Season › 2011-12 › News
Finch Farm up for grabs
Offers sought in excess of £15.356M
Hudson Capital Properties, the current owners of Finch Farm, are looking to sell the prime site, where Everton have a 50-year lease after selling the property to ROM Capital in 2005 for construction of their training complex by a specialist developer AFL, completed in 2007. Everton have the option to purchase the site back on every 5-year anniversary of the original lease. The next opportunity comes in July 2012; the pricetag: £16,511,838.The Investment Summary reads:
An extremely rare opportunity to acquire the training facility of a well known and successful Premier League football club.More subsequent links:The 55-acre complex provides world-class training facilities including a medical centre, gymnasium, offices, dining rooms and a media centre with over 10 full-size football pitches.
The investment provides over 30 years' secure income with 2.5% per annum fixed uplifts, compounded and payable 5-yearly .
Total income of £1,259,153 per annum [ie, rent paid by Everton FC]
Security of income provided by television rights from the Premier League, the world's most successful and lucrative football league.
Offers are sought in excess of £15,356,000 subject to contract and exclusive of VAT. A purchase at this level would reflect a net initial yield of 7.75%, allowing for usual purchasers costs of 5.80%.
The Vendor proposes to top up the rent to the level of the 26/07/2012 uplift which is £1,259,153.
Due to the fixed rental increases the opportunity presents the following reversionary yield profile:
26/07/2017: 8.77%
26/07/2022: 9.92%
26/07/2027: 11.23%
26/07/2032: 12.70%
26/07/2037: 14.37%
26/07/2042: 16.26%
Quotes or other material sourced from Scribd
Reader Comments (54)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 20/10/2011 at 08:49:17
Accountant: It's basically a stick or twist situation Boss.
3 Posted 20/10/2011 at 09:05:55
(does sarcasm come across in text?)
4 Posted 20/10/2011 at 09:27:33
5 Posted 20/10/2011 at 10:01:35
6 Posted 20/10/2011 at 10:10:31
Expect the High Court, and then the ECJ's ratification, to be a further protection of the interests of monoply / cartel behaviour. Sky will probably end up making more out of it.
7 Posted 20/10/2011 at 10:52:18
However, I don't think the words 'long term' exist in the board's vocabulary. Also not sure if we actually have £15m to buy it anyway. We may have received about £17m in transfer fees but how much of this has already gone on lowering the overdraft with Barclays?
8 Posted 20/10/2011 at 11:01:14
9 Posted 20/10/2011 at 10:49:35
As to the original post, this is very interesting. I mean why would you want to sell when the contract gives you such a good & supposedly secure yield ?
Perhaps the compounded payments are a problem in the current climate ? Credit is freezing up again & maybe they just need cash for their other ventures, developments or plans.
or.... are they privvy to some financial information that we are not ?
as me Ma used to say "the truth will out" so I guess we better 'watch this space' for developments.
10 Posted 20/10/2011 at 10:56:54
So effectively, anyone could own this facility right now including our very own Billionaire Shareholders, Grantchester or Green.
Could be the beginning of the dreaded Firesale or another conspiracy theory, who knows? I?m beginning to care less and less as I watch this board bury the club.
11 Posted 20/10/2011 at 11:21:59
Did we initially buy Finch Farm and then sell it? Or did we move in as tenants from the start?
12 Posted 20/10/2011 at 11:26:17
Unfortunately, I fear it would make too much sense financially for our current incumbants to think it a good idea...
13 Posted 20/10/2011 at 12:10:27
Everton bought the land in 2006, but then sold it to a Property Developer for around £2M under the agreement that they would build the complex to the club's specification and subsequently the club would then lease it back.
Short-sightedness unfortunately, sound familiar?
14 Posted 20/10/2011 at 12:25:34
So you are suggesting that we got a training asset worth £15.something million, that we couldn't afford, for an initial outlay of £2M and £1.2M a year rent?.
That's not the worst deal I've ever heard of to be honest!
15 Posted 20/10/2011 at 12:37:02
A better situation would have been to get a redvelopment loan, use this to build the facility and the annual payments would have been interest and repayment of the original loan ? i.e. actually own the asset at the end of the day. At £1.3M a year, the loan would have been paid off a hell of a lot quicker than 50 years and we would own an asset that was worth something.
I am obviously not privy to the inner dealings at the time but would this not have been a better solution? We could have put down the £2M as deposit/equity and borrowed the rest to build the thing.
16 Posted 20/10/2011 at 12:49:31
We have already handed them about £5M in annual payments so am curious to see how much of their initial outlay they have already gotten back (with still about 45 years of payments left!).
17 Posted 20/10/2011 at 13:23:11
http://www.scribd.com/doc/60336675/AFL-website-information-regarding-Finch-Farm-development-Value-now-not-disclosed
So ROM paid £11M, received £5.5M in rent and will sell for >£15.3M; they?ve essentially doubled their investment in five years, not bad business by anyone?s standards. As for Everton that?s another story........
18 Posted 20/10/2011 at 13:29:30
The Sky thing ? that is also of great interest to me. I live in Holland and get to see most Premier League matches through Sport 1 package from cable operator UPC. I pay ?20 max/month (don't know exact figure) for the privilege.
Now UPC also had to negotiate / pay for that package with the Premier League or whoever ? as did Sky.
This women bar owner, buying "European rights" has inded opened a can of worms... but I am not sure IF you guys are on the right line.
To me it will not assist anyone in the UK; the more people who do what she did, will just give the Premier League the nod, that they increase the foreign TV companies' payments. Sky payments and the UK household payments MAY go down... but ours ? the foreign watchers' ? will go up.
Bugger it, shit season so far, shit year.
19 Posted 20/10/2011 at 13:53:48
What was the logic behind doing what we did, can someone explain?
20 Posted 20/10/2011 at 13:56:32
If you think that's a good deal I'll be happy to lend you money.
21 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:02:26
Denis's comments are entirely predicated on the fact that we could get such a redevelopment loan for the full project amount.... which would have been land value + project costs + contractor profit margin. Somewhere between £13-15M as a guideline figure?
I appreciate the logic that it's an appreciating asset etc, etc but if the option is nothing or a £15M training facility for an affordable outlay and manageable rent then it's hardly the end of the world is it?
22 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:06:36
23 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:13:03
Rent is the operative word here
"The investment provides over 30 years' secure income with 2.5% per annum fixed uplifts, compounded and payable 5-yearly"
The club have signed up to this for a quick win. They at the very least could have partnered the Developer to hedge their position.
Sorrry, but that agreement is a joke.
24 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:17:01
If we don't end up buying it, it would suggest that our financial state is much worse than anyone realises and that the banks do not trust us to make mortgage payments that would effectively be the same as what we are paying in rent.
25 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:20:58
26 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:27:46
27 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:34:26
Would we have been better off without Finch Farm but with an extra £1.2M pa in the bank?
28 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:39:06
I have just printed off the brochure and it states that the tenant has the right to buy the training ground every 5 years. If we moved there in 2006, and it is now 2011, does that mean we might be attempting to buy it (2+2=5 and all that).
I don't know if any of you followed the Daisy Cutter thread where a City fan posted something on 10 October saying that an Indian consortium were looking at buying us out imminently but it included the purchase of a 40-acre site in Liverpool. Well, here we are 10 days later and our training ground, which is 55 acres, has come on the market. It couldn't be true, could it? (2+2=100 here!)
29 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:41:57
Bellefield was on its last legs, surely, and too small ? the Academy were housed elsewhere (rented? owned?).
We DO have a state-of-the-art Premier League training complex...
We DON'T have an extra £10-15M in debt sitting on the books...
Is this really such a bad deal? Is it really an example of the Board's lack of foresight? Or yet another "needs must" in order for a club, strapped for cash, to stay in the game? [pun intended]
30 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:21:58
There's a retailer on the highstreet called Brighthouse, where you can get big ticket items no matter how poor you are or how crap your credit rating. You'd only buy from them if you were desperate or stupid, as yeah you get the item, but their interest rate & terms mean you pay way over the odds, in the long term. In business terms the Finch Farm deal is even worse as at the end Everton don't even own it.
It's also very similar to Govt's PFI Scheme where private money builds public infrastructure & the public purse pays for it over 25-50 years. I've experience of two of these projects & you would not believe what a poor deal they are for the taxpayer.
Apart from the fact you are paying over & over again for these buildings, as well as over the odds maintanence costs.
What you also find with these deals is that there are also hidden costs as you don't own the site... eg: I saw one PFI Landlord charge an NHS trust £800 to carry out a £30 job of work. They just name the price & you have to pay it under the terms of these style of contracts.
How would this apply to Finch Farm?
Well, every time EFC wanted to change something, alter or referb', I'd guess there'd be no competetive tendering... just a whacking great bill. It's how these deals work & why they are so lucrative.
The only good thing recently is that the club were going to sign up to one of these deals for the Park End development. Luckily though for the long term of EFC, 'Bungling Bill's' backroom chaos boys managed to cock it up.
31 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:50:27
No we didn't we don't own it we rent it, so we got nothing,
Michael #29 "We DON'T have an extra £10-15M in debt sitting on the books..."
But that would have been at least balanced by the value of the asset.
32 Posted 20/10/2011 at 14:51:11
The question is, WHY? Maybe they think they're about to lose their security.
---------------------
Or they realise the value of land is falling and is likely to fall for the next few years.
UK property selling prices are down by 16% (average of 3 main indices) in 4 years. That is despite inflation of nearly 20% in that time. In other words, the real value of property has fallen by a third in 4 years, and is still falling.
And the 16% nominal fall masks the collapse in volume sales. At the height of the boom, 110,000 properties were sold a month; that is down to 45, 000 a month, as amny sellers refuse offers (for now). Even that masks a more striking figure. Strip out the properties bought by wealthy people not requiring a mortgage (the figures have barely budged, was 20,000 a month; is 20,000 a month), then volume sales are down from over 90,000 to about 25,000 a month.
Property and land purchases are big ticket items that require finance, and the banks have been fooked for 4 years, and it ain't gonna change soon. The spread between initial UK market asking prices for properties and their sales has widened from 10% 4-5 yrs ago to about 30% now.
Which brings us to Everton. We haven't the money to buy, so end of discussion, surely. But if we do look to buy, we should be offering £10 m (not upwards of £15 mn). Only an idiot would pay that price. Oh dear, please no Bill.
33 Posted 20/10/2011 at 15:02:39
34 Posted 20/10/2011 at 15:38:55
For £15m or so, a top quality asset will be added to the clubs books. If the club does want to buy it back the money is definitely there.
After-all, the Echo where forced to print an apology for saying that that the Arteta money has gone to ease the club's finances. Therefore, that tells me that we have at least £10M sitting off in our current account ready to be spent. Yes?
That is right?..
?? Isn?t it?
35 Posted 20/10/2011 at 15:48:20
----------------
and if we buy it back with debt? Would the banks grant us that debt?
FHS, what are we gonna buy it with? Money we haven't got? Money from a bank that wants us to pay down our debt? Can someone explain this to me? And as I explained above, meeting the asking price would be ludicrous folly.
36 Posted 20/10/2011 at 16:22:19
We don't need to buy the training ground outright. If we were to put up 20%, i.e. £3 million, we could get a mortgage for the rest. If you download the brochure, you will see the rental yield based on the rent increasing by a fixed amount every year. The rental yields would appear excellent. If someone bought the training ground at the figures mentioned (£15,356,000), this would bring a rental yield of 7.75%. this yield would increase to over 16% by the end of the contract. This is much more than you would get by leaving your money in a bank account.
The tenant (i.e. Everton) has the option of buying the ground every 5 years, but again this is for an increasing price based on RPI to protect the landlord - i.e. if you buy it now for £15 million, someone will have to pay more than that to buy the land off you under the terms of the contract.
If you download the document you will have a more informed view, but in simple terms it looks like a good investment and Everton have been paying rent against this property for the last 5 years, so they have a payment history they can show to the bank. If they provide a decent deposit, i.e. 20% (which I am sure we could find) and based on all of these facts, I am sure we would be in a position to buy it. And it makes a lot more sense long term to own a place rather than rent.
37 Posted 20/10/2011 at 16:28:31
"No we didn't we don't own it we rent it, so we got nothing,"
Yep I phrased that poorly 'we got exclusive use of a £15mn training facility' is a more accurate statement.
Marc #30 at no point here am I saying that ownership of the facility wouldn't have been better.
I'm saying that if ownership wasnt an option...that no-one was willing to offer us £14mn or so at a good rate...then a deal to at least secure the necessary training facilities was appropriate. As you said about that retailer if you want the kit but cant afford it any other way you choose from the options you have....or you do without.
I dont think we had much of an option to do without so..............
38 Posted 20/10/2011 at 16:19:35
If the current 'market value' is 15m and we are paying 1.3m a year, then even at 8% intererst on say 13.5m (assuming we put in 10% of the purchase price as equity), the loan would be paid off in less than 20 years and the thing would belong to the club. Curerntly we pay rent for half a century and have no asset. Also the rent we are paying is equivalent to 9% a year on the 'market value', which seems a very high amount to me.
Going back to 2006, someone said we may have done this deal like this as we were skint. However, this was before the credit crisis so I would have assumed that even Everton could have gotten a redevlopment morgtage in 2006 to build this.
Was it really worth it and were we really that desperate at the time to enter this sort of deal smiply to get a quick 2m from selling the land?
Just looking at the bare facts above, this deal is appaling from the clubs perspective and we are now a captive as we have no immediate alternaive re training facilities.
I can only assume the developer would want to sell such a great cash cow as they are shitting it that we go into administration in the next few years.
40 Posted 20/10/2011 at 18:47:49
41 Posted 20/10/2011 at 19:41:45
Then a run up to Huyton Leisure for five-a-sides, weights etc (possibly free with a bit of advertising - ie: "Come to Huyton Leisure, where the professionals train...and Anichibe").
Lunchtime, send Mr Round down to Chan's on Pilch Lane.
Sorted innit blood.
42 Posted 20/10/2011 at 21:15:09
Do you mean the new Huyton leisure? It's just opened at a cost of £16mill I think, and is on the old site of Thomas Beckett School. The council probably rent it for £1.3mill a year. with five year rent reviews. They sold the old leisure centre off to a developer as it's in a prime spot.
Bit like Bellefield... Knowsley Council again?
43 Posted 20/10/2011 at 22:07:14
if this lot are in charge much longer that is what we may end up doing.
Does anyone know who provides their funding?
Only founded in 2007 and apparently with a portfolio worth 200 million.
Someone with serious wealth has to be behind that sort of growth!!!
44 Posted 20/10/2011 at 23:17:46
45 Posted 21/10/2011 at 06:58:15
46 Posted 21/10/2011 at 11:08:00
Finch Farm could be rented back to the club (at a peppercorn rent) saving the charges currently being faced. Being owned by the trust would also protect it from either the current board wanting to re-mortgage it again to cover up their other financial inadequacies or, should we become the subject of a takeover by some shady entrepreneur (I know, big if) then it would be protected from any planned asset stripping.
I believe it could be a real focus of what do with any 'Trust Everton' money ? separate from the Board, but of real value to 'Everton'. Unrealistic to raise that sort of money? Maybe, but surely worth exploring. I'd be really interested to hear from those at Trust Everton as to whether or not they see it as a possibility.
47 Posted 21/10/2011 at 12:55:54
If Trust Everton were to raise say £5M, then they could potentially set up their own SPV, negotiate on price and mortgage the rest. They could then continue to lease it back at the current conditions to the club and would eventually own it.
This way the current board would have no claim to the property and couldn?t use it as leverage on other debt, thereby protecting the asset until such a time it could be returned to the club in return for a shareholding.
Just a thought.
48 Posted 21/10/2011 at 13:35:28
49 Posted 21/10/2011 at 15:33:53
50 Posted 21/10/2011 at 18:33:03
If the current 'market value' is £15m and we are paying £1.3m a year, who says it's the market price? The seller? Remind me never to go to you when i need a buyer for my business.
---
Danny, we brought in over £30 million this year including Bellefield. We must have some of that left
-------------
Yeah, maybe £10 million and we need a striker, or do you think our squad is strong enough?
None of this makes sense for a club with no cash. £20 million of that £30 million raised (not all of it immediatley, but some of it over the next two years - clubs never pay up front for a player, but over 2-4 years).
We have no cash. For those saying there would be sth on the positive side of the balance sheet, I would again stress that real estate values are falling, and that is on volumes that are down by over 50%. Commercial rents are falling. The banks know this. So they are unwilling to grant loans, without 25% deposits; or with a huge cut in the price of the property first.
Know why repossessions have not soared ? it's not just low rates. It is because, were banks to repossess, everyone would see prices falling further than most want to admit.
That would wreak havoc on balance sheets of those with lots of property on their books, and that means the banks themselves. They are already close to insolvency, and only inflation and low interest rates are saving them.
We should pay down down debt, invest what we have left in the squad. Let prices slide, then go buying. Preferably looking for a better and bigger ground.
51 Posted 21/10/2011 at 18:45:11
The facility is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it.
--------------------
Actually that is a common mistake. Anything is only worth what someone is willing AND ABLE ro pay for it.
Property is almost always paid for thru debt - mortgages. The ABILITY to bid higher is therefore dependent on how much a bank will lend. That is why property prices rise in booms and fall in crashes. This is doubly so when the boom bust is of banks themseleves.
You cannot pay if you do not have the dosh. Immaterial of how much you're willing to pay.
52 Posted 22/10/2011 at 03:26:27
53 Posted 22/10/2011 at 08:09:30
"The ABILITY to bid higher is therefore dependent on how much a bank will lend"
A couple of points on your patronising remarks
To warrent a higher bid, you're assuming there Is a demand for the property. The 'guaranteed' rental return is the real value here, but should the club fail or even be relegated the value would diminish considerably hence high risk.
Banks are lending, just not to the average homeowner, but they lend on Risk and Return and as I said, the risk here is high and demand low, so it would do well to fetch near it's asking price.
Finally, your black and White logic assumes financial institutions can only make money by lending in a progressive marketplace. Take some time out and look up Short Selling.
Common mistake.
54 Posted 22/10/2011 at 09:00:55
However, if the seller is offering 15m then we can at least assume that this is the maximum price that would need to be paid.
If so, our locked in 1.3m annual payments (which we have to make every year for half a century!) looks pretty high to me. We could have bought the thing and made lower annual payments for 50 years or made the same annual payments and paid off the loan earlier - ending up owning the asset.
Eirther way, the deal looks rubbish from the clubs perspective, based on the facts above.
Non of us here were obviously privy to the negotiations that happened at the time but I cannot understand why Everton (or anyone elses for that matter) would have made this deal.
Put another way from the other side - the developer paid about 11m to buy the land and develop the complex. In the 4 years since it opened they have already gotten almost half their initial investment back - and are still due to get 1.3m a year from us for around another 45 years!!!
Still think this was a good deal for the club?
55 Posted 24/10/2011 at 17:24:06
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 20/10/2011 at 08:15:50