Season › 2011-12 › News
No blue skies for Everton
Swiss Ramble on Everton Finance
TextQuotes or other material sourced from Swiss Ramble
Reader Comments (74)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:23:46
3 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:04:33
If the board were bought out for the £75 million quoted, and the £45 million debt paid off, and Moyes given £30 million to boost the squad, that is £150 million. And I bet we would be right in the mix for the top 4 if Moyes could add £30 million of talent to the existing squad.
The stadium issue could be looked at further down the line, because we are not going to get a new stadium imminently with all the best will in the world. We would be in a much more attractive position to look at moving ground etc if we had a strong business model, and no debt against the club.
So I feel a new owner could obtain us and put us in a much healthier position for around £150 million, which sounds a lot better than £500 million.
4 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:26:45
COYB
5 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:40:47
The 'other operating costs' are still unanswered though - unless I'm missing something (which wouldn't be the first time for me!). Surely that amount of money couldn't be just from the initial stages of preparing the new stadium in Kirkby?... will we ever know?
6 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:37:36
I think you need to read the whole article and not just the brief outline above.... because if you can show us the bit that shows how this board is putting us top of the PL in ANY respect, you need to point it out to everyone more clearly!
Far from topping the prem, we have to sell just to survive!!!! No bandwagon required!
A great article, but it would seem that some wont see our demise until they see the name EVERTON on a gravestone! No doubt even then, they'll want to blame everyone but those "running the show" for the past decade and more.
7 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:55:11
You either need to read the article, understand the article, or seriously consider typing such rubbish.
WE ARE IN TROUBLE
8 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:55:54
One thing I came across on the other operating costs: "The massive increase from £12 million in 2007 to £21 million in 2008 is unexplained..." Apparently, this has been attributed to Finch Farm... but does it really cost £9 million more than Bellefield EACH AND EVERY YEAR? Still very mysterious...
9 Posted 15/09/2011 at 15:02:04
Should be compulsory reading for any journalists writing "investigative" articles about Everton at the moment.
10 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:55:39
11 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:45:07
But what are Elstone and his commercial team under Ian Ross doing? Playing their fiddles whilst Rome burns it seems. Stagnated, even reducing, commercial revenues and match-day revenues are primarily due to lack of marketing initiatives and commercial inertia. And it is in this regard that football is like any other business. If these guys were employed by any other company but Everton, they would be fired by now and replaced by a team with initiative, drive and motivation.
Never mind Kenwright out. Those who want to see a change in the club?s ownership and management should be calling for the heads of Elstone and Ross.
12 Posted 15/09/2011 at 15:11:52
13 Posted 15/09/2011 at 15:50:39
14 Posted 15/09/2011 at 16:20:35
There is no-one at the club to change the culture. It is one long firefight.
We know Bill is staring out of the window thinking of the West End - but what the fuck are the rest of the board doing?
16 Posted 15/09/2011 at 16:38:19
It's an outstanding article and highly informative but I didn't find it was all doom and gloom. We have known for a long time we need to increase revenue (although when I posted the other day that fans should not avoid playing their part in this i was excoriated) and we need to find ways to do that. The basic element is expanding your market base but I never see an effort to do that. I never see an effort to recruit the signifcant Everton diaspora. We have a world class Australian player in Tim Cahill, a world class US player in Tim Howard, both legends in their own countries but I never see any effort to exploit this in those markets. Clubs who operate in a global marketplace do better than those who operate in a parochial marketplace. We need to expand our reach.
17 Posted 15/09/2011 at 17:19:22
18 Posted 15/09/2011 at 17:18:17
The problem is, Mr Parrington is not alone. Far from it.
I've just got lost and ended up on the Grand Old Team forum. There's fuckin thousands of them. Its like the twilight zone.
19 Posted 15/09/2011 at 16:47:46
20 Posted 15/09/2011 at 17:59:50
... why do I have a feeling it wont?
Michael #16... good question. The news is that they were all a figment of Kenwrights imagination. Ultimately.. the guy is a professional actor.. someone who get's paid to pretend for a living.
21 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:16:29
22 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:24:33
Any chance of co-opting this Swiss Ramble bloke onto the Board to help them run the finances? Methinks he rambles rather less than some of the current incumbents
23 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:24:47
24 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:46:30
25 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:51:41
Maybe he could also give me an answer to my previous question about the dicussions with the 3 potential investors...
26 Posted 15/09/2011 at 19:03:02
The most important aspect for me, is that we are keeping hold of our better players (Jagielka, Fellaini, Baines, Coleman, Rodwell) and protecting our future.
The figures show that our performance as a business is no worse than any of our Premier League counterparts, and in many cases much better. It just depends on how you view the situation. Would we be in a better position if like the clubs above us, the chairman was more wealthy and able to under-write more debt? The chairmen above us do not perform better than us, the profit before tax figures clearly show that. The reason we are not competing is that our credit limit is much lower than our competitors. Is this a bad thing in the long run? Or would we be satisfied to treble the debts to compete, and pay tonnes more in interest? I personally wouldn't.
27 Posted 15/09/2011 at 19:12:49
28 Posted 15/09/2011 at 19:59:56
29 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:15:21
30 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:18:26
So, after all that analysis, they agree that our current strategy is the only real one we have.
Surprise? No. Very obvious to us realists.
31 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:17:20
32 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:18:52
Editorial Team
33 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:44:25
There was an article elsewhere the other day that described this particular phenom pretty well... almost depressingly too well as it is exactly what we are seeing from the not-so-silent "majority" of
34 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:30:07
What some of us are suggesting with the be careful what you wish for statements, is someone with the best business acumen in the world is not going to be able to compete at the top level both domestically and in europe, unless they have hundreds of millions spare to pump into the club. You again seem to have no understanding of these basic principles, and resort to childish 'boys pen' comments as you cannot actually come up with anything meaningful to say.
Myself and Ciaran have had many discussions over the years, and to be honest I enjoy the banter as he is an intelligent bloke. The majoirty of times I dont even respond to your comments, as its like trying to teach rocket science to a squid.
35 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:48:26
Michael, so anybody that is loyal to the CLUB (note that the word is club, not board) is thick?
36 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:52:42
Oh, and next time try cutting out the personal abuse.
37 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:59:19
Dan, why don't you go away and read it before spouting more of your lying twisting shite on here?
38 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:47:04
The directors do not seem to be meeting their fiduciary duty and I am surprised that the smaller shareholders ? like the Grantchesters ? have not launched legal actions as the value of their investment is being eroded.
39 Posted 15/09/2011 at 21:21:09
This excellent piece is, disappointingly, merely preaching to the converted which seems like the biggest travesty of all.
40 Posted 15/09/2011 at 21:28:15
1. Educate
2. Comprehend
3. Formulate opinion
42 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:52:14
The figures simply show that we don't generate enough cash. How does the loss of opportunity of the Kings Dock tally into the equation of lost revenues? Who let that pass us by?
How does the failure to resolve the existing stadium's defficiencies generally affect these results.....? Could some of the other club's higher matchday revenues not be attributable to their success in actually delivering new facilities..... How have they done this and we haven't? Don't forget they have had well over a decade to resolve these issues, and even gifted opportunities too. No-one else is to blame for the failures and inactivity.
How did we get to the position that all assets have been lost to pay off our debts and in the process the club has been pursuing non-viable stadium options, when redevelopment options have never been explored fully, and could've benefitted greatly from this windfall long ago?
Fact is.... the figures show that this board are entirely dependent on Moyes inventing a perpetual motion machine, and creating something from nothing. Their contribution in adding value to our club either by investment in team or infrastructure over a 10+yr period appears to be zero.... This is not the case for most of the clubs we compete against.... and many more in lower leagues even.
I too am a loyal fan of the club, and a shareholder..... I feel no need to be loyal to those who don't appear to have contributed anything beyond acquiring ownership initially.
43 Posted 15/09/2011 at 21:52:28
At least you had the conjones to reply to this post.
Anyone heard from Dick Fearon?
Steve Ferns? No?
David Bryant?
Didn't fuckin think so.
44 Posted 15/09/2011 at 22:19:34
45 Posted 15/09/2011 at 22:18:36
46 Posted 15/09/2011 at 22:21:47
That's not "confirmation bias" mate, just listening to an argument, assessing the facts and forming an opinion.
47 Posted 15/09/2011 at 22:50:40
If it's the latter, then I'm afraid that's confirmation bias in action. If not, then I apologise: you, at least, are behaving in a fully rational, analytical manner.
48 Posted 15/09/2011 at 23:00:32
What part of that article lends itself to support of the current financial model being adopted at eveton?
49 Posted 15/09/2011 at 23:04:45
The debate is whether we should care that Everton are on the slide? Whether we as fans should be agitated enough to want something done about it? Whether we can look at other clubs and be placated in the knowledge that we're still in a better position than some/most? Or whether we should continue to leave it in the hands of the current board (in effect, just the one man) who is demonstrably incompetent in this regard despite his own arrogance.
50 Posted 15/09/2011 at 23:06:08
I have never understood why Everton management didn't make even basic efforts to gain presence in overseas markets, not just Australia and the US as Peter suggests, but Asia and Africa as well. Seeing all the ManU gear in China on my last trip got really frustrating. And when I walked around Shanghai in my Everton cap, nobody knew who we were.
51 Posted 15/09/2011 at 23:30:58
52 Posted 15/09/2011 at 23:45:29
In 2009/10 We were
9th in Wages
9th in Sponsorship revenue
9th in average attendance
8th in total revenues, and we finished 8tn in the table. So we are performing to expectations on the pitch in relation to our performance off it.
54 Posted 16/09/2011 at 00:28:27
My point about confirmation bias is relevant to some, if not all, of those issues. The Swiss Rambler piece would seem to indicate that, in absolute terms, the business is being run abysmally (which is music to the ears of Blue Union affiliates) but, when compared to the majority of our peers, we?re performing well or, at least, significantly less badly (which fuels the ?apologist? arguments) - as evidenced by the way that both sides have used portions of the article to support their stance.
Unfortunately, people are becoming increasingly black or white in their view on the matter when the reality remains a dingy grey.
55 Posted 16/09/2011 at 01:21:34
Any fan who continues to blindly ignore the issue and cheer when Bill is on the big screen is a joke. Its that attitude the will see us never sit on top of the pile again.
Everton fans and the board are all involved in this together, like a giant family. The board is the junkie brother. Some of us see the problem and are trying to do something about it while the "silent majority" are happy to sit back and watch the club slowly die. Our motto is NOTHING BUT THE BEST! Its pretty fucking clear that has absolutely no meaning to most around the club.
I wish the blue Union every bit of success. We don't need a billionare. I'd settle for a realistic strategy managed by qualified professionals.
56 Posted 16/09/2011 at 00:56:24
You state that "..........when compared to the majority of our peers, we?re performing well or, at least, significantly less badly........."
HOWEVER.......... The full picture is that this report shows 10 years of building debt, stagnating revenue streams except ironically those outwith the boards control (i.e. TV revenue) and selling both physical assets and players to SERVICE the debt.
That basic model, which has left us at this exact moment in time as "significantly less badly" than our peers is now in tatters BECAUSE......
1) We have no more Physical assets to sell
2) Our Operating costs have increassed because we have to lease everything back that we once used to own
The report is very clear, we now have to reduce our costs by 15 million per year AND raise another 10 million per year NET through players sales JUST TO BREAK EVEN! Remember, the Banks have now stopped the previous model from being emplyed anymore, we can not borrow any more money!!!
From here on in we need to find 25 million every year from somewhere and that means one thing, good by Barkley, Fellaini and Baines, hello Leeds United and relegation. We have reached the tipping point and too many blues don't, can't, won't see the disaster heading our way.
Add to this the GFC part 2 and shite football leaves us with revenues GOING DOWN and not up. Our average gates have gone down by 6,000 and show no signs of going back up any time soon, given the mostly dross football on offer.
Now, if there is anyone who cannot now see just why the Blue Union are doing what they are doing then they are beyond reasoning with.
Join the Blue Union now, before it is too late!!!!!!
57 Posted 16/09/2011 at 03:25:19
I think you miss the overall point that the Swiss Rambler writes ? Everton are run poorly. The fact that you find parts in his article showing ?Everton being run on par or better with other clubs? is meant to highlight his point that given certain elements show parity/ equality with other clubs, the all-important question is why AS A WHOLE Everton's finances are so dire...
58 Posted 16/09/2011 at 03:49:38
Sorry, very bad grammer and typing first time round!!!
59 Posted 16/09/2011 at 05:57:39
60 Posted 16/09/2011 at 08:31:02
Peter #15 and Mike #48, I metnioned something similar about non match day revenue in another thread, we have no visible marketing strategy at the club and simple wins such as Marketing in the USA and Australia are blatant opportunities going begging. If the club want to survive it needs to quite literally whore itself for better want of a term and try to extract as much money from its global fanbase as possible. The outsource deals are clearly poor so they should be rescinded and rebuilt. Some of these are really basic business processes and the country currently has over 2.5m unemployed - I'd be ruthless and put it to the employees in no uncertain terms that if they cant perform then the market place is full of other people to replace them.
61 Posted 16/09/2011 at 09:12:14
------------------------
So, your point about confirmation bais is nonsense then?
Because obviously for someone to selectively take meritorious points from an article to suit their own agenda - those points would have to be in the article in the first place there in the first place...but as you admit the overwhelming implication of the article is that we are 'being run abysmally'..
No offence, but I was marking your psychology homework, i'd have to grade it a D-.
62 Posted 16/09/2011 at 09:32:02
I think cutting costs is clearly the most viable and most obviously this means wages. I think it means really prioritising who the bigger wages should be spent on. A tighter wage structure needs to be put in place with no-one being allowed to break a £50,000 ceiling. If this is insufficient for a player then they have to be moved on and replaced with cheaper.
I would suggest for a start that high earners like Billy and Heitinga could be replaced by youth players or cheaper Championship-plucked alternatives. Getting the best out of decent players is arguably Moyes' greatest strength.
63 Posted 16/09/2011 at 10:09:41
64 Posted 16/09/2011 at 10:07:21
65 Posted 16/09/2011 at 10:45:38
66 Posted 16/09/2011 at 11:20:55
67 Posted 16/09/2011 at 12:49:11
--------------------------------
At last, an answer as to why people applauded Kenwright.
Let me ask you this Barry.
Do you think that Kenwright realised that you were not actually applauding him - or is it more likely that he took it as a ringing endorsement of his tenure - and that he has a popular mandate to continue in the same mode?
A simple question that requires a simple answer.
68 Posted 16/09/2011 at 13:07:44
I just love it.
Of course the fans were only demonstrating their support for the team by applauding when Blue Bill appeared on screen. I mean it's not as if they could simply have greeted it in silence, could they? They just had to cheer!
Just wondering how many of Toffeeweb's "anti-Kenwright" posters who were at the match on Saturday felt the compulsion to applaud Blue Bill?
69 Posted 16/09/2011 at 14:54:18
70 Posted 16/09/2011 at 17:00:35
Behind the grim figures lies the grim reality that robbie @55 spelled out, we own nothing apart from player contracts.
71 Posted 16/09/2011 at 19:36:38
Manchester United. Sale of shares in Singapore. Trouble is on the way, big time. And if you think Leeds U and Portsmouth were bad, then, as the old saying goes, "you aint seen nothing yet"
Prepare, as in most of the Premier league, for Armageedonn. Sorry for the spelling but hey, It's not the end of the world is it?
72 Posted 16/09/2011 at 21:10:11
;-)
73 Posted 17/09/2011 at 14:34:47
There is an unhealthy concentration on accounting conventions that tell us absolutely nothing of the business eg, PBT, amortisation, depreciation etc.
It really feels like what happens when you ask an accountant to tell you about a business. The focus on accounting rather than business.
74 Posted 18/09/2011 at 18:58:41
"So is there anything that Everton can do?... five possibilities: (a) be successful on the pitch; (b) cut costs; (c) build a new stadium; (d) find a wealthy benefactor; (e) focus on youth."
Eh, even Bill Kenwright is sure to have thought these thoughts. Chelsea have shown that finding a wealthy benefactor does not entail the cutting of costs. This club will go down the drain that very day on which the Russian Intelligence Service drugs and drags their owner back to Moscow for a monkey-in-a-cage trial à la Khodorkovsky. Moreover, there are times when the cutting of costs may even prove harmful. This article is clearly written by a chartered account - an unimaginative lot to be sure:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMOmB1q8W4Y
75 Posted 18/09/2011 at 19:18:50
"So is there anything that Everton can do?... five possibilities: (a) be successful on the pitch; (b) cut costs; (c) build a new stadium; (d) find a wealthy benefactor; (e) focus on youth."
Eh, even Bill Kenwright is sure to have thought these thoughts. Chelsea have shown that finding a wealthy benefactor does not entail the cutting of costs. This club will go down the drain that very day on which the Russian Intelligence Service drugs and drags their owner back to Moscow for a monkey-in-a-cage trial à la Khodorkovsky. Moreover, there are times when the cutting of costs may even prove harmful. This article is clearly written by a chartered accountant - an unimaginative lot to be sure:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMOmB1q8W4Y
76 Posted 19/09/2011 at 10:51:57
77 Posted 19/09/2011 at 11:29:07
However, the commentary and analysis of the data is extremely weak, bordering on amateur. As has been said above, the blog is clearly written by an accountant with little or no experience of working in a 'real' business environment. I'm guessing it's written by an auditor.
In particular, I'm referring to the commentary around needing to reduce the wage bill and sell players every year in order to 'breakeven'.
Unfortunately the 'breakeven' he's referring to is an accounting breakeven, rather than cash. Not only are these numbers extremely different but the accounting number is completely irrelevant in terms of analysing a business' real performance.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 15/09/2011 at 14:09:45
It shows that we are in serious debt, but so are many other clubs. It goes as far as suggesting the options available to getting us out of debt, the best of which is to adopt a sell to buy policy. Then put part of the income aside to pay it off. Seems like that is what we are already doing!
A very interesting and informative read.