Moyes explains Barkley's absence

, 26 October, 53comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes has explained withdrawing Ross Barkley from the front line for over a month, since the Carling Cup third-round win over West Bromwich Albion on 21 September.

Moyes said: "Ross deserved to start in the team at the start of the season because of his form in pre-season. There's just been a bit of a dip in him which we've seen in training. Anyone who's watched the games will have said that as well.

"We've got to remember this is a 17-year-old boy and we shouldn't be trying to expect too much too soon from him. There are signs that he's beginning to edge towards coming back, I've seen a couple of things in training in the last few days. Hopefully that's the case and he's getting his second wind now."

Quotes or other material sourced from TribalFootball.com



Reader Comments (53)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Bannantyne
1 Posted 26/10/2011 at 15:37:06
Bullshit

I've noticed a "bit of a dip" from Cahill, Saha (until last week), Jags, Ossie, Neville etc etc ? and none of them have been absent from even the bench for a whole month.

Barkley was our brightest light early on, and he just disappears.
Brian Waring
2 Posted 26/10/2011 at 15:48:13
Going by that then, shouldn't Jags have been dropped, because of his huge dip in form?
Gerry Quinn
3 Posted 26/10/2011 at 15:54:56
Jags? Huge Dip? Don't we mean "Fucking Big Splash"?
Not to mention those other team members Ă  a swimmer terminology:

Howard - the Flap
Billy - the Crawl
Royston - Freestyle
Moysie - the Back Crawl
Victor - the Backflip and moan...
Guy Rogers
4 Posted 26/10/2011 at 16:03:19
Classic, Brian! But then he is only a 17 year old and we don't want him getting too big for his boots!
Phil Bellis
5 Posted 26/10/2011 at 16:26:14
"...beginning to edge towards..."
clear, precise and positive there, Mr Moyes
Thomas Windsor
6 Posted 26/10/2011 at 16:36:19
If you are good enough, you should play; he can be rested the odd game ? not for a whole month.
Michael Kenrick
7 Posted 26/10/2011 at 16:35:05
The lad bursts on the scene, everyone can see he's got what is needed. The spark, the verve, the desire to get forward, the breath of fresh air we were crying out for...

What does Moyes do? Talks him down, makes sure he knows his place in the pecking order; he makes a mistake, gets told he'll be playing in all the Reserves games, gets dropped for a month...

Nurturing of the highest order? My Arse.
Martin Paice
8 Posted 26/10/2011 at 16:48:10
I've never understood why Moyes continually criticises his own players in the media.

Surely if something needs to said it's best said in private.
Denis Richardson
9 Posted 26/10/2011 at 16:46:32
I think people need to read between the lines a little. Personally I think the lads success has meant that Moyes wants to take him out of the limelight until he's signed a longer contract.

Yes, other clubs know about him but we could probably do without the media dubbing him the next Messi / Pele with great performances, when his current contract only has about 18 months to run.

If Moyes still keeps him out of the first team squad after he's (hopefully) signed a longer term contract when he turns 18 in December, then you (and I) can justfiably ask wtf is going on.

Am not Moyes' biggest fan, but he's doing the right thing (assuming I am not talking shite!). Although he could maybe put the lad on the bench at least.
Kevin Hudson
10 Posted 26/10/2011 at 16:47:48
"If you're old enough,etc.."

In what other industry would an inexperienced child be given a position of regular, top-level responsibility?

Those who feel a couple of promising performances warrant an immediate starting berth are short-sighted, quick-fix, fickle & whimsical.
Agi Harrar
11 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:01:05
Spot on, Denis. I think Moyes is just keeping him out of the spotlight until the contract is signed.
Gavin Ramejkis
12 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:03:54
Kevin, think you want to look at what Man U did a few years ago with kids then have a rethink.
John Ballinger
13 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:01:57
Think it may just be something to do with his contract. Moyes doesn't want to put him the shop window till he's a got a five year deal under his belt, and then able to ask a high price. Isn't he due to be signing in December?

Agree all the Moyes-speak pisses me off though...
Tony J Williams
14 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:08:42
I am glad we have so many posters who watch him in training and know more than Moyes does about how the 17 year old kid is playing at the moment.

If only we could get someone on here to get their badges, we would have the league tied up in no time.
Chris Rudd
15 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:09:15
Kevin - 'In what other industry would an inexperienced child be given a position of regular, top-level responsibility?'

Answer - in virtually any other area of the sporting or entertainment industry.

And I don't think people are saying he should start every match, just be given some game time. After all that's the one thing we should be able to offer him over top 4 sides.

If not he might as well be in United's /Chelski's /City's (delete as appropriate) reserves earning more.
Jay Wilson
16 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:12:54
Gavin, were all those United players 17? and had they all just had a whole year out of the game with a triple leg break? Were they also playing for a team that is easy prey for one of the so called big clubs to come along and pinch said teenager?

Spot on Tony by the way.
Chris Rudd
17 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:15:31
Oh and anyone who thinks Ross Barkley is still a secret has to be joking. Do you honestly think he's not been on those 'big clubs' radar for some time already?
Kevin Hudson
18 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:12:28
Rubbish, Gavin.

Ask any Australian cricketer of the last 20 years how easy it was for them to develop in the protective confines of an all-conquering team.Same principal the Man.Utd kids.

Barkley should be gently drip-fed into the set-up, for several reasons, just one of which is that so naive Evertonians don't expect "Roy Race," to turn up.
Kevin Hudson
19 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:21:28
Regardless of theatrical "child-stars," or sporting "Wunderkind," Chris, where possible, these kids are protected by those around them & not over-exposed.

Otherwise they could turn out like Michael Jackson or Gazza.
Tom Bowers
20 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:28:50
Moyes does't make sense. Jags hasn't played as well as we know he can but Heitinga remains out of favour?
Brian Waring
21 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:30:24
Tony (#14) Tell you what, Jags must be absolutely fantastic in training, because his first team performances this season don't warrant him a start.
Thor Sørensen
22 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:46:59
Denis Richardson is spot on. This has something to do with the players contract situation and he will be brought into the limelight again once a new deal is signed and sealed.
Gavin Ramejkis
23 Posted 26/10/2011 at 17:57:50
Kevin what the fuck has cricket to do with this thread? If a player is good enough to play then play him, whats more "damaging" not playing or being slagged off by your manager? Moyes could easily have said anything other than his form has dropped which is a cheek given the majority of the first team could easily wear that particular badge and havent been dragged off for a month.

Jay, the argument was along the lines of kids shouldn't be playing. Whether or not you want to wrap Barkley up in cotton wool after an injury thus retiring him which is utter nonsense or hide him in case he gets the attention of another team, again utter nonsense as he's here to do a job and gets paid a wage to play football not be mothballed or used as an ornament. A friend of mine in the Channel Islands drives classic cars every day as he explained they are a car to be enjoyed as a car, his sheds are full of mothballed icons frankly going to waste whose owners are trying the same trick - pointless.
Kevin Hudson
24 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:07:15
I gave you TWO examples: Cricket & Man.Utd.

You chose to disregard one of those deliberately.

Managerial criticism is a part of football; Name me ONE player who's form hasn't been critiqued at some stage of their career? If you think Moyes' comments will "damage," him then this only further undermines your (presumed) clarion-call for him to play!
Jay Harris
25 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:07:40
If Moyesy wants to "protect"him then surely the best way is to gradually give him more game time with the first team or at least have him coming off the bench on occasions.

I can understand those suggesting he wants to keep him out of the limelight until he signs his new contract but as everybody says he is already well known and the surest way to get him to commit to a new contract is to get him playing.

The points we are continuously losing by playing Ossie as a left winger is going to be more costly than "hiding" Barkley if we are relegated.
Jon Cox
26 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:10:14
If your good enough you're old enough. Never truer words uttered. Do think it's a shop window thing though.

As for Jags, I think his "splash" or "dip" could be measured in Megatons
Steavey Buckley
27 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:07:35
Ross could have been on the subs bench. There is only so much he can do by training and playing for the reserves to make him into a better player. Having some time on the pitch when coming off the bench would have improved his confidence and sharpened him up. What I have seen this season from Cahill and Osman have been big disappointments. And one wonders if they are good enough even to make the subs bench. Cahill has not been the same player ever since he came back injured from playing for Australia in the Gulf in the early part of this year. Osman looks as though he still hasn't come back from his preseason holidays.
Jon Cox
28 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:20:40
Kevin, er, Bobby Charleton.
Ray Roche
29 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:18:12
If Moyes sees him daily in training and knows his character far better than any of us surely Moyes judgement should be the more accurate one? The lad is only 17 and maybe needs to (mentally) mature more before he is ready to play week in, week out before 30k-40k crowds. I know that, at 17, my biggest concern was making sure my copy of "Big And Bouncy" was safely concealed from me Mam...
Kevin Connor
30 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:35:25
Moyes is leaving him out because he's an attacking player who likes to go forward. Moyes doesn't like positive players, he would much rather play midfielders upfront by themselves and central defenders in the middle of midfield. He's happy containing teams.
Kevin Hudson
31 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:37:14
Sure John & plenty of other examples of that ilk. But there's been enough of them who've gone off the rails or not "reached their full potential," to warrant a careful approach.

I'm pretty sure the Gaffer would echo that view.

That said, Carling Cup games are possibly an ideal opportunity to blood Barkley, so I wouldn't mind seeing him tonight. Speaking of which, my Goodison-bound taxi has just been called, gotta run!

Love us to have a real go tonight. Chelsea/ Arsenal at the weekend, so if they "rest," a few of their boys, and give some of their kids a go..
Andrew Laird
32 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:55:31
Ah, so the team is picked based on training performances and not actual first team games? That explains a lot.

Moyes watches Osman in training every day and then puts him wide in midfield for the majority of games for the last few YEARS. How many badges do I need before I can criticise that decision guys?
Drew O'Neall
33 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:52:46
He will play when his contract is signed, until then button yer lip.

This is a good example of how the Everton "support" criticise Moyes selections on a regular basis without being armed with the facts.

Empty vessels make the most noise but don't despair, as in most emotive issues, the sensible majority is silent.

COYB
Jon Cox
34 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:59:30
Agreed Kev, enjoy the game mate. Tell you what you go the game and i'll guard Cornwall.
Seamus Murphy
35 Posted 26/10/2011 at 18:52:12
Kevin - I'm all for a careful approach but dropping him for a full month? Not even a place on the bench? As many others have said already, there are others in the first 11 that are in worse form but remain in the starting 11, seems to me that Moyes is either not telling us the full story or is being very harsh on a young talent in my opinion.

Hope we see him this evening like you said!
Jon Cox
37 Posted 26/10/2011 at 19:09:57
Michael, chop chop old bean, wheres the Matchday Forum?
Matt Traynor
38 Posted 26/10/2011 at 19:19:45
Kevin, in what other industry you ask? This is football FFS, not Management Consulting. Our own club history is littered with players who were regulars at 16. Derby County just had to get a note to play a 15 year old. At the Olympics you have even younger competitors.

Yes, nurture him slowly, I'm sure he'll be a cracker in his late 20s.

Sake.
Robbie Muldoon
39 Posted 26/10/2011 at 20:04:48
Moyes probably did make Rooney want to fuck off.
Michael Carney
40 Posted 26/10/2011 at 20:00:16
Tony (14)
Moyes sees things in Anichibe, when fit, in training that no one else can see.
You don't need a badge to see his inadequacies. Chance after chance, mistake after mistake, opportunity after opportunity are given to certain players, yet Barkely is played out of position where he can't have the influence he showed in central midfield. He makes 1 mistake against Blackburn and that's him for a month. I would rather have him in central midfield than Jack "the crab" Rodwell
Lewis Barclay
41 Posted 26/10/2011 at 22:33:18
I don't normally criticise Moyes but this is pure bullshit. Barkley, Magaye and Coleman all deserve to be in the same team from the start of a Carling cup game against Chelsea, especially when you play an angry Manure the following Saturday.

I was delighted by our lucky win at Craven Cottage at the weekend. Now we have a potentially injured striker, a suspended player who was just coming into form and ow we have to recover from being knocked out of the only trophy we coul hope to win thi season.

We may be skint but I'm tired of the same mistakes at Everton, at least make some new mistakes. It's about time someone stated shaking things up. Moyes, show us you're as good as everyone suggests, or go elsewhere.
Anthony Jones
42 Posted 26/10/2011 at 22:42:30
As much as I want to think of Ross as a kid, as some of you seem to, to make myself feel younger, I cant. If he is a good player he should play. Centre backs and keepers need to learn to cut out errors before they are unleashed but attacking players are supposed to take risks and drop the odd bollock.

Anyone calling him a kid is a bitter old get. He looks like a man to me and he would certainly beat most of us at fisty cuffs!
Lewis Barclay
43 Posted 26/10/2011 at 22:45:45
I don't believe Moyes will play Barkley if he signs a new contract and I challenge anyone else to come up with a legitimate reason he would eithet
Anthony Jones
44 Posted 26/10/2011 at 22:42:30
As much as I want to think of ross as a kid, as some of you seem to, to make myself feel younger, I cant. If he is a good player he should play. Centre backs and keepers need to learn to cut out errors before they are unleashed but attacking players are supposed to take risks and drop the odd bollock.

Anyone calling him a kid is a bitter old get. He looks like a man to me and he would certainly beat most of us at fisty cuffs!
CiarĂ¡n McGlone
45 Posted 26/10/2011 at 22:52:42
I've heard it all now. It's whimsical to want our manager to play our most consistent, exciting and talented players. Classic.
Trevor Lynes
46 Posted 26/10/2011 at 23:04:10
Maybe he is not being played as there are plans to sell him ?? We never had any real benefit from producing Rooney... he was nursed and kept injury free while we had a load of ageing ha-beens playing every week.

No wonder he left, he was ten years younger than everyone else in the team and a different generation than Naysmith, Stubbs and Weir. He was our ONLY true asset and the only one who commanded a sizeable fee. Perhaps Barkley will be moving on sooner rather than later...

Let's face it, we are light years away from a lot of other sides in the Premier League and, unless something happens to attract top players to the club, we will continue the slide!!

We were really lucky against Fulham...
John Daley
47 Posted 26/10/2011 at 22:46:00
"..these kids are protected by those around them & not over-exposed.

Otherwise they could turn out like Michael Jackson or Gazza."

So starting a few more games for Everton could lead Ross down the road to becoming a noseless, squeaking, skin bleaching, kiddie fiddler or a pissed up, self-pitying shit for brains breaking through a police cordon to hand deliver half a cooked chicken and a 4pack of Miller to a murderer?

Here's me thinking it would just lead to him becoming a better player.
Peter Fearon
48 Posted 27/10/2011 at 02:28:53
Maybe doing so well and then being being dropped for no reason could have triggered a loss of confidence and drive - that "dip" in training? Knowing no matter how well you do on the field, others will always be preferred to you, will do that.
Richard Tarleton
49 Posted 27/10/2011 at 10:16:57
moyes simply doesn't trust young players, his inept handling of Rooney meant we lost him far earlier than was necessary and under him Rodwell has gone backwards, what he likes are players who are honest journeymen a la Hibbert, Jagielka , Neville, Carsley etc. No trouble and always do the expected.
Kevin Hudson
50 Posted 27/10/2011 at 11:54:30
Got to admit, John Daley, that gave me a giggle..

Extreme examples I admit - I WAS over-elaborating the point that I think establishing himself in the team ought to be a gradual process for Ross.

I just don't buy in to the capricious argument based on a couple of promising performances, he shuold be given too much, too soon. I think Moyes also adopts that view.

The argument over what IS the right balance is a valid albeit subjective discussion.
Ray Roche
51 Posted 27/10/2011 at 12:17:22
John Daley

"a noseless, squeaking, skin bleaching, kiddie fiddler or a pissed up, self-pitying shit for brains breaking through a police cordon to hand deliver half a cooked chicken and a 4pack of Miller to a murderer? "

Quality!
Mike Knowsley
52 Posted 27/10/2011 at 12:47:23
I agree totally with Chris Bannantyne #1; this IS total BS. I believe Ross Barkley has been 'dropped' due to the number of scouts that turn up everytime it's announced he's playing. Until he signs THAT contract in December Ross will be on gardening leave. Kenwright wants a big pay day when he's sold... and he will be sold!
Kevin Freaney
53 Posted 28/10/2011 at 00:12:33
Moyes explains Barkleys absence....

"He attacks, runs with the ball and shoots on goal, all I want is for him to hang around our box and hoof loss balls up the field to Saha...so we're holding him back and training all that attack out of him, he'll make a great RB when Hibbert retires at 38"
Richard Reeves
54 Posted 28/10/2011 at 00:29:16
Just wants to flog the fuck out of his old timer best mates before unveiling the secret weapon of his younger players. In about three years time these younger players will be getting a bit more regular football after being loaned out to any lower division club that will take them and then come back to kickstart their carreers that should've started three years ago.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads