Season › 2011-12 › News
Elstone: Genuine conversations are ongoing
Elstone insists that there has been "a constant stream of interest and dialogue" regarding takeovers and investment and that "genuine conversations" are underway with a number of individuals, groups and companies.
"The responsibility to find the right buyer is paramount," he writes, "and not an excuse for ?not really for sale' or ?wanting too much for it' or ?wanting to stay involved'," a swipe at supporters who are skeptical of the Kenwright regime's claims that it intends to step aside.
On the question of expenditure, an area that was a focal point of the Blue Union's line of questioning in their interview with Bill Kenwright this summer, Elstone says: "To get this straight again, almost 85p in every £1 we earn is spent at the training ground and academy paying the players, the coaches, the scouts, the conditioners, the medics, the support teams, team travel and accommodation along with rent and other overheads.
"What's left in the coffers, the other 15p in the £1, funds everything else. Quite simply, it doesn't allow us to waste a penny. It means we're a ?lean ship' and one of the leanest in the Premier League."
Quotes or other material sourced from Evertonfc.com
Reader Comments (68)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 08/11/2011 at 23:30:28
Just read our honest CEO's latest blag.
He throws us a bone with the Kenwright / talking to 50 investors / buyers etc, but we can't go into detail for the obvious.
Then we get the 85p in the pound shite for Finch Farm.
THEN... We get the bad news day bit, the Park End fiasco. Yes, you know the one, the one were there were IT problems delaying the development, or the other nugget about problems with the builder.
I wrote on here many times, that the real reason was because, we didn't own the land. Everton sold the idea to Kitbag and Sudexo, applied for planning permission, and received it.
Then the finance company who had a charge on the land, said, "You're not building that and putting sitting tennants into it, [i.e. Sudexo/Kitbag] in case we have to repossess it." He now admits this, after telling the club fed us three different explanations.
The banks got wind of this 12 months ago, and said, "we believed you owned that land." They then demanded we reduce our overdraft,
we sent everyone we could out on loan, sold Pienaar, Beckford, Yakubu and ultimately Arteta, to appease them and to stop them winding us up.
The truth is out there , and it's Everton who keep letting it out after denying it. Robert, hang your head in shame.
3 Posted 09/11/2011 at 01:12:59
Have to say that I am surprised we didn't own that parcel of land but hey, in the current EFC world I guess I should be more used to bad news.
It is perplexing that the land owners would not agree say a ten-year lease? That would you think be enough for the likes of Kitbag and Sodexo to recover their investment and I'm thinking that the land cannot really be used for anything else in that time frame? All very strange and disappointing.... a bit like the team being in 17th when even our limited resources have garnered a decent squad capable of so much more, albeit perhaps not top seven.
4 Posted 09/11/2011 at 02:38:50
"....genuine conversations are taking place about future ownership and future investment...".
Am I being too synical here in drawing the conclusion that all previous announcements regarding potential new owners or investors were therefore "....not genuine...".
Could this be a case of someone who normally doesn't tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, now trying to tell us something that actually is the truth.
If so, it would appear that Mr Kenwright is starting to feel the heat from the BU and "Genuinely" engaging with potential new owners.
Another point I'd like to make is that the Jain Group (Who may or may not be involved in these discussions) according to reports were introduced to Everton by the City Council, not by Mr Harris or found by Mr Kenwright whilst conducting his 24/7 search. This I believe is exactly the reason the BU wanted an independent body to search for a new owner, because the current model has not worked for x many years and showed no signs of ever working. If you want either a change of ownership or even a change in management then the pressure must be kept on through the next planned BU march. The more that attend, the greater the pressure, it has already shown to be making significant progress. My personal thanks to the BU.
5 Posted 09/11/2011 at 04:03:18
Nothing new here from Elstone, and if you expected something new then get yourself checked out. No matter how many marches, taped conversations, and email tirades - we won't be getting insight on commercial discussions. By all means push - but be realistic about what you can expect to hear.
The bottom line remains the same as it has for a while. Increase income / cut costs - to the degree that the football doesn't suffer too much. 'Too much' being a term that will differ in interpretation from person to person.
My view is that we had a nice organic growth with Moyes. Bought fairly well, sold players for decent fees, reinvested in the team. We came to a time when we had a choice - take our shot or go through the sell to buy scenario for another year. Rightly or wrongly we tried to hold onto players and took our shot. Hindsight tells us it didn't work - personally I place a massive amount of blame on Moyes for that. He just didn't know what to do with a full squad that was ready to play football and take on the top few.
So where are we now? Back at square one. Actually we're further back than that. But the only way is to build. Keep the commercial focus going on but sell to buy. Make profits out of player sales (how else are we making a profit?). Organic growth with the aim that we again be in a position to take our shot in maybe 5 years, maybe a bit more. Moyes may still be the man to take us through this process - but hopefully we learn that he isn't the man to take us further if we can ever get ourselves back into that position.
And if we get relegated, well at least we fkin tried - and we were headed in that direction try or not.
6 Posted 09/11/2011 at 04:42:23
7 Posted 09/11/2011 at 06:42:54
I am all too realistic about the Club and what the board have to share with the fans in their blogs. THAT'S WHY I'M SO PISSED OFF!
I'd suggest it's your faith in our ability to start back at square one and grow to have another shot in 5 years that's unrealistic.
We never had a "shot." We made it to the Champions League qualifiers on nothing more than hard graft. Our reward was to be kicked out in the blink of an eye because we simply weren't prepared for it.
Those around us are only getting financially stronger as the years go by. Everton can't afford to put up with this board in the hope that they will sustainably manage us to future success. This is the Premier League. We aren't going to magically turn ourselves into a top 4 side on the manager's tactics.
Even if Everton took the League by storm next year and the likes of Barkley and Vellios turn into surperstars, they will simply be sold off by the board to manage the debt. Moyes says we now have the squad to keep good young players.
Off the pitch we are as bigger shambles as ever. If another Rooney emerged the same result would occur now.
8 Posted 09/11/2011 at 08:49:46
9 Posted 09/11/2011 at 08:58:36
Was the £24m other overheads?
10 Posted 09/11/2011 at 08:58:03
11 Posted 09/11/2011 at 09:22:51
12 Posted 09/11/2011 at 09:35:07
So I believe that the board did actually support Moyes in getting him into position to mount a serious campaign at the top. DM seems to get the absolute most out of a thin squad battling against injuries etc. However, when the squad was up to strength he couldnt get anything at all out of it.
We have subsequently sunk to the situation we are currently at. Ernie's thoughts on organic growth again are probably valid under the current circumstances. Given that BK is trying to tie Moyes down again on a new contract, it certainly seems to be his plan at present.
13 Posted 09/11/2011 at 09:36:31
What EFC has revealed is that they are far too dependent on broadcast revenue as a proportion of overall revenue.
Matchday revenue is constrained by capacity / demand (we're down a couple of k on average attendance this season); and corporate is limited by facilities / possibly demand (?)
Commercial revenue is also poor compared to peers. Merch is outsourced (when it was run in house it was a loss maker). The Park End development has stalled. Outsourcing can be a double-edged sword, but I'd argue that a top tier club should be directly responsible for primary AND secondary revenue streams.
Those cheeky twats across the park argue they should receive more than the flat c.£18m pa from the Overseas TV deal, as they command bigger exposure. Yes they do, but they also benefit from a £20m pa kit deal directly as a result of that global exposure the TV deal gets them, so pipe down!
I don't buy that we can't do more overseas. Two EPL clubs this season both signed on with sponsors who are either HQ'd or with significant operations in Asia. Having had sight of the packages, I don't believe we are anywhere near tapping that market effectively - despite our main sponsor being Asian.
Other clubs in the Prem have either employees or agents acting for them in Asia. (There's no reason this couldn't extend to other areas). Other clubs actively work with their sponsors to piggy back on each others' "product" to widen their association. (We have done a small amount of this with Thai Bev).
So you add our lack of capitalising on the global nature of the EPL along with the fact that we have borrowed against future income revenue, and you can see why instead of the "Trophy Asset" Kenwright talked about a few weeks ago, Toxic Asset would probably be more apt - and that is going to be a factor that any "genuinely" interested party will consider.
14 Posted 09/11/2011 at 09:53:48
To me, that means "give us your money and let us keep control of things." We the fans don't want investment ? we want this current regime bought out and sent packing for good.
15 Posted 09/11/2011 at 09:46:40
Do all the posters who say the BU are a waste of space think the club would be even communicating in this way, if they thought they could get away with saying nothing?
The "200 or so idiots" are making a difference.
Elstone has tried to placate the unrest with soundbites from a couple of months ago. They are now becoming so transparent in their spin, it is becomong a joke.
Is he saying Woods, Earl & Kenwright don't want to make as much as possible out of any potential deals?
As far as the Park End development goes, I wouldn't mention it again if I was him ? put your spade away Bob, the hole is getting deeper.
A few months ago "no-one is buying football clubs." Now there is a queue around the block. What twats.
16 Posted 09/11/2011 at 10:11:36
17 Posted 09/11/2011 at 11:40:12
from BBC website:
"Of course, we fully understand what you [the fans] want to know is will these discussions be successful. That I can't say. Discussions are still at an early stage". Robert Elstone.
So finally after 10 years of looking for investme.... oh I mean a buyer.. we are at an "early stage" with the discussions.. fuck me, what absolute bullshit.
Love or hate them the BU is getting under the skin of the current regime and I for one applaud them even if I dont agree with everything they stand for. How much crap will some fans swallow until they have had a belly full?
18 Posted 09/11/2011 at 11:57:29
Do you really think anyone actually believes you anymore? Same tripe, same quotes, same timing to placate the disquiet amongst fans before ( lets remember, AGM, EGM, Kirkby Inquiry ..oh sorry, yes that you you had to tell the truth, bet that hurt..)
Credibility Robert? you have none. Tell us the truth for once. Your selling your soul with such an approach. Or should I say you have sold it.
The Park end fiasco was just a joke but a sad one given the lies regarding the reasons we were given.
Close the door on the way out and turn off the lights. Taxi waiting.
19 Posted 09/11/2011 at 11:54:42
Peter #11 - I think we're saying the same thing? Time for an overhaul - sell the older players and invest in youth.
Could blow up in our face but when the alternative seems to be a drawn out death waiting for a miracle what else can we do? No-one should be off-limits now. Certainly not older players on high wages. We might lose a few bright young players along the way too - well that's shit but we need to make money and it's obvious that we can't make profits any other way. Don't know if we can stay up with such a tactic but I reckon we might have the right manager for the rebuild. As long as BK (or whoever) has the guts to let him go if or when he's done his job.
I'd accept shit football for a few years if it meant we were trying to improve.
20 Posted 09/11/2011 at 12:26:06
21 Posted 09/11/2011 at 12:41:27
22 Posted 09/11/2011 at 12:47:02
23 Posted 09/11/2011 at 12:50:56
24 Posted 09/11/2011 at 13:01:25
25 Posted 09/11/2011 at 13:08:20
This leaves about £12m - £4.5m(debt repayments)
This leaves £7.5m. Is he seriously telling me that all the operating costs such as maintenance on the ground, ticket office staff, stewards, policing, scouting, legal fees, licensing and a raft of other costs incurred as part of running a Premier League football team are covered by that amount?
I think what he includes in that 85p in every pound would be very different than most of us would.
26 Posted 09/11/2011 at 13:47:51
Maybe you can ask your friends why they blocked the sale of Bellefield which cost the club millions both in lost sales and bridging loans, which may have meant us making the crazy decision of leasing back finch farm.
Could you please confirm were this information has come from because only last week BU supporters were dismissing the Jain interest as total fantasy, this week it's down to BU and its followers that the Jain Group have materialised?
I have said it a million times on this site that a fans group in principle is an excellent idea; a Union of people brought together for their dislike of our current custodians is dangerous, that?s why I and the majority will stay in the pub next week and watch the Sky game.
This is not an industrial dispute; it?s our club so get a mandate so fans like me can join it because in its present form all the good will is lost in the political positioning and most fans just don?t have the will to follow such a conflict. COYB
27 Posted 09/11/2011 at 14:04:45
If the current board were an Indian consortium, there would be riots on the streets of Walton to remove them.
28 Posted 09/11/2011 at 14:51:17
The cloak of cofidentiality is all very well but I cannot recall The Glazers or Fenway being very confidential when taking over United and LFC respectively. After all, investors are either interested or not interested.
The"New Development" was also mentioned; why has it taken so long for a statement on the matter to be made? this rumour has been circulating since last season.
Everton FC have continually failed to deliver and, until their statements contain real substance, Evertonians will remain sceptical.
29 Posted 09/11/2011 at 15:52:50
30 Posted 09/11/2011 at 16:00:52
31 Posted 09/11/2011 at 15:42:34
What's more dangerous than any fan group is the naive mentatlity that someone who is a "true blue"can't do wrong. Combining this and the current apathy/malaise in which a significant proportion of our fanbase now observe towards EFC. And you have a frightening prospect.
The BU have only sought to get answers from those who treat the average fan with contempt.
32 Posted 09/11/2011 at 16:36:57
33 Posted 09/11/2011 at 16:59:30
34 Posted 09/11/2011 at 17:06:36
35 Posted 09/11/2011 at 17:17:44
The lads I go with renew because they want to follow Everton, not because they know that there will be a cash injection on its way.
36 Posted 09/11/2011 at 17:39:32
Want to think again about that claim of blaming the BU blocking the sale of Bellefield caused the lease of Finch Farm?
Finch Farm built 2006, Everton moved in 2007 and the ROM Capital deal was signed upon its completion.
The DK plans were submitted in July 2007 after the ROM deal was already done.
37 Posted 09/11/2011 at 18:15:43
Again, my big fear is that we've now stripped the club of all the assets and have not much to sell...Tough to get your money back when you don't have anything to sell. Something has got to give bc no doubt they are asking for waaaaay too much money for a club that is in a downward out of control spiral
38 Posted 09/11/2011 at 18:04:58
This is all about you all doing something to release your frustration and no doubt you all feel better thereafter but it achieves nothing because most fans understand that football has changed; it doesn?t belong to us fans any longer and when you march just have a look at the players car park and you will see were all the money goes.
We are crap at the moment and need 3 points but those players still get paid millions and they get away with it untouched. BK has had his day and not getting KD was a disaster but we had no money then and none now so nothing has changed. BU can?t change that conundrum so marching on the club singing "We want the board out" has no relevance as the board want out too so you are protesting about a board that doesn?t want to stay, it is completely pointless.
The efforts should be made to get fans groups around the table and both parties need to swallow some pride and it has to come from BU first as they don?t own the club. Like it or not, until a new owner comes on board, if you want to succeed you need to open dialogue with BK and others and by marching you make this less likely. It?s a selfish act to release your own frustration.
Negotiation is about compromise, take the lead and be proactive rather marching which creates confrontation; you want what he has so be clever about it. COYB
39 Posted 09/11/2011 at 18:27:21
40 Posted 09/11/2011 at 18:23:26
There is no other plausible option.
41 Posted 09/11/2011 at 19:45:46
42 Posted 09/11/2011 at 20:57:15
43 Posted 09/11/2011 at 21:21:42
44 Posted 09/11/2011 at 21:40:06
The option is no money in January, no signings and the distinct prospect of a potentially disaterous flirtation with relegation. The stakes could not be higher at the moment, without wanting to come across as a smart arse I knew before a ball was kicked against Q.P.R that all this would happen, the writing has been on the wall for a while and the chickens appear to be coming home to roost.
45 Posted 09/11/2011 at 21:47:11
We'd been frozen out and cancelling the AGM was the final avenue of transparency between club and supporters.
The spin and the absolute bullshit still survived though. Remember the opening of Everton 2 and Sir Phillip Carter's wonderful promise of "exciting signings"
I'm a reasonable man, and I took Sir Phil on face value, I felt re-assured that money must be available and I patiently waited day by day for the breaking news and, well you know the rest.
That is until, the Peoples Group formed last summer, and started asking the question that many Evertonians had been asking for a number of years.
Fans have discussed and debated our plight, and some informed us on forums such as Toffeeweb, that our finances were in a mess and the club had to sell it's assets to survive, but no one really knew, and some of us no doubt, clung to the hope that Moyes's would have a small kitty to play with, from the sale of Pienaar etc
Then the BU, uncovered the real state of affairs at Everton, and what a sorry state we're in. Bill's gamble had failed and now it was time to pay back his debt and in doing so halt any further progression and slip us into reverse.
BK has had his day - but how long should we sit quietly and suffer his tenure - the BU have brought the sale of Everton to the front and centre and into the public domain, so that hopefully it won't drift half heartedly like it has done for the previous years.
I've had enough of the lies, and the promises and the false dawns. Pressure can bring out the best in people and the pressure the BU exert on Kenwright and co should if nothing else keep them honest and on their toes.
So Bobby, thanks for being so candid but you'll forgive me if I don't take the peg off my nose just yet!
46 Posted 09/11/2011 at 21:47:49
47 Posted 09/11/2011 at 21:55:22
Mr Elstone, we already know that EFC spends 85p in every pound... you have repeated that numerous times, we want to know what the £24M is spent on?
Repeated failure to answer that question suggests you are covering something up, does it not? So why don't you answer that question directly in your next blog, then we can move onto other concerns, it's quite simple really.
48 Posted 09/11/2011 at 21:47:38
49 Posted 09/11/2011 at 22:00:38
Continued evasion of that question suggests cover up, just answer the question for Christ's sake.
50 Posted 09/11/2011 at 22:44:45
You saw people still loved Bill in the stadium after the last protest. We are all Evertonian's but please those of you who can get there and can see the problems we face get out there in force. We need numbers so large that it can't be ignored.
51 Posted 10/11/2011 at 01:46:38
Fed up of lies, spin and failure to give the team Manager a budget to work with. Just not good enough.
52 Posted 10/11/2011 at 11:51:14
53 Posted 10/11/2011 at 12:14:51
They talk of an interim board, whose main aim is to sell the club. what gives them the right to demand this?
As much as I want Kenwrong out, I don't believe that I have the right to know the full ins and outs of this business' financial dealings.
I put in £500 a year for a ticket and buy beer at the ground, I sppent ten times that in the boozer and the supermarket. I wouldn't dream of protesting about Asda and their refusal to bring down the costs of Stella and their refusal to sell a certain brand I want, yet I put more money into them than I do Everton FC Ltd.
Posters are saying BU have put the board under pressure....no they haven't. The board is still as smug and non customer friendly as ever, they just reel out "good news" items before planned protests to placate the fench sitters.
They aren't arsed if a clown with a cake gets his 5 seconds on Granada Reports....a fecking clown with a cake, feck me!
All we have learned through the BU involvement is that we are in dire staits and have a dickhead running the club.....well feck me!, stop the press, I didn't know that before.
Us knowing, doesn't affect the running of the business, it may weaken any bargaining position Everton FC Ltd have with a prospective buyer though. However, I'm sure the due diligence checks by the buyer would unearth the shite finacial staus anyway.
54 Posted 10/11/2011 at 12:34:11
I went to the Blue Union meeting in the Casa and a guy stood up and said after your family, job what is the most important other thing in your life 'Everton' ?
55 Posted 10/11/2011 at 12:54:58
We are not fundamentally hitched onto Everton and as shown on here, some are turning their back already...Marshy keeps saying it but he knows he can't leave.
There is a poster that goes to watch another team now, cheap ale and a pie and all that.
56 Posted 10/11/2011 at 16:37:57
57 Posted 10/11/2011 at 17:09:16
58 Posted 11/11/2011 at 01:42:34
59 Posted 11/11/2011 at 04:57:21
You don't get to know the financial ins and outs of companies. Regardless of whether you think you have the right to because of your emotional attachment to it.
60 Posted 11/11/2011 at 15:39:25
You are forgetting that a prospective Billionaire is looking for a plaything, looking to be adored for bringing about a new era, he doesn't really think, here's a great business, this is a decent money spinner.
Do Man City make cash? Really? How many million per point did they pay to finish above Everton last season? So financial sense is not really an issue when it comes to buying a Premier League club.
If we land a billionaire buyer, it will be so that person has a plaything, and can afford to throw around £200M in players over a few years and see what Moyes can do with those players. Who knows, stadium issues might also evaporate quickly as well.
The danger will be Everton maintaining any shuffled debt should billionaire walk away one day. City fans dream of the Premier League title in their sleep on odd numbered days and have nightmares about the current owner getting bored on even numbered days.
61 Posted 11/11/2011 at 15:49:50
If you were a billionaire with no club attachments looking for some fun, would you choose Everton? We're a long way down that particular list.
62 Posted 11/11/2011 at 15:57:12
"We are not fundamentally hitched onto Everton"
You're wrong.
63 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:10:16
Apparantly it's easy to walk away and play golf, go and watch rugby or play X-Box instead.
Anthony, passion? What are you trying to say, I'm not passionate because I don't feel we have the right to see the clubs financials in full? Talk about things being daft.
Thanks Ernie, at least someone gets it.
Mick, what the feck has us knowing exactly how skint we are got to do with supporting the eleven men on the pitch on the weekends?
64 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:22:22
I would sugest,as in any walk of life,you can apply standards or benchmarks which includes footie fans -
i.e EFC;
1)play X-Box then get the result
5) watch EFC on TV/Internet live every week
10) A family with season tickets, going home and away
Turn up to 11) as 10 but add pre season/Europe etc.
And everyone inbetween (running a website),who are as passionate but maybe differing in levels of commitment.
Eg;My wife loves Everton,goes to a couple of games a year,will always try and watch if on TV or internet unless other commitments then gets the results a.s.a.p. I have a season ticket with my 26 year old daughter and we go away a few times a year etc.
Anyway re the march.
We will all support the 11 on the pitch once we get in the ground after the march.Just like we did after the first march re Villa.One of best atmospheres of the season so far at Goodison.
The spin from the club will intesify from now until the march, which if fair enough.
(Remember the 3 buyers reportedly interested before the last march)
We will march,my daughter and I,because we respect and agree with KEIOC and the BU's motives,aims and ambitions for our great club.
Plus I (we) believe that to sit back and do nothing, at this point in our history, is not an option.
See you there.
COYB
65 Posted 11/11/2011 at 17:15:57
66 Posted 11/11/2011 at 18:09:05
67 Posted 11/11/2011 at 20:36:24
Everton are ripe to be bought, and if the cost of Goodison regeneration is an issue (£100 m plus for planning issues alone was quoted on here the other week) then would that stand in the way of a billionaire?? City have that amount of talent consistently warming a bench week in week out (that's not shrewd, but when you are a billionaire, who cares).
What gets me is the fact that you can walk into any shop and buy most shirts except Everton's. We are missing simple tricks...
68 Posted 11/11/2011 at 20:45:48
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 08/11/2011 at 23:18:46
The rest has already been covered in his last posts so comments like "To get this right again" are just rubbing fans noses in the clubs failings.
Ignoring the sale issue for a minute he still seems to miss a major factor that;s driving fans crazy. Spare me the 85p crap the real issue is that he goes on to say we are one of the leanest run ships in the premiership.....WHY!
If he is telling the truth and 85p really are going to Finch Farm its clear we are playing players and staff too much. You pay for results and we haven't had any of those in a long time.