Everton to appeal red card

, 2 October, 14comments  |  Jump to most recent
Chief executive Robert Elstone said: "Following a review of the video evidence we believe the decision to be wrong and we will be contacting the FA requesting that the red card is rescinded."

Rodwell faces a three-match ban if Everton's appeal is not successful; he would miss the Premier League and Carling Cup games against Chelsea and the trip to Fulham later this month.

Quotes or other material sourced from BBC Sport



Reader Comments (14)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Stubbs
1 Posted 02/10/2011 at 17:32:01
The very least the FA should do is to rescind the red card. However, they should also reprimand the referee and the Liverpool player or players responsible for influencing the referee. But I am sure they will do none of those things. My guess is that they will find other reasons to rub salt into our wounds. This could be anything from fining Moyes again for comments he has made since the match to some crowd misbehaviour charges.

But the fact surely remains that like King Lear, our club will always be more likely to be sinned against than sinning. I am not sure what we have done to deserve this treatment, and I am not sure what has to happen before it stops. But the plain truth is that the FA and others who run this game have an agenda to undermine our club and to snuff out any chances we might have to succeed.

If they had any sense, the FA would leave us alone. Our current board is already pressing the self-destruct button. The board does not need any help from bent referees and our opponents on Saturday to bring this club further misery.
Steve Cotton
2 Posted 02/10/2011 at 18:29:01
I will tell you what surprised me most about Suarez, he didnt fall to the floor holding his head when an empty bottle of coke hit his leg? surely his instincts would have been to fein injury (again) to see how much more damage he could do. And the worse thing isthat if he had done it the FA wold have been down on us like a tonne of bricks.

He is a dispicable cheasting coward of a man, who cheated in a world cup quarter final and applauded himself afterwards, badly bit the ear of an opponent in Holland and changed leagues because his reputation in Holland for diving was starting to become legendary.

well he and Liverpool deserve each other, lets hope his reputaion here for diving starts in earnest from yesterday, Andy Johnson was almost hounded out of the game for a similar charge when he was totally innocent, lets see if justice prevails with the goofy twat in red..
Tony Doran
3 Posted 02/10/2011 at 21:02:52
How can that cheating bucktooth twat be handed MOTM the way he throws himself about like that. It must be the same kind of people who voted for Paddy in big brother after revealing in Brittains hardest men how he could bite your lip off in a fight an swallow it. Yet here's a bloke who done his time and everybody screams blue murder when he wins a £1m in a game show. The world has gone bonkers. Just look at the nasties at the shite now, Bellamy Gerard, Riena and Suares. OH and Dalglish
Tony Gee
4 Posted 02/10/2011 at 21:43:48
Tony, it was £100k not £1million...

One word.....research.
Ray Griffin
5 Posted 02/10/2011 at 21:59:17
I got chucked off The Guardian website yesterday for daring to put forward a hypothetical question about referees that I considered was asked in an intelligent and eloquent way.

The point I endeavoured to make was that is it in any way possible that a referee at Premier League level could, hypothetically speaking, could 99.9% guarantee a result not by doing something obvious like awarding a penalty or disallowing a goal but sending off a player early on in a game on a hot, humid day which is enough to totally change the game?

Asian betting syndicates pay huge money for a certain result; referees are not well paid. Cases have been proved in Turkey, Italy, Germany etc.

Anyone check if Atkinson has an off-shore bank account?
Simon Watts
6 Posted 03/10/2011 at 02:24:51
What I could not understand is the referee going to the clubs beforehand. Surely an official should not act as a travelling salesman. There should not be any contact as the clubs are not allowed to comment without threat of heavy fines.

This also leaves the problem of officials being in a position to take bribes. Not saying this happened but there should be Absolutely no way that this should happen. It is scandalous. Clattenburg went off on holiday with Liverpool FC. That in itself should raise eyebrows.
Terry McLavey
7 Posted 03/10/2011 at 10:38:36
How could Rodwell send Suarez into the air as high as he went?!!He looked as though he'd bounced on a trampoline!!

I think this season we'll be playing referees as well as 11 men. Is it 10 or 11 years that Man Utd haven't have a penalty awarded against them at home?! And with some of the players they've had e.g Scholes & Keane!! It's obviously a done deal, like our match on Saturday! (Although we did have a few "tasty" tackles going in ourselves, Hibbo for instance!)

Also don't hold your breath about the appeal ? our managers called Moyes not Ferguson, Mancini or Villa whatever it is!
Jim Burns
8 Posted 03/10/2011 at 12:14:02
Simon @ 6....is that true? Where has that information come from, because if its true - its serious.
Simon Watts
9 Posted 03/10/2011 at 16:53:07
Jim at 8. It's well known he was took by Liverpool on an Asian tour and was given signed shirts by the Liverpool players. Also allowed to be on friendly terms with players. That is what moyes was angry about before the clattenburg fiasco. Same hotel, allowing friendships to develop. Clattenburg loves that sort of thing. His bankrupt business was formed on these sort of deals. He is a failure in life, corrupt in business and bankrupt, but somehow allowed to thrive by the referees association.
Steve Edwards
10 Posted 03/10/2011 at 17:31:15
Oh the joys of being an Evertonian! Same old, same old. I've reached the stage that I expect this sort of thing every time we play them. The FA will back the ref up, after all its only down to an opinion on the interpretation of the law. Thats the problem with the game, the laws are too open to interpretation and even if nine refs out of ten would not have sent him off this one is not necessarily wrong. Well he is but the FA won't see it that way, just you wait and see.

Its the usual crock of shit, 40,000 people paying good money to see a decent game of football and some tosser desides to ruin it for everybody. Its not just Evertonians who were let down, think of all the nuetral supporters who had paid to watch the game on TV. Instead of watching game that was nicely set up they end up with that. Sometimes I think we are all a bunch of mugs for following the game, infact we are.
Simon Watts
11 Posted 03/10/2011 at 18:19:38
Why does not someone take them to court. The thing is if you buy something and you can't contact them then it comes under section 75 of the consumer credit act. This can be a misrepresentation. For instance if you went to the cinema and the projector broke then you would get your money back. The fact that the referees refuse to speak comes under the same. You pay for something and it is up to the card people to pursue it. If enough do it.
Ged Washington
12 Posted 03/10/2011 at 20:54:04
To Simon @ 11, It is interesting that you make this comment.

Immediately after the incident (well after my initial swearing and cursing), I myself said someone should sue the FA or Suarez for letting this game be manipulated, or manipulating the game, in such a way that its excitement and competition had all been sucked dry.....
Alasdair Mackay
13 Posted 03/10/2011 at 21:08:39
To Simon @11. I saw something like this was mentioned in today's Mirror and it is an interesting point, but not realistic. The way to put pressure on referees to get their job right is to make them more accountable to their actions as employees of the Football Association, rather than by suing them as individuals.

I would suggest that it become compulsory for all referees to attend post match press conferences 24 hours after the match they have refereed (after they have assessed their performance internally). This would give referees a platform to justify controversial decisions and maybe apologise for particularly bad ones.

There may also be justification for Everton (or any other league club) to seek compensation from the FA (as the providers of the match officials) for potential loss of revenue if they can prove at the end of the season that this or any further injustices over the course of the season directly contributed to finishing in a lower league position.

I think if you highlighted all the incorrect decisions over the course of one season you may find you have maybe gained 4 points, but lost 9. That means you could look 5 points up the table and sue for the difference in revenue. This could potentially be very costly to the FA if a team finishing 4 points outside of 4th place finds themselves in this position.

Simon Watts
14 Posted 03/10/2011 at 23:47:41
Alasdair @ 13. I honestly think it is a good idea to get them to court. There are no rules that they can hide behind. The rules that they have put in place do not work in a court of law, as the consumer comes first. They will have to turn up in court and explain their actions, and why they believe that they are somehow exempt from the rules and regulations that govern us in everyday life. Believe me, if enough do this they will not have a leg to stand on. They have to turn up, they have to explain themselves, and the media will follow it.

I honestly think that the main reason they don't explain they are wrong is because they can be liable for teams losing vast amounts of money or even being relegated. In a way, this is fair because they can be human, but some of the terrible refereeing is wrong, and open to corruption. It only takes a few hundred fans to take a stance, and take them to court. The media would jump on this as they seem as fed up as everyone else.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads