The solution could hardly be clearer

, 12 September, 91comments  |  Jump to most recent
The Blue Union have released a statement to the media saying they were pleased with the many Evertonians who attended a pre-match demonstration on Saturday that sent a clear message to the club?s hierarchy: enough is enough, it?s time for change. In the statement, they recap some of the key issues that have become obscured over the weekend, and reiterate that their proposed solution could not be clearer: bring in a group of professionals to push through the sale of the club to an appropriate buyer.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Blue Union



Reader Comments (91)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Byrne
1 Posted 12/09/2011 at 07:40:18
Good idea to hire somebody to find a buyer for the club. Good idea if Blue Union finance the people to find a buyer for the club.

Everton Football Club is broke we know this as fact. So I think the smart people at Blue Union should pay for these people to find a buyer. Bill has said he has taken no money out of the club for years so let the biggest whiners and whingers pay to find a buyer if they are so damb smart.

Peter Murphy
2 Posted 12/09/2011 at 07:47:00
I agree with the aims of Blue Union but I think fans need to be careful not to alienate staff and players. Cahill was obviously upset post match on the BBC. Maybe that was the case with Pip too, perhaps the surly face on the bench was not just because he had been dropped.

Bill Kenwright is an Evertonian like us, hopefully he will do what is best for the club he loves and find a buyer that is right for the club and does not just view us as a franchise.

Russ Quinlan
3 Posted 12/09/2011 at 08:06:06
I'm amazed at how many Blues are so gullible to believe that the status quo is good enough.

You obviously don't have the same ambitions as the rest of us if you're happy to see stagnation.

All the BU are doing are bringing the plight of the club to the public domain instead of just Forums and I applaud them.

At least its getting metioned in the Press and TV now and if it forces BK to get his arse into gear and bring investment in then they have done their job.

Why all this bad feeling against fellow Blues who just want to see action is beyone me.

I've supported Everton for over 50 years so I feel entitled to my views and I'm sure the BU and all thsoe involved have the same right of freedom of speech, after all it has been our money that kept the Club going over all these years.

When Agent Johnstone was ousted, I don't remember the same split, I'm not saying BK is the same but I am saying we are all entitlted to our views and how we react to the Club stagnating. That demo against AJ was the catalyst for a new regime which saw BK come in, maybe its just time he now let someone else play with his trainset because loving the Club doesnt give him the right to see it decline.

Time to let go Bill and make everyone see how much you do love the Club by bringing in decent (not Gillionaires) investment that the Club is crying out for.



Alan Williams
4 Posted 12/09/2011 at 08:55:58
I have said this before mainly last week, sadly nobody wins in this situation and I clapped BK too because I felt as a fan I had to make a statement but it wasn?t about supporting BK more to make BU aware that you don?t represent me in your current form. This whole protest was totally misguided by the BU committee and their constitution is so weak and is business fantasy at its best. EFC fans have or had an opportunity to use this to aid the club but they chose to take on the Board and EFC Ltd which is a massive mistake. They should have consolidated after the first public meeting and looked to increases in some form a fans mandate that could have allowed a fans action group to be a positive move for everybody. They used the passion from the public meeting to march on the club and in doing so have lost whatever mandate possible, short term. BU need to bring the fan base back together if they want longevity, first thing in my opinion they must do is be realistic in your demands and asking the majority of shareholders to appoint people to sell their shares that aren?t necessary their choice, well I?m sorry is just naïve and so weak that it completely undermines the BU before it starts. BU in my opinion is a good idea but it firstly needs to change its name to a less political group and start looking more like a fans co-operative as apposed to a Union, then look at getting support from the terraces as apposed to drawing a battle line with the Board. Once the former grows then the board will have to talk with you on a constructive note. This current form of action makes people chose a side when realistically that?s doesn?t need to be the case if you just have a little more panache with your criticism. COYB
Tom Hughes
5 Posted 12/09/2011 at 08:56:51
Alan, the club has been run into the ground..... this not fantasy but fact. This board has delivered NOTHING but failure after failure..... all conveniently camouflaged by a manager living off scraps. Selling to buy has become selling to survive. If PJ had presided over half of this lots mishapsthere would've been snipers behind every grassy knoll from park foods to the park end. The business model..... the strategy for the future is non-existent...... and yet you clapped because you don't like the name of the blue union? What about the real issues.... ie the diabolical running of EFC?
Ben Dyke
6 Posted 12/09/2011 at 10:06:45
I support the BU and they are asking all the right questions but I believe there should be no more marches and no more public 'spats' with employees of Everton via the press.

Tim Cahill and the player's are making it very clear what they feel and I think the BU risk creating a huge schism within the fanbase and with the players and staff.

I dont believe in blindly accepting all that is going on at Everton and I feel let down by Bill (particularly over Kings Dock - dont really care about other stuff), but I think any more pressure applied wrongly by the BU will have an adverse effect on things on the pitch, which at the end of day (good footy cliche!) is all we all care about.

A good win against the Reds soon and we will all feel better.
Alan Clarke
7 Posted 12/09/2011 at 10:08:32
Alan, it's misguided blaming the Blue Union for the split in the fan base. The split has come as a result of Kenwright and Ian Ross' underhand tactics in the media.

Everything is not rosey inside Goodison and that fact needs highlighting to a lot of fans who still believe it is. TBU have done that. TBU are not political, they just know the club is heading in the wrong direction and they're willing to speak up about it. If we all sit around doing nothing or even clapping Kenwright, it is support for everything Kenwright and his board are doing. How can you not care about where the club is heading?
Martin Mason
8 Posted 12/09/2011 at 10:26:47
And now the discussion is descending into a dialoguee of the deaf with neither side doing any listening. The protesters want change but don't know to what. The conservatives want the same ends but not with such radical change and then only justifiable change. We even have the totally ridiculous assertion now that the non-protestors are gullible and how can we tolerate the "failures" that we've been forced to suffer in recent years.
Colin Fitzpatrick
9 Posted 12/09/2011 at 10:38:28
Peter # 2 "Cahill was obviously upset post match on the BBC."

He, wasn't; this was all planned during the week, statements written by others, Samuel in the Mail, Andy Gray wheeled out etc - now that it wasn't just a few hundred, they couldn't all fit into Goodison Rd as the photographs show - they'll be having a rethink.

You have to laugh at Alan Williams attempting to give advice - the Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf of TW lol
Tom Hughes
10 Posted 12/09/2011 at 10:39:11
Martin........ can you list this board's successes and achievements in ensuring that the manager has had all the funds he's needed to make EFC successful? Perhaps a list of the dramatic infrastructure improvements that might have increased revenue streams? Practically every other club's board.... even very modest ones have achieved and contributed more than BK and Co.. we now have the smallest squad in the league and have had the lowest net spend of all clubs throughout their tenure...... Saturday was the lowest saturday-league-gate in 9yrs .. are you listening?
Johnny Rainford
11 Posted 12/09/2011 at 11:08:18
Martin, the protestors DO know what needs to be done... The commissioning of an independant group of professional people to find a buyer for the club. Kenwright has had 11 years to sort this out and done NOTHING.

Ffs why is noone listening!
Dennis Stevens
12 Posted 12/09/2011 at 10:54:35
The most telling thing, for me, is that there has been no response from the Board to show how wrong BU are. No listing of the Board's achievements, no indication of the Board's plans for the future well-being of our club. All we hear is that Kenwright is keen to sell to the right buyer, at the right price of course, & also pathetic attempts to portray the Board as victims of circumstance rather than the incompetent buffoons they really are by wittering on about how well we've done 'under the circumstances'. It's true that, despite his limitations, Moyes has done very well with what he's been given, but who knows how well the club may have fared if the Board were performing.

Over the last decade or so, Evertonians have been incredibly tolerant of successive failures & the many lies that have accompanied them. However, as it becomes ever more apparent that the very manner in which Everton is being run places the club in jeopardy, the tide has turned. It will soon become a flood.

It's imperative that supporters maintain the pressure on the Board to facilitate change. Ideally, for them to sell up to people who are interested in running the club properly, as I think the point is now long past when we can expect anything constructive from the Board. At the moment we seem to have a Board who, apart from the Chairman, appear to have very little interest in the club.
Amit Vithlani
13 Posted 12/09/2011 at 11:19:56
Congratulations to the BU for organising a peaceful march, and for raising the profile of the troubles the club has. Our stagnation has been clear for a while, and the hierarchy at the club have succeeded in dismantling outlets of protest - AGM, Media Spin etc.

Although I respect the opinions of those who support BK, I dont understand why.

It is not a matter of opinion that the club is in deep trouble. Look at our financials, the rising debt, and the failure to find means of increasing off the pitch sources of revenues, and you dont need to be a genius to work out that the status quo is unsustainable.

Selling players is a short term solution and may not be enought to pay off all out liabilities anyway. Instead, we will be left with falling attendances, lower TV income and less prize money.

The situation is critical and the more time that is wasted without a viable plan being implemented to return the club to financial stability (which can include plans B and C to appoint a professional board to sell the club and / or seek minority investment, or a reconstruction with the banks), the deeper our problems.
Danny Broderick
14 Posted 12/09/2011 at 11:28:41
Congratulations to the BU, the issue of our under-performing board is well and truly out there now. We even got a mention on Match of the Day. At the very worst, this will put a bit of pressure on the board to pull their finger out and find a buyer. They need to sell the club a bit more aggressively then they have so far demonstrated. One thing's for sure, it will be interesting to see what we do in the next few transfer windows. If we get more of the same, the BU's numbers will swell even further. It is certainly mission accomplished in terms of getting 'media attention', again a big well done.
Dave Roberts
15 Posted 12/09/2011 at 10:34:26
Many of the names now associated with the Blue Union are the same as those associated with or who strongly supported KEIOC during the stadium debate. KEIOC were partially effective despite their occasional incompetence during their argument with the club over destination Kirkby. They were successful in the sense that they got their way although it was not their arguments that swayed the government but those of the neighbouring local authorities. I lost any respect I may have had for KEIOC when they chose to employ those selfsame arguments against a move to Kirkby , as well as concerns of Kirkby residents about hooliganism, when their only concern as supporters should have been offering their view about the location of a stadium solely with regard to the future of the club and not the footfall losses of neighbouring shopping areas or unfounded fears of hooliganism on Kirkby resident's doorsteps.

Nevertheless, KEIOC (who now form a wing of the Blue Union) claimed victory but it was Pyrrhic in the extreme. Since keeping the club in the city the financial situation has greatly deteriorated (which was predictable and predicted) and nothing of any meaningful value has come from KEIOC since, nor from Liverpool City Council which was once held up by KEIOC as a possible route to a new stadium within the city. Since then....nothing.

Whatever the views of individual Evertonians concerning the move to Kirkby and whatever the faults within the plan, it was amongst other things an attempt to make the club more saleable and/or more tempting for investment. The lack of a new stadium has reinforced the fact to any potential buyers that Everton Football Club is not an attractive investment for anybody looking to put their money into a football club, especially as there are a lot less people about these days who are looking to do that, given the disastrous and current economic climate.

Now that the stadium debate is over and no plans for a new or renovated stadium are extant or affordable, exactly what would be the purpose of bringing in professionals to sell the club when there are no buyers? In this respect, the Blue Union is demonstrating the same sort of kneejerk short sightedness as KEIOC. They have a view of the future but it is only their view and does not take account of the bigger picture. On recent threads, supporters of the Blue Union have now begun to diminish the importance of the stadium at all in the future of the club when not so long ago the stadium was the most important aspect of all. It just does not make sense.

The Blue Union and the rest of us have to consider the longer term prospects and possible repercussions of everything they and we propose rather than just a consideration and demand for the next step whatever the perceived 'next step' is. They have to learn to ask 'and then what?'.

First it was keep Everton in our city. But then what?

Now it is change the board or bring in professionals.

AND THEN WHAT?
Gavin Ramejkis
16 Posted 12/09/2011 at 11:57:19
Dave a very best case scenario if Kirkby ever had gone ahead would have been an additional £78m of debt on the club and a stadium with very poor access which would in turn have created reduced attendance thus making the increased debt very hard to service. Kirkby had no redeeming features at all unless it was from a major shareholder perspective looking to agree a sale of their shares, that isn't beneficial to the club just the seller and buyer.

KEIOC have never been against the departure of Everton Football Club from Goodison Park if the new site was one which was appropriate, Kirkby simply wasn't appropriate on any front whatsoever.

In terms of the interim board if charged with finding a buyer(s) for the club then surely people of that calibre could work for a finders fee as I've mentioned on another post on this site. We are talking of a multimillion pound deal and even a small percentage would make a handsome return for some hard work.
Martin Mason
17 Posted 12/09/2011 at 11:53:23
Dave Roberts - Exactly. We are a club in decline relative to the top clubs and have been since the start of the premiership. We are a poor brand and a dreadful buy for anybody and there is not one guarantee or even reasonable probability that simply changing the board, or unrealistically asking them to cede power (why should they?), will change anything. All that is happening now is that we have no money to spend on new players and have reached our debt limit so unless a benefactor comes along the club will have to run on its current business model wherever that may take us. No change of ownership will alter this unless someone can find a way of making Everton a commercial attraction and how? Despite this we have been successful in that all clubs will define success as staying in the Premiership, in fact we have done done very well considering what we've spent. We can't compete with sides with money from benefactors or massive world following like United. Even with a wedge of money to spend improvement isn't guaranteed. I love the idea of Everton running a club as a business should be run and being successful despite being a small club (as we are now) , successful in developing our own youngsters and buying cheap on the fringes and developing these buys. I don't want Everton to be a City or Chelski, they are a joke. I hold my hand up to United though.

I say again the BU has no credible solutions given the reality of the situation we are in. I'll fully support them when they come up with some.

Look at the success of recent buyouts. Birmingham relegated, Blackburn bottom of the league, Portsmouth history, West Ham relegated, Liverpool just as bad despite two takeovers and massive spending. How the club is run long term that is the solution not short term injection of funds.
Phil Martin
18 Posted 12/09/2011 at 11:56:51
Dave,

I couldnt disagree more. Dest. Kirkby was unfit for purpose. How can you possible suggest we should've moved our great club into that situation just because our current board aren't ambitious enough to do things properly? DK was more about Tesco, Kenwright, Earl and Wyness getting their payday than finding EFC a viable long term home. I'm sure you dont need reminding about how indaquate the entire scheme was.
You also fail to acknowledge that clubs have been bought and sold long before this financial crisis and we are told Bill has been looking 24/7 ever since taking over. So you believe clubs like Villa, Blackburn, QPR, Sunderland, Wolves are all better investments than Everton?
Yes KEIOC haven't always been 100% professional - but they are just fans who care enough to take on an executive board of a football club -ALL in their spare time. Most of these guys are normal fellas who don't run large companies or have extensive experience in media relations
The club has been grossly mis-managed, the current board's relationship with the fans is at breaking point. Let's not pretend pressure groups like BU and KEIOC are responsible for this, or Everton's current plight. They serve to highlight and protest against specific issues which need to be addressed.
I've read some ridiculous comments on other threads today, saying that BU should fund an interim board. Fuck's sake get real!

To anyone who feels Kenwright, Elstone and Ross are the best men for EFC then so be it. For those who believe there are better operators who could be doing a lot more with the 4th most successful cub in England. Then we should demonstrate our disapproval with the 'sell to survive' strategy they now employ (and ask us to swallow).
Alan Williams
19 Posted 12/09/2011 at 12:34:16
Tom, you can?t change the past but you can the future, the board own EFC whether you like it or not and unless you have their blessing to aid or assist then you have no real opportunity here. The board have agreed to sell, the job is done, it?s about finding the correct buyer that will make all of us happy, and we all want the same. BU is confrontational and there in lies the problem, you and all the ?anti Brigade? have to move on from DK and look ahead, its not easy I grant you but its about what the future holds for all of us and fighting with the current custodians achieves nothing as they are not the future of our club. TW is littered about what has or hasn?t gone on, be progressive and included everybody; it?s the only way this can work. BU needs to embrace all Evertonians and it should have spent its efforts in getting a fans mandate before such action but by doing so you have done exactly what the board done with DK, split the fan base. If done properly fans co-operative could be a real positive move for everybody. COYB
Victor Johnson
20 Posted 12/09/2011 at 12:10:37
Gavin17,
If, as you say, DK had no redeeming features (other than to benefit existing shareholders), why state that it would have burdened those same shareholders with an additional £78m without bringing with it any future growth potential?
Either a completed DK would have represented an attractive investment - ie it would have made EFC more saleable, or not - i.e to be avoided (thus leaving said shareholders with a huge headache).
To argue both the flawed investment line and the cynical enrichment line at the same time is mischievous at best.
Maybe in your opinion BK is not only a useless 'luvvie' but a masochistic one to boot.
Peter Laing
21 Posted 12/09/2011 at 13:08:51
The only person to gain from Destination Kirkby was a Mr Philip Green. We would have been a laughing stock had that gone through, imagine playing at the 'Topman' arena.
Tom Hughes
22 Posted 12/09/2011 at 12:50:52
Dave, no-one has presented such a cock-eyed view of destination kirkby and indeed KEIOC since the hairbrain scheme was kicked into touch 4 yrs ago. Ask yourself this simple question..... how come the club didn't still build the thing anyway? The enabling package that was supposed to pay for the whole thing delivered next to nothing in anycase..... so what was stopping them(they only lost approx £10-12m without the shops)? Could it have been the withering effects of a discredited public transport plan that was threatening to limit the capacity dramatically? KEIOC highlighted the serial lies and defficiencies..... and in the end the club dropped the hot potato at the very first opportunity. I wonder why. Why aren't you asking why the club didn't then commission a design competition to look at what can be done at GP as well as accepting the planning departments invitation to look at footprint expansion......... indeed why wasn't it done before we even embarked on moving out of town to a poor quality stadium to a site that cannot support it? Mistake after mistake after mistake..... and none of it the fault or ordinary Evertonians
Alan Williams
23 Posted 12/09/2011 at 13:38:03
Please lets move on from DK, it doesnt help out current situation. We need to look forward not backwards. COYB
Colin Fitzpatrick
24 Posted 12/09/2011 at 12:28:29
Dennis #13 ? you?re on the money there, the response from Kenwright is indeed ?Kenwright is keen to sell to the right buyer?, which is about as much use as saying I?m keen to win the Euro Lottery on Friday.

Dave Roberts #16, well done if that was an attempt on the world record for writing a statement which contained the most factual inaccuracies ? I think Guinness will be in touch very soon; mind you, you?ve got stiff competition from Ian Ross writing Robert Elstone?s blogs lol

Martin # 18 ? What are you going on about? We are a poor brand, why? We are a dreadful buy for anyone, why? We have no money to spend, why? We have reached our debt limit, why? There?s a common factor here, you appear to be missing it, who are the people responsible for all of this and more?

Without change the inevitable will happen, we?ll join those clubs you?ve listed. People naturally fear change, change needs to be managed and the track record of this board in managing anything is abysmal, since Kirkby we?ve managed to hand Bellefield over to the bank, lock, stock and barrel, Moyes hasn?t had a penny to invest in our squad and as for the Park End? What an embarrassment, the chairman thinks it?s an insurance problem, the village idiot thinks it?s about being unable to move a few desks and a computer, the fans liaison officer thinks it?s because two of the partners have had a falling out and the CEO has told everyone it?s a complex legal problem; why don?t they just come clean?
Steve Ferns
25 Posted 12/09/2011 at 13:29:29
Well said Martin. Why should a cash strapped club waste money on trying to find a buyer when there are no decent buyers out there? No one in their right mind will want to hand over a large amount of money to buy the club, pay off debts, consider buying a new ground and investing in the playing staff.

I see Everton at the moment as a decaying stately home. The maintenance costs are horrendous. House prices wavering and it is more than possible that the market may cash and suddenly the house could be worth much less than what you bought it for. Meanwhile, we can't get planning permission to build that new swimming pool we want, or the fancy new extension, or any other idea we come up with to up the value of the property.

The only buyers looking are those who want to bulldose the home and sell off the land for more fancy apartments.

End of metaphor. I'm not saying there will be no buyer, but this is not the time for someone to invest in Everton. The price of football clubs are too high. Look carefully at the signs. The premier league's boom time is over. Football is about to wake up and smell the coffee, that is falling prices on TV deals, reduced gate receipts, reduced revenue for shirt sales and accross the board generally.

Football is about to feel the full force of the global recession and as the recession kicks harder (taking the UK back into another one technically - although I believe we never left it) Everton's revenues and prices will tumble.

Who in their right mind would invest in a football club in the current economic climate? And all this drum banging about the club's finances is akin to the neighbour informing the potential buyer of the stately home about the damp in the drawing room. The buyer then feels less inclined to meet the price and the seller may not wish to lower their price accordingly.

All in all, let's forget that whilst we treat Everton like a religion or a cult, it is not. Kenwright is not our leader. He's the figurehead of a group that owns a business. He proclaims to be a true blue and that he may be. Nethertheless, the group owns the business and we cannot force them to sell or dictate the price. If we really want them to sell highlighting the problems with the club is not going to help in the slightest.

Furthermore, why is everyone so sure that a new owner would be so much better than the current regime. It can't be any worse can it, most of you cry. It bloody well could be, just ask fans of all the other clubs taken over in recent times (man city apart), I would rather have BK than Carsten Young or the porn kings at West Ham.
Colin Fitzpatrick
26 Posted 12/09/2011 at 13:43:36
Oh and Tom [#23] yes let's leave DK alone, as all it does is reveal the total ineptitude of the people who have delivered failure after failure, the people who now expect a return on their investment because that?s just the way it is.

Let?s look to the future let?s talk about something positive, let?s talk about the Park End......
Colin Fitzpatrick
27 Posted 12/09/2011 at 13:50:34
Steve Ferns #26 - "No one in their right mind will want to hand over a large amount of money to buy the club, pay off debts, consider buying a new ground and investing in the playing staff."

What about handing over a small amount of money? How much do you think Everton is worth? Let's face it the business has been run into the ground, they?ve been unable to control costs, the stadium is falling to pieces, gates are on a slippery slope, we?re selling players and assets; why should those that Bill "speaks for" get a ROI?
Steve Ferns
28 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:01:02
Take emotion out of it for a second COlin. I know we cannot really believe everything that BK says, but there must be some element of truth to "I put every penny I had" bollocks into Everton. If so, we should he AND the group he represents walk away from the company they own having made a resounding loss. The others in his group Earl and the other silent slimy so and sos will not allow such a thing to happen. How much does BK actually own, I can't remember the figure off the top of my head but doesn't he own about a third of true blue holdings who in turn own about two thirds of Everton FC limited. But that's a wild guess at the old failing memory so don't hold me to it!

And as for why should they get a return on investment (I presume) because they own a company and that is their right, and whatever anyone thinks we cannot take that away from them.
Paul O'Hanlon
29 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:01:40
Getting back to the BU march on Saturday, I was heartened to see so many blues turn out. I was worried that some of my fellow blues may be all talk and no action, but that certainly wasn't the case. 1,000 for a football protest march is a high number (more than double what Sons of Shankly managed and look what they achieved?) .

The key now is getting other blues on board and the only way BU can do that is by improving their relations in the media. A lot of fans (not all) are still swayed by what they read in the local press and that's where I feel the BU need to focus on. Although the fact that Goodison officials have already banned a number of journalists this year for speaking out will make that a very difficult task.
Martin Mason
30 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:01:29
Colin

All of what you say has happened to Everton but the current board hasn't necessarily been the cause of all of it. Their fault has been to try to keep the illusion of Everton as a big club going when we passed the threshold to smalldom a long time ago. The true value of Everton is around zero but BK wants at least 100 mil. that is his prerogative, it's his toy and while you can ask hime to do what you want with it you can't demand that he does although he may eventually feel threatened enough to do something.

Steve Ferns, that is very well put. That is exactly where Everton are. In a few years we'll settle to our real level when we have sold players to meet cash flow necessities. That probably means partial dismantling of the expensive element of the current squad and reliance on a team that will be paid a maximum of say 30k a week. Where will we level out at? I don't know but I would hope that we can stay in the Premiership. We aren't the only team who will be hit though so perhaps the majority will come down to our level. Whatever, changing the board now will be like shuffling the deckchairs on the Titanic. We've already hit the iceberg,
Dennis Stevens
31 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:07:19
I have to disagree with you, Steve. Kenwright & the rest of the Board have had plenty of time to get a return on their investment through the value they've 'added' to Everton. If that value 'add' turns out to be negative then tough titty. It doesn't need the efforts of BU to lower the value of the club, the Board have been doing that for a decade. As our ability to compete or even survive in the top flight diminishes & gates drop correspondingly, so will the value of the club diminish - it won't require any effort on the part of BU. If the main shareholders are holding out for much more than trying to get their original investment back I think they're making a big mistake & the longer they hold out the lower the price they may have to accept will become. If the efforts of BU serve to underline the reality of our current plight to both supporters & Board members, hopefully it will lead to finding ways to address the situation & start to move forward, as currently there appears to be a serious lack of engagement on the part of our Board.
Paul O'Hanlon
32 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:19:48
Martin, some of your points are correct. We haven't been a big club in a long time (I've had a season ticket for 21 years now and never seen us even challenge for a league title!).

But...(and I know this going over old ground but it's relevant as to why I and others feel the way we do) BK had the chance to turn this great club of ours around with Kings Dock. He may not of had the money required and he may not have been able to borrow it, but as he said himself in the interview with BU "the only way to raise the money was to sell the whole caboodle. Kings Dock was really seriously world class". He was right, it was "seriously World Class" so why was it asking too much for him to "sell the whole caboodle"? Was the future of his beloved Everton Football Club not important enough for him to relenquish control?

That's why we are where we are.
Steve Ferns
33 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:29:05
But Dennis, it is their company and they can take as long as they want to sell it and there is not a jot any can do about it. It is up to them if they sell, for how much and to whom. Whether we like it or not, we cannot force them to sell for a certain price. It's their choice.
Paul O'Hanlon
34 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:44:31
Isn't that the point of the BU Steve, to put pressure on them to sell? Isn't that the point of all protest groups?
Dennis Stevens
35 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:35:37
Force them Steve? No, of course not. But will pressure from supporters sharpen their focus a little, perhaps? It is their company, but we're the only ones putting any money into it - that won't continue indefinitely if they persist with their present strategy for 'success'.

Alternatively we can patiently wait whilst they try to line up DK Mk II - as far as I can see that remains their exit strategy. I doubt it'll be any better the next time 'round, & we'll have to fight that same battle all over again.
Colin Fitzpatrick
36 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:49:51
Steve [29] He may have mortgaged his house sold Uncle Cyril?s bike, Eddie Cavanagh?s coat and borrowed off Elvis to get those shares but none of that money ever went into the club as he?s just made a private investment for Bill Kenwright.

That's not me talking, that's our CEO. Now I may be disappointed in Robert, I bet he's gutted at that, but I've met him enough times to know he plays with a fairly straight bat unlike the rest of them; he told the public inquiry that none of the current board of directors have ever invested a single penny into the club.

I'm not talking about walking away with nothing Steve, I'm asking what the price should be? There's no right to getting a return on your investment as far as I'm aware; you make an investment you take a risk, that investment could be good, it could be bad.

If you?re stupid enough to park your £20k car on Crosby shore and it gets stuck for a week, what would you think anyone would give you for it after 14 tides had wrecked it? £19K. £10k, £50, 50p? Do you think you'd get £19k?

You know what I?m saying; we?ve heard that all these buyers that have come along, Bill doesn?t know why it hasn?t been sold, Robert doesn?t know why it hasn?t been sold...well isn?t it about time somebody did find out why it hasn't been sold? I just think finding the right buyer shouldn't be left to a group of people who have promised so much and delivered so little. We need some professionals - Keith Harris with his guy in the one bedroom flat doesn't exactly inspire confidence tbh.
Phil Martin
37 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:45:23
@33 which is why BU exists to apply pressure and highlight the plight of the club.
Certain non-active board members can afford to wait for their ROI. Unfortunately no potential investor will likely give them that ROI because the club is being run into the ground.

I totally refuse to accept praying for financial armageddon and the mutal destruction of other clubs as the saving grace (and justification) for Everton's situation now.
How did 7 years of painstaking re-building of the club into the 5th strongest team in the land, be undone so quickly that we even entertain statements like "Where will we level out at? I don't know but I would hope that we can stay in the Premiership"?
Why did BK say when he took over 12 years ago that he had to find more suitable long term owners -yet he know states "I've been desperately looking for 4 years"?
Drew O'Neall
38 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:33:23
Why do these posts have to descend in to sarcasm?

Forums will always be useless as a meaningful way of achieving anything other than conjecture while posters argue about arguing.

Make your point, argue the point, move on.

Here's a point, I support the Blue Union in their refusal to accept inertia however don't accept that the current board will allow the club to be sold from under them and I fear that BU will now only accept sale of the club as success and I don't want a sale at any cost.

I would accept the club not being sold and a five year austerity plan introduced by the current board to reduce/wipe out the club's debt.

We could probably sell 5-7 players over the next 5 years, remain in the Premier League and have a business that was sustainable with an Evertonian at the helm - surely what every Evertonian wants.
Dave Roberts
39 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:47:55
Put pressure on them to sell?

Who do you put pressure on to buy?
Giles Larkman
40 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:55:38
Who was the last investor/buyer (in any sport) that built a new stadium for their new team?

An honest question.
Steve Ferns
41 Posted 12/09/2011 at 14:59:02
The point of pressure groups is to highlight the plight of the club. But i sincerely believe that doing so is harming the club. BU's protest is dividing fans. There are people on here who are finding battle lines being drawn and themselves on the wrong side of the line to where they want to be.

There's this whole, "you're either with us or against us" mentality. BU would do well to adopt an attitude of if you're not against us then you're with us. BU have been perfectly peaceful but a number of supporters are verging on the militant. I admire your passion and agree with your sentiments, but I do not agree with your methods.

I do not believe the protest is trying to achieve anything. There is no solution as the title of this article suggests. you cannot find a buyer if the economic conditions are not right.
Paul O'Hanlon
42 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:08:11
Not sure Giles, but what's the point of your question? No one has asked for a new stadium?
Paul O'Hanlon
43 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:14:18
The fans have been divided since DK Steve, don't blame BU for that.
Steve Ferns
44 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:17:34
Paul there is always division between fans, but the latest thing is causing greater divides. Laughably, there's great divides between people who are not happy with BK. Why? Because some of us do not agree with the protests.

Protesting is all well and good but there must be something tangible to aim for. The appointment of a middle man to facilitate a sale is ridiculous. BU need to come up with proper solutions if they want to mass a proper protest and then they will see the majority of the fans rally to their cause. Make no doubt about it, most Everton fans are not happy, but the battle lines are being drawn in the wrong place and forcing some onto the wrong side.
Giles Larkman
45 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:19:57
Paul, my honest opinion is that it is very hard to sell the club with Goodison in the state that it is. An investor will, in some way, be looking for a return, and the stadium issue has to be addressed. It's ageing and is in need of updating or replacement. The cost of which will be expensive. In my opinion it will put off potential investors.

I'm not on either side, but I feel the stadium issue is 'the elephant in the room'. We will be more saleable if we have some plan in place to fix it, thus becoming more saleable.
Colin Fitzpatrick
46 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:14:12
Oh and Steve [28] what are you going on about TBH - they've long since been dissolved. You don't post on another forum do you? Your infernal fence sitting and grasp of reality [lack of] reminds me greatly of somebody else
Dave Roberts
47 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:13:03
Giles

Off the top of my head I can't think of anyone who, as owner of a football club (at least in the UK) paid for the rebuilding or renovation of a stadium out of their own pocket. But that's the point. These owners want to own clubs with what they perceive as iconic stadia that can make money in their own right or are at least in the best place to make money (Chelsea?)...and they want it in place before they buy. They don't even have to own it.

The only rare exceptions tend to be London clubs. The kudos there is a little different. As the new owner of QPR said, 'the attraction of owning a premiership club IN LONDON was too great to resist'. Walton doesn't have the same attraction for these people unfortunately.

Manchester City were a club not so long ago in a very similar position to Everton....skint and going nowhere. The council rent them a stadium and suddenly they are the richest club in the world. That's not how I think football should be or would hope it should be, but that is the way it is. The 'premises' and their location are very important to these people.
Mike Green
48 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:30:54
Steve (28) - they will theoretically get a ROI if the company is worth more now than when they took over. The question is - is it?

Martin (30) - you may get asked who was at the wheel when we hit the iceberg..?

Many of our issues are down to frustration, based largely on our history as one of the biggest and most successful clubs in domestic football history. This is what you?re seeing in the rise of the Blue Union.

Until relatively recently we were one of ?the Big 5? ? we?ve dropped well out of that league due the change in the dynamic of the top flight competition and the Champions League, a viscous circle of less success on the pitch leading to a shrinking fanbase, leading to lower revenues, leading to less spending power, leading to less investment on and off the pitch, leading to less success on the pitch, leading to a shrinking fanbase?.

Regardless of the reasons and finger pointing we?ve gradually become a less attractive proposition to both fans and investors.

Over the past 12 decades we?ve never had a dynasty but we?ve consistently competed at the very top ? ironically until the advent of the Premiership, which we were instrumental in founding. There are now only a handful of clubs that can compete at the very top ? either through a global brand (Man Utd, Liverpool), a billionaire (Chelsea, Man City) or from being a big club, run well (Arsenal). Others are having a stab at it by throwing money at it, which is horrendously risky if that money doesn?t come from a bottomless pit.

We are not a global brand. We are no longer a truly big club. Whether or not we?re being run astutely is what much of the current debate seems to be focused on.

So ? are our options to either live within our means, tread water, try to stay in the top flight, enjoy it for what it is and see how it goes v sell out to someone with some cash and hope for the best? Doesn?t sound like a great place to be to me, which is why people are getting restless. There is definitely a ground swell of support for new ownership because of frustration and worry that the clubs decline is only going in one direction (see para 3?). In their defence, when your manager hasn?t bought a first team player for a fee for over two years I?d say they had a point and where will it ultimately end?

So why wouldn?t a billionaire buy Everton? I can see nothing that makes Man City a better proposition than us other than the new ground. Arsenal hated the idea of leaving Highbury but knew they had to do it to remain competitive and as long as we stay at Goodison in its current form our revenues will not improve and we wont attract the type of investor that can make us truly competitive again. See Spurs and West Ham fighting over the Olymipic Stadium.

So ? you can say forget about the Kings Dock and forget about Destination Kirkby but Everton F C?s failure to build on their significant historical success, location in the heartland of British football and their place within it during the most lucrative era the game?s ever seen is precisely what has put us in the position we are in today, treading water not knowing which is the best way to shore. And the only people you can blame for that are the people running the club ? not the players, not the fans, not the manager ? the people running the club. The buck stops there I?m afraid. The question is - have we already missed the boat?
Dave Roberts
49 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:27:40
Oh, and before somebody comes on and asks why it is that Liverpool can find buyers when their stadium is only half a mile away and is not really that much better than Goodison.

Its a trade off.

Their success over the years has made them a world brand. Anfield would not be an ideal place for an owner on a level playing field but the 'world brand' status counters that. It's just a case of adding up the pluses and minuses.
Giles Larkman
50 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:31:28
Dave I couldn't agree more. The whole ManCity investment stems from them being given the keys (via a long term lease) to a large, new stadium. This should not really be allowed in a competitve league.

But for me this just reinforces the importance of the stadium.

You're spot on about the London clubs. They're all sitting on very expensive plots of land. I hate to imagine how much Stamford Bridge is worth.

I think if we sold as is, it is quite likely that the next owner will be in a similar situation as the current and I don't think that will move EFC on.
Paul O'Hanlon
51 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:35:43
Giles & Dave, yes it would be easier to sell the club if we had a profit making stadium. But I don't believe that alone would put off a serious investor who's looking to buy into the Premier League. I believe it's a combination of the debt, the stadium and most importantly...the asking price.

If BK is asking for £100m then that's a hell of a lot more than it was bought for and what major investment has been put into the club since that time? None! I don't believe BK's to blame for the valuation though, rather his financial backers Earl and Green.
Drew O'Neall
52 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:36:56
Perhaps the Blue Union should be protesting Liverpool City Council in order to find Everton a suitable location in order that they become an attractive investment.

Perhaps this is KEIOC's agenda.
Paul O'Hanlon
53 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:47:11
Drew, perhaps LCC are fed up with EFC after they handed us the most sort after piece of land in Europe in the Kings Dock, only for us to cock it up!
Drew O'Neall
54 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:47:14
I don't think the debt is insurmountable at all (I personally don't even think our debt is unsustainable except that it is the type of debt which cannot be paid back early).

That leaves the stadium and the asking price.
Dave Roberts
55 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:41:07
Mike Green

I agree with most of what you say. But when you blame the people who are running the club I hope you are not restricting that to the present lot. This club has been mismanaged for decades. It was Alan Ball himself after the championship win in 1970 who urged the club to reinvest in the team. The club thought that was unnecessary and that success would be permanent. Ball was not happy with that and started to complain about the players around him not being good enough. Kendall talks about that as if it was a joke but Bally was serious. Not many years later we were shite and Ball was proved right although by that time he had been sold to Arsenal. That was the beginning of our decline. The 80's were just an unexpected interruption of that process of decline.

The success of the 80's came along in spite of the board not because of it and even during that period there was no significant investment happening. The club were spoiled by John Moores' deep pockets in the sixties and never learned to cope for themselves. BK is just carrying on the tradition.
Drew O'Neall
56 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:50:40
Paul, I would have thought LCC regard this as a narrow escape in retrospect but I take your point.

Do you think / does anyone know for a fact whether LCC point blank refuse to deal with the current board?

Steve Ferns
57 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:55:51
Colin, no, I've only ever posted on here.

As for saying I have little grasp of reality I find that insulting.
Mike Green
58 Posted 12/09/2011 at 15:57:13
Dave - I can accept that and also that staying at the top is a very diffcult thing to do. Fergie and Man Utd have managed it by being ruthless and never standing still. I witnessed an hour long presentation by their Head of Marketing, Jonathan Rigby recently and they are a commercial juggernaut, make no mistake - it scared the shit out of me!
Colin Fitzpatrick
59 Posted 12/09/2011 at 16:05:41
Steve [57] I'll take your word on that - you're commenting on TBH owning two thirds of Everton ; TBH ceased to exist six years ago, that's a fact, that's reality, that?s what I meant.

I know your name from somewhere, are you a lawyer?
Steve Ferns
60 Posted 12/09/2011 at 17:01:10
Here?s a solution loud and clear, in fact here?s two:

1. BU should put their money where their mouths are. Buy the club themselves. A Fans Takeover. £1,000 a share (max. one share per person and so many per household) will need 100,000 takers to meet the mythical £100m figure. Or 50,000 coughing up £2,000 each. BU can have their fans parliament then. After that a bad president can be easily deposed. Never has there been a better time for the fans to buy the club. If BU want a real solution this is it. It hasn't worked elsewhere, especially down the road. Why? Because they didn't have enough fans paying £1,000 to reach the club?s astronomical price. Our club is worth a lot less, and we do, surely, have enough fans able to raise the funds.

2. Fan investment. The fans cannot afford to match the overinflated asking price, so how about a share issue raising money for the club, to pay off debts or buy players. This would also shake up the board and break the True Blue monopoly. As this sizeable shareholding organisation would be entitled to at least a seat on the board, a term that can be directly negotiated as a term of purchase. This board member would be directly elected for a fixed term by the members of the Fans Investment group.

BU could liaise with banks to come up with a scheme so members could raise the funds needed (those who can't afford £1,000 cash may be able to borrow) and BU could have an account ready for the funds to be paid into.

The fans would provide the kind of investment the fans want. I.e. not investment at all, a gift with no expectation of any return and really just the prestige of owning a part of the club with the right to directly elect the board or a board member.

Surely, with all their collective intelligence, BU can come up with better. If they come up with such a scheme as a Fans Takeover, BK will really struggle to resist the pressure of the fans as he cannot deny their intentions when there is real money waved in his face. Then we can all chant ?let it go, Bill?.
Dennis Stevens
61 Posted 12/09/2011 at 17:20:22
Steve, are you the same guy who posted : "... it is their company and they can take as long as they want to sell it and there is not a jot any can do about it. It is up to them if they sell, for how much and to whom. Whether we like it or not, we cannot force them to sell for a certain price. It's their choice" earlier in this thread?
Johnny Rainford
62 Posted 12/09/2011 at 17:35:25
Better idea... what about if Kenwright simply does what he's allegedly been trying to do the last 11 years... find a buyer for the club...?

If Martin Broughton isnt available, sure there must be someone else who can step in and help him.

(not holding breath)

Brian Harrison
63 Posted 12/09/2011 at 21:11:38
I hear many suggest an intrim board be appointed to sell the club. But without agreement from the present board this is a complete non-starter. But just let us presume the present board agree.

Can someone tell me who appoints the intrim board, and has anybody any names who might be on this board?

Also what timescale they would be given, and what salaries will this intrim board be paid?

Then let's take the fantasy a stage further: they come up with what is considered a creditable buyer, and within 12 months we find we have a Shinawattra or a Carson Yeung, who do we blame then?

Steve Cotton
64 Posted 12/09/2011 at 21:30:13
Alan Williams #4 says 'I clapped BK too because I felt as a fan I had to make a statement but it wasn?t about supporting BK more to make BU aware that you don?t represent me in your current form.'

Well if that was your reason then Bill's smug expression was totally because he thought the clapping was for him. He is already the best salesman Everton could have.

You encouraging him will make him believe his own hype even more.

Even the woman behind him was surely saying, 'Look Bill I told you they really love you' I bet he went into the executive gents and kissed the mirror at half-time...

Thanks Alan, and by the way sorry you gave the Beatles up just as they became big, Bummer....

Anthony Jones
65 Posted 12/09/2011 at 22:25:16
Victor, #20, well said.

It never ceases to amaze me when posts directly contradict themselves.

How could DK have benefited the buyer and seller of the club without increasing commercial viability in some way?

Another Toffeeweb bullshitter. And these same clowns call Kenwright "Billy Bullshitter".
Tom Hughes
66 Posted 12/09/2011 at 22:48:59
Anthony,
Anything that requires multiple lies to support it in a vote against no other option will invariably not be an option at all.... as was proven outright at the inquiry and subsequently when dropped by the club at the first opportunity. If the outdated out-of-town stadium option was really so great an option why wasn't it built, after all the loss of the shops hardly affected the club's final costs, because the promised enabling-windfall didn't exist? Go back and read up about the whole process and the inquiry. The stadium was never viable and the whole scheme was il-conceived from start to finish. That is why it was never built, and even the club was forced to accept its pure folly! The intention was simply to package the club as cheaply as possible for a high return quick sale and to ENABLE the retail moguls onboard to have their shops, with little or no real regard for the future of EFC.... hence the multiple-revised transport strategy that was laughed at in the inquiry for the joke that it was, and that ultimately had knowsley covering their arses with last minute clauses to actually limit any stadium capacity to possibly even less than GP because they knew what they were inflicting on their residents and the eventual backlash. If you want to see bullshit dig out your ballot literature for DK.... and or any excuses given for the loss of Kings Dock or the mysteries of FSF or............... tell me I'm wrong!!!!
Anthony Jones
67 Posted 12/09/2011 at 23:16:29
#66 Tom,

I agree with you.

My post, #65, is challenging those that contribute to this site to stick to reasonable arguments based on the available evidence (fat fucking chance!).

It seems somewhat hypocritical to topple a bullshitter via the method of bullshitting. You may have realised this if you actually read my post!

Frank McGregor
68 Posted 12/09/2011 at 23:34:02
Before I comment I would like to mention that the game on saturday was a great improvement on the previous games and, by the way, after spending no money, we are only 3 points behind Liverpool with a game in hand!!

I agree that change is needed; however, I do not believe the protest march is the correct way to address the problem.

Also, if an independent person or company comes in to oversee the sale of Everton and it turns out not what you expected, who do you blame then? Consequently I cannot support the Blue Union approach.

Martin Mason
69 Posted 13/09/2011 at 04:07:23
I was out of the country and missed the King's Dock Fiasco. It seemed such a marvellous idea though and was probably our last chance.

Regarding the iceberg? I believe EFC hit it in the early 70s when we had the team and the revenues to be the very best. Leeds and Man United were on their way down and while Arsenal were strong the world was our oyster and we blew it. We blew it when we threw away all credibility and bought players like Bernie the Bolt. The mid 80s was unfortunately just an accidental blip on what has been managed decline ever since. Whatever we do, I believe that we have to move from the train wreck that once glorious Goodison has become and I believe that we should stop screaming for "somebody" to come and rescue us. Let us put our money where our mouths are and invest in the club ourselves.

A bit of credit for how the team played Saturday too. A few more games like this and there could be light in the gloom.
Gavin Ramejkis
70 Posted 13/09/2011 at 08:45:49
Victor, read the transcript of the DK hearings, the telling lines are the board not having spent a single penny of their own money on the club or willing to dilute their shareholdings, that in itself smacks of a plan for sale. Having sold their shares they literally wouldnt give a monkeys toss about the £78m debt as they would have relinquished their shares. We are talking about the same directors that fed us £10m a year from the new stadium for DM for players, 55k capacity, non match day concert venue, most accessible stadium in the country.

What it transpired was a huge property scam at the behest of Tesco, KMBC and a certain "friend of the club", if you don't believe that was the case why did Everton not continue with the stadium on their own after the retail element failed which had supposedly nothing to do with them?

The shareholders believed DK was their exit strategy and it failed. Anthony very childish to claim the available information for those that bother their arse to review it as a bullshitter. BK and his fellow major shareholders had no plan B, they clearly had no intent to spend any of their own money, or dilute their shareholdings and looking at DK as an exit route and payday. A buyer would have got a new stadium the debt of which was against the club and not them in a similar fashion to the way other buyouts have leveraged debt against the company and not themselves. If you and Victor want to revel in denial thats your choice but don't insult my intelligence claiming the moral high ground as bullshit.
Gavin Ramejkis
71 Posted 13/09/2011 at 09:16:44
Anthony can you entertain me with some of my supposed "bullshit", I've a tiny window of opportunity between some meetings later today and could do with some of your humour.
Dennis Stevens
72 Posted 13/09/2011 at 10:15:50
The worst of it, Gavin, is that this still seems to be their exit strategy. All talk since the demise of DK has been about a new retail lead development, with great emphasis on how it's not viable to redevelop Goodison Park. The intention just seems to be to try & keep the club ticking over until such a deal comes to fruition. Hopefully the clear widespread unrest amongst supporters will cause the Board to re-evaluate.
Tom Hughes
73 Posted 13/09/2011 at 10:58:41
Dennis.....

I have also heard this mentioned a few times, and if true it illustrates the ineptitude of the current ownership. No retail-led scheme will ever get planning permission within the city, or even the city-region. Even if one such project was allowed in some dim and distant site far beyond our city-boundaries, the out-of-town retail model yields the least of all enabling schemes, as was shown by DK.

The inherent low value of these type of developments ? cheap and cheerful shopping warehouses will never compete with high-quality, high-value multi-storey city-centre developments ? and of course that's all before you consider the transport issues that render this idea a non-starter in the first place.

The club has wasted money, time and real opportunities to get their house in order in this respect. Few, if any other clubs have been as wasteful and unproductive as ours.

Anthony Jones
74 Posted 13/09/2011 at 20:40:57
#71,

are your meetings with your psychiatrist by any chance?

Childish it may seem, but you Sir are a bullshitter, just like your nemesis Bill Kenwright.

Cheers
Brian Harrison
75 Posted 14/09/2011 at 06:10:10
I have a couple of questions for the guys of the Blue Union. There has been a call for the appointment of an intrim board being appointed.

I would imagine without the go ahead from the present board, this would be a non-starter anyway, But let us assume they agree to an intrim board.

Who appoints the people to sit on this board? Also I presume the members of the intrim board would be paid a salary. Anyone care to throw a figure into the ring?

Then what timescale would the intrim board be given to secure a buyer for the Club? Let's assume that after 12 months no buyer is found, is this intrim board allowed to carry on indefinitely until one is found?

But let's be positive and say within 12 months they find a buyer; Who decides if they are fit and proper to run our club, the intrim board or the present board?

Michael Kenrick
76 Posted 14/09/2011 at 06:11:21
Brian (#63 & #75), you seem preoccupied with this idea of an interim board (not 'intrim'!) and you've failed to take in the fact that it's somethng BU have moved beyond: they are not pushing for an interim board ? read the BU statements.
Alan Williams
77 Posted 14/09/2011 at 08:13:50
Steve, 64#. Classic comment about ?the woman behind him? you don?t even know who she is do you? Obviously you?re well read on BK and his mistakes and you know all about the man?s dealing don?t you???.sorry still laughing. I made a statement, just like fans marching nothing more, nothing less.

BU is not a bad idea it's just totally misguided in its objective and is missing the point and should be concentrating on a fans co-operative as opposed to making it more like an industrial dispute. Therein lies the problem: people just don?t have the appetite for such action in their spare time so embrace the opportunity and get something positive out of forming a fans group as apposed to seeking notoriety and offering sound bites that just have no substance whatsoever. COYB

Tom Hughes
78 Posted 14/09/2011 at 09:08:15
Alan, the people behind the BU have also bought into the whole Everton Trust concept too and have been in discussions about it for months. You really have to get your facts straight before you criticise just for the sake of it.

The protest was made to help raise media awareness because of the club's strangle-hold on local media allowing the blissful ignorance of so many to continue..... when the powers that be continually fail to act in the club's best interests, fans have every right to protest.

Danny Lizars
79 Posted 14/09/2011 at 12:26:05
Well done to the BU! Hopefully BSB (BullShit Bill) took note.

His time is without a doubt up. He and the rest of the board need to do one fast!! So why dont they name the asking price for Everton? I know £100million has been mentioned but where has this come from? If thats what BSB is asking then we are fucked!! He must be drinking too much Chang!!
David Thomas
80 Posted 14/09/2011 at 12:19:45
Michael,

I noticed the BU don't want an interim board anymore. They seemed to move on from that idea very quickly.

I would imagine they moved on from it because after jumping on the idea of an interim board they realised very quickly that they had no answer to the type of questions highlighted on Brian Harrisons post.
Tom Hughes
81 Posted 14/09/2011 at 13:01:59
David,
The BU only had its first public meeting a short while ago. I believe the general concensus was that the current board have contributed and delivered nothing.... (and who could argue with that?)hence the reason why so many concerned fan groups have been springing up, and their amalgamation into the BU in the first place.

Meanwhile BK has been trying to sell us or find investment for his entire time in charge.... hardly surprising then, that fans feel that some kind of intermediary or interim might be needed to actually make something happen.

The questions in Brian Harrison's post have little or no effect or relevance. If BK's talk of holding off the banks are to be believed, which certainly seems to be borne out by recent sales, then it would only be a matter of time before banks might be requesting similar action.

David Thomas
82 Posted 14/09/2011 at 14:11:32
Tom,

The BU have released press statements and carried out a protest arguing that firstly an interim board and then a group of professionals are the changes that are needed at the club. Their actions suggest that they see these changes as viable solutions.

Yet, questions on who makes up these group of professionals, how much they are to be paid, how long they are given and who has the final say on decisions ets are beind deemed to have no relevance?

Surely, before any statements / protests etc were carried out they would have taken legal advice / spoke to people who have had first hand experience in these matters and got a rough understanding of the legal issues surrounding this course of action so they had answers to these type of questions.
Tom Hughes
83 Posted 14/09/2011 at 14:40:13
David... It's an irrelevance because we are talking about the sale of an organisation that pays many of its employees in £millions per yr..... some of whom they have recently offloaded, releasing funds that could be utilised. There is also a large body of share-holding professionals and advisers that could be part of the process..... IMO, It's a side issue to be honest.

Then again of course we could leave it all to BK who seems to have problems accounting for £24m of operating costs and how they are made up..... and has been trying non-stop for over a decade to no avail.
Alan Williams
84 Posted 14/09/2011 at 18:02:41
Hi Tom, just so you?re aware I too offered my services to Tony I?Anson along with a potential personal donation. What I?m saying is a fans co-operative needs to include the fans and not just the head of minority groups who serve a purpose but don?t control the fan base. I said they should have put their efforts in getting a fans mandate as opposed to marching on the club after one open meeting with just 300 present.

The concept of a fans group is actually a positive idea the delivery so far in my opinion is poor as you jumped ahead far too quickly, hence causing a split and now an element of distrust which in my opinion detracts from the positives that could be taken out of this situation.

Criticism I?m afraid comes with the job and BU need to be able to handle whatever is put to them; after all, you are trying to take a moral high ground here. We all want the same at the end of the day so include everybody ? and that means EFC Ltd in whatever form possible. COYB

Tom Hughes
85 Posted 14/09/2011 at 19:57:38
Alan, these groups met with Tony a long time ago, and have been involved throughout the process (even long before it was first anounced publically), and long before BU itself was formed. It is an intrinsic part of all of their "principal objectives".....

The formation of the blue union itself was in response to a need to unify all the groups that were sprouting up within the theme of raising awareness, seeking accountabilty and/or change (my words, not theirs as I am not a member, but supporter of the group). It is simply a natural progression as numbers grew dramatically on each of the websites supporting these groups. No-one is seeking "notoriety" as you stated, and they have certainly raised awareness, with several notable articles appearing in the national media...... Proven by the fact that it has prompted the club's biggest media saturation exercise since they tried to push the il-concieved and fundamentally flawed DK on to us. Many fans tried to similarly rubbish KEIOC when they first put their collective heads above the parapets..... I remember the multiple threads with cries of "you don't speak for me" and "why would the club lie to us" etc...... By the time the inquiry had finished, they were fully vindicated in everything they said, and the websites were full of apologies from those who tried to shoot the messenger.....

Only the club have personalised this episode... just as they tried with DK. It's a common tactic when you can't argue against the real issues.
Alan Williams
86 Posted 15/09/2011 at 07:59:19
Tom, totally appreciate what you?re saying but we are talking about a company that has a cash value of many tens of millions so you should expect resistance, it?s not a game its normal business tactics, I see and hear about it everyday. What I?m trying to say is this is not DK, I honestly believe all fans can be united on the future of our club but marching on the club whilst making a statement short term, could lose everybody (fans group) a seat at the top table long term.

The fans should be looking to open up dialogue with BK and EFC Ltd immediately and possibly do a bit of brown-nosing or, dare I say, compromise a bit and make a joint statement or even appearance to look as one group/club for the future of our club. Failure to do this will alienate the fans groups as militants and you will never get the blessing of the fans as we are loyal, maybe too loyal to everything EFC.

I see a positive opportunity here in my opinion if it?s played correctly, EFC will be around a lot longer than BK and both of us so use this platform as a positive opportunity. Good Luck, COYB

Tom Hughes
87 Posted 15/09/2011 at 10:10:33
Alan,
I understand what you are saying..... I can assure you that protesting goes against the grain of practically every one involved..... but it is not as if we have arrived at this point suddenly. It is following a whole series of well-documented off-the-pitch failures over a long period of time. Culminating at the point where the whole future of the club is now in question, and where we now have to sell not just to buy, but to exist. We have all been very patient and loyal, and loyalty is indeed a great asset..... but absolutely worthless and even dangerous if it is misguided and faith-based only. We have bought into the club every year, we have played our part. What have the board contributed apart from multiple broken promises and failures to deliver, time and time again?

KEIOC have been in dialogue with the club for years now, as have the other groups more recently. The whole Everton trust and football quarter initiatives have (directly or indirectly) come out of their discussions with the club, city council, Universities and various developers and many others, all of whom have been very receptive. There have been ideas galore but nothing acted on and nothing delivered by the club, except what appears to be pure lip-service. Let's face it even shareholders (of which there are many in these groups) aren't allowed to formally voice their views at AGM's anymore. Why? Because the mood at AGM's changed dramatically over the years when the board increasingly failed, or even refused to answer share-holders' valid questions and concerns, that are now all being fully vindicated by our current predicament. There was very little "clapping" for BK at any of these later events I can assure you. Hence the plug was pulled, and a 100+yr constitution was rewritten to keep the embarrassing questions at bay..... so, I think there might be only so far you can go with those avenues and with the characters involved...... talk is cheap as they say.

Brian Harrison
88 Posted 15/09/2011 at 21:08:44
Michael 76,

I suggest you read what the Blue Union say in their statement at the top of this page. They state that they want an autonomous group of professionals should be employed to find a buyer.

So this is not an intrim board, so who would give them the authority to sell the club, surely it would have to be the present board.

Blue Union state that this group of professionals would be employed which suggests that they would be getting paid for carrying out this task. Could I possibly ask who pays them and how much?

Then going back to my original question have you any ideas which professionals would be on this group, and also what timescale they would be given?

See, Michael, you say that Blue Union have moved on from the idea of an intrim board, yet that as I can see is pretty much what they are still advocating. I would suggest that Blue Union have another meeting and have clear and precise goals and ambitions that they will stick too.
Michael Kenrick
89 Posted 15/09/2011 at 22:46:40
Yes, I think I've read it a few times, thanks, Brian. In fact, I told YOU to read it!

You're right; it's not an 'intrim' board... not even an interim board. I think I told you that already?

I would imagine the plan would be to have these professionals paid by Everton FC Co Ltd ? probably a fraction of what EFC paid the professionals who worked so long and hard on that failed Destination Kirikby project, so nothing unusual there, having professionals paid to do a specific job for the Club.

How much? No, you can't ask that.

Once the principle is accepted by the current board, I imagine Blue Union may already have some suggested professionals they would nominate. However, I doubt that they are going to tell you and me who they are at this stage. We would probably find out once they had been appointed.

The timescale question is a difficult one. I would hope they'd be given enough time to find a buyer... but they may need more time.

Yes, the Blue Union have moved on from an intrim board... and from an INTERIM board (you're still not getting it, are you?) No, this is definitely NOT 'pretty much what they are still advocating" (What's going on here? Are we going around in circles?)

The existing board would remain in place. An additional group of professionals would be appointed to succeed where the current incumbent (Bill "I am the best person to sell the club" Kenwright) has failed.

I don't think the Blue Union need another meeting as their aim is clearly stated from their last meeting. Of course, if you don't agree with their aim, or you see problems with it, then you might want them to go back and have another go. But I don't think they are going to somehow.

Hope this helps.
Ov Collyer
90 Posted 16/09/2011 at 14:09:54
Something I feel is missing from the Blue Union strategy is a single website, in their name, that summaries who they are, what they have done and what they plan to do.

If I had only just heard of the BU - perhaps via a mention in a BBC match report or something - then I might type "Blue Union Everton" into Google.

This yields a number of results, but none jump out clearly and say "This is the official page of the Blue Union".

A few results down there are couple of entries for Evertonians For Change, one of which details the 1st August meeting and explains what BU is about. But even here though, it's not clear that this site is (as far as I can tell) the "home" of BU. Indeed it describes how BU is a coalition of organisations, including Evertonians For Change.

I feel that clearing up this slight confusion between who are Evertonians For Change and who are Blue Union would help strengthen the message and give additional credibility to the organisation.

I'm sure if there was a donation option, plenty of blues would contribute towards any hosting costs.
Darren Ainscough
91 Posted 16/09/2011 at 23:16:26
I don't have to write a big essay. The bottom line is, We have to remove BK and his useless board. We are on borrowed time. Enough said!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads