Why have Everton not been sold?

, 10 October, 83comments  |  Jump to most recent
Mirror Op-Ed piece skims the surface
After concluding it can't be the manager, it's not the players, and the stadium issue has not deterred other deals, Anderson wonders if Bill Kenwright is asking too much or is he standing in the way of a potential deal?
It was interesting that the fans' group Keep Everton In Our City, who were opposed to the Kirkby move, held a well-attended meeting in Liverpool on Saturday and they are tired of Kenwright's excuses.

Together with the Blue Union, they feel Kenwright is an obstacle to the sale of Everton and want him to step aside while a new board is convened to sell the club.

Obviously Kenwright disagrees, but while Everton remain in limbo, more supporters may start to support this view.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Mirror



Reader Comments (83)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Knox
1 Posted 10/10/2011 at 15:09:12
All BK has wanted is to get funding so he can stay in charge and spend other people's money, like PG's money.
Trevor Mackie
2 Posted 10/10/2011 at 16:04:14
After the revelations of the BU meet with Kenwright it's hard to believe he's anything other than an obstacle.

Most folks owning a sinking asset would flog it at the first opportunity and, according to BK, they get offers all the time... clearly something doesn't add up.

We probably do attract as much interest as any and could be sold tomorrow but the pirates are greedy with Kenwright probably insisting on continued involvement.

But they're fireproof, fans have changed; they're just not as passionate as they were ? not only here but globally.

Going back to the disintegration of Leeds and the piss-taking by Hicks and Gillete, even the Glazers remortgaging Man Utd to the hilt, there was protest but nothing like the scale I'd imagine pre-Premier League... ditto the shenanigans at Portsmouth and Birmingham.

The BU are finding out how alluring apathy is.

They're killing us ? but who really cares? ... traditionalists who did are now a minority, maybe 0.02%.
Denis Richardson
3 Posted 10/10/2011 at 16:05:39
Better late than never I guess.

Great that the national press is finally beginning to see the real issue with Everton and asking the obvious question of why we have not been sold yet, even though the 24/7 nonsense keeps getting put forward by BK.

Good to see that this seems to have been brought about by the BU and their meeting. They are slowly getting our plight highlighted to the wider public. Hopefully a few more journos will finally see the truth instead of backing the status quo all the time.

Keep it up lads.
Steavey Buckley
4 Posted 10/10/2011 at 16:26:18
Everton are supposed to be valued at 140 million J, add on the 40 millions it owes the bank, a new stadium and a need for more investment in players and inflated salaries that go with it, who has got 600 million J to burn on a club which is not a household name?
Colin Malone
5 Posted 10/10/2011 at 16:59:45
Trevor # 2.
Most folks owning a sinking asset would flog it at the first opportunity.

Me thinks, more like a sleeping giant, remember we come from a footballing crazy city, ok two teams but amagin if we got took over by the Chelsea russian at the time he controlled that. club?. Everton would be bigger than what Chelsea are now.
Peter Laing
6 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:06:04
Totally agree Steavey Buckley @ 4 regarding the £500-600 million required from the point of a blank canvas perspective. The issue with Kenwright is that he was responsible for the demise of the King's Dock, the failed Destination Kirkby fiasco and the £4-5 million pound loss and continuing debt being accrued year on year.

Kenwright should have accepted total accountability for the King's Dock, it would have been the spring-board to project Everton in a positive light both comercially and in every other sense. If he had any dignity or honour, he would have accepted that both he and Gregg fucked up on a grand scale and walked away.

Since the demise of the King's Dock we have continued to lurch from one disaster to another, an interim board is the only logical solution to the current malaise that is pervading the Club whilst Kenwright and his silent benefactors remain in control.
Pablo Brown
7 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:11:39
Steavey Buckley City were a lesser known name than Everton before their take over.
Kevin Tully
8 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:21:40
That's another journo barred.

Cheeky bastard, asking Bill how much he wants, boys pen ya know.
Steavey Buckley
9 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:24:46
The could be one way out of the financial dilemma, if it is feasible, issue 500 or 600 million shares at a pound each. What are not bought by Everton supporters, could be sold around the world, to give everyone a chance to own part of a premier league club. The chairman and board could be decided by majority shares.

Robbie Riddal
10 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:25:33
Steavey Buckley #4 - I don't necessarily agree with your assertion that £600M would be required. The main obstacle to redeveloping Goodison is not because it cannot be redeveloped, it's a finance issue. The land is available, providing the finance is available to pay for it. That being the case, a redevelopment of our historic home could be implemented piece-meal, requiring a much smaller initial outlay, to 'get the ball rolling' as it were. The debt need not be cleared in its entirety.

And even if we did agree that Everton need to fund a new stadium, the Sheikh's at City spent upward of £500M on transfer fees & wages alone in the first few years. Obviously they're an almost unique case but I think it disproves the argument that the initial outlay required at Everton would be too big.
Jim Hindley
11 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:33:52
We all have our own opinions as to why the club can't be sold but I have heard from a very good sorce the it is Kenwright who is stopping it. He wants to sell the club but still remain in charge ? who is going to go along with that?
Steavey Buckley
12 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:33:22
I would have thought a new stadium would require a shopping and hotel complex to maximize extra income, other than pure football income. This would attract local financial support from the Liverpool council and much needed jobs for local people. When Everton close their gates at the end of every match, Goodison appears like a ghost town.
Denis Richardson
13 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:56:51
Steve, where do you get Everton being valued at £140M from?

We are net in debt and last time I asked how much one share was I was quoted £1,200. There are 35 million shares so that would total about £42M.

I know that we are not listed so you cannot value a company by the number of shares x price of one share as you have premium for control and other factors etc. However, your £140M number seems way off the mark to me.

I think I read somewhere that BK was asking somewhere around £100M for the club ? which is still ridiculous given we are in debt.

Anyway back to the £140M, where did this come from?
Ste Traverse
14 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:53:58
I too am sick and tired of Kenwright's excuses and have been for years, hearing of the potential ownership of Sheik Mansour is just another kick in the bollocks.

Kenwright blames the stadium issue for him not purchasing us, but I believe Kenwright and his cronies wanted to sell up once Kirkby had been given the green light so, when they sold, they could charge more.

The approach from Mansour obviously came at the wrong time for Kenwright and the board in their quest to make a killing.

Mansour is supposed to be worth over £20 billion. He could have bought us 10 stadiums!
Phillip Greenhow
15 Posted 10/10/2011 at 17:57:14
My opinion only: The money needed to take us on to the next level would not be astronomical. £100mil? to buy William and his fools out. £45mil to clear debts. Give Moyes a healthy transfer kitty of say, £75mil, and if he cannot add to the squad to take us into the top 4 ? sack him.

As to a new stadium, if we invested another £15 million each season over 10 years, Goodison would be akin to Old Trafford.

Initial outlay = £220mil
Ground improvement = £150mil over ten years
Phillip Greenhow
16 Posted 10/10/2011 at 18:21:54
And operating loses would be anywhere between £5-15mil season... until we cracked the top 4 and regularly participated in the Champions League.
Lee Gerrard
17 Posted 10/10/2011 at 19:29:54
@Denis Richardson

"We are net in debt and last time I asked how much one share was I was quoted £1,200. There are 35M shares so that would total about £42M.

You need to do some sums mate.... 35 million shares at £1200 a go is £4.2 billion in my books.
35 million shares at £1.20 a pop is £42M
Brian Waring
18 Posted 10/10/2011 at 19:33:28
BK's probalby waiting for Sir Philip Green to give him the thumbs - up to sell.
Brian Denton
19 Posted 10/10/2011 at 19:54:49
Brian, I think he means 35 thousand shares, not 35 million !
Brian Denton
20 Posted 10/10/2011 at 20:17:21
Sorry Brian Waring - I meant to write Lee (Gerrard)
Joe McMahon
21 Posted 10/10/2011 at 20:28:41
In 2 weeks time we'll be in the bottom 3 as well, if they show Kenwright's mug on the big screen, people will still clap, well he's a blue ya know! - wouldn't want to be like City and sell our souls... Looking at the football City play, I bloody would! Not gonna happen though.
Richard Dodd
22 Posted 10/10/2011 at 21:04:41
Perhaps Blue Union could get a REAL owner involved... someone like Ken Bates. After tonight`s Leeds United `expose` on BBC Yorkshire, I bet the Elland Road mob would gladly do a swop!
Steavey Buckley
23 Posted 10/10/2011 at 21:11:10
Denis Richardson: The Forbes value of Everton Football Club, some seasons ago was about $207 million or about £140 millon:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forbes'_list_of_the_most_valuable_football_clubs
Robert Daniels
25 Posted 10/10/2011 at 22:58:18
Well said Kevin @24, he could've given us the stadium before all the rest, United, Arsenal etc.

Gregg was backed by a billionaire, Granchester, £1.2 billion. We would've been ahead of all of them and we wouldn't be where we are today. But he wouldn't relinquish control...

He says he's looking for a billionaire to take over? Who better, than the grandson of Sir John Moores (RIP). The Moores family, I believe, will come back and save the club their grandfather loved with a passion.

John Moores, or rather Sir John, left his wedding day, and his new bride, to go to Goodison, because Everton were playing. Imagine that went well with the missus on your wedding day! He didn't care... he loved Everton.

Blue Bill, "There's no bigger blue than me..." ? Wrong!!!

Sir John ?The biggest blue ever.........

Over to you, Lord Granchester.

Join the Blue Union, Sir, and help us get your granddad's club back to where it belongs.
Peter Barry
26 Posted 11/10/2011 at 03:52:57
If and when Everton go in to administration, the colossal short sighted blunder made by not moving to Kings Dock, a location which would have provided numerous non-football fund-raising possibilities, will go down as the major contributing factor.
John Audsley
27 Posted 11/10/2011 at 06:59:57
I really don't think Bluey wants to sell, he wants investment and CONTROL. It's like the bloke who's knocking off a girl at work "I will leave her, Marlene, I'm just waiting for the right time..." Meanwhile, said chap gets home and eats his tea next to loving wife in the knowledge that poor old Wifey is completely clueless and Marlene too starry eyed to work him out.

Bill wont sell and cos he's a blue that's all that matters to most of the fanbase. I'm not sure this wouldn't happen at any other club apart from ours...
Liam Reilly
28 Posted 11/10/2011 at 07:26:53
is Kenwright asking too much or is he standing in the way of a potential deal?

Yes
Alan Williams
29 Posted 11/10/2011 at 08:26:03
Peter 26, the fact we aren?t spending means we will not go into administration.

EFC, like it or not, are not putting the future of the club at risk by leveraging debt to buy players, other than what is seen as an acceptable level by our creditors.

Robert 25, what a load of crap about the Grantchesters, they never backed Gregg at all and have never in the past 15 years backed EFC as a club and in my opinion they are more to blame than Kenwright as they have the means to do something but have chosen to do nothing.

Please stop the bull shit about Kenwright wanting to keep hold of EFC, he doesn?t own EFC ? he only has 27% of the company!!!! If the Grantchesters at any point wanted EFC, they could purchase control in days, they have enough allies on the board to do so.

This myth about Gregg and KD is just fabricated he; was a businessman trying to get the best deal for him which included his company SFX taking control not just of large chunks of future EFC revenue but also large chunks of the other revenue that KD would generate and the board of EFC (including the Grantchesters) decided this wasn?t in EFC's best interest.

At the time, it was a simple choice... maybe wrong in hindsight, but Gregg was not looking at the interests of EFC but his own pocket which is totally fine in my book. But don?t hold a flame for Gregg as the lost savour ? he was in it for himself: nothing more, nothing less. COYB
Martin Mason
30 Posted 11/10/2011 at 08:53:44
It is blindingly obvious why Everton haven't been sold. The asking price when you include all liabilities is just too high even for an idiot. Move along, nothing hapening here.

Sensible solutions on how to rescue a broke business anybody?
Eric Myles
31 Posted 11/10/2011 at 09:40:25
Martin #29: a shares issue.
Eric Myles
32 Posted 11/10/2011 at 09:42:21
PS Martin, by 'all liabilities' I assume you mean Kenwright?
Peter Laing
33 Posted 11/10/2011 at 09:54:19
An iterim board is needed to get answers to the elephant that is in the room in the form of Robert Earl / Philip Green and to ellucidate what are their motives concerning Everton. The pressure has quite rightly been applied to Bill Kenwright in this respect, after all he invited them to the table. The recent BVI loan requires further investigation as I am sure that the interest rate is yielding a more positive return leveraged against the Club that sitting in some offshore account.
Dave Wilson
34 Posted 11/10/2011 at 10:43:55
EFC has been in steady financial decline for 40 years. Sure, Kendall's team of the eighties and Royle's FA Cup winners were able to paper over the cracks, but let's be mindful of Kendall's revelation concerning Reid's transfer fee and the fact that we were already in the business of loaning players from clubs like Blackburn.

Kenwright is out of his depth, that is now just about incontestable and nobody in their right mind would want to sink their fortune into our club, so what are our options?

The task... the RESPONSIBILITY of rescuing our club, rests with us, The Evertonians; we have got to stop looking for this knight in shining armour ? he ain't coming.

Everton Football Club have too many fans who contribute little or nothing. Adult match-goers entering the ground with cut-priced junior tickets; fans spending their money on beer and watching the match on foreign channels in the alehouse instead of going to Goodison; Fans all around the world who want to call themselves Evertonians but don't want to purchase Evertonia membership.

I read somewhere that there is an estimated half-a-million Evertonians world wide. How can we be skint?

If all those fans were to set up standing orders payable to EFC, for just a tenner a month, the club's debt would disappear in a year. Imagine how far we could come in five years?

What would you get in return? Fuck all, except the knowledge that for the price of a weekly pint you would be doing your bit.

Many will turn away in disgust at the suggestion that we should be bailing out Bungling Bill... but, if we leave him to sink, we go down with him.

If Everton Football Club is as precious to you as you say it is then prove it. Stop sneaking into the match at junior prices. Stop watching it in the alehouses... and if you live abroad, send in your contributions.

The club doesn't need your love or undying loyalty ? it needs you hackers.

Ask not what your club can do for you...
Ste Traverse
35 Posted 11/10/2011 at 12:23:03
Alan Williams.

Why should the Grandchesters bail out Kenwright for the mess created by him and his cronies?
Tony J Williams
36 Posted 11/10/2011 at 12:25:46
Playing Devil's Advocate here (I want Kenwright gone too).

If Kenwright owned the club (instead of just a minority percentage) and was able to sell without getting the thumbs up from his cohorts... Why should he sell it just because us fans want him to?

Isn't it his to do with what he pleases? What gives us the right to tell him he MUST sell the club or stand down and let someone else sell it for him?

I wish he would eff off but after reading this post and many others, I thought, why should he if he doesn't want to?
Shaun Brennan
37 Posted 11/10/2011 at 12:56:03
Just to play devil's advocate again, perhaps Kenwright does indeed want to sell. But the other directors Earl and Woods don't. Maybe they are quite happy sitting on there shares with Everton and not having much input into the club. Sort of stashing money away for tax reasons by owning some of the club?
Paul Gladwell
38 Posted 11/10/2011 at 13:08:15
Here's on for you:


http://www.thedaisycutter.co.uk/2011/10/cutter-exclusive-new-everton-owners-announced-this-week/

Dave Randles
39 Posted 11/10/2011 at 13:02:34
I would like to sell that 16 bedroom mansion about two miles from where I live for £7.5m. Oh! But hang on I don't actually own it, so that decision isn't mine to make.

Sound familiar?
Brian Harrison
40 Posted 11/10/2011 at 14:11:50
I know many posters believe that there is a billionaire waitng to buy Everton, and he is just waiting to get the go ahead from BK.

But I can't see any reasons why anyone with half a brain would buy Everton, never mind somebody clever enough to amass a billion pounds.

Would he ever get a return on any of his outlay? Almost certainly No! Would pumping £750 million into the club guarantee Champions League status? Well, there is a club not far from here whose spend dwarfs Everton's and they have just spent £100 million trying to get into the Champions League and they may fall well short.

So... can anyone tell just a couple of reasons why a businessman not a fan would invest such fortunes?
Steve Jones
41 Posted 11/10/2011 at 13:39:28
Why are people still fixated on the asking price?

If the board's shares were offered free, we wouldn't automatically get the kind of owners we need ? is that not well understood?

Everton, like every other major English club, is a business now and not a football club. We are a business with fairly fixed income (as we aren't suddenly going to find another 100,000 evertonians globally all queueing up to buy Everton-branded merchandise) and in a market with ever escalating costs just to remain competetive. A business that barely breaks even in a good year right now.

Why is someone with sound business accumen going to consider Everton as a good thing to get in on again at any price?

If we find someone, or a consortium of someones, willing to put in a couple of hundred million for a new ground and debt elimination and take the long-term view that Moyes can build us to a regular CL team without having to drop in the lunacy spending of Man City or even the relatively serious spend of Lerner at Villa, we have something to offer.

There has to be an acceptance that that specific type of owner isn't going to be ten-a-penny and most will look for a way of making a faster return than something that only starts to pay off 5 or 6 seasons after they put their money in. Even with the incumbent idiots swept away, this would still be the reality of the situation... why is there this belief that reducing the asking price would suddenly lead to a flood of offers?
Steve Guy
42 Posted 11/10/2011 at 14:49:37
I watched a fascinating half hour on "Who owns Leeds?" this week with the excellent David Conn presenting.

Ken Bates (read Kenwright?) was a figurehead from Day One at Leeds and the ins and outs since then make your hair curl. Basically, for years no-one knew who owned Leeds as it was all done through offshore loans (ring any bells?).

I hope there are no comparisons between our position and that of Leeds' ownership because if there are, we are definitely in the doo doo and it would explain why no-one is buying.
Jamie Barlow
43 Posted 11/10/2011 at 15:39:04
Has anybody seen Thedaisycutter.co.uk. Indian takeover soon. Nothing to worry about. It'll all be sorted soon enough.
Richard Knights
44 Posted 11/10/2011 at 15:49:56
Exclusive! New Everton buyers revealed!

After extensive research, background checks and due diligence by a high powered team of lawyers, financial experts and investment bankers Bill Kenwright is finally able to announce the short list of potential buyers. So in alphabetical order...

A fella he met down the pub who said he was definitely interested...
Bernie Madoff
Croesus
Don't Stop Believin'!
Enron
Fairies at the bottom of the garden
Gillett and...
Hicks
Internet ? another guy with loads of money who sounded interested...
Joker, The
Khan, Aga
Lord Lucan
Midas
National Bank of Greece
Oprah
Presley, Elvis ? last seen working in the Everton Megastore
Queen, The - another Friend of Bill's (FOB)
Ringo
Someone else (who is definitely interested but who doesn't want his name revealed at the moment but is really, really considering buying the club at some point in the future...)
Thomas, Clive
Ummmm
Virgin on the ridiculous
Warren Buffett
XXXXXXL
You've Been Framed!
Zzzzzzzzzz...
Trevor Mackie
45 Posted 11/10/2011 at 17:03:19
Steve #40

If I was in the market for a Prem club and most everything else was equal, I'd go for the club realistically priced.

When the dirty linen eventually gets aired, who'd be surprised if, on this basis, buyers have gone elsewhere... and if one was Mansoor...
Alan Williams
46 Posted 11/10/2011 at 17:40:11
Ste T, because they have been board members just like BK, and I think to date are still major shareholders in the company, so they have much to gain. BK doesn?t own EFC so stop getting hung up on bailing out BK, the club will survive a lot longer than BK.

My answer was in reply to Robert?s post wrongly claiming the Grancthesters are the savour as they backed Gregg which isn?t true at all. The Grantchesters don?t need to back anybody, they have the means and the wealth to do it alone if they so wish, and it's obvious they don?t wish too, which again is their call ? nobody else?s.

They had the opportunity not just to guarantee funds for KD but advance the whole lot should they wish... so we did have the resources at board level but they chose not too. BK's biggest mistake is he doesn?t have the money to back up his love for the club; sometimes, being too close can be a massive hindrance in business terms and I personally feel that has been his biggest mistake.

Everton is a passion for us all but in business you have to make decisions that are not that popular and sometimes we have fudged them because we aren?t ruthless enough. Basically, in my opinion, having such a dedicated fan at the helm isn?t the best mix, unless he has billions to spare, that is! COYB
Ste Traverse
47 Posted 11/10/2011 at 18:34:58
I don't agree at all, Alan.

Bill Kenwright and his yes men have got us in to this financial mess, it's up to them to get us out of it, not expect someone else to come along and clear up their many mistakes.
Richard Dodd
48 Posted 11/10/2011 at 19:18:39
There is every possibility that, even if Everton had changed hands years ago, the Club would still be in the mire. BK may have made a bad shout or two but so have many of the owners who have been seen as saviours of other clubs and are now as unpopular as those they replaced.

Whilst there is absolutely no possibility of ANYONE with one iota of business sense taking the Club on in the forseeable future, I would much rather be stuck `with one of our own` than most of the clowns who call the shots at other Prem outfits.
Steve Jones
49 Posted 11/10/2011 at 19:41:41
Trevor #44

If Mansour, or anyone else serious, wanted us but balked at the asking price they do exactly what anyone in that position does. They negotiate.

If the board refuse to sell, with a restive fanbase, then some unattributable source leaks the fact that the board are blocking legitimate offers to take the club forward. Imagine what happens if tomorrow the news breaks that Stelios Easyjet bloke wanted to solidify his base in Liverpool and take over the reigns.

I have no doubt that Mansour chose City over Everton partly because of Eastlands and partly that, at the moment, the ability to elevate his club to better than their immediate neighbours in Manchester is symbolic and his involement in the Prem is all about symbolism.

Regardless whether the board are asking £140mn, £120mn or £100mn is absolutely irrelevent. They'll get whatever someone is willing to pay.
Andy Riley
50 Posted 11/10/2011 at 20:11:30
Steve #44 ? sorry, I can't see how the price is irrelevant.

If you try to sell something at several times what is considered a market price, you will not attract buyers... and it's even more difficult if you won't give a general indication of the asking price being sought.

If my car is worth £2,000 and I'm trying to sell it for £10,000 then I don't expect to get knocked over in the rush. Similarly if I advertise it as "price on application" and then refuse to speak to any potential buyers until they've signed all kinds on non-disclosure agreements then any possible sale is unlikely to be smooth and trouble free if it happens at all.

I think it is reasonable that in these circumstances any potential buyer of my car may conclude that I am not a serious and committed seller!
Steve Jones
51 Posted 11/10/2011 at 20:37:37
You aren't selling a car here though, Andy. You are selling a multi-million pound business. A business that is leaking money and in need of shoring up.

Using your car analogy, you have a reasonably powerful 70s vintage Ferrari for sale. It's not in the best nick but the engine is essentially ok. It's great fun when it works but it's going to cost £15k upfront to get straight and a few grand a year in proper upkeep.

Do you think you can sell this car in the Autotrader like a 3-year-old Mondeo? Do you think you'd have to find the right kind of buyer willing to take it on and do a proper job with it and, therefore, negotiate on the price?

In context, anyone who is serious about taking us on and developing the club already knows what they want to pay and knows what they need to invest to get us straight. They also know that the board are on thin ice with the fans and are open to pressure. Engineering a suitably unnattributable leak should make certain any confidentiality agreement is worth less than the paper it's written on... it's scarcely a rare occurence.
Trevor Mackie
52 Posted 11/10/2011 at 20:40:15
Steve @ 48

It's a buyers market mate.

Unless interested parties are fans or football aficionados, there's plenty of clubs that need rebuilding from the ground floor up.

In these circumstances fannying around with a fantasist wouldn't be entertained.
Robert Daniels
53 Posted 11/10/2011 at 21:33:40
Alan Williams,

Gregg wanted to invest the £30M, but only if he could have control ? wouldn't you want control for that investment?

Grantchester owns 8% of Everton so he must still be interested.

Gregg at the time said (his words not mine by the way) that he was backed by Grantchester.

You know and so do I, Grancthester won't work with the liar that is Kenwright, Kenwright is the major shareholder and with the support of Woods, cannot be ousted. So your claim that Grantchester could take over at any time is crap ? for want of a better term!

Gregg wanted a reverse mortgage as part of the deal, so eventually he would get his money out. Sound business thinking, and the reverse mortgage that your hero refused, and slagged off, so he could keep power, and invented Fortress Sports Fund to keep alive his chance of retaining control, ain't as bad as the deal over Finch Farm.

Yes, he was in it for himself, a bit like the liar's two mates, Green and Earl.

Dont spout the party political line to me; I know otherwise.

Crap to you with bells on it.
Robert Daniels
54 Posted 11/10/2011 at 21:59:23
Steve Jones,

I think you're right about the price not being a big a stumbling block to the right buyer, ie, a billionaire. Also, the ground as a stumbling block is a myth; if Mansour was interested in Everton at the time and didn't buy us, it was for one reason only: We were tied into the agreement with Tesco and Knowsley.

Another masterstroke by our leader.....
Steve Jones
55 Posted 11/10/2011 at 21:21:32
Agreed Trevor it is a buyer's market. The buyer has a selection of clubs to consider. Right now, you look at someone like Brighton who have a nice shiny new stadium and the potential to elevate to the Prem and you get a Prem team for relative peanuts... essentially the QPR model.

Or are you aiming for bigger fish to take an established Prem club and try to escalate them to CL and silverware glory.

Buyers prerogative that one. If it's the latter, the clubs with latent quality and no need for new infrastructure are actually quite sparse.... there's Newcastle, us and... er... that's about your lot from what I can see. I don't think it would come down to the starting asking price between the two clubs to be honest. Not least as I think they'd be more expensive!.
Alan Williams
56 Posted 12/10/2011 at 08:01:26
Robert, who is my hero? Read my post ? I have no problems with Gregg making a buck out of the deal but the board didn?t back his offer. At the time, if Gregg done deals with other shareholders, he would have out-voted BK very easily ? he was the second largest shareholder so going in to bed with the Grantchesters would have knocked BK out of it... so why didn?t this happen if the Grantchesters backed Gregg?

What evidence do your blinkered views have of Grantchesters not backing BK? They still sit next to him at the game and chat and joke like everybody else?

I repeat, BK doesn?t own EFC he has 27% and Gregg at the time was second largest followed by Woods and Granchester post TBH dissolving in 2004. In reply to your original post, the Grantchesters are not our savour to date and have never ever made any inclination otherwise, which is such a shame considering they have the cash to aid our club, but again that?s their choice and we must respect that.

Ste T, you just don?t get it, do you? As once Directors and large shareholders, they have an interest in the company doing well ? more than you and I. This is about EFC doing well, not BK, and that?s the problem some of you have; you are far too blinkered in your hatred of BK to look at the bigger picture.

I support EFC, not BK; I want him to sell up, but only to the correct person and ? dare I say it on ToffeeWeb ? I would also be very comfortable if he made reasonable profit on it as long as we have a decent new owner. COYB
Martin Mason
57 Posted 12/10/2011 at 08:26:52
Tony Williams. You've got it in one mate. Why would Kenwright and the board do anything that any of us demand he does if they doesn't wish to do it? The concept that they would allow an unconstituted interim board is frankly hilarious.

Eric, a shares issue is what should happen and I'm not sure why they won't do it. Conspiracy theorists would say that it would somehow dilute the board's power.
Brian Harrison
58 Posted 12/10/2011 at 08:38:50
Robert 52

I find it really interesting that you mention Gregg and Grantchester as if either were any good for our club. I might remind you the Lady Grantchester and her son Lord Grantchester agreed to sell their grandfather's shares to Johnson. So they couldn't wait to relinquish any possible investment in the club.

Then we come to Gregg, who single-handedly tried to arrange the sale of Rooney to his pal Freddie Shephard who was the chairman of Newcastle at the time. Ferguson readilly admits that, although they had been watching Rooney, they were happy for him to spend another year with Everton before they would make a move for him. But when it became apparent that Newcastle would offer Everton I think £23 million, then they had to move for him.

So please don't think that either Gregg or the Grantchesters were any good for our club because they were not. Quite frankly, I don't know why Grantchester holds any shares in the club as he obviously doesn't share his grandfather's love for the club.
Eric Myles
59 Posted 12/10/2011 at 09:58:37
The price would be a stumbling block to a bilionaire.

Billionaires didn't get that sort of money by not having business nous and knowing when someone is asking silly money for selling something and being prepared to walk away from a bad deal to put their money into a more realistic one.

Martin, it's not a theory. A shares issue WILL dilute the boards shareholding UNLESS they buy shares themselves to maintain it. And as we know that's about as likely as you buying the Club yourself.
Jimmy Hacking
60 Posted 12/10/2011 at 12:00:06
In my opinion, you would need at least a £250 million initial outlay (that is a very low estimate) to turn Everton into a profitable team, about 10 years of loss-making so that's another £150 million, and then with luck maybe in a decade the investor will start to recoup some of his money. (I assume it would be a bloke, no woman would be stupid enough.)

So we are basically looking for a multi-millionaire madman.
Gavin Ramejkis
61 Posted 12/10/2011 at 12:50:02
Martin #56 not a conspiracy theory either it was said on oath at the DK hearings by the CEO Rob Esltone that none of the major shareholders were willing to dilute their shareholdings.

As Eric points out it highly unlikely that a bunch of millionaires who havent spent a penny of their own money in over a decade on anything beyond shares and in that I include BK despite this supposed £11m that has been claimed as it has never appeared in any of the company annual returns unless it was a gift at which point he has a cheek asking for it back, to buy more shares for the sake of the club.
Denis Richardson
62 Posted 12/10/2011 at 13:24:55
Lee @ 17 - there are 35,000 shares not 35m, was just a typo.
Ste Traverse
63 Posted 12/10/2011 at 13:31:15
Alan Williams.

What pure arrogance. You slam the Grandchester family yet demand they come in and cover Kenwright's arse for all his fuck-ups.

Laughable.

You're a typical Kenwright supporter. Blinded by the fact he's Blue to blame him for anything, as your attacks on the Grandchesters and Paul Gregg prove.
Martin Mason
64 Posted 12/10/2011 at 16:19:01
I know that issuing shares will dilute their power but, as long as they can outvote any other power block, they won't care.

BTW, I'm a lifelong Evertonian and if I had billions to spare I wouldn't buy EFC. It is a basket case of a club with no brand and, even with a new ground, little chance of achieving any significant additional revenue. Wherever it goes, it will hit a ceiling close to the one it's hit now. We are financially a small club with the baggage of having been a big club with a meaningless motto that manages to perform above where it should be by virtue of having a brilliant, if absolutely frustrating, manager and a top class youth development and scouting system.

Evertonians are slowly coming round to realise what I'm saying above and, the sooner we do, the sooner we can get round to giving our club the positive support that it desperately needs. If we can make a business case for developing Goodison Park, then let's do it in stages and with rights issues or loans to do it and accept that it will mean Fellaini and our other stars leaving. It's terrible of course but to do absolutely nothing is the really criminal option.

A sugar daddy isn't going to come with over half a billion quid to build a new ground, wipe out the debt and buy players and even then keep throwing money at the club to keep it afloat. We have to find our place in soccer's order where we have a sustainable debt level and business model and it may be that this isn't in the Premier League? There is no point in running the club with a model where the banks can pull the plug at any time.
Jimmy Kelly
65 Posted 12/10/2011 at 16:28:31
Congratulations, Ste Traverse, on making a complete fool of yourself! Alan does not 'slam' the Grantchesters anywhere in his post ? he actually defends their right to make a choice.

I would say you are typical of a strange but thankfully small faction of our fans who appear to believe that anybody who does not advocate burning Moyes/Kenwright/[insert today's chosen villain here] at the stake is 'laughable'.
Gavin Ramejkis
66 Posted 12/10/2011 at 17:26:05
Martin, the trouble with the billionaire analogy you chose to allude to did indeed plough lots of money into a team called Man City that had won fuck all for as long as most supporters can remember with no brand to boast of living in the shadow of another team that plays in Salford.

Everton would love a billionaire but a new owner and board with business acumen they want to invest into the club must be better than a bunch of millionaires who offer nothing beneficial whatsoever to the club at present at least stand a chance of turning an annual growing debt with little avenue but to sell players to service it into a business plan which turns the debt into profit through some easy wins ? like marketing and insourcing the outsourced deals that offer pitiful returns ? to the more difficult ones, such as cutting a massive loss or renegotiating a far more tenable deal on Finch Farm.
Richard Reeves
67 Posted 12/10/2011 at 17:19:24
From the beginning, Kenwright claimed he was looking for investment which is a tough sale considering your bussiness doesn't make money. Now it is a supposed sale of the club that Kenwright wants us to believe he wants. He either does not want to let go or can't because the price is too high.

And why would the price be too high? Well, it would be interesting to find out who the money goes to when the club finally is sold (hopefully in my lifetime). Who can really believe a word this man says?
Robert Daniels
68 Posted 12/10/2011 at 17:10:56
Brian @ 57,

Gregg was paid for his shares by Green, he said so himself.
Green brokered the Rooney deal, and Rooney's agent was working from an office with his partner Sheppard's son at St James Park.

They sold their shares at the time to Johnson, he looked the most suitable person at that time.

He, Johnson, won us the FA Cup and built the Park End.

What's Bill done?
Steavey Buckley
69 Posted 12/10/2011 at 21:04:33
The basic failing of BK was not obtaining a brand new football staduim, which is badly needed to bring in extra revenue to compete with the big boys. Extra football revenue can only increase when there are sufficent executive boxes and corporate entertainment, which will exceed normal match day revenue.

And with top Premier League clubs threatening to sell their TV rights to the highest bidder, revenues from TV may fall away in the future, leaving Everton in far worse financial position than now.
Eric Myles
70 Posted 13/10/2011 at 02:01:02
Martin #63, I guess that's where you and I differ. If I had a few billion to spare, I WOULD buy Everton... but not try to run it myself without knowing the first thing about running a business, like Kenwright. I'd get in a team of top class business managers and task them with marketing and developing the Club and making it profitable again while I sit back and enjoy the football.

You say "There is no point in running the club with a model where the banks can pull the plug at any time" ? and this is why the current board must go because that is what they are doing.

You also say, "If we can make a business case for developing Goodison Park then let's do it in stages and with rights issues." Well, there IS a business case for redevelopment, it's on this site and penned by Tom Hughes.

And you "know that issuing shares will dilute their power but as long as they can outvote any other power block they won't care." Well, they will care because it would mean that the multi millionaires that currently own the Club would have to put their hands in their pockets and invest and they have already shown they are not willing to do that. Another reason why they must go and be replaced by someone that will.

"We have to find our place in soccer's order where we have a sustainable debt level and business model and it may be that this isn't in the Premier League?" I can't believe you said that. You would rather keep the current Board and watch us slide down the divisions than do something about it?!?! Amazing.
Chad Schofield
71 Posted 13/10/2011 at 08:15:36
For the love of God, Martin #63. If you genuinely think that we'd be better placed financially outside of the EPL, you're delluded. Do you not think we would have to sell our current players cheaply post balloon payment and be less attractive to kids... Both in terms of playing and supporting.

Acclington Stanley...
Martin Mason
72 Posted 13/10/2011 at 08:24:25
Eric, I think what the board is doing now is, like the majority of clubs, starting to run the club in a sustainable manner. We can hypothesise all day about business models that may or may not work but simply changing the board is no guarantee of success and is a recipe for the disaster scenario you mention. The other unfortunate fact is that the present board and them only who decides when it sells, to whom and for how much. The criticism I do aim atthe board is that they aren't open enough with information on what they are doing. This creates a vacuum that sucks in fantasy and that's what is happening.

The billioaire option solves everything but it is also the zero probability scenario and why would anybody rich throw money at Everton? Where mega rich punters are taking over clubs such as Villa and QpR they are running them on the same sustainable model that Everton is having to go to.
Eric Myles
73 Posted 13/10/2011 at 09:02:13
Martin, while 'simply changing the board is no guarantee of success' I do not beleive that a new owner would deliberately not try to achieve success and would actually act to improve his investment.

Wheras NOT changing the board IS a recipe for the disaster scenario I mention and what is amazing is that you are happy with that!
graham foster
74 Posted 13/10/2011 at 11:00:12
I think the fans will have to start helping out,

Maybe we should start with this .. haha

http://www.metro.co.uk/sport/oddballs/878368-female-fans-strip-off-to-raise-money-for-struggling-polish-football-club#ixzz1aaCmvdys
Shaun Brennan
75 Posted 13/10/2011 at 11:38:37
Why have Everton not been sold?

Let's ask Robbie Savage.



http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/15277116.stm
Martin Mason
76 Posted 14/10/2011 at 08:54:11
Eric, but you are starting from the falsehood that the board are doing everything they can not to achieve success which is patently an incorrect opinion. There is an alternative that they are doing everything they can to run the club in a sustainable way with limited revenue. That sounds far more credible than the fiction that they are somehow trying to do the opposite?
Andrew Laird
77 Posted 14/10/2011 at 08:58:34
Martin #75, The board contains at least 2 members with enough financial muscle to lend Everton the money we borrow each season at more favourable rates and terms than banks/ financial organisations for Everton FC as a business but choose not to. This perpetuates the need for other loans to service debt interest..... yes they are doing everything aren't they? If they brought the debt down we would be a more attractive business to buy, no?

Here is the rub Martin: I, as a paying supporter, have invested more money in Everton FC in the last 10 years than all of the board combined.
Liam Reilly
78 Posted 14/10/2011 at 09:11:37
The Board don't necessarily need to put money into the club to achieve success; however, they fundamentally must have a sustainable business plan, which our board simply do not.
Eric Myles
79 Posted 14/10/2011 at 09:24:13
I'm not saying the Board are deliberately trying to fail at all, Martin, but, if they are doing everything they can to run the club in a sustainable way with limited revenue, then they are clearly failing and that's another reason why they should bring in someone else to run it.
Andrew Laird
80 Posted 14/10/2011 at 10:02:29
Liam, I believe it has come to the point where they do have to put money in.

The board's non-sustainable business model is now defunct because every asset, bar the players, which we need to function as a football business, has been sold.

I agree they should at least have another fundamental business model but for me, if they got their cheque books out and said they BELIEVED in themselves and the staff to turn the club around, it would be a start. At the moment (and for the last 10 years!!) they sit on their hands... time to put up or ship out, reduce some debt properly and actually become a more attractive business for a buyer.
Liam Reilly
81 Posted 14/10/2011 at 10:40:12
The irony is, Andrew, that the football club as a business is so fucked, that ? barring a change of ownership ? only an idiot would put his money into it at this stage.
Andrew Laird
82 Posted 14/10/2011 at 11:01:09
Agreed Liam but surely we can find at least one idiot in our boardroom???!!
Martin Mason
83 Posted 15/10/2011 at 08:22:08
The board doesn't have to put it's own money into the club to keep it operating, that is the ultimate in unsustainable business there is. They also have no obligation to appoint an interim board (was that really serious?) or sell on anything other than their own terms.

These are the only facts. We may not like the way they are running the business but we are a successful club by any standard except the often unrealistic and unreasonable ones of some of our fans. I found Keegan's summary very good.
Tom Hughes
84 Posted 15/10/2011 at 11:01:42
Martin,
You make it sound like the board have no obligations at all. They simply have to take up their seat in the director's box (or not) and preside over us all, and we should be eternally grateful. I also think you mistake financial prudence with having been run into the ground to the extent that we can no longer spend but must sell to survive.

I believe the board has the very serious obligation to deliver the schemes that can help make the club sustainable, to create a platform for the manager to achieve real success, and not just survival. The only FACT is that they haven't done this. They have continually demonstrated a complete inability to deliver ANYTHING.

Over their tenure, practically ALL other clubs' boards have fulfilled their obligations to deliver and maximise revenue streams by investing in their clubs' infrastructure and personnel. Our inactivity has seen us gradually fall down the pecking order, to the point where we can now no longer compete with even the smallest of clubs in the transfer market. How this equates to being successful or well-run in anyway is beyond me.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads