Moyes the Constantly Curious

, 12 November, 46comments  |  Jump to most recent
On a recent visit to Finch Farm USA Coach Jurgen Klinsmann said he believes David Moyes is one of the most respected managers in the game.

?David is known within coaching circles as being someone who's constantly learning and constantly curious,? he said. ?He always wants to know where the next edge in psychology, scouting, science?whatever. That's what a good manager is about, he's a constant learner. And David Moyes is a very good learner.

?If you don't have the resources like the big, big teams have to go out and spend millions on the next big player, you have to be even more on top of the other areas in order to get the most out of your players and to compete with the big clubs.?  



Reader Comments (46)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kevin Hudson
1 Posted 12/11/2011 at 15:39:41
Cue the dripping sarcasm & group-hug mentality of the Moyes-bashers..
Trevor Mackie
2 Posted 12/11/2011 at 15:44:30
Too right Kevin, shouldn't Moyes have all this "learning" shit buttoned down by now?

next
Kevin Hudson
3 Posted 12/11/2011 at 15:55:43
Ha ha - there you go!!

Although one should never stop learning, each day is a new dawn etc..

(Other vacuous platitudes are availiable.)
Andy Morden
4 Posted 12/11/2011 at 16:33:50
Cue dripping sarcasm from the defenders of the Moyes!

If you can't beat em....

...join in with the sarcasm eh?
Kevin Hudson
5 Posted 12/11/2011 at 16:48:58
A lot more fun than dazzling them with facts, Andy.

Wait, isn't that more sarcasm?!

Rob Teo
6 Posted 12/11/2011 at 17:11:22
Hmmm...isn't the point of learning to apply what you've learnt, especially when you're the manager of a football team and, presumably, you're continually learning in order to benefit the team?

So, come on, Kevin, after 10 years at the helm, what has Moyes learnt tactics-wise, motivation-wise, substitution-wise, backup-plan-wise, etc, that he has applied? Enlighten us. No, dazzle us with some facts.
Andy Morden
7 Posted 12/11/2011 at 17:22:45
Sarcasm - the one constant on this thread so far. Mayhaps Jurgen was being sarcastic?

Facts. Stats. I saw that debate the other day, was quite entertaining. And granted objective stats facts and figures offer the view that Moyes has done well in terms of finish etc. But, equally, you could argue that people who watch the games observe other facts that exist... ie, stats aren't the only kind of evidence. Quantitative vs qualitative evidence if you like.

And a lot of people observe and report that Moyes really does seem to stick to his tried and trusted methods and players. Even down to defending corners. So you can understand why people may perhaps allow themselves a sly chortle at the idea of Moyes being the curious tinkerman style of manager.

For the record, I probably lean more towards supporting Moyes, but equally I do get frustrated by some of his 'quirks'. And of course, there is the backdrop of the boardroom situation too.
John Daley
8 Posted 12/11/2011 at 17:19:47
"...isn't the point of learning to apply what you've learnt, especially"

Come on, be fair. Moyes has previously utilised all his cutting edge, state of the art skills to strengthen the squad. Even Science.

Unfortunately, his self-teaching technique only extended to watching every Frankenstein film ever made. Except for "Jesse James meets Frankenstein's Daughter". He thought that was shit and switched off after 10 minutes.

You just weren't present that dark, lightning-lashed night when the 'Moyesiah' was leaping around his lab, shouting "It's alive! It's alive!!!", as Anichebe's arm began to twitch. You know it's no coincidence his first name is Victor.
Rob Teo
9 Posted 12/11/2011 at 17:43:39
Wow, Andy. I salute you: A more balanced viewpoint - one that considers both sides of the argument and is able to reconcile them - has rarely been uttered on this site (or on many other sites that I frequent, for that matter). Well done! You should post more regularly.
Ciarán McGlone
10 Posted 12/11/2011 at 17:45:42
Getting in early to predict that this quote will get rightly ridiculed, hardly makes it any less comical. One of Moyes's more frustrating flaws is his repetition of the same mistakes. Klinsmann clearly watches a lot of Everton matches...
Kevin Hudson
11 Posted 12/11/2011 at 19:30:00
Rob,

Far be it from me to commit sacrilege by suggesting Moyes is more "learned," than messrs Kendall & Royle, but compare the last 10 years in the Premier League with the previous 10.

So more facts then, which won't dazzle you at all, as you're blinded by hostility to a manager who's produced the most consistent league returns in a generation.

Oh, and a compliment from one of the legends of the game gets "rightly ridiculed."

Classic, Ciaran.
Andy Morden
12 Posted 12/11/2011 at 19:49:35
Kevin,

Forgive me if anyone has already asked you do this on other threads....

You are a very vocal supporter of David Moyes and you raise a good point by saying some folk do seem to only see the bad side of his tenure. However, in the interests of balance, I am interested in your perspective upon weaknesses you may feel Moyes has?
Nick Entwistle
13 Posted 12/11/2011 at 19:48:25
Weren't we in for Jurgen before he chose London? Sorry - Spurs??

Can't remember if it were before his first or second stint in London. Sorry - Spurs.
Kevin Hudson
14 Posted 12/11/2011 at 19:53:17
Sure, Andy,

I definitely see plenty of weaknesses in Moyes. In fact I agree with a lot of the most popular crticisms. Where to begin?

His persistence with the Blue-eyed Boys, even if they are tactically unsuited to a given role, or palpably out of form.

The apparent decline of strikers under his care.

His determination to deploy defenders in midfield. Or Anichebe on the wing. Or Osman, period.

His insistence on having everyone back for corners.

His institutionalised defensive mindset.

(Unless we're 5-0 up at home against 9-man Nuneaten, with 10 minutes remaining.)

His failure to challenge Howard by offering him a genuine goalkeeping rival.

His record against Liverpool.

Steve Round.

His refusal to go public & tell Kenwright to "get real and stop giving me paltry transfer money that you found down the back of your plush Knightsbridge sofa."

His self-control in not chinning Mancini when he should have. Or Benitez when he had the chance.

I could probably go on..But, "on balance," I think you know where I stand overall..
Andy Morden
15 Posted 12/11/2011 at 20:28:28
Fair play Kevin. To be honest, I agree, the tone of some of the arguments on here end up negating any value they may have. However, football is an emotive game, especially for fans and I think we sometimes have to accept that emotion will enter into the debate.
Dick Fearon
16 Posted 12/11/2011 at 20:23:27
Jurgen would make a good diplomat. As a guest of our Davy he could hardly voice a critical analysis of his host.

He got around it by saying he found Davey to be curious. That could mean, Davey has an enquiring mind, Davey has weird ideas, Davey is an eccentric.

Another thing, for an annual wage of 3 million quid I expect a genius and not a learner.
Ciarán McGlone
17 Posted 12/11/2011 at 20:34:42
Don't really understand that last comment Hudson. Are you suggesting Klinsmann knows more about Everton than the average Everton fan? Or that Klinsmann is beyond criticism? What exactly was 'classic' about my post?
Kevin Hudson
18 Posted 12/11/2011 at 20:41:38
Are we working on a last-name, military-like basis now, "McGlone.."?!

Honestly, feel free to call me Kevin, as everyone else does... you're amongst fellow Blues after all.

Re the comment query, I fail to see what's to understand here.
Andrew James
19 Posted 12/11/2011 at 21:53:35
With Kevin on much of this. He has his faults but Davey has turned us from relegation fodder to knocking on the door marked Europe. Early on he had no money, certainly less than his predecessors. Then Kenwright finally got it and gave him money after Davey was so dismally backed after the 2004/05 campaign. But gradually, after the Fellaini signing, the money dried up and we've been unable to get over that final hurdle.

He and his staff must be doing something right to constantly get us in the top 8. Due to injuries and the paucity of the squad, he constantly has to develop and find alternative solutions that others like Redknapp are never pushed into having to come up with.
Matt Woods
20 Posted 13/11/2011 at 04:07:32
Andrew, are you being serious? Redknapp at Spurs has done more wheeling and dealing in his career than anyone! West Ham, Soton and Pompy? So much so the Inland Revenue will be talking to him in court this week!
Rob Teo
21 Posted 13/11/2011 at 06:27:01
Kevin: you say that I'm "blinded by hostility to a manager who's produced the most consistent league returns in a generation." Well, would it be fair to say then that you're blinded by devotion to a manger:

? Who's never learnt how to beat a top 4 side away from home even after 10 years;

? Who's unable to come up with a new team formation when the players who were suited to that formation have long since been replaced by others who are unsuited to it, and when that formation has long since been sussed out by other managers (as you've pointed out);

? Who hasn't learnt how to utilise the strikers under his care (as you've pointed out)?

? Etc... (I could go on, but, really, you've already listed all the blind spots of Moyes that demonstrate the view that he's crap at applying what he's "learnt".)

Look, I agree with you and Andrew (#19) that Moyes is by no means a shoddy manager, and that he deserves all the kudos for getting us to 4th. But in terms of actually learning and applying what he's learnt, especially in the context of having to develop alternative solutions when present solutions aren't working, well, I would argue instead that he hasn't been able to do so. Again, I want to emphasise that Moyes is not a terrible manager - not by a long shot - but we have been stagnant or backsliding for the past few seasons now. For example, if things stand as they are, it'll be the 3rd season in a row that we won't have qualified for Europe ? not to mention the diminishing quality of our football.

A large part of it is down to diminishing finances, but the calibre of a manager is measured in part by his ability to learn and adapt to the existing situation and utilise available resources to the max (à la Guus Hiddink and South Korea or Australia in past world cups)?

In that respect, I don't really see what "alternative solutions" Moyes has developed recently (or over the years) that are adapted to the current situation of the club. Instead, he's continued with his defensive mindset and persisted with his 4-5-1 formation with the usual players (form or natural position notwithstanding) in an attempt to maintain our league position ? not really an example of "alternative solution" or "learning", don't you think?

Unfortunately, this approach has long since been found out by other teams and we are very much the division's one-trick pony when it comes to tactics, players, formation and substitutions.

The funny thing is, reading through both your comments, I actually think that we're all on the same page: Moyes hasn't been able to adapt or apply new solutions to allow us to "get over that final hurdle" in the face of new challenges (which, I agree, would test any manager) or to address the many "weaknesses" that Kevin has pointed out in post #14.

Except my conclusion from that (and based on general observations of Moyes's approach) is that, even though Moyes has consistently led us to top 8 finishes, it is the limit of his capabilities, in no small part because of his inability to learn and apply new solutions to new situations. Whereas it would seem that you see the previous top 8 finishes as evidence of his ability to take us out of the current mess and forward to bigger and better things (if indeed that is the end-game and not simply mid-table security).

Maybe we're all deluded Everton supporters on this site and our passion for the team has blinded us to the reality of what's happening on the field and to the club. And I respect your views of Moyes as a manager. But I just can't see that his past league achievements are evidence of him being a manager who "learns" or is able to come up with alternative solutions... or, more importantly, as someone who is able to take us out of this mess and forward to the next level.
Robbie Shields
22 Posted 13/11/2011 at 07:15:43
Great post Rob. Kevin, whilst I don't agree with your support of Moyes it's refreshing to hear a Moyes supporter that acknowledges all his faults at the same time, it does though indicate a certain amount of blind loyalty to be fair though. A bit like a mum who's little Jimmy goes round causing havoc in the community but who's mum keeps saying "he's a lovely lad our Jimmy, heart of gold, wouldn't hurt a fly, he's just misunderstood".

Regarding your question about comparing the last 10 years under Moyes and the previous 10 years, I've got a couple of points to make. Firstly, Joe Royle won the FA Cup against one of the best United sides SAF ever produced. And secondly, when Johnson didn't back Joe in the transfer market, he told him where to shove it, and walked. Kendall did the same thing when not given money to buy Dion Dublin; Moyes however keeps taking his £3 million a year and complains he has no money. Moyes can't hold a candle to either of them.
Tony Twist
23 Posted 13/11/2011 at 09:53:38
I think Moyes's major failing is his inability to buy players to have a strong 4-4-2 formation. I think on the youth front also the standard of players coming through needs to be better, they just don't seem to be the finished article.

As regards teaching the players, throughout his 10 years in charge there has been little improvement on the teams ability to keep the ball, at one stage we tended to play what I call runaway train football where there would be quick exchange of passing which would look good but ultimately result in the ball being over run to the opposition.

Bring in Bilic I say! A change in manager / coach, though unfortunate, may develop what we have to greater things.
Kevin Hudson
24 Posted 13/11/2011 at 10:26:45
Rob & Robbie,

Both of you raise good points, but the pair of you question whether I?m blinded by devotion or loyalty to Moyes. I believe my subjective admission of his flaws indicates that I?m NOT mindlessly blinded to his shortcomings!

I do not know if privately, Moyes has run out of ideas, but nor do I think we?re a one-trick pony. Most teams - Spain included, tend to deploy a favoured system, and I don?t know of any other manager continually altering formation etc..

I think the fear of decline & the yearning for improvement is what underscores the debate. People see him cutting a forlorn W.Smith-esque demeanour now, which to them, intuits a manager running out of ideas & succumbing to the constraints placed upon him.

Consider again that in 22 seasons, we?ve only finished in the top 7 eight times ? six of them under Moyes, Whilst I acknowledge that our shared aspirations lie much higher than that, to me, that?s an indication of what?s possible, given the right assistance, rather than the fabled glass ceiling.

The bulk of my wrath is directed towards the board?s annual policy of asset-stripping the playing staff, jeopardising the sustainability of progress, and threatening to produce diminishing returns on the park. There?s only so much mythical, magic-wand waving he can do.
Andy Codling
25 Posted 13/11/2011 at 12:12:39
The team for Wolves is one up front and keep it tight... a fortnight of planning has gone into this game because Moyes is always learning and thinking up new ideas!!!!!!!!!!
Dan Brierley
26 Posted 13/11/2011 at 12:13:43
Its another example that all the people that are actually directly involved in the football world don't actually know anything about the game.

Only 'select' people on Toffeeweb actually know the real truth.

I don't get why the manager the highest points per pound spent ratio in Premier League history is constantly held in high regard by football circles. Don't they know that playing players out of position is the reason we keep losing? This squad should be winning the title year in year out...

Chris Smith
27 Posted 13/11/2011 at 12:18:01
To be fair I don't like one up front but do we really have two strikers who are good enough? Vellios has looked good as a sub but was very poor at Fulham. That said, now is the time to try something different. I'm just not sure what it is given the players at our disposal.
Gavin Ramejkis
28 Posted 13/11/2011 at 12:28:57
Kevin the trouble with a stubborn refusal to change the 4-5-1 is what's killing the club. Other teams (including national sides) play it, yes, but look at the actual component parts of those sides, they all have attacking creative midfielders in them.

To truly evolve you need to play the cards you are dealt as a manager, Moyes doesn't have the parts of the 4-5-1 jigsaw that worked in the past for it to work for every game (if any) anymore; a midfield packed with defenders isn't going to create attacking chances, a hoof to an over-the-hill lone striker with his nearest blue shirt often 30 or 40yards behind him isn't going to work anymore.

Evolution (or the lack of it) and learning from some pretty obvious mistakes are what's putting Moyes on the wane. No matter how many smart arse comments others post or comments about the past, they make no difference in the here and now and the short term.
Kevin Hudson
29 Posted 13/11/2011 at 13:03:42
4-5-1 is "killing the club."?

Not sure I agree with that.
Ben Dyke
30 Posted 13/11/2011 at 12:55:50
Moyes is a good manager. End of. He will never be considered great until he has won trophies, whether that is at Everton or not. I personally believe we will not win trophies at Everton with Moyes unless we receive an injection of money from new investors over a few years and allow him to build a new team slowly and progressively.

I have enjoyed far more games under Moyes than under any previous manager except Kendall (I was born in 1973). Any frustrations I have with Moyes stem mainly from the fact that my expectations have greatly increased and it is has been painful that we haven't quite made it (beaten FA Cup Finalists, no Europa League final, no Champs League Group stage). BUT to me we have been fighting with diminishing resources and greater disparity.

After watching Jags and Lescott last night, it made me realise losing Lescott was a watershed really for Moyes unless we get new investment. And without City's resources, I dont think we would have lost him. Cue imminent disdain.
Denis Richardson
31 Posted 13/11/2011 at 14:08:09
I am more interested to know why Klinsmann was at Finch Farm in the first place.

This just a hello call or something else? Would have thought he would have gone to see Manure's training ground or his old pals at Spurs ? maybe he did I cannot remember Moyes having any sort of relationship with Kilnsmann in the past.

Anyway, he's not going to say a bad word about any manager so again this is no real news.

The most important short term item for the club is 3 points against Wolves next weekend ? performance totally irrelavent, we have to take 3 points.

John #8 ? very funny....
Col Noon
32 Posted 13/11/2011 at 15:28:24
Denis #30

"I'm more interested to know why Klinsmann was at Finch Farm in the first place."

Didn't you hear that "genunine" talks are ongoing regading investment? Maybe he's in to buy the club. We have SUPPOSED interest from: Indians, Americans, Asians. Why not throw a German in there with a dodgy yank accent. Fuck, we could make it a Kenwright theatre production.

Any ideas on a name for this proposed piece of panto genius???
Gavin Ramejkis
33 Posted 13/11/2011 at 17:23:06
Kevin, how many times will we see Moyes throw a striker to the dogs by playing them as a lone striker yards away from support so they are written up as having poor games? ? Beckford last season, never a lone striker in his life... or the boy Vellios this season at Fulham?

The two are examples of strikers clearly out of their depth or skillset being wasted as a lone striker yet Moyes sticks with it, thus killing chances of winning a game (yes we won at Fulham before I get a smart arse response).

The trouble is why don't we play players in a position which would see their potential and not ones which Moyes refuses to see doesn't work and loses the chance to take a game? My conclusion to that is that it is killing the club and chances of gaining points.
Kevin Hudson
34 Posted 13/11/2011 at 17:43:59
Gavin,

See post 14.
Tony Twist
35 Posted 13/11/2011 at 20:52:40
So early in the season but the Wolves match is so important, I just hope the boys in blue prove me wrong and stroll to a win but I think it's going to be QPR all over again. Just hope its not a draw, a loss and things might get done, a win and everyone's happy but a draw is just papering over the cracks of yet again poor preparation to a vital game.
John Barnes
36 Posted 14/11/2011 at 02:59:48
Tony, "Something might get done" if we lose to Wolves. First Ive heard a sort of tripping point put on the present situation. But something, surely, will have to be done if we keep losing matches, no matter who against. I wonder at what point we all think that might be? A lot of blues are expecting our season "to turn around" as in the past, but at what point do we expect to see "something done?"
Brian Harrison
37 Posted 14/11/2011 at 12:57:56
I think it might be worth pointing out that Moyes bought Jagielka and Lescott for peanuts and after their display against Spain, look Englands best centre back pairing. Then add Baines who is unlucky to be up against the best left back in World football.

Moyes is also critisized for his lack of tactical awareness, yet he was the first manager to man mark David Silva, and I dont think Silva had his usual impact on the game.

I would just add not only has he had no money to spend in the last 3 windows, he has also had to sell his better players.
He had built a very succesful team but a lack of finances meant the likes of Rooney,Lescott.Pienaar,Arteta,Yakubu and Gosling. I doubt if any club could flourish under these circumstances
Ciarán McGlone
38 Posted 14/11/2011 at 13:17:11
Brian,

Are you seriously lauding Moyes for his approach to the Man City game?

Frankly I thought it was the must pathetic capitulation I've seen under Moyes.

By the way, the thread is about whether Moyes capacity to learn...it is not about whether he's been handicaped financially. One can be analysed quite independently of the other.
Tony J Williams
39 Posted 14/11/2011 at 13:23:53
Ciaran, I doubt he is lauding Moyes at all. However, he is, in a sense, applauding the tactical move to man mark Silva out of the game.

It was workind until the defected goal, I don;t thing I have seen Silva have a quieter game. I have stated aswel that I think Rodwell had his best game for us too, especially after receiving a early yellow.

Posters are saying that Moyes doesn't learn, he certainly learned that if you man mark Silva out of the game they aren't going to as good going forward but it all fell apart when they scored their deflected goal.

As usual with the league leaders, not many teams will go there and get much, especially now Mancini had got his team attacking, insteading being defensive. But Hey Ho! when you have ooodles of money to spend, you can change things.
Kevin Hudson
40 Posted 14/11/2011 at 14:54:05
Now hang on a minute, Tony..

You can't get away with claiming that Mancini's millions have aided his "capacity to learn.."
Nick Entwistle
41 Posted 14/11/2011 at 15:01:43
How was Everton's approach different to England Spain? Sometimes it works, sometimes it don't.
Ciar�n McGlone
42 Posted 14/11/2011 at 15:04:52
Firstly, I don't agree that he man marked Silva out of the game....He was certainly quieter than usual, but he still ran the game - even though he was being man marked.

Secondly, people are not stating that Moyes doesn't learn anything at all...they are stating, quite correctly, that there is evidence to show that Moyes is repeating mistakes he's been making since he came to this club ten years ago...the argument is that Moyes is a constant learner - the facts say otherwise.

Thirdly, I fail to see the relevance of Cappello in a thread about David Moyes...but in answer to your question..the two approaches differed because Capello allowed his players to go forward for set pieces, and even play counter attacking football...Moyes did not.
Tony J Williams
43 Posted 14/11/2011 at 15:16:18
Let's agree to disagree on the Silva point Ciaran.
Nick Entwistle
44 Posted 14/11/2011 at 16:45:57
Failing to see the relevance, you sure know how to answer the question.
Ciar�n McGlone
45 Posted 14/11/2011 at 17:01:18
Ok yoda.
Nick Entwistle
46 Posted 14/11/2011 at 17:11:22
Ok chief.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads