Productive Blue Union Meeting

, 3 September, 182comments  |  Jump to most recent
Reports are filtering in that the Blue Union meeting today was productive in terms of consolidating support for continuing action. A peaceful protest march is planned for next Saturday, ahead of the Aston Villa game. More details will be forthcoming...

Quotes or other material sourced from Blue Union



Reader Comments (182)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Andy Duff
1 Posted 03/09/2011 at 14:15:36
Just back from meeting. Great turnout room was too small. A few memtions by Toffeewebbers. In short prtotesr will be held before Villa game. Sky BBC and ITV there ? no Echo or Radio City.

I'm sure others will do a proper write-up.
Chris Regan
2 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:11:48
I have just got back from the People?s Union meeting in Liverpool. Well done to the lads for organising a good event very well attended as well.

The up-shot is that a peaceful protest is planned before next week?s game against Vila. Details will be announced on the various fan sites throughout the week. Spread the word tell every Blue to turn up!

Peter Laing
3 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:08:46
Was also at the meeting Andy Duff, great attendance, the Casa was packed to the rafters, I would guess 500+ with lots of people unable to access the meeting room. The mood was one of collective harmony, Blue Union quite clearly and readily admitting that they do not have the answers to the Club's perilous financial state.

However those in attendance where in unison in that we know who is responsible for this mess and it is nigh on time to bring them to book on their continuing failure and mismanagement. The fight starts here, protests and a march to be arranged for the Aston Villa game.

To Ian Ross, we are not going away, this is only the begining and a means to an end, 50 or 60 is now becoming 500-600 and next week / month it will be 5000-6000. Proud to be a blue today.

Robert Daniels
4 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:33:12
Just back from the meeting, well attended, but am shocked after Sky TV, BBC and Granada's attendance, that the Echo, Radio City and Radio Merseyside couldn't be bothered to turn up?

How strange is that?

As others have said, the fight starts here.

Coybs...
Neil Humphreys
5 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:20:46
It was a good meeting and forum. I went with an open mind. To be clear, the Blue Union is clearly in formation phase, they don't have the answers but they are certainly clear on their thoughts on the status quo. I agree with the chap from the audience who said that there needs to be a figurehead or focal point for BU and sadly, as the three organisations haven't merged into one (which I certainly think they should) it will be difficult.

I think that Dave is clearly the most talented and forceful orator of the group, but was most impressed with the speaker from The People's Group. He was the most balanced and charismatic and therefore the most obvious spokesman.

Overall, I have come home a few quid lighter but with more questions than answers. If the Blue Union could ally with the Shareholders Association, then they would have both ends of the spectrum covered ? protest and a right to a say.

I would not demean the group in any way, they are a force for change and a group of well intentioned Blues, but I can't see them being the catalyst for real change.

I'm inspired to go to the Villa game and lend my support, and I'd encourage fence-sitters and nay-sayers to do the same. The Blue Union is not a solution, it's a collective which is making an effort to change things ? and for that, I applaud them.

Peter Laing
6 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:42:44
Viva Blue Union ? a voice for change. Proud to be associated with an organisation that is not prepared to sit on its arse whilst the Club goes down the shitter.
Nick Toye
7 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:48:32
Just come back from the Blue Union meeting at The Casa. First impressions was that it was a good turnout, maybe more than they anticipated.

I was fairly impressed with the speakers, although I still believe that many words were said for a means to an end, rather than being open and honest. I just put that down to the fans fighting the club with fire.

Anyway, what I have noticed over the summer and especially in recent weeks is a fan base split in two. Then split again into 4 groups, and other fans bickering with other fans who are still after the same thing.

It really needs to be fused and roll the fans forward as one element and not different voices shouting different things.

I also feel some of the fans need to get this 'kopite' mentality out of their heads. Fans protest. Liverpool were not the first, and won't be the last. Bottom line is, they got their message across and look at them now. Far too many of our own fans are just obsessed with not being a 'kopite' ? which for me just shows the level of intelligence out there.

The main goal of all is the same, surely we want to see Everton back where they belong. Any like-minded fan knows that Kenwright is not capable of that job, and he needs to get out, regardless of whether or not he feels he is the right man to sell Everton ? it clearly isn't the case.

So all fans need to stop sniping at each other, need to stop slinging mud at each other and concentrate on the one element that is needed to make everyone be happy with being an Everton fan ? because in the past 25 years ? there hasn't been many times when smiles have been had.

I don't post anymore on forums, because it was mainly about sniping and people arguing that the sky is green and not blue, and so on. A quick scout around and they are still sniping at each other. More alarmingly it's between fans who apparently both want the same thing. It's pathetic, and childish.

We need to go forward as one.

Michael Kenrick
8 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:49:22
Nick, good call for unity; that's the whole point of the Blue Union.

But rather than sniping at the snipers, I would suggest you look in the mirror and step down off your own high horse about the forums. Of course there will be disagreements, there always are when individuals put forward their opinions. Have you considered what you could provide by trying to be a part of that process rather than putting yourself above it?

Oh I guess you have... otherwise you wouldn't have posted on such a forum.

Peter Laing
9 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:56:12
Also wanted to add that Everton did not send a representative, Ian Ross and Graeme Sharp had both been invited to attend the meeting but did not offer the curteousy of a reply. Without wanting to stir-up a hornet's nest, there is also widespread recognition of Ian Ross's modus operandi...
Robert Daniels
10 Posted 03/09/2011 at 15:56:49
One of the speakers said they did ask that question, "How much, Bill... £20M? £30M?? £50M??? £70M????" ? "It doesn't matter, it will go for what it's worth."

Strange answer from a strange chairman.

Somebody also said, at one point during the BK/BU meeting, he was gazing out of the window reciting poetry?!?
Billy Bradshaw
11 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:04:50
One of the questions I wanted to ask was why Bluekipper did not advertise the meeting on their website and why they're not part of the Blue Union?? Anyone got any ideas??
Neil Humphreys
12 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:06:10
Robert, that was the chap from The Peoples Group. He managed to get a couple of laughs. You can just imagine Bill sitting in the Directors Box, surrounded with bailiffs tearing the place apart, while he is staring wistfully into the distance and spewing bollocks about the Boys Pen...
Michael Kenrick
13 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:15:08
I believe the person from The People's Group would be Simon Magner. Can anyone confirm that? And give names of the other speakers, one of whom was probably Dave Kelly.
Anthony Flack
14 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:05:43
Mike ? there is something to be said for the position put forward by Nick Toye, a shame that you chose to respond as you have, whether Nick's position is right or wrong.

I have no answer or solution so may fall helplessly into the same place I feel the majority of Evertonians fall ? this place is one where we are worried about the future, love the club to bits but do not yet feel the Blue Union offers anything other than contention with the club but without any clear way forward.

I would be entirely against a march, what is the point? Is it to make the club listen or be aware of the feeling of the Blue Union? Is it to rally support and grow through contagion as someone else suggests?

The club is aware of the predicament and the feelings of the fans and the Blue Union, I am certain that if there was a good idea that someone could present that would make the predicament better then the club would go for it ? but at the moment there is nothing just protest........

For me it will drag the club and supporters down, I will stick to relentless support for the 11 on the pitch and for Moyes, I am not suggesting others who protest will not ? but I just do not see how it is constructive.

Collaboration between fan groups and the club is the way forward, protest is not the way to achieve collaboration, it pits parties against each other. However, I recognise that collaboration requires the engagement and communication from both parties and this is where the club lets itself down....

Long post and sorry if I have bored anyone.
Peter Laing
15 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:14:33
Agree with your comments Billy Bradshaw, BK is also running a piece today regarding Phil Neville's comments which seem like a veiled attack on anyone attempting to question the current state of the Club. BK does pay reference on its diary page to the Blue Union meeting today.

With regards ro Neville, Club captain or not he is a Manchester United fan and that is where his loyalties lie, he is nothing more than an employee of Everton and I hasten to add a Captain that is unlikely to ever lift silverware at Everton ? unlike the greats of Ratcliffe and Labone.

Robert Daniels
16 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:17:27
Joe Jennings was there as well.

Niel, spot on; Reminds me of Mel Brooks in blazing saddles, getting his ping pong bat out in his boxer shorts, complete with suspenders on his socks.

The man's lost the plot, unbelievable to think he runs our club ? or doesn't, more like it.
Peter Laing
17 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:20:23
Dave Kelly from KEIOC, Joe Jennings, a lad from Evertonians for Change and a guy from the People's Group
Michael Kenrick
18 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:21:49
I can understand your concern, Anthony, you raise a very valid issue, and I'm sure there will be Evertonians who agree with you that protest is pointless.

I think what we are seeing here is a developing process. We are right at the beginning of that process (hopefully...) and it could have a very long way to go before we get to a final result.

One important step is to keep the momentum going, and that is vital. Otherwise, people lose interest, support drops away, and the whole thing fizzles.

A protest march will maintain visibility, it will confirm the support of like-minded Evertonians who agree with the aims of Blue Union ? not the solution, as you are right... they don't have one yet ? but a general agreement about the aims of the group.

And above all (if well attended) it should make it harder and harder for the club to continue to marginalise and ignore the protestors as a noisy minority.
Robert Daniels
19 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:30:41
Well said, Michael.

It is the start of the end, a long way to go.

The Blue Union made it clear that they will listen to any suggestions on how to move forward, but we do need to keep up momentum.
Khoon Yean Soo Hoo
20 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:40:53
The solution is for Bill to stop asking for a high price for his shares! He should do the honourable thing by sellling to someone who has the means to bring the club forward. Because of his selfish greedy position he has taken, the club has suffered!
Peter Laing
21 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:32:38
This is what Blue Union said today, Michael ? this is the start, they acknowledge that they do not have all of the solutions, they are open and willing to listen, take on suggestions.

Somebody in the audience suggested that the blue union needs a charismatic leader, a well known face or figurehead. I feel the opposite, it's about growing organically as a group, ordinary supporters with the common belief and aim of affecting change as opposed to one view or esoteric position.

Peter Laing
22 Posted 03/09/2011 at 16:45:56
In answer to Anthony Flack @ 14, I agree with your comments regarding the divisions within the fan-base. However we live in a democracy and Blue Union has a right to exercise its belief that actions speak louder than words. Hence the meeting today and the march planned for next week. You are entitled to believe that such action's may reflect negatively on the Club, however others such as myself feel otherwise.

Opposing views apart, how can we engage with the Club when they handpick fans to attend their forums, ban AGMs, and use spin and dirty tricks to constantly discredit any group or individual that has the temerity to question the fact that the Club is being run like a shoddy corner shop?

Andy Duff
23 Posted 03/09/2011 at 17:00:36
The lad from The People's Group with the Kenwright anecdotes was called Mark.

One point: it was stated on two occasions ? any protest must be peaceful.
Michael Kenrick
24 Posted 03/09/2011 at 17:28:44
Thanks, Andy. That would be Mark Jones then, not Simon Magner (who was at the BK meeting), Barry Jones being the third BU member there.
Trevor Mackie
25 Posted 03/09/2011 at 17:26:00
Well done all involved.

An earlier post saying BK and Co know about discontent so why protest.... because he's not taking it seriously, that's why.

If anything's come from the original meeting, it's exposure of the patronising complacency that exists at Everton ? they see this shit period in our history as acceptable.

Well it's fuckin' not.

Victor Chang
26 Posted 03/09/2011 at 17:02:59
Anthony@14, how many times have the board brushed aside the fanbase in a call-centre-esque script read fasion? A protest march shows them we will not be ignored, puts pressure on them to run the club more efficiently and be more involved with the fanbase rather than treat us like 50-60 idiots loitering around the stadium.
Kevin Tully
27 Posted 03/09/2011 at 17:52:42
One fact I learnt from the BK/BU meeting was the fucker won't go peacefully. He will have to be forced out of the club, along with the other deadwood on the board.

BK underestimates the level of discontent that is brewing. One deluded man.
Gary Rimmer
28 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:11:28
The board is not ignoring the fan base, big deal 500-600 fans turn up on a Saturday for what has been billed as some sort of life saving meeting. Nearly 20 thousand turn up for midweek no-mark cup game.

Until you can prove BK has turned down our shining knight or come up with investors of your own, there's nothing to protest about. What was the result of all this, for you to tell us we need investment. BK has been saying this since he saved us from Mr Hamper. Just like him, you have failed to come up with one.

Until someone comes up with a genuine offer or replacement for BK I will not join you in telling the press and the rest of the country that EFC is a mess. Against the Villa I will be there shouting my head off encouraging the team to win, not worrying about balance sheets. Onward Evertonians.

Phil Bellis
29 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:28:20
Gary ? Get off you high horse; we all support the badge and the team. But supporting the team doesn't mean we can't criticise Kenwright and his disastrous "stewardship" of our club.

"Nothing to protest about"... no wonder we're in such a mess.

Michael Kenrick
30 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:27:40
Gary, we are faced with a choice: do we give the Blue Union time to develop and grow into a movement that can be an agent for change?

Or do we naysay them, and give the current incumbents even more time to sort things out? How long has Kenwright been looking for investment? 24/7? Has he succeeded? No.

It's time for change. What that change will be is something YOU could help shape through your support for Blue Union and what they are trying to achieve.

Or you choose stagnation. No matter what, we ALL continue to provide our support to the team when they play.
Danny James
31 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:00:02
I agree the board are not capable of taking this club back to glories of the past and reinstating us contenders for major honours again.

I also agree that they show the fans a total lack of respect by not being totally transparent with our financial situation and difficulties they are having attracting buyers

What concerns me is that we need a buyer for the club who is worth at least 4 billion.
The minimum initial investment just to clear debts, build a new stadium and provide immediate transfer funds would be 500 million. On top of that they would need to purchase the current owners shares aswell.

The guys who bought QPR and Blackburn arent rich enough to buy a club like ours and make the necessary steps to improve us. I am yet to be convinced if an owner that would have the finance we need is out there

It is one thing for fans to think that kind of owner is out there and the board are refusing to sell for whatever reason. We also have to consider the plausibility that maybe that kind of owner we need has not come forward yet

I applaud that fans are getting together to represent a strong united voice that things arent good enough and that the current board need to be more open with fans about the state of our club
I just think if this purely becomes an anti Kenright movement with protests and chants of 'sack the board' etc it really wont achieve anything. If suitable owners arent out there it doesnt matter how much we protest change of ownership wont happen


Anthony Flack
32 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:27:41
Peter (22) and Michael - good valid comments, I in fact believe it is right to march if one believes there is value to be had in the exercise, I did not intend to suggest people should not, I was offering my personal perspective of why I would not participate and in fact disagree with approach, as it will not lead to an increase in unity between fan and club, and is likely to result in further division.

Reflecting on my earlier comment collaboration is the way forward but I suspect that positions are now entrenched, too many insults and personal attacks from the fans and the inept communications performance from the club. Vicious circle and all that...

I prefer caution in an approach and I am afraid that if the Blue Union does gather a sufficient "head of steam" to be effective, then one must consider the impact of this action,

i.e. are you prepared for several steps back before you move forward - as the club and therefore the players and fans will get dragged down by this, I think the dragging down is more likely than any subsequent improvement.

This is what worries me - until there is a plan for what next, we should avoid dragging the club
down......

Keep up the good work and stay behind the players and Moyes
Simon Smith
33 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:13:33
Not able to be there due to distance but good reading about it. I hope a peaceful demo can go ahead next week and remember this.....

From small acorns mighty oaks do grow!
Paul Johnson
34 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:25:54
It's about bringing these chancers to account, Gary. We are not 50-60 morons but a sizeable portion of the match-going fanbase who are greatly concerned at the mismanagement of our club. I will not stand by and watch our club sink any further without voicing my disatisfaction so I will protest and like you I will get 100% behind the team come kick off.
Gavin Ramejkis
35 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:32:59
A march or protest inside or outside the ground brings visual attention and media coverage. The media lest we forget are still full of the plucky little Everton stories, you know the ones, run well on a shoestring in an environment of excess.

Gary you are entitled to your opinion and method of doing as you please but you cant denigrate the BU or any of the other fans groups for wanting to protest as quite an equal counterbalance to your own argument would be can you prove BK hasn't turned anyone down - its all speculation until the smoking gun appears and equally as valid.

It's also not a non board member or majority shareholders job to find a buyer - even if it was it would be pretty hard with no idea of an asking price. The fans groups might not have the final solution but they are in agreement that maintaining the status quo isn't the way forward. Twelve years of mismanagement and lack of sale, pointless looking to investment now, hasn't got the club anywhere.
Colin Malone
36 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:15:31
Are the KEIOC people involved, ie ,Tom Hughes and Colin Fitzpatrick?

No distrespect of to any other groups but KEIOC did enormous amount of work to keep us from going to DK. Also, there's nothing to stop the pro-EFC boardroom putting a group together, with the backing of the media/ Echo and both radio stations, with the propaganda.

Thanks to you all.

Peter Laing
37 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:55:30
The only 'on the record' KEIOC member at today's Blue Union meeting was Dave Kelly. Having read previous pieces from Colin Fitzpatrick and Tom Hughes I would concur that both possess remarkable knowledge and the investigative skills required to delve into the murky waters of Everton's affairs that would put our local journalists to shame.

Toffeeweb I'm also pleased to say was cited on a number of occassions today, a testament in my opinion for the fantastic role that it play's in offering a platform for both healthy debate and discussion concerning the wellbeing of our Club.
Michael Kenrick
38 Posted 03/09/2011 at 18:55:30
Danny (#31) ? you make a good point. I personally believe we have missed the boat when it comes to the billionaire owner. I'm not convinced that would have been the best route forward, although we could perhaps be doing a Man City right now... but that's pure fantasy.

But Bungling Bill has shown conclusively he is not fit for the purpose. The first step has to be to get some sort of acceptance that what he's doing, while staving off Administration, is NOT taking the club forward. The proposal is for an interim board as a first step, but that has to be achieved with Kenwright's agreement, and we are still a very long way from seeing that happen. Hence the need for pressure, and a protest march.

There may be alternative paths forward... Everton Fans Trust for example. I don't wish to knock them but they have become a classic example of what happens when you fail to maintain the momentum in public.

Keep the pressure on. Otherwise, nothing will change.

John Audsley
41 Posted 03/09/2011 at 19:01:09
Gary 28

If we continue the way we are going then we are finished

Change has to happen

Nothing to protest about!!! ok then, please tell me what Kenwright, Woods and Earl have actually brought to EFC????

In any way, shape or form

If you can give me something that makes me believe these men are fit and proper to run this GREAT club then il personally buy you a beer at every home game i can get to this season

and please dont mention Sly Stallone, his Everton coat still had the tags on....
Gary Rimmer
42 Posted 03/09/2011 at 19:03:09
Protest about what, Take out four teams the shite, Man U Man C & Chelsea, who has money. Maybe Spurs have spent a bit more. The other great historical clubs are trying to catch up with EFC how many Wolves or Stoke players are on the wages Arteta was on. He even had to take a pay cut for the gooners. From my point of view in Bk I see a guy who really tries his best to squeeze every penny he can out of the club to put it on the pitch, You had the Pompey Chairman on 2 mil a year. I will say it again unless someone can show me BK has blocked genuine investment into EFC which would have benifited the club or have viable investment themselves its all just hot air to me. From when I was a kid in 60s till now we have always had our up and downs. There has been much worse downs from managers resigning over not being able to sing Dion Dublin to us being that poor that the fans tried to organise a wip round to get a 100k for Terry Curren but NEVER EVER have we protesed against a scouse guy who puts his life saving into the club and mortgages his house to save us until something better comes along. Until we or I can improve on that not only will I suppourt him but I thank him for it. Oward Evertonians
Andrew Gilbert
43 Posted 03/09/2011 at 19:12:00
Have BU cleared this march with the Police as all marches have to be these days?

If not then it would probably not last last long or descend into something nobody wants.

Just hope it's all done properly as the time scale doesn't look good.
Danny James
45 Posted 03/09/2011 at 19:09:04
Michael. I do agree in principle with the notion of an interim board whose sole objective is to find the right investment for our club. This would help fans to understand the difficulties the board may be having in finding suitable investment.

Because of the secrecy of the current board and their unwillingness to liaise with fans its so easy for us to come to the most negative of conclusions i.e that the club is not looking to sell or are asking too much, or that money is disappearing into the back pockets of the quietly influential men behind the scenes at Goodison. Independent involvment in finding investment could either dispel or confirm this.

I just think that as we develop this movement we have to approach it with initially with objectvity. By all means hold the view that he is responsible for the state that the club is in at present but we also need to consider that it is possible that any owner of our club who has a net worth of 20 million or so might not have been able to progress the club any further

I am not condoning him. He hasnt been good enough and rich enough to take the club foward in the way that we want. But if the protest descends solely into a hostile anti-Kenwright movement it may prove more detrimental than anything. I reserve pure hostility towards him until i am convinced he has turned away people who would have taken this club forward or it is proven he is seriously not looking for investment.

Hopefully this movement can clarify whether he is deliberately holding the club back or whether he has done all a man of his limitations can and that there is just no willing person waiting to take over the baton .

I just pray we arent going into this having already made our mind up from the outset
Ged Alexander
46 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:07:03
All I would like to add is this: No anti-Bill chanting DURING the game...the team comes first.
Neil Humphreys
47 Posted 03/09/2011 at 19:45:31
Andrew, the details of the march have not been set for exactly that reason. They will speak with the police before confirming anything. We also made the point that the march should be on the highway and not on EFC grounds. No point allowing the club to cause issues by moving fans off premises.
Mark Rankin
48 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:10:41
For me it is put up or shut; good, bad or indifferent bk wrestled control of the club and until one of us blues, blue union or some other party stumps up the cash then I think we should just wind our necks back in - thems the rules.
For anyone slagging off bk by the way, if you landed a big jackpot how many of us would 'invest' it in everton (or any other footy club for that matter) if you did you'd be pissing it up the wall.
Neil Humphreys
49 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:19:59
Ged, unlikely. Given the feelings I imagine that BK will feel the wrath, though everybody is fully supportive of the 11 on the pitch as we have been in the past. Its also important that this is an anti-board protest, not just BK!
Neil Humphreys
50 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:22:19
Mark, there is sense in what you say, if you treat the club as a standard company. However, this isnt a consumer protest, the club runs a monopoly based on the love of the fans.... What exactly is the club without the community and fan base? An empty shell.
I wrestle with the thought of what will this achieve, and always come to the same conclusion- is silence and inaction better. Its not... And at least BU is making a public show of sentiment.
And finally, you make the age old claim of put in your own cash, my counter is this. What exactly aside from their share purchase have the board ever put into the club? Answers on a postcard please!
Phil Skupski
51 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:08:01
Well said Gary (41). The club is in a far better position than it was when BK took over and from a distance I have no doubt that he loves the Club just as much as any of us - so I too support him and thank him for what he has done.

Let's not forget that our admission prices are amongst the lowest in the Premiership - shall we all pay £10 more per game and generate another circa £6m a year to bring in another player?

What does £6m buy though? With the fee and the wages Arsenal have just invested circa £21m in the best little Spaniard we know - the sums involved are huge and the truth is that BK is sadly a Pauper in comparison to guys who are shelling out fortunes and gradually, in my view, ruining the English game.

So for the Protesters to get my backing they have to prove that the current Board have blocked genuine investment into the Club.

If genuine incompetence existed at Board level then I do not doubt that DM would have walked by now as would have Baines/Jags/Felli - that to me is the acid test.
Trefor Jones
52 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:25:27
Mark Rankin is spot on,most of the rest is showboating and unrealistic pub talk
Dennis Stevens
55 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:19:32
Gary : "... NEVER EVER have we protesed against a scouse guy who puts his life saving into the club and mortgages his house to save us until something better comes along." - Is that who you think Kenwright is? No wonder you don't seem to understand why people are planning to protest against the current Board.
Neil Humphreys
56 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:35:47
Phil, prior to the current regime, the club ran a surplus; we now owe £90m and own absolutely no assets. You also fail to point out that, far from being anti-Johnson, BK sat on his board and was very close to PJ. He wasn't a knight on a white charger, he was an existing board member who used leveraged finance (from whatever source) to take advantage of PJ getting out.

I always try to understand what BK's motivations were. My take is somewhere between ego and financial reward. In any case, if you continue to believe the Blue Bill, 'jumpers for goalposts' story, fair play to you. I like to use one of my nan's word for him ? he's a phoney!

Joe McMahon
57 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:43:33
Well done all involved, I couldn't get there and very pissed off about that. Good news about a proper march!
Dennis Stevens
59 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:42:17
Mark, there are no rules, other than the ones you've made up. None of the money that flows into the Everton coffers each season comes from the Board, it comes diectly or indirectly from supporters.

Phil, "The club is in a far better position than it was when BK took over." - No, it is most definitely not!
Phil Skupski
60 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:45:24
Thanks Neil - appreciate your view but unless either of us could sit down with BK and glean enough information to arrive at an informed view we will never know which of us is nearest to reality.

£90m debt vs recent Press reports of nearer £50m - where does the truth actually lie?
Johnny Rainford
61 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:54:01
well done lads. we need to build the momentum even more.. please keep it going... Johnny R
Simon Harris
62 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:19:04
Gary #41

The crux of the matter for me, and the reason why I will be protesting, is my belief that Kenwright and his advisors are not fit for purpose in finding investment or a suitable buyer.

For many years we'd heard the odd snippet from Keith Harris and Bill Kenwright regarding the sale of the club, and then a year or two would pass without a sniff. Finally, we then learn through the BU interview, that Keith is in daily contact with Bill (after our CEO denied his involvement) and then we hear the infamous and embarrassing tale, of the man in a one bedroom flat and the inventor from Manchester claiming to be from ICI.

The club has yet to deny this story, even after it hit the national press.

Two failed ground moves, Fortress funds, the appalling communication with the fans (AGM etc) had many of us questioning Bill's ability to lead 'our' club, but hey, he was a fellow blue and surely had the best interest of the club at heart. So many turned a blind eye and used the Pompey and Leeds debacles as evidence to support this theory. (Some still do).

But after learning that our chairman and his trusted advisor (the same advisor who lured Michael Knighton to MUFC) took the club through due diligence only for our chairman to 'smell a rat' at the last minute was the final straw for me.

So why protest? easy, it's in answering the following question - Should Bill Kenwright and Keith Harris be left with the responsibility of finding Everton a buyer (or investment) after their 11 year, 24x7 search has so far failed miserably?

Oh, and a message to the guy sat eating pizza in the Manchester bedsit - could you let us know how much Bill wants for the club please? Ta
Neil Humphreys
63 Posted 03/09/2011 at 21:04:50
Phil, the press are lazy. The club quotes £45 to 50M as a manageable number. That is short-term debt; actual obligations are £90M including the £40M mortgage etc. Those numbers have been batted about on this site for years but the synopsis seems to be accounting terms, we generally have short term debts (short term loans and overdraft) of £45/50M; there is then the mortgage of £40M-ish which isn't quoted.

Far more financially savvy people than me have gone through this in detail... suffice to say, it's more than the club publicly state and the press report.

I apologise for the variances in the above; suffice to say, if it was my business, I'd damn well know what £24M in "Other operating costs" were!

David Barks
64 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:59:23
It doesn't matter what exact figure the debt is at, don't get stuck arguing pointless figures. What matters is that, whatever figure the debt is at, the club is no longer able to service it and cannot strengthen the squad for two years running, in fact they are selling off the valuable members of the team to pay down the debt. The exact figure is irrelevant and only derails the discussion.

A march will be a good step, as long as it stays respectful and on message. By respectful I don't mean being nice to the Board. I mean don't get into shouting matches, cursing at anyone who disagrees. Engage them, ask them how they feel about our two best midfielders being sold within the span of eight months (Arteta and Pienaar), with nobody being bought in two years. Ask them if they are concerned that Everton are falling further behind the rest of the league. Ask them what steps they think should be taken. But don't lose your temper; at that point, the message is lost and if the media is covering it, that will be what gets presented and not the important aspects.

The momentum is starting to build and this can only be positive. It's pathetic that the local media didn't cover it, but I think given the turnout they will have no choice going forward. A newspaper that ignores the news becomes irrelevant, which means they lose more money. They won't want that to happen and will be forced to cover this from now on. And with the national press covering the event the Board will have to start addressing this as well. That is why staying on message is so important. They will discuss and investigate the questions that this group is asking.

So, going back to my original point, they don't need to know if the debt is £50 or 90 million. All that matters is that the Board has no idea what to do about it or how to make Everton progress. That's what's important and what the press needs to investigate. What does the Board plan to do? Who are they? And what is their role? Why are there billionaires on our Board who won't invest any of their money?

Gary Rimmer
65 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:57:47
If the protest isa bout some billioniare who wants buy us., can you please tell me his name. I want to ask him why when we have been for sale for so long he hasn't made is move.
Then again if it is about investment what is there to invest in. The 2nd team in a small city with no worldwide fanbase. The answer lies with us, our comunity, the one EFC represents and if we cant raise anymore thats the way it is. Its not called standing still its called getting into Europe & FA cup final in the last few years. Its our club no one elses & I dont need any protest mob to tell me & the rest of the world that because we haven't been in as many ECL finals ,semi finals as LFC, Man u , Chealse & Arsenal we dont have as much to spend on players. Then again how many of them games were we in before BK. Why are people trying to make out its all BKs fault. Why ? if they are that conceredned about the clubs plight why dont they give an extra £50 per week to the club. It might not solve the situation but surley if your are that worrried about our finances it would help a lot more than moaning and groaning. Then again talks & futile walks are cheap.Onward Evertonians
Phil Bellis
67 Posted 03/09/2011 at 21:26:09
Gary... after reading that I'm getting back in the shower.

Shameful.
Simon Harris
68 Posted 03/09/2011 at 20:19:04
Gary #41

The crux of the matter for me, and the reason why I will be protesting, is my belief that Kenwright and his advisors are not fit for purpose in finding investment or a suitable buyer.

For many years we'd heard the odd snippet from Keith Harris and Bill Kenwright regarding the sale of the club, and then a year or two would pass without a sniff. Finally, we then learn through the BU interview, that Keith is in daily contact with Bill (after our CEO denied his involvement) and then we hear the infamous and embarrassing tale, of the man in a one bedroom flat and the inventor from Manchester claiming to be from ICI.

The club has yet to deny this story, even after it hit the national press.

Two failed ground moves, Fortress funds, the appalling communication with the fans (AGM etc) had many of us questioning Bill's ability to lead 'our' club, but hey, he was a fellow blue and surely had the best interest of the club at heart. So many turned a blind eye and used the Pompey and Leeds debacles as evidence to support this theory. (Some still do).

But after learning that our chairman and his trusted advisor (the same advisor who lured Michael Knighton to MUFC) took the club through due diligence only for our chairman to 'smell a rat' at the last minute was the final straw for me.

So why protest? easy, it's in answering the following question - Should Bill Kenwright and Keith Harris be left with the responsibility of finding Everton a buyer (or investment) after their 11 year, 24x7 search has so far failed miserably?

Oh, and a message to the guy sat eating pizza in the Manchester bedsit - could you let us know how much Bill wants for the club please? Ta
Brian Lea
69 Posted 03/09/2011 at 21:28:04
Bluekipper weren't there because they are up Kenwright's arse. Put threads on there saying Kenwright should go ? they never put it on. A few people I know have said the same.....
Kunal Desai
70 Posted 03/09/2011 at 21:21:25
Will there be any further meetings held outside of Liverpool? Being based down south i'd love to be involved in some capacity. Are there any meetings planned with supporters club such as ESCLA? I think there needs to be meetings held in designated cities for those who would like to participate but cannot attend in Liverpool.

Just one a sidenote, Kenshite is pathetic with his claim about a guy living in a bedsit. At least try and come up with a better excuse. All he's doing is making people believe he's trying to sell the club. More lies. Just how would someone living in a bedsit get to the stage of taking over a club, he/she wouldn't get even to saying hello to a chairman let alone any business dealings. Then again, that's why he's known as 'Bullshit' Billy.
Anthony Manning
71 Posted 03/09/2011 at 21:16:37
The Echo, Merseyside and City not being there today was an arrow to the heart for me, the so-called voice of our city has showed its true colours, they don`t give two fucks about Everton.

The march on Saturday is a start but we need to get the protest inside the stadium, my suggestion is a protest colour like Man Utd, the original colours of black with pink sash tops, they can take our banners down but they can`t strip us of our fucking shirts.

Anthony Manning
72 Posted 03/09/2011 at 21:47:02
GaryRimmer#59 in all my time reading Toffeeweb i`ve never read so much shite. If you think Everton are for sale then you need to get your head out your arse, also Liverpool is the 3rd biggest city in England with Merseyside and Wirral expanding the population to almost 2 million ? hardly a hamlet. If you don't want to be part of any movement for change then log off and go to bed.
Robert Daniels
73 Posted 03/09/2011 at 22:10:16
Anthony @ 65,

Says it all mate, spot on.
Peter Laing
74 Posted 03/09/2011 at 22:11:35
@ Trefor 49 the only pub-talking that happened today at the Blue Union meeting was that yes it was held in a public house. There was no showboating just genuine concern shown by fellow Evertonians regarding our future. Your comments are disgraceful.
Jan Kowsky
75 Posted 03/09/2011 at 21:54:52
If the local media is choosing to ignore the growing concerns among many Evertonians, perhaps it would be an idea to demonstrate outside Radio City and Radio Merseyside?

But I wouldn't waste your time protesting outside the offices of the 'Oldham' Echo.
John Audsley
76 Posted 03/09/2011 at 22:45:47
Gary, thats pretty poor

please answer my q @ 39 please
Chris Leyland
77 Posted 03/09/2011 at 23:21:35
Anthony ? Liverpool is the 7th largest city in England after London, Birmingham, Leeds, Sheffield, Bradford, Manchester.
Julie Naybour
78 Posted 03/09/2011 at 23:09:48
This is a serious question - can you clarify who are you suggesting should take over from BK? Obviously you appreciate the protest isn't going to bring an investor, So I presume your intention is to bring about this interim board to find an investor? But who would you propose this to be?
Helikaon Bow
79 Posted 03/09/2011 at 23:26:45
Live too far away to get involved personally but you have my backing 100%.

Supported the club for 29 years and I DO NOT want it to stagnate! Not while we have a fantastic manager in David Moyes.

COYB.
Lori Fekete
80 Posted 03/09/2011 at 22:47:41
Gary - I'm astonished at your apparent 'everything's fine, what's all the fuss about?' attitude.

Not a Penny spent on transfers in two years should be ringing alarm bells, especially with all rivals (which are now Stoke, Sunderland etc) improving their squads.

Are you Ian Ross in disguise?
Gerry Grimes
81 Posted 03/09/2011 at 23:41:11
Sitting here in Dublin it has been very difficult at times to get a real gauge on what is happening off the field at the club.

There have been times when I've seen Kenwright in a good light and his emotions for the club have seemed real to me. However, reading the "transcript" of the BU meeting with him left me with a real feeling that the club is in the hands of the wrong man.

It is important to judge Kenwright from two separate aspects. From a motive aspect I believe the jury is out. I trust Moyes and he is supportive of Kenwright which provides comfort. However, the lack of clarity involving Green/Earl and other parties, all of whom are "money men", with no emotional attachment to the club, leaves serious question marks over the shareholder motives on the club.

From an ability aspect, I believe the BU "transcript" would lead most reasonable people to the view that the club is in unsafe hands and that serious questions need to be raised and answered.

Kenwright could take the initiative here and provide some clarity on what exactly is going on behind the scenes at the club. If he fails to do this, I believe the type of protest put forward today is both reasonable and justified. Everything should take place outside the ground. The moment Z-Cars sounds out at Goodison next Saturday, it is incumbent on all Evertonians to let out a roar that let's the players and Moyes know that they have the support that they should expect and deserve.

Phil Bellis
82 Posted 04/09/2011 at 00:52:24
Julie,
A team of professionals who have business acumen, ideas, contacts and will listen to the "unqualified" Everton support (although I suspect there may well be some "qualified " amongst us).
Dan Brierley
83 Posted 04/09/2011 at 00:39:02
What exactly is the topic of the protest march? All I can gather from what is above, is that its a march to show everyone that some fans are not happy, and want change. I am certain we are all united in one thing, and that is that we would like a billionaire to take us over and pump money in a la Man City and make us challenge for the title.

So for example, the protest march would be extremely effective if there is already a billionaire ready to take over, and we force the board to sell the club to him/her. Or if there is already an interim board assembled, that has the ability to sell the club to the right owner. But as far as I'm aware there is no billionaire waiting to take over, and no interim board available. This is where I am struggling to understand what exactly the protest is about. I have seen many posts already saying 'we are not willing to stand by and let our club go down the pan'. But it seems to be a protest without purpose or direction. Ironic really, considering this is the main crticism of the board.

I find it strange when people make comparisons to Sunderland expecting us to spend more money than them, when they pull in 12,000 more fans for each home game than we do. Is it really hard to understand why they have more money to spend? And Stoke? What? How do Stoke spend more money than us? Have a quick look at their squad, and ask yourself is it really worth the same amount as ours? Of course not.

There appears to be a lot of delusion surrounding this subject. The real comparison to us is Aston Villa, who have a similar turnover, stadium size and had a similar wage to turnover problem. Villa addressed it by selling Barry, Milner, Downing & Young. This was overseen by Randy Lerner, a billionaire.

This shows that the problem is not solely down to our board, but something that is part and parcel of trying to survive in the Premier League. You will also notice Arsenal also selling to survive currently, whilst Spurs also cut the wage bill. My honest view is that all fans should unite, and protest to sort out this mess that is the Premier league. But it seems that is not the view here, and that new ownership is somehow going to have us competing again, when even a team like Arsenal cannot.

Dennis Stevens
84 Posted 04/09/2011 at 01:11:27
You're quite right, Dan - there is a lot of delusion, particularly amongst those who think that the only way to legitimise these protest activities is to have a list of willing billionaires ready to outbid each other in their enthusiasm to take control of the club & that the lack of such a list renders the whole thing pointless. I think the issue is now less about being competitive & more about survival.
Phil Bellis
85 Posted 04/09/2011 at 01:25:56
Dan; "we would like a billionaire to take us over .."

That'd be nice, Dan... Sir Macca, Big Bill Gates, the Grantchesters? Or, perhaps, a wee bit more realistic... let Bill keep his Sir Topham hat as railway controller. But bring in pros... what's wrong with that? He's wasted enough money already on ill-advised schemes and no-marks.

James Potter
86 Posted 04/09/2011 at 01:20:54
Anybody who thinks everything is just fine at our club is seriouly deluded, making out Kenwright as some sort of hero, even suggesting thanking him, beggars belief at times. There seems to be some extremely dense evertonians out there who either don't understand the facts and figures or choose to ignore them.

Anything we have achieved on the pitch in recent years is in spite of kenwright, certainly not because of him, the bloke is a clown. Is he a fan, yes no doubt, that does not excuse the fact he is well out of his depth, and has had his time at the helm and needs to go.

The protest is about keeping up the momentum and hopefully is the start of something better, if you don't support it then it's up to you, sit in your arse and do nothing, but it won't stop those who do!

Tony Stanley
87 Posted 04/09/2011 at 01:45:12
Gary #59 ? according to you, everything is a okay at Goodison and the people who don't agree with you should just toe the line? Let me sleep on that...
Chad Schofield
88 Posted 04/09/2011 at 02:00:45
Congratulations on getting this sorted.

Lots if face palming reading the responses... And pity the like of Gary Rimmer choose to reiterate moot points, or people suggest the only way to know is to have council with Kenwright. Pressumably you did readthe BU transcript?

Also the belief has been pointed out that Ian Ross himself has used aliases to rubbish genuine concerns of supporters. Whether the email alledgedly from him stating the Fortress Fund was a tool simply to get rid of Gregg is true, I don't know but if it is, and BK did turn the in vestor actually came through but was turned away by Bill because he had no intention of using the money,... It's even more damning for the current custodians.

Why is Bill so scared to put a price on the club?
Thomas Williams
89 Posted 04/09/2011 at 00:51:39
Lori, you said exactly what I was going to say!! Gary Rimmer, please wake up mate, you are like the band on the Titanic, playing on whilst the ship sinks.

Your idea of "Tell me who is the mill/billionaire waiting to buy us, tell me you plead" That my friend is the crux of the whole matter, if no one has come forward like you say (I beg to differ) are you not concerned as to why? Is virtually every club in the Prem bigger or better than us? You can include half the clubs in the Championship as well, all who have been bought out bar us, does that not trigger alarm bells, that something very odd is going on?

Mick Davies
90 Posted 04/09/2011 at 05:30:09
First of all, good luck to the Blue Union; I like BK spent my formative Evertonian years in the Boys Pen so I have good grounding on which to base my following points.

The shambolic actions of the board over the last ten years have been well reported so no need to go over them again, but the Kings Dock episode is the one I can never forgive them for. We now have a ramshackle ground while most of our rivals have built, or are building/renovating grounds which will attract players; like those who we wish to sign.

Kenwright has allowed our club to fall into dangerous levels of debt and decay. His tenure has seen us sell off almost every asset we had, and now it's the players who are being sold to keep the club afloat. The arrogance of the man is incredulous and he appears to have lost all interest in Everton's supporters.

The end-of-season DVD a few years ago has him fawning over Sly and assuring us he will be back the following season. Well he still hasn't shown and we all seen through this publicity stunt while he gets to show off his toy to celebrities. Yes he may have been an Evertonian at one time but it seems to me he couldn't give a shit these days and his impressario hat takes preference over his blue and white beany.

Whether or not he has enough money is irrelevant to me; it's his lack of honesty, integrity and communication that winds me up and that's why I would like to see him shaken up before the club slides any further back. And to point out to a previous poster, Merseyside is the 4th largest conurbation in England after London, West Midlands and Greater Manchester.

John Audsley
91 Posted 04/09/2011 at 07:15:48
Can't believe that so many people think BK is doing a good job and shouldn't be replaced.

He and his cronies have put nothing into EFC and he seems completely in his own bubble of reality.

Look at the facts people, for god's sake ? it's a fucking mess.

Up the BU!
Anthony Flack
92 Posted 04/09/2011 at 08:23:26
I am sticking to my guns:

1. The Blue Union is expressing the concerns of the majority of Evertonians.

2. I would argue it is doing it in a way not necessarily representative of the majority, in particular the personal insults directed at individuals at the club and starting off on a road without really knowing what is around the corner.

3. Er... No #3.

4. Not having direction or an alternative to the current state is not a reason not to protest or to start forming a strategy

5. If you think about it in terms of outcomes, then the target outcome is not actually getting rid of anyone, it is about being something different to what we are now.

6. Has this "different" being concisely expressed? (ie, in more intelligent terms than "we have won nothing, sack the board")

7. I suspect the answer to 6, is that there is no real idea of what should be done differently in terms of direction and strategy.

8. The target outcome needs to be expressed in terms you can measure ? eg, a new board made up of x, y, z; paying off the debts and how; new ground, ground share; sack Kenwright and replace with better person and who.... you can see what I mean?

9. So the majority of you are proposing setting off marching and protesting without direction or a proper realistic and achievable view of the target outcome.

10. This is why I think it will create aggravation and negativity and drag the club down.

11. If this is the way of affecting change and you accept it is an acceptable opportunity cost, and you truly represent the majority ? in this respect, I am not sure you do.

12. Sabre rattling, references to acorns, oak trees and the Titanic are designed to push people with alternative views into a camp where they are ignored as inactive and apathetic. Trust me, if I or thousands of others could think of something useful and productive to do, we would have done it, I actually suspect the same is even true of the board!

13. Any idea that this will not drag the club down is naive, there is no way that this will not rub off on the team....

Best series of posts I have seen in years. Now back to the Tweenies with my seven-year-old who is clutching her Everton teddy and wearing her Everton PJs........

Trevor Mackie
93 Posted 04/09/2011 at 08:45:52
If you want Everton to win something ever again you must support change.

Kenwright's plan of remortgage or sell every asset hasn't worked, we're down to selling the only assets left ie the players.

That's not a financial plan ? it's a suicide note.
Robert Daniels
94 Posted 04/09/2011 at 09:04:34
Anthony,

What's the option then? Sit back and do fuck all for the next eleven years???

We want the board to appoint a business brain to the board to move the club forward, someone who will keep the fans informed and tell us where we are heading.

Reciting poetry in his office while gazing out of the window aint gonna do nothing.

Oh and we've got Horrid Henry on our telly... kids, eh.
Chad Schofield
96 Posted 04/09/2011 at 10:50:12
Anthony #84, I think you make some really good points. The problem I see though is that, by the time you have spent sorting out who is the figurehead who holds no other more political agenda, forming a cohesive argument that represents everyone, it will be the end of the season, there will still be bitter in-fighting and there will most likely have been the formation of annoyed splinter groups.

The problem is, without action, we stay as we are. There are lots of people trying to muddy the water ? some seemingly coming from members of Kenwright's regime itself ? so the easiest thing to do is to come to a quick resolution.

I can't make a case for people to be anti-Bill Kenwright, but then I don't think it's my responsibility to do so. Frankly it is up to people to read and educate themselves. If we all worried about what's going to happen when faced with change, then nothing would ever change.

Basically it's all very well to plead poverty, but I could not afford to run a Ferrari. As I couldn't afford to run a Ferrari, if I was the owner of one I would have to sell it... of course I could point at the economic climate and say nobody is buying super cars... but that's bollocks ? if the price is right, there will be a buyer. It really is that simple. Of course if I met potential buyers but insisted they wore hula skirts and I never gave a straight answer when asked how much the car was, I would struggle to find a buyer.
Steven Bennett
97 Posted 04/09/2011 at 11:08:20
Anthony Flack... sorry, what?

Anyway I was thinking about the proposed protest march and people's fears regarding It being peaceful etc. Why not go out of our way to bring the missus if you have one (daunting thought for some of us, I know) and the kids, little brothers, nieces, nephews and show it's not just a rowdy group of unhappy men but a wide spectrum of the fan base voicing their fears.

Clive Lewis
98 Posted 04/09/2011 at 11:10:44
http://www.historicalkits.co.uk/Everton/Everton.htm

Maybe we should start getting these? I prefer the black away.
Phil Bellis
99 Posted 04/09/2011 at 11:22:38
Thousands (if not millions) of us had no idea with what to replace apartheid or other injustices; we just knew they were wrong.

Yes, cohesion and collective direction is important to achieve change... Yet, if we'd fannied about creating project initiation documents, developing 10-year plans, preparing and publishing our shortlist of potential replacement personnel, detailing infrastructure projections and post-present initiatives ? we'd still be paying the fuckin' Poll Tax!

Clive Lewis
100 Posted 04/09/2011 at 11:32:17
http://www.historicalkits.co.uk/Everton/Everton.htm

Maybe we should start getting these cheaply made, the black one with the red sash. Interestingly they were named the Black Watch, because of the kit ? which is a pretty good description of what is happening at Everton at the moment.
Clive Lewis
101 Posted 04/09/2011 at 11:50:01
Why not all the organisations against Everton's financial problems get together and name the group the Black Watch... just a thought.
Phil Bellis
102 Posted 04/09/2011 at 12:03:30
Clive, a nice thought. It was a ruby sash; the jersey itched to buggary, weighed a ton when it got wet, and the black dye came off on your skin ? honest!
Clive Lewis
103 Posted 04/09/2011 at 12:11:10
That's interesting, protesters could just wear black shirts and be given a ruby sash to wear, would look good from the stands.
Anthony Flack
104 Posted 04/09/2011 at 12:34:56
Phil (89) ? acorns, oak trees, Titanic and now apartheid... get a grip, unless you are proposing direct action, rioting, and going to prison for 30 odd years.

Read the post(s): all I am cautioning against is a lack of cohesive direction ? if you think planning where you want to get to and how to get there is is "fannying about" then I recall advice I got early in my career, which is "never argue with an idiot". I wonder did you think the recent rioting was a reaction to bankers bonuses and MPs on the take... get a grip.

Other point made partly in objection to mine by Chad (86) is well made and probably correct, if the Blue Union prevents splintering then this is positive.

March, make a point, then think about what next, and it will drag down the fans. Also think carefully about how you will react to those who observe the march but object (even boo and hiss) and or ignore...

Mark Wayman
105 Posted 04/09/2011 at 12:48:05
I think it a disgrace that Liverpool Echo, Radio Merseyside and Radio City never sent a representative. Nobody is telling those organisations to take sides, just report fairly.

Just a thought, I wonder why the club hasn't tried to clear up the "other operating costs"? Until they do it is a stick easily used to beat them with, when some sort of explanation by them may kill the question dead.
Dan Brierley
106 Posted 04/09/2011 at 12:34:41
Phil...seriously? Comparing the current board to apartheid? I find that statement a bit sick in all honesty. To my knowledge, nobody has lost their life under our current ownership.

I am fully willing to support anything that results in our club being improved. But my honest current view is that without direction, this protest could result in much more unrest for the club, and has the potential to make the siutation a whole lot worse.

Having fans protesting during the match is going to have more effect on the players than anybody else. One of Everton's strengths over the years has been the ability of our fans to unsettle teams that come to play at Goodison. I don't see how having the fans using that energy on our own team, manager and board during a match is going to make anything better.

The people trying to organise the protest are clear in their message that this to advocate change at board level, and not affect the team. Although the vast majority of people on this site that support the protest, also have a healthy hatred of the manager and many of our players. So I would not be suprised to see the situation turn ugly should we fall behind during the match.

Football is an extremely emotive sport, as we all know. History is littered with 'peaceful' protests that have resulted in riots.

Simon Harris
107 Posted 04/09/2011 at 13:35:10
Mark - Apparently Greg O'Keeffe from the Echo was there. The BU have issued an apology.

http://www.sos1878.co.uk/everton-news/blue-union-statement-an-apology/
Phil Bellis
108 Posted 04/09/2011 at 13:42:55
Ouch! Anthony,

Wasn't having a pop at you or your numbered points; merely saying that sometimes, as with the Poll Tax riots and demos, the initial impetus for change comes from a clear, noisy and visible opposition.

In our case, time is not on our side. I agree, also, that we must avoid drifting into the Life of Brian "splitters" sketch. I, as a young man, was also given a piece of advice (could even have been from your dad if his name was Brian): "You can't be insulted by someone you don't respect."

Trefor Jones
109 Posted 04/09/2011 at 08:32:49
Those who think the march will be potrayed in a "dignified" manner may be in for a shock, SKY and the tabloids do not do dignity, they will use material they can edit to show the fans in the worst possible light. Such marches ALWAYS bring out the crazies who will let down the well intentioned organisers.

In over 60 years of supporting it has been a club that commanded (even in the worst of times) respect and indeed affection throughout football; in the last few weeks, this is disappearing as we fight amongst ourselves.

Most of the comments shows a complete lack of awareness of the complexities of the Premier League as a market. If you want to influence affairs by way of marches just look at the fate of Portsmouth etc.

Phil Bellis
110 Posted 04/09/2011 at 13:52:36
Dan...merely a for instance, didn't mean to offend you or go overboard
How's about the Poll Tax then? Is that a less odious analogy?
Phil Bellis
111 Posted 04/09/2011 at 13:56:32
Dan,
Seriously? "healthy hatred of the manager and many of our players"

Healthy?
Hatred?

Terry Smith
112 Posted 04/09/2011 at 14:28:38
I was at the meeting in The Sasa yesterday and I fully endorse the guy who recommended we all turn our backs when the teams run out at 3 o'clock on Saturday vs Villa, drop our kecks and 3-4 thousand lads in Gwladys Street do a Braveheart? Imagine that on Match of the Day?
Gary Rimmer
113 Posted 04/09/2011 at 14:04:58
It really makes me laugh to read some of these comments. It was just the same after we sold Rooney. You know we were going to collapse, the laughing stock of British Football. That year we finished 4th and the following years have been the best since the 80s.

I live in reality, we haven't sold as many players as Villa and I would not swop Stoke's, Sunderland's or Wolves' squad for ours. I am glad Arteta has gone, he has been a waste of space for nearly two years with his salary helping to cripple us. Time for Rodwell etc to step up.

If the BU has so many experts etc, why don't they have any answers ? Interim board that will make a big difference? How can they make EFC more attractive to foriegn investment? Compared with London, Manchester, Birmingham, or any of the other major European cities, we are the second team in a small city. For those who don't know, Liverpool's population is just below 450,000. If we are going to play silly and call it Merseyside , look at Hampshire's population etc there are very close.

Again what is the unique selling point that BU have suddenly discovered to make us more attractive to buyers? The only thing that can solve our problems is money. If you haven't got any you're just adding to the doom and gloom. Keep the faith and unless you have something good to offer, support your team through thick and thin ? and the only marching you should do is up to the turnstyle.

Anthony Flack
114 Posted 04/09/2011 at 14:45:07
Phil - brilliant and well put. I should not have shot from the hip, but felt the analogy with apartheid and poll tax is not really helpful. I would love to be able to find an example from the football world that worked out well.

I agree re. the possibility of useful initial impetus but clearly worry about the negative impact on the team and supporters and about the "what next", as there is not one yet presented.

So you know my old man (Brian) or have you just had the pleasure of reading his posts. He is currently cruising through Germany delighted that the holiday has not clashed with any home games....
Raymond Nuttall
115 Posted 04/09/2011 at 14:26:36
Gary it must be terribly difficult to see the light when your head is firmly rammed up Rupert Towers arse as he types away for you.
Phil Bellis
116 Posted 04/09/2011 at 14:46:45
Anthony and Dan
If our little exchanges show anything it's that in an emotive issue such as this, we can be disunited in a common cause
I shall now do the Blue Bill open palms towards you gesture, and draw my hands inwards, welcoming you to my bosom whilst saying "now, lads, we're all Evertonians, here"
(personal - Anthony, your dad is a True Blue gent)
Anthony Flack
117 Posted 04/09/2011 at 14:52:03
Raymomd (106) - nothing wrong with Gary's position, it may, just may reflect the position of the majority. Do you think it is something other than money?

Not sure I follow the Rupert Towers bit - I thought that was the tower on the club crest - might be wrong?
Anthony Manning
118 Posted 04/09/2011 at 14:51:23
Chris #69 i,m talking about city boundary poppulation, Liverpool is 3rd just ahead of Manchester, i checked it on google mate.
Kevin Tully
119 Posted 04/09/2011 at 14:59:04
It is not about where we have been in the past or where we are today. B.K. has admitted there is no plan for the future, he and the current board either have no money, or are not willing to invest.

Do we really have to wait until we are relegated or in administration before we all wake up?

B.K. couldn't have been any clearer in his meeting with the B.U. that as a business, we are on the road to oblivion.

This is not about whether you like B.K. and herein lays the problem.

Everton F.C. are diving headlong towards administration at the behest of Barclays bank, but hey, Bill's a good blue.
John Farmer
120 Posted 04/09/2011 at 15:33:46
Went to meeting and have had my suspicions confirmed. Blue union a load of bollocks.Thank goodness they are not running our club
Raymond Nuttall
121 Posted 04/09/2011 at 15:36:01
Anthony, Gary's position is very clear from where i'm 'sitting'...about money? can you elaborate? Rupert Towers is possibly...just possibly one of many alias Gary has used on the internet...also depends on who's majority you believe.
Dan Brierley
122 Posted 04/09/2011 at 15:29:53
Sorry Phil, I meant to type 'unhealthy hatred of Moyes and some players'.

We even have somebody posting to say its a good idea for the whole Gwladys Street to moon our players when they run out. What the fuck is this supposed to achieve? Already we have some people interpreting this protest or march as an opportunity to stick the knife into the team on the pitch. This is really going to convince our better players that they should be staying at Goodison...
Raymond Nuttall
123 Posted 04/09/2011 at 15:41:53
Yes, Mr Farmer, thank fuck we have that very competant accountant called Bill... What the fuck do you mean, £24M other operating costs? Kenwright running his latest show.
Anthony Flack
124 Posted 04/09/2011 at 15:46:39
Raymond, thanks for explaining the Rupert Towers reference -

I think the respective positions are pretty well explained in the posts. Money talks, our lack of it is a problem, the reasons for our lack of it of course more complex....

Cheers
Billy Bradshaw
125 Posted 04/09/2011 at 15:56:53
Farmer, do us all a favour and swop channels.
Simon Harris
126 Posted 04/09/2011 at 15:55:15
I'd just like to state publicly that I oppose mooning as a form of demonstration.

The thought of having my beak anywhere near the arse crack of the old fella behind me, well, just no! And the guy in front of me may like hairy arses and take advantage..
Eugene Ruane
129 Posted 04/09/2011 at 16:22:58
'John Farmer' it may interest you to know that we know who you REALLY are.

http://memecenter.com/uploaded/1b4c52b90a0d9a21676e803021dc95d49.jpg

For techno boffins, the Evertonian in the 60's shirt (to the left) took the shot using the helmet-cam 70XRTL
John Keating
130 Posted 04/09/2011 at 15:59:40
John Farmer.
Blue Union do not want to run the club.
They just want someone to run the club who has some sort of plan and is open and honest with the supporters.
I was at the meeting and the only bollocks I witnessed was a group of guys who had the bollocks to get off their arses and at least try to get answers and advance the club.
Those guys are doing this because of their love of the club and their refusal to see our club go tits up !
I have never belonged to any political or pressure group but I went to see for myself and as my club is more important to me than any political party I am fully aligning myself to this grouping.
As long as any protests are peaceful and organised then I'm in !!
Finally if you thought they were speaking bollocks why didn't you put your hand up when the floor was open ??
Where you really there ??
Jane Smith
131 Posted 04/09/2011 at 16:30:14
As a form of protest, take a leaf out of the AS Roma fans' book, everyone enter the ground at arranged home match and 10 minutes after kick-off, everyone leave the ground, leaving just the buffoons that run OUR club in the ground on their own. Everyone then congregates on Goodison Rd for the remainder of the match. You don't need clearance from the police as it's not a protest march... Who knows, our friends at the Liverpool (programme) Echo might spare a few column inches. FROM JOHN MOORES TO DEATH'S DOORS.
Phil Bellis
132 Posted 04/09/2011 at 17:09:00
Dan #113
What a picture, and what a caption competition that would make - "park yer bikes in the Street End"
I'm against anything happening during the game to distract the team; I remember the post-match cushion throwing of the 70s with fondness, though
Mike Gaynes
133 Posted 04/09/2011 at 16:44:11
Just woke up here on the US West Coast and have been reading this thread with fascination. Dan, Anthony, Phil, Simon and the rest... thank you. I've learned so much from your posts. I think this is an amazing effort to unite the fan base in a good cause, although I tend to agree with Dan (particularly his last paragraph in #75) that Everton have obstacles to overcome far beyond the current ownership and board, and that to expect a true resolution to the club's problems would be unrealistic at this point.

Personally, I have nothing against a protest march and might even participate were I there, but I think two points must be absolutely emphasized:

1. EVERY precaution must be taken to ensure that things remain peaceful. It would only take a couple of drunken hotheads to trigger something that would cripple Everton's public image for years to come. Merely having police presence isn't enough -- the marchers themselves must be prepared in advance to take fast, strong action if somebody starts something.

2. I think it's important that the march be not only peaceful but civil -- people chanting obscenities or anti-Kenwright insults would make it easier to characterize the marchers as merely a bunch of rowdy knuckleheads. I know the personal feelings are strong, but I believe making this campaign personal, rather than professional, would be a mistake.

Good luck, guys, and I'll be watching Sky Sports after the Villa game.

Mike Bates
134 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:07:31
I'll be there for the march as I'm totally behind what the Blue Union are standing for, but I will be cautious of any goons that will be encouraged (paid?) by the club to join the march with a view to cause trouble in an attempt to discredit the Blue Union.
Mark Wayman
135 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:22:54
Simo 98 - Thanks

Mike 123 - Funny enough that bothers me also, although it seems a bit out of this world, there have been strong allegations that certain people involved with the club have been stirring up Everton message boards. Because anything untoward happened it would discourage others getting involved in future protests.
Mike Gaynes
136 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:19:55
Mike, are you kidding? Paid goons? You really think the club would do something to damage its own image? The marchers will all be wearing our colors.

No insult intended to your city, but wasn?t it just four weeks ago that windows were smashed in Liverpool on the excuse of a police shooting in London? You don?t need paid goons to start a riot. Anytime you mix a large crowd, strong emotions, lots of alcohol and the inevitable criminal element, you have the potential.

I'm not trying to be critical of the city or the Blue Union... it can happen anywhere, anytime. Look at Vancouver ? Olympic city, wealthy, cultured, famously genteel. When they won hockey?s Stanley Cup a couple of months ago, the streets were flooded with happy fans. They attacked the cops, burned cars, looted stores, trashed the whole downtown. By the time the ?celebration? was over, 57 people were in hospital. Vancouver?s once-perfect image will be years in recovering.

These marchers won?t be genteel, and they won?t be partying, they?ll be protesting. And there will be other Everton fans there who disagree, as you?ve seen in this thread. If you think it would take paid outside help to turn this into something really ugly, you?re dreaming. The march organizers MUST be prepared.
John Keating
137 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:32:01
Mike #122, Both your points were raised in no uncertain terms and by far the general concensus of opinion from those present were in agreement of your points.

The meeting ? excellently attended ? consisted of all age groups from youngsters to teenagers right through to 60s+. There was concern that any future march or whatever not be hijacked and that we take the moral high ground and give the authorities, club and fellow supporters no opportunity to deflect from what is genuine feeling from those who want to show the club strength of feeling against the direction it is heading under the present stewardship.

There are persistent rumours that the club are attempting to divide the support even more by infiltrating websites etc. Who knows what they may be capable of.

Anthony Manning
138 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:44:14
John Farmer or Ian Ross whatever your name is, if you where at the BU meeting and think they are a joke why didn`t you have the balls to stand up and say something? You're an embarrassment.
Dennis Stevens
139 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:36:49
I'm quite concerned that any attempt at a peaceful protest march could easily backfire as there are so many uncontrollable factors that come into play on the day.

I notice that there's an Arsenal supporters group that have paid for a billboard near their ground to express their concern about the club's lack of direction(!) ? perhaps an idea for BU to consider?

Also how about disgruntled fans smuggling in a cushion each to hurl onto the pitch at the end of the match, in the traditional manner?

Edward Jones
141 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:56:35
Hi all, I think that at the moment any criticism, constructive or otherwise ,will prove to be counter productive at this point in time. As an Everton supporter for the past 55 years, I feel as committed as anybody to the greater cause. However, I feel that the transfers completed on Wednesday will prove yet again to be a masterstroke by DM ? either by accident or good judgement.

Far better to err on the side of caution than to be disruptive. Wait and see is always the best policy. Who knows, but over the next 3 or 4 weeks we could be in the top six. Both Drenthe and Stacqualursi could set Goodison on fire. If all goes sour against Villa then fine, let our voice be heard, but let's never put the cart before the horse. Always a blue.

Mike Gaynes
142 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:57:52
John 126... thanks. I have no idea what your suspicions are based on, but based on what I've read here today, there would be no reason for the club to do something like that. There is plenty of disagreement among good, honest Everton fans about the planned protest, as there are Everton fans who sincerely support Kenwright and the board and are willing to speak up. I doubt you would say that all the articulate people posting here today who are skeptical of the march, like Anthony Flack and Dan Brierly, are paid shills from the club.

Accusing the team of infiltrating websites means you're doubting the honesty of everyone who writes something you disagree with. We're all on the same Blue side.
Paul Niklas
143 Posted 04/09/2011 at 18:58:16
Firstly I must point out I am very much supportive of the board and the Club, just so nobody is under any illusions; however, I have to say that I find the actions of the Blue Union commendable, albeit the taping (if true) in my opinion was despicable.

My point: never has any protest group or any form of movement made any headway without financial support, indeed with the greatest intentions in the world, you will not get very far at all.

I have no doubt whatsoever that your peaceful protest will achieve nothing and I also believe that it has the very high chance of potentially damaging any good you feel as a group you have achieved to date.

I really think you should review your position and, if you feel strongly enough that you can achieve what you are setting out to achieve, and you clearly believe the board are a set of sharks, then rather than attack, berate and act in a manner that creates an even bigger chasm between you and the club, you should consider swimming with them instead of watching from afar, because you will not get anywhere near them with your recent and planned actions.

Try this for example: speak to the club and ask them can you purchase every seat above the away supporters for games that full allocation is not taken, I would suggest this season that would be about 70% of games, even ask for a discount with the buying power.

In this way, you're taken seriously, by your very presence (wear your Blue Union T-shirts with pride); you don't have to say anything but you are there every week supporting your cause and every one knows it, you are also financially supporting your club.

In my opinion, this will get you great respect and I would say some great PR. I really believe that the club would or should have no problem with what would be a unique approach.

If you wanted to go one step further, purchase the remaining obstructed view seats at a discount. You can work out the cost, I would have thought that 1500 of your supporters putting up say £300-400 each might swing it.

A thought only, but believe you me "money makes money, always has and always will".
Brian Harrison
144 Posted 04/09/2011 at 19:19:20
I really am fearful over the planned protest march and possible consequences. Quite often these protest marches are highjacked by some very questionable characters. I also fear it is a march with very few clear aims, other than to get rid of Kenwright.

This seems more a protest against us not having the same investment/buying power as some of the other teams in the Premier League. But in reality over the last 7 or 8years we have spent most of our income on transfers or increasing existing players' salaries. Other than the clubs that have a global fan base, I think we have competed favourably against the rest.

I recently read Alan Sugar's autobiography and he said that his 10 years as Chairman of Spurs was the worst in his life. He said that he too allowed managers to spend more than the club were making. He also said that at some point, however much you allow a manager to go over budget, the fans will always blame the chairman. He says he lost count of the times the fans asked why he wasn't spending the money, only not as politely as that.

Look, I was lucky enough to be going to Goodison when John Moores became chairman and we could out-bid anybody for players, a bit like Man City now. So I can understand the frustration of some fans who weren't even born in that era.

But I think the bigger problem that needs addressing is players wages, as this is the one thing that is crippling most clubs. I mean if Arsenal football club, the most profitable club in the Premier League, are having to watch what they spend, then obviously this must have a greater impact on clubs who haven't been in the Champions League for the past 12 years.
John Keating
145 Posted 04/09/2011 at 19:25:28
Mike (#130) ? I have no problems whatsoever with supporters airing their views either in support of or against the present board. Or people having differing views on hope to move the movement for change forward. I would never condemn anyone who takes an opposite view.

You will note that I have never spoken against Anthony's or Dan's points of view. I know that everyone is a Blue and we just see different ways of achieving our ultimate aim of putting our club back where it belongs.

There have recently been people posting on various websites that tend to be consistent in the wording they use to condemn any person opposed to the present regime. When challenged they tend to disappear. I would suggest that if you feel strongly about somthing you should have the courage to articulate those concerns.
I admire anyone who opposes the general concensus, what I don't admire is someone like John Farmer who says he went to yesterday's meeting, thought the Blue Union was a load of bollocks yet didn't take the opportunuty to challenge them in any way.

Everyone was given a chance to speak up and peole had differing views; I cannot remember anyone getting shouted down. Far from it.

Simon Harris
146 Posted 04/09/2011 at 19:45:48
Paul - I wouldn't trust the present incumbents to use an additional £400 of my hard earned money sensibly. That's the point, they have lost all credibility in many people's eyes.

And the sums you're talking about equate to the annual paycut Arteta's just taken.

Now, if you told me it would expedite the sale of the club ? I'll get my cheque book.
John Audsley
147 Posted 04/09/2011 at 19:56:37
Mr Farmer

It would have been helpful if you had let us now why you think the BU is a load of bollocks.

If you took the time to go to the meeting then why didn't you make a comment?

Your comments are just a waste of time and energy which looking at Eugene's Pic should probably be best used on a treadmill.
Alan Williams
148 Posted 04/09/2011 at 20:29:37
Good luck with your demo. I will be in the pub with the other 36,500 Evertonians. Nothing wrong at all with protest but this must the first ever not to have a goal or shall I say alternative to what we have, just priceless!! After you all sing Kenwright Out, maybe you should have a think about who will be in or does that not matter? If BK steps down, nothing changes at all so I just don't see the point but then again I didn't support the dockers or miners so maybe I miss the point completely. COYB
Dan Brierley
149 Posted 04/09/2011 at 20:47:12
It unfortunately becomes more and more of a joke by the second. Suggesting that anybody that opposes the concept of protesting must be a plant by the club is incredible.

It does show the level of paranoia and blatent scaremongering that some parts of these anti-board factions have instilled into some of our more naive supporters. Whilst I do recognise there are some good people trying to start a movement for change, there also plenty of people looking for their ten minutes of fame. I have seen a number of people suggesting they speak for the 'majority' of fans, which is also complete bollocks. The majority of fans will be at the game on Saturday and on computers all around the world cheering on their team, not trying their best to destroy the already fragile confidence of the boys in the royal blue jerseys...
Gary Rimmer
150 Posted 04/09/2011 at 21:05:40
There has been some derogitory remarks today but I feel sure we all want the best for Everton FC.

I know its hard watching one or two clubs who cant match our history spending a nations wealth on players. But the protest is like asking people to vote for a party who might have an idea.

I just think the only thing EFC need to improve is cash. We have been doing better than 90% of British proffesional clubs in the last five years. You can name the teams on one hand that dont have debt. Unless you have a genuine answer to our desperate money problems, bury the protest and do your duty as Evertonians and suppourt your team against Villa. Whilst all around mock us stand tall and be an Evertonian. Stop telling everyone we're shit and give the season a chance. Onward Evertonians.

Peter Laing
151 Posted 04/09/2011 at 21:35:46
Well you summed yourself up in the last paragraph of your diatribe Alan @ 134 need I say anymore, you are entitled to your views, enjoy your pre-match pint - you and your ilk will not be missed. Sack the Board, Support the team.
Peter Laing
152 Posted 04/09/2011 at 21:39:17
Gary, you're getting very boring now, leave those who want to protest to protest, your views are in my opinion as one-dimensional as what you are accusing Blue Union of. You are no better or worse than fellow supporters who support the notion of a peaceful protest aimed at raising awareness of the wholesale mismanagement for the past 11 years. Whose the next sacrificial lamb Gary ? Fellaini, Baines or Barkley?
Mike Bates
153 Posted 04/09/2011 at 21:59:04
Mike, the people organising the protest want a peaceful protest. Thats not a quiet march, it will be a protest and it will be vocal, but they are not advertising it as an excuse for violence. The Blue Union and their supporters know that being seen as reasonable is one of the most important things in being a success.

So with that in mind, here's something to consider...If there are idiots in there that cause trouble, the club has greater reason to discredit the union. So why isnt it feasible that they have been planted by the club? Its not *that* outrageous. It really isn't. Why wouldnt the Board want people to mess this up for the group?

I'd be made up if I was wrong, but right now I wouldn't put it past that lot doing anything to quell any protesting supporter groups.
Danny Broderick
154 Posted 04/09/2011 at 21:26:21
The point of the march is to get rid of the current board who have mismanaged our club. They have sold off all our assets, maxed up the credit cards and left us in a position where we have to sell players to survive.

Remember, it's the board's job to find investment ? not the fans'. They have spectacularly failed to do this in 12 years. A 2nd tier has never been put on the Park End, even though basic maths would tell you that it would have paid for itself within a few years.

We want a new board who will run our club properly. This means the wage bill cannot ever reach 70% of turnover ever again. The catering and retail operations must be brought back in house to maximise profits further.

I'll say it again as it's so important ? we will be marching to protest against the mismanagement of the club. We want a new board who will run us better. Evertonians against stagnation!

It cannot be right that we are regularly featuring in the top 8,we are getting top 8 crowds,and yet we are barely breaking even...

Dan Brierley
155 Posted 04/09/2011 at 22:36:42
Mike 139#,

You are so wrong, I dont even know where to start. This is a football club, not a secret government agency. You need to stop watching '24', and come back to the real world. The Union will only serve to discredit themselves far better than the club itself could do, with these ridiculous assumptions and statements.

Peter Laing also manages to make the whole thing look even more stupid, by saying 'sack the board'. First of all how do you sack a board, and secondly who takes over? Not having a board at all, means we would immediately go into administration and asset stripped, so our creditors could be paid what they are owed. Good result, Peter, well done. You certainly made everything better.

This has been my whole point on this thread, that the majority of people taking the side of the Blue Union, completely misunderstand the purpose of what they are trying to achieve, and don't have a clue what they are talking about. Having these kind of people marching is dangerous, and going to make us as a club and supporters look very very stupid. I hope to god someone somewhere either organises this protest properly, or postpones it before further unnecessary damage is done.
Mike Bates
156 Posted 04/09/2011 at 23:00:10
Haha. Fair enough Dan I do love a conspiracy theory like - maybe it wont be direct from the club, and I was a bit OTT - but I can see there being people who oppose to the BU and their objectives joining the march in order to turn things sour. And while the club would never condone such a thing...they certainly wouldn't be upset with the BU getting bad press.
Dan Brierley
157 Posted 04/09/2011 at 23:25:48
I just had visions of you on the march Mike, suspiciously eyeing all people around with your ear piece in, while in parallel you have a team of experts parked outside goodison in an ice-cream van, watching CCTV cameras trying to pick out the club plants. And when you find one, you lift his shirt and see he is wearing a 'wire', with a direct line to Bill Kenwright. Who is sat in his nuclear proof bunker stroking a black cat, trying to mastermind the next phase of 'operation everton' destruction.

And he would have got away with it if it wasnt for you pesky kids.... ;-)
Joseph Mercer
159 Posted 04/09/2011 at 23:46:44
Top-four finishes 1888-1992 (the year football began)

Liverpool 33 (18 championships)
Everton 31 (9 championships)
Manchester United 27 (7 championships)
Aston Villa 23 (7 championships)
Arsenal 22 (10 championships)
Sunderland 21 (6 championships)

Yes, we?ve been left behind. But history and tradition are often the only things left to sustain and guide you in the bleak times. The club?s been terribly neglected as an English football force. In the city of Liverpool there?s also been something of an ethnic cleansing of Evertonians (especially when you consider that EFC were the best supported club in England, attendance wise, in 1970).

The fightback has to begin somewhere, and the work of both Trust Everton and the Blue Union could be as good a place as anywhere to start.

Doug Nestor
160 Posted 04/09/2011 at 23:38:10
@ Mike Gaines...........Vancouver lost the Stanley Cup after being 2 or 3 games up they lost 4-3 on home soil,with it being the final game at home everyone here thought it was a forgone conclusion.........that's what started the riot, not an excuse I know but if it can happen in Vancouver it can happen anywhere.......
Anthony Manning
161 Posted 04/09/2011 at 23:14:46
Got a great idea chaps, those who are happy with BK and his board running the club then just dont go on the march, as for the rest of us who actually fucking care for our club see you at the march saturday.
Doug Nestor
162 Posted 04/09/2011 at 23:38:10
@ Mike Gaines...........Vancouver lost the Stanley Cup after being 2 or 3 games up they lost 4-3 on home soil,with it being the final game at home everyone here thought it was a forgone conclusion.........that's what started the riot, not an excuse I know but if it can happen in Vancouver it can happen anywhere.......
Jan Kowsky
163 Posted 05/09/2011 at 01:33:31
@ Dan Brierly No.145

Bill would have already sold the cat
Mike Gaynes
164 Posted 05/09/2011 at 04:00:03
Doug Nestor, apologies for my error and thanks for the correction. And you've grasped my point exactly when you say it can happen anywhere. John Keating indicated that everyone at the Blue Union meeting agreed that the march must be peaceful, which is fine, but it's not enough. The folks who cause riots aren't the kind of folks who come to meetings. I hope the organizers delegate a few dozen people -- or at least recruit volunteers -- to disperse through the crowd and watch for troublemakers, including the well-intentioned Everton fans on both sides of the Kenwright issue who may let their debates get out of hand.

And Mike Bates, with all due respect to your entertaining conspiracy theory, if something blows up at the march, it won't just be the Blue Union that's embarrassed. It'll be the club, the management and every Everton fan around the world. That's why the obvious suspect for subversion wouldn't be management.

It would be the Evil Red Tide.
Paul Gladwell
165 Posted 05/09/2011 at 07:43:14
Alan Williams, there won't even be 36,500 in the bloody ground and if there is 3,000 of those will be Villa, we don't even get them gates now because of people being pissed off with how the club is run.
Paul Gladwell
166 Posted 05/09/2011 at 07:55:16
By the way, how many of those kopite marches turned into the nasty riot some are expecting on Saturday? How bad an effect did that have on the club's name? I actually got a bit of sly respect for what they did as alls we do is go the game, have a pint and a good moan and piss off home.

Evertonians are a lazy bunch and doing nothing is not an option at the moment.

Richard Jones
167 Posted 05/09/2011 at 08:13:19
Where is the meeting point for the protest march?
Alan Williams
168 Posted 05/09/2011 at 08:15:00
Paul, when I watched them RS marches I laughed, then cringed at the embarrassment and took the piss out of fellow RS friends as I?m sure most of us did.

I get why people are not happy as deep down we all feel the same but some people on this site just seem to ignore why we have no assets and why we have little money and seem to just use BK as an outlet when the problem is much bigger than our Chairman. This protest changes nothing, all debt and re-mortgaging has gone mostly to the playing side with players wages, transfers, bank charges and agents fees taking the bulk.

EFC don?t generate enough revenue to afford what little we have ? that?s a simple fact everybody just seems to ignore and it?s the most important reason why we have no money. I (like others) see this and I?m content with BK and the board staying until new owners are found as this keeps continuity with our creditors ? which is important if we are to sell the company in positive means as opposed to a fire sale that would mean this situation becoming worse than it is.

People are saying we are miss-managed, maybe we have made mistakes but we are not Portsmouth, Leeds or Sheffield. I have been critical about ticket prices at EFC ? they are far too low with too many concessions which means we are selling prime seats at up to 70% less revenue which is good for the fan but bad for the club.

If we want more investment then the fans will have to pay more just like the board and that is proven by the cost of season tickets for the top 8 teams. Those who think it should come from the board and nowhere else are just dreaming and need to get a life, seriously, wake up to the reality of modern football ? that?s where the evil is; we are a victim of the greed.

You will all pat the players on their backs whilst they arrive in their Aston Martins and then pass death threats to the Chairman who doesn?t take a penny out of the club, very odd in my book.

Also on another mis-guided line by BU is that the board have no idea how to run the business yet most if not all are self-made millionaires and extremely successful away from football, so how does that work out that BU have more aptitude than what we have???

I see past the bull that?s being put around so I leave you to protest to get rid of a Chairman that doesn?t want to stay anyway, completely pointless and misguided and will damage what little we have at the moment, player moral!! COYB

David Thompson
169 Posted 05/09/2011 at 09:17:59
Alan @ 155

'The Chairman who doesn't take a penny out of the Club' ? has never put a penny in, either.

You want to keep this Chairman and board until another buyer is found, and therein lies the point of protest. With this lot in charge,we won't find another buyer. This is the man who thinks NESV didn't buy LFC, and doesn't know what £24M (30%) of his turnover was spent on.

The board needs to appoint a well-connected, independent Chairman with a brief to find a buyer ? in the way that Martin Broughton was appointed by RBS.

As for these self-made Millionaires, there's a large element of being in the right place at the right time. Kenwright had a massive success with Blood Brothers, but most of his productions since then have been fairly low-key. In the same period, Cameron Mackintosh has gone on to be worth over £500M. Robert Earl has managed to bust Planet Hollywood TWICE. Jon Woods was in at the start of the computer games explosion.

Don't get me wrong ? fair play to them and I don't begrude them what money they have ? but don't over-credit them with business acumen either. A relative of mine held a senior position at NTL during the negotiations with Everton, and his description of Kenwright was 'amateur', and that was before the deal broke down.

I think you're right about the players being the main culprits and taking the money, but 'you will all ...pass on death threats to the Chairman'. Really? I think you need to have a word with yourself.

Derek Daly
170 Posted 05/09/2011 at 12:12:51
A march will be a public display and test of Blue Union's level of support amongst Everton's fan base. I think this will be a good test for them.
Daniel A Johnson
171 Posted 05/09/2011 at 12:10:50
The shocking fact remains that a core group of supporters still think everything's brilliant at Goodison Park,

They still think Kenwright has the club's best interest at heart, they think 4-6-0 is the new future formation and that a change may bring about the end of the club.

They also think that protest is wrong and damaging to Morale.

What about no new players?
Best players being sold?
No hope?
No future?
No chance to challenge?
A crippling debt?

Well what the fuck does that lot do to Morale?

Until we all sing from the same hymm sheet and grow a pair of bollocks, Kenwright is going nowhere.

Seriously, some Evertonians on here are:

A) Fucking stupid
B) In denial
C) Corporate plants by the club
D) Fucking cowards

I love my club and I for one will be there at the protest.
Paul Gladwell
172 Posted 05/09/2011 at 13:02:59
Alan the reason we dont generate enough revenue is down to the board, we have lost thousands of season ticket holders because of them for starters, their business sense is clueless.
Michael Evans
173 Posted 05/09/2011 at 13:13:35
Daniel@158 - I agree with the main points that you have made but find it sad that your A-D description of fellow Evertonians is seemingly dripping in vitriol.

The divisions within the "Everton family" just get deeper and deeper,don't they ?

Alan Williams
174 Posted 05/09/2011 at 14:03:32
Dan, the end to your post just amazes me????. I?m afraid I and others are none of the above. If you read most counter arguments I think you will find we all agree change is required its about how, when and if this can be achieved by the current custodians or by others. My line to sell is the current custodians makes good business practice to do it as apposed to an interim board just selling it off for lowest price when they don?t give a shit who buys it but the silly thing about all these protests is we have no right whatsoever to request an interim board to take place. The BU is saying all the correct things to fuel the crowd but underneath all the hot air they have very little substance or even legal argument to achieve this goal. The whole protest in its current form will just damage EFC more and that devalues us collectively so in my opinion the protest march is pointless and totally misguided. If you succeed in keeping up the pressure on BK then he will just step down if he has any senses and get a patsy in to take the flack and the impetuous of your ?against? demo has lost its thunder because apart from the guaranteed Kenwright Out chant you have no substance and no mandate from the majority of fans that will be attending this weekends game. This is not political and shouldn?t be seen as such as we all love the product we are fighting over so nobody wins at all if it gets damaged in this period when unity off and on the field is our biggest asset so use it rather than split it. The Club is for sale that?s official and let the city (London) decide who takes over not the public bar in the Oak. BU need to gets the fans mandate before arranging such a protest as it will now mean fans will be divided and this protest is built on one meetings hot air and pumped up testosterone and it will prove to be their worst judgement should the demo get out of hand. The BU could be broken before its starts if this goes wrong???.lets just see what the weekend brings. COYB

Steve Jones
175 Posted 05/09/2011 at 15:10:57
"The board needs to appoint a well-connected, independent Chairman with a brief to find a buyer - in the way that Martin Broughton was appointed by RBS"

....and there lies the problem. The Liverpool FC board wasn't responsible for Broughton. The bank was as they were looking to reduce their exposure - that let buyers switch on to the fact that a huge markdown on price was in the offing. LFC were 'saved' by the commercial opportunity presented by their global brand being available at well below the rate that the incumbent owners valued it at.

If Barclays gets to the point where they are so nervous about us as a credit risk that they appoint a similar person to our board what happens if we dont get a sale?. Our commercial attractiveness has so far been inadequate to attract anyone but pokey flat dwellers down the East Lancs. Where is the confidence coming from that, even just at a price to clear the debt, someone would come in for us?.

We are infrastructure limited through years of neglect and delusion so, to develop the business, and actually see a return on the investment represented by buying the club debt would mean spending at very least another £150-odd million on the bare minimum kind of stadium we'd need to go forwards. Big spend on a 'cheap' club.

If the 'Barclays Broughton' wasn't able to find a buyer in a timespan suitable to the bank what stops them declaring us an unsustainable risk and asset stripping to recover what they can while they can?.

However dangerous the current board are they at least want to try and keep a halfway competetive Premier League football club in operation. Barclays have no such concern. Wouldn't be much of a victory to prise Kenwrights claws off the levers of power just to see the bank shut the gates and lock them would it?.
Mike Gaynes
176 Posted 05/09/2011 at 16:09:26
Daniel A. Johnson, I bow to your expertise on the subject of cowardice.

Insulting the intelligence, integrity and honor of fellow Evertonians on a chat board in language you would never dare in person is a brilliant demonstration of the concept.

Well done.
Tony J Williams
178 Posted 05/09/2011 at 17:20:02
Here's a question for people.

If we were to get an interim board in with the one mandate and that is to find a buyer.

If the interim board are unable to find a buyer. Would we a) feel differently about Kenwrong and b) start protesting against the interim board?

Assuming that is, they don't sell us to a chancer on the cheap and we wnd up in the same shit position within a year or two because the new owner hasn't the millions we need to progress.
Daniel A Johnson
179 Posted 05/09/2011 at 17:22:59
I said "some" Evertonians that does NOT apply to all Evertonians............
Trefor Jones
180 Posted 05/09/2011 at 17:08:37
If Daniel A Johnson is typical of the Blue Union approach then Fan participation in any future ownership scheme is a lost cause. If BU want to retain any credibility they had better start getting a grip and put up a realistic proposal we can all consider in a proper manner.

Hopefully it will not contain fantasy land ideas such as an "Interim Board" put up by alehouse lawyers. If done properly, a lot can be achieved as demonstrated by the Wrexham supporters (I do understand the difference in scale) who put their money where their mouth is.

Billy Bradshaw
181 Posted 05/09/2011 at 17:34:56
I see the Echo has reported the Blue Union meeting only had 300 in attendance and it was held in BOLD STREET, if they would have been at the right venue THE CASA IN HOPE STREET they would have seen the 600 and more Evertonians present.
Dickheads!!
Stephen Wissett
183 Posted 05/09/2011 at 18:06:19
Healthy objection outside the ground to what is happening at Everton i am all for, as freedom of speach/protest is part of all our rights.
i would however be disapointed to see this flow into the ground, the team needs our support, negative vibes can easily flow onto the pitch.
We need to watch out we dont end up making things worse.
We need to get behind the shirt and support the team on the pitch. COYB.
Simon Harris
184 Posted 05/09/2011 at 18:12:23
Alan Steve - I respect your opinions and whilst I don't necessarily agree with them, I do appreciate the counter argument of 'forcing' Kenwright out and the risks of appointing an interim board governed by Barclays.

But I ask you a serious question and one I have deliberated, what should the growing number of concerned fans do?

You both appear to be vindicating Kenwright and offering no alternative to him selling the club? Which as I?m sure you?ll agree he?s not had much luck with so far?

From my perspective, and after reading the BU transcript, it's evident that the sale of the club has thus far been poorly managed. To allow a bogus investor to conduct due diligence only for the chairman! to 'smell a rat' beggars belief. How did it get that far, didn't Keith Harris vet them, why didn't he have investigators out once initial contact was made?

Yes I know, I'm not privy to all the facts, but if true (and we've not had a rebuttal to its authenticity from the club) then at the very least the board needs to hold a full review on their strategy for selling the club. A review of the relationship with Keith Harris and most of all, Bill needs to re-consider his self-appointed status as the 'best person to sell Everton'.

It?s 12 years guys of 247 searching with nothing! Not a sausage - how long should we continue to wait while our only remaining assets are sold off? - How long is this sustainable, before Everton slip further and further behind?

The fans are already divided on this subject, they have been for a while, it's just now out in the open, I can only hope by standing together and making some (peaceful) noise, that at the very least the board will feel the heat (finally) and review its strategy, (start with its team of advisors) and then re-double its efforts in scouring the globe for suitors - I can't and won't believe they aren?t out there.
COYB
Gary Rimmer
185 Posted 05/09/2011 at 18:11:49
Just to get it right , its either the BU way or your a coward & you don't love EFC. They are starting to sound like the Taliban already.

What is it next? Do it their way or they will shout you down and bully you into their position. Don't forget we are all Evertonians and that sort of rubbish only comes from long distance cowards.

Just make sure that when any BU member speaks to the press, let them know that the number of Evertonians who support them could fit in a coffee shop. You keep telling us how we are in so much danger and you have the magical recipe. That's why 300 turned up lol. You have already become a laughing stock, stop before you do any more damage.
Onward Evertonians

Steve Jones
186 Posted 05/09/2011 at 18:40:15
Simon

I know where you are coming from, but, I can't believe that the bumbling fool that the BU encountered is the same machiavellian mastermind who has been fending off powerful and wealthy buyers left and right.

I'm afraid I look at Lerner picking up Villa for 60mn and I look at us needing 3 times that spent on us even if the board gave their shares away free and I do think this is a tough sell.

You can consider that vindication of the current board if you wish. I see it as objective reality. To me the choice is hand to mouth survival at best with the current bunch, with the hope for better, or the very real risk of a public and noisy death for the club at the hands of the bank.

At this point I think blame, recrimination and ambition are irrelevent. The only important thing is survival and that means keeping the bank as far away as possible.
Richard Dodd
187 Posted 05/09/2011 at 19:20:34
In a response to a letter of support I sent to BK-together with some constructive suggestions-he tells me it was `one of hundreds` he had received since his meeting with Blue Union.Apparently the majority are `overwhelmingly supportive`and we can be assured that Everton `are very much still in business`.
Time to cut this fabulous Evertonian some slack,I think!
Brian Waring
188 Posted 05/09/2011 at 21:17:33
Richard " He tells me it was one of hundreds he has received since his meeting with Blue Union "

" Apparently the majority are overwhelmingly supportive "

So Richard, one of hundreds received, now constitutes the 'overwhelming majority '..... ?
John Daley
189 Posted 05/09/2011 at 20:49:03
Richard, I take my hat off to you. You've taken your arse licking to a whole new level.

I'd love to know what your 'constructive suggestions' entailed? "We should go out on a date together sometime?", or something along those lines?

I appreciate that you obviously hold the man in high regard but you're starting to take things a bit too far now. You'll be stood in his garden wearing night-vision goggles next, like some Freshfields version of Francis Dolarhyde ( 'Manhunter', not 'Red Dragon').
Anthony Manning
190 Posted 06/09/2011 at 00:19:41
Gary Rimmer #170, see you're spouting your usual rubbish again; not a day goes by!
Steve Jones
192 Posted 06/09/2011 at 09:38:57
Richard, why would you send a letter of supprt to someone who has governed over our fall into a club who's survival is utterly dependent on the manager's continued ability to find raw talent to polish and sell? A manager who's chief scout has just departed for the more affluent climes of Stamford Bridge?

A gradual decline under the incumbent board may be preferable to a catastrophic collapse of the club after a bank foreclosure... but that is the ONLY thing that can be said FOR this board and it is not something, by any stretch of the imagination, worthy of a pat on the back and a big 'attaboy' is it?
Daniel A Johnson
193 Posted 06/09/2011 at 12:05:59
Richard Dodd@172

"Time to cut this fabulous Evertonian some slack, I think!"

Jesus Christ ? with opinions like that, Everton is doomed.......

When we're in the Championship in 2-3 years time, I will be the first on here Richard Dodd to say "I fucking told you so" .

I am now 100% certain Richard Dodd you are a Kenwright plant to talk down the unrest ? shame on you.
Dave Smith
194 Posted 06/09/2011 at 23:37:47
I think Blue Union is harming this club by half informed protagonist who just aren?t happy with their lives.

Do we know what goes on fully in government? No. Do we know what goes on fully in our own workplace (for those that work). No. Do we honestly know fully what is behind every word in our own houses? So WHY on earth would we know what goes on behind closed doors at Goodison? How on EARTH could we have sufficient information to form the cast iron supposition that there is a conspiracy and an utter failing on professional grounds of people who have been employed to do a job?

The nonsense that has gone around after the alleged (?!?) taping of the Kenwright interview ? come on ? if you are going to throw stones, don?t build a glass house.

Listen to yourselves ? you are killing this club. You are an infection desperate to unearth the reality that we are a business that is being propped up by a man and his friends that is losing money each year.

To invest, most financial advisors would suggest as a benchmark to average out the last 8-10 years profit margins and multiply by a factor of 8 and that is what a business is worth. We have consistently made a loss therefore is it any wonder why no-one is interested in us except for randomers?

Come on ? I beg you. The only way we will get out of this is with a sustained period of well placed finishes and European competition. That is the only means in our hands. The other options is that we are swallowed up by a conglomerate as a debt mule (not likely in this financial climate given we are borrowed to the hilt), or we get a new ground that has asset value ? only way that can happen is if we ground share. There is no capital to even start preparation costs. No government or European regen grant ? it is in our hands.

So ? if you accept this?. And to be perfectly honest to the self harmers out there ? even if you don?t. Try and spend a little of your energy working out who would invest in a business of our nature. When you come to the realisation that no right minded business man would touch us as a business, have a look at what we have got. A squad filled with pretty decent players, a manager who is considered to be the best in England, a Chairman with friends with big pockets that seem to have saved us several times and a support that is second to none.

Still want to kill this great club. Through me first.

Michael Kenrick
195 Posted 06/09/2011 at 23:41:40
What a ridiculous post, Dave Smith. You lose all credibility when you claim that concerned fans expressing their concern about the club and seeking to effect change are somehow harming it. Complete nonsense. And your analogies are pathetic in the extreme.

What really gives it away though is your final paragraph where you boast "A squad filled with pretty decent players, a manager who is considered to be the best in England, a Chairman with friends with big pockets that seem to have saved us several times and a support that is second to none."

And yet no-one is interested in buying us... ?!?! Surely even you can see the massive disconnect. Or at least have some concern that somewhere something is not right. Clearly that somewhere is the Everton Boardroom ? did you even read the BK/BU meeting report?

And what's that last bit of nonsense? Some sort of personal threat!?!! Thankfully the lads behind Blue Union are unlikely to be dissuaded by your entreaties.
Alan Williams
196 Posted 07/09/2011 at 08:10:40
Simon, the word that can only describe both sides feelings is utter frustration at the EFC decline and the pace in which the PL and its players have lost control and reality to its members and employers. As a fan I?m gutted with our current situation as a businessman it?s very easy to see exactly why we are where we are. The board have tried to break this constant decline (since 1989 in my opinion) but when you have very little or no spare revenue then you have to go cap in hand to banks or third parties such as Tesco, NTL and many more but when you do go cap in hand the third party naturally have other interests than EFC, and its whether them interests are acceptable and to date they never have been. It?s in EFC interest for the company to be sold by the current board simply because we are not a national/international brand like others so new owners need to add massive added value otherwise any potential sale could be disaster to EFC. What BU and some of its supports just don?t recognise that in difficult times like this continuity is worth a lot as it keeps us stable at best, we are not going bust as some would like to think as the simple matter that our assets (players) value totally outweigh our official registered debt so we are not a Portsmouth and the board decision not to spend whilst depressing as a fan is actually a prudent move as a business. My worry with all this is people just don?t realise that it can get far worse then this and we should be grateful not to BK but to the fact we aren?t Leeds, Portsmouth, Palace, Sheffield W & U, Ipswich, Forest, Derby, Hull and many, many more who were all in the Prem in recent years. COYB
Anthony Manning
197 Posted 07/09/2011 at 16:08:32
Michael#180 what a great reply to Mike Tyson sorry Dave Smith #179, what i have noticed over the last few days is that opinions like his are now well and truly in the minority. See you there saturday.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads