Season › 2011-12 › News
Protest March to go ahead
Quotes or other material sourced from The Blue Union
Reader Comments (72)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
3 Posted 07/09/2011 at 02:14:32
4 Posted 07/09/2011 at 07:03:04
COYB
5 Posted 07/09/2011 at 07:47:04
6 Posted 07/09/2011 at 08:15:54
7 Posted 07/09/2011 at 08:34:18
I'm assuming that Dave Kelly reads this in which case, Dave, I think that you need to circulate a concise sentence that anybody questioned by the media can quote. Better than risking someone coming out with "We want rid of that fucking cunt Kenwright" ? It has to be clear and to the point.
8 Posted 07/09/2011 at 08:43:30
9 Posted 07/09/2011 at 08:46:19
10 Posted 07/09/2011 at 08:57:12
11 Posted 07/09/2011 at 09:01:34
12 Posted 07/09/2011 at 09:12:42
13 Posted 07/09/2011 at 09:29:40
Sounds good.
See you there.
15 Posted 07/09/2011 at 10:23:08
Tick tock, time for change.
16 Posted 07/09/2011 at 10:24:42
17 Posted 07/09/2011 at 10:44:00
As far as I am aware you cannot sack the board, as they own the majority shares in the club. The only way they can be replaced is for someone to buy their shares.
The only other alternative to removing the present board is if our biggest creditor, Barclays Bank decide that we will not be able to keep up our repayments on our loans, then they could appoint someone nominated by Barclays to run the club. This is what RBS did with Liverpool but, seeing as we are meeting our payments to Barclays, that seems a non-starter.
So I would suggest that if the battle cry of the protest group is to shout "Sack the board", I am afraid it would just highlight they have no concept of how a club is run.
18 Posted 07/09/2011 at 10:52:20
19 Posted 07/09/2011 at 10:59:36
20 Posted 07/09/2011 at 11:18:52
Good luck with your "Sack the board" chants.
22 Posted 07/09/2011 at 11:38:24
But even if this board took the coward's way and resigned en masse, then who would fill the void? Well, the board could ask Barclays Bank to appoint someone to run the club on a day-to-day basis. Although I couldn't see Davie Moyes staying around long if Kenwright resigns.
24 Posted 07/09/2011 at 11:35:44
Welcome, everyone watching, to the law of unintended consequence. The aim here, according to those orchestrating events, is to give a voice to those fans who are angry with the failures of the board.
It is therefore a collection of angry people. Raised emotion coupled to large groups of people seldom results in moderate and considered action. There is a reason why the words 'angry' and 'mob' fit together as well as they do!.
There is an undercurrent of intellectual honesty in the BU evident from several of the comments made. I dont doubt they know that protest is meaningless and irrelevent towards the aims of getting the club sold to worthwhile owners. It, according to reports from the Casa meeting, was the will of the majority to have the protest march though.
Therein lies the problem Gary highlights. Regardless of the BU's noble intent a mindless majority exists that does want 'Billy Boy' dragged out and shot for his crimes against the fans and they wont be appeased by any little triviality like logic or objective common sense. Especially not when there are hundreds, perhaps thousands, of them ganged together and they are feeling powerful!.
The problem is a protest is automatically a negative thing. There are ways to demonstrate mass support that are positive and constructive that dont have the associated dangers, large scale fund-raising events etc, but strong leadership is needed to direct the course of the action away from the knee-jerk need to display anger and find a more productive use for the emotions.
The BU dont have the leadership strength yet so we are were we are. Hoping that we keep the lid on this despite the fact that the intent of the protest isnt necessarily on the same hymn sheet as the bulk of the protesters.
27 Posted 07/09/2011 at 12:18:05
28 Posted 07/09/2011 at 12:18:39
29 Posted 07/09/2011 at 12:32:09
"The aim of The Blue Union is simple, it?s not to get Bill Kenwright out, it?s certainly not some mindless attempt to sack the board"
Peter Laing and Lewsis Morrison state:-
"Support the team, sack the board".
I think before the protest starts it might be wise to check if your all actually protesting for the same thing.
33 Posted 07/09/2011 at 13:39:01
Do you think it was the moaning gobshites who got change at LFC ? of course not, it was the bank that forced a sale so lets hope Barclays start to squeeze BK to sell his stake and not his players.
We have 2 new players in the squad for Saturday so let's look forward to that rather than ousting our board or sorting out peace in Gaza which may be easier.
35 Posted 07/09/2011 at 13:12:39
I went to my first game which was a derby back in the 80's when I was about 10 years old with my dad who was a huge Kopite.
It was one of the most magical days of my life, I instantly understood that this was something special, something that affected me so deeply that I wanted to be a blue for life (much to my dads displeasure).
Despite living in Gloucestershire I make the 380 mile round trip at least 10 times a season to support my beloved Blues!
Which brings me on to my point (at last, sorry)....I now have a 6 year son and I have decided that it is the right time to introduce him to the blue family! I booked tickets for the Villa game 10 days ago or so and he has been as excited as I have seen him since.
He is wanting to get their very early, walk around the ground, go to the megastore, hunt down some autographs etc etc and enjoy what should be one of the best days of his life!
Then the news breaks of the protest...... I have many questions spinning around my head. Will this be peaceful? Will it ruin the atmosphere? Is this any place to take a small child? Should we join the march?
I have to confess that whilst I am very unhappy and mystified as to why our massive club is being outspent by Crawley Town in the past three or four transfer windows. What are we asking the club to do? Do we think someone has their hand in the till? I know we need new owners but surely we can not march on GP chanting for a Russian Billionaire.
I promise you I am not trying to take the piss I do just want to understand what we hope to achieve and if it is going to benefit my team and it is peaceful then I will be there with my son!
Any reassurances, advice gratefully received
36 Posted 07/09/2011 at 13:49:24
This would also give a ture number of supporters the potest has, as a potest before the match will always have a large number of people just walking to the ground.
38 Posted 07/09/2011 at 13:45:53
It won't move us forward one inch towards the stated goals of the BU and it carries a huge risk of blowing up in our faces, but, to suggest this is an exercise in vanity is just demonstrating a staggering level of ignorance.
39 Posted 07/09/2011 at 13:55:40
How exactly do you "sack a board"? Could someone please explain?
41 Posted 07/09/2011 at 13:36:01
We have to sell players - why?
We have no assets - why ?
The banks are moving in - why?
We are in big trouble financially - why?
Green and Earl - why?
And on and on.............
Plus the Koppites slur. Grow up. At least they did something. Are you willing to simply sit back and hope for the best while we get left behind? Once the protest is over we will take our season ticket seats in the Lower Glad and support the team.
A footnote just for your ego ? I am 48 and been home and away even in the 70s/80s when it was a dangerous business and have never felt like I do at the moment.
Question - Do you think EFC will win the title in mine/your lifetime as we currently stand?
I think not unless we let our CEO do his job (chech his track record before he came to EFC) and appoint an interim board to find a buyer à la Martin Broughton at Liverpool.
Another question - if we do nothing and we finish mid table, do you think Barkley, Jags, Baines, Rodwell etc will still be with us this time next year?
As I said, League Champions in our lifetimes!!!
Yes, Kenwright loves EFC but we all do and it is time to act before it is too late.
COYB
PS - Please do not come back with the 'We need a new stadium to find a buyer,' or 'How are we going to find a imaginary billionaire,' arguments as both will show your ignorance of the facts.
This is it - a moment in our history. And we have got to try.Got to.
COYB
44 Posted 07/09/2011 at 14:16:58
46 Posted 07/09/2011 at 14:23:10
I was at my parents Yesterday. My Dad is 81. First game with him aged 5 in the old Park End next to the away fans in 1968. Only because that end was close to the pub he drank in.
Anyway, he loves a chat about EFC. I told him of the protest and that we were attending and ... wow. Note: My Dad has always been a calm and placid man but he took me by surprise when he stood up, shook me by the hand and stated quite angrily, 'Thank God something is finally happening. I have known for years Kenwright has no vision and will be the ruin of this club.'
And that is him watching at 81 from the outside with just local and national media as sources of info. Not the internet etc like the rest of us. He added.'We were the biggest club in the country, first in every department, founders of the league ? look at us now.' Passion burst out of him. (Calm down Dad, 81 and all that)
Re KEIOC - again read all the info re Kirkby. It had no chance and was always going to be called in. Not because of the stadium or EFC but because of the impact on Kirkby town centre and surrounding boroughs due to the size of the retail development. Never mind the non existent transport structure. Also see the work and plans of Tom Hughes and others re Goodison Park on their site. Philip Green = Arcadia Group = Topshop, Burtons = Kirkby shops = attracting M &S to site etc.
Robert Earl = hotel at Kirkby. Nothing to do with EFC. Just one of the many mis-judged and short sited cock ups under Kenwright's watch.
An interim board whose sole job is to steady the ship and find a credible buyer - that is the aim.
Hopefully there will be supporters at the protest like myself who have travelled away in the dark days and therefore can recognise trouble before it happens. I truly hope it is peaceful as it will defeat the object and that once it is over we all get in the ground and support the team. Especially if the morale is low after the transfer of Arteta and the injury to Baines.
Anyway, I am prepared to march and see what happens. I can't just sit here and twiddle my thumbs and hope for the best.
COYB
51 Posted 07/09/2011 at 15:18:09
What?s even funnier is the role of Ged Alexander [#5], the agent provocateurs agent provocateur perhaps?. lol
53 Posted 07/09/2011 at 15:21:07
I see varying degrees of enthusiasm for a protest. I dont see anyone believing that the protest will unseat the board or really achieve more than provide a visible marker of the anger in the fanbase.
Anyone who isnt preching the party line is the enemy eh? I thought the BU was meant to be an inclusive outfit?
55 Posted 07/09/2011 at 15:39:14
59 Posted 07/09/2011 at 16:00:52
What exactly are you expecting from the protest? I presume you will be there?
As i pointed out earlier the BU state its not a protest to oust Bill K, yet there have been posts from paricipants in the protest about a protest to sack the board.
What exactly is it that the protest is expecting to achieve?
I personally have no problem with the protest i just don't understand what people are expecting to achieve without a investor / buyer etc waiting in the wings that they can get there support behind.
60 Posted 07/09/2011 at 15:55:24
a)An interim board will run the club to steady the ship and look for a credible buyer.
b)Robert Elstone, CEO will be free to do the job he is paid for.
I think the other point being made re Moyes is that if we have to wait to protest until we are 3 nil up then don't hold your breath.
We are in the shite my man through complete and utter mis-mangement and if it takes a protest or spending time on forums or whatever else then so be it.
To do nothing at this critical point .........for me that is not an option
COYB
61 Posted 07/09/2011 at 16:06:10
I am not protesting about Moyes, I was simply highlighting your brainwave to protest when we are 3-0 up.
The protest is nothing to do with the team ? after the protest we will go into the ground and cheer on the boys and hopefully come away with 3 points. We don't need to wait until we are winning a game to have a protest. A result in a football match is not going to change our resolve to change the board. Even if we win 4-0 on saturday, I will still wake up on sunday hoping for a new board.
62 Posted 07/09/2011 at 16:13:58
I'll ask the question again, don't you want to find out why the club is run so badly?
Don't you want to know where £24m of 'other operating costs' have gone?
That's why I'm going.
63 Posted 07/09/2011 at 16:17:12
We just would like some forward thinking from the board instead of their usual fuck ups,
Plans for stadium development, plans to increase revenue etc.
If they can't do it, they should appoint someone who can!
If you had a business that was falling behind your competitors, you would at least consider bringing in some fresh ideas, not just plodding on waiting for the inevitable to happen.
64 Posted 07/09/2011 at 16:57:50
66 Posted 07/09/2011 at 17:03:29
They obviously don't though, thats the problem. Look at posts 9-12 they seem to be going to the protest with a different agenda to what the BU have released in their press statements regarding the protests.
67 Posted 07/09/2011 at 17:18:20
It's not just posts #9-12 on this thread as pointed out by David, look through almost any developed thread on this site or any one of half a dozen other sites. The baying is there.
The BU might not WANT the protest to be about targetting the board, but where is it ending....outside the Directors' door... literally. What do you think is going to happen when the march gets there? A slow hand-clap and an orderly filing away?
Honestly?
69 Posted 07/09/2011 at 17:45:44
The current board has already failed. We are now in a position where we have used up every asset apart from the ground and playing staff to keep us afloat, and we are now starting to use the players as bargaining chips with the bank. Some people.... eyes wide shut!
72 Posted 07/09/2011 at 17:38:20
Like it or not the protest is happening, and like I said the panic by those who peddle the deception is palpable, the fightback will no doubt start in the media any day now, I've seen it all before, nothing detracts from the fact the club are in the shit and the current board having put us there haven't a clue how to get us out - I'm waiting for the announcement any day now that the negotiations are underway with another mystery buyer!!! - see you Saturday.
73 Posted 07/09/2011 at 18:57:21
74 Posted 07/09/2011 at 19:06:28
If there was a buyer then things would be different.
I agree that Kenwright has crashed this club with his abysmal spending patterns, like the supposed stadiums or the huge wage costs of this club.
This is all Kenwrights fault! Moyes has supported him every step and that makes me angry, because he still sticks by him despite what has happened.
By the way I was shocked when I read that Arteta was sold, that was just the worst outcome of all for me. He was the one creative footballer except Baines and now we have lost him to Arsenal of all clubs, I would have expected him to go to spain , not a rival. It hurts and it also shows desperation, Kenwright must be the poorest chairman football has ever seen. Just hope that the mood at the game will be good towards the newcomers. I also think shipping out Vaughan,Yakubu and Beckford in one go stinks, who is suppose to score goals now? The constantly injured Saha? Stupid is too kind a word for Kenwright.
75 Posted 07/09/2011 at 19:35:18
76 Posted 07/09/2011 at 19:32:23
It reminds me of the Life of Brian - People's front of Judiah, Judian People's front.
People say we should appoint an interim board. Question: who appoints them? The major shareholders are also by and large the current directors. When Liverpool appointed various people to their board to sell the club, it was the bank who effectively put them on the board to ensure that they got their money back. They were then in a position to push a sale through against the will of the majority shareholders.
So maybe we should be marching down to Barclays HQ instead and singing "What do we want? The bank to call in your debts and appoint some interim directors to try and sell the club from underneath the shareholders before we go into administration... When do we want it? As soon as a resolution can be passed by the directors to enable this to happen."
b) Robert Elstone, CEO will be free to do the job he is paid for.
77 Posted 07/09/2011 at 19:49:34
The BU have set aims, individuals still have the right to their own views too.
Believe it or not, you can vote Labour without agreeing with every single Labour policy, and you can back a cause that you see to be right and just without your own view marrying 100% with those of the group.
As has been said, the tide is turning...tick, tock.
78 Posted 07/09/2011 at 20:08:49
79 Posted 07/09/2011 at 20:16:36
Paul Lally,
Who is going to pay for the interim board? I can't imagine they are going to do it for free.
How long do the interim board have until they need to be removed if the club is not sold?
What job exactly is Robert Elstone doing at the moment if it is not the one he is paid for? Can you be a bit more specific?
81 Posted 07/09/2011 at 20:14:01
It would have made a difference as that is the time when the people you need to make a point to....
Err... Ray... you kinda drifted off at the end there. ? Ed
83 Posted 07/09/2011 at 21:57:25
Instead of a straight response you suggest that a fightback will soon be under way? This is confusing as, earlier you seemed to intimate that anyone not toeing the party line was a club infiltrator?
Anyway you are right in that the protest will now go on and, in my view, HAS to go on otherwise any chance at credibility will be lost and fan representation crippled. We are, though, utterly dependent on the BU and protesters being of one purpose. On the strength of comments on this site alone you have to be fairly delusional to believe that.
Join the protest myself: no. When the BU do something constructive, I'll support it and contribute in any way I can. I don't see how strolling past the gift shop and hurling abuse outside the Directors Entrance will take us very far forward though. Certainly won't do anything to lessen my frustration at how we've been run. Each to their own though, eh?
84 Posted 07/09/2011 at 22:41:10
I don't see the big problem one or two people have with Evertonians who just want voice their opinion about how the club is run. They are more angry at the protestors than they are at the people who are destroying the club.
Doing nothing but bitching at protestors certainaly won't improve anything.
85 Posted 07/09/2011 at 22:45:53
I'll be there Saturday, like I was at The Casa last Saturday. I just wanted to ask you, did Ged get back to you regarding Vibrac and the JG link? I have found a link to Investec and Formation, which is bad enough.
Also, are you aware that James Grant acts on behalf of Rodwell and Hope? If there is a link, it means Kenwright has just borrowed £13mill from Rodwell's agent? And perhaps had a previous loan off Rooney's agent?
If all this turns out to be true... I'm finished with football,
Proactive, for anyone else, were turned into Formation; Tthe shareholders of Proactive, Paul Stretford's agency, were Kevin Keegan, Kenny Dalglish, Peter Reid, Bobby Robson, and their office was in St James Park with another owner of the company, Freddie Sheppard's son. They apparently put the first bid in for Rooney...?
The whole thing stinks...
87 Posted 07/09/2011 at 23:00:38
We need this board gone, with something better in its place, everyone is in agreement with that. Me, personally, I want to see constructive action towards that end. You said it yourself this protest is a group of fans venting their frustration, nothing more.
My preference would be to unite the fanbase in a common cause. Fund raising, large scale, towards commisioning our own promotional campaign for the club etc. Achieves the aim of demonstrating our resolve and numbers without the risks of a protest degenerating into the kind of farce we saw at Newcastle or over the park.
Like I said, for me, shouting at the directors door will do nothing to improve my view of the club's future. If you are confident you'll feel better for doing, it knock yourself out. Again, like I said, each to their own.
88 Posted 08/09/2011 at 07:34:39
Your suggestion of large scale fund raising to commission a promotional campaign for the club as a more productive means than a protest? Excellent, when are you beginning work on this?
89 Posted 08/09/2011 at 08:37:21
Interestingly for Everton is that the protest will create more publicity than this useless board has ever been able to muster up. It is certainly nowhere near as negative as Everton selling its best players and who know, investors who had no idea about us might actually look at the situation and wonder what's going on. Who knows where that leads.
If nothing else, I would love to see Ross slither back to the rock he came under.
90 Posted 08/09/2011 at 08:56:16
They could see if a joint stadium could be built, and approach some multi-national companies about naming rights to offset the costs. Then the council could take out a mortgage for the remainder of the cost.
Then they could bill each club a set amount each year; also because it would be a mortgage, this could be taken over the maximum number of years, which would minimise the year-on-year costs to each club.
91 Posted 08/09/2011 at 08:10:32
I have no doubt that interested parties will be trotted out that are as mythical as the scripts he used to act. That said though anyone stupid enough to take such well timed glad tidings at face value deserves t
he fall they get for swallowing it in my view.
On that basis I'm not sure quite how much of a revelation it is that the board will move to try and draw the sting out of this or why you think its significant to repeatedly point it out?. Unless of course you're back to the 'anyone not toeing the party line is working for the club' concept - which is at odds with the inclusivity ideals cited by the BU's mission statement. Do you support the BU's position or not Colin?.
I was hoping someone with more experience of being involved with a pressure group might have had the idea about fund-raising as I'm not an events coordinator by trade. Still I have sent a mail to the Race for Life people as to what steps they took to organise their funruns. If they can get 24k girls running you'd hope we could get a quarter of that, of both sexes, at least given the bulk of our support is local to the stadium.
92 Posted 08/09/2011 at 09:25:20
http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/public/sitesearch.do?querystring=everton&p=tto&pf=all&bl=on
You'll have to pay £1 though !
See you Saturday.
93 Posted 08/09/2011 at 10:23:01
THe style of the march will dictate the future direction of fan involvement in the club.
Could BU make it clear their stance on the abusive and paranoiac nature of much the comment on this site.
When i first heard of BU i thought it was an idea with a future and it could show the way for fan involvement in the Premier League clubs.Not so sure now.!!!
94 Posted 08/09/2011 at 12:04:58
"The aim of the Blue Union is simple, it's not to get Bill Kenwright out, it's certainly not some mindless attempt to sack the board. Its aim is to promote the concept of allowing the CEO to be left to concentrate on reducing costs, developing our revenue streams and repairing the relationship with the fanbase whilst leaving the board to appoint a fully autonomous group of professional individuals who can effectively develop and implement a strategy that will identify and sell the club to a buyer who can demonstrate an ability and a genuine desire to take the club forward on both a commercial and football level."
Pretty clear and exactly the same as they state on their site:
http://www.evertoniansforchange.com/
COYB
95 Posted 08/09/2011 at 12:35:32
96 Posted 08/09/2011 at 12:43:19
Most of the ideas have no connection with real world of finance, banking, legalities etc. I am sure, given its recent history, we all should realise what a minefield the Premier League can be, it's no place for the naive idealistic amateur.
A criticism I have is that the Board were too idealistic in their ticketing policies, BK can't win; he's damned if does and damned if he doesnt.
Peter, I don't really agree 100% with you, the broadsheets (Guardian et al) have been fairly straightforward.The tabloids are a whole different ballgame ? as we will probably see on Sun/Mon.
97 Posted 08/09/2011 at 13:16:22
98 Posted 08/09/2011 at 15:13:43
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/14834439.stm
99 Posted 08/09/2011 at 17:09:32
Simple premise being to ask matchgoing fans, for a single match only (looking at the Man Utd game potentially), to give up their pint of Chang and donate the fiver (ish) to the BU. Dual effect of dipping the matchday revenue to show the board they can be hit in the bottom-line and putting something into the BU war-chest. If you could get just a third of the matchday fanbase to pitch in that would put a sizeable contribution towards a professional marketing campaign.
Looking at options for poster and leaflet advertising for 'Buy us a Pint' day at the derby?. Would you know who to talk to for official BU imagery logo's etc if the idea meets with approval?
100 Posted 09/09/2011 at 09:07:59
Do any of these protesters really think that the team will feel or play any better while all this is going on.
Does anybody really believe that any good whatsoever will come of this. if so, please tell me the Planet they have arrived from. better still, why don't they all post their CV's relative to their business experience, their ability to run a multi-million pound corporation, or their reason for believing they know what is best.
it's true that every Evertonian wants the best for Everton. This includes the present Everton board.
So why do the BU think that they are unique in any way whatsoever. Are they bigger than Everrton FC. We were there long before they popped their head up and we will be there long after they have gone and are forgotten.
COYB's let us never lose sight of the fact that the club and the team are far more important than any small group of people who try to make us believe they are the saviours of our team without any tangible solutions let alone the logistics of the silly claims most of them make.
Finally will all this disruption make us a more desirable option for potential buyers?
Common sense at all times. please do not allow yourselves to be fooled.
101 Posted 09/09/2011 at 12:34:44
I do understand that there are some serious issues at EFC and im very worried at the direction our club is going. However, I can, in no way, see how a march by a few hundred supporters calling for the head of BK and to be replaced by 'an interim board' is going to help.
An interim board? And who chooses them? The few lads from the Winslow / BU? How's that fair? Either offer an alternative or get on with supporting EFC. And dont give me all that 'its not our job to find investment / a buyer'. I know full well its not your job but why moan / protest about something when you clearly have no idea how to resolve matters and, hence, no actual, logical, realistic goal.
I dont expect all the backslapping 'right on Colin', 'well said Neil', etc that goes on on this board but if you're sole objective to respond is with abusive posts or ridiculous accusations of me being a red or club plant, then please dont, its boring.
It just so happens, im an Evertonian who disagrees with the approaches / thought processes of the BU.
102 Posted 09/09/2011 at 15:24:03
103 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:04:10
On these sort of occasions its as well to remember the Chinese curse ""MAY YOU GET WHAT YOU WISH FOR"
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 06/09/2011 at 22:44:42
COYB.