Ethics in the media
I check out the news quite regularly but unsurprisingly the London and Manchester bias of the media has sprung it's ugly head again this weekend.
Apparently Barcelona and Chelsea are going to battle it out for John Stones.
Manchester United want Brendan Galloway.
And Tim Howard committed the ultimate sin of "begging" a girlfriend to have an abortion.
It would take too long to highlight the way these stories have been embellished but there seems to be a real determination by the media to undermine Everton's rise to challenge the rich 4.
I do not believe this should be allowed to continue.
What I can't understand is, although we are allowed the right to free speech, why these so-called journalists cannot be called into question, made to reveal their sources and, if mythical, lose their journalistic licence and the newspaper sued for whatever damage it has been deemed to have caused.
"According to the Daily Mirror" should not be allowed.
In my opinion the FA should step in and if any media report is found to be false or misleading then suspend that particular organisation from games and take away their press passes.
Anyone else peeved at this nonsense and got any other ideas on how it could be dealt with?
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Posted
13/10/2015 at
20:28:40
Hey, if we didn't have this rubbish, what would we put in the Rumour Mill? The fact is that, for all the speculation, the only big money transfers that happened was Sterling to City and Benteke to the RS.
By a fortunate happenstance, we currently have some really good young players so there is bound to be speculation surrounding their current and future careers.
If the last window is anything to go by, RM is in no mood to sell any of our players and no amount of cash or media pressure appears to budge him from that stance.
The freedom of the press is sacrosanct in this country for far more important things than speculation about footy transfers so we'll just have to put up with it.
Posted
13/10/2015 at
20:34:00
Rumour Mill should be re-titled Humour Mill, because some of the stuff that gets printed, you just have to laugh – otherwise you would end up all bitter and twisted.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
09:27:49
Frank Crewe ... 'the freedom of the press is sacrosanct...' Well, maybe it is... but it depends what you mean by 'freedom', doesn't it? And we have a very tainted idea of what constitutes that freedom in this country don't we?
The press (in the guise of the Daily Mail) was free to forge and publish a letter supposedly written to the Soviet Government by Ramsay MacDonald as Labour Prime Minister. The Daily Mail was free to publish the lie in banner headlines that Miliband's father hated Britain. Various newspapers were free or believed they were free to hack people's telephones. The Daily Telegraph was free to describe Jeremy Corbyn's bicycle as 'Mao Tse Tung style'!
The only freedom the press in this country are interested in is the freedom from all responsibility arising from the lies that they tell, the innuendo they create and even the laws that they break.
When the news broke that John Stones had requested a transfer, Darren Lewis commenced an article on the issue in the Daily Mirror by stating categorically that talks had started between Everton and Chelsea in order to progress the transfer.
Now, this particular 'journalist' had been pushing this transfer as much as he could for a few weeks since the news of Chelsea's first offer. One could only guess at his motivation for that but he does seem to report on most Chelsea games. He may have thought that, Stones having asked for a transfer, it was safe to assume talks had or would soon begin. But, assumptions or not, it was not the truth... he had made it up and reported it as a fact.
In other words, it was a lie and the freedom of the press to lie cannot be sacrosanct – whether it relates to sport or anything else.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
09:49:42
Didn't think you need a licence to be a journalist? Just a criminal record seems to suffice...
It's always been this way. Even back in the 60s and 70s certain publications, and "journalists" employed by said organs, were on the payroll of clubs, and used to unsettle players (and managers). I believe Everton were one of the exponents of this tactic.
With the advent of the Premier League, and all the bullshit around it, it's just mushroomed. Just like we've been left behind financially, we're now on the receiving end of the press rumour mongers. The Internet world just means it's 10-fold. There is nothing we can do about it until we're competing with them on the pitch.
It's probably worse for other clubs. Southampton have had half their team sold (or due to be sold) to the RS and Man U over the last 2 years. This morning, listening to the radio, another pundit had sacked Danny Blind from the Holland job and appointed Ronald Koeman.
The Premier League's job is to promote their product. The FA won't intervene, so we're just gonna have to suck it up, or you'll go mad.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
14:24:08
I fully support freedom of the press to produce / print whatever is genuinely correct or perceived to be correct by the author. What I object to is the loaded bias that drives many journalists and editors. The daily rags are profit-driven concerns and one half expects and lives with the truth being stretched or massaged from time to time without getting wound up.
However, what I find completely unacceptable is the BBC's love affair with the Redshites for several reasons:
1) I am an Evertonian and biased, but honest.
2) I pay a TV license and expect professional neutrality and objective reporting.
3) The respect for the BBC, especially internationally, is one of the great and respected pillars of Britain's (albeit fading) position and influence in global awareness and values. However this will only be undermined if they keep on peddling trash stories about one entity at the expense of a general picture of events. The Premier League is the big attraction – not the Redshites and their hanger-on cronies.
4) Living overseas, where the interest in football is largely superficial compared to the history of grass roots support in the UK, it is fascinating to see how different fans who tend to be more fickle, are actually now questioning exactly why the Redshite (they call them Liverpool or 'the Reds' after the BBC's narrative) are actually so constantly in the media instead of say Man City for example, especially in Abu Dhabi.
5) Latest trumpeting from the BBC, after the recent saturation coverage of such a load of Klopp, is the promoting of Brenda as England's next coach?
6) Last but not least are two subliminal messages in firstly, Lawro downgrading Everton more than any other Premier League team is his weekly review, and second, the sheer lack of coverage of Everton who receive the fewest reports numerically per month than any of the clubs in the league.
Am I bitter, twisted and envious? Of course I am, because the BBC's affinity makes no sense to me. Unless they have as an institution been hoodwinked, sabotaged or their publicity arm has been bought out to an extent by the Redshite's investors?
As a biased but rational taxpayer I will remain 'bitter and twisted' until someone can explain to me exactly why this situation should be as it is.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
15:37:58
You guys need to calm down. This "everyone is against us" theory is getting stale. I notice there doesn't seem to be any complaining when the rumours are about players arriving rather than leaving.
I mean how do you think Southampton's fans felt as their manager and best players were picked off one after another?
How about Villa's fans when Benteke left? Or Liverpool's fans when Suarez and then Sterling jumped ship?
These were real transfers not media rumours. I don't want to lose any of our top players. But when rich clubs have money to burn and their squads need improving speculation is inevitable. So far RM has resisted pressure to sell and, as I have already stated, I've no doubt he will resist any transfer bids in January.
Besides it's not as if we don't do it ourselves. I'm sure Barnsley's fans would have preferred to keep Stones and Holgate but it wasn't going to happen. Richer clubs prey on poorer clubs. Without this there would be no transfers at all.
You want Everton to be sold to a billionaire owner so that we can wave our cheque book around and swan off with other clubs best players without a second thought for their fans yet complain when they do it to us. Bit hypocritical don't you think?
I don't know if the back page journo's have an agenda or not but it doesn't matter. Players don't get sold because of what it says on the back page of some rag. The only thing that talks is money and the guy with the most talks the loudest.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
15:47:22
Frank,
We all know how transfers are done but what I am upset about is the press deliberately inventing stories which undermine and destabilize players and clubs.
It is not speculation. They actually print the most extravagant claims which are ultimately proven to be blatant lies.
I have no problem with reporting factual information such as "Chelsea have just offered 㿒 million for John Stones which Everton have rejected" but to report "John Stones is in contract talks with Chelsea and undergoing a medical" is just pure invention.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
16:45:47
Frank (6): I'm an old guy and quite calm, just extremely pissed off and have been for some time. All the points you make are valid and I agree with them. But you are missing the point. I feel a bit like an angry young man being told to accept the social staus quo (great band by the way) because to rock the establishment simply is not on.
Well the truth is; Everton are either belittled, ignored, patronized, or when they slightly step out of line, are sometimes demonized by the media. You don't like to acknowledge that then fine for you. But consider this. I live in the UAE. I get most of my information from the ToffeeWeb, Everton or Liverpool Echo websites. If I tune in to ToffeeWeb, I get a quiet read interrupted by adverts for the Redshites or Manure.
When I log on to the Echo website and specifically click on to the 'Everton page', the side scroll messages always 12 advert type promoted stories promote / report minimum 11 usually 12 Redshite stories. If I tune in to the 'Liverpool' page, guess what... the 12 side scroll messages all, yes all, feature Redshite stories. Where is the balance and interests in that. If you find the reality of that acceptable or embarrassing then I have no further comment.
Perhaps the Echo Sports Editor might. Remember some months ago there was an enquiry into the imbalanced reporting between the two clubs and why the Reddshites were excessively favoured. It fizzled out and the status quo remains. Happy days (great program, that...)
Posted
14/10/2015 at
17:07:57
Frank,
Freedom of speech...hmmm...if I call someone by what is now regarded as a racist insult I will, rightly, be pilloried for it. So "freedom of speech" has its limitations. So should the "freedom of the press". Not just regarding the crap made up about Everton, but on a wider scale.
How great a step is it from repeating or making up a downright lie regarding the transfer of Stones, to lying about the hacking of a dead schoolgirls phone? If something is clearly made up or deliberately dishonest, it should not be allowed, whether it's a football story or an article that is sure to annoy, upset or deride an individual. Journalists should be held to account for some of the downright rubbish that is printed.
Editorial Team
Posted
14/10/2015 at
17:27:36
William (8): "
If I tune in to ToffeeWeb, I get a quiet read interrupted by adverts for the Redshites or Manure."
Could you describe where you're seeing these adverts, William – i.e. are they in the ad slots in the right-hand column of the website?
I regularly go in to filter out non-Everton ads but I'm often playing catch-up as new ads are added to the Google Adsense system.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
17:38:42
Lyndon,
I also get those type of adverts which have a tab alongside named "Our Network" at the moment I am seeing a Dutch / Man United montage with various sites linked underneath the individual pictures "The Peoples Person", "outside90", "Madrid Galacticos".
The whole section is viewable above the "Add your comments " section and below the posts of the article I am replying on. Hope that helps.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
17:53:24
To quote a line from a Lou Reed song (at least that's where I heard it first though he may have borrowed the line from someone else), "
Only believe half of what you see and none of what you hear."
I'm not sure if Lou had the Daily Mirror / Mail / Sun in mind when commenting on 'what you see' or TalkShite in mind on 'what you hear'.
But every paper has an editorial stance which is unlikely to be impartial. And the 'journos' (use the term loosely) have their own agendas depending on their target market; who provides the best prawn sarnies as well as their own football allegiances.
With respect to football gossip etc, it's often complete dross. Don't waste your time unless you want to.
You're also paying the wages of the likes of (makes expression as though just stepped in something brown and turd-shaped with all the fragrant appeal of a Victorian London sewer) Katie Hopkins and Richard Littlejohn.
(Having said that, did anyone else see Riquelme in Everton Two today?)
Posted
14/10/2015 at
19:09:49
Lyndon, the ToffeeWeb non-Everton marketing comments appear at the bottom usually, sometimes in the middle of the message. In this case just above the "Add Your Comments" dotted line.
Tonight's 4-window box messages are; 1) De Gea refuses to deny release clause rumours. 2) How would Klopp's style vary from Rodgers' at Liverpool? 3) Van Persie mocked by Fener teammates on Dutch struggles and 4) Five reasons Pele is wrong to favour Messi over Ronaldo. Usually the stories feature the Sky Famous 5. A footnote states 'presented by Football Collective.
Not being a computer comfy person, I can appreciate that some extraneous messages are slipped in by marketing middlemen. However what really gets me is why the Liverpool Echo 'Everton' website is bastardised so blatantly against the Blues. That to me is inexplicable ...
Posted
14/10/2015 at
19:42:59
Interesting read this one...
Get in there, William Cartwright!!!
Posted
14/10/2015 at
20:15:50
Long overdue this debate IMO. Who can forget that fat cockney, Martin Samuels in the Daily Mail, taking us to the cleaners about having the nerve to play four on-loan players? Who could possibly forget Sam Wallace (The Independent) going ballistic on national TV about Everton turning down Leighton Baines's chance to play for a "great team"? And more recently, Darren Lewis's unashamed attempt to unsettle John Stones with his constant, and unfounded, rumour mongering?
These hacks can write all the lies they want; what I find offensive is when they quite openly talk about their jollies abroad with the 'big clubs'. There is obviously a conflict of interest when so-called journalists like Rob Beasley admit to free trips to Nice to spend a weekend aboard Abramovich's dinghy. Or other journos wax on about long lazy evenings in Dubai in the company of Sir Alex and his band of merry mancs where the players picked up their tab.
It was quite telling when veteran journo Paddy Barclay pulled up senior scumbag Sean Custiss on Sunday Supplement when Custiss quoted an off-the-record comment made to him by a manager. Barclay aghast said this was proof of how much standards have fallen amongst journalists when a private comment is made public. Ethics my arse. I rest my case.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
20:19:38
William, Patrick – thanks for clarifying. Those "ads" are for articles elsewhere on the Football Collective network of which we are a member. You'll notice that sometimes they're internal links to TW items but mostly they are other football stories.
Our association with FBC is still in the early stages because they're still expanding and building but they have some good things in the pipeline that we hope will beneficial to TW in the future.
That ad strip is a trade-off for our involvement in the network but I think it's preferable to the usual repetitive click-bait ads you see in this style on so many other websites. My feeling is that at least it is related to the game we all love (rather than another baiting link for Celebrities You Didn't Realise Were Gay, etc), even if it means showing links to content about teams we would rather not see.
Posted
14/10/2015 at
20:50:05
Frank (#6), I don't believe everything is against us. However, I most certainly believe that there is an agenda in the media which implies that certain clubs are big and therefore entitled to take any player they chose. Other clubs, including Southampton and ourselves are stepping stones.
Our stance over John Stones was a small victory but we aspire to join the group of clubs who feel they are entitled to have the best players. Sadly, most football journalists are where they are because of an inability to write in the real world. Has anyone ever been entertained or enlightened by the lumpen prose or insipid second hand thoughts of the sad specimen that is Martin Samuel?
Posted
14/10/2015 at
22:55:36
About ethics, I'm a bit worried kids may get to see any of these new videos featuring Roberto on this site... There should be some warnings about parental guidance, or whatever! They (and he...) could be taking 'phenomenal' video reports as the base truth.
I still like his deluded positivism when things go bad, if only because I hope the team finds some solace in there! Somewhere... Shielded from reality anyway by their wages.
Posted
15/10/2015 at
04:19:28
Lyndon (16). Thanks for the clarification. I now understand some of how this computer thingy works behind the screen. Meanwhile, have you or any other ToffeeWebbers any knowledge about the status of the recent 'enquiry' about the Liverpool Echo's bias towards the Redshites? The very fact that there was an enquiry at all speaks volumes about the situation itself.
As I mentioned in my earlier post, if you read the website "Everton" page overseas, the side screen stuff is 95% plus focused on the dark side and not the Blues. Is it the same on the UK website (probably a stupid question), and if it is, how on earth does it continue unchallenged?
Perhaps the answer lies in the rag's name. The "Liverpool Echo" sums it up! Is there a complaints forum I can contact to register my annoyance and frustration at the practice? COYB
Posted
15/10/2015 at
06:29:45
The stories that we complain about, particularly in the tabloids, are fed to the media by players' representatives. This is part of the eternal battle by agents etc to keep their man in the public eye and to negotiate for bigger and better contracts.
The media, of course, needing to fill their pages willingly publishes this stuff, but when you listen to "The Sunday Supplement" you soon realise that the reporters treat such garbage with a large degree of scepticism themselves.
Posted
15/10/2015 at
07:51:11
Rick (#20), that's true but also clubs actively use particular journalists to feed stories as well, if they want to unsettle a player/manager, or even move a player of theirs on. It's got a lot more prevalent in recent years.
Chelsea are arch-exponents of this. As are Man Utd. Pre-Premier League we were also not averse to using the tactic, except in those days it was a lot more subtle.
Posted
15/10/2015 at
08:10:47
Anyone else peeved at this nonsense and got any other ideas on how it could be dealt with?
Yes, stop reading red top rags. Easy really.
Posted
15/10/2015 at
09:10:05
I'm not so sure that the bias is so much to do with just transfers.
I can understand and agree that if richer clubs fancy a player, then they have every right to see if that player could become available. I might be naive but I think that most clubs follow the system and do not get involved in blatant poaching.
What Mourinho did was the exception, he just made public that he wanted John Stones and just thought that was okay... because he's the special one.
What then happened was the press/media (or certain pundits within it) either blatantly supporting Chelsea in their bid, or like Alan Shearer, would use his position as a BBC "Pundit" to tell the world how John Stones's career would benefit by playing alongside John Terry!!!
The press and media are biased, whether consciously or not, and you only have to look at the papers or watch the telly on a Saturday night.
How many papers have an ex-player from LFC or an ex-manager from the same place, spouting their views and perpetuating the publicity for their club?
Then there are the journalists (I use the term loosely) themselves. I'm not talking about Sky or BT, as I only have Pov TV but I understand Concorde conk and Mr Personality bypass Michael Owen are pundits on there. But the BBC had Lawrenson and Hansen on for years (maybe even decades!)
The thing is, I don't even think it registers with the producers/recruiters, that they are being biased.
The papers? Well I've given up with them and now Boycott the buggers. Fat Samuelson in the Mail, now joined by Carra, Dave (Me Biased?) Maddocks in the Mirror and Robbie Savage, Ian (I'm the Chief football correspondent) in the Independent; and, as for the Echo!!! Their Banner is a blood red bloody Liver Bird. I don't mind the Liver Bird but why isn't it Blue?
So, in the end I've Boycotted the bloody lot of them! That's the only way they will pay any attention whatsoever, if enough people stop buying them.
Bitter and twisted... bloody right!
Posted
15/10/2015 at
15:22:23
As I keep saying, my irritation is not so much with the bias but more with the blatant lies that are perpetrated.
The media should not be allowed to "invent" stories. That is what I would like some form of control or legislation on.
Posted
15/10/2015 at
16:30:38
The founder of the BBC, Lord Reith will be spinning in his grave at the so called neutral approach of their football journos. There is defo bias towards the Shite at the BBC, ITV and Sky. While the print media salivate if the Kop construct a sentence in English from the Norwegian.
Posted
15/10/2015 at
16:52:15
William (19), I recall the Echo's perceived biases were discussed at length on these pages earlier this year, around the time of the EFC "summit" they held with a group of fans at their offices and were relaunching the print version of the paper.
Their algorithm (on their website) works around their most popular articles which, with that lot being such a big global brand, inevitably skews that metric in LFC's favour. In fact, Everton-related stories don't stand a hope of being listed in the "Most Read" list but the algorithm for their "Recommended" could and the Echo did promise to look into it.
Since then I've noticed more EFC stories appearing in that list on stories related to us, although the Liverpool items always seem to be listed first.
The cold hard truth of it is that until we start having sustained success, we're always going to be second-class citizens when it comes to media coverage. Stories and ad spends by their fickle nature go where the attention is and that is on the clubs winning stuff.
Posted
15/10/2015 at
16:54:55
Makes perfect sense to me Lyndon apart from the 'winning stuff' business, it seems to me it matters not whether the rich clubs are winning or not they are 'Box Office' because the media largely makes them so.
Posted
15/10/2015 at
18:31:17
Exactly Jay 24. Journos are there to report the news not shape or manipulate it. This lot not only want to decide who moves where but, team selections, tactics, formations etc.... And woe betide the manager who ignores these sages.
Report the bloody news and stop thinking you know more than the professionals and fans!!
Posted
16/10/2015 at
10:17:00
Perhaps there should be special rules applied as to what can be published about Everton. Top of the 'no-no' list must be disparaging comments about Blue Bill and his unique brand of governance.
Then, in times of poor form, any criticism of Roberto or his players. Transfer rumours - both in and out - would be no more whilst the sale of certain journals on Merseyside would be banned overnight.
Freedom of the Press - and Internet - must end. All in the cause of cleansing our minds, of course.
Posted
16/10/2015 at
14:55:26
Lyndon, (26) Thanks again for the insight regarding press production procedures. Most is logical but, sniffing between the lines I sense a restrained response. Speaking with my heart and not my head, I genuinely believe Liverpool are marketed as a big club, which goes a long way to making them a big commercial entity, not necessarily a big club, whether they are in practice or not.
The excessive volume of pro-Liverpool coverage in the BBC compared to for example the relatively low coverage they give Man City is a clear statement of favoritism on behalf of 'The Reds". The question is why? No-one really can answer other than the supposed ' BBC themselves.
My major gripe, as stated previously, is not just the pro-active support for Liverpool but simultaneously the negativity that permeates through most if not all of the pundits who report on or discuss Everton. Perhaps the answer lies in the fact we need institutions and icons, but not too many, otherwise they lose their value, and they take a lot of time and investment to be established.
So credit where it is due to Shankly and Paisley for achieving that; but deary me it was a long while ago...
Also interestingly I read a good article a while back reporting how culturally and in sport, the instances of the underdog achieving success in the States is much more common than in the UK, where the underdog is often perceived as a threat and we would rather see a noble failure. More romantic, but less stable revenue in the long term.
Anyway lets stuff the Mancs tomorrow, all 14 of them (including the FA officials as usual...) COYB!
About these ads
© ToffeeWeb
1 Posted 13/10/2015 at 20:28:40
By a fortunate happenstance, we currently have some really good young players so there is bound to be speculation surrounding their current and future careers.
If the last window is anything to go by, RM is in no mood to sell any of our players and no amount of cash or media pressure appears to budge him from that stance.
The freedom of the press is sacrosanct in this country for far more important things than speculation about footy transfers so we'll just have to put up with it.