Taping was 'the lowest of the low'

, 19 , 67comments  |  Jump to most recent
Club Publishes Hatton's Blue Union 'Explanation'
Derek Hatton has asked Everton Football Club to publish his explanation of the circumstances which led to a transcript of the recent meeting between Club Chairman Bill Kenwright and the "Blue Union" supporters' group being published on numerous websites earlier this week. Hatton was instrumental in arranging the meeting, which he describes as 'a very priviledged get-together' only after both sides had agreed to keep details confidential - an agreement which the club claims was broken by the "Blue Union" representatives who they accuse of secretly taped the discussions.

Quotes or other material sourced from Official Everton Website



Reader Comments (67)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Raymond Nuttall
1 Posted 19/08/2011 at 19:22:58
A few things to ponder: The Johnny-come-latleys can have a go at Gavin etc, just like the same people have a go at BU, KEOIC, E4C etc... but is it these dedicated blues who are splitting the fan base? Are they dividing to conquer? No... they are not.

Anyone who ever takes Derrick 'the tan' Hatton ' seriously has to have a reality check. Couple of pointers...

Why is it 'OK' for Kenwright to constantly lie and ignore very well researched fans concerns? Why do the 'naysayers' attack their fellow fans? ? just because it is easier?..or is it a whole more difficult to research and start an organised reality in your own time, with families jobs etc to consider...rather than just listen to the party line.

Kenwright has never 'liked' or trusted fans....they are an irritant....but guess what...he knows it's really the only thing that will dislodge him, his bankruptcy of the club is undeniable... but some still want to dispute and attack their fellow BLUES who have courageously put this in the public domain.

Shame on you for even trying to 'protect' him. It is YOU that will go running and deny responsibility once this great club is reduced to Sheff Wednesday staus.....look in the mirror and see the 'LIGHT'....two years and counting.

Tim Wilkins
2 Posted 19/08/2011 at 20:08:25
I don't post on this site very often, but the way the 'Blue Union' has conducted itself over the Kenwright meeting has prompted me to comment.

I believe these lads (Blue Union) have behaved in a disgraceful way. They have broken a confidentiality agreement and betrayed the trust of the club, Derek Hatton, and the majority of fans. You always moaned that Kenwright never bothered to talk to us ? after your pathetic stunt, do you think he'll EVER want to talk to us real fans now?

And what did you really acheive? What 'revelations' have you uncovered? Fuck all. We all knew the club had no money.

I'm glad Moyes has come out today and backed his chairman. He's said you shouldn't mistake stability for stagnation. Unfortunately, the Blue Union are so detached from reality they can't even see this. They are under the illusion there's a billionaire arab or yank who is desperate to buy a club heavily in debt with a crumbling stadium which can't be expanded. Dream on!

If we lose Moyes, it won't be because of Kenwright and the lack of transfer cash ? it will be because he's fed up with trying to satisfy deluded supporters with unrealistic expectations.

Who appointed the 'Blue Union' to represent Evertonians anyway?? I'm an Everton fan and you certainly don't represent my views. I think you're a disgrace.
Raymond Nuttall
3 Posted 19/08/2011 at 20:37:33
Where is your concrete proof 'Tim'...

You do not represent me and your attitude is a disgrace to fellow Evertonians....

WHO DO YOU REALLY REPRESENT?

Eugene Ruane
4 Posted 19/08/2011 at 20:31:05
Tim Wilkins (66), re the Blue Union, you say..

"I'm an Everton fan and you certainly don't represent my views. I think you're a disgrace".

Just for the record, Blue Union represent my views.

Also I'm an Everton supporter and think Tim Wilkins is a disgrace.

And a bell-end, a poltroon, a dick-weed, a pot-herb, a prick...

(Hey, this Intrenet Warrior thing is a piece of piss!)
Mick Gallagher
5 Posted 19/08/2011 at 20:50:39
Just read what Hatton has to say. So why did Kenwright ask them to write this down as he says below. So someone is lying...

Mark, ?If we have no money now, we won?t have money next summer?? Bill, ?I?m with you; I?ll be your president??sell the club?did you write it down for me? Simon, ?I?ve written it down for you Bill, Keith Harris is going to sell the club ? Bill, ?well write this down as well, Citi Bank, Deutsche Bank, Leon Angel, Keith Harris, Amanda Staveley. You?re saying to me, I?ve listened to you, I think you?re totally wrong in giving an exclusive to a guy, many are better than one guy; there has to be a reason nobody is buying Everton; there is a reason, there?s no money in the world, there?s no point in me being replaced, we need someone with money.?

Tim Wilkins
6 Posted 19/08/2011 at 20:40:11
Raymond (#67), I don't claim to represent anyone. I'm just an average Evertonian who is getting a bit fed up with the negative trouble makers who think we should be winning the league every season but don't have any positive ideas to contribute. It's all bitch, bitch, bitch about Kenwright & Moyes. You lads are starting to sound like a scratched record.

Of course I'd love us to be top of the league every week... but, without a new stadium, we're not going to attract new investment, and without new investment we're not going to get a new stadium. It's a Catch-22 situation.

I think Kenwright has been let down by so-called agents and brokers who are supposed to be helping him find a buyer. This joker who lives in a flat in Manchester who put in a bid for the club ? for fuck's sake! Didn't the so-called 'broker' think to check his credentials first?? It's a good job Kenwright smelt a rat or we'd be the laughing stock of English football now.
Jimmy Sorheim
7 Posted 19/08/2011 at 20:56:25
I just read Derek Hatton's statement to the official website, and I have to say I am disgusted, not at the Blue Union, but toward Derek Hatton for knocking Everton fans because they released the truth about what was said at the meeting with Bill Kenwright.

He of course should have known that the truth would come out either way and that a silence clause wouldn't be taken seriously. Especially in the desperate situation us fans was for wanting to hear from Kenwright about the debt and lack of transfers.

So then to read about his statement it is clear that he only cares about keeping face with Kenwright.

To me the Blue Union did the club and the fans a big favour, to tell the truth so that we all can move on. Look at the ripple effect it had, we have had more news articles these last few days than in the whole summer.

We may also see some things changeing because of this, for example we might get the money we need from Arsenal because Moyes has finally said he is willing to sell for the right price. I would rather see Rodwell go but we can't be too picky in these troubled times, if we get big money for him we should take it, and try to get a striker afterwards.

Anybody else think the Blue Union did the right thing?

Simon Harris
8 Posted 19/08/2011 at 21:29:09
Blue Union statement @ 10 tonight.

I've already responded to this on the OS FB page.

What's the point of a meeting without communication? What were the BU guys supposed to report back, "We've met our chairman but can't tell you anything, other than he has a nice office and lots of Everton memorabilia... Oh and we're up shit creek, but we can't tell you that."

Pure spin from the club to detract from the REAL issue which is the sorry state the club is in under this board.

Tom Brown
9 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:00:09
Best Policy is Honesty.

Look, I don't know what really went on around that Blue Union meeting.... but I know that BK. DM, the players and us should all be together and we are stronger if we are.

We need distrust between us like we need a hole in Howard's head.

I hope they did the right thing and I hope that we can move on together.

This is a hugely tough time for our beloved club and if we don't come together and roar mutual support..... God save us...

COYB

Peter Bourke
10 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:03:50
I'm with Tim on this.

The simple fact is the Blue Union agreed to certain things and did not honour those terms.

Eugene @4, how is Tim a disgrace? Your comments are nothing short of deplorable. Some members of the Blue Union have acted like gutter journos and it's the sort of behaviour you would expect from the News of the World.

Robert Daniels
11 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:09:35
Met Hatton and he wanted to go to Kirkby cause Bill said it was the Deal of the Century.

Him and BK are good chums... he parks his car in the Park End car park every week, and he's a RAT.

Why are the official site printing anything this gobshite says?

Rats and ship spring to mind,

Fuck off, BK and Hatton.
John Daley
12 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:05:37
Derek Hatton eh? Bill is really rolling out the big guns now. Who's next to ride to his defence? Bill fucking Oddie?

'A very privileged get-together'. They weren't meeting up with Nelson Mandela or the pissing Pope, Deggsy lad, you sanctimonious tit.
Paddy James
13 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:15:51
Tim, thanks for posting.

You are right, it is a disgrace what the self-seeking self publicists at Blue Union have done.

Abusive content removed by moderator

John Daley
14 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:16:03
So is this Kenwright's idea of a legally binding confidentiality agreement?

'The lads took out notebooks and Bill immediately asked for confidentiality, ?no notes? and everyone agreed. Notebooks were put away'

No wonder he's fuming. That's almost as watertight as the 'gentlemans agreement' he made with Dan Gosling.

John Audsley
16 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:30:11
Comment removed for abusive content
Paddy James
17 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:31:16
John,
As far as we can tell, there were five people in that office. BK, Hatton and the three from BU. Hatton, who set it up, has clearly stated the terms were it was off-the-record, an explanation of the club's situation from the chairman for the BU's benefit. Hatton states confidentiallity was discussed, and obviously agreed to by BU. These were discussions that would be damaging to the club if it became public knowledge.

It was a three hour meeting, right? It is impossible to remember, apparently verbatim as BU has published, what was said then written down post meeting. How else could they produce a transcript? Therefore it must all have been secretly taped. That is a disgrace.

Chairman agrees to meeting to explain the situation. He doesn't have to; is apparently curteous, frank and honest and they turn him over.

Nothing came out of that meeting we didn't already know. BK has stated ad naseum we are skint and need to find a buyer.

Rich Crawley
18 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:40:03
Wow, we really have some strange behaviour in here. Fellow evertonians swearing and cursing at each other. John Audsley and Eugene I think you really over reacted to what has been said.

I think the taping of the meeting is a disgraceful and unpleasent episode. It will push Bill et al back and now not many will get any good dialogue going. It is underhand and two wrongs do not make a right. Sure BK has a lot to answer for, but he also has a lot to be thanked for.

He helped save this club and has done a lot of honourable things. Unfortunately he has kept Everton fans in the dark in recent times. I'm sure not with malice but it certainly was not with complete honesty. Perhaps he is losing the will to live and now EFC has become a burden for him somewhat, but we should not forget the past completely.

It has been a strange turn of events and a strange week, hopefully some good will come out of this, publicity for EFC is not generally high but this has stirred up a bit of a nest which i hope might be somehow beneficial.

Hopefully the illusive buyer will come to the rescue sometime soon and EFC can once again be restored to former glories.
Tim Wilkins
19 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:37:10
Lads, we have to step back and take a longer term view of the situation.

Uefa are pissed off with the billionaire owners and have introduced new financial rules which are going to totally fuck up the 'get rich quick' clubs like Man Shitteh in a few years time. In 2015 any club that isn't living within its means are going to be banned from European football. This is going to level the playing field and make clubs like Everton more competitive. If we finish fifth or sixth in the league and a couple of the 'Sky Four' clubs above us are banned from the Champions League, who do you think Uefa will invite from England to replace them?

We have to stop thinking short term and look at the bigger picture. Look at Birmingham and Blackburn. One club taken over by a Chinese crook facing charges of corruption and relegated after one season, and the other run by an Indian chicken farmer who sacked one of the best English managers in the game and replaced him with a nobody (and my money is on them going down this season too).

We have one of the best managers in the country and we should be backing him and the players. I'm sure all this shit stirring against the club is bound to have a negative effect on the players. Cahill has pleaded for the fans to back the lads, this shows the moaners from Blue Union may be having a negative influence on the team.

Alan Rolfe
20 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:15:28
Let's try and be practical about this. If it was agreed that the meeting was to forewarn supporters groups the information that was given to Sky at a later interview, then what was recorded and then released despite the 'secrecy agreement' is deplorable. However, if you think that the 'news' that Everton are skint is a revelation then you are more deluded than RS fans who believe they are gonna win the Premier League.

The Club's income has grown, the costs keep growing even faster, so when does reality step in??? Fans want 'Investment' but what they really mean is donations. "Give our Club money and don't expect any returns." In the meantime, the Club is expected to throw money at the football mercenaries who don't care about our Club.

Let's try and be honest about this. Are we surprised by the information?... No. Do we want success?... Yes. Can we afford success?... No.

Let's try and get behind the team and not the politics...

Chris Knox
21 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:36:28
This whole pre-season is becoming a joke.

First off, the hugely publicised lack of transfer activity that I am seriously sick of hearing, then we have us fans (the most loyal and normally realistic bunch in the Prem) arguing not even about football anymore just name calling and slating each other's opinions, which I do believe we're all entitled to.

And now, to top it all off, we have this Blue Union lot releasing documentation, whether rightly or wrongly, but obviously controversial, a few days before our first game of the season. Our strength has always been our backs to the wall attitude and we have even started to lose that.

It's been a while that this club has faced off-the-field problems like this but please remember, all of us, that that team on Saturday will give their all for us (Big Vic.... hmmmm ? benefit of the doubt, even him) on Saturday. That first team can go toe to toe with most teams in the Prem so let's give them our backing and put all this spitefulness behind us, let the season start and let's see where we go.

I still believe Moyes gets it right most of the time and we will have a better season then most believe, but I've come to realise Kenwright's time has come up; thanks for saving us once upon a time but now it's time to go back to being just a fan and having fond memories of taking us back toEurope and setting us on our way back, pass it on Bill

Simon Harris
22 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:48:20
Paddy ? "Nothing came out of that meeting we didn't already know." BOLLOCKS! Did you know the proceeds from the Pienaar and Vaughan sales had been swallowed up by the banks? ? I didn't

Did you know the full extent of our financial woes and the incompetence of the man who's charged with leading 'our' great club? ? I didn't

Plenty of speculation, confusion and lies, but it took a group of concerned supporters to unearth the truth and I thank them for that.
John Roberts
23 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:00:48
Derek H Must be worried that he is going to lose his free tickets off Bill!!!
No: 8 Simon got it so right not much more to say!!
Paddy James
24 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:01:00
Chris, the point is, no-one wants to buy us:

? Redeveloped/new ground, from £50M to £150M?
? Clear the debts, £40M to £80M?
? Squad investment, at a conservative rate of £15M a year?

That's a minimum of around £100M for starters before buying the shares off the current owners. And we are a business losing money each year...

It's OK to say BK has made mistakes, no doubt he has, but he simply doesn't have that kind of money. He's 65. He's stated time and again he wants and needs to sell the club. What part of this don't BU and the other numpties understand?

I've never been so embarrassed, not by the club, but by some so-called fans. They've seen that shower at Sons of Shankly whoring themselves out to any media that will entertain them and thought, "I can do that."

Paddy James
25 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:09:23
Simon, I didn't know the cash for Vaughan and Pienaar went straight to the bank. But I did know we had no money for transfers... ergo that was what I suspected.

I knew we were in financial difficulties, because we haven't signed anyone for ages. This is all well documented and reported on already by the media.

Like I said, nothing substantial came out of it ? BK has said we are skint and need a buyer many times before. So there is unrest over the summer, BK agrees to a meeting with fans groups, tells them how it is. Then they turn him over. His only incompetence in this appears to be to trust fellow Evertonians who have acted disgracefully.

Mick Fleming
26 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:56:52
I havent posted on here for a while so, for what it's worth, here is my take on things.

Its easy for BK to blame the BU and attempt to discredit them; he has got the ear of the media as seen of SSN etc.

Question: ? Why the fuck did honest, trustworthy Degsey agree to facilitate and why did BK agree in the first place? What the fuck did they expect from a group of Evertonians in search of some answers? Why didnt the club comment when they knew an announcement was iminent?

I believe BK fucked up big time and now he knows it. His attempts to discredit the BU and divide the fanbase (not the first time) are an absolute discrace, I feel sick to the stomach. He now rolls out DM and the players to back him up and cover up his mistake and thats all most fans and the rest off the country see.

Whatever respect I had for BK has now gone as I am right behind BU on this and no doubt this is the excuse he needed to no longer communicate with the fans. Some of you on here will blame BU for that though won't you? Open your fucking eyes.
Tim Wilkins
27 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:33:09
"I believe BK fucked up big time and now he knows it. His attempts to discredit the BU and divide the fanbase (not the first time) are an absolute discrace, I feel sick to the stomach."

It's BU who have divided the fanbase. They're an arrogant bunch who think they represent all Evertonians and have no mandate from the wider fanbase. They make me sick to the stomach. They are an emabarrassment to all level-headed Evertonians.
Simon Harris
28 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:17:28
Paddy ? Maybe my moral compass is off, but the more this story unfolds the more I don't care IF they recorded it.

As I previously stated, what did he expect them to do with the information? ? "Thanks Bill, we understand now, it's worst than we thought, but you are obviously the best man for the job. Thanks for letting us into your circle of trust and mum's the word."

What they have done is for the best, the truth is out there now. No more speculating, dreaming of new signings or hoping I was wrong to doubt Bill.
John Daley
29 Posted 19/08/2011 at 22:46:30
"John, you're obviously a bit thick"

I might very well be 'Paddy'. However, I'm nowhere near as gullible or quick to swallow all the spin suddenly spoon fed to us by the charlatans running the club as you clearly are.

"Hatton states confidentiallity was discussed, and obviously agreed to by BU."

So, you believe that constitutes a legally binding agreement? Were they actually asked to sign a confidentiality agreement prior to the meeting taking place, or upon conclusion of said meeting? No, were they fuck. Which is why there will be no legal action whatsoever pursued by the club.

Why would you choose to believe someone as utterly discredited as Bill Kenwright, and an odious hanger-on like Derek Hatton, over three fellow supporters simply seeking the truth? It was stated at the outset of the Blue Union statement that they were only asked not to disclose 'personal matters' relating to Kenwright's family.

"It is impossible to remember, apparently verbatim as BU has published, what was said then written down post-meeting. How else could they produce a transcript?"

How do you know one of the three wasn't some kind of fucking savant? Anyway there was clearly note taking going on as at a couple of points BK actually says "Have you written that down?" and "Write this down as well?". If there was no pen and paper to hand, were they using a fucking etch-a-sketch?

"Chairman agrees to meeting to explain the situation. He doesn't have to, is apparently curteous, frank and honest and they turn him over."

How did they 'turn him over'? Have they twisted his words? Misrepresented anything he said? Made stuff up? Nope, they've just reported it verbatim, as you said. He is responsible for putting his own foot in it once again, just as the club are acting retroactively once again with this pathetic smear campaign. It's just a smoke-screen mate, to divert attention away from the actual content of said meeting. The shame is that supporters like yourself continue to lap it up without question.

By the way I couldn't care less if you've posted on here before, or if you ever do again (although I'm sure we would all be missing out on some really revealing insights and some, quite frankly, riveting shit) but your opening gambit was to proclaim most people on here to be stupid, deluded, moaners who should all fuck off, so surely you were expecting some response?

There also seems to be a trend developing where, when shit hits the fan, some random new posters debuts to make a 'for one time only' appearance in defence of Bill and the board and then disappear off the face of the earth, never to be heard from again. Then there are the rumours that Ian Ross pays fifty quid a pop to penniless 'internet warriors' to penetrate fan sites and post favourable soundbites in support of BK and the board.

Then there's the fact that surely, in today's depraved and cynical society, nobody can really be so ready to display such blind, unblinking faith in the bunch of bungling, truth twisting twats. Add the three up 'Paddy' and see what you get. I trust you studied Maths at school? Maybe you just spent all your time fannying around trying to master archaic languages with no relevance to the real world, whilst trying to avoid all the big kids who bullied you for being 'a bit of a Meff'?

Mick Fleming
30 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:38:43
Tim, are BU slagging BK off? And didn't they say that they are not anti-BK?

Anyway that's my view and I must say the view of the overwhelming majority of level-headed Evertonians posting on the sites I have visited over the past few days.
Paddy James
31 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:39:30
Simon, we already knew "the truth" surely? We are skint, end of.

He's the chairman. He works for the club for nothing, as he stated (though obviously in these fans' la-la land he's got his hand in the till).

Do you expect the chairman of a Prem club, or in fact any business, to publically say, "Come and watch Everton or come and sign for Everton. We haven't got a pot to piss in, mind."?

Whatever you think about this situation, yes, it was hamfisted and badly handled... BUT it was an honest attempt from BK to engage with the fans. He didn't have to. They have now fucked him over to his embarrassment.

To my knowledge, the meeting was not pre-publicised, so we would not have expected any announcement after it, so yes, I did expect them to keep mum. It appears it was what it was supposed to be: the boss man speaking to concerned fans, telling them financially we are knackered at the minute. That's how it is lads, that's why we can't sign anyone. I'm trying to sell the club, but there are no billionaire Evertonians out there.

For the hard of understanding, the ONLY billionaire Evertonian was John Moores. He's dead (God rest his soul). But apparently it's BK's fault there's no resurrection.

Tim Wilkins
33 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:48:09
Mick, BU appears to have a core of support on this site. I subscribe to many EFC fansites but I have been getting increasingly irritated but I have ignored it until now, but this latest stunt by BU is the final straw for me. I have to make my feelings known.
Andrew Gilbert
34 Posted 19/08/2011 at 23:57:47
To find out who is telling the truth about the taping and if it was agreed or not, why not stream the tape online?

DH said that BK continually reminded BU that it was 'Between us'; BU say that wasn't the case. So which is it?

Let's hear it.
Simon Harris
35 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:00:54
Paddy, I disagree that we all knew the full extent of our predicament; we may have believed things were tough and many learned Toffeewebbers highlighted the financial woes, but you only have to look on the OS to see it's littered with naive fans calling for Moyes to sign someone, at least now we ALL know the situation.

If they fucked him over, as you put it, time will tell... but he could have been open and transparent with the supporters.
Mick Fleming
36 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:11:35
Tim, fair point and like you I am making my feelings known. I guess I have sat on the fence a bit over BK, I got a load of shit on this site a while ago for saying that I met BK in Bologna airport after the Fiorentina game and had photos taken with him and my lad.

I am now sick to the stomach and think BK and the club have handled this disgracefully. I no longer sit on that fence as the last 24 hours have confirmed my feelings and like I said in a previous post whatever respect I had has now gone.
Simon Harris
37 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:16:46
As I was saying... he could have been open and transparent with the supporters for the last two years and avoided this situation. Cancelling the AGM and creating a communication blackout has lead to the creation of the BU and they have asked the questions that so many of us wanted answering.

I've not mentioned a millionaire Evertonian but someone with business acumen and a plan would be start.
Paddy James
38 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:17:53
Simon, be realistic. If he comes out and says, 'We are skint' the foaming mouth brigade of Rajpotjelskis, John Daley et al will scream blue murder, he's not serious about selling the club etc etc.

The bank will not lend us any more cash. We are in debt and losing money, like most clubs. If he had come out and said, 'There is money for transfers' he would have been lying. He hasn't done that has he? What exactly do people expect the club to say publicly that has not already been said?

You don't need to be 'learned' to know we are skint. He's been "open and transparent". How more open and transparent can he be ? hosting a three-hour meeting in his office where he spoke (all too) frankly about the financial situation? Can you cite a single Prem club chairman who has ever done that before?

I remember him telling an AGM two or three years ago, "I can't carry on like this". There is no "time will tell". They have fucked him over.

Tim Wilkins
39 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:33:00
Well said Paddy. It's about time some people on here got a reality check.

BK has been honest and transparent all along. We knew EFC is skint. We knew nobody wants to buy the club. BU haven't uncovered anything new. Just made fools of themselves trying to be undercover journalists and looking like amateurs. Even the Sun wouldn't give this shower a job!
Andrew Mackenzie
40 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:17:05
Tim, Paddy... if we already knew the truth, I'm not quite sure where your level of anger and bile is coming from re BU? They have not sought to paint themselves as 'representing' all Evertonians; if you don't agree with them, what they are trying to achieve etc, fine ? don't support them.

But please, do not paint them as some fanatical terrorists intent on bringing the club down ? we have a board of directors more than capable of that. We now have Liverpool fans referring to Bill as 'Agent Kenwright'. Now don't worry, I don't get overly upset by that... but it tells you something.

As for 'saving the club', ha ha... absolutely hilarious. Check the accounts in Johnson's last year. Check the accounts since.

After all that has happened in the last 10 years, the current state of affairs is the Blue Union's fault? Really? I don't know what you're on but please let me have some. Was the following 'selection' the blue unions fault... or the directors, shareholders, executives and chairmans fault?

NTL, Kings Dock, Kirkby, Everton Place, Fortress Sports Fund (the cheque's in the bank tomorrow!) ? remember that one? ... spoken at an AGM ? remember them? Annual General Meetings... one where your great leader told a fellow shareholder and fan that he was 'bored' with him, and then cancelled all future AGMs.

We then have Trevor Birch walking out, the Keith Wyness disaster and bought silence. Awful relationship with the local authority, dreadful deal on Finch Farm. "We won't sell Rooney" (sold)... Gosling, Pienaar running down his contract. Yak and Yobo retained and then loaned despite 'reasonable' offers (and this was before we understood the banks position)...

And now, finally, we discover we can barely move without the bank's ok....!

Yes, clearly the fault of the Blue Union, fans like you and me, treated with contempt by this egotistical idiot. I really do wonder how anyone can seriously defend this guy, other than Derek Hatton ? remember him, the egotistical bully who ran the city into the ground... now who does he remind me of!!?

And how can I forget the playing side, silence from David "I'm going to get my business done early" Moyes ? breaking it on the eve of the season to announce we are fighting for 10th+ with Stoke and Brom...

I take it back, you are right, Kenwright clearly is the man to 'continue' taking us forward.

Paddy James
41 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:41:44
Andrew, if we were not in debt, we would not be in the Prem now. There's a very strong correlation between spending on players and league position. Thankfully Moyes has managed to buck that trend.

You say he's incompetent and want rid. So name the billionaire, or business or anyone else willing to plough £100M into Everton right now?

Like most posters on here, you have your opinion, supposition, conjecture. You spout it all the time. You don't seem capable of recognising the facts.

Simon Harris
42 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:30:41
Paddy, 'There is money for transfers' he would have been lying. He hasn't done that has he?

You're right of course... but then why did Moyes come out at the end of last season and say he wanted to do his business early? Why at the opening of Everton 2 did Sir Philip Carter promise us 'exciting signings'? They must have known the financial state. So stop filling the fans with false hope just to sell early bird season tickets.

I don't hate Bill Kenwright, I just don't believe he is the right man to lead us out of this mess and secure investment. The BU saga will hopefully expedite his departure and offer Everton a better opportunity of returning to its former glory ? here's hoping.

Paddy James
43 Posted 20/08/2011 at 01:08:59
Simon, I honestly think you are wrong about BK.

Anyway, I do know from personal experience, when you have got fuck all, it makes you strong. Hope Everton is the same.

Night and God Bless, and good luck to the Blues for the season.

Andrew Mackenzie
44 Posted 20/08/2011 at 00:57:54
Whoa Paddy, I actually respect DM, and believe he is a man of integrity, and was pleased to see what he said about ensuring the stability of the club. But to be fair that's at odds with Bill's (transparent) statement to the evil BU as he would clearly borrow more if the banks would allow.

I like staying in the black and have no issue with that kind of realistic business model. My issue is it's not to the credit of BK who has led us for the last 10 years.

I believe we are no different than Liverpool a year ago, albeit on a smaller scale. Bottom line is as income is squeezed and expenses rise ? and just watch those rates fly in 12 months ? we will be screwed as we don't have the income or turnover to service the debt, pay inflated player salaries or provide budget for new players.

We could find a buyer, but the seller will have to realise the buyer will simply be buying the debt, and he will be losing the value of his shares. Hence the importance of obtaining Kirkby to ensure there was a nice (albeit debt secured) asset on the balance sheet.

I have in the past sympathised with BK, like another poster stated earlier, but had reservations after the KD/Gregg fiasco. There was clearly politics playing out through the media and the darling won out.

I genuinely don't dislike BK, but he is not fit and proper to run the club, and I accept we will differ on this, the list I give you is a reflection of his performance as a Director and why I come to that conclusion.

BK has all but admitted in the past he is not the man to take the club forward and I respect him for that. But I can't help feeling that that is actually to our negative as he is unlikely to commit to anything that may damage his shareholding ? and therin may lie 'one' of the problems.

Communication, contempt for fans and the disgraceful mis-selling of Kirkby started the divide amongst fans ? it certainly wasn't started by fans.

As for naming a billionaire willing to put money into the club, why would they? I wouldn't, but then that's because of the state they are in... and who created that? Yes, the person you are defending and I assume believe is the right person to take us forward.

We may not agree Paddy, but some of the attacks on the Blue Union are out of order.

Whatever happens, at least while the players are on the pitch, I hope we can all unite to support the lads, because by god they need it!
Tommy Hallem
45 Posted 20/08/2011 at 01:09:55
There is no hidden agenda or scam by the board or Kenwright, the reality and FACT is that Everton do not generate enough income to compete in today's football world. Do you not think that if any genuine buyer had tried to buy the club and had been stopped by Kenwright, we would not have read about it in the Press? Does anybody seriously think money is going missing? Who is going to invest in Everton for no return? Who are these so called buyers?

The club try to buy a new ground in Kirkby to generate more income and the fans don't want that!! The fans don't want the board to sell any players to generate some income either!! What us it this BU want exactly? Do they want Kenwright to sell up? Listen to the man, he wants to do just that!!

What is it that the BU revealed that any half-educated fan didn't already know? It's not rocket science is it? The club don't generate enough money, the banks are no longer lending and nobody wants to buy us! Simple.

Oh forgot, that will be Bill Kenwright's fault won't it? If you're not happy that we don't spend £108M since Jan, or spend like City, Utd, Chelsea, then I'd suggest you're supporting the wrong club.

Paul Marshall
47 Posted 20/08/2011 at 01:23:21
I'm fully prepared for my comments to be discredited... apparently if you don't post on here every other day you have no opinion and you get called all sorts. (John Audsley and John Daley; good comments lads, you make me proud to be a blue...)

I've been reading all the fall out from the Blue Union and I'm not happy. Nothing positive has come out of this great expose that these "fans representatives" (who elected them?) have conjured up and the subsequent reaction is making a mockery out of the club.

Man up, we're skint. People must be bored and deluded if they think money is going to be presented to us on a silver platter. BK is not pretending to be some financial magician, he is who he always has been. If everyone thinks it's easy to find someone else better, put all the effort you spend moaning into finding this saviour, as you make it sound easy.
John Daley
49 Posted 20/08/2011 at 01:43:35
Sorry, but you've got the wrong end of the stick there Paul. My problem with Paddy, initially, was purely down to the fact that he immediately dismissed the majority of people who frequent this site as being stupid, deluded, moaning bastards and then declared that they should all 'just fuck off'. I just found it needlessly antagonistic.

I certainly did not mean to imply that the opinion of someone who posts on this site regularly has any greater merit than the opinion of someone never moved to post before.

Everyone has their own stance on the current situation and should feel free to voice their opinion. It may be an opinion diametrically opposed to those held by some others but never let that hold you back if you have something to get off your chest. Debates, disagreements, arguments and insults might ensue but that's all part and parcel.

By the way, I obviously do disagree with you but I'm not suddenly going to start spouting abuse like some tanked up tramp staggering around outside Tesco. I'll save that for tomorrow night on the way home from the game, when I will literally be 'that tanked up tramp'.
Dan Parker
52 Posted 20/08/2011 at 05:38:20
I think Bill is owed a hell of a lot more respect than he's being shown. As a business analyst, I'd never be able to record someone's conversation without specifically requesting it first.

In the transcript, I agree with Bill, I wouldn't want us to be a Blackburn at all, owned by Indian turkey farmers who couldn't give a flying fuck about the club. Blackburn will probably get relegated this season.

If anyone hasn't noticed, most countries in Europe are struggling to pay their bills, banks collapsed, some are now owned by the taxpayer and yet we ask Bill to conjure up a billionaire for a sport that provides no return.

Give the man a break; yes, we're up shit creek but he's doing more than any Everonian to keep us going in the right direction.

From one Evertonian to another, keep it up Bill, you gave us European football for the first time in living memory after outing agent Johnson.
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
53 Posted 20/08/2011 at 05:01:30
I'm sorry this thread seems to have attracted some first-time posters who have been ignoring our rules about abuse.

I've cleaned up the thread as best I can. Just a reminder that abuse gets your posts moderated more closely...
Peter Barnes
54 Posted 20/08/2011 at 06:10:26
They say extremes breed extremes. The strength of feeling for the club is evident through the posts on here and also through the actions of BU. I do believe that it is misguided though.We can all take a different view of whatever balance is required for this debate however I can't help but feel that this is just about the biggest own goal I can remember regarding a club who have down the years aquired a penchant for producing own goals.As a club we have been on the slide for a lot longer than the last 12-13 years.About 40 years I would estimate.Apart from a brief 3 year period in the 80's when we were given a peek over the shoulders of the likes of Utd and LFC. Stoke are held up as an example of how much we have fallen in recent times.I notice that they have signed 2 ageing injury prone CB's this summer.Both on free's.Woud anyone swop Stoke's squad for our's?
I wouldn't.Hopefully we play well today and the crowd get behind the team.
Back in 1989 I remember going to the opening game against Newcastle.Most peolpe remember it for Cottee's debut hatrick.Fair enough.However I remember their so called fame support starting off the game full of support.Slating the players after 15mins.calling for the manager to be sacked after 30 mins.And the board by half time.God forbid we should ever get as good as the Geordies.
COYB.
Ged Alexander
55 Posted 20/08/2011 at 07:44:31
To be blunt, the guys' decision to record the meeting with Bill isn't the problem ? making it public is. It's fine to have a record of an important meeting.

But my releasing it to the public and Media, Blue Union has made the chances of any fan getting in to see Bill remote at best. Why will he ever trust a fans' group again?

More seriously, Blue Union as just told Arsenal how poor our financial position really is. The Banks are very involved with decision-making so why should any club intereted in our players pay top dollar?

Then there are the potential buyers of the club...why offer the going-rate when you know the board is 'desperate' to sell?

So, laudable though their aims were, Blue Union just showed why they couldn't run a top business. Confidentiality is key.

However, as they have released the trasncript, why not release the audio? It can do no more harm than it already has. If they do, I think they will hear what we most-of-us think; that Bill is a good Blue but a Bad businessman.

Keith Edmunds
56 Posted 20/08/2011 at 08:35:00
Whats the point of people who represent the fans meeting with the Chairman if it has to remain confidential?

If it was to be confidential they shouldn't have gone. if they have broken an agreement its unforgivable!
Mike Bates
57 Posted 20/08/2011 at 09:15:32
What does it matter if it was secretly taped? If there was a confidentiality agreement? Blah blah blah.

What has been released is the truth, if they had known it was being recorded we may have been fed the party line. Surely we can all agree that Bill has been found out as incompetent that he's finally lost it.
Peter Hall
58 Posted 20/08/2011 at 10:25:57
Calling themselves the Blue Union is like the BNP grabbing the Union Jack.

Not In Our Name you bunch of untrustworthy timewasters.
Gavin Ramejkis
59 Posted 20/08/2011 at 08:42:51
If BK has supposedly saved the club and done so many honourable things please post them

If BK didnt want notes then why did he say "are you writing this down?" the guy is an absolute disgrace and so far out of his depth it beggars belief that the chancer has stayed where he is for so long. Look at the occasions he has felt his position could be usurped, he issues nothing short of a character assasination of his lifelong friend Paul Gregg to the Echo about his non attendance at Goodison and then creates a fantasy out of a his own imagination in FSF, Gregg leaves and FSF never existed.

He bans AGMs as he's being asked very pertinent questions by concerned shareholders and treats them with utter contempt in doing so - my trainset so you can all do one.

Roll forward a few years and his fellow board member and shareholder Earl who hasn't been to Goodison in over 3 years and yet its never mentioned ONCE in the Echo, every season bang on cue for ticket renewals the local press are spoonfed his latest fables to boost sales, finally running out of stories this time around as even he knows the sheeple have been bled dry and taken for a fool a few too many times to believe fairy stories of Russians or Arabs or Americans etc poised to buy.

Do people seriously believe competitive companies only know their competitors are in financial trouble through reading the papers and toffeeweb and fans group sites? Christ on a bike how naive are you? For a few quid you can buy copies of a company's annual returns, for a few more quid you can buy directors reports, unlike Everton other teams can scrape a few quid together for this and you must have no idea that businesses do this if they want to asset strip a competitor, it wouldn't even take a rocket scientist to think who is that club in this league that hasn't bought a first team player in two years, lost one for nothing last year without replacing him, sold two since and couldn't even scrape together enough dough for a loan, hmm I wonder. The chairmen are a pretty close community as are the managers and agents and you can bet your bottom dollar they'll all know a lot more than us plebs already.

Denial is the killer calling a downward sprial stability is utter nonsense - read the words carefully, nothing left to hock and the banks not far from demanding their money back add this to no ideas on how to get out of it and if you genuinely think this is stability I'd love to do business with you as you could be bled dry before you even noticed.

Tim, BK divided the fan base with desperation Kirkby, its never been the same since and if you fell for those lies and still back him you'll never learn the difference.

Paddy if you want to pigeonhole me use my name or you just come across as an idiotic bigot
Colin Fitzpatrick
60 Posted 20/08/2011 at 11:26:09
Gavin fella,

I can see you?re angry at these people but honestly mate they?re simply not worth getting worked up over.

Once again they're happy to blindly accept the explanation of people who have a fairly impressive track record of misleading fans and shareholders alike; they never learn.

As ever when the truth emerges next week the same people will just look like what they are. I?ll just be glad to get to the game and support the club on the pitch.
Mick Gallagher
61 Posted 20/08/2011 at 11:06:19
So if billy bullshit would have said to Blue Union heres the interview you wanted but you cant tell anyone anything would you be happy. I fucking wouldnt and to the posters on here defending kenwrite how many fucking more lies do you want to hear from him before you have doubts.

At the start of the interview it says we were asked to keep is PRIVATE LIFE PRIVATE nowhere did I see anything bad about his private life. The other thing I cant get my head around from the champagne socialist and kenwrite is why did he say twice write this down if no pen or paper was available.
SOMEONE IS FUCKING LYING AND SOMEONE HAS PLENTY OF FORM FOR NOT BEING TRUTHFUL
Garry Martin
63 Posted 20/08/2011 at 12:40:25
It's hard to take Degsy "the headworker" Hatton serious knowing his antics & background. Get real Degsy, go to a meeting & treat the discussion with privacy....come get real, or,hang on, is this just an arse covering excersise........surely not Degsy.
Sorry Mr Hatton but we are all well aware of your previous !!!
John Audsley
64 Posted 20/08/2011 at 14:40:01
Apologies for my comments (15)

I was clearly in Malcolm Tucker mode!!!!
Chris Regan
65 Posted 20/08/2011 at 16:09:46
I can't believe Hatton's statement on the Everton website. Inparticular -

'The lads all agreed it had been a positive meeting and felt buoyed by what they?d heard. They repeated it had been ?a great meeting?.

How could anyone think it was a great meeting or feel positive after hearing what Kenwright said?

I felt like doin myself in after reading the comments.
Steve Woods
66 Posted 21/08/2011 at 12:29:12
@Andrew 38 & 42 - Absolutely spot on. I could not agree more. BK, made a comment at the last AGM two or three years ago where he stated (I paraphrase) 'I do not want to be here in another 2 or 3 years time'. Fast forward 3 years and at the BU meeting last week he stated 'I do not want to be here in another 5 years'. Whilst I do not believe that BK is lying about this, it does rather demonstrate again that whatever targets he is setting himself e.g. not to be here by now, he is signally failing. In this particular instance and as a cause for concern he has given himself 5 more years to get out.
Jonathan Stockdale
67 Posted 21/08/2011 at 14:04:53
The question I would think long and hard about is "WHY" Del Boy Hatton arranged this meeting. What's that slippery character after?



Is it a renewal of the EFC website contract for RippleEffect his son owns?



Is it commercial opportunities arising from the Football Quarter for his property portfolio?

Simon, ?I?ve had a little input into the Football Quarter in Liverpool; do you know anything about it? Bill, ?Yeah, a little.? Simon, ?That?s at kind of an advanced stage at the moment; the guys from KEIOC are sitting down with a major construction company and the council over the next couple of weeks to draw up a prospectus??


One thing is for sure, Hatton did not in any way arrange this meeting for the good of Everton Football Club. Not in a million years.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derek_Hatton
John Connor
68 Posted 21/08/2011 at 20:00:10
Despite it all I am yet to see the confidentiality 'clause'. Why should a discussion such as this remain confidential, why the secrecy, what has BK got to hide. Why did DH need to arrange the meeting? BK should be man enough to hold regular meetings with the supporters and have the details minuted and published, Secrecy leads to rumour and division. BK likes the kudos of being chairman of EFC, and will always find a way to put off potential buyers. He likes the power.
I'm glad they published.
John Connor
69 Posted 21/08/2011 at 20:00:10
Despite it all I am yet to see the confidentiality 'clause'. Why should a discussion such as this remain confidential, why the secrecy, what has BK got to hide. Why did DH need to arrange the meeting? BK should be man enough to hold regular meetings with the supporters and have the details minuted and published, Secrecy leads to rumour and division. BK likes the kudos of being chairman of EFC, and will always find a way to put off potential buyers. He likes the power.
I'm glad they published.
John Connor
70 Posted 21/08/2011 at 20:00:10
Despite it all I am yet to see the confidentiality 'clause'. Why should a discussion such as this remain confidential, why the secrecy, what has BK got to hide. Why did DH need to arrange the meeting? BK should be man enough to hold regular meetings with the supporters and have the details minuted and published, Secrecy leads to rumour and division. BK likes the kudos of being chairman of EFC, and will always find a way to put off potential buyers. He likes the power.
I'm glad they published.
Glen Anderson
71 Posted 22/08/2011 at 09:45:27
There is lots of abuse in this thread, even in some of the comments that Michael is letting appear.

I understand very well the emotions that have been provoked by recent statements, both by the Blue Union, Derek Hatton, our illustrious manager and the club itself.

However, for me, my thoughts are very clear on the matter:

1 - The Blue Union had every right to request a meeting with the CEO and also the major shareholder of our club.

2 - The club should have discussed with their legal department prior to such a meeting and, if they wished for confidentiality, should have asked the members of the Blue Union to sign a legally binding confidentially agreement. This is standard business practice and it appears that our club is not following it. In not doing so, the club has left itself open to risk.

3 - The members of The Blue Union should also have been more aware of the potential fall out and risk of documenting almost verbatim the entire contents of their meeting. At best they have shown naivety, at worst they have further undermined the club's already difficult relationship with its bank, its fans and the media.

In short, for me this type of problem is always caused by a breakdown in communication. My opinion is that the club did not safeguard itself and the party representing the fans failed to restrain themselves when revealing the contents of the discussion.

It is a real shame. I won't call anyone a disgrace but for me the fallout from this meeting simply further strains the club's relationship with the fans. Somebody commented earlier that DM, RE and BK will never hold private meetings with a fans' group ever again and I think that is the one certainty that we can take out of this meeting.
Grant Smith
72 Posted 22/08/2011 at 16:59:05
nothing that thewy qouted has been refuted. Kenwright himself has repeated most of what was said himself on SSN or the OS. The club took no legal action for a reason - they haven't a leg to stand on.
Mike Green
73 Posted 22/08/2011 at 23:44:40
Got back from holiday, heard the shit was hitting the fan whilst away, have just got chance to read the transcript.

SHIT THE FUCKING BED.

Get that cunt out now.

Bill - be careful what you wish for another chairman might claim his petrol and phone bill.......?

Fucking unreal.
Anthony Manning
74 Posted 23/08/2011 at 17:57:37
Bill Kenwright has been underhand with Everton Fans for at least the last eight years. So this is just a taste of his own medicine. Well done Blue Union!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads