Season › 2011-12 › News
Elstone rejects calls for interim board
Quotes or other material sourced from Evertonfc.com
Reader Comments (56)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 08/09/2011 at 19:21:27
3 Posted 08/09/2011 at 19:15:33
4 Posted 08/09/2011 at 19:27:33
Bill Kenwright has said that the club has been for sale from day one.
Robert Elstone now tells us that the club has been for sale for the last three years.
Both of them can't be telling us the truth.
5 Posted 08/09/2011 at 19:34:44
Come on Keano - show us all what the current board are doing and how the fuck if its selling the club its taken over a decade or is it three years, or is it investment or is it just a load of bollocks as per usual.
And another thing Keano why is it every time Kenshite is on the ropes or looking for some gullible support the fairy tales of potential buyers appears in the media only to disappear unanswered shortly afterwards.
cough cough BULLSHIT
6 Posted 08/09/2011 at 19:35:37
A Ken Doll with a drinking problem??
Or maybe that cunt Barbie took him for all his money when she caught him sucking Kenwright's hoo-ha?
7 Posted 08/09/2011 at 19:36:44
But as Blue Union have correctly identified, our CEO doesn't appear to have the freedom to run the club on a day to day basis. BK isn't interested enough to take on the full time running of the club, but he's not professional enough to let Elstone run it either.
Must be incredibly frustrating and, whatever you think about Elstone, no CEO is going to be able to be effective if they have a major shareholder who likes to interfere and continually undermines their authority to run the club.
8 Posted 08/09/2011 at 19:37:38
Class. I reckon he'd be alright to have a beer with. Elstone probably feels like a bit of a cock trying to cover up for all the untruths spouted for 12 years. But ultimatey if he wants his money he has to dance to Bill's tune.
9 Posted 08/09/2011 at 20:06:54
Correct me if I'm wrong, but this is Elstone's first 'C'-level position. A title does not mean that you are automatically capable. My feeling is actually the direct opposite, a focussed and driven team of experienced executives would lead a due diligence and business sale process far more effectively than the lightweight board currently in place. It's not rocket science, it's simple. Round pegs in round holes... Everton are well known for doing things on the cheap from top to bottom, hence round hole, square peg.
The irony of this whole situation is that we Evertonians are a fairly understanding bunch; with honest communications, I honestly believe that none of the current activity would be taking place, we'd pull together and try to help. It takes a hell of a lot of lies, deceit and bullshit to get a rise from us.
Sadly, DK was the last straw. I am shamed by the fact that I supported the club in that action and grateful to the self same active Evertonians who are leading the Blue Union currently.
Finally, isn't it funny that Elstone's blogs only appear in times of crisis? Shouldnt they be called diversionary blags rather than blogs? They are rocked by the sentiment of the fans.
10 Posted 08/09/2011 at 20:31:16
Elstone's comment: "The suggestion of a completely new group of individuals coming in and essentially doing what the current board is doing is risible and completely unnecessary" made me smile. He doesn't seem to realise that the "new group of individuals" would be "coming in and essentially doing what the current board is" NOT "doing"!
11 Posted 08/09/2011 at 20:38:58
12 Posted 08/09/2011 at 21:28:01
See you Saturday.
13 Posted 08/09/2011 at 21:35:49
The man doesn't have a clue, but I guess as Blue Bill's right hand man he is not going to say anything different.
Yawn......
14 Posted 08/09/2011 at 21:46:06
Let them have their little march, they will soon be footnote in the club's history books.
15 Posted 08/09/2011 at 21:45:09
This will be the start of the circus, expect the usual suspects to be wheeled out tomorrow, the Mail, Mike Parry ? pity they didn't put the same effort into supporting the manager.
16 Posted 08/09/2011 at 22:53:31
17 Posted 08/09/2011 at 23:15:22
ps: I don't feel sorry for Rob bloody Elstone in the same way as I don't feel sorry for Gaddafis spokesman or the late (and not lamented) Saddam Hussein's spokesman who said to the TV camera's that "the Americans have been defeated", while behind him US tanks were rolling through the streets of Baghdad!
18 Posted 08/09/2011 at 23:36:31
Funny how so many anti-BU comments appear so Closely together- 4 all at 22.20 with pro BK sentiment with people who arent linked via FB or any other social media setting.
Hmmmmmm,
19 Posted 09/09/2011 at 00:47:26
Wait, is this the same Robert Elstone who, under oath during the Kirkby governmental review TWO years ago, said that the club wasn't for sale?
20 Posted 09/09/2011 at 00:56:54
That said, your analogy does somewhat appear to be spot on. We just need some tanks rolling in on Saturday behind the BU march...
21 Posted 09/09/2011 at 01:12:33
The board's behaviour is covered by substantial laws. It would seem completely inappropriate to have a second board. However, as (when appropriate) the board should act in consideration of the interests of all stakeholders, it would be sensible for it to appoint a small group of board members plus invited "others (usually professional or interested party)" to be a sub-committe e (for want of a better term) to seek out a buyer. This committee should report to the board accordingly.
If this can't work, the best way would be to alter the make up of the board ? dismissals, resignations, additions of directors etc ? achieve better board diversity etc.
COYB
22 Posted 09/09/2011 at 02:20:06
We're seriously going to draw comparisons between Robert Elstone and the spokespeople for Gaddafi and Saddam Hussein? That's ridiculous.
While I definitely don't agree with everything Elstone's done, I believe that he has made some efforts (usually undermined by his chairman) to bring a little more professionalism to our commercial approach. He simply seems unable to be *allowed* to act as a proper CEO because of BK's interference, and certainly he's made a number of mistakes himself.
He clearly can't come outright and criticize the board. He's not, as far as I'm aware, a millionaire fat-cat. This is his first role as a CEO, though his business background would at least appear to suggest he's not simply been thrown in at the deep end without the relevant experience. So, what, he's supposed to just criticize the board despite his position, or quit, regardless of the potential impact on his earnings, or his family's financial security. Because we want him to do something differently? He's not acting immorally or illegally as far as I know. He doesn't have a financial interest as a shareholder. So I presume that whether we like it or not, he's trying to do the best job he can in difficult circumstances.
My point is not that Robert Elstone is some amazing CEO. Given all the problems at the higher levels of the club, however, there seems to be an increasing move to demonize *everyone* who has any public profile. We've already seen Elstone get his authority completely undercut by BK's comments in the Blue Union interview. Can't be an easy job working in this situation, with a chairman who seems both incompetent *and* interfering.
He may or may not be the right man to be CEO of Everton. Right now I don't think anyone, however competent, could be a truly effective CEO simply because BK doesn't allow them the authority to run the club properly.
23 Posted 09/09/2011 at 03:07:27
I would suggest they form a board sub-committee whose terms of reference are just to sell the club. It would be this committee's role to appoint consultants and provide them with hands-on management and oversight. This sub-committee would also evaluate potential buyers and would ensure proper due diligence is done. The committee would provide reports to the board when serious opportunities are identified.
Currently, the Everton board has neither the skill nor the will to carry out the task of selling the club. It has abdicated responsibility to faceless consultants who have not been properly managed or controlled. In the corporate world, boards of directors would delegate such matters to expert internal staff who would remain accountable to all impacted stakeholders.
I agree with our CEO that another board is not the way to go. But carrying on the way we are doing now is also wrong. The definition of foolishness is doing the same things time after time but expecting a different result. If you do what you have always done, you get what you have always got.
24 Posted 09/09/2011 at 05:27:09
25 Posted 09/09/2011 at 05:54:40
I thought Ross said it was only 60 young idiots who were calling for change. Surely Ross and the powers that be can't be feeling a bit of pressure from said 60 young idiots???
26 Posted 09/09/2011 at 06:30:00
27 Posted 09/09/2011 at 06:33:50
What you will find in scenarios like this is that anyone that isn't part of the solution is part of the problem. The Arab Spring has highlighted the repeating history that regime change is often accelerated when members of that regime's inner circle voice dissent and breakaway; those that don't face the same future as the regime they staunchly back until its end and that's an exit with it.
28 Posted 09/09/2011 at 07:12:58
See you on the march.
29 Posted 09/09/2011 at 07:54:44
I just read Andy Grey's comments. Utter tripe. Do you think he read directly from a script or was he sitting on BK's knee like a miming puppet?
Stability? Really?
30 Posted 09/09/2011 at 08:14:50
This march is so misguided and a poor demonstration of what could have been a real legitimate voice for the fans but sadly the organisers have allowed themselves to be driven by the mob and sadly, yes, sadly it will mean BU losing what credibility it should have. I predict them having breakaway factions next which is so sad as we should be using this as an opportunity for fans comments on the board but it has actually done the opposite and nobody wins at all. COYB
31 Posted 09/09/2011 at 08:34:46
Here's the issue though: if I tried for the Everton 1st team and gave 150%, I know I would not get in cos MY BEST WOULD NOT BE GOOD ENOUGH.
The point of all the rubbish that comes out of the EFC boardroom is, yes, you are trying your best but unfortunately YOUR BEST IS NOT GOOD ENOUGH. Why can't they realise that, hold up their hands and be honest, just for once?
I think lots of supporters believe the board are trying their best but are failing to see that:
1. Their best is woefully inadequate.
2. There are alternatives, i.e. businessmen out their who CAN run a club properly.
An interim board of professional businessmen needs appointing NOW!
32 Posted 09/09/2011 at 08:52:35
See you Saturday.
33 Posted 09/09/2011 at 09:07:32
34 Posted 09/09/2011 at 09:13:18
The point is the current board are NOT doing it are the....!!
35 Posted 09/09/2011 at 09:38:42
Couldn't find ONE buyer in 10yrs but now he got THREE in the short time since the details of the protest were announced...these people treat the fans with the utmost DISRESPECT and have done for years...do they think we are a gang of cretins....??
Betcha they disappear into thin air if nothing comes of the protest...hope to god the protest works as Kenwrong will have to tell us who these buyers are....that's of course if they are genuine....what do you think...??
36 Posted 09/09/2011 at 09:26:46
Do they have any ideas as to who would be on it? Have they approached anyone to see if there is any interest from any 'big hitters' in this field (I presume you can't phone Maureen or the men with the taches and ask for the 'number of a good interim board please').
Seems we all want change but other than 'get a billionaire Arab in' nobody seems to actually be submitting anything remotely like an answer.
If you want an interim board in, get the people in place and present it to the current lot.
I will own up and admit to being a complete 'fence sitter' in the argument, I can see pro's and cons in both sides, but I think that a protest march may only have a detrimental effect on Saturday (the players are even commenting on it now, and you know how it is, at the time it's - things like that don't affect us on the pitch-, but months down the line it will be - we were all affected by the goings on around us, of course we were-)
Please, we all want everything for the good of Everton FC, OUR Everton FC. Get a workable agenda and viable business plan in place, show the board your not 'the 60 kids on the internet' that Ian Ross thinks you are, and let's take the club forward.
37 Posted 09/09/2011 at 10:52:21
Andy Gray talking utter drivel on the EFC website, im very disappointed that he cant see what the BU are trying to bring about.
Nobody has the divine right to be believed and Bill thinks that being a "True Blue" means that everybody should just except his version of events
No Bill, i dont believe you and i believe your yes men/cronies even less
You have not put anything financial into this club, just the same as your mate Woods and Mr Bankruptcy.
Love the club Bill but now is the time to be honest.
You can't sell it so let someone help
38 Posted 09/09/2011 at 11:42:23
It isn't BU's job to find EFC a new investor. BU is a group formed because of the years of frustations and stagnation the club has suffered - at the hands of BK and co.
It seems fairly clear to most sensible folk (except Alan W.) that BK is not the right man to take the club forward or even sell the club at all.Therefore an interim board with the sole mission to find Everton new, viable, long term owners would probably be more likely to succeed. Especially if our current board claims they have been looking 24/7 for 12 years and yet have only found a psychopath living in Manchester.
BU are just a group of concerned fans - WHY and HOW the fuck would they find suitable international investment experts to form an interim board? This is precisely what BK and co would have been doing 5 years ago IF they ever had any real intention of relinquishing control.
Let's protest and see the board squirm. This "very small minority" can help put pressure on the current board which ultimately could lead to more exposure into our plight.
39 Posted 09/09/2011 at 11:54:28
The point I was trying to make is that the more a structured argument is put forward the more you can make the board squirm. Put a viable business plan together that has willing and compitent participants in place and surely they would have to at least listen and not dismiss it out of hand. If I had the knowledge of who to go to I would gladly give it.
The mission statement of the Blue Union seems to indicate this is what they want to achieve and not just be a witch hunt to force Kenwright out ( but I have to say that what I have seen so far the campaign has only been aimed at discrediting him, and boy has he done a good job of that himself!), so I was asking do they have people in mind?
Mr. Kenwright thinks he is the best salesperson for Everton (his opinion, and I suspect his alone) so surely he doesn't think he needs anybody else. Maybe going to him with a list of willing people better qualified to do the job would be better than shouting for his head outside the ground half an hour before kick off?
40 Posted 09/09/2011 at 13:20:54
You wait ages for one to come along and then here comes three at the same time.
41 Posted 09/09/2011 at 13:53:01
42 Posted 09/09/2011 at 14:23:48
If you want someone to give you a suggestion, how about getting BK and the board to contact some of these people and ask them to take over the 'sales' process!
Also, as mentioned above, no-one in BU or other fan is paid to make these sort of decisions. Just because you point out something does not work does not mean you necessarily need to come up with a solution to fix it, specially when that is the precise job of someone else.
43 Posted 09/09/2011 at 14:53:17
It is not the supporters' job to find a buyer and it never has been nor ever will be. Our mission is to support the team and if the board can't do that also then they should move on.
44 Posted 09/09/2011 at 15:28:01
If you started a job and said "I'm going to achieve xyz" (in Bill's case it was find long term owners)...but 12 years later you had completely failed to achieve what you openly declared was your mission all that tme ago, then would you think criticism of you would be unfair or justified?
The huge problem with BK is there is no humility. I can say with 100% confidence had BK at some stage over the last 5 years held his hands up and said "I'm out of my depth" or "I'm struggling to meet expectations" then very few would be on his back ? like they are now.
Instead we get statements like "I'm the best EFC salesperson there is..." and "...why should I know what £24M of operating costs are?"
45 Posted 09/09/2011 at 15:42:35
That is sort of what I am getting at. They think they are doing the best already, if we're not happy with it we have to come up with an alternative. The board will say they have the best people in place and on board already (Keith Harris etc.); if you don't think they are doing enough or that it's not good enough it's up to us to offer alternatives ? otherwise, they will just plod along as they are and nobody achieves anything.
46 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:02:28
I cannot remember this much public pressure being put on EFC owners to sort something out and the longer and larger it gets, there will only be one solution.
As more fans start protesting, the banks (I hope) will step in and force them to sell or take over the whole sales process, ala the dark side across the park.
Without the fans, there is no club!
Keep the pressue up BU - some people may not agree with the methods but the eventual aim is justified IMHO.
47 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:30:21
It's a strange situation where everyone seems to want the same thing but arguments are raging about it!
Let's hope at the end of it all the club emerges the stronger (our neighbours always seem to come up smelling of roses no matter what happens to them!)
Let's hope all the talk in the pub at 5 o'clock tomorrow is of how well the new lads did in a victory over Villa.
48 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:45:10
49 Posted 09/09/2011 at 18:25:10
50 Posted 09/09/2011 at 20:56:29
How about this one for a spot of viable business planning.
1. Don't tear down one of your corporate facilities, even though it's a tent. Then find out you cannot get planning permission for a new building that will house a museum & corporate facilities.
Oh - and leave a hole in the wall to remind the world of your incompetence.
51 Posted 09/09/2011 at 21:06:37
52 Posted 09/09/2011 at 22:42:31
If you were buying a car would you tell the seller the best price you were going to offer?
If you were selling a football club would you tell people the price knowing they will try to negotiate?
That said, quite right lets roar those blue boys on
53 Posted 10/09/2011 at 00:12:40
54 Posted 10/09/2011 at 11:56:47
What this comes down to is that their half-arsed attempts to do so (have there actually been any !?) suggests they're not really making much of an effort to do so and In the meantime, our club is fading away. You might be happy for this to happen but some of us would prefer to try and do something about it...
55 Posted 10/09/2011 at 22:19:11
56 Posted 11/09/2011 at 14:50:18
Elstone yes it is the responsibility of the board to do what is right by Evertonians. However, their efforts clearly are not good enough. The problem we have at this club at the moment is the fact that the attitude of those in charge from the board room to the boot room is directly at odds to our club motto. The board haven't done enough to bring positive evolution to the club, and on the field we seldom play to our capabilities. If the board we're doing whats right by the fans then they would step aside if they aren't doing the job, like a player on the field should.
Nil Satis Nisi Optimum.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 08/09/2011 at 19:14:51
We're seeing all the usual Kenwright spin ahead of this protest. Suddenly not 1 but 3 new buyers identified just this week. Probably the same 3 identified when the season tickets went on sale. Then Gray's on the website saying the club needs stability. Is this board really providing stability? Selling first teamers to pay back the banks is not stability.
They're scared, the tide is turning. I really hope thousands turn up on Saturday. Lets see how they put any spin on that.