Everton investigate leaked e.mails

, 18 November, 35comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Prentice claims in the Echo that Everton have launched an internal investigation into a series of e.mails that appeared last night on one of our discussion threads, posted by a reader registered under the name "Ethan Dyer". The authenticity and legality of the e.mails was questioned and they were subsequently removed.

The emails, some purporting to be from Everton's Director of Communications, Ian Ross, were highly critical of CEO Robert Elstone's leadership and described working at Goodison Park as like ?working in a kindergarten.?

Other matters discussed include Everton's PR strategy surrounding the protest march by the Blue Union fans' group in September, a growing air of ?paranoia? inside the football club and talk of ?financial meltdown? at the club.

Other emails published last night contain correspondence between Will Hanrahan, a Bootle-born former broadcast journalist, and Ross.

At this stage, it is not known whether the e.mails are authentic; however, the Echo has learned today an immediate probe into how they appear to have been received by parties outside of the club, has been launched.

Club officials have not commented but a series of urgent meetings are now underway discussing the issue.

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (35)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Daniel Hollingworth
1 Posted 18/11/2011 at 12:47:39
Does anyone have the e.mails that Robert Elstone and Ian Ross are alleged to have sent to one another, and what exactly do people make of it?
Matt Traynor
2 Posted 18/11/2011 at 14:43:13
Daniel, the NSNO site has them, as apparently the TW server was overloaded. Hence this was obviously a ploy by MK and LL to boost traffic and advertising $$$s!

See http://www.nsno.co.uk/forums/index.php/topic,15350.105.html for more discussion, including a user who will wait until the club comments formally before deciding if its genuine... BU - why do you bother?
John Talbot
3 Posted 18/11/2011 at 14:47:47
Pretty cynical if its a fake. Not something I would want to be associated with, things at Goodison are bad enough as it is.
Art Jones
4 Posted 18/11/2011 at 14:55:28
If this is an elaborate hoax it certainly has taken a massive effort and research. Not impossible of course but how likely? It's easily checkable by the club, starting by asking Elstone and Ross if any of their correspondence actually happened.

If this has come from someone within the club, what are their motives? Career enhancement by someone perchance?
Paul Lally
5 Posted 18/11/2011 at 14:47:28
Matt@2
The internal investigation would suggest that the emails are genuine. Otherwise, surely the club would act swiftly and decisively, issue a formal statement saying the emails are false and that they are investigating and passing all relevant information onto the police.

Plus we all care about our club, so I would imagine that is why the BU bother.

'Matt Traynor doth protest too much, methinks.'

COYB
Matt Traynor
6 Posted 18/11/2011 at 15:22:55
Paul #5, I am not protesting at all. I think you are confusing me with someone else!

For the avoidance of doubt however:-

? I snipe at the editors re driving traffic, very much tongue in cheek
? I link to NSNO where the full thread is posted

? I refer to a user on NSNOwho states words to the effect of "he will wait until the club confirms it before deciding whether to believe it", and my questioning of why BU bother was, again, tongue in cheek.
Peter Laing
7 Posted 18/11/2011 at 15:24:27
I cut and paste the entire content of the e-mails when they appeared on TW last night and were swiftly removed for obvious reasons.
Eugene Ruane
8 Posted 18/11/2011 at 15:46:19
If it was false, I haven't seen so much time and effort put into a hoax since the Hitler Diaries.
Paul Holden
9 Posted 18/11/2011 at 15:52:49
I think it would be fair to say that the club is very close to meltdown, both on and off the pitch. Saturday should be interesting!
Paul Lally
11 Posted 18/11/2011 at 16:29:27
Matt@6

Sorry... right over my head your earlier post. Just re-read and got it.

I am protesting tomorrow so maybe a tad over-protective.
COYB
Lyndon Lloyd
Editorial Team
12 Posted 18/11/2011 at 16:54:16
We've been a lightning rod for controversy enough times in the past but I'm dismayed that it's ToffeeWeb being associated in the press now with this leak, to be honest.
Gavin Ramejkis
13 Posted 18/11/2011 at 17:59:53
Rumour has it Ian Ross suspended over it

http://www.nsno.co.uk/everton-news/2011/11/everton-suspend-ian-ross/
John Audsley
14 Posted 18/11/2011 at 18:03:22
All I can say is that, when Ian Ross has replied to my pretty reasonable e.mails, it's always been with anger and arrogance.

The man is a disgrace to EFC in my opinion.
Adam Bennett
15 Posted 18/11/2011 at 18:10:14
.... and here is a statement from Robert Elstone:

http://www.evertonfc.com/evertoninteractive/message-to-evertonians
Derek Williams
16 Posted 18/11/2011 at 18:24:37
I read the comments before they were taken down and they looked confused enough to be genuine in my opinion i.e. if someone was going to make it up they would have looked more 'manufactured' or 'contrived' if that makes sense. The interesting bit above is that the club deny their authenticity but are launching an immediate probe to ascertain how they've been received by parties outside the club. Eh??? That makes no sense at all.
Matt Traynor
17 Posted 18/11/2011 at 18:45:28
Derek, I didn't read RE's blog as denying the authenticity of the emails. His phrasing along the lines of alleged email leak is clear to me.

Problem with emails, texts etc. is it's impossible to read much if anything about someone's tone - especially if they're pushed for time.

Down the years, I've seen email correspondence used in many court cases, and indeed in some jurisdictions emails can be construed as a form of contract, depending on their context. I've seen a company where an exec accepted an event sponsorship deal via email, only for the senior management to kick it out. The easy solution was to suck it up and commit to the $1m sponsorship. Instead they got dragged to court, settled out of court (to keep it out of the press) for the $1m plus costs, and got none of the branding!

Suffice to say, a lot of organisations now operate with a philosophy that an email is public, and hence why you can not get anything done by email. (And if you try to get them on the phone, they're too busy replying to emails).

This technology guff was supposed to make our lives easier?
Paddy James
18 Posted 18/11/2011 at 18:58:48
Elstone is not denying it in his, no doubt, carefully worded statement. If they were not genunine emails then surely he would just come out and say so?

If they are true then as a club it looks like we are indeed in big trouble, with the boardroom at war, Bill isolated and a chief exec allegedly having a "breakdown".

I've been critical of TW in the past because of it's agenda, but have to concede I had no idea the club was in such a state at a senior level. But also the emails make no mention of BK "holding out" for a high offer from any interested parties, so not much ammo for them on that front.
John Keating
19 Posted 18/11/2011 at 19:07:33
Just read Elstone's statement. If the leaked e-mails are a hoax why didn't he just say it was all a lie ? end of story! Possibly there is something in it.

Is this the same legal team they threaten everyone with who dares comment on anything Everton??

Have they sued anyone yet??
Wayne Smyth
20 Posted 18/11/2011 at 19:23:57
John, its clear to me that the emails are genuine, not just from the emails, but from Elstone's response. What I'm reading from Elstone's blog on the OS could well be directed at Ian Ross as "trying to undermine" his position.

If he thought Ross was innocent or they were trying to cover it up, I'd expect a no-nonsense statement explicitly saying that Ross and Elstone are working together well as a team, etc and that they'd find out who was responsible, yada, yada.

Only conclusion you can draw from all this is that the lunatics are indeed running the asylum. With these clowns in charge, it's no wonder the club is in such a mess. Give me competent business people ahead of "blue" chairman & board any day of the week.
Anthony Manning
21 Posted 18/11/2011 at 20:52:55
Gavin #12, you're right ? Ross has been suspended, which to me suggests the e.mails are true.
If and when it is confirmed, surely that spells the end of Kenwright once and for all.
Matt Traynor
22 Posted 18/11/2011 at 21:13:08
Paddy (#16), the emails include an exchange from Ross and someone called Colin Bates, where there is mention of 25% of the club being sold for "upwards of £25m".

Therefore that can be interpreted a number of ways, as others have done. Valuing of the club is by no means straightforward, but that is clearly suggesting a value that is significantly higher than shares currently trade at, which is also significantly higher than the price paid per share by the original TBH investors.
Tommy Heskrth
23 Posted 18/11/2011 at 21:30:26
Has anyone got a link to the emails? I've not read them and just wanted to know roughly the content and if indeed they are a smoking gun?
Anthony Manning
24 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:18:19
The Echo will pour cold water on these e mail claims as one of the e mails suggests that the " Echo owe Everton a favour" which discredits that red rag as much as it does Kenwright.
Paddy James
25 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:24:02
All that means, Matt, surely, is the price of the shares have appreciated? Which is no surprise given the influx of cash into the game since BK bought his shares.

I don't think it can be shown from that exchange that BK is over-valuing the club.

There is also talk of investment. There is no suggestion of investors waiting in the wings to take over but being put off by BK because his asking price is too high.

That is of course if the emails are in fact genuine.
John Malone
26 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:29:40
I read it all last night and the whole thing stinks of BU trying to stir it up, it's bang out of order like the recording situation. Well done lads making the club look good again! Good work just what we need at the minute, how far are you willing to go to get kenwright out. There's ways and means of doing things and airing dirty laundry is low and lacks class. In my opinion it stinks and I can't believe an evertonian would back stab the club in this way, it;s knocking me sick to see what's going on around the club.
Anthony Manning
27 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:44:05
John shall we just all sit back then and let Kenwright get on with running of the club? safe and sound knowing he`s doing a sterling job.
Phil Martin
28 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:00:22
Why would you launch an investigation if they're false?
John Malone
29 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:57:45
Na mate, if you believe change is needed, fair enough... but get the point across in a decent manner and not dragging the club's name through the mud, making a laughing stock of our club.

The emails never even had any substance, no bombshell just the usual snipes and jibes you get in any workplace. In my opinion, a bit of propaganda by BU to cause trouble within EFC hierarchy; classic war strategy ? divide and conquer!
Anthony Manning
30 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:13:22
No substance you say... our Director of Communications states in the e.mail that Kenwright is heading for a breakdown, that he should be sectioned, that the Echo owe us favours!! Fucking very substantial if you ask me mate. The only people who are dragging the club's name through the mud is the board.
John Daley
31 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:10:25
"I can't believe an Evertonian would back stab the club in this way"

But it's ok for the board to strangle the life out of the club though? I guess instigating a media campaign to cultivate tension amongst the fan base is fair game as well?
"Dragging the club's name through the mud, making a laughing stock of our club"

C'mon, they don't need any help on that score.
Derek Thomas
32 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:04:26
John Malone, get off your high horse. The truth has to come out or be found out. This regime and I use the word fully realising the other connotations the word has in say relation to Syria, Burma ( I refuse to use the other pretendy name ) for in footballing terms this is what they are a regime...one that needs toppling. The day we can push over the giant figurative statue of Kenwright that stands over Goodison the better.

Just like Lybia nobody can say for certain what the future holds but there is an opportunity for a clean slate and take it from there.
Eric Myles
33 Posted 19/11/2011 at 10:49:48
John #28 "a bit of propaganda by BU to cause trouble within EFC hierarchy; classic war strategy ? divide and conquer! "

That's the Club strategy, not BU. The board have continually tried to divide the fanbase over every issue.

More likely these emails are a 'false flag' operation to con the gullible fans into discrediting BU just a day before a protest.

The same gullible fans that think 'cos Fellaini signed we must be getting taken over because of rumours of an Indian company interest.
Mick Gallagher
34 Posted 19/11/2011 at 11:09:51
John #28 another post slagging the blue Union but singing the praises of the board. Make you mind up mate at least there trying to do something and highlights what going with the board. So you want him out but dont want the Blue Union do it this way. Can you tell me John what is the best way of doing it.
Chris Jones [NZ]
35 Posted 19/11/2011 at 11:32:49
I can fully understand the desire, expressed by some in this thread, to read the e-mails (we all love the club and want the best for it it, and this naturally makes us thirst for information) but surely any info here was gained illegally.

The fact that any of the contents of people's private correspondence has been placed in the public domain should be deplored as an invasion of privacy and possibly 'criminal' also. To want to see and discuss the contents of e-mails amounts to a legitimisation of the actions of scumbags like the News of the Screws.
Alan Rooney
36 Posted 19/11/2011 at 11:58:34
If true, it might be immoral to release these emails, but it might not be illegal - presumably that would depend on the contract that was signed by the leaker! (unless of course somebody broke in to EFC and stole the PC or its content).
Reading Elstone's cleverly worded statement, he refers to an "alleged email leak of private correspondence" not an 'email leak of alleged private correspondence'.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads