“£150M? £160M ? not far wrong...”

, 11 November, 45comments  |  Jump to most recent
Last night on Sky Sports News, Keith Harris talked about the resurgence of interest in buying Everton, mainly from the Middle East, India and China, but confirmed that there had been no offers made. Asked how much it would take to buy Everton — £150M? £160M?? — Harris told the interviewer "you're not far wrong".

Quotes or other material sourced from Sky Sports News



Reader Comments (45)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Martin Hughes
2 Posted 11/11/2011 at 06:33:08
£150m to £160m ...... no wonder we cant sell the Football Club.
Sunny Li
3 Posted 11/11/2011 at 06:46:41
£150M?... unless there is another royal family in arab....
Ernie Baywood
4 Posted 11/11/2011 at 07:22:56
What would you value it at, Martin?
Sam Hoare
5 Posted 11/11/2011 at 07:37:53
Seems a lot for a club that has spiralling debts, has sold off most of its assets and has an increasingly outdated stadium that brings in small comparative revenues!
Mike Green
6 Posted 11/11/2011 at 07:45:49
If Everton go on record saying "£40m" then the price will unsuprisingly be .... erm £40m. Or less.

The price is there to be knocked down -? and why not? "Big Premier League Club For Sale" needs to have a big price tag, it's up to the buyers to decide what they think its worth and negotiate.

Besides, I've not seen it but if that price was suggested to him he's not going to go "Nah, piss off, it's not worth anywhere near that!?"
Danny Lizars
7 Posted 11/11/2011 at 08:20:37
You can't really go on that being the cost to buy Everton but if it that is what Bill Kenwright and the rest of the clowns on the board want then what fucking planet are they on?!?!
Alastair Bates
8 Posted 11/11/2011 at 08:31:57
Well I hope that the 150m price tag includes the Debt otherwise the majority shareholders (who as has been stated on here many times, have not put any additional money into the club) are looking for a big profit.

Put simply the value of a share is approximately £1500 if you are only purchasing a small quantity and there are just 35000 shares in EFC as the board have never wanted to dilute their ownership with any share issue. Thus, as a maximum the club shares can be valued at is £52.5m, unless someone wants to make a profit, or you also include the £80m debt (overdraft and loans ? short and long term) and you are now closer to the £140 to £150m price tag.

But then let?s look back at Mr B Kenwright?s purchase of Peter Johnson?s shareholding and (correct me if I?m wrong) he paid £800 a share ? along with the Gregg family ? so even at £1500 a share our chairman will still receive a profit on his shares after plunging the club into a Greek Style financial Crisis ? and at least they still have the gold to sell off we don?t have anything left!

Personally I don?t think someone needs to buy the whole club as a change of board / leadership could bring Lord Grantchester and the Abercromby family back into the fold and become we will become a strong force again. Or they are the stumbling block to any sale?
Richard Jones
9 Posted 11/11/2011 at 08:55:40
And there you have it "MONEY" that the reason why Bill clings on, not setiment, not his train set, he want a big fay pay day. Some fuckin blue he is, hes done fuck all and now he wants his pension fund and still people clap him!!
Alastair Bates
10 Posted 11/11/2011 at 08:59:25
For info £4300 a share gives the value of all the company at £150.5 million.
That would pocket the board as follows;
Bill Kenwright appox £36.5m (not including his recent purchases);
Robert Earl £35m;
Jon Woods £27.5m;
Sir Philip Carter £3m
Nelly Verdonghan
11 Posted 11/11/2011 at 09:27:23
LOADS of talks with LOADS of interested parties (please note the heavy sarcasm here...) but surprisingly (NOT !!...) not ONE single offer.....more bullshit from Billy Bullshit....

Just ANOTHER case of smoke and mirrors by the King of Bullshit readily turfed out by the yes man that is Elstone...just like the Donavan ( and Pienaar) thing...they know the supporters would welcome him back and so they spin some shit to make them think it just might happen......If Bullshit Bill ( and the rest of his cronies) said today was Friday I would rush to check the calendar....

How much more shite do they think we will fall for...?
James Newcombe
12 Posted 11/11/2011 at 09:49:11
Did Harris do a little wink at the end of that sentence?
Graham Atherton
13 Posted 11/11/2011 at 10:11:20
At least one report puts the price paid by Earl at £15 million for 24% of the club. Add in debt of £40 million (if that still stands after recent sales) and you get a minimum of £105 million for the club before he makes a profit.

Don't expect the price to drop below that!
Kevin Tully
14 Posted 11/11/2011 at 10:36:12
Don't believe it for a minute.

Bobby Elstone himself said the asking price would not be an obstacle to the club being sold.

Bill & the board only have the interests of the club at heart, money is of no importance to them, they just want to see the club in the right hands.

Anyway, who wants to buy a fooball club?

Who would want Everton with their crappy ground?

You would need £500m before you start anyway.

If there were any interested parties, they would have made it known publicly.

That's just some of the shite I have read on here.

Alastair Bates
15 Posted 11/11/2011 at 10:40:49
Graham #12 if you're right and Earl paid the Gregg Family £15m for their shares then he paid around £1,850 a share for his total 8146 shares.

On that valuation, the total share stock of Everton Football Club is £64.75m.
Alastair Bates
16 Posted 11/11/2011 at 10:49:21
Kevin #13...What dont you believe?

That the man Bill has asked to sell the club doesnt know the price, or the value of the shares?

Its simple mathamatics and the information is in the public domain.
Kevin Tully
17 Posted 11/11/2011 at 11:05:49
Sorry Alastair, I don't know if you are being serious?
Alastair Bates
18 Posted 11/11/2011 at 11:12:09
Serious? I just asked what you didn't believe.

I don't have any reasons not to beleive what our Chairman or CEO tell us so we take that information and put it all together as they never seem to want to.

If that is then wrong they need to put the right information forwward.
Ciarán McGlone
19 Posted 11/11/2011 at 12:11:52
Shocking!
John White
20 Posted 11/11/2011 at 12:53:32
I doubt that the value of the club will never be known to anyone who read these pages.

The bottom line is that the club is worth as much as somebody is willing to pay and the baord happy to accept. End of.

Yes they will also be looking to make a profit or at worst, get back what they have put in. Imagine if it were your house, which you have paid your mortgage every month for years. Stick on the market for £250k. Would you accept £150? I dont think so.

The value of the club is not even worth bothering talking about really!
Colin Wainwright
21 Posted 11/11/2011 at 12:56:24
Alastair (#17)

You don't have any reason not to believe the Chaiman or CEO?

Ha Ha. Seriously?

Kevin Tully
22 Posted 11/11/2011 at 13:00:13
I see Alastair, my poor attempt at sarcasm was clearly missed by some.

My point is, the current board are portraying the asking price being dependant on "the right owners coming in."

I believe they don't give a flying fuck who the new owners may be, as long as they trouser as much profit from any deal.

Clear now?
Alastair Bates
23 Posted 11/11/2011 at 13:05:15
Ohh.. I have a lot of reasons not to believe a single word they utter, but have no evidence, so can only rely on my gut and research. Thus, my head rules my heart and you have to take it at face value and support the team.
Lee Smith
24 Posted 11/11/2011 at 13:07:00
@ John White #19 -

Would I accept £150k? All depends. How much did I pay for it in the first place? First I would ask myself, "Is £250k a reasonable figure to ask for?".

Secondly, I would ask myself, if I had spent absolutely no money on the upkeep of the house since buying it, and had let it fall into a state of disrepair, had sold the adjoining garage to my next door neigbour, and had sold all of the fixtures and fittings that were part of my original purchase to Cash Convertors in an attempt to help me fund my mortgage payments, then actually, yes, I would possibly consider selling it for £150k.
Mick Gallagher
25 Posted 11/11/2011 at 13:22:01
You beat me to it Lee
John Daley
26 Posted 11/11/2011 at 13:19:41
"I would ask myself, if I had spent absolutely no money on the upkeep of the house since buying it, and had let it fall into a state of disrepair, had sold the adjoining garage to my next door neigbour, and had sold all of the fixtures and fittings that were part of my original purchase to Cash Convertors in an attempt to help me fund my mortgage payments, then actually, yes, I would possibly consider selling it for £150k."

Then you would inform the interested party that no one else could possibly look after that house as well as you can and the sale would therefore be contingent on you staying on as caretaker.
Tony J Williams
27 Posted 11/11/2011 at 13:26:25
Why isn't Kenwrong allowed to want a profit on his return? Every other business man in every other field of business is in it for the money so why should he accept a loss for his shares?

Lee, a comment from John Bishop comes to mind. He was talking about people worrying that they were in negative equity with their houses...easy solution, don't sell it.

As much as I want the shyster out, there is nothing wrong with the big dope expecting the maximum return for his shares.
Lee Smith
28 Posted 11/11/2011 at 13:34:24
Tony, I have no problem with people expecting the maximum return from there shares. But the question being asked is, have the board members (not just Kenwright) done anything to warrant a profit on their shares? Buying a share, in any business or fund, in no way whatsoever guarantees you a profit. Shares can go down as well as up remember!

If Kenwright, since his tenure as Chairman / large shareholder, had used his business accument to turn Everton Football Club Limited into a striving, profitable concern, then yes, absolutely, reap what you have sown Mr. Kenwright and enjoy your retirement. But he hasn't, has he?
Tony J Williams
29 Posted 11/11/2011 at 14:14:47
No he hasn't Lee and I have done absolutely nothing to my house apart from a lick of paint and lamanate floorboarding, yet my house is worth quite a bit more than when I bought it.

Yes he could "expect" a lot more had he run the club with any savy but he still wants a progit on his money and won't sell until he gets it........or until the Administrators come a knocking
Lee Smith
30 Posted 11/11/2011 at 14:20:35
The fact that your house is now worth quite a bit more now than when you bought it, despite not spending much on it, is where this whole analogy of comparing house prices to share prices falls down.

It really doesn't make much sense to compare the two in this context, perhaps I should have made this point in my original response to John @ #19 really. House prices will usually appreciate in value over a period of time regardless, but you really can't apply that to share prices, in any form, especially those in a football club.

I just hope for all our sakes that it doesn't come down to the Administrator's knocking, and common sense prevails!
Tony J Williams
31 Posted 11/11/2011 at 14:33:52
You and me both Lee.
James Flynn
32 Posted 11/11/2011 at 15:50:04
RE: The housing value analogy. My house doesn't go up in value just because I slapped a coat of paint on or put an in-ground pool in the back yard.

The value of my house goes up or down depending on where I live. Speculation has driven up the value of houses in the EPL "neighborhood" significantly in the last few years. EFC's value gets driven up whatever Kenright etal have done or not done.

Naturally, interested buyers want to negotiate price because the EFC house is in such dis-repair. But the selling price is still driven up because of EFC residing in the EPL "district" of Professional Club Football Town; the most expensive part of town in the soccer world.
David Israel
33 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:15:17
Alastair, # 7 has got it right: whatever the asking price, no one needs to buy all the shares, just a majority of them.

I personally would like to see Lord Grantchester retain his stake. It's a link to the great days of his grandfather.
James Ennis
34 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:19:52
I cannot believe the media circus that Kenwright et al have been able to muster against such a small opposition force such as the Blue Union ? or is it so small? They are obviously very worried

Clearly Kenwright and his motley crew deem it that important as to muster the forces of Sky and Keith Harris. Watch it ? total and utter shite other than revealing an asking price ? which I personally feel is a true reflection of the value of our beloved club. Serious money needs serious partners ? not chicken feed.

All the £500m talk of investment and a new stadium that is needed is utter shite. Get real ? redevelop first the bullens then the gwladys both with corporate boxes - get to 50,000 capacity and most of all invest in the team that gets us back to the days of lockouts.

Nil Satis Nisi Optimum

IF YOU LOVE THE CLUB LET GO

Oh and get on the Graham Beacroft interview on Talk Sport
****The land between the Park End and the Stanley Park border is not owned by Everton***** ? so who does own it?

I was once told Peter Johnson owned the Everton One property ? is it possible he owns both? I don't know but it sure would be interesting if anyone has the resources to investigate and find out
Peter Laing
35 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:30:59
FFS Tony # 28 here you go again comparing the price of your house increasing without spending a great deal, the other day it was the price of your shopping at Asda, are you sure that you are on the right website I'm beginning to think you should be posting on housewives weekly.
Colin George
36 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:25:44
How can anyone come on here and say that the club is in a worst condition than when Bill took over from Johnson? That was the time when we had no money, relegation was a real threat, and the chairman did not even support the club.

The detractors need to wake up and smell the coffee or Portsmouth here we come. We are supporters so why don't we support, let the manager manage and the chairman chair.

I am not naive just a realist.
Tony J Williams
37 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:45:16
Peter, it's called using examples/comparisons. Just because you seemingly don't like it, doesn't make the point less valid.

Here we go them without the analogies..

Kenwrong can want more for his shares from when he bought them all those years ago. there is nothing wrong with that - Simple concept.

Just because I invest money and emotion into Everton FC I do not expect full disclosure of their financial records.

Simple enough for you?
Jay Harris
38 Posted 11/11/2011 at 17:23:33
Colin, you are totally wrong.

The club was not in financial difficulties.The only problem was the bank wanted a personal guarantee on a £5 million overdraft facility which he refused.

Kenwright inherited a net asset position of over £20 million which he has succeeded in turning into a £45 million net liability in other words he has turned a solvent business into a technically insolvent business.

Johnson was also the last shareholder to invest some personal money into the club and was responsible for the Park End Stand redevelopment.

Yes, he wasn't a great chairman, interfering with the management of the playing staff too much, but Kenwright and his cronies are much worse in every respect.

Can you name one of Kenwright's achievements.
Peter Laing
39 Posted 11/11/2011 at 17:50:46
Tony his name is Bill Kenwright, your approach is nothing more than childish.
Brian Keoghan
40 Posted 11/11/2011 at 18:10:38
James Enniis 33 ? I think Everton do own the land behind the Park End stand; I remember streets and houses on that land with a training area at the Bullens Road end. Everton owned at least some of the houses as a few players used to live there, including Dixie Dean (remember the days of "club houses").

In the "Golden Vision", Jack Sharp and John Moores refered to the club's "property" and investments (ironic eh?) and I assumed this property could be the Park End houses. Slowly over time the houses were knocked down and the training ground became an all weather pitch until it became part of the extended car park.

I would be very surprised if Everton do not own that land especially as alterations were made to the stand for the World Cup in 1966 and of course rebuilt in '94, without any problems.
Steve Jones
41 Posted 11/11/2011 at 18:39:01
As Alistair says #9, "For info £4300 a share gives the value of all the company at £150.5 million" ? that's incredible.

To bring it down to small shareholder level I bought a single share 4 years ago for £1250 ? so that's a profit of 3 grand when forced to sell ? unbelievable price.
Thomas Windsor
43 Posted 12/11/2011 at 10:17:34
If this club gets relegated, which could quite easy happen either this season or next, how much will your club be worth then, Bill?

We have not bought a player for 2 years you won't be able to raffle the club off... so you and your cronies should go now before we become a laughing stock.
James Ennis
44 Posted 12/11/2011 at 11:43:46
Brian Keoghan #39
Listen to the Graham Beecroft interview on Talk Sport
He clearly states "Everton do not own the land between the Park End and the Stanley Park Fence" of the Park End
Gareth Fieldstead
45 Posted 12/11/2011 at 15:28:08
Interesting points, but as noted above the majority shareholders will only get what someone else will be prepared to pay. Furthermore, unless there is another benefactor that rivals what City and Chelsea have spent then no businessman would part with the sort of money that has been rumoured. As for David (32) other than sentimental reasons why on earth would we want a multi millionaire to remain on the board who has watched successive chairmen fail our club so miserably? The man has not even offered a penny of his own money. As for Colin (35) point, anybody who just happened to be living on the moon the last thirteen years would presume you were talking about Kenwrights tenure. With the exception of Kendalls third spell in charge, Everton under Johnson were never really in trouble. He did support all his managers, even Kendall was allowed to bid for Ravanelli (remember him?) Yes he did interfere far too much with the playing side, but I personally think Moyes was told to sell Peinnar, Vaughn, Yakubu and Beckord and despite there protestations I would be very surprised if Moyes actually saw any of the Arteta sale, does any of that count as interfering in the playing side of the club?
Brian Keoghan
46 Posted 12/11/2011 at 16:33:18
OK James 33,Mr Beecroft sounds as though he knows more than we do.When the Kitbag deal was first announced it was stated that Liverpool City Council had granted permission for the development so maybe they own the land and are being their usual helpful self !
Brian Keoghan
47 Posted 12/11/2011 at 19:14:42
Gareth #43. Not sure about us never being in trouble under Johnson (apart from Howie's last season). We were close to the drop in '95 despite winning the cup and after Royle left in '97 we had a close call.

More importantly, the "multi-millionaire on the board" you refer to is, I assume, Lord Grantchester. The Lord has not been on the board for some years although still a shareholder and is closely involved with "Blue Blood" (he was at Goodison on Thursday for the Armistice Day meeting as their representative).

Personally, I cannot understand why the Moores family don't become involved in our hour of need. John Moores played a big part in Everton's history and Everton played a big part in his life, yet his family remain on the outside during these troubled times. Rumours have circulated of a rift between Kenwright and the Moores family over Johnson coming in and going out but this has never been confirmed or denied by either party so we don't know. However there has to be a reason why these potential benefactors do not ride to our rescue. Any ideas?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads