Blue Union meeting at Zeligs

, 8 October, 44comments  |  Jump to most recent
Howard Kendall and the FA Cup!
At The Blue Union's second public meeting at 14:00 on Saturday 8 October at Zeligs bar in Liverpool One, representatives will present a progress report; reveal their concerns over Everton's finances and discuss the developing campaign for change.

There will be a special guest appearance by Everton's most successful manager Howard Kendall who will talk and answer questions about his great Everton teams who really did believe that nothing but the best was good enough. And the FA Cup will be there too!

Quotes or other material sourced from The Blue Union



Reader Comments (44)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ian Ravello
1 Posted 08/10/2011 at 09:53:34
I would suggest that, if the Blue Union want to present themselves as serious players in shaping the future of our great club, then they should get serious and start meeting in a proper business setting ? not some bar or pub where proper logic can be quickly drained by a few good pints.

Howard Kendall might be attracted to a few free ones at Zeligs but you won't be engaging with the Terry Leahys of this world anytime soon. Come on, guys ? try and put some innovative thought into this!
Gavin Ramejkis
2 Posted 08/10/2011 at 10:13:13
Ian to counter, the type of people likely to attend aren't captains of industry; it's not for the Blue Union to resolve the failing business by finding a new buyer, they are targetting the fans themselves.

If they pigeonhole their audience, they'll get much smaller numbers. They need to attract as many as possible at a venue likely to attract as many as possible. Equally, they are not a funded business, the conference type venues have significant costs.
Tom Hughes
3 Posted 08/10/2011 at 10:27:19
Ian,

If you read the various websites of the constituent member groups, you will see a lot of innovative thought as regards such things as: the footy trust and football quarter concepts and more besides that have seen them engaged with LCC, city-planners, business leaders and leading football/sports academics.

It's still quite early days for this combined group, and they are still trying to engage with the fanbase more (against a tide of media support for the club). Go along and see what's said.... I think you will be pleasantly surprised by the depth of knowledge about all things Everton.
Paul Gladwell
4 Posted 08/10/2011 at 10:53:26
How come they have picked this venue, as it is not big enough? They said they would not make this mistake after last time and this place is not the correct setting at all.
Paul Gladwell
5 Posted 08/10/2011 at 10:58:30
My apologies, good job I checked I thought it was the other Italian up the top end.
Neil Humphreys
6 Posted 08/10/2011 at 20:24:08
Did anyone go? Anything to report?
Neil Humphreys
7 Posted 08/10/2011 at 20:48:50
Sorry for the double post. Just looked at the website and the echo has not so much as mentioned that this meeting has taken place. The final nail in their coffin with me, wont have it in the house again.
Michael Kenrick
8 Posted 08/10/2011 at 22:32:50
We're hearing very little.. more financial analysis, focusing on Finch Farm costing the club £8M per year, in contrast to just £300k pa for Bellefield...

A few odd rumblings on Twatter that Kendall "was misled" (?!?!) and that he rambled on "for hours" about the 80s... not what people really came to listen to.

Hopefully someone who was there will post a decent and reliable summary soon...
Brian Lawlor
9 Posted 09/10/2011 at 08:20:07
So the club is skint which is nothing new and arguably isnt being run very well. So whats the solution, the raison d'etre of Blue Union?

More gimmicks like the FA Cup and rolling Howard out to try and attract some 'false' support?

'The comparisons with Spurs drew gasps' - how dramatic. Was it because their board and chairman have far more dough than ours?

What was the actual point of this meeting?
Peter Laing
10 Posted 09/10/2011 at 09:52:40
Is that why Spurs are competing at the business end of the EPL, Brian ? and thrashed Liverpool the other week? If only that was Everton, eh Brian?
Tom Hughes
11 Posted 09/10/2011 at 10:40:02
Brian..... The Blue Union has come about because of the serial mistakes and mishaps, that have amongst other things, led to us being unable to sign ANY players, and unable to self-fund ANY stadium developments.

Spurs' turnover is far greater than ours for several reasons.... chief amongst them being that they are better run generally, and have invested in the infrastructure to increase revenue streams.

No Gimmicks just facts.... and whole lists of them. Meanwhile, what facts can you offer to dispute the claims of ineptitude?
Paul Gladwell
12 Posted 09/10/2011 at 11:00:36
Brian, Kenwright claims we are losing £4M a year, this will be double that this year due to our serious fall in gates. A large share of this is due to people being fed up with how the club is run.

A half-decent owner who could make sure we don't waste thousands on stupid pie-in-the-sky failed ventures each year would surely reduce this yearly loss. You can also throw in the fact no-one outside of Liverpool can buy our merchandise and stupid fiascos like pink kits stops people from doing so anyway.

We waste thousands each year on bog-standard basic business practices that these clowns cannot get right.
Rob Squires
13 Posted 09/10/2011 at 11:31:14
I went yesterday, not because of Howard Kendall, the FA Cup or because I thought the Blue Union had all the answers; I went because I wanted to hear what they had to say and what they were about.

Two things came across: Firstly, they are passionate Evertonians who are doing what they believe is best for Everton's future. Secondly, the presentation by Colin Fitzpatrick was excellent.

The breakdown of Operating Costs was frightening, Finch Farm costs around £9 Million per year, I cannot understand how or why it does, but it does. (Even if you argue the figures are incorrect, that £9 million has to be allocated somewhere. The other costs were listed as mundane things like ticket office costs, utility bills etc and couldn't explain the £9 Million.)

Kenwright said Everton will lose around £5 Million per year for the foreseeable future, given we lost around £4 million this year and that included the proceeds from Bellefield, then you'd imagine that we'll lose around £13 million or so each year, unless of course we sell players to cover these costs.

The Blue Union came across well, they didn't slag anyone off, they concentrated on facts. It's sad that people come on forums like this and slate them without actually finding out what they have to say.

They don't have answers to the problems besetting the club, but at least they are trying.

All that is necessary for the triumph of imcompetence is that good men do nothing.
Brian Lawlor
14 Posted 09/10/2011 at 12:07:03
As I asked, a) What are the Blue Union trying to achieve? b) What was the point of yesterday's meeting?

All I see it achieving at the moment is causing conflict amongst Evertonians, kopite marches, huge negativity on the club which inevitably will have an effect on management and players. Kopite-like marches and silly gimmicks like a cake-bearing clown, photos with the FA Cup, rolling out HK and flyers accusing Evertonians who don't attend if burying their heads in the sand. Also, if there was an interested buyer in the wings, what would they make of this behaviour?

A lot of noise including some serious bullshit spin like how many attended the march. Websites like SOS1878 & NSNO banning people who object or ask questions. All this bollocks with no feasible solutions in mind. Embarassing and pointless in my opinion.

As for this latest bullshit comparison to Spurs ? not only have they got a board willing to put their hand in their pocket but they also have 120 corporate boxes to our paltry 9. Straight away that's £5.5 million extra per year (£50k per box).
Jon Beck
15 Posted 09/10/2011 at 13:12:45
Rob can you provide any more information on Colin's presentation? I had heard that Finch Farm was a sell and lease back arrangement at c. £1m a year, so how was the c. £9m derived?
Richard Dodd
16 Posted 09/10/2011 at 13:26:50
Has everyone making comparisons with Spurs overlooked the fact that their principal investor is Joe Lewis, long listed as one of the richest buiness tycoons in Britain?
Colin Wainwright
17 Posted 09/10/2011 at 13:39:34
What the fuck is a 'kopite-like march'?
Brian Lawlor
18 Posted 09/10/2011 at 13:58:33
Ask the Blue Union Colin? You're obviously yet another one who can't answer my questions so instead be pedantic over a minor typo. Good effort, lad.
Steve Jones
19 Posted 09/10/2011 at 13:41:34
Got to agree with Brian. The Spurs stuff is twaddle. They charge more for tickets, don't have obstructed-view seats in their ground that they can't sell, and have a much higher focus on corporates than we have ever had.

Pointing that out is irrelevent as we don't have the facilities in the ground to match the Spurs corporate offering if we wanted to and, likely, couldn't compete with the existing city centre venues for the corporate money way out in Walton even if we had them.

You might as well compare us to Arsenal and haul the board over the coals for a lack of ambition because we arent in the north-west version of the Emirates! I'm all for holding the board accountable for its mistakes, but shouldn't we at least keep things sensible?
David O'Keefe
20 Posted 09/10/2011 at 14:14:22
Steve, the comparision is sensible. Even taking into account London prices, the clubs were in the same position financially in 1999. What's changed?

I don't think Walton is a barrier to EFC getting in the corporates, unless you think Tottenham ? the epicentre of the recent riots ? is a similar barrier to Tottenhams getting in the corporates in the capital city.
Colin Wainwright
21 Posted 09/10/2011 at 14:19:51
Not arsed about the typo, lad.

Just this assertion, constantly spouted by the likes of yourself, that a legitimate form of protest, is somehow kopite-like.

So I won't ask the Blue Union ? I'm asking you.
Colin Wainwright
22 Posted 09/10/2011 at 14:26:13
BTW Brian, the Blue Union haven't caused conflict amongst Evertonians. Bill done that all by himself.
Steve Jones
23 Posted 09/10/2011 at 14:25:00
David,

The complaint is that they haven't developed Goodison for corporates since 1999?. Point 1 they've been, albeit woefully, trying to move ground since then and point 2 Walton is a limiter.

For your comment on Tottenhams relative position to be worth anything you'd have to believe that London and Liverpool are equal in terms of composition. They aren't!. Tottenham is not Kensington & Chelsea, but, its still far, far more affluent than Walton and gives Spurs FAR greater visibility as a brand than Everton. Walton IS a barrier to accessing the corporate money that the likes of Spurs tap into.
Adam Bennett
24 Posted 09/10/2011 at 14:40:17
I'd like to know how our commercial revenue is £9m per year, and Spurs' is £41m.

Such a massive gap is unreal to me.

Do our Commercial and Marketing team actually do any work, or just sit on their arses all day doing sod all?
David O'Keefe
25 Posted 09/10/2011 at 14:37:02
Steve: I think we're going to have to disagree on this one. In 1999 both clubs had squads and net asset values that were broadly similar. I think we need the relevant slide from Colin Fitzpatrick's presentation to clear this up.

The issues about Walton being a limiter is absolute rot. Claiming that Tottenham is more affluent than Walton is a misnomer. Both clubs are based in impoverished areas one is prospering the other stagnating, Why? Thats the question that needs answering.

Some blues not just you Steve need to stop making excuses for the clubs stagnation and need to hold those responsible for it to account. We should also ask them what they're going to do about it as they're not in a hurry to leave.
Steve Jones
26 Posted 09/10/2011 at 14:47:12
Adam

....the first little hint was, as Brian mentioned a few posts above, Spurs 120 corporate boxes and Everton 9 corporate boxes.

David,

Excuses is laughable. Some Evertonians need to knock of the lazy fucking attitude that if they blame everything on the board all the problems will go away.

You want to have a think about whats being said mate. We need a board with a 'business plan' is the clamour....we need a new board thats for bastard certain....but you have to be hideously stupid to believe that there is a 'business plan' that finds us the tens of millions per year, in commercial revenue, that we need to compete without huge investment in facilities.

We need a board with money to invest in a stadium that gives us the corporate facilities that Spurs have and in a location where we can at least have a fair stab at filling them. Anything else and you, and Evertonians like you, will be back on here 6 months after the takeover bleating about the new mob same as the old mob!. Pointless and frigging useless.

Of course Tottenham is more affluent than Everton its not even bloody close a contest. Tottenham is also London not Liverpool. The London effect on corporates isnt something that needs explaining is it?. If we had got a stadium prime located in the heart of Liverpool's city centre waterfront we'd still be at a commercial disadvantage to Spurs where they are - you do realise that?!.

Comparing us with Spurs commercially is a fucking joke mate. As is anyone who tries it.
Brian Lawlor
27 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:05:52
Colin, you figured out the answer to your question. Well done lad.

In 1999, Spurs also had 120 corporate boxes and we still only had 9 and also had a board willing to spend.

Is that the answer to one of my questions i.e yesterdays meeting was all about comparing us, unrealistically to Spurs? Even if was a level playing field with them they've hardly outshone despite spending 100's millions more.
Colin Wainwright
28 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:14:13
What the fuck are you talking about Brian?
Are you on glue?

Steve. There may not be a business plan that finds us tens of millions of pounds per year. There certainly wont be one with this board running the show. So, surely, the first step to achieving this aim is to get shut of the current board.

I'm just talking first steps here. Like the Blue Union, I dont come armed with years of business savvy and a spare fuckin billionaire, just the realisation that the current board are taking us on a downward trajectory, and we need change.
Brian Lawlor
29 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:27:45
Colin - you asked what i meant in post 18 and then explained what it was in post 23 so pass me the glue when you've finished lid.

No plan + no idea = no point
Adam Bennett
30 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:24:05
Steve, but there is no way the extra boxes Spurs have makes them £32m a year!

For me it is blatantly obvious our Commercial and Marketing team should be doing a much much better job than what they are doing. Increasing this income stream is an absolute must, yet those who are employed to do marketing and commercial deals are doing a second, no third, rate job.

It?s about time the club started employing people who actually know how to do a good job.
Rob Squires
31 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:24:41
Jon - There wasn't a breakdown, but I thought the same as you it was around £1 Million a year, on the slide it was over £8 Million per year.

The point of the comparison with Spurs was that in 1999 they were broadly similar, in terms of commercial revenue and assets on the balance sheet. This is not the case now, despite us both finishing in similar positions in the league.

Obviously Everton have outsourced most of their commercial activities and that would affect the figures, but not to the amount that it is the difference now.

Commerical Revenue, shirt sales etc has nothing to do with how much money the chairman has or has not got.
Brian Waring
32 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:34:21
Adam, our commercial and marketing board is probalby a few people sat in a broom closet.
Robbie Riddal
33 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:30:24
Brian Lawlor. What do you suggest? Clearly there's an element of our fanbase that believe we've been poorly run. So what do you suggest those fans do? Nothing? The aim of the Blue Union, I imagine, is much the same as the aims of KEIOC were - to counter the propaganda and spin that emanates from the Club; to offer an alternative view for the larger fanbase to consider.

Steve Jones. I presume you feel that the district of Anfield is far more affluent than it's neighbouring district of Walton, then? Seeing as Liverpool have no problem filling their own corporate capacity? Or do you accept that it's actually nothing to do with the area whatsoever, and more to do with the success and branding of the Club, for which the Board are ultimately responsible?

Everton aren't in a dire financial situation because we've been unlucky or because of the economic deprivation of the community in which it resides; Everton are in a dire financial situation because of the way the Board have run the club. At every turn they've taken poor advice and poor decisions. It's indisputable. Unless you've a vested interest in trying to promote otherwise.
Colin Wainwright
34 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:30:15
Brian. No I never.

No point. No fuckin point! See that's the problem I have with your silly little equation. You can't seriously be happy with the way the club is being run.

Go back to sleep Brian. Bills in charge. Lad.
Brian Lawlor
35 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:56:15
Robbie - what do I suggest? Im asking the Blue Union what they suggest because its them making all the noise and them who've created this group so surely they've got the answers? As for spin, it appears they're countering spin with more spin, claiming 1,000s at the march, Howard Kendall, banning anti-Blue Union from relevant websites and now the ridiculous claim that somehow, commercially we're the same as Spurs.

I am certainly far from happy with Kenwright and the way the club has been run but I'm a realist. However, quite frankly I'm embarrassed by most of the things Blue Union have done so far and what has it and what is it going to achieve other then negative things? Not one Blue Union member or supporter has offered anything of substance so until they do most Evertonians find them a blot on our club. Instead, the latest bollocks is a ridiculous comparison to Spurs.

Colin lad - that glue must be strong if you can't remember or even read your previous posts
Steve Jones
36 Posted 09/10/2011 at 15:54:21
Robbie you've not looked at the RS corporate offering have you mate?.

When you do you'll see that Anfield boasts a mere 32 boxes....I think I read somewhere that MK Dons ground has 28...just as a little comparison for you.

LFC want to move to a new ground, in case you hadn't heard, partly to address this kind of missing revenue. They are hoping that their 'brand' and a truly awesome £400mn stadium will be enough to drag the market out to them. If it doesnt then they still have their global brand and international marketing to fall back on.

You think we could fill a 60k seater £400mn super-stadium?. You think a new board will suddenly bring in global clamour for Everton merchandise such that our brand can match theirs and allow us to gamble on not catching the corporate market?. Nah.

If they are going to be stupid and demand that the coporates come to them we need to take advantage of that mistake and beat them to the corporates.

Everton are partly in the financial mess they are in because of the low affluence of the fanbase. Lets face it if we were all richer the ticket prices could be hiked up a good way....which would help.

The board are amateurs...no-one has said different....this expectation that a new board will sweep in with 'the answer' is absurd. The likelihood is that there has been little interest because those used to putting together the bright business plans have had a look and realised that there IS no easy answer. Staggers me how Evertonians dont understand that simple premise.

Robbie Riddal
37 Posted 09/10/2011 at 16:10:32
I don't have the answers you're looking for Brian. I'm not a member of nor have any affiliation whatsoever to the Blue Union; however, as a concerned Evertonian, I am pleased to see a supporters group formed, even if it's sole achievement is to educate other less enlightened supporters of our situation; just as KEIOC did.

Personally, I'd like to see the Blue Union lobbying for greater transparency from Everton. I feel ex-communicated, disenfranchised, completely disillusioned with not only the predicament Everton find themselves in, but the lack of accountability and disgraceful lack of communication about how the Club plans to progress. I am sick and tired of hearing Kenwright insulting the intelligence of all Evertonians every time he opens his mouth. I am sick and tired of Elstone and Ross dismissing the concerns of Evertonians with such shocking disregard and contempt. And with a local media unwilling to investigate how Everton have reached an impasse, seemingly on the grounds of favour and that 'the grass isn't always greener', I am grateful to the coalition of supporter groups who have united under the Blue Union umbrella.
David O'Keefe
38 Posted 09/10/2011 at 17:27:11
Steve: I attended the BU meeting yesterday and I think the comparision between Spurs and Everton is valid. I'll ignore your straw man rant and stick to the point that both clubs in impoverished areas have moved in different trajectories off the park since 1999.



Comparing Spurs to EFC commercially now, is a joke theres a 32million pound difference and its not down to location. Its facilities and having no business plan other than asset utilisation and disposal.
Colin Wainwright
39 Posted 09/10/2011 at 17:30:22
You have lost the fucking plot Brian.

Post 23 was from Steve Jones. My post (#22) certainly did not answer the question, ' What the fuck is a kopite march'.

Keep sniffin lid. Oh, and try not to be so condescending when your talking shite.
Colin Wainwright
40 Posted 09/10/2011 at 17:44:40
Agree Robbie.

Why should you, I, the Blue Union, have the fuckin answers? The board should have the answers. It's very fuckin plain to see, they don't.

Sean O'Brien
41 Posted 09/10/2011 at 18:10:22
As I live in london and unable to attend such meetings, can someone post the contents of the meeting please and if possible attache the presentation that has been discussed.
Steve Jones
42 Posted 09/10/2011 at 18:10:56
David,

Ignore whatever you dont like fella....seems to be a recurring theme amongst some Evertonians these days. Simple fact is that your use of the word impoverished is meaningless. North London is only impoverished in terms of comparison with the rest of Greater London and the surrounding counties.

Comparing Tottenham with Walton prodces a very different gradiant. It also does not illustrate the very 'specific' demographic that is deeply involved in supporting Spurs which extends beyond the immediate surroundings of North London.....though there is still the concentration of course.

Spurs have far greater commercial opportunity than us by their location. They have been quick to capitalise on that commercial opportunity.....which is good for them. We do not have the same commercial opportunity in Walton. If there were 100 executive boxes in Goodison do you think we'd be filling them?. We have to move to grow - the problem is that the people we have in charge are so witless they couldnt get laid in a whorehouse but, more importantly, are poor.

You can talk about business acumen and all the rest of it as much as you like. Its bull. The new ownership has to be able to buy us a new ground with all the facilities somewhere we can be competetive or all this with the BU and Kendall etc is worthless....there is no 'well its better to start somewhere'' its crap....if there is no way forward we're no better off.

People need to realise just how tall an order is being demanded here!!!!!

David O'Keefe
43 Posted 09/10/2011 at 19:25:51
Steve: This is getting nowhere you claim that being based in Walton is a problem, yet Spurs being based in Tottenham is not a problem? They're both poor areas, one club is prospering the others not.

Being based in London was not a commercial advantage in 1999; So what did they do differently? Develop a sustainable business plan! If Everton had done the same we would not be having a ludricous debate on London weighting issues.

I'm glad we're agreed that new ownership is required, so why the attitude to the BU? They gave a good presentation on the finances and outlined possible solutions; reduce costs, stadium plan and new ownership.

The elephant in the room is that the board have the gall to ask anyone to pay a price for a business that they have run into the ground. They should sell for the debt (Colin's personal view). They have put no money into the club; loaded it with debt and added no value and they expect a return on their shares....they deserve nothing.
Steve Jones
44 Posted 09/10/2011 at 21:03:34
What? Of course being based in London was a commercial advantage in 1999 but the game hadn't gone through the full Sky evolution at that point where money was as absolute a factor as it is 12 years later.

We have tried to move twice in those twelve years. Stupidity reigned in both cases... but the target is clear that it's accepted Goodison takes us nowhere. This is where your 'develop a sustainable business plan' is so much crap... the sustainable business plan is move somewhere we can generate significantly more bloody revenue!

I dont know if you are deliberately misreading what I'm writing about Tottenham or just don't want to read it. Tottenham is more affluent than Walton. Spurs' fanbase is spread around the Greater London area and home counties areas far more affluent than Walton, North Liverpool and Merseyside in general. It doesn't make a bit of difference whether Tottenham is a deprived area in London because it's a damned sight wealthier than Walton and its proximity to London makes it a lot more commercially attractive for sponsorship etc than us up on the outskirts of Liverpool.

Why do I have a problem with the BU? I want to see an alternative to the board capable of taking real action. Putting together a PR campaign that's positive about the club and its fans... selling the idea of the club regardless of the board's stance. I had hopes that the BU might be the outfit to take that constructive action. Colin Fitz and the like have been at this for years, but have they even tried for a real mandate from the fans? No. They wheel out Kendall for an after-dinner speech completely unrelated to the rest of the meeting and we get a litany of meaningless stats about a club with a completely different commercial backdrop to us. Disappointed doesn't cover it.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads