New chapter in Rooney / Everton history

, 30 October, 32comments  |  Jump to most recent
At A Different League, Andrew Tuft thinks the relationship between Rooney and the Goodison crowd is changing: It appears, to the great majority inside the stadium, that Rooney is merely a name from Everton's past. Rooney is no longer viewed as a former Everton player now plying his trade elsewhere. He is a United player who had a brief cameo with Everton. In that distinction lies an enormous difference.

Quotes or other material sourced from A Different League



Reader Comments (32)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nick Entwistle
1 Posted 30/10/2011 at 19:34:50
He's shown himself as a dislikable granny shagging wife cheating petulant bum-fur browed oik. I think we can happily ignore him, and happily bypass anything he did for the club. Thanks for the memories, Tosser.
Peter Fearon
2 Posted 30/10/2011 at 19:35:51
New chapter my left bollock! Obviously tempers cool with time but Rooney will never be anything but the object of ridicule and scorn at Goodison. It's not just the "Always a Blue" nonsense, but the corrupt nature of the events leading up to the transfer - read legalized abduction - that rankles so much. This man was a Man Utd player the moment he signed with an agent being paid by Man Utd to bring him to Man Utd. He may as well have played his last season with us in a Man Utd shirt. Rooney has spoken about coming back in his twilight years to grace us with his god-like presence when he is past it and Utd no longer wants him. I say, if he crawls through 100 yards of broken glass and offers to play for free the answer should be no. Ironically, in the light of recent events it may be that we are well shut of the whole tribe of Rooneys. Andrew Tuft, does it sound like my disdain is less intense than seven years ago?
Tony Horne
3 Posted 30/10/2011 at 19:46:50
At the end of his career he will look back and think what could have been. He could have been the player that an emergent Everton side was built around instead of having to fit in to an already successful Manchester United set up. Thereby swapping adventure for security, sporting immortality for money, the chance to re-write history for medals.

He could have been something truly great. What a waste!
Robert Daniels
4 Posted 30/10/2011 at 20:07:32
I agree with 1, 2 and 3.

Fuck him and the twats that sold him.........
Joe McMahon
5 Posted 30/10/2011 at 20:28:27
Peter (2) Bloody Hell - Let it go man. Yes he handled it badly but he had agents and was still a teenager. He'd been given the chance to play for SAF at Man U and play with Giggs, Keane, Scholes, Ronaldo etc and win plenty of Silverware in an attacking team. Now compare that with Kevine Kilbane, and Gary Naysmith and a Manager who wouldn't know what to do if Henry, Zola, Batistuta, Weah and Maradona suddenly all wanted to join Everton, play for nowt and pay their own transfer fee.
As a person I don't like Rooney, but I still put him in my Telegraph fantasy footie team and he's getting me plenty of points.
Trevor Mackie
6 Posted 30/10/2011 at 20:41:23
He reminds me of Michael Owen more interested in England than club football his performance against Citeh was non existent and he strolled about against us.

Honestly think if he wasn't at utd getting an armchair ride he'd have imploded by now - certainly don't think he has the technique or temperament to cut it in Spain or Italy.

Joins Beckham on the "english great" myth simply because he's the best of a diminishing pool.

I spoke to one of the Everton scouts instrumental in bringing Rooney some years ago he said Rooney couldn't stand Moyes and his methods.
Robbie Shields
7 Posted 30/10/2011 at 20:53:27
If Moyes had built an attack minded, pass and move team at anytime over the last 7 years then I would still be bitter about Rooney going to United. As it stands it was the best thing for both Everton and Rooney that he left when he did (but it's has taken 7 years and shite Moyes tactics for me to let it go). It would have been a travesty to see the ball constantly hoofed 60 yards up the pitch for our 1 up front truly world class striker Rooney to then be asked to bring the ball down, dribble past 4 defenders and win us games 1-0 week in week out.

I for one would love to see him back before he reaches 30, but only if Moyes is long gone by then, otherwise he's better off staying where is is.
Kase Chow
8 Posted 30/10/2011 at 21:50:59
Totally agree with the poster R Shields (7). I've finally let it go cos the guy would have been crap under Moyes

I'm a striker for my team and I'd hate to play under Moyes.

Hate to say it but Rooney (and Lescott, Pienaar & Arteta) made the right choice.

I love Everton but we're a fcuking mess of a club at the moment
Thomas Williams
9 Posted 30/10/2011 at 22:38:36
I have a theory that may get shot down here but I'll have a go anyway.

Just say the rumours of takeover are true, what is the first thing new rich owners do? Look for a marquee signing... who better than Rooney?

If Rooney saw that suddenly Everton have new potential, I personally feel he would drop Utd in a shot. It is the lack of ambition mainly that caused the sale.
Glen Anderson
10 Posted 30/10/2011 at 23:08:26
Robbie #7, that's the best comment I've read on Toffeeweb for well over a year. I fully agree.
Chris Brown
11 Posted 31/10/2011 at 00:21:44
I'm actually with Thomas here. As power has shifted in favor of city, if he isn't winning trophies, why is he there?

ManU 's days are ending. SAF will retire, and they are still have a culture of success, it will crumble soon.

If he's not winning championships, he may as well be at the club he loves helping them do something great.
John Ford
12 Posted 31/10/2011 at 00:28:08
Kind of bizarre ? Rooney, Arteta, Lescott and Pienaar all became really good players while at Everton, yet somehow Moyes and Everton messed them up..... and they all left before it was too late?

I've met tablet totting long-term psychotics with a clearer grip on reality.
Peter Fearon
13 Posted 31/10/2011 at 03:17:08
What is this "the club he loves" rubbish? The club he loves is called Manchester Utd. Incidentally, don't you remember him missing against Utd from about two yards in one of the last games he played in an Everton shirt? You think that was a coincidence, an accident? He was already a Manchester Utd player in his head. It's a promise I won't have to keep because it won't happen but I can tell you I will never go to a game in which he plays in an Everton shirt. Fuck him and his match fixing family.
Richard Jones
14 Posted 31/10/2011 at 07:32:41
I think its more of a case of we have bigger things to worry about at the moment, like when this joke of an Evertonian in charge is going to name his price and fuck off!!
Derek Thomas
15 Posted 31/10/2011 at 09:32:40
John Ford; you had better keep taking YOUR tablets.

The Everton pre injury Euro 2004 Rooney was the real deal who ever the name is or was on the Everton managers door at the time.

Arteta, Pienaar, and Lescott, nobody wanted them ( look at the fees ), coz if they did we would not have had the clout to compete, so Moyes did make them what they where, not what they ARE. What they are is finished, on the bench and gone for lots of money in that order.
Dave Wilson
16 Posted 31/10/2011 at 09:56:09
John Ford

Your 100% right of course. Rooney was already an international Superstar when he left us, Lescot found the form of his life playing for Moyes and the Evertonians themselves voted for Pienaar and Arteta as player of the season when they were here.

what a cockeyed view some people have "they left because we are crap" . . .the logical thinker would surely believe it was the other way around.

Can anyone really doubt that some of those 5ths and 6ths we have achieved under Moyes would have been changed into CL qualification if Rooney had been in our team ?

I think we enjoyed the best football Arteta, Pienaar and Lescot ever played, we then sold them for a combined profit of arround 25m . . yet Moyes is to "blame" - staggering.

Oh btw Robbie

How did you think Rooney looked in his new "Carsley role" on Saturday ? Still at least he was picked. SAF left him, Nani and Bebatov out at Anfield so he could get another couple of defenders in
Robbie Shields
17 Posted 31/10/2011 at 11:00:32
Dave, your continued ramblings have the air of a madman.

5 losses out of 6 matches, thank God for Zamora's missed open goal and Blackburns inability to score from their 2 penalties. Shite football, shite tactics, shite substitutions from a shite manager.

You keep hanging on to your belief in the Moyesiah, Newcastle away next up, that'll be fun for the traveling blues, 1 up front trying to nick a goal at the mighty bar codes. Get your fabled excuses ready. They've spent more money than us, haha.

Still think Moyes out by November was so laughable do you? The tide is turning, you can fool most of the people most of the time, but not all of the people all the time, you though are still being fooled, for shame.
Dave Wilson
18 Posted 31/10/2011 at 11:12:45
Robbie

It shouldnt really come as a surprise that you can make excuses for another team when we beat them and then overlook our poor finishing, bad luck or the shite refereeing decisions when we lose.

As for the tide turning, You should have been at Fulham mate, thousands of Evertonians singing Moyes`s name at the final whistle . . . They must all be madmen too

And what makes you think we`ll need an excuse next week ?
Sorry mate we dont all wave the white flag as readily as you. I think we`ll win

"Moyes out by November" ? yes still pissing myself at that,

Did you mean 2012 or 2013 ?

BTW Robbie you didnt answer the question. What did you think of Rooney in the Carsley role ?
Robbie Shields
19 Posted 31/10/2011 at 11:40:13
Dave, the person who raises the white flag is Moyes, that's the point, crikey it can't be that hard to understand can it? As as supporter, I am resigned to the shite we have to watch which will result in us NEVER winning anything with the Moyesiah in charge, IMHO of course. That's why I want the dour, defeatist, defensive thinking 1 up front, one trick pony to do one.

I was out on a stag do on Saturday night in Bris Vegas, so I didn't get to see the United game, from all accounts same old same old. As for Rooney playing in the Carsley position, weird one that, wouldn't be where I would play him that's for sure, so what's your point? SAF makes some weird decisions, including fielding a shite team at Liverpool, so that excuses all of the Moyesiah's ineptitudes? Completely irrelevant.
Adam Bennett
20 Posted 31/10/2011 at 11:54:48
Rooney is a cunt. End of.

Cheated on his girlfriend with a wrinkly prostitute.

Cheated on his pregnant wife with two young, fame hungry footballer, prostitutes.

Told a pack of lies in his book.

Kissed the Man Utd badge on his return to Goodison.

Etc?. etc?. etc?

The only reason I?ve stopped booing him is because my voice goes too easily and I?d rather use it to support those in Royal Blue, and the ?Rooney?s an Evertonian? PR campaign by the club and journalists over the last year or two has left me nauseous.
Dave Wilson
21 Posted 31/10/2011 at 11:56:47
It's a simple point, Robbie.

And it's this: it takes two teams to make a game, but every team that comes to GP comes with a spoiling plan. You seem incapable of understanding this, you seem to think it's something only Moyes does.

It's a measure of the respect the other top coaches have developed for Moyes over the years. Not even City will dare to come to GP playing two up top, yet- when Moyes refuses to play into their hands and go gung-ho, you don't seem to get it.

United may go out and smash lesser teams 5-0 but this is still a shite league and, despite spending £100`s of millions, Ferguson will instruct his guys to park the bus everytime he feels his team will be threatened.

It's not just Moyes; they all do it, wih the possible exception of the Holloways and the Mowbrays.
Mick Davies
22 Posted 31/10/2011 at 12:13:37
i'm sure I am not alone in being overjoyed at the emergence of Rooney. How I harboured dreams of the new Dixie ripping PL defences apart once he'd matured and a team had been built around him. Only 2 years later he was gone! All those dreams shattered and made worse by the disgusting way in which our club was ripped off - £70m for Ronaldo, £23m in instalments, a second hand Astra, an incomplete set of Bird watchers monthlies and a bag of marbles for the greatest player in the last 30 years - by a filthy Scheister and a bent family. We believed in him because we mistakenly thought he was one of us. For all the adulation, the years of nurturing his ability and the protection over his personal sexual habits, the club he claimed to love were nothing but a vehicle to obscene riches. Never mind his best years, we never even had his teenage years. Reds fans vilified Owen when he left but after eight years and numerous trophies, and being a boyhood blue, who could blame him for moving abroad? With us, we had to suffer the badge kissing indignities every season as he could only move 35 miles down the road to rub our noses in it. No, for me there will never be any thawing of the contempt I hold for that greedy little slimeball and if he ever returned to Everton, I would sooner become a Marine, or Southport or Tranmere fan than give him any of the support he so gladly spat on 7 years ago
Phil Bellis
23 Posted 31/10/2011 at 12:54:40
C'mon Dave, do you really think we'd have been singing Moyesy's name if Zamora had've tapped it in?

Be honest, now.
Dave Wilson
24 Posted 31/10/2011 at 14:20:16
Of course they wouldnt Phil, but like I said to Robbie, it works both ways, do you really think Moyes would be getting so much stick if either of Baines free kicks against QPR or Man U where an inch lower. or Balotelli`s shot didnt take a poxy deflection, or . . .
Phil Bellis
25 Posted 31/10/2011 at 14:38:55
Depends on your expectations, Dave, illogically, unrealistally I'm still old -school NSNO
I just wish Moyes would revert to the bullish, optimistic manager he used to be; look at his demeanour - he appears ground down by the lack of help and hope from this useless Board but trapped in a thankless job by his massive salary (it's a hard life)
David Bridge
27 Posted 31/10/2011 at 20:44:51
Thomas #9
Rooney will NEVER be welcomed back at Goodison he has had his best years and constantly doesnt borther to turn up now. At Goodison on Sat he couldnt get near the ball and was completely ineffective.

he will stay at UTD and continue to win things (mostly by fluke)
Peter Laing
28 Posted 31/10/2011 at 21:08:01
David Bridge @26 your comments regarding Rooney not getting near the ball are way off the mark. From where I was watching Rooney never got out off first gear, he never broke sweat and sat in a Carsley-esque position spraying the ball around. My honest opinion is that he no longer wants to play against Everton, on Saturday he went through the motions and was only momentarily interested when Barkley came on and he got a little dig into Ross which I knew he would. I hated Rooney more than most but these days to be honest I am so sick of following Everton because we are shite that I would have him back in a blue shirt in a heartbeat - rationale because we would instantly become a better team.
David Hallwood
29 Posted 31/10/2011 at 21:02:12
There is a fundamental difference being a football supporter/fan and being a professional footballer, and there are loads of Evertonians, that can't get their heads round it.

Go back 25 years and Kendall calls Sharpie into his office and says that he's received an offer from Man U and he's accepted it, what would Sharpie's reaction be? Probably to say boss have I done something wrong, because we were winning things and involved in Europe (and don't forget at the time Man U weren't) and good footballers are ambitious and want to test themselves at the highest level.

Fast Forward to 2004 and Everton are perennial relegation fodder and you are a young 17 yo with the world at your feet, you're on a pre-season tour with your boyhood club in the states and at some games they cannot muster a full bench-Then Man U come knocking, the most successful club of the prem era. What would you do?

I posted this before on TW, don't blame Rooney, blame the stewardship of this club, that took us from champions to relegation fodder in less than 6 years, that gave Rooney, Lescott and Arteta no other option but to move to further their careers.

It is a journey that many footballers have travelled to move from a small club with little or no chance of winning silverware to a bigger club. The trouble is that at one time we were the destination not the departure platform; it is that fact which we can't or don't want to accept
Trevor Mackie
30 Posted 31/10/2011 at 21:35:34
After hearing SAF's prickly comments about reducing the amount of opposition chances and seeing Rooney in midfield I swear he used the everton game as practice for his defence.

Lets face it - good heading practice from the "mixer ball" so favoured by the genius that is Moyes
Jon Cox
31 Posted 31/10/2011 at 22:00:04
When Rooney plays agains us his body language on the pitch gives it away. He's so quiet he may as well not be there.

For those who have never seen this they never will. For those who have it shines like a nuclear weapon.

Whatever you may think of the guy he still loves his boyhood team.
David Hallwood
32 Posted 31/10/2011 at 22:23:53
Jon Cox#30 I think that as well, he always looks like he doesn't want to be there-probably seeing things that ain't there
Eddy Bernard
33 Posted 31/10/2011 at 22:28:07
Jon Cox @30 I,m a believer too. Rooney only ever looks half interested at most when he plays at Goodison. I for one wouldnt have a problem with seeing him in an Everton shirt again and the sooner the better for me.

I,m pretty sure the hatred some fans still feel for him would soon evaporate when they saw him slotting the winner past the RS at Goodison or better still across the park.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads