Everton ?Relatively debt-free?

, 11 November, 33comments  |  Jump to most recent
Graham Beecroft explains the current investment-sale-ownership-takeover-stadium-selling-transfer situation at Everton to the journos at TalkSport, including this amazing quote that Everton are now relatively debt-free!!!

Quotes or other material sourced from TalkSport



Reader Comments (33)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Perry
1 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:42:17
Relatively debt free? How can that be the case, all other media outlets are stating £50 - £60 million debt. It's just bullshit again from Billy Bullshit and his team of propoganda puppets.
Tony J Williams
2 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:51:44
Would have posted sooner but I passed out laughing too hard and have just woke up again.

Relatively debt free?, relative to what? Italy?
Margaret Morgan
3 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:54:55
Relatively debt free? ... relative to what? Italy?
-----

Class.
Jem Traynor
4 Posted 11/11/2011 at 16:54:36
Basically this latest release saying in essence, there will be no takeover and we do not understand why there will not be as we are trying our hardest to protect our own interests and oh look we are relatively debt free, A LOAD OF SHITE! IF NOT WHY CAN'T WE BUY SOME PLAYERS.....
Paul Lally
5 Posted 11/11/2011 at 17:11:05
As I have just posted on the 'Elstone:Genuine coversations' thread.....
'The spin will start to intensify as we get closer to the march.'
They think we are idiots.
All the info is out there re the lies and mistakes etc.
See you at the march.
COYB
Ian McDowell
7 Posted 11/11/2011 at 17:30:37
I like Graham Beecroft as a sports reporter, but I don't understand this relatively debt free.

Then again compared to Itay who are billions we are relatively debt free. I mean I owe £10k on me car and £3k on my loan so compared to the British economy I am relatively debt free.

If your outgoings are larger than your incomings you are never going to be debt free unless you sell assets.
Roberto Birquet
9 Posted 11/11/2011 at 18:41:12
Italy has trillions - not just billions - of debt. Compared with Italy, France and even Germany, Britain has relativley little debt.

But, UK govt tax receipts have plummetted, and our spending is 10% greater than govt revenues. So I guess it is all how you read it. Normally you look at debt as a percentage of income. And of course, Everton's income is quite low, compared with Villa, Spurs, Liverpool, and especially, Chelsea, Arsenal, and United. City don't care about income - except when UEFA fair play rules come in (so they pay themselves £100 million a year via sponsoring own stadium, but that's off topic).

The Guardian recently produced a graphic showing each club's debt and income; http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2011/may/19/football-club-accounts-debt

It had Everton at £45 million debt, of course, since then Everton has raised money to pay down a lot of its debt.

Who had lower debt (last year's Prem teams)? According to Guardian: Brum, Blackburn, Stoke (just £8 mn), and who cares anyway, Man City (£41 mn).


so, relatively speaking, I guess just Blackburn and Stioke have less debt, and perhaps one or two of the new arrivals. I doubt Swans have spent much the past couple of decades.
Ray Robinson
10 Posted 11/11/2011 at 18:55:28
Well if we sell all our assets, the players, we probably are debt free! There wouldn't be a team or a football club, but we'd owe nothing.
Nick Entwistle
11 Posted 11/11/2011 at 19:07:00
Italy... Hah!

Still laughing.
Karl Masters
12 Posted 11/11/2011 at 19:09:04
We ARE relatively debt free to other Clubs, but that's not the whole story is it?

As others have alluded, there are other factors here, such as:

Ability to pay debt off.

Anybody on the Board wealthy enough to secure the debt.

Too much goes on Player Wages- 71% is too high. If it was say 55%, that would be 16% of £80m, ie £12.5m to spend on players. THAT IS THE CRUX OF THE WHOLE PROBLEM.

Overpaid players and weak management of the Club letting it happen. I wonder whether Pienaar is really happy to be on another £15k a week at Spurs and never in the team? No player is bigger than the Club. Either accept what would still be astronomical wages to most other Leagues around the world or piss off!

For every Pienaar there's always a Drenthe or Barkley waiting to be given a chance.
Simon Templeman
13 Posted 11/11/2011 at 19:45:50
Well said, Karl, it seems too many contributing here are fiscally illiterate. True, we owe money... but, compared to Fulham, Villa, Wigan and many others, we are solvent. The only reason the previously stated are still operating is due to wealthy benefactors.
Phillip Greenhow
14 Posted 11/11/2011 at 19:37:53
I dont think the main reason for the drivel we are listening to/reading from the the club is solely to do with Blue Union. The simple fact is we need to sell half-season tickets!

The club talks utter bollocks!

On the Blue Union front, its encouraging that they are raising the profile of our plight. I do wonder though that if something big doesnt occur before this season is finished that the impetus will be lost and the majority of fans will lose interest in both the Club and BU.
Trevor Mackie
15 Posted 11/11/2011 at 20:20:07
Karl Masters

"For every Pienaar there's always a Drenthe or Barkley waiting to be given a chance."

Fantastic shout, I would add this is ties in with the Moyes caution on all things.

Edward Robinson
16 Posted 11/11/2011 at 20:29:33
I feel that Moyes is reaching the end of his patience ? No money and no chance of any soon, leading (I fear) to the selling of Fellaini in the January window (and we all know how much he was missed against Newcastle!)

Moyes has not yet signed an extension to his contract so WHERE ARE WE GOING?

I fear for the club...
Brian Alexander
17 Posted 11/11/2011 at 20:56:30
Hang on here guys, how the hell can Graham Beecroft, reasonablly successfull reporter locally on Chester, Tranmere, Southport, Everton, Liverpool, local radio tv etc etc, feel he is qualified to throwaway and unqualified comments about EFC and all that is going on ?????

I live in the REAL LOCAL world. Kenwright is screwing this club for personal gain. WAKE UP. Sit on the fence any longer, and you people that support that Coronation Street TWAT will be so sorry in years to come. Support The Blue Union NOW, before you regret what is coming. COYB XX
David Hallwood
18 Posted 11/11/2011 at 22:08:12
Tony J Williams is on form today, Italy! Lol and on another thread after yet another conspiracy post, he replied 'step away from the tinfoil Jimmy' Classic!
Jason Heng
19 Posted 12/11/2011 at 00:10:34
Selling off Rodwell, Fellaini and Barkley will be enough to clear the debts? Some on ToffeeWeb think Rodwell is underachieving and Fellaini is shite anyway.
Thomas Williams
20 Posted 12/11/2011 at 00:26:17
Given the near £40M the club have recieved in the last 13 months, outside of matchday revenue, ticket sales, tv money and prize money, we should be nearly debt-free.

Be interesting to see the next accounts because, if our debt hasn't gone down considerably, someone is looting our club.
Ste Traverse
21 Posted 12/11/2011 at 00:45:10
Well said, Brian.
Kase Chow
22 Posted 12/11/2011 at 01:07:31
Tony Williams (1); you made me laugh out loud sir!
Eric Myles
23 Posted 12/11/2011 at 04:32:13
Roberto #7 "It had Everton at £45 million debt, of course, since then Everton has raised money to pay down a lot of its debt."

But that debt was from the last set of accounts (FY 2010), it will be greater in the new set so I am expecting that the money we've raised / saved from player sales might just about offset he increase and the debt will remain the same.
Thomas Windsor
24 Posted 12/11/2011 at 10:09:53
If Everton are dept-free, it should be easy to sell then? Watch this space...
Chris Jackson
25 Posted 12/11/2011 at 10:18:34
So, Brian #15, are you supporting the BU because it will/might lead to Kenwright going, or cause you support their cause?

The problem is you see, everybody needs to stick on message if it's going to have any effect. Ludicrous claims that BK is on the take, committing fraud, just ruins a lot of what the BU are trying to do.

People are working hard to get a good name for the BU, certainly after the reports which made them out to be a very dishonest bunch of cowboys (taping the conversation, if indeed it did happen). The claims you are making in their name dilutes that message and makes it out to be a personal vendetta against one man.
Gavin Ramejkis
26 Posted 12/11/2011 at 10:26:19
I don't believe for one minute that BK is pocketing away millions, it appears more that he is clueless and taking the equivalent of loan shark loans like those advertised on TV now with ridiculous rates just to keep the club afloat as not one of him and his merry band of carpetbaggers have yet to unstitch their sewn up pockets and spend a penny of their own on the club.

Items like "other operating costs" and these short term loans to give cash flow for wages and servicing previous debts are crippling the club. Rather than addressing these, BK is selling anything not nailed down then realised he still needs loans so he takes on more. The banks have rightly told him to get fucked and start paying back what he owes so more sales and more loans from other sources; this can't be kept up ad infinitum as the league presence money has been pissed away for the next two seasons, he hasn't a clue on how to generate new matchday and non-matchday revenue streams and our outsourced and merchandising deals are piss poor.

Don't expect many changes in the accounts other than a slightly healthier EBITDA; next year more loan(s) will appear to operate and pay off the latest set of loans, an ever present form of consolidation loans which just stretch out the debt duration. Remove the core of the problem, the chairman and board, and replace with new ideas to reverse this strategy or the board finally decide to invest as speculation to gain a return on a new investment beyond their shares (can't see that happening as they've refused point blank to do so for over a decade).
Trevor Mackie
27 Posted 12/11/2011 at 10:48:47
"Personal gain" isn't the same as nicking money from the till.

Anyone believing Billy isn't in this for personal gain don't know much about business.

Whether it's kudos from being "Chairman of a Prem Club" or getting millions in return for his initial stake don't believe that "benevolent Evertonian" shite.

He's hanging on amidst all the insults because it suits him and, while Moyes behaves like a pet poodle, the fans turn up and we stay in the Prem ? that's how it will stay till he decides different.
Ian Bennett
28 Posted 12/11/2011 at 12:03:03
We do have a low debt compared to others granted. Although others don't have a knackered stadium or a side that needs a good £50m spending on it.

A tramp is relatively debt-free.
Roberto Birquet
29 Posted 12/11/2011 at 15:57:16
so Eric 21,
you reckon Everton made record operating losses of over £20 m? I don;t see you could get that from apart from Arteta's wage rise of what under £2m.

Our debt will be lower. I would put it at under £30 m - over 80% on a repayment plan that has about 17 yrs to run.
Andy Crooks
30 Posted 12/11/2011 at 16:06:37
Graham Beecroft is an utter cretin who sounds like Alan Partridge.
Karl Masters
31 Posted 12/11/2011 at 16:59:12
Andy Crooks : Classic, and I might add that a DJ from BBC Norwich would probably do a better job of digging out the truth than just about all other journalists I have seen so far.

Only the Mail On Sunday paragraph on BK wanting too much for the Club has scratched the surface. Two greedy Spurs fans and a Board of Directors consisting of nobody to oppose BK are the problem. Can there be another Board of Directors like it at any other Club?

BK ? enough said

Woods ? silent nodding dog to BK

Earl ? just why would a Spurs fan invest in Everton? Answer: to make a killing.

Carter ? they probably have to get him out of his glass coffin to sign the minutes.

Tamlin -? in charge of Youth Development, at least he's doing something right.

Aided and abetted by Robert Elstone who seems nice enough, but also would do or say anything to keep his job, ie, a total Yes man.

So, leaving all other criticism aside, is there ever any discussion / new ideas / blue sky thinking going on in there. I doubt it. Too cosy by far.
John Shaw
32 Posted 12/11/2011 at 20:33:43
Hold on a minute, in the 2010 accounts our debt stood at £94.5 million, of which £52 million was due within one year, I don't know where this £45 million figure has come from!!!
Eric Myles
33 Posted 13/11/2011 at 02:37:45
Roberto #27 - yes, I expect greater operating losses, why do you think we're having to sell players.
Brian Alexander
34 Posted 13/11/2011 at 07:50:22
Chris #23. Don't spin my post, Chris, that is purely MY opinion and not a statement on behalf of BU. I am a solid supporter of BU but do not speak on their behalf. Go to the next meeting, if only to listen and observe and you will see that this honest bunch are extremely decent people, rightly concerned about the state of our club.
Jamie Rowland
38 Posted 13/11/2011 at 20:21:11
So I read The Guardian report: http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2011/may/19/football-club-accounts-debt

IN the table at the bottom it says that we have a £45m debt (which is somewhat incorrect ? the debt stands at £45m but the liability is closer to £100m)

However, what concerns me about that table is that Villa (a club similar to ours currently) has a debt of £110m... and an interest payment of £5m (presumably per year)... we have £45m and an interest payment of £4m... doesn't add up. Did we go to the Provident for our loan?

Similarly - Fulham: £190m debt, £2m interest... how come?

How come we earn £10m commercially (via the shop etc) and the shite take £62m? Same city - same chances?

All this tells me is that the club has been mismanaged since as long as I have watched them... Carter, Johnson, Kenwright ? all utter garbage at exploiting commercial situations whereas our neighbours have clearly been brutal at it.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads