Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Vellios, Anichebe, Bent, Johnson, Beattie Stracqualursi, Max-Moore , McFadden and even Jeffers back on loan.
For me, we only had one good striker during Moyes's time and that was the Yak, plus we had two true talented youngsters and one left for Man Utd and the other suffered the same sort of fate as Yak in being badly injured – that was James Vaughan.
Just saying!!
"I was never convinced myself, he strutted around thinking he was Ibrahimavic, in training he would try the same things that he'd seen Ibrahimavic do, he walked like him and even wore the same clothes as him, that's where the comparisons ended though!!"
Enough said.
I think Louis Saha, Yakubu were the two most natural goalscorers under the Moyes era.
I quite liked Andy Johnson, you couldn't knock what he did in his 2 years; he'll always be remembered for sinking the Shite 3-0 .
I do think AJ was a victim of bad luck with his ankle and after a change in the way we asked him to play.
Yak was a natural goalscorer & made it look easy. Saha had some great moments (when not on the treatment table), fastest goal in fa cup history, 4 goals in one game. He was a better player than Yak, but sadly never fully fit for us, but if he was injury free I doubt the Mancs would have sold him to us.
Not forgetting that Dunc was there for part of Moyes reign, he never scored boat loads of goals, but I always loved the way he played.
Vaughan was plagued by injuries, I always felt he could have had a great career, a natural goalscorer with pace & strength...what could have been??
I suppose it goes to show how far we've come on, in terms of players not league placing, over the last few years.
Rom is a little bit better than Vellios.
Saha was a good striker, but he clearly struggled with injuries.
Bent was and always will be a championship striker, yet Moyes turned him into a total work horse to gain us a top 4 place.
I don't go along with the theory Moyes killed all our strikers; my opinion is he always had an almost man or a dud.
Yakubu or Saha were clearly the most talented but injuries plus a bit of a half-hearted attitude screwed their Everton careers.
Beattie and Johnson were the level below the level Moyes had us operating at. We were a top 6 side and they were a mid-table striker, give us a top 6 striker and we would have been top 4.
We had Johnson, the Reds in the top 4 had Torres; we had Beattie, the Reds again top 4 had Cisse and Morientes.
I'm not trying to start a Bring Back Moyes campaign, I'm just stating the facts.
Moyes had us good for a while; if he would have had a Rom, we would have played Champions League football.
As for Vellios, was he any worse than some of the youngsters that Martinez is stockpiling? Let's see how they fare or let's see where they are all playing in a few years time. We need a striker who is ready to step straight into the team now. Were our scouts sleeping when Charlie Austin came on the market?
If you look at Beattie's stats, he made his name, and transfer to us, on a 4-year spell at Southampton when his goals tally was 11, 12, 23, and 14. Not amazing, and not worth a record transfer for us.
And Andy Johnson got his transfer on one season in the Premier League with 21 goals, 11 being penalties, seven which he 'won' himself. If only Saha and Vaughan had been injury-free!
Beattie never got the service from crosses that he needed. but even so he wasn't CL quality.
You can't 'destroy' a striker. Simply none of the people mentioned were good enough, they didn't do it at Everton and they haven't done it since.
As Disraeli said, Lies, Damned Lies and Statistics.
Krøldrup was sold pretty quickly, when it became clear he couldn't even head a ball properly. We didn't lose too much money on him. Simon Davies, Beattie and Bilyaletdinov were sold for decent fees.
A better way to judge Moyes's transfer dealings is to look at the squads he built in the time he was here. Look at the squad he inherited then look at the squad he created 5 years later consisting of all the players he had bought, not players he had inherited from 'Wally Walter':
Howard, Hibbert, Jagielka, Lescott, Yobo, Baines, Osman, Neville, Arteta, Pienaar, Cahill, Yakubu etc...
Then there was the squad he left for Martinez, with the likes of Fellaini, Mirallas and Distin in it a very good squad which Martinez improved with all the extra broadcasting revenue and sale of Fellaini.
All-in-all, Moyes was excellent in the transfer market, considering the lack of funds he had at his disposal. It was just his 'safety first' mentality and lack of imagination that held a good group of players back. Having said that, though, I would love us to be an organised unit like we were back then... with a little bit of the Martinez attacking flair.
No, I'm not saying Moyes was shit in the transfer market. He made some fantastic signings over a decade. It was one of his strengths. I just thought I'd bring up the bad signings because they get overlooked by some of the anti-Martinez mob that frequent this forum.
Personally, I think Martinez is just as good at spotting a player and the tide is turning and most now believe that he can be trusted with a transfer kitty. This wasn't the case last season when posters (not naming) were saying the likes Rom and Besic were a waste of money and just using Kone, Alcaraz (free transfer) and McGeady (£2M nominal fee) to beat Martinez's transfer acumen.
For every Kone, there was a Beattie. For every Alcaraz, there was a Krøldrup or Senderos. And for every McGeady, there was a Shandy.
So I just used that list to point to point out that fans will use selective highlights to serve their agenda. Like when we had posters saying that Martinez was ruining the Moyes legacy by breaking up the team.
No, I think both managers are very good in the transfer market but they just differ on how they feel the game should be played. It's a shame we can't have the best of both. If we could do that, I think we could win the league with this squad we currently have.
Manny Fernandes was a good little player we had for a little while back in them days, shame he chose Valencia over us.
He was quite a cool customer in front of goal. Never smashed it and seemed to pick his spot. Mind you, looked like he picked his spot on that YouTube clip.
Most others were cheap punts like Vellios and Joao Silva that didn't work out (as in all probability, Leandro Rodriguez will not work out either). Is the concept of context so hard to grasp?
Martinez actually thought Alcaraz was good enough for the team. And he even now persists with Kone ahead of his betters. Such a cheap argument to call Moyes transfer dealings 50/50; he sorted us out big time.
I'll meet you halfway he sorted us out small time.
If you looked at the players he brought in after that season, the best signings were probably Heitinga, Jelavic and Distin, which all did ok for some time but really do not feel Cahill-esque. And that in for years time. In the years before, Moyes would find a raw gem every two years or so. He didn't redo that magic. Although, he actually brought in Stones during his last months as a manager. Didn't play him though.
Both the results on the pitch and on the transfer market seemed to slowly fade out after 2009. At that point we were clearly the number 5 team in England and we should have capitalized on that. Didn't do it, Man City and the Spurs did, and the rest is history. Shame really.
Eugene, that is witty but again context is crucial. If you think Everton were small time under Moyes what the hell were we under Smith?
Anyone can do a quick summary of transfers and put Tim Cahill in the plus column and Antolin bloody Peterlin (a virtual trialist for God's sake) in the minus and come out with 50/50 but what worth could that possibly have?
Astute transfer dealings took us from the bottom to perennial challengers for Europe. Then we plateaued and after 11 years without success we wanted more. That is the context Martinez found himself in and the evidence now is we are going all the way back.
I know I am a broken record but as has been pointed out on the 'Genius/insane' thread; factually dubious statements like the 'boring football' myth start gaining traction if not challenged and I would rather enjoy a debate with more substance.
On that note Erik your post makes a lot of sense but the comment; Moyes bought Stones but 'didn't play him though' is another bugbear because, yet again, it doesn't consider the context.
Stones was bought in a January window and then was an unused sub a few times before Moyes left. Why? Because Jagielka and Distin were a solid partnership. So much so that they remained the first choice partnership for Martinez until his spectacular falling out with the errant milkman. Stones got some games but only really came into his own the following season.
If Martinez was sacked tomorrow and in 2 years time our central defence consisted of Holgate and Foulds, I for one would give him credit for signing them even though he 'didn't play them though'.
Same with Barkley; Moyes never played him. Why would he when he had Fellaini in the same position who, no matter how awful he looks now, was a snip for Utd at £27.5 million after banging in 11 from 31.
Stones is probably the best transfer we did this millennium so far; we will either receive an insane amount of money or have the best defender in the country for years to come. The people responsible for getting him in deserve all the credits for this. If Moyes was actively involved in the process then credit must go to him.
But as Stones was only 18 when we bought him, I am not very sure if Moyes was involved that much. He probably will have had a say in the matter and clearly did not stop the transfer from going through, so he has got that going for him.
I just looked at Stones stats before joining us and I see he was a regular in Barnsley's squad before we bought him. Didn't realize that; I thought we bought him straight from their youth ranks and assumed our youth coaches/scouts did the trick. I somehow manage to translate that into "Didn't play him though". But seeing that he played in the Championship every week, Moyes probably did see Stones play and had an active part in the decision-making. That he didn't play him for those couple of months doesn't mean anything as you rightly point out. My bad.
Probably a load of old crap, but the truth is out there!
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 14/01/2016 at 19:04:56