More talk of a Super League...
Those kind souls that read my “rant” entitled “Cold, cold sweat” (regarding the League Cup) will already understand that the constant shelling from the bastard club (using the word bastard in its dictionary form) across the park has left me with the footballing equivalent of post-traumatic stress disorder!!
It takes very little to make me reach for the opiates I'm afraid.
That PTSD flared very briefly this week when my brother (clearly in an effort to send me over the edge) sent me a piece regarding certain teams meeting in London to discuss a “super league”. Yes, we have heard this one many a time before, but the reason for the PTSD occurrence? Quite simple really, I had taken some heart from the purchase of all those shares by Farhad Moshiri. I actually believe that he has the business acumen and passion for football to put the Toffees back in the top group of English teams (I know but I'm getting old and need something to cheer me).
It suddenly hit me, I bet we manage to turn this old juggernaut around and position ourselves as a mighty force in English football just as the other top teams feck off to form a Superleague!! We will be left top of a league without Man Utd, Arsenal, Man City, Chelsea and yes... those Red Bastards!! (using the term bastards in the naughty way now).
They will have dragged the carpet from under us again... its 1985 all over again... aaaarrgh!!!!! I hate hate hate hate them!!!
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Posted
04/03/2016 at
16:48:42
Personally, I don't think it would be a disaster if the "big 5" bugger off to a European Super League. (Are Liverpool really a big team any more, anyway?) It would leave the genuine clubs in a league that would be much more of a level playing field.
I want Everton to be able to compete and win things and I realise that that involves some investment but I never want them to become soulless corporate entities designed only to maximise profit. Besides, after a few years of lack of success, some of the new Euro League teams, hitherto unused to regularly losing, would really suffer.
Playing the same teams each year without the prospects of promotion and relegation and with the travel difficulties, costs and distances precluding regular away supporters, the league would soon wither and the "big" boys would soon come back cap in hand to their national associations. So, let it happen I say. Let the greedy clubs destroy themselves.
Posted
04/03/2016 at
17:12:51
Laughable, really, it's not long ago that Man City were sailing the seas of the third tier in English football, something that they've done that we haven't, as I remind any City "fans" who I talk to, and I also tell them that that is the reason for the three stars on their badge, a reminder of the Leagues that they've played in.....
Then the camels came trotting into town and they're suddenly a BIG club, ready to leave us little beggars behind to clean up the camel shit. I'm with you, Ian, I was apoplectic when I read about the Judas clubs secretly conniving behind the backs of proper football clubs in order to lever even more money out of the Beautiful Game.
And as for the RS, outraged by everything and ashamed of nothing, conveniently forgetful about their past unless it gives them a chance to squawk "Five Times" at us.... A pox on the lot of them.
And... calm... deep breaths...
Posted
04/03/2016 at
17:21:30
Ian, we have a long history of being top of a league without Man Utd. Chelsea, Man City, Arsenal and our neighbours in it, it was called the First Division and existed for 100 years before Sky invented football.
Posted
04/03/2016 at
21:06:55
This whole "Super League" is a joke. Let them (Man Utd, Liverpool, Chelsea etc....) go and play in Asia. Once they get bored of watching that turgid shit, they'll soon come crawling back.
Has Mr Moshiri been accepted by the Premier League yet? Still haven't seen him holding his blue shirt yet next to a smiling Bill Kenwright.
Posted
04/03/2016 at
21:08:24
I truly hope that the 'big 5' (why Liverpool are included in this I don't know?) fuck off to form a European League of their own. I think it is a ploy from the other big European clubs to get their hands on the SKY and BT money. I, personally, think it will flop and will leave a more competitive Premier League for us to play in.
Posted
04/03/2016 at
21:17:48
As do I Sam. I guess though, that the scummy gets will want to have their cake and eat it. Some sort of exclusive invite by the feller whose dreamed this up to a Mini Tournament of "All Star Titans" to take place in America in the Summer.
With maybe a season long Euro challenge where the scumbags take part in, over and above any European Competition they may or may not be involved in, plus still being members of the Premier League. Well I hope the other Chairman fuck them right off and it all goes tits up for the so called big four (oops Famous Five now that the dark side are regularly missing out on the Champions League)
Posted
04/03/2016 at
22:07:55
For the record, I did not include LFC as a big club and never will.
I know the Super League has been bandied about for years. Since 1998 at least. For those thinking it can't happen, wrong. The CL and the Europa League have proven travel is not an issue. Only travel in midweek with league games on weekends has proven to be a problem. They wouldn't have that with playing each other on a weekly (weekend) basis without additional league games to worry about.
As for the TV money, ESPN, NBC, Sky, beIN, and any others will be tripping all over themselves to get in on it. The success of the CL tournament (since that is what it really is) and also of the made-up Guinness Cup over here prove there is a market for seeing Barca and Milan and PSG and Man Utd, and Real Madrid, and Bayern playing each other. If it is a true league of 16-20 teams with a 30-38 fixture schedule who knows where it would go.
I think teams should worry about relying too much on TV money, without paying proper attention to other areas of generating revenue. The TV deal could dry up or shrivel. (Didn't it happen to the Championship and the other two leagues several years ago when the TV deal went belly up?) Putting the money into marketing globally and a stadium and training grounds makes sense more than stuffing it into a player's pockets simply because you can. There has to be a balance.
Posted
04/03/2016 at
22:10:03
IF there was a European Super League then the issue would be that the money and top players would follow. We might be left with a more even field and we might even win the First Division but it would feel more like the Championship.
As to Man City past or RS present form, unfortunately that doesn't matter squat. All they are interested in is TV money and which clubs have the most drawing power.
Posted
04/03/2016 at
23:26:23
Jim, a very sound post in my view particularly in relation to not putting all our eggs in one basket.
I am not sure what the contract is for the TV deal but if that shrunk substantially it would leave over committed clubs up the creek without a paddle.
I have an acquaintance who is a big United fan and a very shrewd businessman that feels that we should "stick with Martinez and grow slowly don't fall into the trap that Liverpool did". For his part he is not impressed with Van Gaal
Posted
05/03/2016 at
00:36:24
I’d like Van Gaal as manager. He has a great record developing young talent.
The Super League will happen. Why? Money. Money always talks. People said the Premier League couldn’t happen and when it was initially planned there was no guarantee that the Football League would cooperate with a promotion/relegation system as the other clubs and fans were horrified by the prospect. But the haves at the time said "screw everyone else" the likes of Stoke City and West Brom – we the elite Liverpool, Everton and Oldham are going for the gold. Yeah eventually things worked in the sense of the relegation issue but it would have happened regardless.
The Super League could go one of two ways. A closed shop like MLB in baseball with the rest of us consigned to minor leagues as nursery teams for Super L teams. Everton may be the feeder team for Liverpool, Spurs for Arsenal and so on.
The other option is having tiers with promotion relegation. The issues with that is there’d be little money thrown at say a European division four. So it would be too costly for say Watford to play home and away games in Moscow, Istanbul or Athens. Realistically two tiers is probably as far as they’d go. So maybe five Premier League teams –let’s say Spurs, Everton, West Ham, Southampton and Newcastle (based on size as with Liverpool as opposed to form) get in alongside Dortmund, Lyon, Benfica, PSV etc. that’s the better option for us if we get in but we may not.
We are in the last chance saloon guys.
Posted
05/03/2016 at
01:09:06
If the People / TV want a "super league" why is all the TV money flowing into the Premier League and not the Champions League.
Why are the viewing figures for the Premier League so much higher than Seria A, La Ligua, ETC? Because people like the product from the premier league, they like the style of play, history, teams involved. That is why the TV money for the Premier League dwarfs anything else in Europe. If the viewing figures were not there than the TV money would not follow.
At the moment there would be zero financial incentive for English teams to join a super league, there would be no extra money for the Premier League teams and they would in theory have a much smaller chance of winning anything or having success.
At the start of each season a Premier League team has the opportunity of playing in 6 competitions (if you count the Charity Shield) and winning 5 pieces of silverware would they really swap that for a chance of winning only a super league?
Posted
05/03/2016 at
03:13:42
I can't help but think all this talk about Super leagues is coming from our American cousins on this thread. As Craig #32 says. We've already got the best brand and league in the world.
Why would anyone want a souped up Champions League?! I personally hate the Champions league and everything it represents. I wish we could go back to the days when it was the European cup and UEFA cup when there was still some excitement from them being knock-out competitions. Yes, I'd love to see Everton in the CL for the kudos it brings, but the competition itself is nearly as bad as the Europa league apart from the money.
I think I'd prefer to keep Martinez than have Van Gaal as manager, Kieran. People moan now about Roberto's obsession with ball retention. Van Gaal is just as bad if not worse and he's spent over £200m to put that spectacle together.
Posted
05/03/2016 at
04:20:26
I think we need to address this European Super League issue.... The big Euro clubs are eyeing the money that the EPL is now generating and see that in five years time all other European leagues will be irrelevant as all the best talent will be plying their trade in England.
If as supposed five "big" clubs breakaway the pot of gold will shift quickly to the super league and Everton will be nothing more than a provincial club playing in a depleted EPL and never having the ability to rise up and be a top club again. Please fervently address this issue.
Posted
05/03/2016 at
04:36:50
But would we want to join a European Super League if we were invited?
Posted
05/03/2016 at
14:33:07
Filler for dead-air space and blank Word documents.
ManCity LFC and ManU are going to step off the EPL financial gravy train? In whose fantasy?
BM dump the Bundesliga? For what reason?
RM and Barca already break transfer records. EPL TV money doesn't worry them.
PSG is guaranteed a Champions League spot before a game is played. They're giving that up?
This is a story puts the "Non" in Non-starter.
Posted
05/03/2016 at
16:08:25
I can't see it happening unless all European football leagues are involved in some way. Not just promotion or relegation but would other countries involved want 5 English clubs in an 18 team league?
Deciding who would be left out and who would benefit would, I think, see the whole thing fall apart.
Let's try it, 5 English, 3 Spanish, 4 German, 3 Italian, 2 French....I think we've just run out of places and even if it was 20 that only leaves 3 places for the rest of Europe. Or would it be groups of 5 on a seeded basis with the top 2 into further groups and then play-offs for a Grand Final.
Sounds like a decimation of all leagues.
Posted
05/03/2016 at
22:48:02
Gavin and Craig,
I gave you the answers to your questions. The money is currently in England because of the American market and fans adopting the EPL as one of its own leagues thus generating the huge TV deals. I can see every EPL game every week. Can you over there?
Look at how successful the EPL is with teams like Aston Villa and Sunderland etc. Now just think how big a TV deal could be for a league that has truly good teams from top to bottom.
The Guinness Cup sold out every game over here. The Chinese and Indian markets will open also creating bigger TV deals. The money willl come from there and also the original European countries.
The world has changed so that anyone can choose any club to root for. The league is not important and neither is the country of the team to a large portion of the fans. I would bet (no data to back it up) that new fans to Barca, Bayern, Real Madrid, Juventus, and Atletico outstrip new fans to Everton, Stoke, Watford, West Ham over the last 4 years. Why? Because those are the teams playing in the top competition (the CL). Otherwise, the Club WC would be the biggest draw right? I would also bet that the majority of those fans do not hail from the country of the club they follow.
Maybe it is the Americans to blame for this round of talks but not for the first round and not for the CL. Why wouldn't these top teams want to play each other on a regular season basis? Face it, regular league games are a mere formality for most of the perennial favorites for the CL. Only in the EPL are the same four not going to go this season.
Posted
06/03/2016 at
09:19:17
Could it just be that the greedy clubs are paying lip service to the idea as a way to threaten to the EPL that they will leave for newer riches if the EPL do not take on board their (the clubs) idea of a 'fairer' distribution of the telly rights money to give them the most proportionate share as they have the greatest world-wide fanbases.
Posted
06/03/2016 at
09:31:01
Eric #19, the Domestic TV deal (Sky, BT, MOTD and radio) is the bulk of the broadcast revenue, and has fuck all to do with world-wide fanbase.
The overseas TV deal is currently split equally across all 20 teams in the EPL, and as far as I'm aware, only Liverpool were arguing for that to be distributed based on their global reach. Aside from the obvious question of how do you measure (and audit it remember that in Asia they wear the top of whoever the current champions are), none of the other clubs backed that proposal when it was tabled a couple of years ago even Man Utd.
The current revenue distribution of (I think) 25% equal share, 50% on appearances (with minimum of 10), 25% prize money has for long been the most equitable in Europe. The winners of the Prem Money League get roughly 1.66 what the team finishing bottom (of the earnings league) gets.
In Spain where they negotiate their own deals it's around 22:1 for Barca and Real versus "the rest".
Only now as the revenue increases, and clubs are finding it harder to stockpile all the talent (or, like the RS, insist on wasting it on shite) are clubs able to buy and importantly retain their own talent to compete and what difference it's made this season.
It's bitten the Premier League on the arse the last thing they needed was the top 4/6 cartel being broken it really doesn't do the UEFA co-efficients any good. (Remember, City were gash in Europe for the first few seasons after the Thai and then UAE money rolled in).
Posted
10/03/2016 at
08:12:52
One of the many questions over the attractions of a so-called European Super League is just how many teams there are the average fan would actually want to watch on a regular basis.
Personally I wouldn't be attracted by the visits of more than a handful: RM, Barcelona, Bayern Munich certainly; AC and Inter Milan, and Juventus probably. Couldn't see many salivating at an annual visit from Shaktar Donetsk! And as for making the away fixture......
About these ads
© ToffeeWeb
1 Posted 04/03/2016 at 16:48:42
I want Everton to be able to compete and win things and I realise that that involves some investment but I never want them to become soulless corporate entities designed only to maximise profit. Besides, after a few years of lack of success, some of the new Euro League teams, hitherto unused to regularly losing, would really suffer.
Playing the same teams each year without the prospects of promotion and relegation and with the travel difficulties, costs and distances precluding regular away supporters, the league would soon wither and the "big" boys would soon come back cap in hand to their national associations. So, let it happen I say. Let the greedy clubs destroy themselves.