Season › 2011-12 › News
Birch on Everton's problems
Quotes or other material sourced from BBC Sport
Reader Comments (48)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 25/09/2011 at 17:43:29
One of these cart before the horse spreadsheet answers so beloved by ivory tower number crunchers.
Deal with the root cause not the symptom - the club needs someone with capital and ideas to jump start enthusiasm and bring the fans back.
Simplistic wishful thinking to believe a bigger ground means bigger crowds, bigger revenue.
No wonder he's an ex CEO.
3 Posted 25/09/2011 at 17:58:13
4 Posted 25/09/2011 at 18:30:17
As stated above, we need to be able to fill a bigger stadium before we think about building one. So we need to attract supporters, old and new.
Yes, a board with good marketing ideas could help a lot, but the main thing that creates new fans is attractive football.
Now, I will leave any arguments about how good Moyes has been for us aside, one thing we generally havnt done during his tenure is play attractive football. People are only going to want to watch and support everton if they enjoy what they're watching (im talking about the fickle band wagon fans here, not us guys that just enjoy seeing the royal blue regardless)
Unfortunately for us strikers and exciting midfielders sell shirts and attract crowds, not central defenders. We have a couple strikers, but they're always on the bench, and we have one particularly creative and exciting midfielder (barkley) but he has, for some unknown reason, been completely left out altogether.
So, effective or not, Moyes' tactics have to change in order to attract crowds.
5 Posted 25/09/2011 at 18:45:32
Filling the stadium, in terms of ordinary fans, isnt the issue. As individual fans we dont spend very much it seems.
Getting new corporate boxes in and filled more than jacks up the average revenue per game. That means having the attractive facilities, and convenient location, to bring in that business.
We certainly dont need the 55k seater proposed for DK. A reasonably well appointed 48k is more than sufficient. The same thing that was built at Eastlands for less than £150mn for example.
6 Posted 25/09/2011 at 18:59:10
As for a new stadium G park will see less than 30,000 for a home game this season in the premier league why ? because the football is dire and I don't believe with the players we have it has to be that way. I am sick of Moyes's style. Every team knows how he sets up , what he is going to do re subs, its predictable beyond belief. Thats why I won't be travelling 12 hours round trip this season too many times - Simples
7 Posted 25/09/2011 at 19:13:21
8 Posted 25/09/2011 at 19:14:15
It wasn't so long ago that the reason for the empty spaces was the "obstructed views". Well last week against Wigan there were plenty of empty seats in the Park End.
The negative football Moyes likes doesn't help matters either. The most important thing nowadays seems to be the result no matter how it is achieved. Don't get me wrong I don't want to see fancy dan footy every week with us losing but the dross we have been served up over the last few years has obviously tested the resolve of a lot of fans.
Fans want to watch a decent game of football and that seems to be what is keeping them away from Goodison these days. Lets get the sold out signs up at GP on a regular basis before we go down the road of another "new stadium" fiasco
9 Posted 25/09/2011 at 20:07:58
Only a halfwit would try and connect the corporates spend with "spurring the players on".
The corporates pay the players wages and the ordinary fans do the singing....cept that we dont these days do we Mark?. We whine that the team gives us nothing to sing about!.
If ordinary fans are, as per this thread, going to abandon ship otherwise we'll have to find something to bring revenue in until the fair-weather fans return.
11 Posted 25/09/2011 at 20:47:00
12 Posted 25/09/2011 at 20:50:59
In my view this is about the only argument against Moyes, but it may also be the one which removes him.
13 Posted 25/09/2011 at 20:37:27
Obviously in this day and age we would all love to sit in comfort but even that is irrelevent if we aren't getting value for our hard earned cash,and at present Everton are not delivering that at Goodison so a new venue would be an expensive waste of money.
In the past I have stood amongst over 75,000 to see the 'greats' play on our hallowed turf, today even a new palace wouldn't attract anything close to that figure.
14 Posted 25/09/2011 at 22:40:26
Football is 11 v 11 and you can use 3 subs so the opposition starts equally on the same footing. The result on the day shall be determined by the team with the most goals by way of skill, guts, endevour, hardwork, desire and luck and in our case v Man City having a decent ref! The manager needs to select the right squad and play the right tactics.
It is only financially that we cannot compete. Moyes cannot make the signings he would wish but at the end of the day it is 11 v 11 and who wants to win more. No excuses about signings, ground improvements and other finances, injuries etc
Desire! who wants it more. Players who are winners. This is what I want to see from our players. Talk is cheap
15 Posted 25/09/2011 at 22:48:36
Can we get rid of this idiocy that fans alone will turn our fortunes around. Even if we could suddenly fit 55k 'ordinary fans' into Goodison it would barely turn the corner for us. We'd be pulling in about £1.1mn a game....still a third of what Chelsea manages.
How does Chelsea manage it?. They charge more per seat and probably a bit more for food/drink etc but the bulk is Corporate entertainment money pushing the average up.
We are not going to get 55k through the turnstiles, but, if we have a nice shiny new ground in the right place we can attract the corporate money. That can offset the lower, less affluent, fanbase. Simply put it is the only chance we have....unless you want to gamble on regular CL qualification currently?.
16 Posted 25/09/2011 at 23:02:28
Sorry but thats a load o' balls! Let me take you back to when you first started playing football on the street. How did you decide the teams...was it alphabetical, was it the bondes/gingers v the dark hairs, was it the over 6 foots v the under 6 foots..no I bet you like us lined up and we picked the players based on ability..one at a time.
The only difference iis that Man City can buy the !st , 2nd, 3rd 4th etc etc etc choices!
17 Posted 25/09/2011 at 23:02:28
Sorry but thats a load o' balls! Let me take you back to when you first started playing football on the street. How did you decide the teams...was it alphabetical, was it the bondes/gingers v the dark hairs, was it the over 6 foots v the under 6 foots..no I bet you like us lined up and we picked the players based on ability..one at a time.
The only difference iis that Man City can buy the !st , 2nd, 3rd 4th etc etc etc choices!
18 Posted 25/09/2011 at 23:23:20
19 Posted 25/09/2011 at 23:24:57
We definitely need a big dose of optimism put back in the boardroom first and then the management etc... Top down approach. Just as with the playing squad, new ideas (players) are needed from time to time. We need new blood on the board. It is too stale now.
COYB
20 Posted 25/09/2011 at 23:24:57
We definitely need a big dose of optimism put back in the boardroom first and then the management etc... Top down approach. Just as with the playing squad, new ideas (players) are needed from time to time. We need new blood on the board. It is too stale now.
COYB
21 Posted 25/09/2011 at 23:24:57
We definitely need a big dose of optimism put back in the boardroom first and then the management etc... Top down approach. Just as with the playing squad, new ideas (players) are needed from time to time. We need new blood on the board. It is too stale now.
COYB
22 Posted 25/09/2011 at 23:30:19
Look at Brighton even a season after Poyet came in they were averaging 6500 gates. They move to the Amex and their smallest gate this season has been just under 20000!.
They'd sold 16k season tickets before they were confirmed promoted. Thats new stadium effect.
GP isnt enough if we filled it every match....unless we triple ticket prices!. Stick your fingers in your ears and wish it weren't so all you like, It doesnt change the simple facts.
23 Posted 25/09/2011 at 23:42:09
Your first ever post on this site. I do sincerely hope it is your last one too.
24 Posted 26/09/2011 at 02:36:13
25 Posted 26/09/2011 at 07:14:32
26 Posted 26/09/2011 at 07:52:41
27 Posted 26/09/2011 at 08:28:43
I know it's raking over old ground, but KD was the future in so many ways. Sadly, having been close to the project, at no stage did any of the people working on it felt it would be delivered by EFC. The hardest part (convincing the Kop season ticket holders on the council) had been done (not by EFC I hasten to add). All they had to do was deliver the "ringfenced" £35m (which did increase to £55-65m) and they couldn't. Like Lee, no matter how big a Blue he is, I can't forgive either.
Put current attendances to one side, we do need a new stadium. I was thinking about penning an article looking at the income breakdown of the EPL clubs, and why Everton is too dependent on Broadcast revenue, and why a new stadium has to be the #1 priority, but like a lot of fans are feeling at the moment, I just can't be arsed.
28 Posted 26/09/2011 at 09:56:41
Perhaps someone who makes a 12 hour round trip to watch DM's brand of anti-football deserves a little more respect ?
29 Posted 26/09/2011 at 10:26:43
Exactly Steve, you can add Spurs as a further example of that, they are fully self-sufficient and have spend stupid amounts of money on players. (except for this summer's transfer window that is, although they bought Parker and would have had Cahill but ran out of time)
That money has mainly come from corporate.
Obviously the normal fans are needed for atmosphere, but to get the money to get a good team on the park - who will bring in the fans and excitement in the first place - we need corporate first.
One corporate seat is worth more MONEY than about the price of 7 adult fan attendances.
30 Posted 26/09/2011 at 10:36:27
31 Posted 26/09/2011 at 10:39:54
Everton, in my opinion are an ordinary team with some above average football players,who in most cases try their heart out for the manager.
If we were to have taken city on in and end to end game of football we would have gotten hammered.
You can only work with the tools you have got.
Tactics is one thing,common sense is another.
32 Posted 26/09/2011 at 11:12:31
Anybody spot the problem here?
You can blame Kenwright and the board as much as you like, and believe me I do, but with what we are watching on the pitch we are deeper in the shit than we have been for a very long time
34 Posted 26/09/2011 at 12:54:05
I don?t profess to know all the finer details of Kings Dock/Kirkby, unlike some ?supposed? informed people on this site, but to all those howling at the Kirkby move, you?ve made your bed?s?better lie in them.
35 Posted 26/09/2011 at 13:16:28
Wasted by Bill because he wanted to stay in control.
So much for EFC bigger than any one man.
Kirkby = Tesco, Arcadia Group,Earl's hotel etc and a big fat Zero to do with EFC.
Your 'supposed' informed people actually read and understood all the facts re Kirkby and pointed out it was a totally flawed plan and a complete waste of EFC's time and money.
Called in for a reason and not to do with stadium.All there in black and white.
Green - the non investor invisible man = no shops.
Earl - why is he even on the board now = no hotel.
EFC no plan B.
Kings Dock ahhhhhhhhhh - I try very hard not to think about it too much now, at 48 years of age, otherwise it would drive me to insanity.
David Dein, then vice-chairman of Arsenal, still at Highbury, on Sky Sports news,-
'If I could get the same deal Kenwright has got for Everton at Kings Dock I would give both my arms and legs.'
Bill Kenwright 23/05/01 -'Dock will be Everton's salvation.'
Sir Philip Carter 16/05/01 - 'If we failed to take this opportunity (Kings Dock) our fans would not forgive us.'
Shit - forget it, I am starting to get pissed right off again and not good for blood pressure etc.
COYB
36 Posted 26/09/2011 at 14:15:27
We need to start living in the harsh realities of the modern world of the haves and have-nots. It?s the same as all the people on this site that scream for Moyesy?s head while ignoring the reality of the task.
37 Posted 26/09/2011 at 14:43:48
Believe me Mac, you will struggle to find many people at all who were originally against Kirkby who now wish the move went ahead, regardless on how bad things have become. No matter what, Kirkby was a bad, bad idea, and nothing will change that fact.
38 Posted 26/09/2011 at 15:01:21
I have voted with my feet and will not be attending Goodison Park again until the day when Bill Liar packs up his suitcase and has the honour to allow Everton to prosper and move on from the pungent stagnation that is emanating from the Club.
39 Posted 26/09/2011 at 15:15:57
Get in right on the pitch; success and CL riches will follow
Surely a new "investor" would firstly invest in playing staff rather than a new ground
40 Posted 26/09/2011 at 16:24:06
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/football/teams/e/everton/3901225.stm
Lack of summer activity in the transfer market in 2004
Talk of debt and......
Birch was brought in to Goodison Park with the brief of overhauling the club's finances and long-term position.
But it is thought he quit after a perceived lack of boardroom support for some of his proposals, one of which may have been to look for new owners.
7 years later and nothing has changed really.
41 Posted 26/09/2011 at 16:20:54
Having seen the length and depth of your reply, I could see a reason for not posting on here again. A little mutual respect would be reasonable dont you think? Or at least the manners to offer a counter argument, instead of the dismissive childish response you offered to a fellow blue.
By the way - as a season ticket holder and someone who travels to all home and away matches from Yorkshire, I can understand Simon's frustartion - even though I dont happen to agree with his views on Moysie's style.
There's room for us all on here.
42 Posted 26/09/2011 at 17:15:32
This game is ultimately about 11v11 and it is crucial that any manager of Everton sends our team out believing that they can beat the opposition. Desire, teamwork, solid graft and perhaps some luck can make up any shortfall in individual skill and financial clout.
If your attitude is that you're not good enough to win before a ball has been kicked then you don't deserve to manage this club. If you want us to pay you 70k / week for the privilege then that is just taking the piss.
43 Posted 26/09/2011 at 20:15:55
Football was created for the working classes as a form of escapism and somewere along the line we have lost touch of this and its time to get this back on track and to just ENJOY it. If Everton get you so depressed that you have to march then join a political party as they may get the best out of you and passion.
Love Everton, love football, hate the red shite
44 Posted 26/09/2011 at 22:06:02
Sounds like you've never had to do the corporate entertainment footy thing. I have unfortunately....dragged along several times to Stamford Bridge to support our sales team.
They dont care, the sales team, what the team is playing like. In fact the sales guys told me, after one particularly successful weekend, that they try to avoid a matchday if they know the customers are fans of either team playing.
The reason strikes you as obvious after you think about it for a minute. You're trying to create a favourable impression and sell them stuff. If their team get battered or hand out a tonking they arent likely to be switched on to the sales pitch,,,,,,,,they'll be too busy with the football pitch!.
The corporate entertainment thing is frig all to do with football. For the club though it represents a revenue stream we haven't been able to tap that we need to.
You say 'get it right on the pitch and it will all come good'. You are missing the small fact that you have to pay the talent on the pitch a shedload of cash if they are any good. Chelsea wage bill £170mn, Man City's is about £130mn, Utds about the same, Arsenal and Liverpool about the £110mn mark. If you want the quality in depth in the squad you have to find the cash to pay for it. Where does that come from to bring the success on the pitch eh?.
45 Posted 27/09/2011 at 11:30:23
I know it's a different world now, but, as has been said, it's still 11 v 11
A good man-manager and tactician can still get a team to perform better than its individuals
I wonder how much Villarreal and similar `poor' clubs manage to do it
If, as you think it's always and ever going to be about wages, what's the point? Let's pack in now
46 Posted 27/09/2011 at 12:09:10
With the skill in the side you can play poorly and have 3 points rescued by 5 minutes of sheer brilliance from a Ronaldo etc.
With the skill in the side this magic quality called 'confidence' isn't the crucial factor it is for us.
Its no accident that the teams playing the highest wages finish at the top slots in the league. Is it all about wages....pretty much yes. Do we give up....up to you I guess?!.
Myself I think its a step by step process. We have to start with a new stadium and an ability to match at least a Spurs level wage bill....about 30% up from where we are now. We can challenge for top 4 with that when Moyes rebuilds and balances the squad piecemeal as he did last time.
A few CL spot finishes and the new stadium, with its commercial value, allow us to spend a little more and/or make us more attractive for investment. No instant gratification, but, progress. The hard part is that, I think, we have to sell players we'd rather keep to part fund the new ground. Someone offers us £30mn for Barkley I'd take their hand off at the elbow....there's 20% of the new stadium in a oner!.
47 Posted 27/09/2011 at 12:27:34
But, apart from the Kings Dock (weep) we lost our chance to join the pigs at the trough when this Board failed to help Moyes consolidate the 4th-place finish - it would not have taken a billionaire or a corporate-laden stadium, just a bit of vision and action
48 Posted 27/09/2011 at 12:37:08
49 Posted 27/09/2011 at 13:06:29
"we are all in the gutter..."
50 Posted 27/09/2011 at 21:47:58
Sound familiar???
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 25/09/2011 at 15:41:49
- Birch said manager David Moyes was performing "nothing short of a miracle" with limited finances
- He is armed for hand-to-hand conflict and he is competing against armoured artillery
- They simply cannot generate sufficient revenue when Man Utd are earning £3m a game and Everton £500-700k
- Those clubs with great stability, which Everton have, with the younger players coming through, you could look with enthusiasm to the future.
"But what they won't do is ever compete for the league title again in the short term."