BU Letter clarifies aims

, 9 September, 18comments  |  Jump to most recent
In an 'Open Letter' addressed to Bill Kenwright, the Blue Union have distanced themselves from the objective of installing an interim board and are instead asking the existing Board of Directors to appoint a group of professionals to secure the sale of the club.

Quotes or other material sourced from Keep Everton in Our City



Reader Comments (18)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


David Thomas
1 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:08:48
If the club is skint then who is going to pay for the "autonomous group of professionals" and who elects them?

Also, how long are this group of professionals given to sell the club, are they given a timescale? We could be paying this group of individuals with money we don't have for years whilst they try to find a buyer?
John Otway
2 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:16:59
David. Make their remuneration performance related. No sale. No fee. I'd like to think that someone like Terry Leahy would do it for the good of his and our club.
Carl Arnold
3 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:22:24
John, wouldnt that be nice of Leahy? Maybe him and Paul McCartney should buy EFC and leave it to be run by BU? Laughable. In fact, no, not laughable, because you actually believe what you're saying.
David Thomas
4 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:25:10
John,

Good luck at finding a group of top professionals who would agree to that deal. I think that you will find they would laugh you out the room if that deal was offered.

Also, is this the TL who has previously been accussed of not giving a toss about the club and was only using Everton to line his own pockets and Tescos on this website and many others?
Simon Harris
5 Posted 09/09/2011 at 16:54:22
David - "Also, how long are this group of professionals given to sell the club, are they given a timescale? We could be paying this group of individuals with money we don't have for years whilst they try to find a buyer?"

Doesn't that series of questions smack of irony?

How much has the club wasted on 2 failed ground moves, park end development, Keith Harris et al..?

The wage bill reduction of Arteta would surely cover the costs and IMO appear a sound investment as Bill obviously needs some help as he's failed miserably thus far, wouldn't you agree?
David Thomas
6 Posted 09/09/2011 at 17:25:08
Simon,

Don't get me wrong the concept from Blue Union looks great on paper.

However, i imagine the money for the Artea deal has already gone to the bank to lower the debt. Therfore, i would envisage that in order to keep the banks of our back in the short term and to pay this professional body of people for an undertermined period of time would mean we would have to offload more players in January.

I mean does this body get say 1 year and then after that they are removed and another body is elected if they have not been successful.

Maybe someone from the blue union could explain in a bit more detail how they see it working?

However, i suppose whose to say that i an ideal world this proposed board don't find us this elusive billionaire on their first day in office. Here's hoping.
Neil Humphreys
7 Posted 09/09/2011 at 17:50:14
I may be wrong, but I think that its an issue of wording. I think they mean for those autonomous professionals to be the board?
In any case, its a well written piece. Did Michael edit it?!
In terms of attracting this level of professionals, its not difficult. Appoint a headhunter and allow them to identify capable individuals. The only concern I have is that the people appointing these executives should be the bank, not the board. Though imperfect, the majority of bankers can infact distinguish between their arses and their elbows....
Alan Williams
8 Posted 09/09/2011 at 18:16:34
Neil, I?m sorry its not well written and it is a complete load of crap, and the truth is BU know it?s a complete load of crap too they are just saying it to burn the fires as most people cant differentiate between BK and the Board. The statement in business terms is complete and utter fantasy and they have no legality or mandate to request such dribble. The more these people issue benign statements the more I really feel what the hell is going on are they run by 18 year olds, seriously BU you need to decide just what it is you want, BK out, no sorry we want interim, oh sorry we don?t want as it?s a legally not required, oh yes how about appointing a group of professionals to sell the club!!! What like the Chairman of Seymour Pierce who has an excellent pedigree and vast amount of experience in this field??? No not him, that BK choice and we want him out, sorry we don?t want him out we want to aid the sale with him!!! Seriously people, protesting that your aren?t happy is totally acceptable in my book but the reason given for this march are preposterous and totally misguided. If you want to look at acumen as some point, look no further than the committee of BU. A massive opportunity has been lost hear for a fans group to actually be part of the club but I?m afraid BU have been guided by the mob. My last question to BU supporters, if you follow the BU constitution or statement then you won?t be able to sing Kenwright Out??? So what the hell are you going to chant tomorrow now??? A good opportunity wasted in my opinion, COYB.
Dennis Stevens
9 Posted 09/09/2011 at 18:50:15
"A massive opportunity has been lost hear (sic) for a fans group to actually be part of the club ..." - has it? Damn, I didn't even get an invitation!
Karl Howard
11 Posted 09/09/2011 at 19:40:08
That clarifies little and is vague at best.

I want improvement in my club, but I can't get behind BU because of how they're conducting their campaign. They're embarrassing themselves and the club. It's just a shame that the club is doing a decent job of embarrassing itself. Childish, the lot of em.

COYB!
Neil Humphreys
12 Posted 09/09/2011 at 19:48:35
Alan,

I think that what they want is the best for the club. Do you honestly believe that the current board are running a tight ship? Will they deliver the success that the customers crave? This is in effect consumer activism if I follow the logic of your arguement, ie, no shares, no mandate, no say.

I'm sorry, but your arguement is flawed by the fact that football clubs are possibly the ultimate example of social enterprise. They live, thrive and die by the support and custom of their fan base directly or indirectly. To say that the fan base have no right to protest when they see pitiful mismanagement and a certain trajectory towards failure is harsh.

We have a well meaning amateur at the helm of the entity that we all love, Everton Football Club. The board have stripped the assets, they have sold players to fund an unworkable business plan and they have repeatedly mismanaged every opportunity to put right what is so obviously wrong. On top of the above, we have a Chairman and CEO who have lied to us. That is the source of my personal anger, they treat their fans/customers with contempt.

The Blue Union are not the ultimate answer, but they are a well meaning and evolving group. The contradictions you point to are part an parcel of that development.

I re-state, in the context of their earlier musings, this letter is well written and their plea for change is valid and polite. I think that you are uncharitable at the very least to label them dribbling fantasists.

Alan Williams
13 Posted 09/09/2011 at 20:27:46
Neil, 300 fans meet and decide an agenda that they want to be allowed to advise or recommend people in to selling their shares that they own worth millions when they have already agreed to sell on block? Mark Jones has just confirmed this on TalkSport! how does that work seriously? its complete fantasy at best. I have always stated that change is needed and fans can play a part but BU have jumped ahead after one week and placed demands without any mandate or even thought to what actually they want. They should have concentrated on getting a larger fan mandate, approached the club to re open dialogue then worked with the board as opposed to against as in simple terms without the board assistance or a spare 100 million then they will get nowhere. You say we should excuse the mistakes in their demands because they are new, evolving, then for that reason they should have held their own council until such time meant they have no other option. This is about the future of the club we all love not the past, i have no issues at all with what the end goal they want as we all want the same but they have made this massive statement and have chosen to make this a national story and take on EFC Ltd, if you make such a statement then you need to have substance, sadly we all know they dont and I genuinely believe they have missed an excellent opportunity. COYB
David Thomas
14 Posted 09/09/2011 at 21:22:51
How exactly does an interim board work? What are the legal issues that it entails etc. Same for this "group of professionals", what are the legal requirements, the cost outlay, who elects them and are their decisions legally binding etc?

Have the Blue Union taken legal advice regading these type of groups and obtained a good understanding of the "ins and outs" of how groups / boards such as the above operate?

With this in mind could someone from the BU please advise what advice / information they were given?

Also, i have read and heard from the BU that this is not a "Kenwright Out" campaign yet from numerous posts on this website alone people are stating they are participating on the protest in order to get "Kenwright out" or to "sack the board" which appears to differ from the explanation on why the protest was organised.

In my opinion the BU are now going to live or die by the outcome of their protest. If they gain significant numbers they may have a platform to build on but they are going to have to start releasing more information on what they are proposing / asking for because at this moment it is a lot of "big" words but very little substance behind it.

I hope this protest has been carefully organised because if it is not structured properly and everyone is not protesting for the same objective then it is going to damage any credibility that the BU may have been able to build up.
Bobby Mallon
15 Posted 09/09/2011 at 21:50:17
David thomas the same people who paid all the money for the kings dock and tesco fiascos
Gavin Ramejkis
16 Posted 09/09/2011 at 22:07:47
Dave Thomas a quick question as your reasoning makes sense but has anyone questioned if Keith Seymour has ever been engaged by the club formally to find a buyer or is it just a favour for BK? If its the latter then do you think he's seriously spending time on it as he's a businessman with his own agenda and business to run, if he is then that answers your question on the club paying someone to find a buyer.

If Keith really is engaged or not the claim of his credentials would make me inclined to say the price must be wrong as he's found other buyers but then again did fuck all for Man Utd which would be a far more attractive proposition.

The use of an interim board who would be tasked with finding suitable buyers with the simple inclusion of a finders fee would get applications, no sale no fee, sale and they get a predetermined percentage of the deal thus incentivising the sale; the higher the deal the better their slice.
Gary Rimmer
17 Posted 09/09/2011 at 22:58:09
Alan Williams excellent post.

Without a answer to the problem. What is there to protest about ? There's much to wish for, a new striker, a few bob, a new owner who loves the club as much as the present one (but has more money).

To protest because no one will by your club ! I really think it be littles us.
I like to think that we'll fight, fight, fight with all our might for the boys in the ROYAL BLUE JERSEY.
ONWARD EVERTONIANS
Colin Fitzpatrick
18 Posted 10/09/2011 at 00:27:24
Is it just me or is Alan Williams getting more and more desperate - "the Chairman of Seymour Pierce who has an excellent pedigree and vast amount of experience in this field" you simply couldn't make this up.
Alan Williams
19 Posted 11/09/2011 at 14:42:15
Colin, your reply just proves my point, do some research on him and you can then see just how pathetic your response is. Im not desperate at all, im concerned like everybody else. this whole thing has been rushed without real thought, there in lies my issue with this, coyb

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads