Moyes has best price-per-point ratio

, 6 October, 60comments  |  Jump to most recent
The 415 points Everton have picked up in the Premier League since 2004 under David Moyes have cost the club just £48,192 according to a new study that seeks to find the best value-for-money manager in the top flight.

By contrast, Liverpool manager, Kenny Dalglish is running at £7.5m per point gained based on his enormous expenditure since taking over at Anfield a year ago.

The findings highlight both the paucity of Moyes's transfer kitty but also his success in milking everything from a routinely small squad and a number of low-budget and loan acquisitions that has resulted in regular finishes in the top eight.

Quotes or other material sourced from MirrorFootball



Reader Comments (60)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ian Tunstead
2 Posted 05/10/2011 at 23:48:48
99.98% of us Evertonians already new this. The other 0.02% can be found on this site.
Gerry Quinn
3 Posted 06/10/2011 at 00:23:51
Ha, brilliant summary Ian - nail, head....now wait for the fall-out!
IMWT :)
Ian Tunstead
4 Posted 06/10/2011 at 00:30:06

Stubbs, speaking at the Leaders In Football conference about Moyes. ?He knows the situation of the club and I don?t think anyone can dispute what a fantastic job he has done."

But what would you know Stubbs? You will find plenty to dispute it on here mate.

Andy Crooks
5 Posted 06/10/2011 at 01:34:33
Statistics, Ian. David Moyes is an admirable man but adding this convoluted statistic to his manager of the month awards doesn't equate to good football, trophies and a positive attitude.

I warmed to the man at the weekend. Against Chelsea, I'll warm to him even more if he sends out the last starting eleven with Drenthe instead of Osman. By the way, I doubt that only 0.02% of Evertonians were unaware of this statistic.
Paul Knox
6 Posted 06/10/2011 at 01:53:11
What about this stat: 0 trophies, 100% lack of success.
Ian Tunstead
7 Posted 06/10/2011 at 02:02:30
Andy considering the amount of money he's had to spend per point, I think it's going to be difficult to win trophies, play good football, and have a positive attitude.

That last sentence is like a double negative, I can't quite understand if you are saying more than 0.02% knew about the statistic, or that more than 0.02% didn't know about it. If they did know about it, why do they want rid of Moyes?
Gerry Morrison
8 Posted 06/10/2011 at 02:31:09
Well said Ian.
John Daley
9 Posted 06/10/2011 at 02:35:37
Stubbs also said the following though: "It is very misleading, because our stat is from 2004 and Liverpool is only from last year,?
Marcus Choo
10 Posted 06/10/2011 at 03:37:54
Hi John #8

I wouldn't really take it as misleading. I think what Stubbs is implying is that any fresh takeover is usually accompanied with a injection of transfer funds by new owners which raises the price-per-point ratio. So he's saying that with Liverpool's recent takeover in 2010, it makes sense that they have spent vastly more than us (our last takeover in 2004).

What is perhaps comparable is to have a look at other clubs who have had takeovers further in history than ours (Fulham 1997, Spurs 2001, Chelsean 2003) and compare with them. Overall, I think it takes nothing away from Moyes' ability to squeeze out the most points per pound of spending...
Derek Thomas
11 Posted 06/10/2011 at 04:52:16
Ian and Jerry, when are you two young love birds going to be posting the Banns
Ged Simpson
12 Posted 06/10/2011 at 05:55:35
Well said Ian
John Roberts
13 Posted 06/10/2011 at 06:16:07
So does that mean if we can find him another £1,301,184 we'll win the league!!

Last season we finished 26 points behind Manure - so - 27 points @ £48,192 each is £1,301,184 - oh so easy!!
David Barks
14 Posted 06/10/2011 at 06:44:13
John,

You do realize that your argument made no sense right? Since essentially what you're saying is that United only spends £1.3 million more each season than us, in your offer. I just want to make sure you do realize that.

The fact is that, given the extremely limited budget, which is in FACT, indisputable, Moyes has done a very good job to keep Everton where they are. If Everton had the money of a United, I have no doubt he would play a different type of football due to the different quality of attacking player he could afford. But he's a pragmatist, he knows that a strong defense gets valuable points which makes a team difficult to beat.

And in so doing, Everton continually finish further toward the top of the table than the bottom. I'm not happy with that, but being a realist, knowing the reality of the Premier League and how unequal and pathetic it is, I'm not mad at Moyes. He didn't create this system. And make no mistake, Everton is a victim of the system and not of Moyes.
John Roberts
15 Posted 06/10/2011 at 06:55:18
Errr, David, maybe I was joking!!

I am fully aware of the great job Moyesy does given the limited (or no) budget available.

And, like you, I'm also not happy with the current situation but am also not looking for us to become some super rich dudes plaything. I'm sitting here in Oz waiting for the whole thing (EPL) to implode.
Danny Biddle
16 Posted 06/10/2011 at 07:28:29
I dont trust stats. They can be manipulated so much so that you basically see what you want to see!

Besides, 95% of stats are wrong and the other 5% are made up. I'm here all week and try the veal. :D:D:D
Matt Traynor
17 Posted 06/10/2011 at 08:00:00
It should also be pointed out that this study includes the cost of acquisition of the club. I believe it goes back to when the current owners of the club bought it.

It's also for the teams that finished in the top 10 of the Prem last year.

Whilst it is interesting, it is not a true statistical picture, more an illustration, so for "either side" to use it as gospel would be unwise.
Dave Lynch
18 Posted 06/10/2011 at 09:11:02
Pointless load of bollox !
Howard Don
19 Posted 06/10/2011 at 09:32:46
Ian (1) - Well said, although I suspect this news will be dismissed by the TW Politburo as the Apologist rantings of the reactionary running dog lackeys of the Acolyte tendancy.

Paul (5) this is another tired argument. Apart from the odd cup success, who actually wins anything other than the Sky four for obvious reasons. Moyes great success is in constantly overachieving as highlighted by the statistics in the OP.
Dave Wilson
20 Posted 06/10/2011 at 10:23:02
Moyesie's stock just keeps on rising...
Ian Tunstead
21 Posted 06/10/2011 at 10:35:37
It's amazing how people can still try and turn this round into a negative, they can not accept anything positive about Moyes, and have the nerve to call him negative.

Even the signing of a 15-year-old, considered the best young prospect in the country was used as a stick to beat Moyes. Get a grip please for your own sake, it's pathetic.
Ben Jones
22 Posted 06/10/2011 at 11:28:04
Cmon Michael, condemn the apologist movement! Ian Tunstead is our leader!
Carl Arnold
23 Posted 06/10/2011 at 12:39:12
Ian (1). Couldnt have put it better
Steve Guy
24 Posted 06/10/2011 at 12:56:27
It's a stat but an amazing one and confirms what many feel, which is that BK found us a great manager who he has then grossly underfunded for years. For me this is not a stat about Moyes but more one about how the Club has been so badly run. We have been successful in achieving regular top 8 finishes despite the Club and BK. The latter individual has Moyes to thank for our continuing status in the top division.

BK talks to the BBC about how, with a bit of luck, we could have got ourselves a Sheikh. Unfortunately, BK used up all his luck getting Moyes; a little less luck at that time would have got us Megson and the Championship.
Denis Richardson
25 Posted 06/10/2011 at 13:28:40
What most people seem to ingore is that the '0.2%' that the first post refers to also know this. However, we have never disputed the manager for his early years and are 100% grateful for the period 2002 to around 2008. It's the last 2-3 years that I have an issue with and the style of (shite) negative football that is played.

It's also very unfair (even if it is the dark side) to compare 7years for Moyes with barely 12 months for Dalglish ? it's not like Dalglish will get 100m every season! Also half of this came from the Torres sale.

As always statistics will cover any crack people wish to cover. What cannot be covered however is the fact we are shite to watch live and on TV.

Anyone know why the stats started in 2004 ? bit of a random year to start with. If you started in 1992 when the Premier League began, would not Man U be top given most of their side in the 90's came from their youth set up ?- and hence cost them nothing....

80% of ststistics are made up on the spot!
David Barks
26 Posted 06/10/2011 at 14:43:26
Denis #24,

It is also "unfair" to say that for the past 2-3 years the style of football has been shite. During that period when we had Pienaar and Arteta working alongside each other, with Baines partnering Pienaar on the left, our football was often brilliant to watch. There were long runs where we played some great passing football. But that's the problem, people like you see the bad performances and choose to ignore the good performances. You just state that we always play shite. But it's just not true. You choose to see what you want to see.
Joe Bibb
27 Posted 06/10/2011 at 15:12:01
Not Misleading? Didn't David Moyes come here in 2002?
Brendan McLaughlin
28 Posted 06/10/2011 at 15:06:21
Denis #24 ? My impression is that the "Gang of 0.02%" have been around a hell of a lot longer than 2008. Go back on ToffeeWeb a year or two before that and you'll find plenty of examples.
Tony Marsh
29 Posted 06/10/2011 at 15:24:48
Polish a turd all you want but it's still a turd... Factor in Lowest Points Total Ever in the league and Lowest Goals Ever Scored in a season. Worst buys ever: Shandy Andy and that guy he bought and sold within days because he couldn't head a ball? Factor in all useless data but it still doesn't mean a thing does it? We haven't won jack shit and we aint going to either.

How about a stat for least spent getting a team into the Prem from Championship. That would be an achievement ? and something Moyes couldn't do.
Colin Wainwright
30 Posted 06/10/2011 at 15:58:06
Don't want to get you too excited now Ian, but with Big Bill still in charge, that £50k per point will be a lot fuckin lower next season.
Matt Traynor
31 Posted 06/10/2011 at 16:09:24
Colin (#27), so you're predicting we'll be hauling in the points then? Hope you're right...
Brendan McLaughlin
32 Posted 06/10/2011 at 16:46:19
Must have struck a nerve when Tony "Marsh Say-Dung" founder member of the "Gang of 0.02%" but in a state of self-imposed exile for the past few years, is forced to make public comment.
Martin Mason
33 Posted 06/10/2011 at 17:07:22
It is absolutely mind boggling that there are Evertonians who base success on trophies won. We can't win trophies now as we don't have resources and we are successful by the position that we've maintained under Moyes. Is this accepting mediocrity? absolutely not, it's called reality and rationality..
Andy Crooks
34 Posted 06/10/2011 at 17:56:04
Brendan, is the price per point accolade up there with the manager of the month? Is that what we are reduced to? Martin Mason, "we can't win trophies now". Well I beg to differ. We have good players who have ,up till last Saturday, been badly employed. Reality and rationality is a fine slogan but how can you know that the squad, which David Moyes hailed last season, could not do better under a different coach? The club play with fear and too many supporters are happy with this.
The "gang of 0.02%" statement is silly.
John Ford
35 Posted 06/10/2011 at 18:08:59
We knew this already, or rather anyone who actually bothered to think about where Everton were at in terms of spend knew it.. To have it confirmed in these terms really shows the value Moyes brings to Everton. It should also be an embarassment to Kenwright.

The other key point about money - if you plough millions in then you win trophies, simple as that. A direct correlation

Does anyone actually think that Chelsea and Man City would be challenging for trophies without huge sums of money. Yet people are still prepared to ignore these facts and criticise Moyes at every turn.
Gerry Quinn
36 Posted 06/10/2011 at 18:24:05
Hey, if we all sold off our pensions, re-mortgaged our houses and withdrew our life-savings.........we could up that points total and win the league! Who needs an Arab or a Russki?
John Ford
37 Posted 06/10/2011 at 18:16:55
Denis24 , theres some truth in the point that we're not quite the team we were in 04 -08, although a cup fnal in 09 was a good effort.

If you take the 'money per point' stats and apply them to the period after 2008 it makes staggering reading - and also explains why we're not quite as good.

Moyes has had absolutely nothing to spend for the best part of three years. So money spent?.....£nil ......so the cost of each point won since 2008? ....£nil...!!!!!!!!

Noone else has to put up with that.
Kevin Hudson
38 Posted 06/10/2011 at 18:33:05
Another indication of Moyes' canny, and a reflection of the constraints under which he works wonders amid relentless criticism from the shrill minority.
Robin Cannon
39 Posted 06/10/2011 at 18:45:12
There's no real point doing it on a manager by manager basis. But if you took the different clubs since 2004, regardless of management, then that would be a worthwhile analysis I think.
Ian Edwards
40 Posted 06/10/2011 at 18:52:07
This survey proves that there are lies, damned lies and statistics.

Anyone can park the bus every game and play for a draw.

Lets have statistics as to which Manager in the last 10 years has been knocked out of more cup competitions by lower league opposition than any other manager?

Marsh is right about polishing a turd.... Moyes is a negative tactical numbskull. He has never won at Arsenal, chelsea, Man Utd or Liverpool. That's over 40 games.





Denis Richardson
41 Posted 06/10/2011 at 19:14:44
John@24 - you saying the manager has had nothing to spend for 3 years? How about the 24 million from Lescott in 2009?

Leading to Distin great buy, Jonny H good CB although not needed and then played out of position, Billy 9m(!) erm, will leave you to answer that one. We also bought a certain Fellaini for 15m in 2008.....so I make that at least 39m moyes has had in the last 3 years!

The above is not to say the manager has not been shafted by the board but it is delusional to say he has had NO money in the last 3 years. years.

David Barks@ and I quote 'when we had Pienaar and Arteta working alongside each other, with Baines partnering Pienaar on the left, our football was often brilliant to watch'

I hope you had your toungue in cheek when you said 'often brilliant to watch'. Or maybe we simply have different expectations as to what a good match involves. Dire performances against QPR, Blackburn, West Brom, Spurs, Bolton, West ham spring to mind (off the top of my head) - in a period when said players were at the club. And these teams are not exaclty the cream of the crop.

Granted there were a few good displays but in recent history a lot of the (h)football has generally been dire. I can also not think of a single team that regularly lines up so defensively / negatively against supposedly weaker teams at home nor plays regulary without a recognised striker.

The manager complains about not having a strike force but lets 3 strikers go during the summer (the yak scroing 2 on his debut for Blackburn!).

At the end of the day we can simply agree to disagree. My wish is to see a confident Everton team taking the pitch with the belief and positive strategy that they will (not can!) win the game.

Regardless of how many millions Moyes is perhaps given in teh future, I simply cannot see him changing his negative style.

Time will tell...
Denis Richardson
42 Posted 06/10/2011 at 19:44:47
David @25, forgot one thing. you say I only hand pick games to back up my shite playing argument.

Can you name me any one of the league games this season in which we have played real positive football and been attractive to watch?

I am just interested to see if you are happy with any of the perfomarnces so far.
John Ford
43 Posted 06/10/2011 at 19:51:43
It may be incorrect re the spending but its certainly not delusional because which ever way you look at it, he has spent one sixth per point of any of the other top clubs

It is two years not three. Point taken. However you look at this his hands are tied. I also agree with David Barks weve played some great stuff with those players in recent seasons. The negative tactics he's accused of are mainly as a result of not bringing players in.

If he was given 25m to spend for the next three seasons and didnt deliver more entertaining football, id be the first to ask him to leave. Id love to see what he could do with dosh. For now we need someone who can work on a shoestring. Noone does that better.
John Ford
44 Posted 06/10/2011 at 20:01:15
..... he hasnt spent anywhere near 39m, he hasnt been allowed.
Trevor Mackie
45 Posted 06/10/2011 at 20:20:33
After that SKY statistic I take it all back, I'm getting a T-shirt printed with Moyes wearing a crown,

"Price per point king" emblazoned underneath - bollocks to trophies.

How can anyone argue....absolutely brilliant....the man's a genius.

Anyone saying playing a more attacking style might have led to MORE points would be WRONG.

- that's a fact by the way 'cos I said it loudly and flounced -

I challenge anyone to find a game we should have won but didn't because of fear, rubbish substitutions and unbalanced team selection.

Where's that road map?

The Damascus one!
Chris Leyland
46 Posted 06/10/2011 at 23:23:56
Fantastic don't you just love toffeeweb?

We sign a young kid every one wanted and Moyes is a wanker who doesn't give kids a chance.

We find out he has won the most points per money spent and this makes him a clueless manager who surely would have even more points in the bag and trophies galore if only he would adopt an all out attack style and stop with this defending nonsense.

We even wheel out the ultra-negativist Tony March to effectively inform us that Moyes has been the worst manager the club has ever had. He picks one of Moyes 10 seasons to evidence this in terms of total points. He even informs us that Moyes has made the worse signing in the clubs history.

Only in the weird and wonderful world of toffeeweb do these "Nil Satis is what it fucking says in our motto mate" fantasists exist.
Kevin Freaney
47 Posted 06/10/2011 at 23:39:00
Chris #45

Let's see what happens in 3-4 yrs time with that 15 yr old kid, then we can have the agruement when we either release him or let him go on a free (as is moyes way with most youth at the club).

As for the stats, the system they've used is hardly a great basis to assess a manager. What about the big games won? Nothing there for Moyes. How about cup runs? Cup Final appearances? Getting knocked out of cups on a continual basis by lower league sides. All it reflects is the fact that Moyes has done well on a tight budget. Which we all know, but the main criticism of Moyes through all this is his inability to adapt. When we all see a system not working he will use it time and time again. The last 2-3 seasons his tactics have been questionable and his decisions dire.

Someone once posted on here about Moyes being Gordon Lee! How long do you reckon our other managers would have lasted without a trophy.....11 years?

It worries me that supporters are happy to settle with defensive boring football and a 7-10th place finish every season with little or no progression!
Brendan McLaughlin
48 Posted 06/10/2011 at 23:47:08
Kevin #46
I think you miss the point Chris is making. OK the lad may fail to make the grade but most supporters would be made up that their team has secured a highly promising youngster in the face of (apparent) competition from other clubs. But of course on TW the naysayers and begrudgers have to treat the signing with typical contempt & distain.
And really Kevin...7-10th place EVERY season..how much of a distortion of the truth is that?
Ian Tunstead
49 Posted 06/10/2011 at 23:53:34
Kevin, it's a different game now, it's no longer the level playing field it was, so to expect Moyes to win a trophy when considering the joke that is the premiere league is a bit too unreaslistic, sad to say but is the truth. You can mention Birmingham or Portsmouth but where are they now? Their winning a trophy was a freak one off.
Kevin Freaney
50 Posted 07/10/2011 at 00:03:33
Fair enough Brendan, I get what you;re saying about us getting the kid with the supposed attention he was getting from other clubs. Got to love the postings from Bradford fans though stating they were delighted he went to Everton as when we HAVE to sell him they'll get a nice cut. But that's a point away from Moyes. Although, I don't reckon we'll ever see him in the first team.

The 7th-10th was a future prediction rather than a comment on the past.

Ian, I agree with you on the PL but not on the cups. It's a different game, especially in the league cup where the big teams play weak sides, yet we always seem to suffer against smaller weaker teams. I really do think that more than 1 cup final should be expected for 11 years.
Ian Tunstead
51 Posted 07/10/2011 at 00:01:49
Denis you talk about the 24m we got for lescott but that was down to Moyes bringing the player to the club in the first place for 6m. That is the whole point, he has had to sell to buy.

You also mention 15m for Felliani, where did that money come from? Again that was down to Moyes making a profit on Andy Johnson and James McFadden. So the 39m you count is down to Moyes in the first place,the profit that he has made.

The only slice of luck Moyes had was having Rooney but he replaced an individual with a team and took the club forward. Who would have thought the 17th best team in the league could sell its two best players, Graveson and Rooney and go on to finish 4th?
Steve Carter
52 Posted 07/10/2011 at 10:16:33
The simple point is that David Moyes is, all things considered, the best manager we could possibly hope for in the circumstances we are in and have been for years.
David Holroyd
53 Posted 07/10/2011 at 10:03:50
Arteta , beckford. yakubu , sold . Money to the bank overdraft down. But every position in the league we finish lower will cost Everton approx 700 grand. 8th last season say 13th this 3million plus gone in prizemoney. On the plus side the above players wages will be saved. But sooner or later we will have to spend.
Denis Richardson
54 Posted 07/10/2011 at 13:42:30
Ian @50 - virtually every club spends transfer income on new players so yes, I do count the £39M Moyes got for Lescott and Fellaini as him getting money. After all, he HAD £39M to spend.

Man Utd got £80M for Ronaldo so should we say SAF got no money to spend? Liverpool got £50M for Torres so should we discount this when saying how much money Dalglish got to spend? Should we ignore the £24M Sunderland got for Bent? etc etc. The question IMO is not necessarily Where did the cash come from? ? it is What did the manager do with it?

Anyway, going back to the original article, the whole basis of this 'pounds per point' is bollocks, IMHO.

For example,. they started calculating Fulham's from 1997 and yet for Arsenal they started in 2007! What about 2004 when Arsenal won the league without loosing a game? Why do they start with 2004 for Everton when Moyes started in 2002? For Man Utd they start in 2005 even though the likes of Scholes, Giggs, Nevilles x2, Butt, Fletcher etc etc cost them nothing as they came through the youth system. Also Ronaldo was bought for £12M and sold for £80M, how does this count?

As I say, the analysis is pretty much a waste of time, IMO. Also, whoever did this analysis seems incapable of using a calculator, taking just the last 3 years: 39M divided by our 415 points given a total of 93,975 per point not 48k! ? and that is ignoring all other transfer spend between 2004 and 2008!

Bring on Chelsea and let's see if we can take the points tally from 415 to 418.
Denis Richardson
55 Posted 07/10/2011 at 14:01:06
Actually... how the fuck have they calculated this???

Liverpool supposedly spent £7.5M/point getting 59 points, That means a total of £442M spent! So they are presumably including the cost of buying the club?

Arsenal £2.5M/point for 298 points ? so total spend £715M!!!!!! WTF?

If people really want to use our supposed £48k/point stat as something actually meaningful, then that is their choice.
Brian Lawlor
56 Posted 07/10/2011 at 16:06:57
Spot on Ian.

You're can't argue with this (unless you're in the 0.02% of course).
Brian Lawlor
57 Posted 07/10/2011 at 16:12:21
Interesting to see the Blue Union's latest serious meeting about the future of our club includes the gimmicks:

"There will then be a special guest appearance by Everton?s most successful manager Howard Kendall who will talk and answer questions about his great Everton teams who really did believe that nothing but the best was good enough.

The FA Cup will be present, so bring your cameras, bring the kids, bring a billionaire if you know one and get your picture taken with the FA Cup"

An attempt to swell numbers and make it look like they've got more support than they actuallly have?


Jim Burns
58 Posted 07/10/2011 at 16:19:34
John @ 8 ? I'm pretty sure that if you worked out the cost per point for ALL of the RS purchases since 2004 ? apples with apples etc ? they'd still look stupid .....especially when you start looking at the (relatively) small points gaps between the clubs at the end of each season.

I'd love to see the same calculation made over the period that both Moyes and the fat waiter were in charge.....
Jim Burns
59 Posted 07/10/2011 at 16:24:16
sorry....should read points gaps - freudian slip.
Jimmy Sorheim
60 Posted 09/10/2011 at 17:48:53
Hello people, to say that Moyes is shit regarding this article is wrong. He is not shit.
He has done well in the past. But now we are without money and without top rated players to sell:
Fellaini will leave for a reduced price lower than 10 million pounds. Brkley will also be sold if there is a bid over 18 million for him.

Past is past, present is present. That statistic does not mean anything on what is to come for us. We will struggle to survive relegation, Moyes has admitted that we will struggle, he is trying to find his feet again, trying to put together a new team that will do well in the future.
If anybody thinks we wil be top 8 then you need to check with your local doctor.

I am not defending Moyes and his tactics, his defensive negative play is killing me softly and I know that the expectations we had years ago no longer can apply. That is the hard truth. If you do not like it then tough. There is nothing you can do to change things unless you get Moyes out of this club, his time has been up for at least a year and you all have to see that. Time for change.
Art Jones
61 Posted 10/10/2011 at 09:51:47
7th, 17th, 4th, 11th, 6th, 5th, 5th, 8th, 7th. 7 top 8 finishes in 9 full years in charge. The 5th most points accumulated in that time. The 6th most goals scored and the 5th fewest let in. 14th highest net spend on transfers in that time. Hasn't finished below a club with a budget less than his for 5 seasons.

This should make it a bit clearer.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads