Season › 2011-12 › News
A gameplan that does not work
Manchester City 2 - 0 Everton
Match Summary
Everton made just one change from the side that beat Wigan at Goodison Park last weekend, although six of them were in action midweek in the struggle to beat West Brom in extra time.
Everton started brightly, swinging crosses in from either side with Rodwell having a rather lame poke from distance too. Baines's first free kick was poor, though and Osman lost the ball, then Baines cut inside but his shot was woeful as Everton totally dominated possession in the first 5 minutes.
A poor defensive header by Jagielka almost let Dzecko in. They inevitably had more possession but were denied space and effectively stymied by dogged defensive work from the boys in Royal blue.
Aguero's first effort on goal came on 18 mins out of very little but he screwed his shot over, as Everton's forays penetrated less and less, while Rodwell went in the book for a sliding tackle on Silva.
Neville switched with Rodwell with the same result: an incident off he ball had the Ethiad crowd screaming after Silva blatantly dived over Neville's leg yet the Everton captain went in Howard Webb's book followed by Osman who tangled with Richards before the half-hour. Yaya Toure was also booked for a late tackle.
City structured something approaching a second chance that Dzecko also screwed over as Everton were forced to stand off a little under fear of more unjust cards. Aguero got his first shot on target that Howard saved well as he was fouled by Dzecko: not given. A poor clearance let Barry have a poke too but Moyes's "keep it tight" plan was holding, just as Everton looked for half-time.
Aguero ran into Baines to more howls but this time no Blues card as Everton let City probe and poke away at a very disciplined Blues defence, with the almost entire second quarter of the game being played in Everton's half.
Everton almost fashioned a chance for Cahill but it was laboured stuff on a rare visit to Hart's goal, and a rather wild cross from Hibbbert before the half-time whistle blew with the Moyes gameplan so far on track. <:P> City attacked with more zest after and Aguero almost forced a goal at Howard's near post before normal service resumed, with Lescott, Fellaini, Coleman and Kompany getting feisty. Aguero was forced to clip one wide from distance.
Some neat work down the Everton left led to a good strike by Osman, straight at Hart, while Howard was well placed to save from a Clichy cross. Fellaini did brilliantly to win a ball that was eventually delivered to Coleman whose hard cross was just too high for Cahill, his header going over.
A gifted series of corners allowed Everton to put some pressure on Hart but Mancini kept at least two attackers up and Everton failed to make use of the space in the City area.
Balottelli was swapped in for Dzeko on the hour as City appeared to become a little frustrated at their failure to break Everton down. Fellaini tried to get a break going but Cahill injured his ankle badly tackling Kompany and he became the fourth Everton booking before Louis Saha replaced him.
Nazri was forced to strike from 20 yards that Howard saved easily and Everton broke rather lamely with Fellaini squandering a good ball from Saha and in the next City attack they finally broke through, an Aguero backheel to Balotelli was deflected wide of Howard's dive by Jagielka's desperate block.
So the gameplan worked for almost 70 minutes, Silva then hitting the post as City smelt blue blood, shots flying in from all and sundry.
Royston Drenthe came on for Phil Neville with 17 minutes left as the Blues became more aggressive in trying to win the midfield. but it was worth nothing when Webb refused to give a free-kick for a blatant Kompany block on Saha, perhaps because he did not want to give Everton a penalty..
Milner replaced Aguero as Drenthe strated to have more impact and Vellios came on in place of Coleman and Everton went full-blown 4-4-2 for the last 10 minutes. An Osman corner came out to Drenthe but he drilled a half-chance over Hart's bar.
Howard had to be alert for a low curling shot from Toure as City won a few corners that kept Everton at the wrong end of the field. Jagielka became the fifth yellow card for Everton. In the last minute, a poor Drenthe mistake allowed City to run at Everton and Milner got the ball in the net to underline the ultimate pointless of Moyes's much vaunted gameplan.
So... the brilliant gameplan, brilliantly enacted by Everton, worked for all but 10 or 15 seconds of the game... and the result? Null points. Voodoo broken.
Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page
Reader Comments (118)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:42:40
We'll have to grind out results against the poorer teams unfortunately.
A long hard, boring season ahead (football wise)!
3 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:41:39
A midfield with no creativity, Rodwell doing a man marking job on Silva (which was mostly ineffective), no forwards on the pitch for most of the match..
The most embarrassing and annoying thing about this whole shambles was the continuous refusal to put anymore than 4 players in the box for any corners we managed to get...
They're a great team, but that was lay down and die mangement, selection and tactics.
Pathetic.
I can't believe I gave up a day of pre-paid salmon fishing for that garbage.
4 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:47:35
Negative tactics equals negative results. This no strikers thing is winding me up.
5 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:45:15
There's a difference between clubs being wealthy and a club having, effectively, completely unlimited money. It's great when we sometimes beat those clubs in a single match situation but really, sitting there watching us lose to them, it's like "well, whatever". Beyond enjoying individual games in themselves, I've lost all interest in the wider context of the Premier League.
6 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:52:31
7 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:52:50
Dull and fucking boring shite and David Moyes gets paid a shit load of cash to do that FFS.
8 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:58:40
Give it a fucking break. Todays performance was down to Moyes and his negative tactics.
9 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:02:36
I agree with what you say completely.
CiarĂ¡n
Perhaps Robin was talking in a wider context. If we hadn't made those two mistakes it would have been a nil-nil and not many teams will get a point there this season. I do agree though, it was negative.
10 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:59:15
11 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:57:26
Armchair managers might notice that in fact we only actual conceded when we were forced to bring Saha on for Cahill...then conceded another when we went more attacking with Drenthe and Vellios.
So presumably the tactical mavens here would have had us play open attacking football from the start and get totally torn to shreds?
I'm depressed too, but more in line with Robin's post. The financial inequalities are making a total mockery of the Premier League as a sporting competition - why bother with building up a solid club, growing young players, picking up talent from lower leagues plus the odd star name splurge when you can just throw more and more money at the problem to buy all the best players...then earn more money by qualifying for the Champions League, etc.
If City win the league this year it'll be a fucking travesty, which is why despite my better instincts I'll be cheering for United. They may have spent silly money too at times, but they've actually brought through their own players too, stuck to some principles and have a proper heritage of success.
I'm usually more a glass half-full guy, but I'm increasingly hating City...and Chelsea...and an increasing number of footballers who are in the main greedy, totally unprincipled twats advised by scum-of-the-earth agents.
12 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:52:43
Spot on.
I'm afraid the financial mis-match amongst clubs is killing the game as an exciting and sustainable spectacle. Obviously not for the few rich clubs, but the thrill of competitive games across the board is greatly diminished.
The league has become a Scottish Premier League with everyone else cannon fodder for the few.
Nothing new here but I see no real prospect of any team challenging the top 3 or 4 clubs in the future which is not going to motivate me, and I suspect many others, to retain the enthusiasm for the game going forward.
You've got to have some kind of hope that your team can compete. Unfortunately that is almost gone I'm afraid.
A sad time for Everton, but more importantly, for English Football.
I think I'll whizz down to my local park and watch some non league football for a thrill!
13 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:09:46
Nail on head mate. If we had started the game with the players that ended it, we would have lost 6-2.
The inequality in the game needs to be addressed, at the moment the Premier League is a joke.
By the way, Webb's refereeing didn't do us any favours.
14 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:03:32
15 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:14:13
Robin is making a convenient excuse.
16 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:19:07
Maybe we would have won 7-6!
17 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:16:27
There's a reason why certain players cost what they do, BECAUSE THEY'RE FUCKING BETTER!! United, City and Chelsea will finish in the top 3, it's guaranteed before the season even starts. Stop living in the 80s thinking if we'd just go and attack all will work out well. If we'd just gone out and attacked it could have been worse than Arsenal's 8-2 thrashing to United. They carved us apart once we started to chase a goal. The only reason they didn't get more is they didn't have time and they knew the game was over already.
We went to try to get a draw, maybe stealing a goal. It was going well until a deflected goal. You live in a fantasy world if you think Everton have some starting line-up that could have matched up against Aguero, Nasri, Silva, Toure.
18 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:15:15
It took 100% effort and concentration just to stop them scoring. I can understand Cahill playing up front, but not where he was. Felliani is simply wasted where he was.
But what would you have changed?
As soon as Saha came on they scored due to him switching off.
Moyes tactics can and do frustrate, but I think it is symptomatic of wider problems within the game.
If Moyes possessed their embarrassment of riches going forward (ie Tevez and Balotelli on the bench) we wouldn't have started with two midfielders up front.
19 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:00:20
Just a few points to get off my chest:
- Jagielka clearly isn't playing well, and contributes to YET another goal... Why won't Moyes drop him and play our first choice Dutch international centre half?
- Why was Neville brought back?
- How the fuck does Leon Osman still get a game? Sorry but he is wank. Might do good aginst Wolves and Macclesfield Town but is CRAP otherwise. He is beyond defence that lad. Useless.
- Why didn't Drenthe and Vellios start, considering the difference they both made last week? Oh sorry answered my own question there, Moyes doesn't believe in attacking, exciting football does he.
- Why was Fellaini played as second striker? He is clearly a class centre mid - so fucking play him there Moyes you tool.
- Few plus points: Distin was solid, Howard was sound, Hibbert was solid, Baines was his usual composed self, Drenthe (apart from that pass) looked spot on and I really like the look of Vellios - got the markings of a traditional Everton centre forward.
I can totally understand going ahead and maybe sitting back second half a la last season but to go at it from the off is terrible. The game wound me up no end today because I thought Man City looked pretty ordinary, and we could most definately have got a win.
I am not anti-Moyes and am certainly no "apologist" (I hate that term), but he got it wrong again today, and is increasingly getting it wrong nearly every game.
Play like that next week and it's a certain defeat.
20 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:17:07
What you're right in is that a negative performance, while increasing the odds of a draw, probably also increases the odds of a defeat.
I don't see how it's a convenient excuse. Regardless of tactics, we're far more likely to lose to City in any single game situation than not, simply because of the disparity of playing resources. And over the course of a season we're guaranteed to lose. And we're relatively lucky in one sense, in that we still at least have a team that on its best days can sometimes match the top teams. Never consistently, but occasionally.
The disparities in the Premier League are so great now, though, that it's becoming pointless. I watched this match with less passion than I watched us against Wigan or Villa or QPR, because at least against those teams its a contest on relatively equal footing.
The depression comes from having no hope of really competing on any long term basis. That's exacerbated by Kenwright's ownership, but unless we "do a City", which would disillusion me just as much as our current decline, it's like two different games are being played.
21 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:19:46
'Armchair managers' probably also noticed that Cahill for Saha was a straight swap.
Your suggestion that we would've been 'torn to shreds' for playing attacking positive football from the start is nothing but conjecture..
As it stands, we got 'torn to shreds for playing negative defensive shite from the start..
But at least your a 'half glass full' kinda guy...
22 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:21:28
Stating the reason is not the same as an excuse. If my car gets a flat tire on the way to work and I'm 15 minutes late that's not an excuse, it's the reason. Stating the insane financial inequalities of the premier league is not an excuse as to why Everton can't compete against the like of City and United, it's the fucking reason.
City get a billionaire and buy anyone they want and they go from relegation contenders to the Champions League in a couple of years. The likes of Blackpool don't get a billionaire and they get relegated.
23 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:15:45
"Striker," Cahill making tackles on the edge of his own box, kind of summed it up for me.
Moyes tactically tried to mug Mancini today. Didn't work - too much respect shown.
24 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:19:39
Excellent first half from Everton. Rodwell superb maturity in a man-marking role for his age.
Lots of negative comments already, but to take City on toe to toe, then you get United/Arsenal repeat. It took a lucky deflection and one mistake when chasing the game to beat us.
In an already inbalanced financial league, what you at least hope for is a balanced performance from the ref. Webb was a disgrace and how he managed to book Cahill for attacking Kompanys studs with his ankles, god only knows. That was at 0-0 and the thug should have seen red.
Balotelli then rakes his studs down the back of Jags's achilles, free kick and nothing else.
25 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:25:02
----------------------
It's a convenient excuse because you didn't mention one factor to do with our approach in your opening post.
You simply implied that we were likely doomed to failure no matter what ? because of the financial divergence. That's a fucking cop-out in my opinion, given the context of that game and the way Moyes approached it.
That's why it's a convenient excuse.
26 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:24:08
Are you happy with players being played out of position?
Are you happy with the manager believing he is justifying his position and reputed £60k a week wages by playing a team half-full of defenders?
Don't give me that bollocks about Man City having a shedload of dosh meaning they have a God-given right to win games, therefor we should just hope for the best... What total bullshit.
As I stated, yes City are indeed a good side ? with a team like that of course they are ? but going off today just a LITTLE more attacking incentive from us would have got us something out the game, and even a win.
27 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:27:31
To slag the team and Moyes off is unfair, they showed pride in the shirt.
28 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:22:36
29 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:29:36
I was brought up with us being fucking awful, but I still would never expect us - nor any fucking team for that matter - to go and play for a draw. Totally and utterly WRONG.
30 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:29:21
Please don't try and explain causation to me. I'm not in the mood for your half-baked defences of mangerial alchemism.
31 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:29:49
"just a LITTLE more attacking incentive from us would have got us something out the game, and even a win."
It took eleven players simply to contain them, when you attack you leaves holes and they would have picked us apart. I don't like us playing without a striker, but I don't like watching us shipping 5 or 6. Losing by the odd goal or two is far better for long term confidence.
32 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:24:05
33 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:28:31
It simply is laughable to play any opposition with a makeshift striker (when did he last score a goal)? No excuses, just plain and simple shite tactics yet again.
For those who are saying look at City's team, so what, give the opposition something to fucking think about and not put the same predictable shite out week by week. Ever thought of having two strikers up front could actually alleviate some of the pressure on the defence and midfield?? No excuses, sorry.
34 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:29:32
That doesn't mean we don't have a chance in an individual game against them. But the disparities are so great that in the long run we *are* doomed to lose to them far more often than not, just as we're doomed to finish behind them in the league. It's last season's results that are the exception to the odds, rather than this defeat.
35 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:33:06
------------------
Fuck this...i'm away to the pub...you boys are like the Everton equivalent of the red hand gang.
For fucks sake, get angry for once!
36 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:36:16
It is the state of football that leaves us fighting with an arm tied behind our back.
Get angry with that.
37 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:33:40
Such big words from you. Half baked huh. Tell me why the richest clubs always finish in the top 4 spots of the league then. If money isn't the ultimate factor then why is it that only the richest clubs win the league? Go on, tell me. You obviously have some magic formula that would allow a poor team to simply play a certain way and render all those rich teams powerless on the pitch. So go on, what is this magic formula? I'm sure there is a club out there that would pay you a decent fee if you would let them in on the secret.
38 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:12:34
I don't understand the perseverance with playing no one up front. I especially don't understand the perseverance with constantly passing backwards until it reaches the central defenders and then punting the ball down the pitch when there's no fucker there.
Someone's bound to say "Cahill's a forward" ? He's not, but even if we let that go and say he is, he's shite at it. He spends all game challenging for long balls in the air but never wins any of them, he can't hold the ball up well enough, he gives away too many fouls, he hasn't scored for about 9 months, and he constantly pulls that stupid face where he looks like he's going to burst into tears at any given moment.
Not that I'd blame him if he did. Moyes tactics are enough to bore anyone to tears.
39 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:35:03
But DID it take 11 players to contain them? How do you know that if we started with say Drenthe and Vellios in place of Osman and Cahill respectively, we would have let in 5 or 6?
You are making out as if some of us want us to play gung ho like Blackpool last year, which is not the case. Just a bit more positive minded play from us is what I want, not playing for a fucking draw.
40 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:32:31
Fellaini really needs to learn how to hold the ball up, and he gave away possession too many times. Distin was excellent for us I thought. I would agree that we should have at least 1 recognised striker on the pitch though.
41 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:32:50
Moyes tried something and got close to getting something from the game. If Balotelli hadn't got the deflection that wouldn't have been a goal and who knows what could have happened if the sting hadn't been taken from the game through some awful decisions from the referee?!
44 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:36:12
Maybe some people are happy with that, but I'm not. I want to see pace the attitude to have a go. So what if we get beat, so fucking what? We got beat anyway.
The whole thing wants stripping down and rebuilding from top to bottom.
Verdict, utter SHITE!!!
45 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:54:30
For what it's worth I thought we did ok today and, had the fouls on Saha and others happened at the other end, the whistle would have been blown.
46 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:00:27
Shame there was more chance of me scoring with Pippa Middleton than us nicking a goal.
47 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:56:55
Like you I would love to see us have a go, but Spurs tried that and got mauled. I can't say that we would have let 5 or 6 in, but was it worth throwing a few kids to the lions and risking it?
I don't know.
Moyes is negative, but he isn't a fool. He has some gems there and risking smashing their confidence this early in the season would have done the club no favours.
Maybe I am wrong, this tactic frustrates the hell out me, but I honestly feel it is borne out of necessity and not choice.
48 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:50:32
It wasn't pretty, it didn't happen for us, we move on. We've been horrific against Blackburn, great against Villa, superior against QPR and in none of these games did we come home with what we deserved. If you make your own luck, luck can also go against you. Problem with today's game, the most luck would have given us was a 0-0.
49 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:01:00
50 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:09:51
51 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:03:51
I would maybe agree with you if the kids in question were defenders / defensive midfielders, but having a striker in place of a midfielder in a striker position... Well without sounding rude do I need to explain myself on that one? Vellios came on last week, made a difference and scored. Even today I don't think he put a foot wrong, and even set up Fellaini at the end. In the time he was on he won more headers and held the ball up better than Cahill. I'm not slagging Cahill off but why not just give him a go?
Drenthe is 23 and is certainly no kid. He has pace in abundance, creativity and will have a go. Osman is useless - sorry but he's shite - Drenthe in his place should have been a given. We still could have set up the same and attacked on the break - would have been way more beneficial than what the actual turn of events were.
Hindsight is a great thing but the above mentioned points to me is a great example of us wanting to properly get something out of the game without letting the defence go to shit.
52 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:06:30
Yet again our play was ponderous going forward at best. City had all the time in the world to get back.
Okay so we play a defensive game but for crying out loud, start with some pace up front and give their backline something to think about.
53 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:13:31
No strikers. No intention of trying to score.
Typical Moyes: negative shite anti-football.
54 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:09:28
In saying that, it's not good enough playing for a nil-nil ever. We lost anyway so what's the problem with actually trying to attack? Moyes at his absolue negative best.
And anyone still trying to justify the sale of Arteta as a footballing decision can fuck off. Neville in our midfield is an utter joke. Our club is being sunk by an inept chairman and a joke of a manager.
55 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:01:20
When you have nothing, you try and hold on, and we nearly did ? but hey, please don't go on about the world class players that Moyes refuses to play... because we don't have any. That's right, not a single fucking player who can give opposing teams a go.
56 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:13:25
I agree with the Drenthe for Osman, that is the no brainer for me.
Felliani is wasted where he was today, he controls games in midfield, but gets isolated by long balls up front. The Cup Final is all the evidence you need for that.
I also agree that Vellios did more than Cahill, but Cahill is a crafty bastard over 90 and are we sure Vellios could last a full 90? Don't forget, we played similar tactics there last season and how many times has Cahill been on the scoresheet in those sort of games (admittedly not often recently).
I am pissed off with today but there are shades of grey to football. Knee jerk reactions of "attack attack attack" are not productive (and I know that you are not being that simplistic).
57 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:24:31
I reckon Anichebe, but play him on the wing.
58 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:07:44
Bring back Gordon Lee.
59 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:27:50
60 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:06:37
In the Moyes interview when the subject of Rodwell shackling Silva was mentioned he looked so happy I thought one of the Sky Sports cuties was giving him a handjob.
He's got us into this position of having no forward threat but isn't arsed as long as he gets kudos for some defensive tactic.
He's as deluded as Kenwright, mind you so are some of the FM kids on here backing him up.
61 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:31:53
I'm not going to get depressed on this result but overall I'm reminded of the Jerry Maguire quote:
"That's how you become great man, hang your balls out there"
Any more good film quotes for Moyes ahead of the derby?
62 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:31:31
Once again, Moyes is so negative: no strikers to start with is a joke ? no other manager in the Prem would even think about it, let alone do it.
He starts with four attacking players on the bench, another joke. Why? Just for once, why can't he have a go and see what happens? If you're going to lose, better to lose 4-0 attacking than 2-0 like that.
63 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:26:12
It's Jon by the way, Cahill did well last season. But this is this season and hasn't earned his starting place. At least not as a striker. And for me even if Vellios is young, if you're good enough etc etc.
I agree about the money side of things but it's the attitude that counts. Moyes went for a draw, bad altitude. His fingerprint of negativity was there for all to see today. That's what I'm depressed about. I always had a feeling we'd lose this one but it's the way we always seem to be mentaly shackled.
64 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:32:05
Saddest piece of diving I´ve seen in a while, fucking overpaid scum.
Fellaini btw had a really, really poor game. If we were to stand a chance he would have had to be many, many times better than he was today.
65 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:18:28
I thought defensively we had a good game today, the first goal was a lucky deflection, the second a poor pass from Drenthe. We certainly didn't deserve to win it, but the defensive display if we had held out would have merited a draw. City have scored 19 goals in their opening 6 matches, so are not a team to 'have a go' at. They will beat any team in the league on their own turf that decides to go with an attacking formation. The only option is to play it tight and try to nick something. Unfortunately its hard to do that for a full 90 minutes without being punished.
My biggest growing concern is with Fellaini, who's first touch has become shocking, and who's body language looks as though he doesn't want to be on the pitch. During his brief period as one of our top players, he held the ball up and brought others into the game excellently. Without that, we suffer dreadfully as Osman or Rodwell are never going to give you that option. Dust ourselves off, and give the shite a good spanking next week. COYB!
66 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:44:06
If you're going to play it tight and try and nick something then you need a modicum of pace.
I fail to see how you would nick something when by the time we get down their end they've had time to get 11 men behind the ball.
If Cahill and Osman went any slower they'd be in reverse !
67 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:50:11
The cold hard truth is Moyes shit himself and went for containment which never works. Fulham had a real go against them last week and deserved their point.
Today was just a depressing reminder of the side of Moyes I despair to see.
68 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:54:25
69 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:03:34
I can't believe a huge amount of our fans still believe in this man.
70 Posted 24/09/2011 at 16:55:08
I actually did think ahead of time we could of got something out of todays fixture, after the recent results, even if it was mostly getting a result out of the jaws of banality. From what I can see Moyes went for a defensive approach today, chose not to attack from the off and the end product was another frustrating performance with no end product.
Granted, City are a good side and deserve their place in the league but it appears we lacked any fight or intensity again. Said it before, won't be watching this night.
71 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:07:38
72 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:01:22
73 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:06:13
I thought we did pretty well, with Rodwell playing well as man to man on silva. They got a jammy deflection from an overpriced no-mark. If Moyes could have got to 70 odd mins at nil-nil, I would have fancied us on the break with Drenthe and Vellios. But should they have both started ? nope.
Moyes has less money to spend than Walter before him, but thankfully the days of 5-0 don't seem to be that frequent against the Sky 4.
Seen plenty of fans come here with garbage with names like Di Matteo, Holloway etc. Moyes is still the right man for the job, his hands are tied but he gets on with it.
74 Posted 24/09/2011 at 15:57:39
He booked Neville without seeing the challenge; Rodwell got a similar result; and the taking down of Saha on the edge of their box was the icing on the cake.
If you don't get the rub of the green against the richest club in the world then you can expect sweet FA from this game.
Webb should ref in the Conference for a while to get his moral compass back.
But yea, we were still poor...
75 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:37:18
Those tactics today were an utter embarrassment to our great club. Anyone defending Moyes should watch rugby instead.
76 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:31:30
What did strike me though was when we had some corners, City left 2 players on the half way line. What do we do in such situations?
It's not so much today's tactics that hack me off, it's the tactics against the poorer sides, particularly at home, that earn Moyes the justified "defensive" label.
77 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:30:34
78 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:49:19
79 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:58:14
80 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:02:22
81 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:00:41
"A justified negative approach from Moyes in my view even if its depressing and rather turgid to watch."
Are you serious?
What on god's earth is the point of watching football if being negative is justifiable and it's depressing?
I'm at a loss here.
82 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:13:16
What does Drenthe have to do to get a Premier League start? Okay, he has to reward Pip after his goal in midweek... but surely not as a midfielder again.
When is he and others going to learn that Osman is still not strong enough for the Prem? Or did he think he is our answer to Silva? The strength of Everton where it matters will never improve with Osman there and don't tell me he is now a striker because he scores once in a blue moon.
Cahill is also rapidly becoming a player that's underachieving and doesn't have a true position despite his timely goals in the past. The new blood has to be used for crying out loud.
Most of us are sick to death of Moyes's tired excuses. He has lost the plot and a lot of other Premier League managers have realised this and will capitalize this season.
84 Posted 24/09/2011 at 17:58:00
Its monumentally narrow minded to criticise the manager for playing the same style which won the last two visits here. Pack out the midfield, restrict their passing and break when you can with Coleman Osman and Fellaini supporting Cahill where they could.
The only differeence today is that city are a better team than they were last year. Why? Because they just spend and spend and spend until they get a team good enough to challenge for silverware.
If we'd gone to city with two forwards yhey would have played us off the park a la Totenham. Moyes isnt to blame. The shitty world of top heavy footy finances is to blame. It results in total and complete inequality and we're left to pick up the fucking pieces.
Caeran, getting angry may get this shit off your chest but you sound so pissed off that you end up missing the real reasons we're in the shit . Dont blame our team and its manager for this deeply crappy situation, they did their utmost today.
85 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:17:21
86 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:06:59
If he had quality strikers in the squad fair enough, but he doesn't. Saha 33, unknown quantity in the Argie and a kid for fifty grand. Compare to Tevez, Dzeko, Aguero, and Balotelli ? price what £200m?
We are treading water until the next window, and I hope he gets some of the money that he created from player sales, cause it didn't come from anyone else (the board have put nothing in for 10 years). The league picks itself on cash and it's sad but Everton cannot compete. Stomping feet against Moyes will change nothing ? apart from taking Everton backwards.
87 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:16:34
We started to play a bit once we went behind, when he brought more offensive players on and thank god Cahill got injured or we would've had to watch that shite all game. How bad does Osman have to play before he is taken off ??
88 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:28:49
Well said.
According to this financial argument we should roll over for Liverpool next week ? not acceptable.
89 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:37:32
90 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:51:56
All time low for Moyes??? Get real, Complete nonesense. They hardly had a shot for the first hour.
If we go there with two in attack, we give them space and we'd probably have been slaughtered. We all want more but you're deluded to think anyone could do better in our circumstances.
91 Posted 24/09/2011 at 19:01:09
92 Posted 24/09/2011 at 19:41:05
93 Posted 24/09/2011 at 18:59:36
Saying that, hopefully the setup will be changed for next week's game and any in the future where we are not away against a "top 3" side.
94 Posted 24/09/2011 at 19:46:32
95 Posted 24/09/2011 at 19:39:11
Firstly, I'm not anti-Moyes and respect the job he has done, but he made us look a laughing stock today. Reading Robin's comments about the money issue made me fucking white with anger (I'm white anyway so hope you understand). What the fuck has the arab millions got to do with keeping 3 centre forwards on the bench and playing Tim Cahill running around all over the pitch like Forrest Gump with a blindfold as our most advanced player? Before I get slaughtered, same scenario as Moyes: great servant, but time stands still for no-one!
I didn't go today but just feel so sorry for the mighty Evertonians that did. If anyone can explain to me how we can win with 10 men behind the ball, I'm all ears.
Robin, wake up; Man City were shit-scared of us today but suddenly realised after about 15 mins that we were more scared of them.
Finally, Moyes ? stop fucking talking about your squad like they are Southport. It's packed with ability if you use them, eg, Saha is better than Cahill, Barkley is the most creative midfielder we have (surely not... he's too young), and Neville is better in the dressing room than on the pitch.
Never mind; we have signed a 40-year-old keeper, but he will probably start up front next week as Vellios is still too young!!!
96 Posted 24/09/2011 at 20:13:06
97 Posted 24/09/2011 at 20:50:09
"The best chance we had of winning today was to keep it tight, pack the midfield, break quickly and try to open up late if we could. Why is this so difficult to get?"
Because it's your opinion ? not fact.
Oh yeah, and we don't have the skill or pace to break quickly.
98 Posted 24/09/2011 at 20:24:12
True, you're going to have to defend for long spells against the top teams but to hope to do only that for 90 minutes is unrealistic. You're relying on every single player putting in a shift and working their socks off the whole game, relying on every single player not switching off once or making a single error the whole game, relying on the opposition to fail to create any clearcut chances or convert any half chances that come their way. You might pull it off for 60, 70 mins or longer but once the opposition manage to find a way through then that's your game plan well and truly fucked. You've got no way back in the game because the whole team has been selected and set up solely to defend and they can't suddenly switch from the ultra defensive mindset that's been drilled into them to one of all out attack. The opposition have been invited to dominate possession and make all the running the entire game and that's not suddenly going to change just because you throw a forward on as sub for the last ten minutes. It's too little, too late.
That's my half-arsed theory anyway. Then again I don't have an innovative tactician like Steve Round stood next to me, doodling away in a notebook and furiously nodding his head up and down for 90 minutes like he's Linda Lovelace in a fucking Everton trackie. Honestly, Moyes would be better off hiring the 'lovely' Debbie McGee as his assistant.
99 Posted 24/09/2011 at 22:21:17
Okay, apparently some think it was good we didn't lose by four or five or more. I don't agree. I don't think you can be so sure that playing Vellios and Drenthe in place of Osman and Neville from the start equals a slaughter?
I found today's approach embarrassing not clever. We set out to lose by a couple of goals and it worked perfectly. I don't think we would be more of a laughing stock if we had lost by five.
I do perfectly understand that the incredibly obscene gulf in finances means a lot over the season but today it didn't have to equal a massacre; we decided it meant certain defeat well before kick off as Davey's pre-match comments suggested.
I respect the views of those who see this as a reality check; I often argue on this basis myself. But today was taking it too far. Fulham came from two down to City by ATTACKING them and keeping hold of the ball. We simply caved in from the get go.
I cannot be sure that by being just a little more positive, not crazy OTT, it would have equalled disaster. I really think we can trouble defences in the weeks ahead and it may mean some draws and the odd thumping, but we draw way too many games and just four more wins a season would be worth the risk.
We will never know if there was a squeak we could surprise City because we were beaten from the start, just waiting to concede... and we did. Disappointing and not necessary is my honest view, and no amount of "spirit" changes that.
100 Posted 24/09/2011 at 23:49:21
Amazing what £300m can buy you though... And where not being able to spend anything in 2-3 years gets you. And we've beaten City 7 out of the last 8 before today despite this, and twice last season when I remember us playing very similar tactics.
101 Posted 25/09/2011 at 00:23:00
103 Posted 25/09/2011 at 06:30:49
104 Posted 25/09/2011 at 07:19:06
"Play it a again jags hoof it up the fucking middle" I'll be bacckkkk with more of this pathetic shit. Its a good job we have a sense of humour.
106 Posted 25/09/2011 at 09:40:26
Theres no excuse whatsoever for that utter shite yesterday! I dont care how much money city have spent and how little we have. To go there playing for a draw and possibly nick a win is simply not good enough! We are EVERTON FFS!!!! Also to start with no recognised striker on the pitch while 3 sit on the bench? WTF?
Theres no way anybody on here can justify giving moyes a higher wage packet and extending his contract
107 Posted 25/09/2011 at 10:11:33
I am just waiting for someone to say Citteh were there for taking.
We were too defensive, but did anyone else see Moyes waving at them to get further up the pitch, probably not, as it doesn't fit in with their "coward" nonsense.
Sky made me laugh, they give Silva man of the match. I thought Rodwell had one of his best games in a Blue shirt. SIlva didn't get a look in until it was 1-0 and Rodwell started leaving him to move forward.
We deserved nothing but its frustrating when their goals come from mistakes, the first one, it was our throw but Webb gave it to them and they score the deflected goal. The second, three players at fault, Drenthe for his cack pass, Jags for pulling out of the tackle (yellow card on his mind) and Howard for checking his run off his line. Three moments that could have stopped their goal.
Talking of Webb, gives a card for something that was completely missed (Zidane anyone?) Silva goes through Jags, nothing Bellotelli scrapes down Jag's leg, nothing. Kompany assaults Cahill, Cahill gets booked, Kompany completely bodychecks Saha, nothing, Baines fouled on the edge of the box, nothing, Good challenge by Rodwell on Silva, get the ball and is booked and the best was Ossie, all 5'5" of his shoulder challenging Toure, who stands at about 6'3" and gets booked. Stand up Mr Webb as one of the most biased and shithousey displays as a referee in a long time.
The 4-5-1 worked well enough the last few visits, it's a pity that Citteh can go out and buy superstars to beat their current hoodoo side
108 Posted 25/09/2011 at 10:29:34
Pathetic - Moyes seems to have a habit of avoiding all attacking options against the better sides, and his result - loss after loss after loss.
I can't wait for the League Cup tie against Chelsea...
109 Posted 25/09/2011 at 10:19:11
' Great entertainment ' '
Joe Hart having to pull out all the stops '
' Fulham still trying to find a winner here as well '
' This second half has really been a great advert for the premier league and Fulham '
Doesn't sound like Fulham ' Parked the bus ' does it?
110 Posted 25/09/2011 at 12:06:44
If thats the future football for us time to pack it in. Shite tactics and totally boring football no real threat all game.
111 Posted 25/09/2011 at 13:03:10
112 Posted 25/09/2011 at 12:45:24
113 Posted 25/09/2011 at 13:07:36
114 Posted 25/09/2011 at 14:07:19
115 Posted 25/09/2011 at 14:45:46
I for one would rather see us at least try play football that setup a constant negative formation with the sole purpose of frustrating your opponents.
Dave Moyes sets up the everton team just to do that even at home. Lets play football . If we fail doing that well so be it.Anything other than doing that is fanatism and tribalism , its not a love of a beautiful game.
116 Posted 25/09/2011 at 14:45:58
Ciaran Cahill definitely deserved a yellow but what about Kompany's stamp?
Brian, difference was with Fulham, they were 2-0 down early on so of course parking the bus wasn't really an option.
117 Posted 25/09/2011 at 15:06:47
118 Posted 25/09/2011 at 15:22:50
Fulham had a whole half to "go for it" and fair play to them they did manage it.
119 Posted 25/09/2011 at 15:15:40
120 Posted 25/09/2011 at 17:14:53
Moyes played the same tactics as our last two at City but they didnt work because they're a better team now than last yr and the yr before. We couldnt break often enough because our five in the middle were occupied just keeping city at bay.
All out attack with our squad would have been suicidal. Teams who try this just end up with some high spots but drop down over a season (last yr Bolton Sunderland Blackpool Wigan) Fair play to you if you'd rather die by the sword than by defence, I cant argue against that as a philosophy, only in terms of where we may end up.
Moyes knows more about winning games over a season than all the managers in the league bar those with squillions. There is noone gets more from their team.
The solution is to buy better players. We'll have enough for most teams with our current squad, but sometimes , like yesterday, we just have to concede to a better team. Shit though that is, and shit though yesterday was as a spectacle. Dont assume from that that im prepared to accept it, im not but we know what has to happen in order to change, and for me it isnt moyes
121 Posted 25/09/2011 at 19:26:04
I am not saying that it wasn't negative but it would have been the team that I would have picked to try and get something from the game.
122 Posted 25/09/2011 at 20:28:30
Moyes had no option but to put a man marker on Silva, whilst Neville was needed to stop Nasri cutting in.
Fellaini is our main man whilst Ossie is the only player left after losing Peanuts and Arteta who has the creative touch.
The midfield picked itself.
Rather than anguishing over the result and tactics, I am moving on. The momentum created by Blue Union must not stall - our financial situation is hopeless - and there are more winnable games where Moyes tactics will come under greater scrutiny.
I hate losing as much as the next guy, but our circumstances now demand more attention than a loss away to a 400m team.
123 Posted 25/09/2011 at 15:14:09
People saying we should lose to this team because we have a 19 year old striker with no experience and that it isn't Moyes' fault. Fuck that. It's his squad - he said so himself a few months back.
City might have had 3billion quid of players on the bench, but on our bench we had a World Cup finalist centre half, a striker who on his day has hit four goals, and played for one of the best clubs on the planet, and two vibrant players who almost single handedly got us 2 extra points last week.
I don't give a fuck how much that disgusting lot pay for their players. At the end of the day, they have 11 blokes on the grass who bleed red blood, breath the same oxygen, and tie their shoelaces in the same loop, swoop and pull motion.
If anyone thinks that a team doesn't have a fighting chance of winning every match they participate in, then there is no fucking point in even watching the game. That is an attitude that the most important figure at our club HAS TO adopt if we are ever going to be a good football side again.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 24/09/2011 at 14:38:41
Need to get more ruthless and calculating than that.