Two points squandered

, 10 September, 28comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 2 - 2 Aston Villa
A great first half of good attacking football saw Everton go in one goal ahead at the break thanks to an excellent finish by Osman, but Everton sat back increasingly and allowed Villa back into the game, through a Petrov strike after a clear penalty appeal was denied. Everton finally won a penalty that the superb Baines completed and they thought that was game set and match... until Agbonlahor planted an easy header for Villa to draw level again. Finally Moyes bought on a proper striker in Vellios, who showed he knew where the goal was but just could not beat a very good Shay Given. Two points thrown away again by very poor management decisions.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (28)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kevin Elliott
1 Posted 10/09/2011 at 17:28:52
Our game seemed to step up when Drenthe was introduced. Rodwell is absolutely brilliant at sending the ball either over the bar or wide. Can our defense actually pass a ball when under pressure? And why the fuck didn't we play Vellios from the start??? We should have had this one in the bag. I despair.
Richard Dodd
2 Posted 10/09/2011 at 17:47:38
I thought we played very well today and were extremely unlucky to miss out on all three points. Given was truly inspired in the Villa goal with Vellios and Drenthe going very close. Prospects very bright, I feel!
Jay Wilson
3 Posted 10/09/2011 at 17:50:28
Why do you suppose a different team would have played better than the one who started. We played excellently from start to finish and but for some terrible refereeing decisions would and should have won at a canter.
Jimmy Sorheim
7 Posted 10/09/2011 at 17:39:36
I have supported Everton since 95 and I just dont feel like there is anything left to cheer for.

This game was a upturn in terms of playing good football BUT the abysmal decision to not use Vellios from the start cost us; perhaps Denis could have been used here also but no. Same crap different asshole, as Cahill was prefered again in front of Goodison for the scond time running.

No use in saying that Cahill looked out of form, as he clearly is no lone striker kind of guy!

David Moyes's crap tactics are killing off my interest for watching Everton play games. I feel I have had enough of all things Everton as the protests take its toll and the mood with Moyes bad tactics isn't helping at all.

After watching the last seasons failure I belive we are in for more of the same, David Moyes came into this club playing 4-4-2 and the last season was the start of his famously boring 4-5-1 with no strikers upfront. I am exhausted after watching Moyes's tactics these last few years, and I just don't feepbr />I am hurt at losing Arteta and I am not the only one. I just want to say good luck to you BU guys as I take a break from Everton. I wish things were different but the sale of Arteta has taken the fire out of me somehow. Decline is imminent ? off the pitch and now on it.

My wish is to see Moyes out the door, and until such time I will keep away. I have had enough of him!!!

Steve Cotton
8 Posted 10/09/2011 at 18:02:50
after letting the shit house Warnock off for a dreadfull challange from behind the ref looked to try and level the game at every opportunity. he only became impartial once again when Villa equalised..

saying that we could have won at a canter if we had taken our chances.

Thought Drenthe and Velios looked good, Bily was poor but better than he has been. hope springs eternal...
Steve Woods
9 Posted 10/09/2011 at 18:01:20
@ Richard for the very first time I have to agree with you. I thought that from what I saw of the 1st half (only) we looked like a good outfit. Two points dropped, undoubtedly, but we got away with daylight robbery against Blackburn.

The team looked up for it and by and large played well. Villa do seem to be our bogey team. Good to see Coleman back, Vellios given some game time and Drenthe just maybe be good.

Unhappy not getting all 3 points but with the limited squad forced upon us by the inept board (thanks a bunch), if we continue to play the rest of the season in this manner and remain injury free due to lack of options (thanks a bunch to the inept board again), then maybe we will get in to the top ten.

Have my standards dropped? No, Everton FC should never be in the financial position that we are in (thanks very much to BK and the board)
Paul McGinty
10 Posted 10/09/2011 at 17:56:10
One goal leads are always dangerous. The key decision was the non-call on the first penalty which would have made the game safe... assuming it was converted. Our failure to pressure the ball cost us both goals and that's clearly a problem but overall I was encouraged by the performance.

If MKs issue was with the Cahill selection today, granted we will never know how Vellios or Strac would have played over the 90mins, but Cahill made the first goal and was active throughout. Coming on the last 10 against a tired defense is a bit different than playing the first 80.

Given saved the Villa today; we needed Timmy H to make a big save for one of their goals. Everton's performance warranted a win.

John Ford
11 Posted 10/09/2011 at 18:17:54
The anti-moyes focus and jibes in the report are unwarranted and tiresome. He got the team playing well today, after a really diffucult time.

Apart from a short spell in the second half we were well on top, showed good movement and a sense of urgency, and his substitutions maintained that. It was lethargic defending and an untidy defensive fmidfield formation around the box which cost us. This and the continuing need for a top striker.

Lots of positives, but we need to kill sides off. Very frustrating.
Jamie Barlow
12 Posted 10/09/2011 at 18:19:48
" Two points thrown away again by very poor management decisions." What decisions Michael?

I thought we played well today. Felli was amazing throughout and Cahill led the line superb without any help at all off the shite officials. In fact, everyone did alright today and a couple of lapses when we didn't close down quick enough cost us the game.

Howard Don
13 Posted 10/09/2011 at 18:47:52
Agree 100% Jamie (10).

What very poor management decisions??

We looked better balanced than for ages today, all in all you have to take positives from that display.
Jamie Tulacz
14 Posted 10/09/2011 at 18:46:41
Like the previous two posts, that certainly wouldn't have been the lasting impression I took from the game.

Yes frustrating not to get the 3 points, but plenty of positive signs, and I guess just a reversal of the lucky result we had last game. Thought the midfield, and especially Fellaini, stepped up following the loss of Arteta, and looked a better unit based on that game. Positive signs from Vellios and Drenthe who both looked really lively when they came on too.

One slight downside is that at times we looked quite exposed to the counter-attack, by committing too many forward and leaving Distin/Jags exposed on the counter-attack
Michael Kenrick
15 Posted 10/09/2011 at 18:51:51
I disagree. For me, Moyes's failures to act decisively cost us yet again.

It was obvious to a blind man after half-time that the impetus was swinging in Villa's favour and they would in all probability score. Moyes dithered, as only he can. They scored, and suddenly our winning position is sacrificed. His failure to read the game and act BEFORE THEY SCORED was nothing short of criminal.

From there, it seemed certain we would not win, even when we got the penalty. And indeed we had to wait to the last 20 minutes before Moyes bought on players who showed real signs of being able to secure us a win... IF THEY HAD BEEN GIVEN MORE TIME ON THE FIELD.

Astounding to me that Evertonians are happy with that result. Yes, we played a lot better for much of the game, but Moyes squandered the win by thinking (as he always does) that a one-goal lead is sufficient.
John Malone
16 Posted 10/09/2011 at 18:45:27
Jimmy Shoreheim!!!! We played well today really well! We had a good go and created loasds of chances and on a different day could have scored five. Cahill led from the front never stopped battling, setup the first goal and had a header cleared off the line!! I'm sick to the back teeth of going the match and people moaning and being negative before we've kicked a ball. I walked away today feeling ten times better than I did against QPR. Granted we never won but we should have, credit should be given for a good performance and not unfair unwarranted criticism.

Baines and Felli top performers!
Ray Robinson
17 Posted 10/09/2011 at 19:01:49
Richard Dodd, you have outdone even yourself today? Talk about spinning! Did you actually go to the match? In what way was Given inspired today? A good performance today from the lads but what precisely did Given do that was inspired? I can't remember him being worked hard at all!
Chris Smith
18 Posted 10/09/2011 at 19:43:02
I thought Cahill did well and we looked a good side today. Clearly we won't win the league but I think we can find strength in adversity.
Robin Cannon
19 Posted 10/09/2011 at 20:17:12
It was a shame how Vellios didn't have the maturity to look up and play Osman in to score in the first half, and how Drenthe looked so good at the start of the game and tired badly in the second because of his lack of first team practice. Also, it was clear during the game that playing two strikers had left us a little short in midfield, there was a real opportunity to dominate that area and give our wide players the chance to push forward, but only having two in the middle gave Villa the chance to get a foothold on possession.

Oh...wait...
Mark Wayman
20 Posted 10/09/2011 at 20:02:54
Incredibly frustrated after that result.

I thought all the players did well today - except Bily, although he was better than usual. Drenthe made a good first impression.

When we were on top we harried and hassled Villa and made them look poor. It was when we sat back and let them come on to us that we had problems. There was some good passages of play, and some through balls that a pacy striker would surely have taken advantage of. We could have been 5-0 up before their first equaliser, and that isn't an exaggeration.

The atmosphere was tremendous throughout. The referee was atrocious throughout.

There were definitely positive signs from today, but still frustrated. I hate that Villa!
Harvey Miller
21 Posted 10/09/2011 at 19:33:23
Michael is right: Moyes wasted the two points by not acting when Villa started pushing forward. He always waits too long before making changes, usually he does not do anything before other team scores.
Cahill played well, but he's not a striker and he sure as hell is not a lone striker. Only a fool would play a midfielder in that position.
Rodwell was bad as usual and should have substituted at halftime. I'm beginning to loose faith in him, seems like he is not going to make it big time. Barkley should have started instead of him.
I would have wanted to see Strac given a chance but of course it didn't happen. He'll be lucky if he plays even as much as Gueye played last season. He will play some part during the season because we just don't have strikers but Moyes will probably try everybody else in attack rather than play an untried striker. That way he won't have any match practise and when he finally gets his chance and fails, Moyes can say he was right not to have played him.
We didn't play "really well today", we played ok. Villa was poor. It just felt so much better because our first two games were utter crap from us.
By the way, the ref was awful, he gave all 50/50 balls to Villa, even the pundits on tv noticed that.
Jon Cox
22 Posted 10/09/2011 at 20:21:19
As a lot of people have mentioned the Blackburn game, the one we shouldn't have won, I think it ties in nicely with todays game.

At the end of the season it wont matter that we played shite at Blackburn and played really well today. What will matter is the fact that at Blackburn we gained three points and today we lost two at home.

We are in a result based business and I for one am not happy with droping two points.

It's the same old same old. If the new lads weren't up to scratch to start the game then how come they were good enough to come on in the second half.

Are people saying they'd be happy with that starting line up every week and have the lads who came on just polishing the bench. I'll wager if we'd have had another fifteen minutes at the end we would have scored.

All i'm asking is that players play in their rightful position and stop having a midfielder leading the line. Too many times today we were stretched, too many times balls were pumped into the box only for us not to jump on the second ball thus giving Villa the counter attacking advantage. I'm sorry but Moyes makes too many mistakes for me and costs us too many dropped points.

The amount of times the ball was given away only to come straight back at us was criminal. The ball hoofed up to Cahill was never going to be the answer. Cahill's goals from his head never come from that particular tactic anyway.

I dont think Moyes will ever learn and will leave us frustated time and time again.

So until the next game......
Per Anders Todal
23 Posted 10/09/2011 at 22:29:58
The negativity on this board ? and in most of the Toffeeweb match reports as well ? is baffling at times. Everton played very well today, we dominated the match completely, and the media reports I have read agree that Villa were very lucky to get away with a point. But the Toffeeweb match report tells me about "Two points thrown away again by very poor management decisions." I am sorry, but that is nonsense.
Mark Dunford
24 Posted 10/09/2011 at 23:02:42
So far this season ? we've lost a game we should have won, taken three points from a second we looked like losing and drawn a third we dominated. We've yet to play one of the best teams but reports agree the performance was far better today. We all know there is no money in the pot and the squad is tiny.

Difficult to know what to make of it but ? I agree with Per ? the relentless negativity on the site is baffling and wearing. No one is trying to destroy the club. Toffeeweb is a really valuable forum and more considered criticism would improve the position for all of us.

Michael Kenrick
25 Posted 10/09/2011 at 23:39:39
Look, it's fairly simple. Moyes is in his chosen job, well paid, working with the tools he has selected. The transfer window is over, so bleating about lack of money, small squad, blah de blah, has to stop at this point; I'm sure he would agree that they all have to buckle down and do their best with what they have.

And that's the test: are they all doing their best with what they have? Most of the players did well today, especially the excellent Baines ? I think every single corner was top drawer... (Who was that Spanish bloke again?) and of course the penalty was perfect.

But, given the players he had, I don't think Moyes played his best hand in the second half. As usual, we sat back both at 1-0 and 2-1. Rather than taking the initiative and carrying the game to Villa, we let them back in.

Unfortunately, it's Moyes to a tee. He adamantly believes in the merits of defence, so when you have a goal advantage you keep shape, you drop back and defend, rather than play more risky, more expansive football going forward. And... instead of scoring more goals than the opposition... you don't. End of.
Andy Peers
26 Posted 10/09/2011 at 23:52:10
We scored 2 goals without a striker on the pitch so Moyes will always remember that and think his tactics were correct. The problem is that Villa were there for the taking and playing a striker and taking off Bily at half-time would have been better.

I would actually like to have seen Vellois and Straq on at the half for Bily and Cahill and Barkley or Drenthe on for Rodwell. Drenthe looked promising and think he should start in future to build a relationship with Baines. Baines will make him a good player just like he made Pienaar. By the way, what happened to his career lately?

Jamie Barlow
27 Posted 11/09/2011 at 00:10:15
Andy, why would you change a team that dominated the first half? You just don't do it.

Maybe Michael is right and he did dither a bit but if I'm right, we really should have had a penalty and Jags should have scored just before they equalized so we were still playing alright at the time and should have been two or even three up.

It's all about opinions and seeing different things though and Moyes would have been slated if he'd have made a substitution and then they scored as he did with Barkley and I didn't hear one person disagree with that one at the time. He could and maybe should have took Coleman off and brought Neville on instead of Barkley but then that would be too negative wouldn't it?
John Ford
28 Posted 11/09/2011 at 00:42:10
We didnt 'sit back' at anytime today. We did our best to get forward and create chances.

We didnt 'drop back' and defend which is evidenced by the fact that Villa hardly had a shot all game. We dominated for most of the match and had a nailed on penalty shout denied. Suggestions to the contrary just dont stack up. Mark @21 is spot on, the negativity really is becoming wearing.

Paul McGinty
29 Posted 11/09/2011 at 00:46:07
MK 22, I too am disappointed at just the point. But if we were sitting back at 1-0, what the hell is our left back doing dribbling deep into Villas penalty error for what I thought was the missed penalty call. I don't think we sat back at 2-1 either, or 2-2 for that matter. I get it loud and clear you don't rate the manager.
Jarod Avila
30 Posted 11/09/2011 at 01:22:12
@Jimmy (#4) - times get frustrating and you decide that it's all too hard and that you need to "take a break"? Pathetic!! Nobody with blue blood flowing through their veins could ever walk away from this club, even if they were relegated all the way to the Conference. *If* you really mean what you say, then you were never a true blue to begin with. Good riddance.
Mick Davies
31 Posted 11/09/2011 at 06:06:17
Two home games and one point from both. If this carries on that's relegation form. To play with no strikers at home is a disgrace. Selling our top scoring striker on deadline day is a disgrace, what other manager would do that? Selling one our most influential players on d.d. without a replacement is ridiculous. Playing Tony Hibbert and not Neville was stupidity. How many goals does Hibbert have to cost us before he never gets another game? The cross for their winner was Hibbo at his best. .5 yards away and just sticks his leg up like a can can dancer. Moyes needs someone to advise him about tactics. He was a defender, Round was a defender, Stubbs too and now he's trying to get Weir back on the coaching staff and Neville is already helping out in preparation for his retirement. No wonder we have no strikers, no one knows what to do with them

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads