A meas to an end

, 29 , 89comments  |  Jump to most recent
Members of the Blue Union have finally responded to the war of words coming from the club and other shackled media outlets regarding the supposed taping of their meeting with Bill Kenwright.

Quotes or other material sourced from School of Science 1878



Reader Comments (89)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Gavin Ramejkis
1 Posted 29/08/2011 at 20:58:51
The Blue Union response is up Boys and Girls makes interesting reading - http://www.sos1878.co.uk/everton-news/blue-union-statement-a-means-to-an-end/
Mark Jones
4 Posted 29/08/2011 at 21:34:23
A superb article. Well done The Blue Union!
Brendan O'Doherty
5 Posted 29/08/2011 at 21:51:59
Good read. The Ian Ross e-mails are are utterly scandalous; what a tool to speak about fans like that.

Keep up the good work BU.


Ian Bennett
6 Posted 29/08/2011 at 21:49:40
If Everton are talking to Amanda Staveley and some of the big banks I am heartened that a deal will be done. For those who haven't heard of her, check out Wikipedia.

Despite a downturn and the club not resembling a business in any shape or form, someone will buy it, I am sure.
Michael Kenrick
7 Posted 29/08/2011 at 21:45:32
Great that they show up some of the nonsense going on. This line that they have not provided us with anything new is increasingly irritating. Who had heard the astounding Keith Harris story? Who knew Bill's ignorance and arrogance combined to such devastating ineffectiveness?

Just such a pity it takes Blue Union so long to respond. And when they do, it's far too long, it's almost too much information.

Yes, I know there are lots of excuses and reasons for the delays... and they want to make sure they've covered every aspect. But they lose the initiative by not responding more quickly...

There is no reason why they didn't issue the Rowan email and a statement immediately about observing the one and only precondition to the meeting.

Instead, they included the headline-grabbing nonsense about not being allowed to take notes... which only highlites via the detailed transcript that they obviously did tape the meeting... but are still too coy to admit it... headline aside.

What they need to be doing is ANTICIPATING the cynical misinformation, and getting their word in first. Otherwise, they risk gifting a section of the fanbase a strong reason to side with the club ? exactly as happened with KEIOC and their Manc hooligans video.
Henry Jones
8 Posted 29/08/2011 at 21:56:10
Well done lads. Keep it up.
Colin Fitzpatrick
9 Posted 29/08/2011 at 22:08:36
Love the title, says it all really. Well to those of a certain vintage is does!!!!

Well done to the Blue Union lads for not taking things lying down and respecting the team whilst a couple of important games were being played.
Daniel J Johnson
10 Posted 29/08/2011 at 21:55:32
Reading this makes me feel like Dustin Hoffman in All the Presidents Men.
John Feeley
11 Posted 29/08/2011 at 22:36:38
Well done Blue Union, appreciate your efforts!
John Daley
12 Posted 29/08/2011 at 22:04:05
Ian Ross is an odious, smug, slimy, self-important cretin. Consequently, it's not surprising to discover he's earnt himself a promotion at Everton.

Yes, he has a job to do but he goes about it like General Zod from Superman II. Instead of dealing diplomatically with supporters, he treats them with sneering disdain. He'll be demanding they "Kneel before Ross" next.

He summed up his own winning methods in a meeting with an Everton Supporters Group a few years ago: " what I try to do is protect the Club?s reputation at all times ? and that means poring over everything the media does?if I find something I don?t like ( and I just have ? another disgraceful piece by the Mirror?s LFC-supporting columnist Derek McGovern ) I complain?in fact, I rant".

Keep on winning friends and influencing people Ian. Thank Zod the club has someone like you to ensure it's reputation remains untarnished.
John Daley
13 Posted 29/08/2011 at 22:48:57
Forgot to add this pearler from the lips of General Ross, talking about the clubs interaction with the fan base : "Ours is the most open club within the Premiership?..many will argue against that notion?..but it is a fact."
Nick Armitage
14 Posted 29/08/2011 at 22:55:46
Irrespective of whether confidentiality was breached, the meeting showed Kenwright up for what he is - a bumbling twerp who is, at best, a bare-faced liar and at worst, criminally negligent in discharging his legal obligations as a company director.

OUR CLUB needs to rid itself of this imbecile and his arrogant crony old boys club.

The actions of the Blue Union hopefully are the beginning of the end.
Gareth Hughes
15 Posted 29/08/2011 at 22:40:25
Well done, Blue Union; if only the media had the appetite/balls/competence to ask these hard questions of the club.
Ian Smitham
16 Posted 29/08/2011 at 23:10:16
Just been reading a bit on the Blue Union site and a comment struck me from one of thier contributors.

Michael, please help. You know from previous that we do not see much in the same way, but I have to say I respect what you do and the site.

Anyway, not to digress, there is a comment on there by a contributor that this site (TW) is set up by and supports KEIOC.

Any thoughts?
Tommy Coleman
17 Posted 29/08/2011 at 23:15:58
John Daley,

General Zod, ha ha.

Everton Fan: "How much is the club up for sale for?"

General Zod: "Why do you say these things to me when you know I will kill you for it!?"

Well done, BU. Keep it up. And if you possibly can, try to speed a few responses up.
James Flynn
18 Posted 29/08/2011 at 23:17:26
Michael (5) - Agree their tactics should be to attack first, then constantly. Guessing running things through lawyers for legal reasons caused the delay.

Blue Union is detailing what all of us know. Good stuff. This ownership group is done.

Jay Woods
19 Posted 30/08/2011 at 00:28:03
It's laughable how the club's Fans Forum wants to focus on trifling issues like timing of the "Z-Cars" theme and betting kiosks, but talk about the wayward running of the club is a major no-no. Seriously, Bill and his mates could teach Kim Jong Il a thing or two about rigid discussion boundaries and oppressive secrecy. Just as long as they don't ? and here's the paranoia kicking in ? try to copy North Korea's "Dear Leader" and seek to subvert BU from within.

Anyway... I only wish the BU could somehow find a prospective and well-credentialed buyer, present said buyer to the club and force the issue. But no. Bill would probably insist on everyone signing two hundred inane NDAs and then lament the breakdown of the deal, despite his "24/7 search for new investors".
James Flynn
20 Posted 30/08/2011 at 00:35:25
JD (10) - My Man!!

"Ian Ross is an odious, smug, slimy, self-important cretin. Consequently, it's not surprising to discover he's earnt himself a promotion at Everton".

In a nutshell. Laughed typing this. Good stuff.

Gavin Ramejkis
21 Posted 30/08/2011 at 00:55:02
Ian, go to the TW homepage and look at the site history, TW has been going for over a decade as have many of its contributors. KEIOC came about when DK raised its ugly head. TW is independent you can tell from the posts and articles, it may not be everyone's cup of tea but if you want a biased site based on rumoured funding try bluekipper, ever known any other Everton site have so many inside interviews?
Michael Kenrick
22 Posted 30/08/2011 at 01:09:12
Yes, Gavin, it's longer than that. I've been at this malarkey since 1994!

Ian (#14), I can categorically deny that TW was set up by KEIOC. Presumably that comment was made for the usually divisive purposes, Sadly, some Evertonians (or is it just Ian Ross in one of his many internet guises?) wants to divide the fanbase in his determination to conquer and subdue them. I think that's why I'm wary of anyone whose first inclination is to condemn fan groups for whatever feeble reason.

As this episode shows, no lie is too heinous to be used in anger against a vocal section of the fanbase, in the hope that it will strike a chord with another section.

We thought KEIOC's aims were admirable, and you only have to read their excellent testimony to the Public Inquiry to marvel at their diligence and knowledge in unmasking Destination Kirkby for the charade that it was. We supported and publicised their efforts in the interests of what was best for the club. They made mistakes ? we all make mistakes... hopefully we are prepared to admit them and learn from them.

We have given support and publicity to many groups and efforts over the years who have tried to improve the situation at Everton. Blue Union deserve the greatest of credit, as others have said, for revealing the true extent of the bumbling arrogant incompetence that is leading this club nowhere.
Lori Fekete
23 Posted 30/08/2011 at 01:15:26
Just wish this response will get as much publicity as when the club and even Moyes were calling them lying cheats, but fat chance of that.


Tony Stanley
24 Posted 30/08/2011 at 02:06:17
I feel the Blue Union have given me a voice, thank you.
Garry Corgan
25 Posted 30/08/2011 at 02:04:55
Mike - you and I have known each other a long time now and tend to agree on most things Everton. I want to offer a counter-argument to your views on the timings of Blue Union's releases. Food for though, as it were.

I'm almost enjoying the delays between their statements. Those of us that support the aims of the Blue Union should realise that in order to be taken seriously and actually achieve some of our goals the pressure needs to be applied and increased over a long period of time. Whether it's done intentionally or not, I'm happy that the BU appear to be giving the fans and the media time to digest each statement, thus increasing the pressure upon the current administration at the club.

If the BU were to immediately respond to the club's misinformation, this whole thing could be seen as a tit-for-tat flash in the pan by a group of, as Ian Ross puts it, "militant fans and kids." I would much much rather the intensity be sustained over a long period of time, making the current administration's position more and more untenable.
Ernie Baywood
26 Posted 30/08/2011 at 03:36:32
I'm finding this whole thing a bit unsavoury. The BU are starting to sound more and more grand in their opinion of themselves. What did they actually tell us that was new? Didn't we already know that Everton are skint and that Kenwright is not a businessman?

It's all starting to look like another anti-Kenwright mob (which is hardly breaking new ground) and a group of people enjoying a bit of self importance.

That they don't touch on the taping issue is significant and I now believe that they must have done it ? otherwise you'd surely deny it? Who thinks covertly recording a conversation is proper? No chance.

Sorry but I've got them pegged as a bunch of cranks on an ego trip. I don't want Kenwright as Chairman but I won't be associated with these blokes.
Aiden Doyle
27 Posted 30/08/2011 at 04:52:11
I think I?m with Ernie on this one.

I?ve no issues with the Blue Union?s goals, but I?m far from impressed with the way in which they?re trying to achieve them. I?m actually quite uncomfortable (morally opposed, I guess) to someone?s conversation - even Kenwright?s - being recorded without their consent and I?m particularly interested in the legality of that covert recording.

My understanding is that it IS legal for an individual to record a conversation in which they are taking part, regardless of whether the other participant(s) are aware, so long as it is for their own personal use. I?m no lawyer, so I?ll be happy to stand corrected, but I?ve always been advised that subsequently providing the content of that conversation to third parties is asking for trouble - and that was the Union?s specific intent.

The ?only one precondition, which was observed? disclaimer that they?re clinging to also seems to be of questionable relevance. There are certain standards of behavior that it?s reasonable to expect, whether or not they?re explicitly stated. I?m guessing that Kenwright didn?t feel the need to specify that they could?t bug his office any more than he felt he had to tell them not to shit on his desk.
Mike Dolan
28 Posted 30/08/2011 at 06:23:52
If this is a battle between Everton Supporters and Everton FC then I would have to say after carefully weighing up the story...

Yes, Evertonians win by a landslide; Everton FC is now staggering like a dying animal.

No-one seem to care that Our Club, The Team is suffering from this constant negativity.

Chad Schofield
29 Posted 30/08/2011 at 08:09:37
Yes, it is sad to see it come to this, but then I would argue that the board only has itself to blame after years of neglect, lies and incompetentcy.
Trevor Mackie
31 Posted 30/08/2011 at 08:19:39
I'm of the opinion Kenwright knows he can sell whenever he wants. I strongly suspect the rumours of Sheikh Mansoor's and Randy Lerner's interest ARE true and the fact we haven't got new owners is simply down to HIS GREED AND INCOMPETENCE.

I don't care if the BU taped the meeting, bugged the phones or whatever ? one man should not be allowed to drive a wedge between fans, distance the club from supporters, and allow mediocrity to prevail throughout the club.
Richard Dodd
32 Posted 30/08/2011 at 09:07:43
As long as Flossie is in chage of Everton`s PR -whoeful as it is- all this nonsense will continue.I can tell you,the man is loving it and just lives for confrontation-with anyone!
It has to put Bill`s judgement in doubt that he continues to employ-and even promote this odius individual far beyond his ability!
Chris Matheson
33 Posted 30/08/2011 at 09:25:54
Anyone who thinks our communications department is rubbish, that Ian Ross is hopeless, will get a hard lesson from this episode.

The Everton PR dept has been superb.

That transcript was dynamite. It demonstrated BK was a meandering, clueless fantasist, totally out of touch with the management of the business. Within 24 hours, the story was not, however, the contents of the tape, but the fact that the meeting had been illicitly taped. That was all people were talking about and even now some comments on here (mine included!) are focussing on that aspect ? it is down to canny PR management by the club allied with support from the local media..

I for one applaud the BU and thank them for doing ? instead of (like me, again) simply pontificating on websites. I thank them.

Incidentally, those emails from Mr Ross, if true, are dreadful: if we are indeed a business, would any other business talk about its customers in that way? Shades of Gerald Ratner.

My view is that Kenwright should step down as Chairman, he can keep his shareholding of course and therefore have ultimate veto on a sale, but a business-competent and focussed interim Board should be appointed with a brief to generate finances and sell the club.
Martin Mason
34 Posted 30/08/2011 at 09:54:27
The BU seem to be a rational organisation of the type that I'd like to see discussing issues with the board and keeping the rest of us informed. I can't go to the meeting but I wish them the best and would be willing to help in any way including donating toward any running costs.
Steve Jones
35 Posted 30/08/2011 at 10:06:11
The Blue Union need to get a clear, unassailable mandate from the fanbase to represent them.

The point of unifying the different 'interest groups' was, surely, to form a critical mass at the time the club were trying to protray them as isolated fringe groups of nutters. Thats probably been achieved with the credibility media-time has lent them.

Now they have to entrench their position on the Everton landscape and make themselves the 'recognised' voice for the fans. They have to do it sooner rather than later as well!.
Michael Evans
36 Posted 30/08/2011 at 09:56:28
This is really developing into a battle for hearts and minds... I guess the fundamental question here is what constitutes a "good" supporter of EFC?

Should we give blind, unquestioning support in the belief that the "Powers that be" know best? That would no doubt make BK et al feel much more comfortable.

Alternatively, you can ask those difficult, searching questions about how the club is run because you care too much to just trust that "they know best".

Of course, if you do that, you will get ridiculed and pilloried by those in power who will accuse you of endangering the future of the Club and state that your motives are merely self-aggrandisement.

Change is often a difficult and painful process which few enjoy. Whilst rarely agreeing with Richard Dodd's views, I admire his courage/conviction for continuing to put forward his opinion on TW despite the ridicule that he often receives. Therefore, I find his comments @30 significant in that even he is beginning to question how the Club is run.

Peter Laing
37 Posted 30/08/2011 at 10:23:37
In the words of Curtis Mayfield ? You just have to keep on, keepin' on until you've acheived your goal.

Respect to Blue Union for their efforts in taking the fight to the incompetent Everton board and PR machine headed up by the spineless Ian Ross. You seriously have to question Robert Elstone / Bill Kenwright in their choice of friends / advisors in the shape of Derek Hatton ? incidentally the biggest fraud to socialism and the working classes in history.

Adam Luszniak
38 Posted 30/08/2011 at 11:08:42
Like Peter 35 I have respect for the efforts and hard work put in by the various members of The Blue Union. That said, I think the comments made by Ernie 24 and Aiden 25 both ring true for me. Regardless of any specified 'confidentiality agreements,' the idea of covertly taping a conversation does not sit well with me, and I doubt that it will with a large number of Evertonians.

Steve 33 makes an interesting point about this being a critical moment for BU to identify themselves as a legitimate majority voice for the fan base. Frankly I feel by going about things in this underhand manner they will end up alienating, rather than unifying a large section of Evertonians.

Tony J Williams
39 Posted 30/08/2011 at 12:09:54
Whilst I applaud the Blue Union for actually doing something, it is clear, as Michael suggests, that they did tape the meeting... but so what? Yet, legaility aside, Kenwright was willing to make his points, so taping them to reveal them accurately later on is not that troubling.

My only issue is the one that Michael seems to find irritating. What have they revealed that we don't already know? We knew we were skint, we knew Kenwrong is running this club into the ground... We all know about old Deggsy Hatton. The other new bits of information gleaned from the meeting... so what? The public knowing these things will not help the sale of the club, will not bring any further money in from the banks.

Yes Blue Union got a lot of information, but ultimately all it does is show to everyone how badly run we are, which we Blues already knew... now the other people do too.
Tim Marchant
40 Posted 30/08/2011 at 12:34:05
Secretly taped information, then used to sensationalize already known facts. Where have I heard that recently? Did the BU used to work for the NotW?

Regardless of what was said in the meeting, if they agreed not to tape it, then they should not have. What credibility does it have that they lied, or twisted the truth to get what they wanted?

I personally think that the Blue Union is not the best thing we need now. They strike me as some kind of "Toffee Terrorists" striking to cause fear in the hearts of all true Evertonians.

I agree the club is at a very precarious position, both financially and in its ability to maintain its supporter base. Yes, it needed to be brought out into the light just how strapped we are, but the way the BU have gone about this is just wrong and I have an issue in believing they are now embelishing some aspects of this for their own BK-and-the-board bashing ends.
Brian Harrison
41 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:04:57
I agree totally with Ernie and Aiden in their earlier posts. I believe that most Evertonians would be interested to know how many are involved in this cancerous group. They choose to eat away at our club, without giving any indication of how to solve our problems.

We all know that we are in a poor financial position, and the chances of a super rich investor/buyer coming forward is slim to say the least. I believe if anybody had made a bid and thought that BK's asking price was the stumbling block they would have spoken out publicly, which to my knowledge no-one has.

I keep asking the question: If the whole board was replaced, how does this encourage a new buyer? Maybe this group would prefer the bank to take charge and sell Everton. I would just remind people that banks are not interested in the long term future of Everton ? only in getting their debt paid off.

John Keating
42 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:04:05
Tim 39. So if I support the BU and their actions so far, that does not make me a "true Evertonian"???

So I can only be a "true Evertonian" if I agree with whatever methods you or the Everton heirarchy deem fit?? ? I don't think so, mate!!

I've been going the match to watch this lot since the early 60s and nobody is going to tell me when I am or am not to be classed as a "true Evertonian"... Bloody cheek!!

Chris Matheson
43 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:18:26
Tony J, we knew (or suspected) what was going on at the club. Many other Evertonians did not know, or wanted not to know. What the BU did was confirm suspicions, provide impetus, provide focus.

For me, the current situation of poor management is unsustainable; something has to give. The sooner it does give, the better, for the best interests of the club, because, the longer this goes on, the harder and further we will fall. In this respect, the BU's work is justified, hence the title: "A means to an end".
Colin Fitzpatrick
44 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:26:47
Brian # 40, "I believe that most Evertonians would be interested to know how many are involved in this cancerous group."

My understanding is that there are four, possibly five. Bill, Jon, Robert, Philip and err err another Philip who just hands out free advice to "friends".

As for your last paragraph, I'd re-read what the Blue Union's proposal is if I were you.

Glad to help.
Paul O'Hanlon
45 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:29:25
It makes me laugh when people such as Tim (39) link what BU did to the NotW.

NotW hacked into murder victims voicemail, whilst BU secretly taped an agreed meeting. I don't remember the outcry when John Higgins was secretly taped confessing to taking bribes? The headlines in that case were the content and so it should be here.

Keep up the pressure BU, you have my support and the support of many other supporters.
Andrew Mackenzie
46 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:08:10
I'm not really sure why people are so upset about recording of meetings and I am surprised they are confusing these with recent News International issues.

Illegally accessing people's voicemails is a criminal offence under the Telecommunicaitons Act; taping a private meeting where no written agreement was made is a civil matter and one which a judge is unlikely to find for the club.

Give it up, guys, and stop having a go at supporter groups who are simply trying to highlight the club's desperate financial plight, through mismanagement by the current regime.

Kenwright out!

ps: Moyes, I'd be grateful if you kept your comments to matters on the field, we will continue to be supporters long after your contract expires.
Gavin Ramejkis
47 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:46:29
Brian, you've obviously missed previous posts on NDAs (Non-Disclosure Agreements) ? if a party were to approach Everton seeking to buy, they would be asked to sign an NDA with threat of legal action for disclosing pertinent information that was given to them, such as the company's asking price. If someone with sufficient wealth tries to buy a club and doesn't accept the asking price is right, what on earth would make them go running to the papers crying like a spoilt brat??? These are likely to be multi-millionaires (unless Keith Harris brought them that is in which case 'multi-personality' might be a more suitable term).

Another reminder as you've brought it to the table that given the on-oath statement of Elstone regarding every last man jack of them majority shareholders haven't spent a penny on the club beyond shares, or are willing to either, I'd say your current board are exactly the same ? just looking for a payday and have no other interest whatsoever.
Brian Harrison
48 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:54:19
Colin 43 would you care to say how many attended your last meeting that you had at the Elm Tree.
Colin Fitzpatrick
49 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:59:37
Brian #47, I never had a meeting at the Elm Tree. You're thrashing about like a drowning man - give it up, it's undignified.
Eugene Ruane
50 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:57:19
Re the alleged taping, had to laugh at Ernie Baywood's comment (24).

"I'm finding this whole thing a bit unsavoury".

Tell me Ernie, does your sister dolly still make those upside-down cakes?

As Captain Mainwaring might say: "Well that's too bad Godfrey, there's a war on!"
Steve Jones
51 Posted 30/08/2011 at 13:57:28
That doesn't work Gavin.

If the Club won't deal without a non-disclosure agreement, then the interested party comes out in the media and says 'Look, we want to do x, y and z with EFC and the board aren't even willing to talk'.

How would you react to that story?
Gavin Ramejkis
52 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:08:40
The club are using NDAs though, Steve. Why would anyone take any interest in someone whingeing about standard business process of an NDA? ? they would make themselves look like unprofessional arseholes...

If the club were to put themselves on eBay, you'd know what the price is but it simply isn't that type of sale. A business worth millions of pounds (in its shareholders' minds) would want to keep the price private to deter lower bids which in turn would fuel a downward bidding war.

In the case of Everton Football Club, the information that is openly available for a few pounds would show any significant price to be fanciful, just as Waldorf and Statdler tried across the park.

Tim Marchant
53 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:07:06
John 41 - At what point did I say anything like if you don't agree with me you are not a true Evertonian??

Are you not concerned at the information revealed by the Blue Union? Does this information not make you afraid for the future of the club?

What the sentence says is that they are making more problems than they are solving by using underhand tactics and breaking agreements to reveal what was said in the meeting, and sensationalizing this whole affair.

Get off your high horse and learn to understand the context in which something is written, and read something properly before leaping on it.
Colin Fitzpatrick
54 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:18:31
Tim # 39

"I agree the club is at a very precarious position, both financially and in its ability to maintain its supporter base. Yes it needed to be brought out into the light just how strapped we are, but the way the BU have gone about this is just wrong and I have an issue in believing they are now embelishing some aspects of this for their own BK-and-the-board bashing ends."

How would you have done it Tim?
Brian Harrison
55 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:20:18
Colin 48 sorry I thought you may have been part of the BU protest group, which I understand that they held a meeting in the Elm Tree pub.

So can anybody tell me how many attended this meeting?
Tony Waring
56 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:34:55
Can anyone enlighten me and thousands of other Evertonians what possessed the EFC board to wheel out Derek Hatton at the recent meeting with Bill Kenwright?

This the man who almost single-handedly brought down the city of Liverpool some years ago with his pathetic policies. He may be a true blue but as far as I am aware holds no official position in the club. What exactly is his role?

Colin Fitzpatrick
57 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:34:07
Like I said Brian you're confused, I stand to be corrected but I don't think the Blue Union has ever had a meeting in any pub.
Tim Marchant
58 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:25:43
Colin# 53 Honestly ?

I would have said something like I asked about this, but due to a non-disclosure agreement I cannot tell you what was said, I then asked this, but due to a non-disclosure agreement I cannot tell you what was said. That in itself says volumes for people to read between the lines, but not breaching any NDA or even a handshake or gentlemen's agreement not to publish results. Maybe that is just the way I do things.

You can say that you are forbidden from talking about something, as long as the details of the meeting remain confidential, the fact they are confidential, is not in itself confidential.

Each NDA is different, I have signed several for my work, and they are all different so without knowing the exact details of the NDA, I cannot say for definite.

So much of this from the BU is not directed at the highlighting the clubs problems, but at blaming BK for it, THAT is my main gripe.

To me it seems they are more interested in beating the drums and making a lot of noise that the club is broken, rather than something like, "Ok this is the problem. How can we help the club fix it.

I'm no expert, and do not claim to. I am an eternal optomist, and people can slaughter me for that if you want, I do believe that Bill Kenwright is a good man at heart, but he lets his heart do the business for him, which is a disaster in any ones books.

In this day and age, clubs do not need a fan at the helm, they need a business man who knows football firstly, a fan as well is a bonus but I know which I would prefer.

Getting rid of BK might not solve everything wrong with the club. In fact what we get might be a whole lot worse. (Portsmouth, anyone?)
Michael Kenrick
59 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:35:18
Tony, he facilitated the meeting. I can't remember how the initial contact with Blue Union came about but it's possible that, without him, there may have been no meeting.

I suppose it's understandable then that he would attend the meeting but what puzzled me was that the original report made no mention of this. Did he remain silent for 3½ hours!?! The latest revelations suggest that he may have persuaded them to exclude him from the transcript.
Eugene Ruane
60 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:35:22
Tony (55) a good question.

Some are looking at BU and crying 'unsavoury' yet say fuck-all about the fact that this shifty, swivel-eyed chancer seems to be hand-in-glove with BK et al.
John Keating
61 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:27:41
Tim. Far from getting on my high horse and not reading your mail properly it was actually you who insinuate that by supporting the actions of the BU thus far they are striking fear into the hearts of all " true Evertonians "
I can assure you I am a true Evertonian and their actions do not put fear in my heart.
Who said there was an agreement not to tape the meeting ?
How do you know they lied and twisted the conversation.
Yes Tim I am very much concerned by what was revealed by the BU.
Iam even more concerned about the future of OUR club.
Looking at recent history of our esteemed board and the misinformation that comes out of the club, I am extremely grateful that these young guys had the bottle and commitment to do what they did.
I fully support their actions so far and I would humbly suggest that you actually read what you wrote.
Tommy Coleman
62 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:36:47
Isn't it amazing how a few pro-Kenwrights have popped up out of nowhere.

They don't talk of Kenwright's behaviour and failings over all these years, they're more incensed by a group of Evertonians questioning how he runs the club.

I wonder how much they are on the payroll, maybe we could find out from the £24m 'operating costs' ?
Brian Harrison
63 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:41:54
Colin (56) ? obviously I am mistaken over the location. So would it be possible to ask anyone out there if you have attended any meetings held by the various protest groups? If so would it be possible to state where the meetings were held and how many attended the meetings.
John Keating
64 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:06:52
Brian.

I've been following this thread and, correct me if I'm wrong, it appears that you are trying to correolate the number of people at meetings of "cancerous groups" and the level of disenchantment with the board of EFC.

I personally am not or have not been a member of any "cancerous group"; however, I fully support any action by any group of Everton supporters that enhance the credibility of my club and expose any shortcomings of any person associated with my club that may potentially damage in any way my club.

The actions so far of the young lads of the BU pale into insignificance with the cancerous actions of the board of Everton Football Club in recent years. Just because only 50 or 100 or 8 people attend a meeting, please do not think that that is the total sum of like-minded individuals.

Eugene Ruane
65 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:09:43
Tommy Coleman (61) - Exactly my thoughts.

Outraged Ernie Baywood (24) says..

"That they don't touch on the taping issue is significant and I now believe that they must have done it ? otherwise you'd surely deny it? Who thinks covertly recording a conversation is proper? No chance".

Significant?

Shite and totally IN-significant to me.

Couldn't give FUCK if they taped it, hope they did in fact.

Let's face it, they were dealing with a PROVEN liar, so taping the conversation would have been the smart move.

(ie: don't give the bullshitting, shifty, self-serving twat the chance to say "That's NOT what I said..." etc blah spoof).


Andy Collins
66 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:23:54
Ok so to get this clear..... The pre arrangement was that they could not ask the selling price? correct? and we know from the emails that there was pre agreed there would be a report correct? finally we see that BK himself insisted to write everything down, also correct?

so he knew there would be a report and he insisted on them taking accurate notes so whats the problem with also recording it? as Eugene (64) says, the only thing is now it stops him from lying and saying his word against theres- the end justifies the means for me,
Peter Laing
67 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:30:39
In answer to Brian Harrison @62, Blue Union clearly state the venue of their next meeting ? The Blue Union will be holding a public meeting at 12:00 on September 3rd at the Casa on Hope St when the current dilemma faced by the club and the way forward for The Blue Union will be discussed.

As far as I am aware Brian the Casa is a public bar / venue, I guess the invitation is therefore open to all who want to go along and question their motives. Its more than can be said for the dirty tricks being employed by Everton to try to silence dissenters... see you there mate?

Tim Marchant
68 Posted 30/08/2011 at 14:44:56
Once more then for the cheap seats.

"They strike me as some kind of "Toffee Terrorists" striking to cause fear in the hearts of all true Evertonians."

They strike "ME" ? i.e. this is my opinion of them. As this is my opinion, I reserve the right to say what I said. In my opinion, they are using scaremongering to make a very bad situation, even worse by using a 'gee-whizz' journalistic approach.

I doubt, very much, that we have many fair-weather fans. They would not stick it out long enough waiting for success here. Anyone who has stuck it out this long is either a true fan, or fit for a straight jacket. I'll let everyone make their own mind up which they are.

I did not accuse them of twisting facts in relation to the facts and figure in the report they sent from the meeting. It is not, I repeat NOT, what was said, and the information that came out of the meeting that I have an issue with. How can a source be believed to have the club's best interests at heart if the information is gained by underhand means. It does not lend credibility to what they say. The method is my problem.

I hear no denial about the request for no notes and privacy during the meeting, THAT is the lie; to agree not to do something, then doing it anyway.

We do not need any more hysterical cries of "We're broke, BK is lying to us, worst chairman ever, burn the witch" etc etc. We are in a bad way, we get it; what we need is something constructive.

If you were Bill Kenwright, would you talk to the media, and the Everton fans? The ones that are screaming for him to be hung, drawn and quartered, then the pieces displayed on each corner of Goodison as a warning to the next chairman to do better?

Or would you keep quiet, and keep your head below the parapet?

Who here would enjoy looking at forums like this and seeing themselves insulted like this, every day, and blamed for everything wrong with the Club. I sure as hell would not!

I knew BK several years ago, before I moved away from the area. He won't run the club into the ground because he is incompetent, or because he does not care. The deck is stacked against him, partly bad signings, partly our lack of an ability to keep pace with the rest of the football world, partially bad luck with investors seeming extracting the urine out of us, Partly bad advise from consultants. (The guy in the bedsit in Manchester !?! Seriously WTF was going on there.)

He wants the best for the club, and uses the NSNO philosophy to pass on everything and wait for the golden goose to appear.

Just in case anyone does not understand this now. In simple english.

I support the BU in WHAT they are trying to achieve; however the methods they have employed thus far are not helping to settle anything.

At no point did I indicate, insinuate or suggest that anyone who disagrees with me is not a true Everton fan. If you read it like that than it is your tough luck, and your problem not mine.

The arguments will continue to rage, of that I have no doubt. I will read anything further from them with a pinch of salt.
Ian Smitham
69 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:33:19
Gavin and MK ? Thanks for the replies and thank the good Lord for your comments.

Looking forward to some great debate amongst us in the following weeks. Good men and Thanks Mr MK.
Tommy Coleman
70 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:39:03
Eugene and Andy, you are both right, the Blue Union HAD to tape the meeting, it was the only way to publically expose the truth. Without the tape, Kenwright would have denied everything, even denying that the meeting had taken place.
Chad Schofield
71 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:17:24
Tim #57. Yes to can keep reiterating "I asked about this, but due to a non-disclosure agreement I cannot tell you what was said" but this does really tell anyone anything... Other than you signed an NDA. You seem to suggest that this is better some how than getting three people to recount what they discussed.

I'm struggling to see how this group are being vilified for not producing an out-and-out mandate and springing a violent coup... Or is that not what those angry at the Blue Union not having announced their route forward calling for?

This "cancerous group" have highlighted and produced evidence of what many feared. Cutting the options of those who still believe Bill's some kind of infallible God because of his shared support for Everton. Now all that can be wheeled out is the old "careful what you wish for" mantra.
Tim Marchant
72 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:48:01
The fact you would let everyone know you are gagged speaks volumes itself, given three minutes to think of a solution is not ideal. They would be able to word the interview with enough nounce to make what was being said obvious, but without actually saying this. People are not stupid, and would work it out. Alternatively offering a joint statement may have been an option, or there are probably several other avenues open to them rather than this one.

The other way would be to get the cabinet politician who is a big Everton fan, whose name escapes me at the moment, to use parliamentary privileges to read it out, and legally expose the rotting foundation of the great house.

I wish I knew the solution that would allow all parties to be happy, and I fear that there is not one.

To break one story, the blue union have, presumably, made themselves persona non gratia at the club. cutting all official avenues at Everton now. What more can they achieve without official links into the club, but shout at the walls?
Andy Collins
73 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:44:47
Just to add for any there claiming that the methods used by BU were underhanded ? I say you live by the sword and you die by the sword. FSF was a tool just to engineer Gregg out of the club as opposition to BK, constant lies over issues like DK "not costing a penny" to "well maybe just a little but deal of a lifetime" to about 70 million? He has been underhanded and deceptive in his handling of the club.

Tim says BK wouldn't run the club down on grounds of incompetence ? really? What other chariman would not be able to account for £24 million of your annual income ? especially when we are financially struggling? Maybe if the earnings were billions, yeah... but not a struggling side ? that my friend is criminally negligent.
John Keating
74 Posted 30/08/2011 at 15:55:06
Tim, You must be related to BK.

You wrote a piece - 39 - it seems a few people have questioned parts of it and you have decided that everyone is wrong and you are right. Everyone appears to have read it wrong

Your opening remark in 67 is another hint of the BK connection.Bill also thinks that we are all a load of ignorant hicks!

But then again as you said I read it like that, it's my tough luck and the problems mine.

Brian Waring
75 Posted 30/08/2011 at 17:39:36
Tim (#52) "By using underhand tactics and breaking agreements to what was said in the meeting, and sensationalizing the whole affair."

If that was the case, why didn't the club carry out its threat of legal action?
Colin Fitzpatrick
76 Posted 30/08/2011 at 18:44:00
Tim Marchant #various

Tim, I?m finding it hard to write this reply seriously after reading you?re genuinely suggesting that the blue union could have asked Andy Burnham to read out the document in the house under parliamentary privilege.

Back in the real world and returning to my original question, ?How would you have done it, Tim?? it was indeed a serious question as you had stated ?Regardless of what was said in the meeting, if they agreed not to tape it, then they should not have. What credibility does it have that they lied, or twisted the truth to get what they wanted?? and ?Yes it needed to be brought out into the light just how strapped we are, but the way the BU have gone about this is just wrong.?

In your reply, you start off by telling me a story about a NDA; apart from the fact nobody would be any the wiser if you persistently reported ?due to a non-disclosure agreement I cannot tell you what was said? in answer to every question, you would , a) have wasted a day of your life, b) informed people of nothing, c) made yourself look a complete twat, d) done exactly what the club have done for years; you obviously have missed the point, THERE WAS NO NDA ? THERE WAS NO AGREEMENT FOR THE MEETING TO REMAIN CONFIDENTIAL.

Like a few others on here, you?re exhibiting a complete naivety about dealings with Everton under the Kenwright regime. They want to control everything in the meeting and the reporting of the meeting.

Bill Kenwright is getting most of the blame because he?s the chairman, he is the person the buck stops with. He said it himself: he speaks for the people who own 75% of the club; he is therefore the legitimate target of those who are angry over the club's inability to address long-standing areas of deficiency on the field; deficiencies that whilst no guarantee of success are certainly hindering the possibility of success.

Accepting that there was no NDA or any other agreement whatsoever, save not asking the chairman the question he?s bored with ? and accepting that Everton, from a supporter and shareholder perspective, are an incredibly difficult organisation to question and report on ? I?ll ask you again: Can you please offer a workable scenario that was better than the BU?s method of delivering the confirmation that many have been advocating for a long time on TW but a few, mainly the same few who are now flouncing around doing impressions of ?disgusted of Tunbridge Wells?, who maintained this was all scaremongering?

I have to laugh at what some people are concerned with; let?s just ignore the fact that Bill Kenwright has said things are that bad that he had to not just beg the banks not to kill us this season but he had to confront them with a document that ?Prevented them from stopping the club from trading?.

Jesus wept, yeah let's worry about three young lads outwitting the club and let?s ignore not an elephant in the room but King fucking Kong looking through the window.

Finally Tim, you've just said this, "To break one story, the Blue Union have, presumably, made themselves persona non gratia at the club, cutting all official avenues at Everton now. What more can they achieve without official links into the club, but shout at the walls?" ? I have to ask you, have you actually read anything in that Blue Union statement?

Colin Fitzpatrick
77 Posted 30/08/2011 at 18:59:04
Brian Harrison #62,

?So would it be possible to ask anyone out there if YOU have attended any meetings held by the various protest groups.?

What?s this? Evidence of Teutonic ancestry from circa 1930?s??? Ha ha.
John Shaw
78 Posted 30/08/2011 at 20:02:09
The following was posted earlier by Nick Toye on the Blue Union website:
Nick Toye says:
August 29, 2011 at 9:25 pm
I?d love to know why Ian Ross felt it acceptable to phone a fan (me) up and amongst other things, claim that David Moyes is preventing players joining the club and that David Moyes is a ?cunt?.
This man is part of the problem for me.
If this is genuine, and there's no reason to not believe Nick, somebody at the Echo or Daily Post should be asking the gobshite Ross for his comments.

With Directors like this we haven't got a fucking chance of getting out of the shit we find ourselves in !!
John Farmer
79 Posted 30/08/2011 at 20:45:01
Do Blue Union realise what damage they are doing to our great club, all they are doing is putting off future sponsership and investment. Get real lads.
Brian Waring
80 Posted 30/08/2011 at 21:26:41
"Do Blue Union realise what damage they are doing to our great club?"

That has to be tongue-in-cheek John, right?
Dennis Stevens
81 Posted 30/08/2011 at 21:30:19
John, I think you're the one who needs to "get real".
John Shaw
82 Posted 30/08/2011 at 21:52:24
John (77) - yeh, because after all, those sponsorship deals signed by Elstone in the last two years, (Kitbag, Chang, etc), have been huge, erm, hold on, actually them haven't, they've been embarrasing when compared to other Prem teams !!!

Don't know about get real, i think you need to get a grip !!!
John Audsley
83 Posted 30/08/2011 at 21:34:05
Hahahaha

Top comments Mr Farmer 77

Its those BU Bastards who will put off investment and a buyer coming forward

That has to be a wind up, nice try tiger
Neil Steele
84 Posted 30/08/2011 at 22:25:54
Why is anyone still responding to that obvious crank "Tim Marchant"? The mix of intelligence yet childlike naivety seems a little too concocted for my liking. Funny how you get 30 like-minded replies and then, as if by magic, a few very well versed board cronies rear their heads isn't it....almost as if they weren't real!
Colin Fitzpatrick
85 Posted 30/08/2011 at 23:27:56
John Farmer only appeared on here for the fist time a few weeks ago ? his first post was this:

?Isn't it time we all got behind Bill Kenwright as he is stopping us from going down the same road as Leeds Utd etc. Just look at the debt the reds are building up again. Be careful what you wish for...?

How did that second email from our loveable director of miscommunication end again...... lol
Øystein Heggelund
86 Posted 31/08/2011 at 09:22:09
The content of the email responses from mister Ross is quite frankly unbelievable. How can such an arrogant man, completely without customer relations skills or competence, be our head of PR? It really defies belief.

The tone in his answers, coupled with the reports of journalists being banned for critical journalism, is reminiscent of the attitudes seen in totalitarian states, whose leaders have long since realized that they are out of touch with the general population, or even worse, about to be overthrown. This "our critics are our enemies" view doesn't bode well.
Eugene Ruane
87 Posted 31/08/2011 at 09:44:18
"Tommy Osterburg".

No, too..'Nordic Noir'.

"Ronnie Ball"

No sounds too...invented.

"Dave Smeetle"

No sounds like it's trying to AVOID sounding invented.

"John Farmer".

Hmmm...I like it, it's 'earthy', kind of sounds honest.

John Farmer it is!
Tim Marchant
88 Posted 31/08/2011 at 11:03:32
#82 Neil Steele

I am no crank. Just because my opinion is different to yours makes me a cronie or a crank?

I am entitled to my say as much as you are, and in all honesty I am sick of the crap that is wielded out here.

I live hundreds of miles from Goodison, so the commute to be on of the 'board cronies' would be hellish.

This is supposed to be a fans forum, yet anyone that voices support for Bill Kenwright, or disgrees with anything the Blue Union have done is labelled as a crank or something similar.

As I have said many times, and this the last time. I am glad that this has come into the open; however I do not approve of their methods. I am aware that the ones I suggested earlier are nowhere near ideal, and I wish that I could come up with something perfect, but I can't.
Ernie Baywood
89 Posted 31/08/2011 at 12:02:18
Eugene, you're not looking too good on this thread. Anyone posting an opinion that is contrary to your own is subjected to what I'm sure you would consider to be your sense of humour.

My earlier post wasn't exactly controversial. I don't like the way the BU are going about things and I don't think smearing the club and our owner is the answer.
Dave Randles
90 Posted 31/08/2011 at 12:24:39
Ernie #86. If we knew who our owner was, we could perhaps then smear him!
Eugene Ruane
91 Posted 31/08/2011 at 15:09:23
Ernie (86) - Such is the degree of your general wrongness in EVERYTHING, if YOU think I'm not 'looking too good' comedically, I must ACTUALLY be coming across like a cross between BillHicks and Woody Allen.

You say your post wasn't 'controversial'

True, but it WAS fucking idiotic.

Fact: The BU report revealed (if such a thing were possible) an even GREATER level of uselessness, stupidity and bullshit in our chairman.

YOUR response?

You criticise the BU!

Nob head!
Harry Duffin
92 Posted 01/09/2011 at 17:18:23
A hypothetical situation:

An employee of a midsized company enjoys coming to work; he has good colleagues and strong working relationship with his managers and the board of directors of the company. He realises that there are constraints in the company and things may not have progressed as well as they should in the last couple of years, but believes in the people running the company have the best interests at heart and will try to make things better. He has been sold on the dream of what could happen and team morale outweighs the deficiencies in the existing structures. He knows that there are plenty of other good companies out there, ones which pay better, have better terms and conditions and the perks and potential to meet personal objectives are more possible, but is willing to sacrifice this because he genuinely loves the company, surrounding atmosphere and lifestyle where he is at.

The next day the employee on his way to work finds out via newspapers, the predicament at the company is significantly worse that previously explained and this now causes a number of personal concerns, unlikelihood to meet personal and company ambitions in short-term and causes a significant drop in morale.

If you were in this position what would you do? Would you:

a- Stick it out and hold your ground?
b- Know you could get a job elsewhere, somewhere were your aspirations were more likely to be met and get paid more?

I personally believe that given the circumstances that in all likelihood the only people who would remain in that circumstances will be people who, are unlikely to benefit personally by moving, are coming to end of their careers and know it won?t make a big difference either way, are unlikely to be working full time at any new company. Anyone who could get another job elsewhere and has coveted skills is likely to make the transition elsewhere.

For those of you slow on the update - Moyes+team, Blue Union announcement, current situation.

Without investment in all likelihood Felliani won?t sign, others will not commit to long contracts and our loan signings will not exercise the options of staying even if the club could afford.

It?s a question of Morale. Support the club, stop the whining and provide sensible suggestions on how to make this club better again.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads