McFadden not a signing, insists Moyes

, 22 October, 49comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes goes to some lengths to counter the negative vibes surrounding Jamie McFadden's return to Everton, insisting he is not actually a signing:

?I think James McFadden would be worth bringing in as a free transfer no matter what,? said the Goodison manager, ?That's why there were a few clubs in for him.

?We just need to check how quickly we can get him back playing after his knee injury; before he got injured he was arguably Birmingham's best player.

?It's amazing that we bring a player in who is on a free, we're a bit short, and there's an awful lot of attention drawn to it.

?Some clubs buy players for massive money and don't play them or let them go on loan, and nobody says anything.

?We've brought someone in for nothing who we are going to use. What's the big problem? What would people be saying if I'd brought Faddy in a few days before the deadline??

?If Faddy helps us out then great,? said the manager. ?If he doesn't then we'll go our separate ways at the end of the season, but if it does then we'd have sold someone for £5m then bought him back for nothing, so that's good business.

?It's a wee bit of a gamble. But if anybody reads into it as an Everton signing, then that's way off the mark. Folks need to put it in the right place.

?You can't sign players right now, the window is shut, so we've got in a free agent.?  



Reader Comments (49)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Gavin Ramejkis
1 Posted 22/10/2011 at 16:40:53
Smoke and daggers bullshit, you bring a new player in and give him a contract I'd suggest both need to "sign" a contract of employment... QED a signing. People have put it in its right place ? a shite move by a potless club scraping the gutters to make up numbers.
Ian Ravello
2 Posted 22/10/2011 at 17:06:45
Unbelievable negativity! This is as close to a no-brainer deal as you can get. If he'd gone to Celtic & done well there we would be fielding comments here as to why we didn't sign him. We've got an additional squad player outside of the window who can provide us with some much needed attacking creativity and who knows and respects what we're about. Welcome back Faddy & best of luck to you!
Anthony Flack
3 Posted 22/10/2011 at 17:09:33
Christ almighty Gavin, shite post, scraping the barrell, I would not have bothered, brings nothing new. To be self critical not sure why I bothered commenting.
Brian Waring
4 Posted 22/10/2011 at 17:23:24
McFadden, attacking creativity, hmmm......?
Brian Waring
5 Posted 22/10/2011 at 17:26:29
Isn't McFadden going to cost us wages? It might not be huge money, but he isn't going to cost us 'Nothing' in the long run.
Andrew Heaton
6 Posted 22/10/2011 at 17:54:59
This pretty much has decided that my arse wont be sat on seat LB4 B180 next season! Any takers? it's not a bad seat apart from a gobby cunt behind me and a big fuck-off post in front of you that means you can't see the corner flag! Other than that it's great!!
Gavin Ramejkis
7 Posted 22/10/2011 at 18:17:07
Ian and Anthony ? I can only assume you must both be fairly new to Everton and, if not, were in some unfortunate coma for the period 2003 to 2008 when we finally managed to get shut.

Hailed ridiculously as "the Scottish Rooney" he offered nothing but frustration and the odd goal, something similar to Bily but with more time on the pitch to do just as little.

He will be taking a wage at the club and is not an unknown; he's an average player with nothing surprising to add to what we have already seen. He'll also be taking a wage. If you genuinely believe that he is the sort of player Everton should and could be signing, you really have very little if any ambition.
Brendan McLaughlin
8 Posted 22/10/2011 at 18:27:22
Andew #6
You sit in front of Trevor Mackie then?
Andy Crooks
9 Posted 22/10/2011 at 18:39:52
Ian Ravello, if he'd gone to Celtic believe me I wouldn't be asking why didn't we sign hiim. I'd be asking Neill Lennon are you fucking insane?
Adam Wilkinson
10 Posted 22/10/2011 at 18:43:09
Brendan #8 the smartest comment I've read on this site in a long time!
Trevor Mackie
11 Posted 22/10/2011 at 18:52:19
Adam and Brendan

You should both enter politics, as Napoleon said:-

"In politics stupidity is not a handicap"

You'd be cabinet ministers in a week.
Brendan McLaughlin
12 Posted 22/10/2011 at 19:10:43
Trevor #11
Learn to laugh at yourself...everybody else does!
Simon Harris
13 Posted 22/10/2011 at 19:02:40
?You can't sign players right now, the window is shut, so we've got in a free agent.?

That's the funniest thing I've read since the BK interview. Duh - Dave we can't even sign players when the windows open.

What a load of BOLLOCKS.

Peter Fearon
14 Posted 22/10/2011 at 19:47:23
Moyes is right. It's not a signing, it's an act of charity and clanism. The real issue is not McFadden's proven mediocrity - I think we can all agree on that - but the clear implication by Moyes that he plans to use him ahead of other players like Gueye, Drenthe, Stracqualursi, etc., etc. I liked McFadden, I expected some good things from him, but he rarely failed to disappoint in front of goal. Most disappointing of all was the effort he put in playing for Scotland and the clear nonchalence in his attitude when playing for us.
Nick Entwistle
15 Posted 22/10/2011 at 19:48:07
"What would people be saying if I'd brought Faddy in a few days before the deadline??

Well, why didn't you? Before, we would pass it off as a necessary in the face of dire circumstances, doing it now smacks of desperation. Not sure what's the best.
Kieran Kinsella
16 Posted 22/10/2011 at 19:56:05
The truth is that we Signing McFadden is like signing Beagrie back from Bradford - we did it because with only 18 players in the squad we literally need another to sit on the bench and preferrably someone who is a professional football player. Rather than attacking Moyes for signing him I would point the finger of blame at all of the fans who backed BK when he organized a coup against Johnson even though we all KNEW that BK had NO MONEY. I am so tired of this "he loves the club" rubbish. Sorry Beatles but you are wrong and love is not all you need. If love was all you need then ANY of us could run the club. Moyes signed Mc back as a desperation mood because ill-informed fans backed BK's coup and those same naive fans still back BK to the hilt. End of.
David Bridge
17 Posted 22/10/2011 at 20:08:02
Whilst Moyes doesnt know how to use quick, creative, skillful players like Gueye, Drenthe, Barkley, Velios we can all rest assured that he knows exactly how to use McFadden. Joke signing from a joke manager.
Peter Fearon
18 Posted 22/10/2011 at 20:04:23
Kieran, I'm sorry but that theory defies logic and the facts. Elsewhere on this site I count 24 available players, not counting Anichebe who obviously is injured.

Naming only 18 in the squad was Moyes' decision. If he wanted another just to make up numbers or merely to sit on the bench he had others to choose from or he could have named Adam Forshaw, just for an example or he could have brought back a player on loan.

Moyes clearly says he will be using McFadden in an active capacity with a view to re-signing him at the end of the season if he does well, not merely to get splinters in his arse, which is the role he has chosen for one or two other players. Remember, McFadden is going to earn more in two or three weeks of training - not even playing - than most fans earn in a year.

As for the rest, because Kenwright's continued ownership appears to be problematic now does not mean it was always so. The reality is that we desperately needed someone to oust Johnson at that time and now we are faced with a different situation.

If Johnson had stayed we might well have gone the way of Leeds or worse. Same with Moyes. Once he was effective and achieved some things we can be proud of. Now it is time for him to go.
Trevor Lynes
19 Posted 22/10/2011 at 20:06:54
Signing Faddy is a retrograde, embarrassing step on our way to mediocrity minus!! I remember the outcry when it was mooted that we take Horne back some years ago... it smacks of jobs for the boys and it's no surprise that he is from Scotland.

We kept Weir, Naysmith and others for too long on the payroll and it's an indictment of Scottish football that they were able to continue playing regularly for the top clubs over there... I am disgusted at the way money is wasted when we could have kept Pienaar (who was playing well for us) for the money that will be paid to McFadden to bring him to deserved parity with Arteta, who has left us anyway.

When all these facts are weighed up, it's a catastrophic series of blunders that are making us the laughing stock of the Premier League.

People talk about changing our manager... who the hell would want to come to a club with absolutely no financial backing and a string of youngsters who are not ready according to DM and a few ageing has-beens.
This club is playing brinkmanship to the limit and if the present board are not going to dip into their pockets then neither am I.
Ryan Holroyd
20 Posted 22/10/2011 at 20:24:03
We've more than 18 players in the squad because I don't believe under 21's have to be registered but can still play
Trevor Mackie
21 Posted 22/10/2011 at 21:20:27
Brendan

Your attacks are the same as Moyes - mediocre.

It's like your his love child?
Brian Williams
22 Posted 22/10/2011 at 21:52:25
I'm just wondering if McFadden's still dating Will Young?
Steve Jones
23 Posted 22/10/2011 at 21:58:09
So Drenthe gets himself suspended for a couple of matches....Bilyaletdinov picks up a knock and Gueye, as first choice left, starts looking out of his depth on the big stage. In that circumstance is having Faddy on the bench a bad thing?.

Like the manager says he's no-ones idea of a marquee signing. He's not brought in as anything other than squad cover and that well down the order. Even the lad himself has acknowledged that, were it not for the thinness in the squad, he'd likely not have got a look back in at Everton.

You do realise some of you are actually pretending that Faddy's signing has some massive significance just so you can shoot it down FFS??!.

You know what?. I remember the same spouting off when Moyes brought in Lucas Neill a couple of seasons back in the same sort of deal. Of course when Galatasary offer a million quid, the very next window, for a player we signed for nowt then everythings fine again of course and Moyes is the bloody messiah again.

Maybe we take this news with the proper perspective and concentrate on the real problems the club has?.
David Mathieson
24 Posted 22/10/2011 at 22:22:33
Brian 21# why are you interested?
Anthony Flack
25 Posted 22/10/2011 at 22:23:27
Gavin, nope I was brainwashed by my old man in 1977' and totally committed ever since.....so not new to Everton, I also did not suggest McFadden is a good buy, I was just depressed by your rank negativity...

Cheers
Brian Hill
26 Posted 22/10/2011 at 22:46:42
Are there any players with the name "Whitehead"? If we could sign him then there would no stopping us. You need to be quite old and sick of this shit to get this comment. Sorry.
Andy Crooks
27 Posted 22/10/2011 at 23:40:32
Brian.
We gonna get ourselves together
We gonna polish up our act.Yeah
There's a lot to be learned from Philadelphia soul.
Gavin Ramejkis
28 Posted 23/10/2011 at 00:40:21
Anthony I questionedf the validity of McFadden as a signing as it is utter garbage. I've seen this type of wastes of money by the club before and given we are potless they dont make any sense, you have at least three other players who could perform the role for fuck all outley yet the club sign him and we all know he is utter gash.

Someone uses the Lucas Neill signing as an example then point out the moment the club were offered £1m he was sold, surely that put the club exactly where it was when he was signed if it was only to make up numbers and guess what the money didnt go on a replacement.

Bringing McFadden along smacks of Moyes having little or no faith in the youth at the club and in particular at least two if not three of his own signings in Gueye, Velios and Bily, the latter I would saqy is simply a younger version of McFadden with a better left foot. If you truly want depressing you must love going to the match and watching some of Moyes' performances or hearing his pre match build ups this season?
Chad Schofield
29 Posted 23/10/2011 at 01:09:23
Spot on Gavin. I'm quite disappointed with DM's comments. Likely to.be a waste of money while he gets fit. Most probably the dame if he does.

Sound harsh? Well just look back to his performances when he last graced us.
Kieran Kinsella
30 Posted 23/10/2011 at 01:17:50
The Moyes "doesn't give youth a chance" argument doesn't hold up. Many fans demand the homegrown players be given a shot and then turn on Moyes when he plays them and sticks by them (Hibbert, Osman, Anichebe, Vaughan) As for Gueye, Forshaw etc. How about JP Kissock ? I have read tonnes of threads on here about how good he is? Ohh yeah it turns out that he was rubbish. What about Daniel Fox, Nathan Craig, Nick Chadwick, Mark Hughes, Bjarni Vidarsson etc all of whom Toffeewebbers demanded that Moyes play because they were so much better than his favorites? I am as unhappy as anyone with the rubbish team that we have now but the sad truth is that Bily, Gueye etc are even more rubbish. Like it or not McFad is the level of player that we can attract and afford to pay now. Also Mr Fearon, BK has never done anyhting good for this club. We won the cup right before he took over and we've seen no benefit from his "love" of the club ever since. He is the poor man's Doug Ellis. Obviously, SKY killed football but BK had already poisoned Everton anyway so Sky just pulled the plug after he left us on life support.
Chad Schofield
31 Posted 23/10/2011 at 01:29:35
Moyes would be best making and kind of live sacrifice by beheadeding a chicken and releasing it into.the pitch. Plus chickens don(t cost thousands of pounds per week.
Steve Jones
32 Posted 23/10/2011 at 10:03:47
Bringing McFadden in doesn't smack of anything other than an opportunity to bring in a squad player, on a short term deal, who might do a job for us if he's needed at all.

Thats it. End of story. We haven't gone out trying to secure the signing of our prime target McFadden because he represents the level of player we want at the club FFS!. He was available on a free and everyone else was offering him trials not a playing deal. If he has improved no further on where he was last time with us then he clears off in the summer and is forgotten. If he gets fit and gets a go in the first team, for whatever reason, maybe Celtic come in with a million's worth of an offer come January!.

Either way its a non-story isnt it. The lads hardly going to be on Arteta wages is he....he's not even properly match fit. So, really, all this whining and moaning is about picking up a prem-experienced player for a few grand a week as insurance against a thin squad?. Seriously thats a huge issue???

Matt Traynor
33 Posted 23/10/2011 at 10:29:51
Gavin (#1), have to disagree, I think it's more a classic case of Cloak and Mirrors...
Robbie Muldoon
34 Posted 23/10/2011 at 12:12:49
At least he pays attention to how the fans are feeling. I haven't seen any big media outlets reporting the signing of McFadden negatively, so I wonder where he has realised the majority of fans aren't happy with this signing. If he's being reading TW he must be majorly depressed right now!
Gavin Ramejkis
35 Posted 23/10/2011 at 12:26:21
Thanks Matt, must engage brain before rant mode is used
Terry McLavey
36 Posted 23/10/2011 at 17:52:46
We'll all be silenced when he comes on a gets a hatrick against United, wouldn't want to be the next team to play them whoever that is !............oh shit!!!!
Dalziel Kane
37 Posted 23/10/2011 at 18:00:54
There's this Scot I know and he holds McFadden in the same regard as William Wallace, "Oh I was there in 2003 when he beat The Netherlands, it was a night of epic proportions, sitting in a bar in Cambuslang and having a few wee slurps and the night became hazy" etc. "Pity about the return leg in Amsterdam though..."

I don't know how I truly feel about this McFadden return; sure he has done well at international level, almost reaching cult status not seen since the days of Law and Henderson.

But on this week and a Goodison return, I was kind of in two minds about it. He didn't really make an impact at Birmingham, is still only 28 years old, seems to have been around for eons, and could still do a job admittedly. He'll get another chance to show he can still perform on the day. Moyes brought him back and that's that, not much anybody can do about it now.

Said so above that there's a Dean Whitehead at Stoke City, put them two together and etc etc...
Jimmy Sorheim
39 Posted 23/10/2011 at 19:04:51
We are going to have ijuries that is a given, give it a break we need cover and we all want more players coming in. Mcfadden is just a pre taste if he does well then that is good. January will show that Moyes has money to spend and then we will actually have a real signing.
It is a worry that faddy will make little or no impact but he is an emergency addition, nothing more. As Moyes says the windov is closed so I dont know about any other freebie that could be brought in who is better than faddy.
You cant slag off Moyes for bringing in a new player, that is ridiculous. Either you want him to sign players or you dont. I want more players and I want cover for our weak midfield, to say that it is wrong to strengthen the midfield is just insane.

By the way after the Fulham win I sense a different mood in Moyes spirit, I think he is trying to do well, as he changed the line-up against Fulham shows that.
I just hope he can keep changeing things until we find our new best first eleven. As it were before Arteta and Pienaar left the squad pick was easy, now it is very difficult to find the right mix. I dont belive we have found the right mix in midfield yet and I do feel that Billy,Drenthe and Neville is a must. Rodwell and Fellaini are too alike, no creativity. Neville has a silent effect in the team, the only problem is that he is not as good a defender because he backs off tackles way too often, with hibbert you see a proper tackle now and then. We have tobuild a new team from what is left and it is a puzzle for Moyes to fit in the current players.
Bobby Mallon
40 Posted 23/10/2011 at 19:36:54
The reason we are in this mess is because keioc and the likes stopped us getting a new stadium in Kirkby.

Now before everyone gets on their high horse, I am glad they did but ? and it's a big but ? if we would have got the stadium, we definitely would have been sold by now with stadium naming rights sold and loads of cash in the bank for signings.
Brian Waring
41 Posted 23/10/2011 at 19:49:06
Bobby, bit naive there lad. It wasn't KEIOC that stopped us getting the stadium in Kirkby, it was because everything in the plans submitted was shite.
Robbie Muldoon
42 Posted 23/10/2011 at 19:55:06
Bobby Mallon are you serious? Stop for a second and use your brain. Think before you type, or at least delete any bullshit before you press enter!

I see the Echo Arena everyday and always just think 'what could have been'.
Chad Schofield
43 Posted 23/10/2011 at 20:12:19
Jesus Bobby, are you five? Even if we did get the stadium, we would have been £78M in the hole reverse mortgage style... our credit would have been screwed given the downturn and the lack of use of the stadium for concerts etc.

The plan had no consideration about transport to the DK, and supposedly 2,000 would cycle there. So tell me how the gazillions we would have got (£4M a year approx) for being called "The Every Little Helps Stadium" would have helped?

Seriously, one of the stupidest comments I've read... well done.
Colin Wainwright
44 Posted 23/10/2011 at 21:19:40
Aye, your right Bobby. We could have sold the naming rights, in a high profile deal, to Bargain Booze.

Sorted.
Bobby Mallon
45 Posted 23/10/2011 at 21:55:17
Brian 40, Robbie 41, Chad 42, and Colin 43 ? especially Chad ? take a chill pill. Oh and Chad, I don't care how much in debt we would have been, some billionaire would have bought us just like they bought Chelsea who had serious amounts of debt, cause when you have billions, £75M is not a lot.

Plus Chad, tell City about naming rights ;they have just got a shedload from an airline that was not very rich, there are always ways in big business that get you money.

Oh you wrote the stupidest comment (only kidding). Football is the richest game around and Everton are attractive to buy, new stadium or no new stadium we all know why we ain't been sold but i believe we would have if we had got the stadium in KirKby.
Brendan McLaughlin
46 Posted 23/10/2011 at 22:12:37
FFS Trevor

"Attacks"... lighten up... it's a joke. You know banter with your mates in the pub. Erm, then again... penny drops!

BTW... "Moyes's lovechild... " loved it. I've never heard that one before... Patent it before some other "master of wit & rasping repartee" jumps on your bandwagon!
Colin Wainwright
47 Posted 23/10/2011 at 22:23:44
Bobby. We may have had a nice new stadium, in the plush environs of Kirkby, but you wouldn't have been able to get there for the kick off.

Even if you did, you wouldn't get home for Match of the Day. Read about it mate.

BTW, sheiks shit new stadiums.
Chad Schofield
48 Posted 23/10/2011 at 23:38:27
My mistake Bobby, you're clearly a candidate for The Apprentice given your knowledge of "Big business". Anyway, as everyone knows there's no money in the world or interest in buying football clubs... Bill's told us.
Chad Schofield
49 Posted 24/10/2011 at 06:38:00
Bobby, re-reading my comments I think I'm being pretty harsh. I'd recommend you read http://www.toffeeweb.com/club/kirkby/ though (no link in Club by the way). There's a lot to digest, and it gets pretty heated... But it's well worth it.

Neither of us (pressumably) know what it's like to be a billionaire. However let's try an analogy of you wanting to buy a car off me.

I'm selling a Sierra Cosworth which is worth £1,000. You've got money to burn, and this looks like a fun project. I have ragged the Hell out of it, but it's a classic. However the spoiler on the back has almost rusted through. A replacement is going to cost around £300, but to save you the hassle I say I know a mate who can get one from work, it's practically free, but looks the part.

Turns out though it costs £78... Not the end of the world but it's made of plywood. If it gets fitted, I'm also going to treble the price of what I was going to charge you, plus have no ambition to pay for the spoiler myself so you have to pay my mare with interest.

Would you prefer to buy my car with or without the new spoiler, or would you call me a prick and go down the road and buy the light blue XR3i for £2,200?
Bobby Mallon
50 Posted 24/10/2011 at 19:32:20
Cheers, Chad ? I will have the XR3i but only for £2,000.

On another issue has there been any sniff of a buyout from any rich person? God I would love to turn the tele on and for once see we are buying a player for £30 million, even if he was shite.

Just to be able to buy anyone of that price would make me smile for a long time. I can only dream....

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads