No action against Atkinson

, 11 October, 23comments  |  Jump to most recent
Referee Martin Atkinson has predictably been spared a temporary demotion to the Championship by the Professional Game Match Officials Limited.

Despite a three-man Football Association panel ruling that the official was wrong to send Jack Rodwell off in the Merseyside derby, Atkinson will face no punitive action for his egregious error, one that Everton believe will cost them revenue from league placing.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Guardian



Reader Comments (23)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Michael Coville
1 Posted 12/10/2011 at 00:00:58
Hardly unexpected. Total corruption in the game today. Atkinson couldn't wait to get his red card out for an Everton player. That diving RS gets away with it as well. Watched the replays and he actually hit Rodwell rather than the other way around and yet goes down screaming like a little girl. Bloody pathetic.
Ian Pennington
2 Posted 12/10/2011 at 00:56:04
I think he'll have been strongly spoken to behind closed doors; it's sensible that referees aren't vilified in public, because it would only succeed in increasing the huge amounts of pressure under which these reasonably fallible human beings find themselves working.

The reason he hasn't been dropped a division (which is the same as the reason why he regularly referees PL matches as opposed to League 2 games, for example) is because he's better than most of the other refs in this country ? making fewer mistakes than most who would take his place.

The best thing that could happen as a result of Atkinson's decision the other week is that he learns from it and doesn't make the same mistake again, whilst being sure to update his contact lens prescription. Unfortunately for us, the moment has passed; move on.

Moyes was correct in pointing out that we lost the game due to our own defensive sloppiness (which could have been prevented by his own sub choices in terms of allowing a scenario in which we were caught 2 vs 1 down a wing, while Cahill floated around and defended when he chose to, but that's another story). The travesty was that the game was obliterated as a spectator sport as a result of the decision, but, alas, referees are not machines.

On the Suarez issue, you will notice that he was caught and thus wasn't feigning injury. The collision was accidental and Atkinson's mistake was in jumping to the conclusion that Rodwell was to blame in what was a whole-hearted, totally legitimate tackle. Suarez is a crooked type of player who fits the mould over at Liverpool, but you can't blame him for the red card. Atkinson immediately reached to his pocket because (I believe) he was too close to the incident and essentially used guesswork.
Michael Coville
3 Posted 12/10/2011 at 01:35:43
Sorry Ian, I can't agree. Atkinson is better at giving red cards than any other referee, look at his record. He is a machine, a red card one.

Suarez hardly got hurt, the type of contact is one which occurs numerous times during a game and he goes down screaming in pain. He does it every time he is tackled and referees have to start dishing out yellow cards to stop this cheating.

You really believe it did not influence Atkinson, to say nothing of the other two RS players who were shouting at the ref? We were robbed and, yes, we have to move on... but I hope we don't get Atkinson again.

Simon Watts
4 Posted 12/10/2011 at 01:48:32
The problem here is not the sending off, but the fact that, after all the uproar between, journalists, reporters, TV pundits, managers and not just supporters of the club, but supporters of football in general, not one person is any clearer on the rules of the game.

What was Martin Atkinson's reason?? Why does he still believe he was correct in sending a player off, and will not, even with his own bosses telling him he was wrong, acknowledge, apologise or explain? All we get is that he is a well respected referee?? Who by - Just the referee association.

As I mentioned before, some supporters should get together and take the matter to court, to get their money back. If people stand up, then things change; otherwise they will carry on and nothing gets done. If they get a summons to go to court then they can't stand by their own laws and have to go by everyone else's.
John Barnes
5 Posted 12/10/2011 at 03:54:11
I can't agree with Simon about taking the matter to court, and don' t understand the law(s) angle in his last sentence. Is bad refereeing against the law of the land? Dodgy refs and their dodgy decisions are a typical talking point, the likes of which makes the game what it it is. They've always been there, but now every single one of them is shown over and over again.

I can't agree with Ian either about Suarez not feigning injury, not causing the red card, or that the contact was accidental. Suarez saw it coming, could have got out of the way but took the opportunity to let it happen and try con the ref. And the stupid prick fell for it.

Sadly that type of behaviour is in the main accepted by the pros. The only way anything will change is by hitting the FA and the clubs in their pockets; staying away in (large) numbers, not paying your subscriptions etc.
Peter Barry
6 Posted 12/10/2011 at 04:09:26
Suarez did not DIVE but he did feign INJURY which is a far more serious offense. RS Players also waved cards and screamed and yelled at the Referee, especially scumbag Charlie Adam who even followed Rodwell from the field pushing him and yelling in his ear.

At the very least both Suarez and scumbag Adam should be given a retrospective yellow card for bringing the game in to disrepute. I hope Everton fans reserve a special welcome for these cheating RS scumbags next time we meet them.
Mick Davies
7 Posted 12/10/2011 at 04:11:46
I assume there is a pecking order regarding refs and like the league tables, the worst refs are demoted and the better ones rewarded with the top jobs. Well this doesn't seem to be working. Atkinson has been at the top level for a long time and the derby wasn't his first inept performance. If he was a newly promoted ref then we could cut him some slack but the man regularly travels to Europe to represent the cream of our country''s officials.

God knows what they must think of our standards. If there aren't any better refs at the lower levels then we are doomed. Webb, Twattenberk, Atkinson, the three not very wise men. Thank God for Halsey. He is human but consults his linesmen and apologises for his mistakes. Apparently Atkinson doesn't have to apologise... he doesn't make them.
Simon Watts
8 Posted 12/10/2011 at 06:43:50
@John Barnes. The red card has been admitted to be a mistake, rescinded, so the match was ruined as a result. Under the consumer credit act, you are allowed to ask for your money back, not only for that but also because one of the parties does not wish to communicate. There are consumer laws, and these apply to everything including football matches.
Alan Rooney
9 Posted 12/10/2011 at 08:44:32
'Egregious' ? what a great word! You don't just learn about football on here!!
Lee Gray
10 Posted 12/10/2011 at 09:54:56
How can you be disciplined for carrying out direct orders?
No suprise there!
Peter Laing
11 Posted 12/10/2011 at 10:15:25
My gut feeling just as half-time approached was that David Moyes should have been ready to storm on to the pitch and confront Atkinson with the mother of all finger-wagging expetive ridden tirades. That would have drawn attention to the incident, it should have been followed up with a rant to the media on Match of the Day and the ensuing touchline ban / hefty fine.

David Moyes demonstrated remarkable restraint given the circumstances, something though tells me that his mentor Sir Alex would have been less constrained and would almost certainly have blown a fuse.
David Hallwood
12 Posted 12/10/2011 at 11:05:46
Like every poxy dictatorships, we never make mistakes.
Peter Cummings
13 Posted 12/10/2011 at 12:43:56
Ian, while I appreciate your very articulate comments re the red card issue, I can't agree with your view that Suarez WAS injured. Having seen the incident several times, it seemed that Rodwell's follow through caught the cheat's boot underneath it's back end as he was midway through his 'high jump' routine.

The main issue is why, with all the technology available, the FA mandarins still refuse to recognise instant TV replays ? except when they use it themselves to 'convict'. Plus their view that referees can do no wrong. Like other posters, I agree that we move on and hope commonsense prevails in the future, but I won't be holding my breath.
Tom Bowers
14 Posted 12/10/2011 at 13:23:40
Suarez, like most South Americans, over-reacted. It is part of their stupid macho make-up. Saw it several times yesterday in a few South American World Cup qualifiers. Atkinson acted stupidly and this is why we need technology to immediately review situations like this.

It is becoming increasingly more frustrating to watch referees getting it so wrong and many import players capitalizing on such deeds. Hardly any wonder they keep doing it.

How many times do you see them clutching their faces when the face was never touched? It is corruption and the authorities need to get some guts and issue stronger punishments to them and poor referees.
Mike Elbey
15 Posted 12/10/2011 at 13:43:13
Interesting to see that in games Atkinson has refereed involving Liverpool he has shown 10 red cards ? only 2 of which have been shown to The Shite!!

This is also the referee that ignored the football equivillent of an assault on Steven Pienaar by Jamie Carragher in the first minute of the Anfield derby a couple of seasons ago.

He is also the same referee that allowed Man Utd 8 minutes of injury time to score against Man City 2 years ago dispite only 4 minutes being indicated ? when questioned he stated that he had to add time on for goals scored within injury time. A year later when we were playing Man Utd we had a 4 on 2 break in the 3rd minute of 3 declared minutes of injury time ? he blew up whilst the attack was ongoing despite us having already scored 2 goals in injury time, as such by his previous ruling he should have allowed a further 2 minutes.

The bloke is a proven fraud who totally favours the team he percieves to be of higher rank. Call it cheating if you want, whatever it is it is not impartial refereeing ? the facts speak for themselves.
John Barnes
16 Posted 12/10/2011 at 14:31:37
Hmm Simon, You've got me there with your legalese. Good luck in court.
Gary Mortimer
17 Posted 12/10/2011 at 13:35:22
For all the people who think that having a video ref reviewing borderline/controversial decisions would make the game too stop/start. The fact it took about 3 minutes to resurrect Suarez using the defibulator would have given a 4th ref planty of time to see that
1 - it wasn't even a foul
2 - Suarez hadn't actually been shot.

The trouble is that it wasn't an honest mistake by Mr Atkinson - it was just following guidelines - Liverpool must be allowed to get back into the Top 4 - we've had too many complaints from disgruntled Norwegians.
Colin Malone
18 Posted 12/10/2011 at 14:54:54
Yes i agree simon, Everton football club have to take it further, but will they?
I know there is is no excuse for plastic bottles being thrown [ which the club is taking action]on to the pitch but in my eyes, the ref caused it by he,s bad decision. Further more does a ref have to be attacked for these pricks at the F A to do something because i felt like throttling the cunt.
David Donnellan
19 Posted 12/10/2011 at 17:11:39
Ian, Suarez injured?? Are you kidding? I play football to a good level. The amount of contact there was on Suarez, wouldnt have injured him in the way he was making out. I would be ashamed to go down like that, he bahaved like a big jessie.
I have friends who are big rugby fans & i have no love for rugby, they are always telling me that footballers are all big girls & Suarez play-acting like that, just adds fuel to their argument. Hes an embarrassment to football. Cheating scumbag! If i was Rodwell, after being shown the red card, i would have given him something to really cry about, before i left the pitch.
Peter Cummings
20 Posted 12/10/2011 at 17:26:16
Another comment made after the cancellation was 'justice was done' how is this justice when millions around the world were denied one of the biggest, if not the BIGGEST derby days of the season reduced to a battle of wits instead of an exciting confrontation of attacking football and incident.

I don't believe 'we wuz robbed' but we should have been allowed to compete on a one-to-one basis, but they say what comes around goes around, just hope for a good game against another team loaded with 'diving' opportunists.
Mike Elbey
21 Posted 12/10/2011 at 17:43:04
Just another point on Mr Atkinsons consistency (or lack of !).

He refereed Newcastle v Blackburn a couple of weeks ago and booked a Blackburn player for placing his hands on him clearly mouthing 'you're not allowed to touch me'.

During the Rodwell sending off that other Red Scumbag Lucas clearly puts his hands onto Atkinson in a manner at least the equal of what the Blackburn player did the week before - any action from Atkinson ? Of course not, afterall Blackburn aren't Liverpool are they, well not in his book anyway. One horrible arse licking twat basically ...
Chad Schofield
22 Posted 13/10/2011 at 00:21:40
Some scary stats banded about in here. I am not sure whether sending the ref down a division is best, but I certainly agree that those players whom clearly feign injury should be reprimanded as fully as those players who are issued punishment post match.

Saurez was caught slightly while mid flight by Jack's knee. The moment he landed he would not have been in pain. And I was thoroughly disappointed with Adam in both his actions against Rodwell and the disabled act before twatting off the bar.
Jim Burns
23 Posted 13/10/2011 at 22:40:19
Peter @ 6 - dont worry on that score mate - there will most definitely be a warm welcome for both of them - as well as that slinky git Lucas. What happened that day will not be forgotten for a long time and I very much doubt we'll see Atkinson back at Goodison a la that other prize prick Clattenberg.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads