Season › 2011-12 › News
More gloomy mortgage news
Quotes or other material sourced from The Guardian
Reader Comments (75)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 20/09/2011 at 15:47:21
If it wasn't so sad it would be comical.
3 Posted 20/09/2011 at 15:49:19
What the hell is this board up to, if this doesn't galvanise the fans against this shower of charlatans then i don't know what will.
4 Posted 20/09/2011 at 15:46:25
5 Posted 20/09/2011 at 15:58:29
So back to reality - will it be Barkley or Fellaini in January ........ or both !
6 Posted 20/09/2011 at 16:00:45
Anyone who still supports BK should, in the words or Malcolm Tucker, wake up and smell the cock!
Medium outlay on wages, consistently top eight in the richest league in the world, and we've sold off any future pot we had to piss in. We're pissing down our leg and into our socks. Fuck me I'm having a binge on the comfort eating tonight. Fish and chips with a fucking cheese cake on top.
Can anyone suggest a time when the bank will call in our overdraft as there's no money to pay the interest?
7 Posted 20/09/2011 at 16:12:49
After all, Bill Kenwright is one of us, he is blue to the core, and he used to go in the Boys' Pen. Plus he still has the support of a majority of fans.
So no, this is not a problem and the Blue Union should hang its head in shame for whatever it has done now.
8 Posted 20/09/2011 at 16:08:48
9 Posted 20/09/2011 at 16:19:37
Just 1 more excellent business decision made by the saviours in charge.
10 Posted 20/09/2011 at 16:39:56
11 Posted 20/09/2011 at 16:52:00
12 Posted 20/09/2011 at 16:56:27
Cynical, me...?
13 Posted 20/09/2011 at 17:02:08
This is serious but it is the reality.
Oh yes, an investor will be along shortly.
14 Posted 20/09/2011 at 17:08:08
15 Posted 20/09/2011 at 17:17:49
16 Posted 20/09/2011 at 17:32:26
17 Posted 20/09/2011 at 17:37:46
21 Posted 20/09/2011 at 18:28:25
Our whole board are not even creditworthy. They neither have the will, or the inclination to risk one penny of their own money. They will not put up any of their assets as collateral.
When you hear people quoting there are 35000 behind Bill, I reckon 34000 just want to go to the game and really can't be arsed with financials - and who can blame them?
22 Posted 20/09/2011 at 18:28:35
This is a very important question.
23 Posted 20/09/2011 at 18:59:59
24 Posted 20/09/2011 at 18:57:59
Attentances are falling.
25 Posted 20/09/2011 at 19:43:10
26 Posted 20/09/2011 at 19:44:45
27 Posted 20/09/2011 at 19:53:47
Threadneedle investment also own shares in Vibrac and these are an investment company who, in there sports portfolio list Liverpool fc as one of their clients.
Didn't have time to dig deeper but i suspect all is not being revealed about this loan ?
28 Posted 20/09/2011 at 22:05:22
Formation, are involved with Investec; they lent us £13 million?
Investec are involved with James Grant Sports. James Grant act for Rodwell and Hallam Hope. James Grant are involved with Vibrac.
Vibrac have just lent us £14 million?
We are borrowing money off football agents!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Don't know who Barkley's agents are?
29 Posted 20/09/2011 at 22:38:08
This Loan stuff out of the blue makes me wonder, can you get him to look at this, and also, thanks to Dave above, all that I ask for is transparency.
I am sure we would all like to know where we are, that can be a base for progressing in some way rather than dealing in smoke and mirrors.
30 Posted 20/09/2011 at 23:15:48
31 Posted 20/09/2011 at 23:39:52
The Swiss ramble thing has just been shown to be largely accounting magic numbers and the actual cash loss per year is closer £3mn than the £20mn quoted. Far from it being us needing to sell a £20mn player every season its actually a £20mn player every 6 seasons on current going.
Likewise here. We have been taking on these 1yr loans secured on the coming seasons TV revenue for years. We pay them down each year and take on a new one to cover the shortfall from paying the last. Its no way to run a business but its hardly uncommon. Securing the loan against TV money a season ahead wouldnt seem such a risk either as we pay the loan off at the end of the season anyway....its a 1yr loan!.
This story seems to boil down to the fact that we've paid down last years loan and gone to Investec for this years. They've not played ball so we've gone elsewhere and got a better rate.
If you look at it this is a very short term, sub-prime, loan. Getting that at 10% or less doesnt seem so terrible when you look at the Bear Stearns loan running in at just short of 8%?.
Apart from the obvious stupidity of getting into the situation where we live off these 'payday loans' I dont see what the need for the big drama is here?.
32 Posted 21/09/2011 at 00:22:15
33 Posted 21/09/2011 at 02:02:13
34 Posted 21/09/2011 at 08:16:29
Given the recent sales of players, loans, wage savings and Bellefield an annual debt service amount in excess of £20m must have been there, the trouble now is does this level reflect a one off or the new normal level?
35 Posted 21/09/2011 at 08:49:50
Apart from the fact Barclays won't touch us, and we can't find the funds for day to day expenses, and we can't afford to buy a player, and the fact we have the smallest squad in the Premiership, you're right - no drama at E.F.C.
36 Posted 21/09/2011 at 09:13:40
Its irrelevent. We pay down one years loan and leave ourselves short we take another loan out. Its cashflow and, likely, cheaper than the interest were paying on the overdraft, its doesnt add up to anything outside of the £3mn or so cash loss. £3mn cash loss by the way that can be reduced with the reduction in the wage bill....if that is what we've managed to do.
If you dont believe me the Swiss Ramble blokes comments are quite clear....now:
"So, to answer your question, assuming that they sell no players, Everton would have to find at least £22m savings for an accounting break-even and £3m savings for a cash break-even. Of course, this also assumes that the club buys no new players."
Kevin,
You want to go and read what I wrote again fella?. By all means sharpen your pitchfork, light your torches and all the rest. Dont go off half-cocked because you've read a story on the net and not taken the time and care to actually make sure what you are getting fired-up about is really an issue.
Getting led by the nose doesnt make you the revolutionary hero mate.....just a mug.
37 Posted 21/09/2011 at 09:49:42
38 Posted 21/09/2011 at 10:11:11
Specifically for this loan though the fevered responses of how much deeper this digs us in etc doesnt seem warranted. This loan appears to just be same old, same old and, like I said to Kevin, theres no problem with people getting twitchy about the general state of things but getting all fired up over a nonsense story like this just makes us look stupid doesnt it?.
39 Posted 21/09/2011 at 10:17:22
40 Posted 21/09/2011 at 10:23:07
41 Posted 21/09/2011 at 10:39:26
The plan is flawed and plain daft, similar to the logic of Finch Farm, if you've read the report on PFI burdens in Scotland thanks to the Labour Government before the SNP got in on the BBC website its pretty clear that this short term blinkered idea is catastrophically wrong. The money will need paying and its as bad a gamble as any as its an increasing self perpetuating spiral unless one of the board members finally puts their own hands onto their pockets and speculates on the club beyond their shares.
42 Posted 21/09/2011 at 11:00:53
43 Posted 21/09/2011 at 10:52:42
I think I used the word 'stupidity' to describe the practice of using these payday loans. You work it out. I'm saying that THIS loan, as in the topic of THIS thread, is normal service and nothing new to get fired up about.
Kevin,
The point of this thread is to discuss ONE loan and its implications for the club. Many above were claiming it was one more nail in the coffin. Reality is that its just the way things have been done for years and nothing new.
You want to get swept along with the angry mob its your business. Me, I want to know whether what I'm reading is the truth before I get angry about it, i reckon anyone who doesnt is a mug. See all the vitriol on the Swiss Ramble thread. Turns out the guy was selective in what he was writing...didnt stop the sheep getting herded along did it?.
Gavin,
You might have missed the bit where I wrote: "Apart from the obvious stupidity of getting into the situation where we live off these 'payday loans". Anthony missed it as well....funny eh?.
The point is that this is not, as written here, something that warrants comments about our impending relegation or having to sell players to recover the money. This is the same business that we have been doing for years. Yes its massively stupid.....its been proven beyond shadow of doubt that the chairman and a good proportion of the board ARE massively stupid or willfully ignorant....this isnt damned well going to push us into insolvency though!.
I'm saying Gavin that the worst this represents is, as you say, a marginal but repeating increase in interest repayments. Lets put it in context though knocking Yak off the wage bill has likely offset any increase in interest, from this loan and the next few years already.
44 Posted 21/09/2011 at 11:04:26
45 Posted 21/09/2011 at 11:19:59
At what point does the cyclical misuse of short term loans just to provide operational cashflow become an issue which cant be resolved through flogging what remaining playing staff we have left?
46 Posted 21/09/2011 at 11:23:54
No I got your point and I was trying to show that I agree with you. Using these loans is stupid and indefensible, but, the damage is done isnt it?.
Unless, perhaps, we ring fence the money raised from the player sales this last window then paying down this loan will again require us to take another one out. I'd have no problem if that was the case and we managed to break the dependency cycle on this kind of loan. I imagine the keen followers of our net spend and those who like to present cakes might have a slightly dimmer view on that.
Regardless the point I'm making here is that this loa is not the end of the world and, of all the things that Evertonians should get all agitated about, this isnt one of them.
47 Posted 21/09/2011 at 11:29:34
Completely irrelevant that this poor fiscal policy has been around for the past three years.
You cannot defend bad management & poor planning, if you want to, be my guest.
48 Posted 21/09/2011 at 11:54:46
I'm saying that ON THE TOPIC OF THiS THREAD that this loan does not warrant the bullshit about fearsome interest rates, relegation, player disposals or any of the other rubbish written in the early posts on this thread!.
I didnt say anything about our management or planning....certainly nothing positive. I did say something about fans jumping on a bandwagon without having the wit or care to actually look into what they are reacting to though.
49 Posted 21/09/2011 at 12:23:00
I BLAME HIBBERT!!!!!
50 Posted 21/09/2011 at 14:10:29
Thanks Steve Jones for putting this in perspective. Its not news is it - we're badly run but this is not something to get excited about and start marching again.
post 40 - pretty childish aren't you - i remember in the playground being asked who's side I was on and found it tedious then!!
not that apparent on this site but we have a footy match tonight - I reckon a sneaky win on penners?
51 Posted 21/09/2011 at 14:38:01
52 Posted 21/09/2011 at 14:58:56
How the fuck can you blame Hibbert without mentioning Osmans part in all these shennanigans is beyond me.
Try and be more balanced in future young man.
53 Posted 21/09/2011 at 15:13:23
"I think I used the word 'stupidity' to describe the practice of using these payday loans"
".....its been proven beyond shadow of doubt that the chairman and a good proportion of the board ARE massively stupid or willfully ignorant.."
which part of those statements do you think supports the current regime then?.
54 Posted 21/09/2011 at 15:25:38
55 Posted 21/09/2011 at 15:34:52
56 Posted 21/09/2011 at 16:18:16
It seems like there business practices got us into this financial mess so at least do something decent and lend us the money without taking a profit. If only they treated Everton's interst like they treat their own.
57 Posted 21/09/2011 at 17:34:04
58 Posted 21/09/2011 at 18:55:24
"For the third consecutive season we have advanced a relatively small amount of next season's TV money.
"Each season the amount is repaid in full and then the loan is repeated at the same level, with no increase in overall debt levels. This is a very familiar source of finance to football clubs.
He added: "We were pleased this summer to find a lender able to offer us better terms than previously."
Anyone spot the contradiction?
59 Posted 21/09/2011 at 18:50:19
60 Posted 21/09/2011 at 21:49:17
Something very fishy in both the requirement to have this degree of financing after the recent fire sale, and the degree of collateral required.
61 Posted 21/09/2011 at 22:48:20
Bellefield was stated as tagged for debt reduction well before that and the only other disposal before the loan was taken was Vaughany which was only a few mill with his wages included.
The need for 2 seasons money as securitisation is an odd one though I'd agree with that. If it was through us being a bad credit risk you expect the lender to ask far more than the 10%-or-less rate mentioned?..
62 Posted 21/09/2011 at 23:04:29
63 Posted 21/09/2011 at 23:11:45
I don't think it's a non-story; I think it's getting close
to uncle bill finally realising he's been painting for ages and that's a fuckin' corner he's stuck in!
64 Posted 21/09/2011 at 23:32:27
65 Posted 21/09/2011 at 23:46:01
That's the point, pal ? it isnt hocked as the loan is repaid by then. No loan exists with any claim on that season's money.
It is a non-story and it won't teach the chairman a thing because a) we can keep on doing this year after year until one day we flog another big catch and don't need to do it any more... or b) the chairman isn't likely to understand the fiscal realities anyway is he?
66 Posted 21/09/2011 at 23:56:17
67 Posted 22/09/2011 at 00:21:50
As for the Arteta deal, people need to remember that we didn't get £10 million in used tenners to stick in the bank at the close of the transfer window. No doubt there are agents' fees, I think there was a sell-on fee to his former club, maybe some money to Arteta himself (though maybe not as he put in a transfer request and this may have been forfeited) and likely some other money going out too. Arsenal probably did not pay the balance in cash, it could be a series of payments over a period of time. So, when the question is asked: "What happened to the £10M for Arteta?" ? it's probably coming in over a period of time in the next few years. All an educated guess because I don't know the terms of the deal.
I'm not saying that the Everton management team are doing a fantastic job ? though I do support Mr Kenwright et al ? but, without being privvy to ALL the financial data, I can't really make an informed decision one way or the other.
Finally, if someone were in the market for a football club, they would be put off Everton simply because we need either a new ground or massive redevelopment. And that's going to be very expensive.
68 Posted 22/09/2011 at 09:01:56
You appear to be missing the fact that this cycle of debt is one that allows us to lose £5mill a year ? WHILE NOT BUYING PLAYERS.... This would appear to be the most pertinent part of the current financial mess that you are avoiding.
69 Posted 22/09/2011 at 10:29:53
I'd doubt the chairman does anymore than rubber stamp these things on behalf of the board. He appeared to be very distinctly divorced from the operational running of the business in his BU meeting.
Ciaran,
I'm not talking about the general state of club debt here though am I? I'm talking about this specific loan and the massive over-reaction that has been made to it from some elements of the fanbase as per the earlier entries on the thread. What bothers me is the readiness, of some fans, to use any stick to beat the club with ? without checking first that they do actually have a stick in their hands!
Getting all shouty about specific topics that then turn out to be non-events, like this, just makes us all look like fools. Better for all of us that some Evertonians get shown the need to check what it is they are going to kick off about before they do so. Fairr comment?
If you want to talk about the club making a cash loss of up to £5M a year without buying players perhaps start a new thread on it?
70 Posted 22/09/2011 at 11:09:37
You cannnot distinguish this loan from the framework that precipitates it. To do so is naive.
You may think that a financial model ? which this loan is symtomatic of ? that results in a financial loss and no player aquisitions is not worth comment...
I happen to think it is.
71 Posted 22/09/2011 at 11:52:29
I've made no comment about the club's wider financial performance. It's not relevant to this thread.
I've said that the practice of taking these short-term loans represents unadulterated stupidity. The fact remains though that we have taken them out in the past and that, without a way to plug the gap, paying down the previous season's loan will demand that we have to do so again. Calling it stupid, whilst accurate, changes nothing does it?
If Moyes is asked to forgo spending the Arteta money in January so that we can pay down this Vibrac loan without having to tap into the TV revenues, does that leave us better off? By the £1M we'll save on interest for the next year's loan... and the next year's... and the next etc I guess. We'll save a million on the wage bill when Yobo finally goes though so does that offset these interest payments?
Is it worth more to us to bring in a new face or two in January off the back of Arteta's sale or is it better to cease our dependency on these short-term 'advances'? I can't call that one.
72 Posted 22/09/2011 at 12:52:57
73 Posted 22/09/2011 at 13:48:12
Doesn't your £30M figure include £10M from the Arteta sale plus the £3-4M on his wage savings? If that is the case then, as stated before, this loan was set up before that deal was confirmed, wasnt it?
The question would be, I guess, what debt did the Bellefield and Pienaar money pay down? ? as it obviously wasn't the 1-year loan from last year. Rumours were something to do with the overdraft. I can understand it, if the bank wanted us to cut down our overdraft, that putting in £10M from those two sources would do that. It would also not contradict the statement from the Swiss Ramble chap of our cash losses being just a few million and not the £20-odd million that scare stories often seem to talk about.
74 Posted 22/09/2011 at 14:54:04
Indeed, the loan has nothing at all to do with our perilous financial state ? and can be debated in isolation.
75 Posted 22/09/2011 at 16:23:31
"The loan is a one-year facility for £14m, replacing a mortgage agreed with Investec 12 months previously, in which this season's central funds were signed over to the bank."
From the OP's thread starter. The thread is to discuss this one loan and its ramifications. What is your problem with that?
If you want to discuss the clubs wider finances open a new thread to do so. We wont be talking very much about THIS loan in it though because it is damn near inconsequential.
That's why ON THIS THREAD its important to make the distinction. This loan....no issue. Evertons financial status... many issues. Let's not fudge together two issues which can remain happily seperate.
76 Posted 22/09/2011 at 16:40:14
Has anyone got an answer to who Vibrac are? ? and I don`t mean, "t may be this" or "I think it`s that"; I am talking about a real answer?
77 Posted 22/09/2011 at 17:22:33
I think, were the news to come out tomorrow that the Arteta money was going to be used to pay down Vibrac, that all those who watch our net spend and present cakes etc would have a serious hissy fit.
Especially now that news has leaked about Moyes potentially getting a bit to spend in January.
Who're Vibrac? To be honest who're Investec? I have to admit I hadn't heard of Bear Stearns before 2002 and our loan with them!
78 Posted 22/09/2011 at 23:35:39
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 20/09/2011 at 15:38:23