and might be able to improve their results a bit, but I genuinely believe Liverpool FC aren't 'Liverpool FC' anymore and are only part of any elite group in the addled brains of their football tourist supporters and few gobshite jounos/pundits.
And long may it continue.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
20:03:26
Ged, this thread IS about the Liverpool manager NOT about Stones!
Posted
11/10/2015 at
20:58:46
Anthony 76.
Some folk are never satisfied, we're doing terrible are we not.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
22:07:37
Raymond, what are you on about? Like many posters on this site I want less keep ball and more shots on target. Thus, I would like to see a manager that likes fairly direct football have a go with our squad.
Colin, shots on target and sprinting may only seem important on Football Manager in your eyes, but I can assure you that they matter in the real game also. Believe it or not, you can only score goals if you shoot, and you won't get many chances to do so with jogging alone.
The bias of some fans is frightening.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
22:37:49
Patrick Murphy (#89),
I'm with Paul (#88) on this one, I also remember Shanks arriving at LFC and, although he could be an irritating git with some of his comments, comments which I can smile at now, he was a real football man and a socialist.
After he resigned at LFC he always received a welcome at Everton, something denied to him at Liverpool, and admitted a real affection and admiration for our club. He would be seen most home games walking along Goodison Road to take his seat in the Main Stand and enjoying a bit of banter with the Blues fans.
I certainly don't think he was responsible for any divide between the fans; that came later with the likes of that gobshite Emlyn Hughes.
Posted
11/10/2015 at
22:50:44
Anthony (97) - 'Believe it or not, you can only score goals if you shoot.'
Only?
What about headers?
Or those goals when the ball is sort of passed into the net?
And own-goals?
And those ones when the keeper tries to clear it, but it hits the attacker and sort of ping-pongs between them before rebounding into the net?
Plus Maradona punch-em-in goals?
And Denis Law-style back heels?
There's loads of non-shooting ways to score.
The not thinking arguments through of some fans is frightening...
Posted
12/10/2015 at
00:37:37
I've got a sickly feeling that Klopp might just turn them into title contenders. I really really hope I'm wrong.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
03:41:36
By the time the transfer window comes round in January, the shite will be so far behind the field, they will have to tip toe back, until then he has to manage that crop of shite players just short of three months.
I think I have more chance of turning water into wine, than that shite challenging before January.
Carra, Stevie me, ratboy, Stirling all gone, Sturrige competing with Gibson for crock of the north.
Relax, they have the manager who can talk a good game, we have a team now that can do it on a field, the Blue revolution is in full swing.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
03:52:08
Brian #101, that's all true - but it doesn't cover the fact that they are a money-making machine, and have oodles of cash to splash or waste to try to get back to the top.
When FFP was briefly in place, they were a nap to fail it, except somehow UEFA allowed them to book a 𧴜m loss on the Stanley Park stadium, which covered for their disastrous transfer deals under Dalglish and Hodgson. (Amazing how not even laying a brick can lead to a loss of 𧴜m – more than our "mid-level" stadium in Kirkby would've cost.)
They've since sold Suarez and Sterling for top money, and FFP has quietly died a death anyway (or Chelsea and City wouldn't be in Europe).
Now the problem they have is they are not a first pick for top players, as long as one of the challenging money teams is in – but they can throw more in wages at signings – which means if they start going for players we would be after, it's no contest - they will outbid us on fee and wages everytime.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
05:13:17
I also thought this chap was normal till I heard him promise to win the title within four years. Okay, he might achieve it but it's still a silly thing to say.
We know and Klopp knows, the Fenway group will not rest till they are sitting on top. If he fails to perform miracles he won't last four years. They need to be in the limelight and if the team are not setting the world on fire then a change of manager will see them back in the headlines.
Personally, I think he faces a very difficult task. Brenda couldn't do it with Suarez, Sterling, Coutino, Sturridge, Henderson and Gerrard and three of them have gone. The other three have frequent injury problems and will certainly not enjoy Klopp's double-shift training methods. Happy days.
In the meantime, we Blues have tough matches ahead and I hope our international boys are well rested and ready to go.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
06:31:37
Harold, check Jay's submission @71, he offers an interesting insight on the "lost in translation" scenario.
I found it curious that Mr Klopp should apologise for his English, when most of his club's supporters can't speak the language at all.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
07:54:04
The thing to remember, is that Corporal Klopp is going to be working under the same 'Moneyball' approach as Brenda was, so while he might improve the team, his hands are still going to be somewhat tied as far as transfers are concerned.
They used to say that Brenda had final say in who they bought, but if that's truly the case, why have the Moneyball team in place at all? Makes no sense to me.
I like(d) Klopp, but as Colin says above, the moment I saw him wearing Satan's red vest, that was the end.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
08:09:30
Time to take this Krapp off TW now I think. Back to Blue Stuff.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
08:11:12
George - I like having a RS bashing thread!
Posted
12/10/2015 at
09:13:00
Ray (98). Shankly came from a working class background are you sure he voted that way, his wife was connected to a Tory group at Liverpool Council at one time, doesn't mean that Shankly was but I have my doubts that he was a Labour voter.
It could be my natural bias towards the man; didn't like him. To get Liverpool to the top, he was given the one thing that was denied to all previous Liverpool managers... MONEY. It made a big difference; he managed four clubs... he was only successful with one.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
09:37:58
Let's hope Klopp takes after Shankly, then, Dave!
He's dead funny, that Stan Boardman, Paul. He will probably say they only bombed the chippies in Walton.
Seems to be a common theme with Liverpool, and at least 80% of their mostly delusional fan base. The more they are convinced by something, the more it's doomed to failure. Long may it continue, although I do think that once that new stand is up and running, they will be generating an extra 㿀 Million a year, and football changes quickly.
Let's hope the Yanks are getting ready to sell them to that fella who lives in a one bedroom flat in Manny!
Posted
12/10/2015 at
09:59:18
Dave#108
I seem to think that Shankly's socialist leanings were quite obvious in his biography and, indeed, the The Labour Party conference afforded him a minute's silence after his death. I can't think of many ex-Scottish coal-face miners from the 1920s & 1930s who were Tory party members, can you? ;-)
Despite what you say about his wife, Nessie, and her Tory leanings, I think you'll find that Shankly was certainly no Tory. (I enjoyed the comment that there are more Pandas than Tory MP's in Scotland.)
This quote from him says all you need to know about the RS:
"I have been received more warmly by Everton than I have by Liverpool. It is a scandal that I must write these words about the club I helped to build."
He was also stopped from going to Melwood but, again, welcomed at Bellefield where he spent some time helping train the youth side. His house overlooked Bellefield.
If you think that I have an admiration for a man who managed the RS, albeit a grudging one, then yes, I do. He was a character and a real football man of the people, far removed from the idiots like Mourinho etc.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
10:03:26
Tony (#109),
An interesting piece in yesterday's Times by Souness who thinks that FSG aren't really bothered whether LFC win a trophy or not. He thinks that, long term, they are just getting the club ready for a big Middle or Far Eastern outfit to take them over for a fat profit, especially after all the BT and Sky money really kicks in and considering their global appeal.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
10:18:20
Ray (#111), I think that's the plan, because they got Liverpool, for a very decent price.
Ray (#110), alls you need to know about Liverpool, and their approach to football, in the seventies, and eighties. Shankly obviously loved football, but you can't have your ex manager in and around the club, when you have a new man in charge. Hard-hearted? Maybe, Ruthlessly professional? Definitely.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
10:28:16
Dave Abrahams (#108),
I can confirm that Shankly was a staunch labour supporter. I have been lucky enough to have been in his company and he was a real man of the people.
I wish Moores would have got him instead of Catterick. Shanks built that team from nothing and as for money Catterick had more than double his budget but didn't have half of his passion.
I know another poster said about him being banned from Melwood, well what happened was that when he resigned he still used to go to Melwood to train. But all the players used to stop training and go over to Shanks to talk to him. So Paisley said, "Look Bill you can come here and train whenever you like, just not when the players are here."
Posted
12/10/2015 at
10:36:37
I totally agree Brian. He was a great man and I'd have loved him to have been the Everton manager...
I remember listening to an interview on Merseyside with Alex Young. He was reminiscing about a charity match when Everton and Liverpool Scottish players were managed by Bill Shankly. Youngy had nothing but praise for the man and his way of instilling belief in players. When he was asked if it was different under Catterick, Alex didn't respond.
As for their current manager, I don't know enough about him... I just have a horrible feeling!
Posted
12/10/2015 at
12:10:49
I remember in my youth we were going around West Derby with a collection tin for the Poppy Appeal, we were in the roads around Bellefield and knocking on doors. We asked one house holder which one Bill Shankly lived in, we were pointed in the direction of a red door (of course). When we knocked, Bill's daughter answered and she was trying politely to get rid of us (perhaps she knew what was coming). Then Shanks popped his head out of an inner door and asked what what was going on.
He was was chuffed that youths were collecting for Poppy Day and when we told him we played for Huyton RBL Youth FC he invited us in to his front room, got his wife to provide juice and chocolate bars and showed us a collection of his medals. He had retired from LFC and gave us plenty of tips to encourage us and said he would come to our end-of-season presentation night if we did well.
He was true to his word and Brian Labone turned up to, what a night for us all. When he was shaking my hand, the manager told him that I was another Evertonian "We all make mistakes, son," said Shanks in his dry Scottish accent. Brian Labone just laughed.
What a man, he may've been a red but he is one of the few I admire to this day.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
12:13:35
Ray (#98) you are right; I saw Shankly walking down Goodison Road regularly, usually with the actor Bill Dean (Harry Cross in Brookside).
I agree that it was that horrible get Emlyn Hughes (no relation to us - thank god) and McDermott that started the animosity between us and RS fans, even Tommy Smith did not like Hughes at all. COYB
Posted
12/10/2015 at
12:49:13
Jim (114), the story that Alex Young told about the benefit match he played in with Shankly as manager, told more about Young than Shankly. Alex said that Shankly was a great motivator for that game, motivation in a benefit / charity game? Unbelievable.
I remember that story well, it's a pity Alex couldn't be motivated for dozens of league matches he played in for Hearts and Everton.
I accept Shankly was a socialist, I read one of his books and some of the stories he told in it, Hans Christian Anderson had a serious rival there.
If some of you liked Shankly rather than Harry Catterick that's okay with me; Bill to me was a fanastist, Harry was a realist, better to be hurt by the truth than comforted by a lie.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
13:01:12
Jim#114
Jim, I well remember that match, it was actually Dixie Deans testimonial in 1964 and about 35000 people turned up. It was, as you say, two teams from us and "them" mixed together to provide and England team and a Scottish team. For the day, Vernon became Scottish. Or, being a Celt, he'd fit in anyway.
When you think that we could between us provide almost a full team of Scots players, all or most Internationals, something that would be as rare as Unicorn dung today. We had, from memory, Sandy Brown, Jimmy Gabriel, Alex Young, Alex Scott, Alex Parker and Roy Vernon and they provided Tommy "Flying Pig" Lawrence, Willie Stevenson, St John, Yeats(?), Graham. How many clubs could boast so many really top Scottish players nowadays? Those Scottish players were as good as any team in the old First Division in those days.
Brian (#113),
I suppose it's fair comment that Shanks would have disrupted their training to some extent but it was clear that his treatment hurt him deeply. As you say, he'd have been a great manager for us.
I think that any Blues who can't see that Shankly WAS a true football man should have a word with themselves.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
13:40:22
Therein lies the problem for me when I look at the two clubs. Are we too honest? Whilst those across the park, are outraged at everything, but ashamed of nothing?
They have an inner belief that we, as a football club, have never really possessed. We have people saying Klopp makes them worried. I know what they mean but we should fuck them. (I mean Liverpool FC.)
Mentally scarred, I hate going in the game until the last ten minutes before kick off, (I was in Goodison at one o'clock when Glen Keelley got sent off), because of that day, but Eugene is correct. We should start to look at them differently, and turn the absolute fear, and hatred into a much more powerful force.
We hate them so much, I believe it makes us too desperate to beat them. I just can't see how it's going to change, but Joe Royle wound them up, and they never beat Everton whilst he was in charge, so maybe that's the answer.
Klopp has a decent track record, or they wouldn't have went for him; let's just hope he turns them into plop!
Posted
12/10/2015 at
14:01:15
Ray (#118),
Of course Shankly loved football. He was also a showman who loved himself as well. Nothing wrong with that, I suppose... I'd just rather have a realist.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
14:20:46
I remember seeing Shankly on Goodison Road before the first game of the season... 74-75 vs Derby County? It was just after he had resigned , and guess what? He was being mobbed with handshakes back-patting "arlrite Bill" etc. I liked the fella... well as much as you can like a Koppite !!!
As previously stated, he was going to Mellwood and the players were calling him "Boss" and Bob Paisley was feeling undermined, so he was told about this and went to Bellefield instead.
Are we as a whole obsessed with Liverpool? I would say yes... in the way Liverpool are obsessed with Man Utd...
As for Herr Klopp (Austin Powers lookalike) he could be good for them; hopefully not...
Posted
12/10/2015 at
15:05:19
Dave,
I guess we will have to disagree on Shankly and Catterick. What I do know is that if you talk to ex players, Shankly was adored by his ex players; I can't say our ex-players spoke in the same terms about Catterick.
I know Joe Royle said you knew when the TV people were coming to Bellefield as it was the only time Catterick wore a track suit. He bought the players and picked the team but left the rest to his coaches.
My big criticism of Catterick was that, with us having more money than anyone to spend, we should have at least been in a European Cup Final.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
15:24:17
Brian (#122), there is nothing to really disagree about, just different points of view. As for managers, they also do the job in a different way.
In a lot of jobs people don't like their boss and Shankly couldn't kid his players after a certain length of time; Roger Hunt and Willie Stevenson said Shankly didn't have any thing different to tell them after he had been manager for a few years.
And for as much as some Evertonians like Shankly, and I do understand them, according to Peter Robinson, Liverpool secretary, there was a lot of red supporters writing in to the club asking that the manager be replaced. This was during the period when Liverpool never won a domestic honour for seven years: 1966-74.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
15:27:53
Brian, let's be honest, Everton got knocked out of the 1963-64 European Cup by the eventual winners Inter Milan... some might say very unluckily knocked out.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
16:45:34
Dave, VERY unluckily knocked out...t he Roy Vernon goal being disallowed for offside when TV replay showed that he clearly WAS onside.
As for the realist and showman comments, I think Royle's observation re Catterick donning his track suit when the cameras were due speaks volumes.
Catterick may have been a pragmatist and by selling Ball and saying that it made financial sense he underlines his pragmatism but at what cost? One of the finest Everton players sold for a profit...
Posted
12/10/2015 at
17:42:18
Ray, I think the England team was something like West, Lawler, Wilson, Milne, Labone, Smith, Callaghan, Hunt, Pickering, Stevens, Thompson.
I stand to be corrected, but don't think I'm far off. Some line-up.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
18:19:37
See the Liverpool fan who used his disabled granddads ticket to watch the merseyside derby, and completed a triathlon the next week.
I'd do it again, said the man with no shame, it was good banter??
Posted
12/10/2015 at
19:05:20
Dave (117) I'm not so sure I've given Alex an accurate enough
summary of his comments but I think it showed me the difference between Catterick and Shankly.
I think that Alex was a player you either adored or you didn't. To me he was one of the best footballers I've ever seen in a blue jersey I also think that man-management plays a massive part in a manager's job. I don't believe Catterick's man-management got the best out of our players.
There was a view that Shankly got good players and made them great; I go along with that view. I think that when Liverpool got Shankly, it was the beginning of a dynasty for them. I don't see Catterick in the same light at all.
I'll agree about their game against Inter Milan. A good goal by Vernon, ruled as offside.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
22:02:44
Eugene, you are correct that not all goals come from shots on goal. However, I think you will find that most goals stem from shots, and so my original point stands.
Incidentally, headers are classed as shots on goal if performed by a member of the attacking team (now who's not thinking?)...I digress. Your pedantry betrays your lack of a viable argument, or is it your unrelenting desire to sound like the high chief of ToffeeWeb, or perhaps your indignation that I had the temerity to answer back to an ally?
Well, whatever the reason at least you have stopped using capital letters in every other sentence to help explain your prophetic opinions and side splitting humour (loving the italics you have upgraded to by the way).
I don't like to waste time providing courtroom level answers to criticisms of my subjective opinions. I'll leave that to the likes of yourself. Now go and troll someone else.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
22:17:11
Peter Mills (#126),
Peter, you got me thinking with your England team so I've haunted the internet for the answer, the team was (apparently)
Rankin, Byrne, Moran, Harris, Labone, Kay, Callaghan, Stevens, Pickering, Temple, Morrissey
And the Scotland team was:
Lawrence, Brown, Thompson, Gabriel, Yeats, Stevenson, Scott, St John, Young, Vernon, Wallace.
I remember Dean came on to the pitch and kicked off the match to a great reception.
Jim Lloyd (#128). Good post.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
23:41:34
Ray (#125), Joe Royle was a great natural footballer who had everything in his locker to be one of the best England international footballers of all time, Alan Ball used to scream at him in training to work harder at his game, but he didn't and I know he suffered with his back injury but he was too easy going. I never heard Harry Catterick criticise Royle, talk about washing your dirty laundry in public!!!
I loved Alan Ball as much as any Evertonian and he had a go at Catterick after he left Everton. It was well rumoured that Alan had huge gambling debts, and it was possible or even likely that was one of the reasons he left Everton; again, I never heard Harry criticise Alan Ball.
Posted
12/10/2015 at
23:57:17
Jim (#128) I've had this argument with many an Evertonian over Alex Young. If they say to me Alex, ON HIS DAY, was the best player they have seen, they would get absolutely no argument from me.
Young had a God-given talent as far as I'm concerned but, on too many occasions, he wasted that talent. It was something in his make-up that he acknowledged himself. Some days, he could make me be in love with the sheer magic and quality of his ability but, on other days, he made me despair.
In short, he was brilliant but he could and should have done a lot more with his career — and I bet he would agree with a lot I have just written.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
00:40:48
I agree, Dave. When Alex Young came to play Irish league football he was so awful that I doubted the great things I had heard about him. It seems to me about the man and the moment. Great now and again or good most of the time. What would you rather have?
Posted
13/10/2015 at
07:19:42
Cheers, Ray (#130), I knew someone would correct me. No Roger Hunt or Peter Thompson – so they were pulling their stars out of internationals even then!
Posted
13/10/2015 at
08:12:08
Dave (#131),
So, like me, you were a member of the Joe Royle fan club! As you state, he had back problems which I'm sure curtailed his time at Everton, Joe moving to Man City far too early.
Catterick may not have criticised Ball but he did sell him for a profit when in his prime, which was the point I was making. Ball made over 300 top appearances for Arsenal and Southampton after leaving us, he had plenty left in the tank when sold. Young, though, is still my all-time favourite player, just ahead of Ball.
Peter Mills (#134).
I hope you don't mind me correcting you, I was curious as to who actually played in that game myself. Like you say, pulling their stars out even then!
Posted
13/10/2015 at
09:11:42
Ray (#135), fair enough. You say Catterick got rid of Ball too early, he certainly wasn't past it when he went. I'm saying it's possible Alan wanted to go, he wasn't having a great season when he left.
Maybe one of us is correct or maybe we are both wrong. I don't think we'll find out now, do you!!!!
Posted
13/10/2015 at
12:30:05
Catterick got rid of anyone who had a mind too early: Bobby Collins, Roy Vernon, Jimmy Gabriel and Alan Ball.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
14:06:58
Ray and Jim; Re Inter, I found 30 seconds of video while looking for something else (as usual) but haven't been able to find it again. Vernon WAS onside when he scored, but Young wasn't (he may have even headed it back) but back then the rules were much stricter.
Shankly has the legend and as we know, if in doubt, print the legend, but Catterick gained more 1st Division points in the '60s than any other manager: Busby, Shankly, Nicholson, Revie... anybody. But that's boring, so the legend wins every time.
He had his faults – many – but when he got it right, I saw the best football anybody ever watched and it was a privilege to be there.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
14:54:09
No-one who was there in 62-63 and 69-70 disputes it, Derek, but Catterick was an awkward bugger who ruled by fear. I vaguely knew Brian Labone at the time,(Hermitage Bowls and he did occasionally help the Collegiate team) and he wasn't exactly effusive about the man.
He created two great teams, something Shankly never managed, only Busby, Clough and Ferguson did the same. But Catterick was a martinet and he mishandled the four players mentioned above and upset a few others.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
15:57:11
Dave#136
True, mate, we'll probably never know, but Ball was always effusive in his praise for and love of Everton. After all, we all love his quote "Once Everton has touched you nothing will be the same." and "I was running back to the centre circle after I scored the second goal against Liverpool and pure elation welled up inside me. I remember thinking, 'I just love this place – I want this place forever.'"Â
Somehow I can't imagine Ball wanting to leave. I found the following in an old ToffeeWeb article. Read it and weep.
http://ToffeeWeb.com/fans/fanclubs/eisa/dinner-4.asp
Derek#138.
Yes Derek, the stats do point to Catterick's unsurpassed points tally and, yes, we both witnessed the finest Everton team ever, in my opinion, the 1969-70 side. I would love to be able to watch us dominate football as we did with that side, especially for our younger supporters who can only listen to us old arses banging on about our great teams from the past.
We all love a stat, here's one, of the last 9 games in that season we won 8 and drew 1, away to Sunderland when we were already Champions.....
Posted
13/10/2015 at
17:23:18
Ray, yes, I loved Alan Ball; was sad when he went. I missed Bobby Collins more, Vernon was probably better than Young, to me anyway, and what was there to dislike about Jimmy Gabriel?
I'm sure he got rid of Collins too soon, maybe Ball... Vernon was sent home from a pre-season tour of America. And was transferred to Stoke not long after. Wasn't Jimmy Gabriel past his best when he went?
Anyway my thanks to Harry Catterick for the many, many happy hours his teams gave me at Goodison and all over the country. I for one will never forget him.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
17:45:36
Dave (#142),
Spot on. As a youngster, I thought Young was the bees knees but, looking back, Vernon made everything tick.
We had so many great players, many under-rated, such as Stevens. Of that era, the greatest sadness in my opinion was the loss of Tony Kay.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
18:18:13
Anthony (129) - That is one whole heapin' helpin' of doo-lally.
Troll = anyone who points out the gaping holes in your posts.
Pedant = anyone who points out the gaping holes in your posts.
Colin Hunt's office trolley...
Editorial Team
Posted
13/10/2015 at
19:24:09
Before we close this thread, just a side question for Dave Abrahams:
"Vernon was sent home from a pre-season tour of America."
I was not aware of that. Anything more to add?
Thanks.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
19:53:04
Just to go back to an earlier thread. What did Stan Boardman do that so upsets everyone? I haven't lived in Liverpool for years. BTW, I am no relation; I just feel I should know.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
20:10:34
Dave (#132),
I totally agree with your comments about Young. I remember a gang of us were all hanging off the old Paddock wall, Young had already developed a reputation, but he was hardly setting the place alight this night. We were asking each other what all the fuss was about concerning the guy who would later become "the Golden Vision".
Suddenly, a wayward pass was sailing out of play towards us. Young – who was a few feet away – watched the ball drop over his "wrong" shoulder, and to everyone's amazement left the ground, both feet and dragged the ball out of the air. I swear it was 6ft off the ground! A dozen scally jaws dropped and hit the wall as one, it was an astonishing piece of skill.
I don't even remember what he did with it once it was under his spell, we were all giving each other a staggered "Did that just happen?" look.
At least half of our gang were undecided back then, Red or Blue? But there was no doubt after that: everyone present was from now on a Blue. No going back.
There were a few members of the gang (gangs used to be everyone in the street back then) who were not there. They hated the constant harping about this blinding peace of skill, they hated that they were not there.
Quite a few were "undecided"; back then, it wasn't so unusual, but to a man (boy), those not present that night drifted over to the dark side and we were never to be reconciled. Sure, you'd still play footy with them, but they would always be "Them".
Regularly anonymous but, when he played... he played; he could be breathtaking.
He was more than a Golden Vision; he shaped lives.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
20:18:09
Michael,
I too remember Vernon being sent home from a pre-season tour of America. Now I can't quite remember why he was sent home but I think it was something not appertaining to football.
I keep thinking it may have been something to do with illegal drugs, but not 100% sure. I am sure if someone can look into the archives of the Mirror they will have reported on it I am sure.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
20:27:14
Michael, Royston was sent home for missing a curfew, from memory. This was one of Black Harry's favourite ploys.
Brian Labone once told a few of us that Catterick used to keep everyone's hotel room key in his room, so you had to ask him for your key. That way, he knew who was late back.
Vernon was made captain in an attempt to curb his excessive individuality. It never quite worked out.
But what a player.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
20:47:16
Michael (#145), no not really; Roy was his own man.
The time he was sent home from America just sticks in my mind. It did happen but what the reason was I'm not sure, I can't even think of the year it happened.
At the time, Roy went to Stoke; they were buying a lot of established internationals who, shall we say, we're getting on a bit. I'm not sure how long he stayed at Stoke or how well he did there. He was a great player for us and Wales – by the way, he knocked us back when we first went to sign him, but eventually signed a few months later.
If I'm correct, he joined us with Johnny Carey who was our manager at the time and also managed Roy at Blackburn.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
21:21:31
The obituary for Roy Vernon printed in the Independent bears out what Dave has been saying:
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/people/obituary-roy-vernon-1465927.html
Royston Vernon RIP
Posted
14/10/2015 at
01:03:31
Ray@135 re Ball, I am pretty sure I read about Andy King and how he was sold due to his gambling, unless I dreamed this, Andy King said the same happened to Ball, the signing on fee Ball got helped clear his debts.
Please do not quote me on this but I think that was the reason Ball was allowed to leave Everton.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
01:08:10
Thanks for that, Patrick, what a joy to read.
111 goals in 200 appearances... leading goalscorer in each of four seasons, captain to win the league with a hat-trick in the final game. Roy of the Rovers stuff... only he was not playing for Rovers anymore!
Fantastic stuff.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
01:13:24
David Pretence's interview with Andy King says King leaving because of gambling debts and how King regretted it. King says the same happened to Alan Ball and that is why Everton sold him.
So I hope this clears up in regards to Catterick selling just for a profit not being the case, if we are to believe Andy King.
About these ads
© ToffeeWeb
1 Posted 09/10/2015 at 01:34:53