Atkinson was the wrong choice

, 1 October, 48comments  |  Jump to most recent
Moyes, visibly disappointed, said: "I just thought the sending off ruined the game. You get lots of questions from people asking about derbies, tackles and sendings off but that wasn't even a bad tackle.

"I don't even know if we can appeal. I would have been disappointed had it been a free-kick and if he had got a yellow card I think people would have asked 'what's that for?'"

Moyes revealed he had not spoken to referee Atkinson, who felt the full fury of Everton's fans inside Goodison Park at half-time and at the final whistle, adding: "We've not had that referee since myself and Steve Round were fined one year ago against Manchester United."

On his side's showing, Moyes said: "The team did everything they could and I'm disappointed. It wasn't the referee that lost us that game because we had a couple of defensive lapses but it would have been hard at 11 against 11."

Quotes or other material sourced from BBC Sport



Reader Comments (48)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Peter Fearon
1 Posted 01/10/2011 at 16:55:08
Yes, it was a terrible decision to send off Rodwell but it did not ultimately effect the result. That's not just my view. It's also that of David Moyes. He said after the game: "At the end of the day it wasn't the referee that lost us the game."

No. Had Rodwell stayed on we still would have adopted the same stale negative pointless defensive posture which leads to losing to a late goal. Even at 1-0 down, we were still crossing the ball into a penalty area without a single blue shirt in it. Defending a deficit the David Moyes way. Ineptly.

Kunal Desai
2 Posted 01/10/2011 at 16:57:36
I really don't understand why referees cannot be briefed a day or two, maybe even a week before a derby match, why can't they be told to use some common sense because of what's at stake and due to the nature of the game!! Same old shitbags of referees this country has, nothing ever seems to change. Most fucking useless they should be trained on the continent and then brought back here.
Ian Bennett
3 Posted 01/10/2011 at 16:59:48
Peter, of course it affected the result.

For Everton to win today we had to keep 11 men on the pitch. They have a better side than us, so going down to 10 men it was game over.
Nick Armitage
4 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:02:49
Peter

What evidence do you see of the "same stale negative pointless defensive posture which leads to losing to a late goal?"

Sorry mate, but we put a team out to have a go at them and until the sending off, we were doing exactly that. It is difficult to get players into the box when you are a man down, and I saw only two crosses into the box with no players around.

Until the sending off, Cahill and Saha were causing them all sorts of problems and we would have scored at least one against that defence today.
Dalziel Kane
5 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:04:30
Poor refeeres are getting a blasting today, and with some justification too.

Would've Rodwell staying on made a difference?, the thing is Liverpool wanted it more you felt. The weather did no-one any favors, anything can happen in a derby fixture, really miffed that the horrible ugly fuck Kuyt managed a strike against us yet again. Saha had chances and glad he was involved after his Twitter nonsense, but we have some testing fixtures coming up soon and it's imperative the players bounce back with the right attitude and lift themselves from today's disappointment. It's still early days in the season and everything to play for.

I'm not going to get too upset from today over some ass clown official or being beaten by a team I genuinely cannot stand. We'll have our own moments this season you'd like to think and watch as the shite themselves have their own pitfalls and genuine disappointments.
Lol McNally
6 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:13:19
12 against 10 ? need I say more?
Paul Olsen
7 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:15:44
Before Rodwell was sent off we were leading 5-0 in corners and 5-1 at attempts on goal.

So yeah, I think it made an impact.
Stuart Mitchell
8 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:30:51
Even with 10 men we looked the better side in spells.

Atkinson should be suspended for this display!
Dalziel Kane
9 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:38:20
He should be suspended alright... by his testicles above a vat of shark-infested custard.
Andy Crooks
10 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:46:27
Dignity, acceptance of defeat, pragmatism, sportsmanship, yes all qualities we would expect from an Everton manager, Not today, definitely not today.

Today, Mr Moyes ,speak out on behalf of all of us, Call it as it is. Denounce Atkinson as an incompetent, unfit to referee at the highest level. Denounce Suarez as a cheat and a disgrace to the red shirt. Get fucking angry, get fined and you know what, you'll galvanise Evertonians behind you.

I was gutted when you described Nolan as "not that type of lad" (he is and deserves all the bad luck in the world). Get it off your chest and pay your fine.

Set a precedent, if you fuck with Everton you are going to get slated. It worked for Sir Alex. Show passion, show anger and you will gain the respect of Evertonians.

Michael Kenrick
11 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:47:59
I'd love to see him go ballistic, Andy, but I honestly think we've seen all we're going to see in that BBC interview. It's not his style...
Kevin Tully
12 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:00:38
Peter Fearon #1,

Speechless.
David Hallwood
13 Posted 01/10/2011 at 17:57:10
What's the point Michael, when the FA makes the Syrian government, tolerant and fair-minded. Any criticism of officials not matter how piss poor they are results in a fine for the player and/or the club, and the ref normally gets off scot free. No wonder it?s so corrupt.
Alan Newton
14 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:05:59
Sorry, I rally can't agree with the view that they are a better team than us. I was astonished with just how poor Liverpool were for most of the match. Despite a numerical advantage and huge periods of possession, they didn't look too dangerous. I was always fearful the heat would eventually be a factor and we would be worn down, but the goals we conceded were - typically for Everton - give aways, rather than a Liverpool masterclass. Baines lost his man for the first (Ok, Carroll still had a bit to do, but Anichebe could have scored it), and we all saw the fuck up for the 2nd. I thought they were poor and we were the better footballing side up until the Rodders injustice. In fact, blue tinted glasses off, I think we were the better side for large parts of the second period, despite the lack of end product.

As for Moyes and his tactics, I was a little more buoyed that he went with Saha today, but I was hoping he would have the balls to start Drenthe and Vellios and really have a go for once. Maybe, just maybe, he will have the balls to try that sometime before Xmas....!
Shayne Willliams
15 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:02:45
Honestly don't mean to be sarcastic but did you even watch the game Peter???
Denis Richardson
16 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:01:56
Can't blame the team or the manager as the sending off changed the game and it was so early in the match.

This one was lost thanks to the ref, yes they missed a pen but when you go down to 10 men inside the first half an hour, the game is pretty much gone. Only on rare occasions will 10 men do something against 11 playing for over an hour.

F'ed off as I though we could have nicked tihs before the start, only chelsea and manure up in hte next 3 games and then this horrible run of fixtures is over!

At least we have a 2 week break to take our minds of this shit!
Dalziel Kane
18 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:04:12
I've just realized plastic face didn't actually score against us today, thanks to Howard, pity about the other two, and Carroll, £35,000,000, what a fucking joke that is. Also just heard Moyes saying that 'we would of been very angry if it had been a yellow card' (Rodwell incident). I wasn't exactly jumping for joy when the kid got sent off Dave.
Kevin Hudson
19 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:09:26
Our boys worked their socks off today.

Thunderous applause for J-Rod's tackle turning to absolute bewiderment, then fury, at the sight of a red card. From my seat in the Gwladys I could clearly see contact with the ball. Yet Atkinson is yards away!

Couple of quick points:

Was Cahill equally guilty of "looking," for something simlar to Suarez when HE went down..? Haven't seen a replay of it yet, so don't know if he was milking it too..If he was - we shouldn't be so holier-than-thou about it. I detest the sly side of the game, anyway.

There were far meatier tackles commited by us than Rodwell's, that weren't penalised as harshly.

In any case, the day I see a derby without a few crunching tackles is the day I stop watching football frankly.

Finally, some of the tits to my left lobbing bottles etc at Bellamy ought to be ashamed of themselves. No need for that.
Declan Brown
20 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:25:12
Andy Crooks #10, couldn't put it any better myself.

I remember years ago Moyes went on the offensive regarding Clattenburg and he won a lot of respect from me day too.

How many times have we go through against Liverpool before somebody does something about these referee's? I reall do despair.
Alan Newton
21 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:20:34
I am just so angry about this.... I just don't know where to vent. My wife doesn't understand, the lads are just as angry and disappointed but I just want someone to hear the scale of injustice here. Sharpy looked totally distraught in the studio on Sky and that's only a smidgeon of how I was feeling.... absolutely fucking raging inside. I'm not sure I'm going to be calm on this issue for a long while. Worse still, we have a 2 week fucking break to continue to ponder the injustice of it all.

The pact with the devil grows ever stronger every passing year. I can't think of another fixture where we seem to continue to suffer such huge injustice.... it's incredible. I've never seen it in any other Derby, not even north of the border, where you would almost expect religious intolerance on the part of referees to sway the outcome of the Old Firm games more frequently than we see it.

From the Brian Hamilton joke, to the Hansen 84 Milk Cup handball, to the McAllister free kick, to the disallowed Hutchinson goal, to Lescott being wrestled to the floor, to today, and plenty more in between. Why is it allowed to continue and continue and continue?! I wouldn't mind as much if we were complete toss and been outclassed. I could take that as a fair playing field, despite the irony of a gulf in finances meaning it's not a level playing field but 11 versus 11, we're as good as they are.
Brendan O'Doherty
24 Posted 01/10/2011 at 18:54:06
If Moyes went ballistic (in public - I'm sure he did in private), he'd be getting slated on here for 'lack of dignity', 'throwing his toys out of the pram', 'making lame excuses', etc. He can't win. On balance, he's better adopting the dignified response in public, as we all know what he really thinks about that refereeing 'display'.

Howard Don
25 Posted 01/10/2011 at 19:02:59
Peter (1) That has to be a joke Peter? ........... Wasn't it? Surely?
Michael Kenrick
26 Posted 01/10/2011 at 19:04:48
I'm not sure that's entirely true, David (#23). There must be some mileage in the idea that Clattenberg has effectively been banned from officiating derbies / at Goodison / Everton matches?

In this instance, Moyes and Everton should kick up one almighty stink and not let it rest. The red card decision was atrocious and inexcusable. The most plausible explanation appears to be that the ref was too close(!!!) to the incident and reacted to the yelp of pain Suarez uttered as he flung himself at Rodwell's knee and then rolled around in fake agony.

Rodwell did absolutely nothing wrong. It was not even a foul, never mind a yellow card... a red card was an absolute travesty that is a complete disgrace.
Peter Murphy
28 Posted 01/10/2011 at 19:40:10
Are we really surprised? there are a handful of refs who don't care as much about football as they do about seeing their name in the papers on sunday morning, unfortunately Atkinson being one of them something like this was bound to happen.
Ian Tunstead
29 Posted 01/10/2011 at 19:47:34
I am delighted to see Rodwell finally starting to put his foot in and stamp his authority on the game since Moyes instructed him last month to get a bit nasty. But the lad is still too nice for his own good.

I think it was Rodwells reaction that got him sent off, staight away he put his hands on his head because he thought he had hurt the cheat. That showed a sign of guilt to the ref which i think made his mind up to send him off. It shows lack of experience from Rodwell. He should have just walked away as if nothing had happend. He will learn, at least he is no longer non existant in games and he is making his mark.
Karl Jones
30 Posted 01/10/2011 at 19:48:38
Moyes is far too negative. His tactics are stale. Everbody knows the way he plays by now. He makes excuses for losing, even before games these days. What does that say to the players and fans?

This Everton team is the worst since the last time we were relegation fighters and an embarrassment to Evertonians everywhere.
We sold our two most creative players within six months of each other and have not signed a replacement or anyone!. What other premier league club would act like that? The team is past its sell by date and so is the manager.
Alan Khan
31 Posted 01/10/2011 at 19:57:13
Moyes must appeal the red card!!! The way Suarez fell to ground holding his foot, you would have thought that was the end of his day. Between Atkinson's shocking call, Evertons attacking start, Tim's outstanding penalty save and some defensive blunders that caught us, I was proud of our lads today. Just a pity we have an extra week to feel the pain.
Wayne Smyth
32 Posted 01/10/2011 at 20:13:32
Peter(1) I've been highly critical and pissed off at Moyes team selections and tactics recently the same as you, but the sending off was easily the key moment in the game and it ultimately decided the result.

Up till then we'd looked comfortable in defence and my gut feeling was that we'd win. We were also playing 2 up front with cahill in behind a proper striker and things were going well.

Moyes got his tactics spot on today with a good lineup and formation. The boys were playing well too. Down to 10 men against a good side we were always going to struggle.

I don't think you can have a go about the performance after the sending off. The end result was entirely predictable given that we were down to 10 men with 70 minutes to play.

Martin Handley
33 Posted 01/10/2011 at 20:19:59
Peter#1 You're taking the piss or you're a red mate.
The sending off effectively killed the game, even Aldridge said we looked the more likely winner upto that point.
What did you want us to do take a C/B off and put Velios on?
You really need to have a word with yourself mate!
Andy Crooks
34 Posted 01/10/2011 at 20:48:59
Words I never thought 'd write. I'm in full agreement with Ian Tunstead.
Phil Bellis
35 Posted 01/10/2011 at 20:45:06
"Liverpool wanted it more" - do me a favour - with one or two exceptions, they are an unerwheliming, rudderless side of expensive 2nd-tier players
Until the ref decided to even up the game, us paupers were doing fine; why we can't have a screen-watching official to do away with such refereeing errors is beyond me
Worst ref display since the Clattenburg derby
Keith Pratt
37 Posted 01/10/2011 at 21:29:02
Andy Crook, you speak so much sense. I'm very critical of Moyes and last week was a disgrace, but we were totally in control today until the farcical sending-off. Can't wait to see that horrible, spitting, diving, ear biting little cheats face when he gets seriously hurt, hopefuly, sooner rather than later. A total disgrace to football and Liverpool FC.
Andy Parsons
38 Posted 01/10/2011 at 21:43:29
This idea that referees don't affect results is completely untrue. Of course they affect the result, they are front and centre of so much of what happens on the pitch. Penalties, free kicks, bookings and sendings off - they determine the flow of the game. That's precisely why players try to con them and precisely why players are in their face over everything that happens on the pitch. It's completely stupid to believe they don't affect results.

Today is a text book example of that.
Brian Waring
39 Posted 01/10/2011 at 21:50:42
Now I have calmed down, if you think about it, sending Rodwell off (even though he was a cunt to do so, and it did have a huge bearing on the game) was realistically the only decision that went against us.

No arguements about the pen, it was a pen, and I have mentioned it before, Fellaini and Hibbert's tackles were very late, and both could easily have been red cards. By the way, I'm not trying to defend the twat.
David Hallwood
40 Posted 01/10/2011 at 22:52:14
Brian 33~ Kuyt was offside for the 2nd goal, bent refs (and that fuckers bent) only have to get a couple of decisions wrong, and they can even it up by giving container load of free kicks in non dangerous areas.

Atkinson's a clever cheat, but still a cheat
John Hands
41 Posted 01/10/2011 at 22:54:10
I didn't see the game today, but I spoke with a team mate who's a RS supporter who watched the game. He echoed Moyes's view that the ref got it totally wrong.

I just went on to the Beeb's web site and watched Dalglish's after game interview. What a twat!! I wouldn't piss on him if he was on fire. In fact, if he dropped on the street in front of me having a heart attack I'd help him on his way to hell!!

At leat DM had the decency not take anything away from the RS. It just showed he's a lot more classy - and my brother hates Jocks with a passion!!
Tom Owen
42 Posted 01/10/2011 at 23:28:03
Does anyone know if the red card is being appealed? If nothing is done about this, it just makes it even more of a travesty. It's about time these incompetent, biassed and possibly corrupt officials were brought to account for their actions.
Andy Crooks
43 Posted 02/10/2011 at 00:56:40
Just watched king Kenny on MOTD. What an utterly charmless specimen he is. It is pleasing to reflect on the shite signings he has made and to slowly watch him fuck up his legacy. However critical of Moyes I might be I'll have him any day over that that sour, bitter,poisonous piece of shit.
Mick Gallagher
44 Posted 02/10/2011 at 11:48:08
I havent been one Moyes biggest fan of late but to say he was negative yesterday is talking shite. Saha was troubling the 2 gobshites in the middle Cahill was looking up for it and the midfield were on top till clittemberg mark 2 took over. Hopefully the gobshite will be refereeing sunday league u11 on the ba next week. Even old whiskey nose has already slated him this year saying how sHite he is.
David Mathieson
45 Posted 02/10/2011 at 12:11:29
Everyone was slagging of Howard Webb after the other night but he is the best referee we have had in the Derby for a long time.

I notice since The Shite got beat by MUFC when Webb was in charge and he has never refereed them since, funny that one of the few fair referees The Scum get they ensure they never get him again, The Scum are not as stupid as they look but they are even more uglier and inbred.

We should not let this go and even should consider suing the referee for gross incompetence; that would make them think twice about ripping us off.
Peter Barry
47 Posted 02/10/2011 at 13:20:43
How sad that a guy like Peter Fearon can post the absolute nonsense he has and still call himself a Blue.
Peter Norris
49 Posted 02/10/2011 at 18:47:49
Kevin #18. If you were so annoyed at the "Finally, some of the tits to my left lobbing bottles etc at Bellamy ought to be ashamed of themselves. No need for that." - what have you done about it? Informed anyone. Get some balls and report them mate - we don't need these "tits".
Tim Welsh
50 Posted 02/10/2011 at 20:31:55
Alan Newton post #20

I could not agree with you more.

I don't mind being beaten fair and square by the evil filth...it may even happen one day.

Never mind the Blue Union, we should go to 'Premiership Towers' armed with a video of the countless dodgy decisions and ask for an explanation.

One last thing...Kuyt has taken more penalties at Goodison than Everton have had at Anfield (against them!).
David Price
52 Posted 03/10/2011 at 17:39:15
When was the last pen we got at Anfield?
David Price
53 Posted 03/10/2011 at 17:49:48
Just checked, it was Wayne Clarke in 1988 and he scored.
Then we got another 49 years before that.
One penalty in 72 years.
Dave Randles
54 Posted 03/10/2011 at 17:51:26
Arguing with some red nose mates about the injustices of derbies and I am citing the ones I can remember. I don't recall any the other way, but the ones that spring to mind in no particular order are: -

This one
Clattenburg
Clive Thomas
Hansen's goal line handball (League Cup Final)
Gerrard's two footed lunge on Naysmith
Poll claiming he had blown up before the ball cannonned off Don Htuch's arse
McAllister's free kick in time added on for a Liverpool winner (Though Paul Gerrard was as much to blame - have I imagined the time issue?)

Any others that spring to mind?
David Price
55 Posted 03/10/2011 at 18:02:11
Derby history, in every competition, we have scored 2 pens they have scored 16.
Granted we may have missed 27 perhaps and they missed 2, but somehow i don't think so.
Dave #46, Carraghars assault on Pienaar, nothing happened and the ref was, Atkinson. very strange.
David Mathieson
56 Posted 03/10/2011 at 18:40:05
What happen to the scum that spat on and punched Everton captain Neville? Did Liverpoo get in any trouble over it or what? What is the odds they do us more for throwing a few coins etc

To be honest I wouldn't encourage £2 coins bouncing of Baaaaaaaaaallamy's head but it did make me laugh

Liverpoo make out like they are whiter than white when really they rob of their own, spit an punch on opposing players try to push ambulances over with players with broken legs in (good at pushing stuff surprised it never went over)

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads