Fellaini to reprise Pienaar saga?

, 15 September, 20comments  |  Jump to most recent
With no apparent sign of an end to the many months of talks being held on a new contract for Marouane Fellaini, the fear is growing that Everton may be forced to sell the player next year to avoid a replay of the Pienaar saga.

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Daily Post



Reader Comments (20)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Anthony Hughes
1 Posted 15/09/2011 at 15:58:41
it looks like the countdown to the inevitable happening.
Rob Birks
2 Posted 15/09/2011 at 16:33:02
I mean, what's he on now, and what is he asking for? if he wants what Tata was getting then I'd honour that salary. We've got to keep our assets, not sell them off!
Matthew Williams
3 Posted 15/09/2011 at 16:57:26
Its craazy really, it is obvious he is not going to sign especially with the club showing zero ambition. we should have sold this summer so at least we could have recouped what we paid for him, we will now end up selling next year for 5-7 million and you wonder why the club is in a mess.
Wayne Smyth
4 Posted 15/09/2011 at 17:05:37
I disagree rob. I don't think we can afford to pay a defensive midfielder 70k / week. If he were a striker banging in 20 goals a season then its a different matter.

He's an excellent midfielder, but replaceable with someone of a similar standard. Given a few years I think Rodwell could do about as good a job.

If Fellaini doesn't want to sign for 40-50k / week then I'd ship him out to the highest bidder(we should get £20m for him), and use that money to reinforce the squad with a couple of up and coming youngsters.

Without investment we will need to be a selling club to have any chance of staying in this league and maybe winning something. With our current income, we cannot afford individuals on 70k / week.
Gary Leonard
5 Posted 15/09/2011 at 17:34:02
It was to be expected. He's a fine player. I'd like him to stay, but if he's not going to, let's get the best price for him and replace him.
Michael Mcloughlin
6 Posted 15/09/2011 at 17:53:49
Great player, great prospect. But we have ot be realistic. If he is not oging to sign, Get as much as we can for him.
Steve Sweeney
7 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:22:42
At the beginning of next season his value will be virtually nil, he will sit on the remaining 9 months and then get
a massive signing on fee plus wages of
£80/90K per week.
Wake up guys
His contract wil be worth £25+over five years and he will also benefit from a signing on fee of upto another £10m.
Sign for Blue Bill and this lot of clowns you must be joking.
I bet he has an injury around December which means he cannot be sold in January,
The Guy is doing a Pienaar/McMannaman
Denis Richardson
8 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:26:33
Wayne, I'd be very surprised if anyone offered 20m for him. There are only a few 'rich' clubs out there that would cough up that much cash for a defensive midfielder - and they all more or less have that position covered, with argualby better players.

If we get what we paid for him, I think that would be a good deal. However, the longer we wait the less chance that will happen. Cannot see someone offering 15m in Jan and by next summer he'll be in his last year, we may have already missed the boat, will have to see.

I dont blame the guy for stalling on the contract given where we are at the moment.
Peter Laing
9 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:34:56
Sign of the times and all too predictable. David Moyes team looks to me to be getting dismantled before our eyes, how long is he going to want to stick around with the asset stripping policy that currently pervades. I have given up caring to be honest, the apathy and stagnation around the Club at the moment is rancid. Blue Union have tried their best to increase the pressure on the board to make them accountable for their lack of support for the manager, it appears that we are currently in the minority though, to Kenwright et al and his supporters you reap what you sow and your welcome to it.
Peter Laing
10 Posted 15/09/2011 at 18:41:35
In addition it makes me wince to read some of the FM posts constantly being bandied around on here, the excuses, justifications etc etc, do me a favour and leave that to Robert Elstone and Ian Ross. I want to support my team, the Manager and the Players, watch our finest player's ply their trade not be in the shop window for the next round of Jim White's super transfer deadline day dealings.
John Ford
11 Posted 15/09/2011 at 19:41:51
Peter,I agree. I ignore most of whats said in football, even at Everton as its mainly the usual merry go round.

Not much gets to me but when I see things like this on the horizon it really highlights our status, its just depressing.

As you say just how long will Moyes put up with this. You cant just keep selling your best players and hope you can find a replacement on the cheap who's just as good. The more you do it the more your chances of getting it wrong and weakening the squad. Rooney Lescott Piennar Arteta (although right time right price). All players 'made' by Everton. How nice would it have been to see a new talent like Fellaini coming to the fore at Everton. How pissed must Moyes be.
Dick Fearon
12 Posted 15/09/2011 at 20:49:49

Fellaini or any other player wanting to leave is merely a symptom of the pernicious malaise dragging Everton down.
The atmosphere around the club is poisonous and has been growing steadily worse for the past ten years.
In our different ways we have each contributed toward this depressing situation.
The finger of blame is pointed not only at Kenwright and his board but also at those venomous poison pen letter writers that are so quick to tip the bucket over everything connected with the running of the club.
In all the years I have been a follower of TW has anyone come up with a single viable solution to any of the problems.

unless their is a replacement standing in the wings screaming for BK to sell up til your blue in the face is a complete waste of time.
In all those years not one prospective and feasible buyer has come to the fore. To say that secrecy clauses are the reason why not one of these potential buyers has been named is quite simply conspirational theory poppycock.
If we learn one thing from the LFC experience it took the threat of bankruptcy to bring about regime change.
Even in then it is yet to be proved if a long term gain was made by swapping one set of yankee leveragees for another set of yankee leveragees (spelling?)
Perhaps the threat of bankruptcy could be the catalyst that could force our fabulously wealthy directors to open their purse strings or face losing the lot in a fire sale.


Jay Harris
13 Posted 15/09/2011 at 21:42:27
It sounds to me that Moyes was putting him in the shop window by alerting other clubs to his contract situation.

Appy Arry will be on to his agent now starting the undermining of his contract talks with Everton.

Gerry Grimes
14 Posted 15/09/2011 at 21:45:05
Can't disagree with much of the above, but I really believe Fellaini is central to any future the current team has.
All we can ask for is best efforts are made to sign him up. If his mind is set elsewhere ,there's little we can do about it.
I trust Moyes, but I wish I could believe the business people around situations like this are up to the task.
Watching Arteta last night, it was difficult to blame the lad. Massive stadium on a Wednesday night in Europe is where any footballer worth his salt should aspire to be. If Fellaini wants the same, who can blame him.
Nick Armitage
15 Posted 15/09/2011 at 21:55:50
I will be utterly gobsmacked if he stays.

If we can't keep kids who love the club, then what chance have we got with him?

They once said that no player is bigger than the club, well we are now being proved wrong. Wayne Rooney will soon be worth more than Everton and that is why he left.

Barkley will go, Coleman will go, Rodwell will go and so will any of the others if they are good enough.

Under Kenwright we have turned into a feeder club - nil satis nisi optimum my fucking arse.
Peter Cummo
16 Posted 16/09/2011 at 00:33:49
Soon as I heard last season that Fellainis old man/agent,was advising him not to sign a new deal 'because bigger clubs are interested' I guessed the writing was on the wall and I firmly beleive that whatever we put on the table won't be acceptable to daddy, like most fans I'd love him to stay but ?????
Simon Watts
17 Posted 16/09/2011 at 07:25:59
No doubt he was in a hotel on holiday in the summer, where miraculously members of the Tottenham board where there. As what happened with Pienaar. Pienaar, what he did should be illegal. He knew what he was doing, and it is little satisfaction his career has bombed, and he is forever injured and falling down the pecking order. Fellaini is a good player, but Everton did better last year without Arteta and without Fellani. Problem Everton have got is that we will struggle to get good value for him, as other clubs know now we have no money, and wait to pounce like vultures to get players on frees or cut down prices. ie Yobo, Yakubu, Pienaar. 19 million paid and 5 million back.
Simon Harris
18 Posted 16/09/2011 at 06:46:13
Dick #12 - "In our different ways we have each contributed toward this depressing situation."

I'm not sure what to make of that statement - it's very much subjective, but the vast majority of fans have stood by the current regime despite often being treated with contempt. Kings Dock, Fortress Funds, DK to name three almighty blunders, that have exposed the clubs appalling communication with it's fans.

Then on the playing side, despite having what many consider(ed) the best young manager in the league, we sat bemused at the failure to invest when champions league football beckoned.

The Kenwright era has been littered with missed opportunities, our only strategy has been to speculate through lending and now that is finally unravelling before our eyes.

We're in this mess because the current board have failed to deliver. Sad but true.

There is by all accounts a lot of interest in EFC, so let's review the strategy that has failed to sell the club despite all this interest, starting with BK's self appointed role as, 'the best person to sell the club'. Is he really? History would suggest otherwise.
Pete Sullivan
19 Posted 16/09/2011 at 12:35:15
I get totally baffled and confused when people are coming on here and continually say "What are the alternatives ? " or "There are no other viable solutions" etc etc etc...hang on a sec...let's get one thing clear..the existing Board have not put one single penny into Everton Football Club..not one..the only thing we can be grateful for is that they haven't taken anything out - or so we are told. So under Kenwright's Stewardship.."giving David Moyes every penny we can to get players on the pitch" has been achieved by the EFC Limited Company borrowing money plus using our money plus Sky's money (ours again effectively) to fund getting "players on the pitch"..so what exactly should we be grateful for or happy with as regards the current board? As we stand now , if anyone were to buy us..could we be worse off..could we? If someone buys the shares and rapes the club funds for fees etc etc , further increasing debt and the finance problems what would be the value of their investment after that..? Why would anyone actually do that..destroy their own investment? So unless the person EFC was sold to was an unhinged lunatic, I don't see how we could not be worse off. The problem in all this is..as always..the amount wanted for the shares..the price offered to all (any?) of these people who have engaged in due diligence makes no business sense..so we remain lumbered with a captain who is steering the ship at increasing speed towards an iceberg...the only difference is we all know that it's there..we keep saying that it's there, but for some reason we should be glad we have a captain steering the ship on this course ? There are thousands of Everton fans who really do not want to be saying "I told you so" when we crash into the iceberg of administration but if there is no change in this ownership, there is nothing more certain to happen..it is just a question of when, not if...
Kieran Carr
20 Posted 16/09/2011 at 15:19:19
Lets just get realistic - this team will be sold off over the next18 months and the team needs to based around youngsters and value lower league players.If we understand that now we may just survive, otherwise we are Sheff wednesday waiting to happen.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads