Tony Hibbert: True Blue

, 28 October, 38comments  |  Jump to most recent
A boyhood blue, Hibbert needs no telling about Evertonians' frustrations yet offers a measured response. "I can see where they are coming from but also the club has got to survive, it has to be here 100, 200 years later. They have got to manage the books and if it's got to be the way we are now then it's got to be and the lads have got to pull their sleeves up and have a go for the club and they are doing that at the moment."

Hibbert maintains that Everton's much-publicised failure to sign players has not damaged the spirit in the camp — "I don't think it has done. What I said about the team spirit, that is a big factor with Everton" — though he does admit that Moyes's men are still adjusting to the loss of midfielders Steven Pienaar and Mikel Arteta.

"The type of player Steven was, he was world class and for him to not be in our starting lineup again is noticeable. Like with Mikel, you will notice it and it takes time to adjust because they offer something different that we haven't got [now]."

Quotes or other material sourced from Full Interview in The Independent



Reader Comments (38)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Matheson
1 Posted 28/10/2011 at 09:52:42
Good for Tony. I am pleased for him getting the attention for once.

This lad tends to split opinions. If I am honest, he is not good enough to be a 1st team regular. That said, he is a local lad and a blue, but, crucially, he never gives less than 100% and his commitment is an example to all others. So he will always have my respect.
Gerald Foo
2 Posted 28/10/2011 at 10:17:25
He is the perfect pro. Never complains, never whines. When called upon always gives 100%. He plays like how fans like us would if given an opportunity to play for the club.

I would love for him to get a goal this weekend against Man U just to see Goodison go ballistic.
Tony J Williams
3 Posted 28/10/2011 at 10:46:18
The game has passed him by now, he was a great tackler and used to take the man with the ball, the Suarez's of the world have put paid to any kind of tackle that used to be applauded.

Even the nonces on MoTD picked up on this point last week when they said a challenge where a player got booked used now to end up with a new contract back then.

Brilliant professional if somewhat limited player. I would have him at right back above Neville and Coleman every time.
Andrew Laird
4 Posted 28/10/2011 at 11:05:13
I like Hibbert, as limited as he is he does the job that is asked. He is a better RB than Neville, and probably picks up half the wages, end of.

Like Tony J above states, the game has changed and being a good tackler is becoming less and less prominent as an attribute as football slowly becomes a non contact sport, succumbing to cheating and feigning of injury by unscrupulous opportunist wankers the world over.
Kevin Sparke
5 Posted 28/10/2011 at 11:16:50
Three things every Evertonian knows about Hibbert:

1. He cannot cross
2. He's slow
3. He's limited in his game

All three are true of the Tony Hibbert of 5 years ago but not now. Hibbert is a rarity in the game ? he's a player who got better after the age of 25 and if you can get beyond the facts that we all know about him and actually watch him play you'll see that:

1. He can cross and he can cross with inch perfect precision at times ? I just wish he did it more often.

2. His excellent reading of the game as a defender makes up for his lack of raw pace and this anticipation has saved our bacon on more than one occasion over the last couple of years. His tackling is also precision-guided ? how many times does he miss games through suspension due to accrued bookings? Hardly ever...

3. As a defender, he's the almost perfect right-back and he didn't disgrace himself when he was asked to play centre-half two seasons ago.
Richard Reeves
6 Posted 28/10/2011 at 11:11:58
An honest fella yet if the very same words had come from Neville's mouth then my blood pressure would be going up as I type.

It maybe that Neville has short circuited and is probably in the engineering lab having his memory re-programed so expect a few others to toe the party line in the near future. Coleman, Rodwell and Barkley are young and considered to be the future... yep ? they'll be next.
Martin Mason
7 Posted 28/10/2011 at 12:09:17
I like the bloke and think he is a far better defender than many give him credit for. He has had to change his hard tackling game and if anything has improved his game. I also completely agree with what he said about the situation at the club and having to survive. We should read and note this.
Brian Waring
8 Posted 28/10/2011 at 13:24:11
Top lad. One of the best right backs in the prem.
Chris Rudd
9 Posted 28/10/2011 at 13:29:07
Ha, you almost had me going there Kevin with your first few lines.

Totally agree with the rest of your post and can't understand how anyone would prefer Neville at right back. One of the few 'tackling' defenders left in the game and his crossing has improved so much that I reckon he'll have a few more assists by the end of the season.

Proper footballer in my book and if you ever need a Vladimir Putin double...
Danny O'Neill
10 Posted 28/10/2011 at 15:01:43
Totally committed and always gives 100%. I think his problem is that he's a traditional English style full back in a modern game that screams out for attack-minded ones. Agree with Kevin Sparke @5-he has improved with age. I think had he been taller he would have made a great centre back.
Gerry Morrison
11 Posted 28/10/2011 at 16:35:46
I wish we had a few more like Tony Hibbert.
Ken Buckley
12 Posted 28/10/2011 at 16:40:26
When asked the question 'Name three better right-backs in the Prem' you will find it is not that easy.
Gerry Quinn
13 Posted 28/10/2011 at 16:41:11
Gerry M #11 - if we had more like Tony Hibbert the moaning here on TW would be even more unbearable!
I personally like the guy, a true blue and gives his all in every match - which is more than I feel for one or two of our other players. May not be the best right back in the world but he is what we can afford.
Jim Hourigan
14 Posted 28/10/2011 at 16:46:47
Sad how mediocrity is now championed as something better. He is a poor RB who might put 3 good crosses in all season, which by the law of averages is pretty poor ? how many does Baines put in each match?

As for his positional sense, it's appalling ? watch how often he is caught out on his blind side by not even checking, put any cross in at the back post and he will be found wanting. His throw-ins are a joke, lobs the ball up in the air in an aimless fashion - schoolboys are taught more constructive ways at throw-ins.

As for his speed of thought!!! ? ever seen him take a quick free kick? Ever seen him take a quick throw in or a give and go. He might be a decent tackler who is rarely beaten for pace but when he plays the right hand side of out team is redundant. How many goals in how many games?

Neville might be no better but just because Moyes's options are poor does not make Hibbert a good player. He is clearly a whole hearted player who puts his body on the line, but the words good, quality and Hibbert do not belong in the same sentence.
Chris Rudd
15 Posted 28/10/2011 at 16:56:25
Was it you Jim, about whom I once said, you'd clearly had your cat run over by Tony Hibbert, as you clearly just don't like him mate?

I think, if you'd watched him this season, you'd find he's put in way more than 3 decent crosses in most games he's played, including an assist against Wigan.

And nobody's infallible ? Baines was shite the other night, in every area apart from on his own goal line.

Nobody's making out Hibbo's a world beater but, as Kevin said earlier, he has improved markedly this season which is more than you can say for most of our squad.
Tony J Williams
16 Posted 28/10/2011 at 17:02:41
How many goals did the long standing and most capped England right back score for Man U when he won his many League titles and Cups? He scored 5 in 485 games.

He was shite that Neville wasn't he?

Jim, Jags or Howard take the free kicks from the back usually.

He has put at least three cracking crosses over in just the last three games, one assist and should have had more if the new saviour Stracq didn't have a ten bob head.

He has improved over the last few seasons and is arguably one of the best "defenders" in the league....pity the rest of his game doesn't match up to his defending.
Simon Howett
17 Posted 28/10/2011 at 22:01:45
Tony Hibbert is what football is all about. Local lad made good. Never gives less than 100%, never moans and just gets on with it. An honest, true pro. If football had a few more Tony Hibberts then it would be in a much better place than it is now.
Chris Jones [NZ]
18 Posted 28/10/2011 at 23:44:20
A good honest lad who always gives of his best. True, for some, his best ain't good enough but Tony Hibbert can't be faulted for his comittment and professionalism.

And consider this, if your contribution to the game = natural talent multiplied by application, then I'll wager he makes a bigger overall contribution than most pros who are blessed with a greater degree of natural talent.
Kevin Freaney
19 Posted 28/10/2011 at 23:50:56
He's dedicated and can put the man into the sponsor boards, but he's not a Premier League player and is a classic Moyes player.

Look at Fulham: he gets drawn into the centre way too much and leaves his man unmarked. Top scorer in Europe for us through own goals? He wouldn't get a game in the vast majority of Premier League teams.

Cracks me up that Hibbert is revered but we gave Unsworth a hard time everytime he had a bad game.

The fact is, he's the best of the worst in that position... but fair play to him; he's been a loyal Everton professional while at the club ?and you have to admire him for that.
John Shaw
20 Posted 28/10/2011 at 23:58:11
He may well be limited in an attacking sense but I sure wish more of today's players had his attitude and commitment.

In future, before people criticise him for failing to cut out a cross or for being caught out of position, take a look at how often he has no cover whatsoever in front of him, or how often he gets across to cover for either of the two centrebacks who are out of position; both happen on a very very frequent basis.
Kevin Freaney
21 Posted 29/10/2011 at 00:08:49
#20 John, very true, he ends up in the centre covering for Jags and Distin leaving his wing wide open. You'd think Moyes might have worked on this at some stage!
Kevin Hudson
22 Posted 29/10/2011 at 00:19:16
Hats off to Hibbo.
Michael Kenrick
23 Posted 29/10/2011 at 03:18:15
Many times on here I've seen Osman and Hibbert lumped together in the rejects bin...

Osman? Yes. Nice lad, but hopeless for us on the field. Just hopeless. Can't keep the ball, brushed aside... no protection from the ref. Rarely scores.

Hibbert? Never scores... But see #5 above. Superb post by Kevin Sparke. Everything he said is bang on. I like Tony. Yes, he gets skinned occasionally but, more often than not, he saves us.

And he he plays with total combatant and all-abiding passion. You can't ask for more than that.
Steven Pendleton
24 Posted 29/10/2011 at 03:23:47
Wow, he's professional and gives his all for the shirt. Wouldn't you if you were on his wages!!!

Guus Hiddink clearly picked our weakness in the FA Cup final and Hibbert's flaws were shown for all the world to see. We are going nowhere if he's our best right back.

But hey, he's a bloody good professional and a local lad. What a load of shit.
Kevin Freaney
25 Posted 29/10/2011 at 04:09:37
Steven #24

Spot on!
Andy McNabb
26 Posted 29/10/2011 at 05:14:14
Great to see Hibbo get some credit. I wouldn't be surprised, if like me he has a scruffy scrap of paper stuck to the frame of his computer screen. I printed it off Toffeeweb years ago and it has survived several lap and desk tops since then.

It runs along the lines of ? "Evertonians are born not manufactured..."
Danny Burke
27 Posted 29/10/2011 at 09:38:06
I like Tony Hibbert, great defender. Yes he isn't the most skillfull lad in the world but he is a defender not a winger. He can put in decent balls though and as long as he defends like he does and pops in a few decent crosses then great. Not every full back can be Roberto Carlos! He gets a lot of unfair criticism.
Trevor Powell
28 Posted 29/10/2011 at 10:42:28
Hibbert might not be a world beater, a Gary Stevens, Tommy Wright, Alex Parker or would he have been a regular in the great eighties team. If things were better financially, Tony would be a great and loyal squad player just like Alan Harper, Tommy Jackson and Kevin Richardson.

Give the lad a break, he is one of us, a true blue living his dream and giving his all, what else can he do. Remember, he was never a Peter Johnson or Bill Kenwright messing up the financial heart of the club.

I hope that he gets a damned good testimonial in a couple of years. He's one of the few players in a mercenary league who deserves one. The felings are the same for Leon Osman!
David Mathieson
29 Posted 29/10/2011 at 11:34:03
I don't mind Hibbert, decent squad player but he should never have started in that Cup Final ? worst decision of Moyes's career. The Cup Final was easily the biggest game we have had in many years and we ended up with Jacobsen at right back for 45 minutes, how? It should have been Captain Marvel at right back and Rodwell in the middle; Hibbert in the eleven was silly.
Nick Armitage
30 Posted 29/10/2011 at 14:20:39
Problem with Hibbert in the Cup Final was that Malouda was in the form of his life and he had no help whatsover from Osman who spent 90 mins pathetically chasing Ashley Cole's shadow as he had a new arsehole torn for himself.

The whole right flank was simply appalling and in a club with money, they both would have been replaced.

Moyes's tactics were dreadful and most of the team turned up expecting to lose. Fellaini got kicked twice and gave up, Lescott didn't want to know. Men against boys, as usual.
Andy Crooks
31 Posted 29/10/2011 at 16:45:57
Everton have been lucky in having few players who don't try. Tony Hibbert gives 100% . He can do no more.
Kevin Dillon
32 Posted 29/10/2011 at 16:37:03
Terry darracott anyone. He wasn't great either, but he was ours, and like Emily with bagpuss, we loved him. Tony is a good honest pro, and they are few and far between nowadays.
Greg Anderson
33 Posted 29/10/2011 at 18:33:04
Great article. This kind of modesty and humility is as unusual in football today as it is refreshing. Which is one reason why I still find our current team easy to like, despite the disappointing results. It is full of relatively humble, un-Tevez-like, team-orientated players, like Jags, Bainesy, Howard, Neville, Cahill, Distin, and others. And this has always been a characteristic of our club, one that makes me very proud. Most of our stars have not acted like stars, from Sheedy, Ratcliffe, and Southall, back through Harvey, Labone, Wilson, Wright, and Royle, to Hickson and Dixie Dean himself. Everton: quietly excellent since 1878.
Mick Davies
34 Posted 30/10/2011 at 05:38:31
I'm a local lad and a true blue, can I have a game? Some of the comments here about this lad are too blue-tainted.

Has to be the worst "player" I can think of after watching Everton for 40 years. He needs others to look after his position, spends more time on the floor or turning his back on the ball than doing what he is supposed to do.

Constantly caught out of position with no pace to get back and with his ballet kicks he's more Billy Elliot than Billy the fish. Lionel Blair as opposed to Lionel Messi. Please just take the time to watch him... if it wasn't so serious, it would be worth a laugh.
Tony J Williams
35 Posted 30/10/2011 at 16:42:36
Mick, you obviously slept through the period when we had Ian Wilson ... then Bret Angell, Mikel Madar, Alexandersson etc.
Marc Williams
36 Posted 30/10/2011 at 16:57:50
Mick @ 34...Your post & a response to it has actually made me agree with one of Tony J Williams comments on Toffeeweb.
I never thought that would ever happen !

Off the top of my head please add Stuart Barlow & Claus Thomsen to Tony's list.
Mick Davies
37 Posted 31/10/2011 at 12:41:49
Tony and Marc, opinions are like arseholes, We all have them, it's just some of us don't talk through them. I am seriously staggered by his lack of ability and all the players you mention were bought and sold so other clubs must have wanted them. I havent heard a single whisper in Hibbert's decade of playing in the PL of another club wanting or even looking at him.
Andy Crooks
38 Posted 31/10/2011 at 18:27:43
Mick, where were you when Alex Nyarko graced the blue shirt?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads