BBC have just announced VAR is coming in next season, while the League Cup will no longer have
replays extra time, going to penalties if games are tied after 90 minutes.
Extra time will now only be played in the final at Wembley, while the ABBA penalty format is also to be scrapped.
Also, Premier League clubs will be given a winter break in February starting in the 2019-20 campaign. The break will be staggered across two weeks, with five games set to be played each weekend, meaning the FA Cup 5th round will be moved to accommodate the changes.
Reader Comments (51)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
1 Posted 08/06/2018 at 14:52:44
Also the replays... tell you what. Just scrap the whole thing. We never win it anyway.
As for the supposed winter break, sounds like it's a weekend off for half the teams at a time?
2 Posted 08/06/2018 at 15:02:34
The winter break is something we definitely need. I was waiting for more information to understand what they mean by half the games one week and half the next. It sounds very vague. I suppose if you play week A, then you miss the next weekend and so have a two week break, and if you play week B then you miss the first weekend and get a two week break that way, whilst TV doesn't miss out.
3 Posted 08/06/2018 at 15:06:27
Changes in any sport should be applicable at all levels; nevertheless, I get the argument for VA at the top level.
As for the mid-season break, I'm sure the teams will have high profile friendlies or warm weather camps which will piss the public off no end.
4 Posted 08/06/2018 at 15:21:29
There will be no replays in the FA Cup from the fifth round onwards, which will also be played in midweek, if that's what the OP means?
5 Posted 08/06/2018 at 15:30:44
Seeding also removed, so that means we could be drawn against a Premier League team in Round 2.
6 Posted 08/06/2018 at 15:39:16
7 Posted 08/06/2018 at 15:51:26
8 Posted 08/06/2018 at 15:58:52
I feel another lament from John McFarlane Snr coming on...
9 Posted 08/06/2018 at 16:52:26
VAR can make anything look like a foul. Prepare for games taking 10 minutes longer to finish and for few VAR judgements being 100% accepted as correct post-match.
Anyway, I thought the Premier League had already decided against its introduction this season?
10 Posted 08/06/2018 at 16:59:51
Oh wait a minute
11 Posted 08/06/2018 at 17:08:05
12 Posted 08/06/2018 at 17:13:43
13 Posted 08/06/2018 at 17:20:57
14 Posted 08/06/2018 at 17:25:04
So the moneyed boys, the rich owners, the financial club backers, have now had their concerns addressed, but at what will undoubtedly be a cost in terms of the enjoyment of the spontaneity, drama, and flow that football provides to the spectator.
15 Posted 08/06/2018 at 17:29:06
But not surprising. Same game played by G7 countries for years.
Seems a sad inevitability to this and fans are so partisan they will probably never get together to save their game.
I understand the hope that Everton climb into the top 6 to benefit but in end we would just be part of a tedious moneyfest. Remember that Python sketch when the guy ate so much he just exploded?
16 Posted 08/06/2018 at 17:34:47
17 Posted 08/06/2018 at 17:49:19
I'm positive about VAR in general. Getting it right with only a few seconds' delay is a good thing – yes, driven by money, but also by justice. There are always hiccups in deploying a new VAR system, along with lots of grumbles from traditionalists, but here in the US we've seen video review systems deployed in all the major sports, and generally it has proven to be more and more positive as the systems have gotten quicker and less disruptive.
18 Posted 08/06/2018 at 17:50:21
They wouldn't have even got to the final if VAR was already in place.
19 Posted 08/06/2018 at 18:11:12
On the other matter concerning the League Cup, can anyone explain the rationale of doing away with extra time?
To my mind, extra time is fairer in determining who goes through and it is often the case that the extra 30 minutes is the best and most entertaining part of the whole game.
Also, doesn't it provide the managers of the Premier League sides the opportunity of giving fringe squad members and youngsters a greater chance of getting on the pitch?
Against all this, the benefits of having no extra time are...?
20 Posted 08/06/2018 at 18:38:07
21 Posted 08/06/2018 at 18:53:28
But the incidents in the Final involving Ramos, if VAR was in operation, would very possibly have resulted in two bookings and so a sending off. Yet they are far from clearcut and so ultimately just as subject to the VAR judge operator's personal opinion as the ref's.
You don't think my perspective is somewhat biased here, do you?
22 Posted 08/06/2018 at 20:06:31
Slowly, but surely, the magic is being sucked out of the FA Cup.
23 Posted 08/06/2018 at 20:22:02
I wonder if you can tell me how the clubs further down the pecking order will view the apparent injustice of not only operating without the present technology, but falling behind in what will surely follow? It appears to me that promotion and relegation issues are only of importance to the Premier League (formerly First Division) and Championship (formerly Second Division). What started in 1888 as a 12-club competition and was built up over the years into a 92-club competition, is being fragmented slowly but surely by the greed of the few.
I was naïve enough in 1992 to believe that, with the formation of the FA Premier League, the only thing to change would be the name, but – and it saddens me to say this (as Everton were prime movers in establishing the greed culture), the game which to an extent was always about money, became likened to a 'pigs at the trough' bonanza.
With regard to the abolition of matchday programmes, and extra time in what I still refer to as the League Cup, I feel that the most important person, the supporter, is being disregarded completely, and I consider it one more sad day for football. I can feel my enthusiasm for the game rapidly waning.
24 Posted 08/06/2018 at 20:24:37
Not sure if the stats bear that out.
One might argue the lower ranked side has a punchers chance, the lottery if you will if it goes straight to pens, Maybe?
You might feel extra time creates mores injuries through fatigue, we all know rolling subs would sort that out, again perhaps.
My preference has always been for it to be settled in extra time, by reducing the number of players to 7v7. It would in my view be both exciting and get a result without the lottery of a penalty shoot out.
One sudden death period of 15 minutes and rolling subs would give us a result more often than not I would think.
For many people for the golden goal thing was an issue, further encouraging both teams to sit back, but with seven players that cannot happen, too much open field to exploit.
It would lead to tactical innovation and new ideas to win a game. It would encourage attacking play and ultimately finish the game playing football rather than the angst of the shoot out.
The idea might seem too noveau or ‘American sports styleee! But is the way we settle cup games now really any good? Id argue not. Its dated, archaic and rarely exciting.
Real innovation in ‘the game is sadly lacking of changes as rightly pointed out are feared around money.
Anyone tell me the last game Everton played in that had an exciting ET period? Maybe West Ham away but I cannot bring many to mind?
25 Posted 08/06/2018 at 20:30:54
I just don't see the point, it will kill emotion and atmosphere at games.
I think for the TV viewer it gives another dimension and talking point for the punters but will ruin the game for the match going fan.
26 Posted 08/06/2018 at 20:37:19
Sounds like a wind-up!
27 Posted 08/06/2018 at 21:12:33
Sometimes, I think I get more fun/enjoyment watching Bangor City, my local team, but I couldn't give up on the Blues if I tried.
28 Posted 09/06/2018 at 19:19:35
Just glad I'll be unaware of it all when it comes to pass — that's if compulsory euthanasia hasn't been voted in to save what is left of the fast dwindling public money. Remember Rollerball?
29 Posted 09/06/2018 at 19:33:18
I do think FA Cup ties should be sorted on the day, for every round. Yes, I know smaller clubs getting an away draw is a great result and then going back to their place,but if the original draw goes their way and they get a home tie, there will still be cup upsets.
Also, remember when we drew 1-1 with Altrincham in the 70s at Goodison, I was happy with a replay; now it would go to pens!!!
30 Posted 09/06/2018 at 19:38:13
31 Posted 09/06/2018 at 19:43:44
In my opinion the best of the lot was Adrian Heath's winner at Highbury against Southampton in 1984 - Howard hadn't even realised that extra time was to be played at 90 minutes.
32 Posted 09/06/2018 at 20:10:38
The Gosling game was over 10years ago the others decades back, perhaps I was pointing to recent history and moreover extra time in general.
The general trend in cup competitions of all iterations is one of soporific almost passive encounters which live but a beat in ones memory.
I really think its time to shake it up!
33 Posted 09/06/2018 at 20:18:41
34 Posted 09/06/2018 at 20:35:30
The real fun started later on in the Fulham workies, when the bizzies asked about a hundred Evertonians to keep the noise down, drink up and go home... now that did go into extra time.
35 Posted 09/06/2018 at 20:44:02
I haven't studied the latest proposals, but I'm led to believe that changes threaten the FA Cup and what we knew as the League Cup, and as I understand it, our poor footballers are in need of a winter break, which amounts to a complete weeks rest; no doubt they will return to the fray reinvigorated.
Football has just said goodbye to Ray Wilson, who played 35 League, 8 FA Cup, and 4 European games for Everton in the 1965-66 season, followed a couple months later by 6 appearances for England in the World Cup, the Final of which was played on Saturday 30 July 1966.
The start of the Football League season 1966-67 was Saturday 13 August 1966, preceded by the Charity Shield game against Liverpool. 'Oh Happy Days'.
36 Posted 09/06/2018 at 20:55:53
fondly remember the likes of the Sheff Utd team of Tony Currie and Alan Woodward, Clough's Derby and then his Forest, the Huddersfield of Fran Worthington vintage and Bobby Robson's Ipswich, all of whom were promoted into the top division and continued to play attractive winning football, with Cloughie way out as the most successful.
For decades now everyone knows before the season kicks off who's going to be top six and it's become way too boring as a consequence.
37 Posted 09/06/2018 at 21:57:43
The referee is meant to be a bastard, linesmen are meant to be blind, pitches are meant to be heavy, slow, angry defenders are meant to get away with it.
We are devoping a sanitized version of football that makes me despair. Skill has always thrived but it took skill and character to thrive in the past. George Best never dived, went down as though shot by a sniper or brandished imaginary yellow cards.
There is one massive attribute lacking in too many professional footballers and that is the ability to feel shame or embarassment. I don't begrudge them a penny of their fortunes but I hope that our new coach will realize that integrity should be installed in every lad at Finch farm.
This has been typed on a failing kindle so, apologies for typos etc.
38 Posted 09/06/2018 at 21:59:58
39 Posted 10/06/2018 at 00:11:23
40 Posted 10/06/2018 at 03:49:32
I have also witnessed the use of VAR at a live game or two this year at the LA Galaxy and – to be none too poetic – it fucking sucked the life out of the game.
Cue... 'The video's a wanker...'
41 Posted 10/06/2018 at 22:23:51
If you can't score in 90 minutes, then how much more time do you want? Good, it'll go to penalties, so then we might see two teams going for it knowing the outcome will be settled that day via penalties. The aim of the game is to score more goals so I'm up for it.
Plus the game has changed hence the poor lads might be knackered and replays is more time playing for mega money and they're getting a winter break too. Bless em.
42 Posted 10/06/2018 at 22:41:06
43 Posted 10/06/2018 at 23:36:07
League games are 90 minutes but you can draw, but we are taking about cups. Makes sense to me.
44 Posted 12/06/2018 at 14:15:35
As for the League Cup part... does it matter? No doubt we won't turn up and no Blue (apart from me) will give a flying fuck about the competition.
We never bothered for the first 58 years... why start bothering in its 59th year? Moshiri, Brands & Silva haven't mentioned either of the domestic Cups so far... and therein lies the major problem!
45 Posted 12/06/2018 at 14:50:55
Michael @1, I hope you're just trying to cry it in, mate, because I'm desperate for my kids to see Everton running round Wembley with any cup!
46 Posted 12/06/2018 at 15:50:03
I admit they have a thankless job but when they became full time professionals I thought things would improve. They didn't.
My biggest beef is when they don't have the guts to call penalties on defenders who clutch and grab but would rather cop out and call it against the offensive player.
The offside call should only be made when there is clear daylight between the forward and last player. Change the rule for God's sake as there is too much guesswork to flag it when players are level.
Other decisions are acceptable when the referee clearly cannot see it but now, with a fourth official, they should be seen surely.
47 Posted 12/06/2018 at 16:41:53
In its current guise, its a complete clusterfuck. The crowd in the stadium has no clue whats going on. Even if the referee does review an incident himself he does so on a small CCTV screen. Why not use the big screens in the stadium? Are they scared of unrest amongst the fans? Why dont other sports have that worry? Why cant we listen to the referees discussions?
For me, some decisions being wrong is a part of the game. Even with VAR, it appears that decisions about offsides and fouls are still subjective. Is something a foul or not? How much contact does there have to be?
Im just not sure anybody is really getting anything out of this version of VAR.
48 Posted 13/06/2018 at 00:30:03
As for Var, imagine if that was in place when we played our neighbours in the 77 semi, the 84 Milk cup final, the Panethinikas game, all the other times we have been on the receiving end.
We would have nothing to complain about, cannot have that not being able to have a whinge.
49 Posted 15/06/2018 at 11:51:43
I agree that it should be only used for the black-and-white decisions, anything that is open to interpretation needs to be left alone.
Jamie Vardy wins penalties week-in and week-out by initiating contact, about 50% of them are open to interpretation of some sort. It is a minefield.
50 Posted 15/06/2018 at 12:32:08
51 Posted 15/06/2018 at 12:54:57
They don't even show the replay now at Goodison of any 50/50 issues.
Still open for bent referees to buttfuck anyone outside of the "Top 6" clubs who are now getting a bigger slice of the pie.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.