A Blue Dream Team
I recently found myself playing that age-old pub game of naming the best Everton fantasy team of the past 50 years.
The idea was to assemble a team of players who had worn the 'Blue Jersey' at some point in their careers judged by their overall peak performances. I dutifully selected a team which I believe would have broken all scoring records, played incredibly exciting football, whilst playing solidly at the back. May I invite comments please?
My 'Blue Dream Team' (Playing in a 4-4-2 formation) comprises;
SOUTHALL
COLEMAN, WATSON, LABONE (capt.) WILSON
STEVEN, BALL, BEARDSLEY, SHEEDY
LINEKER, ROONEY
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Posted
19/03/2016 at
12:18:53
South all Pscyco Labby Rats Wilson
Holy Trinity plus Dave Thomas
Latch and Lineker
Posted
22/03/2016 at
17:12:29
I find it impossible to select an XI. I will wager that the only two names that are going to appear on everyone's teams in this thread are those of Southall and Ball.
Posted
22/03/2016 at
17:24:17
I can only name players that I've actually seen play. I'd go for:-
Southall
Coleman, Watson, Ratcliffe, Baines
Steven, Reid, Bracewell, Sheedy
Rooney, Lukaku
Subs: Beardsley, Ferguson, Kanchelskis, Arteta, Lescott.
Posted
22/03/2016 at
17:39:40
No Everton dream team in their pomp and prime could be without Alan Ball and Andrei Kanchelskis. Those two players alone could score at least 35 league goals between them.
Next, add Dave Thomas and Bob Latchford and there is another 35 goals. Throw in Rooney with another 20 league goals, 5 players would contribute with 90 goals plus assists. Making a grand total of over 100 goals.
With players like that, forget about emphasising a defence, because the dream team would win every match, whatever the final score.
Posted
22/03/2016 at
22:58:07
Coleman for Gary Stevens. As much as I admire Coleman, he wouldn't lace those Le Coq Sportif boots of Gary.
I have spoken to Blues fans young and old and every one of them simply say this: The greatest Everton side they have ever seen was the 85 Bayern Munich and Rapid Vienna side. And I have spoken to guys who witnessed the 60s, 70s sides. It's all about opinions. But that Rotterdam side was fucking untouchable.
Posted
22/03/2016 at
23:17:10
Mr Johnson #5. Sir, you hit the nail on the head. Proudly, I say I was there. Surely there are players who may well possibly been better than those on the night.
But the reality is that "a team of players" was that on display that night.
Sure there are a few that may have had a claim to a place on fantasy football, but as a team of players I will have to leave them as I saw them.
Posted
22/03/2016 at
23:24:43
And just before my blood boils, a team denied the ultimate success the next year, not by footballers, and a club that can possibly (obviously) trace its demise to this point in its long distinguished history.
Bitter? Bitter? Don't even get me there. Pass me my blood pressure tablets. Brian Clough said in the commentary of the game, that we were the best team in Europe.
I love my Everton, and I love my Neville Southall, Neville Southall, and I love my ......
Posted
23/03/2016 at
21:54:44
Well said, Ian, I can remember that night in Rotterdam like it was yesterday. As Ratters lifted that glistening trophy, I cried tears of joy.
Yes, because we had won our first European trophy. But also that now we had a team to challenge that shite across the park and further afield.
And then it all changed. We have every right to be bitter. They changed everything for us.
Posted
23/03/2016 at
22:32:45
Kevin (#5)
Er... you never spoke to me. I might be in a minority but as a TEAM I think that the 69-70 side were better. Kendall, Ball and Harvey are three reasons.
Interestingly, if you pick a best TEAM that you've seen who, would compliment each other as a team should, you'd probably have a different (and better) side than if you picked a team of the best players. Alex Young is my all time favourite but would he get in my best team? Difficult.
Lineker, Sharpe, Latchford, Young, Gray, Royle, Vernon, even Pickering... midfield or wide; Kendall, Ball, Harvey, Rooney, Kanchelskis, Morrissey, Steven, Beardsley, Scott, Reid, King, Sheedy, Bracewell, Heath, Temple, Stevens, Kay... see what I mean?
And don't get me started on the defence... but there's one name that will appear on every ones team... Southall.
Posted
23/03/2016 at
22:41:22
Ray,
I'm sure Young and Vernon would walk into any Everton team in any era.
Posted
23/03/2016 at
23:00:14
Maybe, John, but it'd be a difficult job to sort such a wealth of truly great players into a team...
Posted
23/03/2016 at
23:08:21
Young and Kay certainly, Harvey and Steven were classic Everton players.
The most ferociously gifted player I have seen in blue, albeit in a flash of excellence with us, was the young Rooney and, in particular, the 0-0 Bolton game when he gave a performance that was probably the most astonishing I have ever seen live in many years of watching.
So many names though as others have said.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
10:45:07
The greatest Everton team I have seen is the 69-70 side. Pure class throughout the team from goalkeeper to striker. The best midfield ever, a great captain and special mention of Johnny Morrisey who was immense that season. Wonderful days.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
10:55:23
Andrew, the amazing thing about 1970 is that we were a young side and also had seemingly great youngsters coming through like Buckley, Kenyon, Whittle and Dave Johnson. We were superb and the future seemed golden but a season later we were finished. This was where our decline began and the mid-80s success was just a blip on the way down.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
11:13:08
Andrew,
Morrissey was one of my favourite players, hard as nails as Jack Charlton and Tommy 'Thug' Smith would acknowledge, but fast and capable of a superb cross. What I'd do to have him going down our left flank now. We'd see how hard the likes of Terry, Skirtl and Cahill really are. He also won two Championship medals in 62-63 and 69-70.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
11:24:45
Martin, I remember the season after the 1969-70 Championship win well. My mate and I won season tickets for the Upper Bullens Road stand on the halfway line after spending the previous few years on the Gwladys St end.
Things were never the same again but I'm still here hoping for those days to come back.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
11:29:35
I'm well stricken in years and have suffered and rejoiced in watching the most infuriating and wonderful club in the world since 1954 so I've seen the good the bad and Bernie Wright.
My highly subjective choice would be (rose tinted spectacles and all)
Southall
Wright
Labone
Ratcliffe
Wilson
Ball
Kay
Harvey
Kanchelskis
Lineker
Vernon
Subs
West
Collins
Kendall
Sheedy
Latchford
Young
Morrissey
My favourite team was 1962-63 team, the first great Everton team since the war, and I was young and optimistic. I was spoiled at an early age and have had high expectations since, despite all the evidence to the contrary.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
11:57:37
Are we talking about the last 50 years, going back to 1966? Some posts mention Vernon, Collins etc who played before that date.
If it's open to all years, we cannot omit Dean and players from that era.
If we're opening it up to the '50s and early '60s, then Collins, Vernon and Tony Kay would definitely be in my team.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
13:26:01
Mike, I took it as teams that we'd actually witnessed, sure, 50 years would mean omitting the 62-63 side but what the hell!
Chris has the ultimate back four, although teams didn't line up as such then. Possibly Stevens for Wright? He was the finer athlete but it'd be a close thing.
Kendall for Kay and Steven on the wing, up front? Christ knows. Vernon and Sharp, maybe, or Young and Vernon, or Young and Sharp.... nurse! Help!
Posted
24/03/2016 at
13:50:45
Tough ain't it Ray?
Some positions are easier than others though.
Southall, West, Martyn in Goal
Wilson, Baines, Hinchcliffe Left Back
Ball no alternatives
The rest are down to personal choice, memories, age and possibly prejudice.
My personal non negotiables are Vernon and Harvey, because as I say I was young and I'd never seen the like of Roy Vernon before. Before that there was Dave and Bobby Collins, but Vernon was special. Colin Harvey was massively underrated, great skill allied to industry. Also I went to the same school as him (and church) but I don't think that's an influence on me, because he was the 'White Pele'.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
13:52:00
On another note. Very sad to see the passing away of the great Johann Cruyff today.
A wonderful player, one of the true all-time greats.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
20:46:23
Ray @9 Like I said it's all about opinions. You have included some legendary players into your dream team. Not so sure about Wayne, for me he's similar to Franny Jeffers. Went too earlier, without gaining Goodison Greatness for me. But again, that's what I think.
The '85 team achieved something none of the others have. And I doubt will in the near future as a team, Ray, excluding national teams.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
21:04:02
Dream Team:
Southall
Stevens Labone Ratcliffe Baines
Kanchelskis Ball Reid Sheedy
Lineker Rooney
Posted
24/03/2016 at
22:39:12
Kev (#22),
At least we've been lucky enough to see true greatness in an Everton team, I've said before today that I really feel for the younger fans who've yet to experience that feeling, that we're Champions, after sweeping away everyone else before us. Wonderful, wonderful feeling.
Posted
24/03/2016 at
23:06:04
Southall
Gidman
Todd
Labone
Pejic
Ball
Kendall
Harvey
Thomas
Latchford
Mackenzie
Subs:
Wood
Lyons
Stevens
Reid
Morrissey
Sharp
Lineker
Posted
24/03/2016 at
23:55:02
I tend to agree with Kevin #22.
If we're picking the Everton FC Dream Team, it should be based on how they performed during their time here. (Also, on who you've actually seen play). For me, I'm sorry but Rooney was distinctly average in his last season with us.
It's not easy picking the team though, is it? (Can you imagine any of their faces in reaction to a Roberto Martinez team talk?)
A measure of the quality of those selected is indicated by some of the notable omissions for example:
Richard Gough. Ian Snodin. Adrian Heath. Andy Gray. Nigel Martyn.
Imagine having the likes of those lads in the current team, let alone the first choices.
Posted
25/03/2016 at
08:21:35
Colin#25
Colin Todd, who only turned out 32 times for us?
Ahead of Ratcliffe? Watson? Mountfield? Even Gough?
Pejic before Wilson? Baines?
Oh dear...
Posted
25/03/2016 at
13:12:01
Ray @24 well said. I pity the younger generation of our fans. For me, the late 70s and 80s, then the majestic mid-80s were magical days. I only hope this new guy grabs this wonderful sleeping giant of a club by its shirt and steers us to those past glory days. It's why we worship this great club.
Posted
25/03/2016 at
14:23:38
Picking and agreeing on what would be the best team would cause to many arguments, Bobby Collins and Tommy Ring never won anything with the Blues but it would be hard to leave them out, and how could Ieave out Johnny Morrissey, one of my favourite players and leave out the magical Tommy Ring.
Even picking out the best team from any era would be just about opinions, I'd go for the 1962-63 team, but wouldn't argue too much over the 1970 team. The 1984-85 team gave us back our pride but wasn't as good as the others, only my opinion.
Finally I loved Colin Harvey but would always go for Howard Kendall first, and Tony Kay over those two, I'm getting off here before I start arguing with myself.
Posted
25/03/2016 at
14:41:35
International recognition and international achievements should be an indicator how good Everton players were in the past. Alan Ball and Ray Wilson were in the 1966 England team that won the World Cup. Ray Wilson was in the previous Everton team in 1966 that won the FA Cup. Gary Lineker was an amazing goalscorer for both Everton and England.
Posted
25/03/2016 at
15:29:52
I am sure we could post 100 times and come up with a different team.
There literally have been truly great players seen at GP.
Interestingly I would not pick any of the current team.
For me there are some absolute shoo-ins that would have to be included.
Big Nev (the best GK I have ever seen)
Ray Wilson (Bainsey on steroids) what a class LB..
Howard Kendall (One of the best all round MF players) He could tackle, pass short, pass long and score goals and had a terrific engine.
Labby (A true Corinthian and exceptional leader)
Tony Kay (Cruyff like with a biting tackle, had stepovers sorted way before they became fashionable)
Roy Vernon (The Welsh wizard, could dribble around the opposition from his own half and then round the goalie for fun and slot it in) Would make Ross seem like a Tranmere reserve in comparison.
Alan Ball (Legend need say no more)
The rest:-
Choose anyone from Alex Parker, Gary Stevens, Seamus, David Weir, Gough, Stubbs, Watson, Ratters,Psycho, Reidy, Bracewell, Paul Powers, Sharp, Latchford, Dave Thomas, Trevor Steven, Sheedy. Inchy. Andy King, Johnny Morrisey, Kanchelskis, The Golden Vision. I have left Rooney out because he didn't make it as an Everton player. He had his chance but chose the Mancs.
Very interesting that Ball and Kendall were playing top class football in their teens none of this shit about they are still learning the game at 23 years of age.
Posted
25/03/2016 at
15:51:05
Is it possible the best Everton players could have all come in the last ten years?
The '85 team was, like all other clubs at the time, made up almost entirely of British players. Was there a golden generation of Brits at that time or is it simply that importing players from around the world, the supposed leap in quality this provides for the current top flight, would mean Everton of '85 would be also rans?
So given that could be true, I'll offer...
Southall
Coleman Watson Yobo* Baines
Drenthe* Arteta Fernandez* Pienaar
Beardsley Lineker
*Slightly shame faced with this, but if we're talking in their pomp then Yobo was a phenomenal (cough) in his first season, Drenthe was great if the pubs closed early the night before and Fernandez in his first spell was a class apart.
Posted
26/03/2016 at
13:52:26
Nick
I can only conclude the pubs were open late last night as the reason you are putting Yobo, Drenthe and Fernandez in such a team. Even Arteta and Pienaar who were good players for us given the other players vying for their slots in their positions.
The mid 80s side won a European trophy and would definitely (obviously I can't prove this) have won the European Cup if not for our lovable neighbours at a time when British clubs were dominating European competition, so your theory is very flawed. Players can only be the best in their own time and the mid 80s were the best. Earlier sides did not do well in Europe so there is a bit of a benchmark comparison there.
Posted
26/03/2016 at
14:11:31
My dream team... 4-4-2:
Southall
Coleman, Ratcliffe (Capt) Kay, Baines
Kanchelskis, Reid, Ball, Speed
Lukaku, Lineker
Posted
26/03/2016 at
17:13:53
Supporting Everton for about 45 years or so, I recall a couple of nearly moments in the '70s that never quite came to fruition. In the '90s Joe Royle quickly got a team together that clawed inexorably up from the bottom of the table & capped it all by winning the FA Cup too. However, I'd have to say the best teams in my time were those who achieved so much in the mid-'80s.
Disregarding all that, if I were to select a team of my favourites over my time as a supporter it would be:
Southall;
Stevens; Watson; Ratcliffe; Baines;
Steven; Bracewell; King; Thomas;
Latchford; McKenzie.
Posted
27/03/2016 at
22:45:11
Marc Hottinger
Carl Tiler
Ian Marshall
Mitch Ward
Stefan Rehn
Ray Atteveld
Ian Wilson
Michael Branch
Brett Angell
Stuart Barlow
Just can't decide on my goalkeeper Richard Wright or Paul Gerrard.
I think this team of legends would just keep us up!
Posted
27/03/2016 at
23:08:18
Peter Laffey, that's a cracking team. Glad you found a place for Ian Wilson, a much underrated turkey.
The sad thing is, I've watched Everton for fifty years and you could probably squeeze three really good teams out and about thirty-three teams of selling players.
Interesting debate as to the better of the 69-70 and 84-85 teams. I was a kid when watching in 69-70, although I went to plenty of games (beating Man Utd away and home in the space of a week takes some beating). I was a bloke by the time 84-85 came along so probably appreciated it more, especially given how shite the seventies were.
Too close to call.
Posted
27/03/2016 at
23:27:43
Seriously in my life so far, I can't get past 84-85 & 86-87 title winning teams.
Big Nev
Stevens
Rats
Big Dave
Physco
Tricky Trev
Reidy
Brace
Sheeds
Sharp
But I couldn't decide who would be his partner?
Andy Gray
Inchy or Lineker
And imagine A fully fit Big Dunc with Steven & Sheedy supplying the ammunition.
I've watched it a few times Sky Sports 'Time Of Our Lives' with Howard, Colin Harvey & Joe Royle. Jeff Sterling posed the question "Who could you take out of one side and put in the other from the 69-70 side and the 84-85 side?" and basically they said they couldn't.
About these ads
© ToffeeWeb
1 Posted 19/03/2016 at 12:18:53
Holy Trinity plus Dave Thomas
Latch and Lineker