Moyes one of the Best in the World!

, 2 November, 141comments  |  Jump to most recent
In the build-up to another early match next Saturday for Everton at Newcastle, their manager Alan Pardew has proclaimed David Moyes to be one of the best in the world.

?We are playing against an Everton side on Saturday who have some good players and a manager who is one of the best in the world.

?If we can get through that game — even get a point — and get to Manchester City unbeaten that would be fantastic."

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Daily Post



Reader Comments (141)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dave Lynch
1 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:16:57
Speechless.......
Nick Entwistle
2 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:18:31
Well, name all the better managers in the Premiership. There's not many.

And no ones allowed to say there's 15 of them!
Dave Rice
3 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:28:12
What absolute nonsense - there are at least 20 fellas who post on here that are far better than Moyes.

They've identified him as "tactially naive", deliberates too long over player acqusitions, plays players in the wrong positions, doesn't motivate, develops and implements poor strategies, is overtly negative - the list goes on.

MOYES OUT!!!

And one of the legion of experts from here IN!!!
Andrew Laird
4 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:38:36
Mutual appreciation club, I can imagine them under the tunnel doing their freemasonesque handshake.

Lets face it, there are millions of football clubs and Moyes is managing Everton in the Premier league, although I cringe at most teamsheets and performances, the statement, on the that basis is probably correct.
Mike Keating
5 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:49:46
Managers often pay pre match respects to Moyse and then give us a good stuffing. Villas Boas was the last to do it - with 10 men.
James Stewart
6 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:58:49
Whats the odds on Ba to net a hat trick again? Not paying him what he wanted looks pretty stupid now while we are paying Saha 65k p/w and another 15-20k splashed on mcfadden now. World class my arse!
Richard Reeves
7 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:50:18
I think Mr Pardew is getting a little excited with the position they find themselves in the league. Managers always heap praise on other managers when things are going well but this one's a cracker.
Brendan McLaughlin
8 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:56:22
Looks as if David Moyes isn't the only manager who "indulges" in defeatism and damage limitation before games.
Gerry Quinn
9 Posted 02/11/2011 at 14:28:45
Bet we still finish above them...........did I just think that or say it? OMG
Denis Richardson
10 Posted 02/11/2011 at 15:05:43
Usual back slapping stuff between managers before every game, nothing new here, move on.
Neil Pickering
11 Posted 02/11/2011 at 15:19:27
Living proof that using crystal meth does serious damage to your thought processes.


Cheered me up though!
Ian Tunstead
12 Posted 02/11/2011 at 15:40:32
Managers usually have a kind word for the opposition manager but it will usually be an honest comment as well. He could have just said Moyes is a good manager who has done a great job but instead he decided to say Moyes is one of the best managers in the world so I imagine he believes it. He would be right in thinking it as well.
David Mathieson
13 Posted 02/11/2011 at 15:46:42
This reminds me Tim Cahill's comments about Sam Allardyce.

Tony J Williams
14 Posted 02/11/2011 at 15:46:39
By definition, because he IS a manager, he has to be ONE of the best in the world. Doesn't say which end of the spectrum he means though. (Also one of the worst by default too because he isn't top)
Nelly Verdonghan
15 Posted 02/11/2011 at 15:50:51
He had got to be fuckin kidding!!!
Elaine Riding
16 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:03:43
The quote is a single word short..
The missing word is 'PAID'...

The quote actually said ' Moyes is one of the best paid managers in the world'..
All makes sense now eh ?
Ciarán McGlone
17 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:09:22
Well... he's hardy gonna say that he's still doing 'positioning for corners 101' - and he's twice failed 'don't bring a right back on when losing a game 101'... is he now?

Nothing to see.
Paul Foster
18 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:10:14
#3 David Rice

Cracking post.
Dave Wilson
19 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:25:27
No wonder the EPL is so shite.

Every team in it is managed by an apologist
James McPherson
20 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:29:34
Anaesthetic comes in many forms.

He's putting Moyes to sleep.

Sadly this once hungry ambitious manager turned donkley will happily buy it.

All so very cosy - that's the problem.
Luke O'Farrell
21 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:37:46
He's a good manager but 'one of the best in the world'; no chance.

Although it was Pardew who said it and he does tend to talk rubbish, constantly.
Brian Waring
22 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:50:42
Dave, do you think he is one of the best managers in the world?
Kevin Elliott
23 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:54:50
This takes me back many years to when a reporter asked John Lennon if he thought Ringo was the best drummer in the world. To which he replied, "He's not even the best drummer in The Beatles".
Dan Brierley
24 Posted 02/11/2011 at 16:52:18
I am surprised that all clubs aren't now sending their scouts to pick out new managers from this very website, as there are plenty of people here that apparently not only know how to run the club better than the current board, but can also do a better job than David Moyes.

And you know what, they are better than every manager that has ever existed. Because they know who is the best for each position, without even needing to see them train or even knowing their physical condition. They have even come up with a bonafide solution to all our problems by themselves: playing a 4-4-2 formation will automatically win every game regardless of the opposition. And if you cant play that formation for whatever reason, including Ross Barkley in the line up also results in an automatic win. If only dithering Davey could use this website as a basis for his information, we would have already won the Champions League more times than the kopites...



Brian Waring
25 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:11:20
Come on Dan, its an opinion by Pardew, people are just questioning him saying Moyes is one of the best managers in the world.

Do you think he is?
Trevor Mackie
26 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:09:05
Self serving tosh.

If Moyes qualifies for such status what does that make Pardew lording it over him in 3rd?

Enjoy your moment in the sun Pardew.
Mike Keating
27 Posted 02/11/2011 at 13:49:46
Managers often pay pre-match respects to Moyes and then give us a good stuffing. Villas Boas was the last to do it - with 10 men.
Mike Keating
28 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:18:34
Sorry
was trying to escape from this dungeon of doom and clicked the wrong button as usual
Ian Tunstead
29 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:19:15
Brain, if the PL is the one of the best leagues in the world (many would say the best) and David Moyes has for 10 years consistantly finished in the top 8 with his hands tied behind his back for much of the time, then Pardew could argue that Moyes is one of the best managers in the world.

The thing is its not just Pardew is it? It was the Chelsea manager saying similar things the other week and most of pundits and media have been saying it for years nearly every week. Even coaches from other teams are taking less money to send their youth to Moyes like George Green who should have gone to Spurs because they have more faith in Moyes to get the most out of a player.
Wayne Smyth
30 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:31:45
Its partly psychology, part being (4 years)out of touch and part the knowledge that managers shouldn't bad-mouth each other....not many managers issue negative comments about their peers, after all. Glass houses and all.

If Newcastle loses, Pardew doesn't look such an idiot.
If Newcastle wins, Pardew looks great for beating such a legend.

Meanwhile Moyes is getting more positive feedback confirming his genius status and becomes more likely to continue with 1 striker, sideways passing and many of his team played out of position.

I wouldn't be surprised if every manager who plays us tells us what a fantastic manager Moyes is before the game, then proceeds to beat us and walks off with their 3 pts.
James McPherson
31 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:39:40
Credit where credit is due. In his time at Everton, Moyes has demonstrated his ability to get the team to perform greater than the sum of all its parts. Through fire in his belly and sheer determination he did build a derserved reputation. This has to be acknowledged. Anybody on here saying otherwise is disingenouous.

My point is that the fire has gone. Moyes is stale in himself and this manifests itself on the pitch. The turgid displays are reflective of a manager who is coasting - coasting in the safe knowledge that he is bullet-proof.

He is now living on his reputation rather than building it further.

Surely that's clear for all to see.
Trevor Mackie
32 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:32:35
Ian

The problem with ignoring circumstance is you can extrapolate anything.

Prince Philip is adorned with medals.

My grandad was one of the last off Dunkirk, building a raft with his mate to get out to sea after blowing up the oil dumps and ammo.

When he died about 6 medals adorned his coffin.

Therfore Prince Philip is a better serviceman than my dear departed grandad or any other unknown front line soldier.

Somewhere, as we speak there is another young Wenger or Mourinho, probably loads of 'em - they just can't get a break.
Conor Skelly
33 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:31:52
Have I missed something over the past several years ?!

Everton are in ruins at boardroom level. We haven't had a transfer budget in years and are competing in a league where the extreme opposite is the case with all of our competitors(top 8 teams). The only way we can buy is if Moyes takes a donkey like Jags from a relegated Sheff Utd, makes something out of him to sell at a huge profit to give us some spends to buy players in other areas or give to the bank to keep the club going full stop. If it wasn't for Davy's skill in this area alone we would surely have been relegated by now or worse.

Moyes may not be the perfect manager as his team selections are sometimes confusing but he's a damn good one and yes I would say relative to what he has to work with ~one of the best in the world.

Look at how many top class players Everton have signed in those years and look how many we have sold. Lescott, Arteta and Graveson were not top class when we bought them. Same goes for Baines and Jags. Moyes has done well in spite of Everton and not because of Everton. Its not like the old days when a full house on a Saturday and a few mill gave you enough to compete.

Our grievances should lie with Peter Johnson and perhaps Sky because lets be honest lads, We've been shite for years. The last big name signing we made by the way was KanKan in 95'. people need to get a grip and hope that Moyes gets money. I think if he even had Arry's transfer budget we would win the league, and the rest.
Conor Skelly
34 Posted 02/11/2011 at 18:03:05
James @ 30. Bang on. A great manager being suffocated by an average club.
Wayne Smyth
35 Posted 02/11/2011 at 17:41:26
Ian, as regards George Green and other young players:

Coming to Everton probably has more to do with the fact that we have a threadbare squad meaning young George will be in and around the first team in a couple of years, rather than go to spurs and sit behind 40 established premier league players, never to get a lookin.

Looking at who would qualify as one of the best managers in the world, perhaps Arsene Wenger who has only spent £500k per year more than Moyes over the last decade on transfers, yet consistently finished top 4 and has won the premier league and cups while maintaining a young squad and playing attractive football.

Or Alex Ferguson who has dominated the british game for nearly 30 years. And even when spending significantly less than City, Spurs, Chelsea or the RS over the last 10 years has managed to stay ahead of all of them.

David Moyes who once finished fourth, but generally is only able to get the best out of his side for 3 months of the year, has no trophies to his name and whose side plays some of the worst football I have ever seen from a professional side....well he is a decent manager, but he has far too many failings to be called great.
Brian Keating
36 Posted 02/11/2011 at 18:35:47
Wayne Smith, are you having a laugh? Man Utd have not been spent "significantly less" than Spurs, Liverpool or even Chelsea. They have been outspent by City, fair enough.

Up to City hitting the Arab Jackpot Alex Ferguson could compete with anyone in the Premiership and definatly outspent Liverpool, Arsenal, Spurs and the rest over the last 10 years.
Mike Berry
37 Posted 02/11/2011 at 18:50:27
This is the same manager - who shows no imagination and safety first tactics every match. Plays people out of position - ie. Biy. Plays with one striker.......
Jimmy Kelly
38 Posted 02/11/2011 at 18:55:00
I'm going to keep saying it until you finally get it through your hate addled heads.
I would love to accuse all of you who say it of not knowing anything about football but of all the hateful insults that are allowed on here, that one is barred.

Bily is not playing out of position, he has spent virtually his entire career playing on the left - i've seen him play there - live - for Lokomotiv a number of times, i've posted links on this site to articles showing that he was played on the left for his club before he came here, and when he signed he was described by Moyes, Hiddink and numerous journalists as a left sided player. But you like to base your assertions on a few 20 minute run outs for Russia.

Bad signing? Yes
Waste of money? Absolutely
Worth giving a chance behind a striker? Maybe
Out of position? NO!!!!!!!!!
James McPherson
39 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:04:51
Jimmy @ 38, hear what you say and respect your view.

However, can I ask you a couple of simple questions.

When you hear Moyes repeatedly churn out the acknowledged gulf in spending and the effects upon Everton as a pre-cursor to any forthcoming game do you not have a sense of him creating massive negativity prior to any player crossing the white line?

Also, given that he endlessly goes on about the gulf in spending and given that he is a man you admire, at what stage does your respect for him diminish if he does not cut loose and go to a club that will fulfil his ambition?



Nick Entwistle
40 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:01:09
Safety first and lack of imagination has always been successful in football. Catenaccio and all that. Trappatoni, George Graham, Ottmar Hitzweld, Sacchi. Moyes - February through April every year...
David Mathieson
42 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:35:56
Nick the names you put Moyes amongst is laughable; all the rest have won trophies and worked at the highest level of the game.

People can talk Moyes up all they want be he will never be a great or even be remembered for anything of note.

John Ford
43 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:27:52
James Mc

Moyes is right to highlight the gulf in opportunity (money - thats what it amounts to). Our shitty media, particularly the beeb and Sky do their best to ignore this taboo because it ruins the myth that somehow the premier league is competitive, which would spoil their party.

I agree though that combined with his recent glumness this represents a change to his old determined self. I really hope he can snap out of it but I fear he knows what many of us suspect, that the current squad just wont give him the league success (relative) that he's provided in recent years.

Id love nothing more than to see his prickly temperament once again giving the cliche'd media something to think about.
Nick Entwistle
44 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:42:19
Well, that's the obvious followed by conjecture. Not sure what to say.
Nick Entwistle
45 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:44:42
To David that is.
David Mathieson
46 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:44:11
Moyes' names belongs amongst Sam Allardyce and Curbishley: Bolton in the Europa League and Charlton up in 7th.br />
David Mathieson
47 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:55:35
If you use some of the logic on here Bolton got into the top 6, Bolton, a tiny club so when they finished in the top 6 because the English League is one of the best in the world Allardyce was one of the best managers in the world.

HIs style of football may not be the best but "Trappatoni, George Graham, Ottmar Hitzweld, Sacch" They all used the same.
Robbie Muldoon
48 Posted 02/11/2011 at 19:55:20
Fuck off Pardew, is somebody in the top four or what!?

What a load of patronising shite. A manager who has won fuck all during his time as a manager is one of the best in the world, yer right!
Tony J Williams
49 Posted 02/11/2011 at 20:01:36
Robbie, he is the same prick who said his West Ham side gave us a footballing lesson when they fluked a 2-1 win against us with a deflected goal.
Peter Fearon
50 Posted 02/11/2011 at 20:00:43
If I said someone was one of the best strikers in the world and yet had never scored a goal in top flight football you would say I'd been huffing the freon from the fridge. Yet it supposedly makes sense to claim that a manager who has never won anything in top flight football - indeed rejects most opportunities to advance in the major knock-out competitions - is one of the best managers in the world! How is that even remotely possible? He is a moderately talented manager who had a few good years at Everton and is now struggling to have one original idea. Even those who want him to stay can't claim much more than that.
James McPherson
51 Posted 02/11/2011 at 20:06:46
I agree Peter.

He's spent.

From my perspective, my anger is that he protests about the situation but will quite happily stay on board and take the money with zero expectation.

Dissappointing as I had him down for someone with more about him than that.

Robbie Muldoon
52 Posted 02/11/2011 at 20:07:35
Is it not possible that managers can be like football player? By this I mean, a striker is a striker and a defender a defender. A quality striker makes a shite defender by logic. So with managers can they be split into different types? I'd put money on Moyes to do a job with any club struggling for Premiership survival, he could turn them round. But definitely not capable of crafting a winning side.
Sean Patton
53 Posted 02/11/2011 at 20:18:32
Tony @ 48

I remember that game and that quote afterwards
"Everton are a club i respect a lot but we gave them a football lesson tonight"

Moyes took exception to these comments after the match and i always thought there was tension between him and Moyes,so I would think with his latest utterances he is taking the piss a bit but it will backfire as we will turn them over on on Saturday.
Brian Waring
54 Posted 02/11/2011 at 20:33:39
Gordon Lee must have been a world class manager as well.
David Bridge
55 Posted 02/11/2011 at 21:09:32
How come its only the people who watch Moyes week in and week out who actually acknowledge he is shite!

Others such as Lineka, Hansen, Pardew, Fergie etc etc who base their views on us getting into Europe in the past really cant see the wood for the trees.

It would be like saying -

Bring one of the best Premisership managers - Steve Keane IN
(based on the fact Blackburn play good footy according to the highlights on MOTD)
Dennis Stevens
56 Posted 02/11/2011 at 21:08:47
It's surprising that one of the best managers in the world, who is so highly thought of by his fellow professionals, isn't sought after by the world's top clubs.
John Daley
57 Posted 02/11/2011 at 21:36:29
"How come its only the people who watch Moyes week in and week out who actually acknowledge he is shite!"

To be fair, have you ever heard any manager come out and accuse another manager of being absolute shite? It's just not 'the done thing'.The done thing is to slap each other on the back and pay mutual homage. They always praise eachother and back each other up. Only last week we were being told by those from the football inner circle how disgusting it is that unhappy supporters are slagging off Steve Kean and Mick Mcarthy when they're both 'fantastic' managers. Oh, and Neil Warnock was being bigged up by slackjawed 'Arry as a top contender for the England job. It's a load of bollocks.
John Maxwell
58 Posted 02/11/2011 at 22:09:21
I'm suprised not to here on this site "Pardew for Everton" from our Moyes haters ?

We've been through Holloway, Coyle, Di Matteo etc, thought it was only a matter of time as they are in 3rd so he must be better than what we have right ?
Ian Edwards
59 Posted 02/11/2011 at 22:18:31
If Moyes was in charge of Newcastle then I suspect Demba Ba, Leon Best and Ameobi would be on the bench and he would be playing Peter Lovenkrands up front on his own with a midfield player just behind.
Ryan Holroyd
60 Posted 02/11/2011 at 22:29:58
John Maxwell

Don't forgot Nigel Clough as someone mentioned on here some weeks ago!!!
Trevor Mackie
61 Posted 02/11/2011 at 22:43:03
Thought you apologists were always asking "who'd do a better job?".

Seems you keep a list after all.
Jimmy Sørheim
62 Posted 02/11/2011 at 22:24:42
Why bother? We all know the truth. Moyes is NOT the greatest or among the greatest in the world, far from it. This saliva bullshit makes me wanna throw up. You can feel and see the tunge of Pardew between Moyess butt cheeks. It is disgusting. Anyone who agrees with Pardew just shows that they have no real ambition for this club, not now, not ever. It is as simple as that. Luckily the majority knows the real truth about how poor Moyes has become over the last few years.

I am just waiting for enough fans to rise up and make a big fans unrest so that Kenwrights hands will be forced into action. It will not be long now, there is just so much shit a fan can take in at once, and we have been overfed with crap for the last year or so.

I ask myself, what will it take for the doubters to say that Moyes must go? When we fight relegation in the Championship with Crystal Palace? I find much comfort knowing and reading all the Everton fans here who see Moyes for what he has become. But it will be no comfort when we will get relegated because that is the next step, we were very close last year, but at least we had Arteta, Beckford and Yakubu then, we dont have them know.

Do the math, so far our top scorer is Vellios with 2 goals, Saha has played much more but only hit one goal this far. Last season he went until January until he scored. We just can't afford to gamble on Saha alone anymore. He is not up for it. Knowing is not enough, we must do. Knowing what you all know, what will YOU do?
Tommy Gibbons
63 Posted 02/11/2011 at 23:09:15
Moyes has outlived his usefulness; if we do get taken over, it may look a little unfair if Moyes was sacked before having a go with some money behind him, but if he's 'world class' he'll get another club soon enough. And we'll get a proper 'world class' manager like Carlo Ancelloti or Gus Hiddink.
Jamie Sweet
64 Posted 02/11/2011 at 23:27:57
He is definitely one of the best managers in the world called David. I can think of few better.

That's about as much praise as I could possibly muster.

You could also replace the word "best" with "most boring" and you wouldn't be far from the truth.
Ian Tunstead
65 Posted 03/11/2011 at 00:59:21
Nobody has said Moyes is a great manager, why do people twist things? Some people have said it could be argued that he is one of the best managers in the world, there is a difference. Great shouldn?t be used so loosely.

Trevor, I keep a list for amusement of the managers mentioned on here as better than Moyes so I can observe their ?success? and watch them finish above Moyes only to find that they are relegated or sacked within a year of being mentioned on ToffeeWeb by the experts.
Gavin Ramejkis
66 Posted 03/11/2011 at 06:16:18
Ian and right back at you, I'm sure there are many equally as amusing lists create by the apologista. Semantics over great manager but you earlier agreed with the "one of the best managers in the world" tag which is simply not true; he hasn't won a thing besides some back slapping meaningless LMAs and you yourself claimed the EPL is the best league in the world when only last season the world watched Barcelona take the best of this best league in the world apart as if it was a sunday league side.

Don't believe the hype, don't believe the cringeworthy media claims and as daft as the claims of best or worst manager in the world are Moyes appears to be a once decent manager who seems to be on the wane, whether thats because he is simply getting worse, the football world is evolving and he isn't or he has simply become complacent and given up are all conjecture. He isn't even the manager he was five years ago
Thomas Windsor
67 Posted 03/11/2011 at 10:07:58
Just watched Everton v Bayern Munich, 1985... Thank fuck for DVDs!

I wonder if we will beat rapid in the final? That's what my life is like now, thanks Bill and Dave.
Nelly Verdonghan
68 Posted 03/11/2011 at 10:25:03
Let's not forget he couldn't even win the big games whilst at Preston...

Got to plenty of League 1 play-off finals... but NEVER won one!
David Hallwood
69 Posted 03/11/2011 at 11:30:32
Wayne Smith #35, when people come on here saying the Wenger's spent this and Fegie's spent that, always factor into the equation wages. For instance when Arsenal signed Arshavin he was reportedly on £80k pw, and that's £5k more than Arteta, our highest paid player.

Players are only interested in wages and we don't pay high enough to attract the really good player who know they can double their wages elsewhere.
Tony J Williams
70 Posted 03/11/2011 at 11:49:56
Also David, when Wenger sells, he gets top dollar because his players are far better and are usually sought after by the top sides and therefore his outgoings are easily matched by his incomings
Ian Tunstead
71 Posted 03/11/2011 at 14:24:36
Gavin, So what if Moyes hasnt won anything, Moyes could probably go to Celtic and be as successfull as Smith at Rangers or go to the Dutch league like McClaren and Jol and look like the next SAF. Even the chelsea manager had a much easir time in Portugal. It is far more difficult to finish in the top 6 in England than to win the league or trophy in any other country. 5 or 6 teams in the PL are good enough to reach the latter stages of the CL probably only 3 or 4 in the Spanish league are good enough.

The Spanish league is more like the Scottish league, Barcelona and Madrid might be 2 of the best teams in Europe but taking into account all teams from the prem and the spanish league i think the prem is stronger overall
Gavin Ramejkis
72 Posted 03/11/2011 at 14:48:40
Ian, you are talking gibberish, the Scottish Pub League? When did a team from there last win a major trophy? When did a Scottish team last win the CL? When did a Spanish team last win the CL and then look at the two leagues and ask yourself how many teams from Spain have won the CL and how many teams from the SPL have.

The EPL is a fucking joke, two teams regularly carve up the title, followed by three or four teams for the remaining chance to gain entry to the CL and the dregs fall off the banquet table for the Thursday night cup. The EPL simply isn't even worthy of a lot of European games from various leagues which offer much more appealing football to watch, the media brainwashing is in full swing, the EPL isn't the best league in the world no matter how much bullshit Sky want to market it as.

Being the "best of the rest" doesn't by a country mile make you one of the best in the world or you'd have one of these teams winning trophies, remind me again how many trophies Moyes has won?
Brian Waring
73 Posted 03/11/2011 at 15:33:45
There must be some truth in it though, because of the queue of clubs from all over the world trying to snap him up, oh hang on...........

Well maybe it's because of the queue of clubs from all over Europe chasing him, oh hang on..........

Maybe it's because of all the prem clubs trying to lure him away, oh hang on.........
Dave Lynch
74 Posted 03/11/2011 at 15:58:21
Ian.
Remind me again, who knocked us out of the champs league qualifying stages ?
Which Romanina side battered us ?
Was it Benfica who made us look totally out of our depth ?
For every game you Moyes-ites like to quote, the bottom line is this.
When it matters he fucks up !
Dave Wilson
75 Posted 03/11/2011 at 15:50:23
I`m completely won over here.

The couple of Dozen Moyes detractors were already putting up a far more convincing argument than all Match goers who chant Moyes`s name

Pardue may be the latest in a very very long line of premiership managers dating back nearly a decade to sing Moyes`s Praises . .but what do they know ?

For me the turning point in the debate came around post #60 when Mr Mackie left the arguments of the Moyes supporters in absolute tatters.

His blindingly insightful and highly original "You Apologist" made me realise the 0.02% had been right all along

Moyes . .err out
Brian Waring
76 Posted 03/11/2011 at 16:53:58
Dave, he's a good manager, who gets the best out of what he has, but he has a fair few faults.

But its gone a bit silly when we have lads agreeing with Pardew that he is one of the best managers in the world.
Brendan McLaughlin
77 Posted 03/11/2011 at 17:20:02
WOW! Brian #74
"..a good manager, who gets the best out of what he has" High praise indeed!
Stephen Kenny
78 Posted 03/11/2011 at 17:13:13
I've slated Moyes for saying this type of thing and no doubt a few Geordies will slate thier boss.

I think while wrong, it's clear he's trying to manage his own fan's ambitions, knowing as we all do how quickly a Geordie imagination can run wild!!!

99.99% of people got into the football industry by having a God-given talent and usually a strong mentality to go with it. The vast majority of present day managers and coaches were once players, though theres a few exceptions.

It does not mean they understand the game any better than me or you. In many cases after listening to a fair few "pundits" I wonder if we're watching the same game at times.

To assume they all know something we don't or theres some secret formula is nonsense. Anybody who's managed a group and been managed themselves will most likely understand the difference between a good and a poor man-manager. The traits are always similar in all walks of life.

Likewise a great understanding of the game is not exclusive to great players, or even just players. Mourinho and Wenger have never played anywhere near the highest level, yet it would be hard to argue a case against both being tactically astute and understanding the game.

I'm not saying I'm a tactical genius but I understand the game as do the majority of us on here, what differs is our outlook and what we expect to see. I.e. how many you bring back for corners.

I believe this squad has the potential to beat the majority in this league and do well by playing good football with an attacking bias, not gung ho football. Moyes believes otherwise and sets them up to boot, despite the fact we haven't kept a run of clean sheets for god knows how long?

He selects players seemingly regardless of form that sometimes results in defeats, but if anybody disagrees we can never go back and play the game again so who's to say who was right?

I don't value any pundits opinion about all things EFC any higher that that of Trevor, Dave, Lyndon or anybody else's.

One last thing, I go the match with a fella who's like Tony Marsh's lovechild. He constantly bemoans Moyes decisions. A few weeks ago the Gwladys were singing his name and next to me my mate was belting it out at the top of his voice. His explanation "If the Gwladys are singin, I'm singin". Doesn't mean they are all happy as larry with Moyes.
Stephen Kenny
79 Posted 03/11/2011 at 17:34:21
Ian,

"Even the chelsea manager had a much easir time in Portugal. It is far more difficult to finish in the top 6 in England than to win the league or trophy in any other country"

Would you care to hazard a guess why Chelsea didn't go for Moyes over Villas-boas if the above is true?
Oliver Molloy
80 Posted 03/11/2011 at 17:45:19
I fully expect us to beat Newcastle and collect 3 points on Saturday.

COYB.
Wayne Smyth
81 Posted 03/11/2011 at 18:45:17
Brian Keating (36), yes Alex Ferguson has been outspent by Chelsea, Man City, RS and Spurs in the last 10 years:

http://www.sportingintelligence.com/2011/08/12/arsenals-net-spending-of-48m-in-a-decade-puts-them-9th-in-premier-league-120802/

Care to provide your source which shows I'm talking bollocks? Certainly the £80M Man U received for Ronaldo skews things, but then Moyes also received £40M-£50M for two players he spent about £5M on.

Ferguson (like Wenger) is a great manager and can be considered "one of the best in the world" because he is consistently winning and challenging at the very top in England and Europe, while spending less than his peers. His sides play attractive football to boot.

The money argument has shown to not be the be-all-and-end-all Moyes likes to portray it as. Both Wenger and Ferguson have done far better than their net spend warranted.
Wayne Smyth
82 Posted 03/11/2011 at 18:59:38
As others have alluded to, whatever our opinions, and whatever managers say publicly, what clubs DO is a more important indicator as to how highly they think of a coach.

The day Moyes is employed by a moneyed/successful club is the day we can see what people in the footballing world actually think of his abilities.

Kenwright wants to hold on to his trainset too much to get rid of a manager who is happy to take his £70k / week in return for not rocking the boat.
Jamie Barlow
83 Posted 03/11/2011 at 19:01:44
Trevor, you recently said on here that you don't use the term 'apologist'. It seems to have become one of your favorites lately. Broken record.
Trevor Mackie
84 Posted 03/11/2011 at 19:18:20
Jamie

Fair comment.

When they come on agreeing with all his faults then start making excuses it comes over as apologising.
IMO his excuses ran out the beginning of last season and what a shambles that was rolling on to this season.
The latest fashion is point to "best of the rest" seasons as entirely justifying his anti football - halcyon days almost.

Completely wrong, his non management has led directly to the shite we're in. The tide is clearly turning people now openly say he should go and I'm afraid the remaining apologists seem more concerned in supporting their personal point of view rather than the club.

People realise another 10 yrs like this is a death sentence, as a bare minimum we should we get back to playing football.

I call them apologists because they deserve it and I urge all like minded blues to do the same.
Rob Hollis
85 Posted 03/11/2011 at 21:01:54
David Moyes is a fantastic manager, all the stats will tell you that. As long as you ignore the honours bit.

I did think he was really good when we came fourth. I thought 'this is finally it' when we had Landon Donovan. it's just that most of the time at the game I don't thank the Lord we have got him.

But what do we simple souls know. A lot of people on here think it is too complex to be understood by mere mortals. I expect they also think we should not vote for a governent
Rob Hollis
86 Posted 03/11/2011 at 21:19:37
Pressed send correcting the final word!
Brendan McLaughlin
87 Posted 03/11/2011 at 22:34:33
Trevor # 83
When "they" come on...you mean your fellow Everton supporters?
David Bridge
88 Posted 03/11/2011 at 22:42:17
Brendan, support of Everton doesnt have to include a support of Moyes or BK... in fact, it should mean the complete opposite.

MOYES OUT!!!
Brendan McLaughlin
89 Posted 03/11/2011 at 22:46:27
Dave that's your opinion and as a fellow blue I respect it... that's why I unlike Trevor don't refer to you as one of "those people".
Ian Tunstead
90 Posted 03/11/2011 at 23:59:17
Gavin

Don?t act stupid, you know I wasn?t comparing the Scottish league and Spanish league in terms of success, I am comparing the two leagues as regards only 2 teams are ever likely to win the league. The gap between Barcelona and Madrid and the rest of the league is similar to the gap between Rangers and Celtic and the rest of the league. The EPL is much tighter for the top 6 or 7 teams.

?The EPL is a fucking joke, two teams regularly carve up the title,? You sound like you?re talking about the Spanish or Scottish league.

As I said who cares how many trophies Moyes has won, how many have O?Neil and Smith won? Did they do better than Moyes in the PL?

Brian,

how many clubs are queuing up for any manager? I never knew anyone was after Villas-Boas until he was on the front page of the papers having signed so who?s to say there isn?t a queue of clubs after Moyes? If rumours are to be believed Newcastle wanted Moyes, Aston Villa wanted Moyes. Spurs want Moyes if Redknapp leaves, Celtic want Moyes, and there have been rumours for years linking Moyes with the Man Utd job. So there?s your argument blown out of the water.

Dave Lynch,

Villa Real knocked us out of the CL qualifiers because we were robbed by a corrupt ref who came out of retirement for the game only to retire again afterwards, then years down the line the same ref is investigated for corruption along with many of the top Italian teams. FIFA didn?t want 5 English teams in the CL.

As for the Romanian side, Everton were still shell shocked and had the stuffing knocked out of them because of the dismay of how corrupt the game is, it took half a season to recover. Benfica were a good side they gave us a good hiding but put them in the PL and they would struggle to finish in the top 6. Put the Benfica manager as manager of Everton with the same restraints as Moyes and he wouldn?t finish in the top 10.

Stephen Kenny.

Abramovich always like to go for the flavour of the month or the most fashionable manager of the moment that is why he went for Villas-Boas
Jamie Sweet
91 Posted 04/11/2011 at 00:38:42
At the end of the day, you only have to watch 90 minutes of football at Goodison to realise Moyes isn't anywhere near being one of the best managers.

The proof is in the pudding so they say.

After a few giant hoofs up to our lone striker who is surrounded by defenders and completely lacking in support - you quickly realise that we aren't being coached by a footballing genius. In fact, quite the opposite.
Robbie Shields
92 Posted 04/11/2011 at 03:48:37
Ian #89, just listen to yourself for a minute will you.....

"As I said who cares how many trophies Moyes has won"....... well I bloody well do, I spent $10,000 AUD to go to the Cup Final with my son after we emigrated to Australia, where Moyes did his normal roll over and die tactics together with crap and too late substitutions, despite being 1-0 up after 34 seconds.

"If rumours are to be believed Newcastle wanted Moyes, Aston Villa wanted Moyes. Spurs want Moyes if Redknapp leaves, Celtic want Moyes, and there have been rumours for years linking Moyes with the Man Utd job. So there?s your argument blown out of the water."..... So now rumours that teams were interested in Moyes blows that argument out of the water does it???? Are you for real??? By using that argument, there are rumours of Everton being taken over by an Indian Billionaire, so that blows all the Kenwright train set mob out of the water doesn't it, FFS.

"Villa Real knocked us out of the CL qualifiers because we were robbed by a corrupt ref"..... Oh come on, a shocking decision no doubt but corruption to keep Everton out of the CL, do me a favour, so now you're a consipracy theorist and even THAT is easier to believe than the fact that Moyes hasn't got a clue.

"As for the Romanian side, Everton were still shell shocked and had the stuffing knocked out of them because of the dismay of how corrupt the game is, it took half a season to recover"... So it was still that UEFA and nasty refs fault that WE were shite for 6 months because we felt sorry for ourselves.

"Benfica were a good side they gave us a good hiding but put them in the PL and they would struggle to finish in the top 6."... Yep you've got me there, no way could a pass and move side that attacked with pace, flair and creativity get into the top 6 in the EPL, that's only possible with hoofball init.

Is it any wonder the likes of you are labelled an "Apologist", just look at how many different ways you have apologised for Moyes there, it just NEVER is his fault is it, it's EVERYONE elses.

Truely unbelievable statements

MOYES OUT
Andrew Laird
93 Posted 04/11/2011 at 08:48:40
Here is something worth reading if you missed it 10 years ago;

www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2003/apr/06/football.newsstory

www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2003/apr/06/football.newsstory1

Ask yourselves this: Do we still have the same manager? I think it's fairly obvious he has given up.
Andrew Laird
94 Posted 04/11/2011 at 08:55:51
...... believing in himself and his team.

(that's how my last post should have ended, before I hit the submit button!)
Jonathan Tasker
95 Posted 04/11/2011 at 08:57:15
We will see tomorrow that Moyes is not even one of the best managers on Merseyside , let alone the World.

Fully expecting another show of negativity and a defeat.
Dave Wilson
96 Posted 04/11/2011 at 08:36:06
Robbie

Thousands of Evertonians couldnt get into that final because they had spent their dosh following Everton through thick and thin all season and coudnt afford the inflated black Market prices.

I assume you knew this before you deprived one of them of a seat , I assume you knew that Chelsea were superior - vastly in some cases - in just about every position on the park, even their left back was better than ours at that stage of their careers.
I assume you know that although Moyes and his team had done us proud by dismissing some of Europes bests teams on route to wembley we were missing our two most influential players against a team that had only lost to Barca in the CL due to ridiculous refereeing decision.
I assume you knew that Chelsea where the ovewhelmig favourites with the bookies ?
I assume you realised there was a very real possibilty of us losing ?

If you did know all that, why are you whining about the money you spent ? . . and if you knew all that why on earth are you still blaming Moyes for the defeat ?
And why are you complaining about late substitutions ? we made one at HT when the match was still all square.

You criticise others for making "unbelievable statements" but some of yours really take the biscuit. It was only this week you were criticising a performance that by your own admission you hadnt even seen.
On these pages in the past couple of days I`ve seen statements such as "Kenwright has money, but he wont give it to Moyes" . . . or "Moyes`s didnt really want to win"

For several reasons Moyes has pissed me off this season, not least for his ill advised comments directed towards loyal but unhappy Evertonians.
HOWEVER . . if being an "apologist" somehow distances me from this sort of inherent nosnense I will print the name, and wear it on my chest like a fucken medal of honour.
Trevor Mackie
97 Posted 04/11/2011 at 10:09:28
Dave Wilson

"I assume you knew this before you deprived one of them of a seat "

Even allowing for your infamous lack of judgement including a recent defence of name calling against "good evertonians" (your words), this is a new low.

Robbie has travelled from Australia with his boy ffs.

You're a malevolent piece of work Wilson.
Ian Tunstead
98 Posted 04/11/2011 at 09:57:20
Robbie, the point is, i am being told that Moyes isnt being linked with any other jobs but he has been linked with many. They could be rumours, fair enough, but some have seemed very credible and there is no smoke without fire.

As Dave said we lost to Chelsea not because of Moyes but because of Chelsea's millions and the fact that they had far better players.

As for the Villa Real result, whether it is a conspiracy or not, we lost due to a terrible decision by the ref. And yes, you need to realise that footballers are not robots, they are humans who have good days and bad days. Having given an unbelievable effort to to break into the top 4 only to be robbed agaisnt Villa Real i believe it had a physicological effect on them and it took them half the season to recover, it didnt help that Carsley was injured for most of the season as well because when ever he didnt play we leaked goals for fun.

And yes you are right about Benfica they wouldnt have had the chance to reach the level they were at if they were in the prem. For starters they wouldn't have had the money to keep up with top 4, secondly their best players would have been swooped on by Chelsea or Man Utd early on before they had a chance to take off and develop a team. Benfica were on a similar level to Liverpool who finish around 5th to 7th, so yes they would struggle to finish above Liverpool.
John Audsley
99 Posted 04/11/2011 at 10:17:59
Dave Wilson @ 95

"Deprived a fan of a seat"

Utter garbage, you should be ashamed of yourself mate

Muppett
David Mathieson
100 Posted 04/11/2011 at 10:19:12
Dave
?Thousands of Evertonians couldnt get into that final because they had spent their dosh following Everton through thick and thin all season and coudnt afford the inflated black Market prices.?

What a load of rubbish Everton could have easily sold tens of thousands more tickets for the Cup Final.

The main reason why thousands lost out on the Cup Final was due to the capitalist greed at the FA, selling 1/3 of the gate before the game had even kicked off, essentially it would seem there was another team at Wembley with a ticket allocation of 30000 or more also how many other tickets out of the Everton allocation of 28000 from 90000 ended up with touts?

We were given less tickets for the Final than the Semi Final also a truck load less than the allocation for the Play Off Final it was a disgrace; production for use anyone?
Dave Wilson
101 Posted 04/11/2011 at 10:20:22
Mackie

I think that honour belongs to you. You wont hear me resorting to name calling

I applaud anyone who goes to great lengths to see Everton.

but I have no sympathy at all for somebody who has done it at the expense of people who have spent thousands all season following them . .only to moan about the cost when the result doesnt work out for them.

Are you really sympathising with the guy who says he wont pay to see Moyes`s Everton again and attacks him at every opportunity only to turn up at the show piece ?

or are you just pissed because I used one of your claims as an perfect example of the nonsense me and thousands of others are trying to distance ourselves from ?
Dave Wilson
102 Posted 04/11/2011 at 10:38:20
David #99

It works like this mate; If there are no glory hunters, there is no market for the greedy.

If the thousands who saw Everton -or chelsea - for the first time that season did`nt pay hugely inflated prices to the greedy people who recieved their tickest at face value or free. then every single person who had regularly watched both teams that season would have been able to get a ticket
Trevor Mackie
103 Posted 04/11/2011 at 10:41:20
Wriggle as much as you want Wilson the "good evertonian" jibe is your baby, you see "bad evertonians" as anyone with a counter view as evident from your last posts.

Do your deluded ranting and support Moyes all you like, celebrate playing like shite aiming for "best of the rest" but it's on it's last legs no matter what bollocks you google.
Dave Rice
104 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:16:09
We should bin Moyes now and have a commitee of Toffeeweb experts replace him.

It'd be a lot cheaper for the club and we would have tactical experts on board. We'd play flair football and would attract the best players for nominal wages because they'd benefit from more than just money - they'd benefit from being coached on how to play from taxi-drivers, car mechanics and painters.

We'd play two up front, or at least we'd have two players with 9 and 10 on their backs up front, and certainly not someone who was bought as a midfielder so can never be desribed as a striker even if he's clearly playing as a striker.

We'd challenge Kenwright to get his money out, and the £100M he's clearly squirrelled away, despite there being no evidence whatsoever to substantiate this opinion, would be made available for new signing.

And we wouldn't dither in the transfer market to get these new signing - we'd lunge in, gung-ho, and damn the consequences.

Moyes OUT !!!

Toffeeweb Expert Commitee IN !!!
David Mathieson
105 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:28:36
Dave

It works like this: 30000 tickets for the FA; how many of them ended up in touts hands? This created a huge market for the greedy and ensured that regulars could not go; if Everton were awarded 40000 tickets we would have had all our season ticket holders and more, so would Chelsea .

The FA are to blame for the touts and hyper inflated prices also for the thousands of Evertonians who missed out. I agree there will always be people willing to pay over the odds and touts but this should minimised clearly this did not happen.
Dave Wilson
106 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:16:01
dont need to wriggle.

I stand by everything I have said and you wont find a post where I refer to "bad Evertonians" because I dont believe they exist.its a contradiction of terms

Your making a habbit of dreaming up things I`ve said . .I dont expect another apology though


Sam Morrison
107 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:33:17
Dave I like your posts in general but having a go at Robbie is kind of ludicrous. Is it beyond you to have a rethink on this one?

Who could honestly say to themselves, Everton are in a cup final but I'd better not go, I don't deserve to?

Brendan McLaughlin
108 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:28:35
Dave #102
Great idea Dave & the beauty is we don't even have to change our IMWT mantra....it just will read "I Manage With Toffeeweb" in future.
Of course establishing a full commiittee from 0.02% might be a bit of a problem.
Dave Wilson
109 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:32:59
David

Your are preaching to the converted. I hate the FA system.
But if the people who hadnt attended the games all season didnt offer such an obvious market by paying so much to be at the show case the touts would be out of business.


Trevor Mackie
110 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:35:45
Still wriggling Dave, you don't fool anyone and on the subject of apologies here is a perfect opportunity for you to offer one to Robbie.

I won't hold my breath you don't have the class.
David Mathieson
111 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:40:41
Dave
You have stated yourself that there will be always be a market for touts so they will never go out of business; I will reiterate:

The FA created a massive market for the touts therefore not the touts fault or the people willing to pay big bucks.

If the FA creates a little market for the touts still people willing to pay big bucks.

Surely you must understand the differentiation between the two and how this affected Evertonians and Chelsea fans.

The people in the wrong are not the people who purchased tickets at inflated prices.
Dave Wilson
112 Posted 04/11/2011 at 11:46:14
Apologise ? I stand by every word I said

BTW Trevor as another who has said he was not prepared to pay to watch Moyes`s Everton . . did you go to the cup final ?
Christine Foster
113 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:04:24
Dave Wilson, your arrogance is only matched by your self-righteousness. I now live in Australia, I get over each season to watch 6 games, home and away. I held a season ticket, every year for 28 years, indeed kept paying for one for three years after I got here and gave it to my nephew in Kirdale. But according to your logic I am not as worthy of a ticket, a seat or even a qualified comment because I do not follow to every match. I am in someway a lesser Evertonian?

Grow up.

Everton and its supporters are a broad church, once an Evertonian always an Evertonian. No one Evertonian is better than another. Not I , not you.
Dave Wilson
114 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:10:27
David

Like I say you are preaching to the converted, but I think the people who pay thes prices are wrong too. if they didnt the market would die
Two wrongs not making a right.

I live a couple of doors way from a guy who took his two young lads to nearly 50 games that season, they couldnt get tickets.

My sympathy lies with them, not the guy who doesnt have any time for Moyes and his team, but shows up for the show peice . .and is still moaning about it two years later
Dave Wilson
115 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:16:23
Christine

Read the post, I dont say anyone isnt worthy.

But I DO say that anybody who "wont pay to see Moyes`s Everton" has no right to moan when he takes the seat of a regular match goer for the final.

How is that arrogance ?
Dave Wilson
116 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:22:27
Do you know what. I`d love a poll on this and if I was shown to be wrong I would happily hold my hannds up.

I dont think many who actually read what I have said would disagree
Christine Foster
117 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:22:47
David
I read the post, your implication was clear, some are more worthy than others, you repeated the implication in your justification of who should get tickets and who shouldn't.

We all invest our time AND money, some of us CAN'T be there, so I repeat, who are you to deem who is worthy and who is a lesser Evertonian?

Your implications are clear in the statement you make as to who has a right to a ticket, a comment, an opinion. Thats arrogance
Andrew Laird
118 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:29:00
Lets start the poll then Dave Wilson. I think you are very wrong.
Dave Wilson
119 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:33:32
Christine

I`m not implying anything, I`m making a very clear statement.

imo some people DO deserve a ticket more than others.

One question : do you think a guy who refuses to pay to watch Moye`s Everton - but changes his mind when we get to a final - deserves a ticket anymore or less than my neighbour and his lads who had seen 50 games that season.

Forget the Fa allocation Christine. look at the facts the way they are and answer yes or no
Andy Crooks
120 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:42:18
Brendan, # 106, superb post.

IMWT
Ian Tunstead
121 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:38:15
Haha it's funny how when the 0.02% are losing the arguement they completely change the direction of the arguement and grab hold with both hands one point Dave Wilson made but ignore the main point he was making. Can we try to stick to the origional post about Moyes being one of the best managers in the world?
Brendan McLaughlin
122 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:43:21
And here are the results from Ireland & its a Correct for Dave Wilson. Andrew #116..thought you jumped the gun a little but now that Dave has framed the "Poll Question" @ 117...do you still think he's "very wrong"?
Tony J Williams
123 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:46:15
Andrew, I will counter your vote. I went the final but if someone had been to more games than me that season....away games, he should have gotten a seat before me.
Christine Foster
124 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:43:07
Who are YOU to judge? Or who am I?

At the end of the day it isn't equal, it isn't based on someones interpretation of whats fair, its based on who will pay.

That life, thats reality, deal with it, there will always be those who miss out.

Do I think its fair that clubs who have little or no interest in who is playing are awarded tickets? Thats a different story.
Andrew Laird
125 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:48:31
Brendan, Dave has made a statement about supporters that is not ambiguous at all. I still think he is wrong for that.

Fair enough it is his opinion so it's right in his head.

By the way, are you suggesting that you speak for an entire population as well?
Damien McKay
126 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:59:38
At least Pardew didn't say that Moyse is a World Class Coach or Tactician. He will make a great Assistant Manager one day but will never win trophy's as he does not believe in his OWN team.
Christine Foster
127 Posted 04/11/2011 at 12:58:21
Sorry Ian, not sure exactly who your refering to with a ficticious % but if anyone on any post denegrates any Evertonian because of their ability to pay, because of their opinion of who should be a more worthy Evertonian and who is a lesser one, then they deserve to be questioned.

Conversely if you want to take another slant on it, if you believe that 99.98% have the right to say who is a better supporter because they agree with you, then I refer to my earlier point made to David. Arrogance.
Christine Foster
128 Posted 04/11/2011 at 13:05:54
Because we are all allowed (thank goodness) to voice an opinion, that does not mean its right or wrong, thats why we can debate, thats why we improve.

I may disagree with your view but not the right to state it.
Andy Crooks
129 Posted 04/11/2011 at 13:13:06
If, I'd managed to get a ticket for the cup final I'd have been there like a shot. There are ,I'm sure many more "worthy" supporters but I'd be a liar to say otherwise.
John Daley
130 Posted 04/11/2011 at 13:16:50
"Can we try to stick to the origional post about Moyes being one of the best managers in the world?"

The original post wasn't about "Moyes being one of the best managers in the world". It was about Alan Pardew (Alan Pardew FFS) saying that Moyes is one of the best managers in the world. Massive difference. Unless the 'proclamations of Pardew' are now any more meaningful than the groans emanating from a boozed up bindlestiff dossing in Debenhams doorway?

Dave Wilson, I get what you're saying but I think it was the use of the word 'deprived' that caused offence initially. It makes it sound like they selfishly robbed someone elses rightful place. I ended up not being able to get tickets but did not feel that someone who did, who had been to less games than me, had 'deprived' me of anything.
Ian Tunstead
132 Posted 04/11/2011 at 13:32:24
Christine, it?s nothing to do with agreeing with me, its if you agree with Moyes.

Anyone who agrees with Moyes are constantly called apologists on toffeeweb. Its an easy term for them to use as a put down. The thing is it?s the same dozen or so people that come out with it. So 0.02% is an easy term for me and others to use for the people who disagree with Moyes and want him out.

Admittedly Its not scientifically proven that it is only 0.02% but I personally don?t know anyone who wants Moyes out and judging by the reaction of the majority of Evertonains at Goodison, it does seem to be only a very small percentage. So as long as I see apologist on this site I think we are going to see 0.02% as well.
Robbie Shields
135 Posted 04/11/2011 at 14:56:55
Firstly, I'd like to apologise for this thread having been hijacked by Dave Wilson questioning me and my son attending the Cup Final after we had emigrated to Australia, that wasn't my intention.

Secondly, I'd like to thank the Evertonians that jumped to my defense, much appreciated.

Mr Wilson, I'm afraid I can't stand by quietly and let you come out with statements such as the following.........

"One question : do you think a guy who refuses to pay to watch Moye`s Everton - but changes his mind when we get to a final - deserves a ticket anymore or less than my neighbour and his lads who had seen 50 games that season."

I've never felt the need to 'prove' my Evertonian credentials before, but unfortunately in this case I think I am compelled to set the record straight, so here goes........

Dave, I am 41 years old, my Grandad and Dad lived in Frodsham St, just off Goodison Road. They both travelled around England supporting the Mighty Blues long before I was even thought of.

I came along and then from the age of 7 was a season ticket holder with my Grandad (God rest his soul) and my Dad in the family section, which was then in the Lower Bullens for some reason, where the away section now is. Since then I've been watching the Mighty Blues all over the country, saw the wonderful 80s team and the subsequent slide to mediocrity.

Even after I moved away from the North West, first to London and then to Norwich, I continued going to as many matches as I could, home and away, probably 8 or so games a year. When my son came along I took him along to Goodison from Norwich with my Dad and brothers, he was 3 years old and loved every minute of it. Despite the 5 hour journey each way he insisted on me taking him to as many games as possible.

We travelled the country watching the Mighty Blues, we even won a lot of games early doors, mainly 1-0 wins and with a fair lump of luck, we were very happy. It was costing us over £200 to go to every home game from Norfolk, so I set up the NorfolkBlues website and arranged to pick up other Blues from the East and shared the petrol costs.

When we decided to emigrate to Australia, we saw our last golden chance of getting to Wembley and travelled down to Stamford Bridge with 10,000 other blues to roar us on. Chelsea went down to 10 men and were there for the taking; Moyes bottled it, failed to take the initiative and Chelsea got a last minute winner in the first leg, I was fuming!!!!!!!

Then came the second leg, another midweek match, this time I took half a day of work, pulled both my kids out of school, and we all went over to Goodison. Moyes bottled it again, despite the most amazing support from the Evertonians there that night, Moyes didn't go for it. Chelsea scored and broke my boy's heart, in 6 months time we would be in Australia for life.

I promised him there and then that if the Mighty Blues EVER got to a Cup Final then I would take him, he'd seen a lot of crap in the 7 years he'd been traveling the country with me and deserved to see us at Wembley IF we ever got there.

With my son and wife in tears, we said Goodbye to Goodison......... Wouldn't you believe it, the first Cup Final after we got to Australia and the Mighty Blues had done it. True to my word, we bought 2 tickets from an agency for £1,000 each (in the middle tier, you know the Club Wembley seats that are held by bond holders and not given to the clubs' supporters by the FA).

Four days were spent traveling to and from England and we had a fantastic time with our fellow blues, an amazing atmosphere and memories my son will never forget, despite a certain Mr Moyes bottling it once again.

I don't begrudge the money I spent, I loved every minute of it, my son saw the Mighty Blues at Wembley and had an experience he will never forget. If you are interested you can watch my Video of Saha's goal on YouTube

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CvTby5U1Ypg&sns=em

Did my son deserve to go the Cup Final after 7 years of traveling around the country watching the Mighty Blues? I think he did. Did other blues more deserving than us miss out? Undoubtably, but I was keeping a promise to my little blue eyed Evertonian, and he deserved to go too.
Stephen Kenny
136 Posted 04/11/2011 at 14:44:41
Ian,

Abramovich always goes for flavour of the month? Really because looking at the managers he's appointed and seeing what they have won says different.He didn't go for Moyes because he's not a winner. His appointments include european cup winners, world cup winners, treble winners and the like. Some even from them secnd rate leagues you haven't got a clue about.

You have spouted some world class garbage in this thread about certain sides and how they would get on in our league. Benfica have turned over both Man Utd and the R/S in two legged affairs over the past few years and given some other good sides a right hiding. They would finish well above any side that Moyes ever manages.

Also your nonsense about how we were robbed by a bent ref. You clearly weren't there. I was, they gave us a footballing lesson like you wouldn't believe. The "goal" would only have brought us even, they went up the other end and scored straight after, it's fair to say we had commited men forward at that point but they were a much, much, much better side than us and still are, despite not spending fortunes. Anybody who thinks we were robbed is a fool, they didn't need the ref to see us off.

Dave,

50 games? Were any of the Everton??? Really??? I think that nonsense comment suits your agenda. Thats every home and away plus the cup run and a few european games to boot and they couldn't get a ticket?

That said I do support your point that a fella who goes home and away/goes up and down the country deserves a ticket first!!!
Trevor Mackie
138 Posted 04/11/2011 at 15:02:28
Robbie

It's not even an argument about what Dave Wilson meant.

His sanctimonious almost xenophobic shite was appalling. If there's such a thing as a "little evertonian" it's him and those indulging.

Make no mistake the vast majority of Evertonians would have no truck with remarks such as these. Any potential buyer from outside the UK reading this sort of garbage would know exactly what he was getting at despite his weasle words after.

Take no notice.
Dave Wilson
140 Posted 04/11/2011 at 15:15:58
Robbie

I didn't read your "credentials"... Not interested, they count for nothing during our current plight. They do not keep our clubs head above water,

Oh and Robbie, just in case you think I`m being hypocritical; Circumstances mean I will probably have to forgo my ticket next season, I wont get to many games but like you I will still have my "credentials". I will still be passionate about Everton and I will still want my say. If Everton get to Wembley I will be as desperate as ever for us to win.

But I can guarentee I won't be taking up a seat.
Colin Wainwright
144 Posted 04/11/2011 at 16:28:32
Dave, if you had read Robbie's ''credentials'', you would have seen that he and his son didn't deprive an Evertonian of a seat. He bought Club Wembley tickets, that where never destined for Evertonians in the first place.

You can blame the system for that, but not Robbie and his lad.
David Bridge
145 Posted 04/11/2011 at 16:31:25
Dave. I agree with you in some respect but those of us who watch Everton at home and away games DID get the chance for a ticket at the final so can't really see your point.

Shows how disillusioned we are all now becoming bickering amongst ourselves ? let's get rid of MOYES get rid of BK and all move on! COYB
Ian Tunstead
146 Posted 04/11/2011 at 16:11:29
Yes Stephen, Abromovich is like a rich kid in a sweet shop, whichever manager is bigged up by the media the most during the summer, they are the ones Abromovic looks to bring in, it wouldn?t surprise me if Moyes has been Roman's 2nd or 3rd choice, or if he comes in for Moyes in the future just to get one over on Man Utd.

You are confusing my point about Benfica. The point is give the Benfica manager a job in England similar to Everton when Moyes took over and see if he could be successful without the CL money and up against sides like Man Utd Chelsea Arsenal Liverpool Man City and see where he finishes. He wouldn?t get higher than 6th.

Also whether you think we deserved to beat Villarreal or not, was the goal unfairly disallowed? Goals change games, if the goal was allowed to stand it?s a completely different story.
Stephen Kenny
149 Posted 04/11/2011 at 17:13:24
Ian,

Stop making up lies to suit your point. Abramovich is not like a kid in a sweet shop he picks proven winners to lead his team. Who the media bigs up is irrelevant.

I haven't misunderstood your point at all. You implied that Moyes was at least as good a manager as villas-boas, which clearly is nonsense.

When I asked why Chelsea didn't go for Moyes you then said Abramovich picks his managers based on the media perception?? which is it? Either way it's not true he picks them based on achievement.

Through this thread you have mentioned a load of different managers as if they can't hold a candle to Moyes yet virtually all have achieved more in the game than the man you clearly revere above all others.

If the goal stood in Villarreal (two "r"s, no space) then it still made no odds because we had been ran ragged for two games and would have been ran ragged through extra-time and probably got beat. We tried to play long ball against one of the best sides in Europe.

Only god knows how you know that the Benfica manager wouldn't be able to do what Moyes has done??? The only way I can think to compare the two is when thier respective teams faced each other. Again I was there and it weren't pretty, not from my seat anyway. Also, with regards to T.V money one of those two clubs recieves a fair bit more than the other, can you guess which one.

The cold facts are that other managers repect what he's achieved as most blues do, even me. That doesn't alter the fact that he's going backwards with us and his heart's not in it.

It's nice to see you moving the goalposts now you struggling to answer asimple questions.
Wayne Smyth
151 Posted 04/11/2011 at 17:27:18
These days, calling an Evertonian a "glory hunter" is akin to calling a starving Ethiopean a "fat, greedy bastard"....more topically, I suppose it's the same as calling Moyes "World Class".
Michael Kenrick
162 Posted 04/11/2011 at 19:37:50
"... deprived of a seat... " ? What a thoroughly obnoxious piece of judgemental shit-throwing by our Mr Wilson.

Of course he does not have the good grace to profer an apology. I should be astounded by his self-righteous blather but sadly I'm not.
Ryan Holroyd
163 Posted 04/11/2011 at 19:34:45
Jon Cox

I'll raise you:
Mikel Arteta
Joleon Lescott
Tim Cahill
Steven Pienaar
Phil Jagielka

All either in Championship or out of favour at their clubs.

Come to Everton and either sold as a profit, become international players or give great years service to the club.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads