Blue Union case restated

, 18 November, 70comments  |  Jump to most recent
Dave Kelly interviewed at Sabotage Times
Ahead of this weekend's second protest march, one of the Blue Union leaders, Dave Kelly, talks to Steven Tudor at the Sabotage Times, where their case for continued protest against stagnation of the club is presented. Dave Kelly expresses his exasperation with the local media for failing to pursue the issues raised because, he believes do, they not want to jeopardise their close links with the club.

The fight continues because Everton are still stagnating and under the stewardship of a chairman who is generally considered to be well-meaning but hopelessly out of his depth the club remain in a seemingly irreversible financial mire that prevents progress. As the Swiss Ramble website so succinctly put it recently, theirs is a business model that is bust.

It is, on the surface at least, a baffling state of affairs. Everton have been ever-presents in the Premier League — that's eighteen years of windfalls and riches — and they have never been ones to spend beyond their means... Yet, as harsh as this sounds, they have become paupers in the golden palace, with an estimated debt of £45m which has required them to sell off their training ground and outsource profitable revenue streams such as merchandise and catering.

Hindered by a ground in desperate need of updating (their lack of corporate facilities alone limits them greatly in relation to their Prem peers), and with commercial operations that bring in a third of Tottenham's revenue, the solution solely lies in investment and change.

The Blue Union have found themselves ignored time and again when it comes to getting their efforts recognized in the local media. Dave Kelly believes it is because the Liverpool newspapers do not want to jeopardise the close links they have built up with the club.

"At our first meeting at Zeligs in Liverpool there was 700 people there, including Howard Kendall and the F.A Cup on display. Sky covered it amongst others but the local media did not. The Liverpool Echo were in attendance but evidently were not there in a professional capacity as no coverage appeared anywhere. For our second meeting — even though it was an international weekend — the local media informed us it was not sufficiently newsworthy. During a subsequent demonstration there was a call from the floor for a boycott of local media. There is a feeling of being let down by them."

Quotes or other material sourced from Sabotage Times



Reader Comments (70)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


James Morgan
1 Posted 18/11/2011 at 20:02:20
The Echo are clowns and deserve to be treated as such.

The Blue Union have my full backing as they only want to see the club move forward and compete in the PL. Those that shoot them down and abuse them, call them kopites etc should be ashamed.
Colin Wainwright
2 Posted 18/11/2011 at 20:09:04
I agree, James.

There is something rotten at the core of the club and the BU are doing their best to extract it, not sticking their head in the sand.

Fully behind them.

Ian Edwards
3 Posted 18/11/2011 at 20:15:32
Their credibility is reduced in my view by their support for Moyes. A positive campaign doesn't sit well with backing for a negative Manager.
Ged Alexander
4 Posted 18/11/2011 at 20:30:32
They are howling at the moon
John Malone
5 Posted 18/11/2011 at 20:54:50
Tell you what then if blue union are so great tell me there solution to our money problems and what business model they would put in place. It's easy to criticise and say so and so's not doing their job, why not put their effort into finding the inestor/investment instead of causing a bad vibe at the ground were we go to back our team. Coming out and just saying new investment and change doesn't cut it! What do they honestly Kenwright and the board are doing? I'll give you's just taster of how hard they're trying, my mate started off a small business and registered on google, within days of being on he had a random phone call off e.f.c. asking who he was and was he interested in investing in the club! Now that's only one thing that I know of imagine how many other avenue's the club are trying to gain investment. BU's heart is in the right place we all want the best for our beloved everton and I believe that goes for kenwright aswell, after all he is an evertonian!!!
Anthony Manning
6 Posted 18/11/2011 at 21:14:09
John#5, your comments are so naive it`s unreal, Everton under Kenwright is a sham which the BU have exposed, how can the BU attract a buyer/investment when none of us know the price Kenwright wants! "after all he`s a evertonian" still falling for the boys pen rubbish John.
Danny Broderick
7 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:01:17
John,
Your story is just plain daft. It's not for the Blue Union to run the club,it's for the current board - that's right,the same board under whom we have broken even once in the last 8 years - the year we sold Rooney. Despite being pretty much ever present in the top 8 all that time,Cup Finals,Europe etc. They couldn't organize a piss up in a brewery.
Anyhow,I better go, I'm expecting Kenwright on the phone trying to sell Everton to me...
John Daley
8 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:08:03
"I'll give you's just taster of how hard they're trying, my mate started off a small business and registered on Google. Within days of being on he had a random phone call off EFC asking who he was and was he interested in investing in the club!"

Fuck me. They'll be standing outside the train station soon saying "Any spare change, guv?".
John Malone
9 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:09:27
What do you want the man to do? Sell to who? Do the decent thing and let it go to who? For how much? what difference does that make if you know that! Your not gonna buy it are you! You lot are the one's who are naive the man's a self made millionaire knows more about business than everyone on here put together! He's come out publicly and said for a couple of seasons now he want's to sell so what do you want him to do? Come on BU supporters tell me!
Gavin Ramejkis
10 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:27:22
John your beloved self made millionaire has had 12 fucking years in charge, he hasn't spent a single penny of his own money to the benefit of the club beyond the shares he owns and even they were bought for by a former friend he stabbed in the back to keep control. Roll over the twelve years of lies, two failed ground moves and as has already been stated the only year in recent times of a profit was due to the sale of a player and NOT the wy he has run the business.

Given all of these pretty clear and undeniable facts evidenced not in hearsay but in the annual accounts you still stand by him being the best person to own and run the club into the ground? At what point in twelve years of failure do you think is a reasonable point to admit you are out of your depth and sell up?
a. whilst the company still has assets?
b. whilst the company still has a squad of a reasonable size in comparison to its peer group?
c. when the company has been asset stripped down to the playing staff and has burdened itself with piss poor marketing and sponsorship deals, a training facility that will cost an absolute fortune to ever pay off, your television rights through membership of the EPL hocked for the next two years?
d. when the administrators say you have to?

Just interested at what point exactly it would be suitable in your mind for the single worst chairman in the club's entire history to finally relinquish control and admit he really hasn't got a fucking clue what he is doing to the club he reputedly loves so much.
Danny Broderick
11 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:28:00
For a start John,he could name a price - £30 million or whatever, and that would start the ball rolling. That alone would help the sale by generating interest.
If he doesn't want to do that,he could reveal what the stumbling block was with all of the parties who have shown an interest but not made firm offers. Why is that? It has to be because the price is unrealistic. Either that or he is not looking to step aside,only seeking investment. It can't be right that half the clubs in Britain have now been sold - some twice - yet we are expected to believe no-one would buy us because we share a city with Liverpool,or aren't based in London,etc. He's running out of excuses.
Anthony Manning
12 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:27:25
John#9, sell to who you say, in the last 5 years 12 premier league clubs have been sold some of them twice over. all the man has done is to oversee disaster after disaster, Kings dock, DK, sports fortress, Everton place etc etc etc, just writing those facts is boring and old hat and shows how out of touch you are. Take your Kenwright tinted spectacles off John and wake up.
Danny Broderick
13 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:36:27
All Blues should boycott the Echo. As the e-mails revealed,the club were due to call in favours to keep the fans on side. The job of the local media should be to report the news. At the end of the day,Everton fans represent one half of the city,and consequently half of the Echo's customers. They deserve to be told the truth,not just soundbites from the club. The Echo has let the Blue half of Merseyside down badly by refusing to acknowledge any hint of unrest this summer. They have tried to paint a picture of everything being rosy,and not portrayed a true picture of the fans feelings at all. Instead of being the voice of the people,they have made it harder for the people to have a voice. They have been complicit in the club's shenanigans. Corrupt journalism should be treated with the contempt it deserves - boycott the paper.
John Malone
14 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:43:05
Gavin I never said he was the best chairman in the world! It makes me laugh to see how people love to jump on the slag kenwright bandwagon, you said in 12 years he's done nothing he brought in David Moyes give him financial backing to build a whole new squad, turned the club around from relegation battlers to top half european place contenders, into the champions league and into an F.A cup final. I asked the question what do you want to him do? Fair enough he hasn't come out said how much he wants but it's not good business to show all your cards. At the end of the day ask yourself the question does Kenwright want the best for everton? I believe he does!
Anthony Manning
15 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:53:02
Well said Dan i haven`t bought that shit red rag since the summer, they bent over backwards to help Liverpool get rid of Hicks and Gilette and stick the middle finger up to us well fuck them.
Trevor Mackie
16 Posted 18/11/2011 at 22:39:47
I really can't understand how anyone who has read the BU interview with Kenwright can accept he is of sound mind, let alone capable of managing an £80m turn over business.

I'm at the point of despising all things EFC, any leak or utterance from these twats just widens the chasm between an ordinary blue like me and these absolute fuckin' tits.

All and sundry involved in the loss of expectation at this club to a point where survival in the division is all we have need chasing out of GP and never allowed back.

It's all about a return for Kenwright and his cronies and it's a scandal after what they've done.
Anthony Manning
17 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:02:44
John you say Kenwright has financialy backed Moyes to build a team, when? Moyes net spend is 15m in 10 years! We haven`t bought a player for 2 years in fact we are the only profesional club in England not to have bought anyone this year! They say love is blind but you take the biscuit.
Brendan McLaughlin
18 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:10:42
Trevor #16
"at the point of despising all things EFC"... I can't understand anyone who made that comment.."is of sound mind"?
John Malone
19 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:18:01
LIsten I want Kenwright out and I want a new board with more doe, but I don't want us to end up like brum, portsmouth, the first lot of yanks at the r.s., my argument is getting rid of this chairman and board brings in who? To be honest I reckon this Jain group deal is gonna come off and hopefully we'll all be happier!
Trevor Mackie
20 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:20:03
Brendan

Your use of quotation marks is pointless.

Your sentence remains intact without them .....

.... possibly reinforced without the misjudged attempt at wit.
Kevin Tully
21 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:41:50
Wow John Malone,

WE HAVE NOT BOUGHT A PLAYER FOR OVER TWO YEARS.

GET IT NOW?
Mick Gallagher
22 Posted 18/11/2011 at 23:58:29
Well John you have posted 3 times the first backing billy bullshit and slagging the blue union . The last one saying you want him out so poor billy bullshit has lost another fan.
Phil Bellis
23 Posted 19/11/2011 at 00:02:48
Fuck'n ell Mr Malone!
Quickest conversion since the road to Damascus
John Daley
24 Posted 19/11/2011 at 00:03:41
"I want a new board with more doe"

A few more female antelope or Duke of Edinburgh awards would come in well handy. I'd rather have someone with shitloads of cash though.

As for the Jain group 'deal'? I won't hold my breath. I think that's more dead in the water than Robert Maxwell and Josef Mengele.
Gavin Ramejkis
25 Posted 19/11/2011 at 00:04:51
John a few tidbits for you

Moyes was recommended to BK by Walter Smith, want to remind us all of who he wanted instead?

The squad building you speak of was funded by Sky money (you know the stuff even a chimp would get if they were chairman), bank loans using the club turnover as collateral (again a chimp as chairman could have done this) and finally player sales (hmm not looking good this one as well the players were either here already - Rooney, or paid for by the first two - Lescott), as far as league places, European games and cup matches go I'd be inclined to question what the chairman did exactly to achieve these sitting on his arse in the stands (that's of course when he turns up)

A beneficial chairman would either be speculating their own cash and looking for a return on investment such as ground upgrades and taking a slice from increased revenue or selling the club at a profit, BK has done neither and looks for a profit so in answer to your final line I think BK's interest is purely BK. A beneficial chairman would bring a short, medium and long term strategy to the business and employ a team of suitably skilled professionals to make it happen, explore match and non match day revenue streams and expand the business instead we have a chairman who has let the business run to rat shit without even a short term plan

Again, doing nothing is no longer an option, BK has had 12 years of just that and were are we now?
John Daley
26 Posted 19/11/2011 at 00:16:28
Gary Megson? ( even a chimp as chairman would shake his head, rip up his c.v. and start chucking his turd at him.)
John Malone
27 Posted 19/11/2011 at 00:34:36
Mick 22, if you read them properly mate I never backed kenwright and his regime I said he's an evertonian and there's evidence of them searching for new investment. I want change and improvement as much as the next blue.

Gavin, you're still slagging Kenwright off which I'm not arsed about, fair enough, he could've, should've done more... the man is far from perfect ? no-one is. State as many nerdy facts as you want, my point was I believe him to have the club's best interests at heart and WHO IS GOING TO TAKEOVER AND DO BETTER?? ? WHO????
Gavin Ramejkis
28 Posted 19/11/2011 at 01:12:13
John Malone - ANYONE, trouble is we've had to wait 12 years and until the club is on its arse and even now there's no clear evidence BK is actively seeking a buyer. After so many lies and so many false dawns to sell tickets to the gullible you'll have to admit he is guilty of that I and many others won't even believe that until I see the door hitting his arse on the way out.
James Flynn
29 Posted 19/11/2011 at 02:03:23
1. Why is the BU worried about a local newspaper? It's all over the internet about the BU. I have to assume the internet there has rendered the print media as near-irrelevant as it has over here.

So David Kelly, take a deep breath. The local newspapers will come along eventually. Stop worrying about them. As far as disseminating info (or taken seriously) is concerned, they're marginal.

2. Why the occasional animosity here towards the BU? Whoever they are, they're pushing for improvement of the Club. You there have a closer look at everything, but why this animosity?

3. I don't question for a second that being part of the ownership which bought EFC was a thrill for Kenwright as a life-long Everton fan. Good for him.

But there's no denying that ownership group didn't know what to do with the Club once the purchase was made; particularly as the "cost of doing EPL business" escalated over the years. Most particularly, as the obvious and simple revenue stream avenues were sold off instead of being taken advantage of.

4. My take? BK was funded by backers who saw a major payday in the new stadium happening and the resultant financial windfall of selling to the highest bidder. Didn't happen.

Why they've stumbled along since instead of dumping EFC as soon as possible, I don't get.
Mick Davies
30 Posted 19/11/2011 at 05:18:22
I have just cancelled my Echo delivery, ironically on the day they DID run a good article concerning the BU march and the reasons behind it. I can't stand the rag any more with it's Sun style celebrity crap and X-Factor girlie mag style coverage. And fuckin Pete Price must be the world's worst ass-licker who'd do anything for publicity.

As for BK, the Kings Dock fiasco really done it for me. £30m for a prestigious stadium on one of the world's most iconic waterfronts and he couldn't be arsed raising this relatively modest amount. What would our club be worth now if he'd carried it through?

Would we still have Rooney and God knows who else could have been tempted to star in such a magnificent arena? He should get some backing to support his dynasty or find someone who'll take this club back to it's rightful place among the elite of English football.
Eric Myles
31 Posted 19/11/2011 at 05:57:59
John Malone "At the end of the day ask yourself the question does Kenwright want the best for Everton? I believe he does! "

Kenwright only wants the best for Kenwright.
Eric Myles
32 Posted 19/11/2011 at 06:18:48
John #27 "WHO IS GOING TO TAKEOVER AND DO BETTER?? ? WHO???? "

ME, I'll do it.
Eric Myles
33 Posted 19/11/2011 at 06:27:52
Mick #30 "As for BK, the Kings Dock fiasco really done it for me. £30m for a prestigious stadium on one of the world's most iconic waterfronts and he couldn't be arsed raising this relatively modest amount."

But he was happy to raise £79 million for Despertaion Kirkby.

*shakes head*
John Keating
34 Posted 19/11/2011 at 09:53:35
Just read the O'Keefe article in the Post. Absolute joke and I think this will no doubt convince anyone who has any doubt whatsoever where the Echo sits on Club and supporters.
He reckons the paper has been balanced. Fucking unbelievable !!
He reckons he shouldn't have to report on what " a few thousand " supporters want just because they differ from the status quo.
Even if ONE supporter has a legitimate concern the fucking LOCAL paper should at least give them a hearing !!!
Sorry guys it really has reached that point where this shit rag of a Local paper has to be boycotted !! Afair reporting system is an impossibility.
Wayne Smyth
35 Posted 19/11/2011 at 10:02:43
If Kenwright wanted the best for EFC, he'd sell his shareholding for what he paid, plus interest to cover inflation. That would be the "fair" thing to do if he had the clubs best interests at heart. I'm sure that kind of offer would also have investors queuing around the block.

However, I don't see Kenwright as being any different from any other investor. He wants someone to pay him £100M+ for his shareholding so he can get a big fat payday. Which is fine, and is what most rational businessmen would do, but not someone with the clubs interests first.

Given that he is self-interested, I'd rather take a chairman with some sound financial backing and business acumen over Kenwright who has no financial backing and has thus crippled the club to paying 10%+ interest rates on our loans to keep us operating.
Liam Appleby
36 Posted 19/11/2011 at 10:30:59
Blue Union doing another protest march.

*Game changing......



*(not really...bore off)

Brian Waring
37 Posted 19/11/2011 at 11:47:05
John Malone, if, as you say, BK has the best interests of the club at heart, then why, when we had the chance of a stadium at the Kings dock,that would have been one of the best in Europe, didn't he take the deal offered by Gregg?
Dennis Stevens
38 Posted 19/11/2011 at 19:16:05
"At the end of the day ask yourself the question does Kenwright want the best for everton? I believe he does!" Totally irrelevant, John. I'd suggest you ask yourself whether Kenwright & the rest of the Board are capable of delivering the best for Everton - I believe they've repeatedly proven they're utterly incapable & incompetent. Whatever their intentions may be, I don't wish to see them paving our road to whatever Division 2 is now called.
Brian Harrison
39 Posted 20/11/2011 at 11:46:50
I think the simple fact is that Everton as a business is not profitable. Hence the call for a new owner with deep pockets to come in and build a new ground and pump millions into buying new players.

Apart from a select few, most clubs try and balance the books, so the survival of most Premier League clubs relies mainly on Sky money and sponsorship. Which is precisely what Everton have done, only sometimes they have spent a little above their income. They have also tried to maximise their income by some outsourcing... not sure how profitable doing that has proved.

So, given the fact that we spend nearly all of what money we get (and, as far as I am aware, Kenwright takes no money out of the pot) then we need somebody spending a minimum of £400 million of his own money with absolutely no return on his investment ever. I would think trying to find someone of that ilk would take some finding. So, until that happens, I am afraid we have no choice but to live within our income, as even the banks have closed their doors on any future borrowing to buy players.
Kevin Corness
40 Posted 20/11/2011 at 15:01:44
I've been reading all the comments on this page with interest.

What I've realised is we all agree that things are not perfect behind the scenes and we urgently need invetment not only in the team but also in improving the facilities at Goodison Park.

I was at Goodison yesterday as the protest was in process and, while I agree with Blue Union in principle, I do not think the majority of Blues would agre with the chants coming from fellow Blues.

One of the reasons we will struggle for investment is the need for a new ground. Maybe the move to Knowsley would've helped but we will never know... I for one think we should force a change but not by trying to split the fan base.
Alan Williams
41 Posted 21/11/2011 at 08:12:03
Regarding the main article, the local media haven?t reported too much for the simple fact that maybe the BU is losing public support, first meeting 700 people, first march 400 and in the Sunday papers just 250?

Why are the numbers dropping so much? Well I can?t say but my friend called me on Saturday whilst I was heading home on the train and one of the local phone-in said there was more people in the Blue Star Chippy than on the march. Whilst amusing, I feel the BU is becoming a laughing stock with a lot of fans which is a shame. They are not my cup of tea at all but I do believe having a fans group of some sort connected with the club is a real benefit to every EFC fan.

BU ? please try and open up dialogue with the board and do your best to repair what?s gone on, because moving forward we need to be united as a fans group so we need both sides to swallow some pride, the way forward is to have dialogue with the board not march against it. This is not your personal fight like some on this site seem to think, the club belongs to all of us emotionally whether we support the current custodians or not.

Marching is clearly not embracing the average fan so look at alternative ways of bringing the fans together; if the BU wants to be a credible fans group then this should be your priority, be clever with your opposition ? not industrial. COYB
Gavin Ramejkis
42 Posted 21/11/2011 at 09:00:14
Some whoppers on here. Alan you really need to check a few things for yourself before making statements. Google the photos of the first march and be completely honest and ask yourself if that really looks like 400. Then have a look at the photos of Saturday's march and ask yourself again does that really look like 250 ? this is almost as laughable as the club mouthpiece Sharp claiming it was a bloke and his dog, completely disingenuous.

Kevin, the move to Knowsley was wrong on so many fronts but to even think it remotely could have helped is again fantasy, read the many articles about DK and then think again.

Brian, whilst living within your means is a truly admirable achievement ask yourself how other teams who have regularly finished below Everton who by no means have the largest wage bill in the EPL but have been burdened with some atrocious business decisions. Finch Farm, "other operating costs", loans against EPL membership with the next two years having been spent, players and former training ground sold with no return investment into the squad beyond a recent wage increase for one player having lost five since the start of last season.

The business is being ran incredibly badly not astutely and those bad decisions are coming home to roost to the detriment of the club's capabilities on the pitch ? its bread and butter membership of the EPL.
Peter Laing
43 Posted 21/11/2011 at 09:07:16
In short, Alan Williams, this whole issue of investment, the lack of support for David Moyes to strengthen the team, and the wholesale stagnation that is stinking the Club out would not be in the media or a talking point at all without the gallant efforts of Blue Union.

Prior to this campaign, we had a wall of silence, PR soundbites and the usual lies and spin. Blue Union have clearly achieved in that following the two protests the Club have been forced to react to the campaign both in the run-up to the action and the days preceding.

The way you sign off every post with COYB would suggest some sort of superiority complex to people such as myself that support Blue Union, you are entitled to your views ? what is your suggestion then to move the Club forward in these dark and despairing times?
John Keating
44 Posted 21/11/2011 at 09:20:50
Prior to the BU, there was absolutely nothing in either local or national newspapers regarding the state of our club. Now, we have national paper and TV coverage AND extremely reluctantly, local press coverage.

Even the club's mouthpiece O'Keefe has been forced to mention the march in today's paper - even though it must have taken him at least 5 seconds to cobble his miserable report together. Why aren't Prentice and O'Keefe asking the club the questions the supporters want answering?

Finally, Alan, if you were at the ground on Saturday and you reckon there were 250 protesters in Goodison Road, then my friend you are off your head !!
Tom Hughes
45 Posted 21/11/2011 at 09:28:26
Alan.... open up dialogue with the club?

This the club that doesn't even talk to its shareholders.

KEIOC have had plenty of dialogue with the club over the years.... but what's the point if they won't listen. KEIOC have brought many ideas and experts to the table.... but the problems have been either a complete unawareness or inability to address the issues. This ineptitude has continued to the point of almost collapse...... and yet some are still oblivious. I fear the time for dialogue is long since passed.
Eric Myles
46 Posted 21/11/2011 at 10:10:25
Brian #39 "then we need somebody spending a minimum of £400 million of his own money with absolutely no return on his investment ever."

Well at least the mythical figure has started to come down, it was £500 million a couple of weeks ago but still way too high.

Look at this comparison of Goodison and Molineux

http://peoplesgroup.wordpress.com/2011/11/10/everton-v-wolves-goodison-molineux/

For a total of £91 million they are going to increase their capacity from 28,000 to 50,000, that's virtually rebuilding the whole ground and only £12 million more than Bill would have had to find to fund Desperation Kirkby and we would have an increased revenue stream to provide a return on investment.

And how much for the Club? Well Bill's bored with that question but based on share values the cost of buying up all the shares would be around £45 million, and the same for debt?

So a new owner would be looking at £200 million tops, and needn't pay for the stadium redevelopment all in one go as it could be self funding.
Matt Traynor
47 Posted 21/11/2011 at 11:00:20
Kevin (#40), are you a politician? Can you cram any more sycophancy into that post?

Trying to split the fanbase? Er, the club did that with the DK thing. Some people on here still believe that KEIOC were responsible for it not getting approval.

I've worked with people who were involved in the ill-fated Kings Waterfront proposal, and the ill-advised Kirkby proposal. One was the real deal of the century.

But, no worries, as the money for Kings Dock was in the same ringed-fence as the money for Kirkby.

Even if the Kirkby proposal hadn't driven a bulldozer through planning guidance and was given approval, Everton wouldn't have been able to afford it.

But keep up with the Blairisms "Yes, well, we have a problem, don't we... but let's not get too passionate about it".

Sake.
Phil Bellis
48 Posted 21/11/2011 at 11:15:49
The move to Knowsley would've helped ensure more profits for Tesco plc shareholders, more like

Brick wall I fear.
Alan Williams
49 Posted 21/11/2011 at 13:18:30
Peter, COYB meaning I'm better than others? Really you need to get a life. Fans groups need to include the club, it?s the only way forward; your actions are more like an industrial dispute so it will never achieve its potential.

Regarding how I would change it short term is take away many concessions in prime areas and up the ticket prices, including season tickets, they are way too low.

Gavin, I said the reports in the papers, I never witnessed the marches; like 99.2% I stayed in the pub, a lot friendlier.

Tom, KEIOC is a spent force, we are talking about a fans group, you have no right whatsoever to exclude the club in its own constitution.

EFC by law don?t have to have shareholders meetings they have exercised their right to do so like many other companies have done. This law has come from the Government not the company EFC. Holding shares in EFC at a minor level is completely pointless investment as it pays no return its merely an emotional tie.

Tom, unless you have dialogue with the custodians of EFC your efforts are a complete waste of time and will never, ever gain recognition you need, so take off your blinkers and swallow some pride as this line of protest is doomed.

All I?m saying is use your combined intelligence to enhance EFC; lots of members of BU have more than enough brain power to be of value to EFC, it?s the only way forward. But as you're wanting what they have, then you need to be the first to offer an olive branch. It would be a massive PR for BU if you could get a new official meeting with the club in an environment that suits all, it?s the only way forward if BU want some credibility with the majority.

EFC fans are generally a conservative bunch in a non-political form and you need to address why your support hasn?t grown and, if press reports in the National Sundays are true, falling. It?s all about getting the best for EFC and this won't happen when BU only get 0.8% of the match day attendance showing support for them.

Like it or not, either you get more support from match day Evertonians, or start dialogue with the club... because, if you don?t, then your efforts are wasted. COYB (sorry Peter)
Gavin Ramejkis
50 Posted 21/11/2011 at 14:30:37
That must be some big pub Alan to claim 30,000 plus were in there with you, you made a comment based on hearsay and repeat it with little or no foundation. The report from the mouthpiece at the club claimed a man and his dog, suggest you do a quick google search for yourself as I said earlier, there are stills and videos available in the public domain.
Kevin Corness
51 Posted 21/11/2011 at 15:24:29
Matt (47) ? The point is not the move to Knowsley, it's more with the fact that if we had a 21st century stadium then we would've had investment a long time ago.

But the fact remains the majority of Evertonians would not like to see us be another Blackburn or even Aston Villa. We want someone who can take us forward which the two I've just mentioned have not.
Peter Laing
52 Posted 21/11/2011 at 17:21:14
What a laugh, Alan, increase the ticket price and take away the concessions in prime areas ? masterstroke. For those of us living in the real world Everton do not have a season ticket waiting list, are by the last count 4000-5000 season ticket sales down on last season and have not signed a player for over 2 years. Factor in that Evertonians are largely in the lower socio-economic groups (based upon fact not fiction) and we are in the midst of a global economic recession ? genius. But then that's you all over isn't it always on the wind up looking for provocation, enough said, in future I will just ignore your posts.
Phil Bellis
53 Posted 21/11/2011 at 17:47:00
We're on course for another season with lower average attendance and Alan wants to put up prices; apply for a job with the Goodison executive ? you'll fit in nicely with the other barmpots.
Matt Traynor
54 Posted 21/11/2011 at 17:53:32
Kevin (#51) yes we would have done. If BK had been happy to give up some shareholding, he would've been a part owner of a team playing at Kings Waterfront that would've been generating revenues that we can only dream of now. It was a multiple use stadium, that could've held a speedway meet in the morning, a match in the afternoon and a Stone Roses gig in the evening. (Unlike the KD proposal which saw no other use permitted).

And it would've been built using a large amount of EU money that was from the time-limited Objective 1 fund.

But instead of having 20% of something worth a lot, he decided to hold onto 30% of nothing. Because despite his attempts at getting £100m for the club, his self-described "Trophy Asset" is actually a toxic asset. If he doesn't make a penny from the sale, it's his own fucking fault, but like the whoppers at the head of some of the banks, it's the customers who pay for their mistakes.
Alan Williams
55 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:00:12
Peter/Phil, if EFC want to stay in the black they either put up ticket prices, drop player wages or sell year on year. I?m sorry but you can belittle me as much as you want but, unless you solve that problem of losing between £5/7 million per year, we are knackered.

EFC prices compared with the top 6/7 are way too low, in life you simple get what you pay for. We as fans get a good financial deal out of Everton especially on concession of which I benefit for my son but in the real world if we ever want to aspire to do better then the fan has to pay more that is proven fact in the Premier League. BK refuses to increase prices for the exact reason you all give so maybe he isn?t such a pig as you make out.

I?m sorry but you all want your cake and eat it, it?s a recession out there when we talk about increasing ticket prices but not when BK is looking for a buyer. Excellent, just proves that BU want new owners who will keep the prices as low as they are, build a new stadium, and invest heavily in to the team... but only if it's out of his own pocket and he gets no return on his investment!! Complete fantasists the lot of you. COYB
Kevin Corness
56 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:16:30
Kings Dock would've been great for Everton, I think football grew too much for BK and he found he did not have the right people around him (Gregg to name one) to take advantage of the amounts of money coming into the game.

And yes, we, and I think He himself now understand how much it has cost us. But ? and it is a big BUT ? I hope when investment comes our way it is the right investment.....
Andy Crooks
57 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:25:57
Alan, I expect that most Evertonians would settle for a chairman who knows what he's doing. One who is honest and transparent and who gets the absolute maximum from what we've got. Surely know one can suggest that Bill Kenwright is such a man.
Dennis Stevens
58 Posted 21/11/2011 at 19:06:25
" ... unless you solve that problem of losing between £5/7 million per year we are knackered." Alan, surely one reason so many want rid of the current Board is their inability to resolve this problem. Indeed, many would say the problem is somewhat of their own making due to their own incompetence & failure to deliver change which could have moved the club forward.
Tom Hughes
59 Posted 21/11/2011 at 20:49:06
Alan,
Brilliant.... you've solved all our woes in one go. Increase ticket prices and all our problems disappear!!! Have you not heard of basic supply and demand theory and correlation with price? Have you really waited till now to reveal your genius masterplan? Get on to Robert ASAP! Best use a letter though..... I've heard he doesn't do e-mails nowadays.

Attendances are several thousand down on corresponding fixtures from last year.... and yet you advocate price increases? Is this a large-posterior issue, and you're just after more space to spread those cheeks?

Has it not occured to you that our club could've done a lot more over the past 12yrs (and more) to raise revenue by addressing the stadium issue. They have in fact done the least to the stadium of ALL major football clubs (and nearly all smaller clubs too). They have created no new high-value capacity, no new boxes and lounges, and indeed no significant new additional capacity at all. They have done nothing to address the excessively high number of obstructed views, and to add value in that way. Did you also not hear about the lost opportunity of Kings Dock? Thrown away for no other reason than to keep control of the club. A stadium that would have addressed all of these issues and more in one go, and for a bargain price too. 12yrs down the line, and they still haven't commissioned a thorough design study of all the options at GP..... which is unbelieveable!

Can you blame BU for any of this? I'm sure you would like to!

Our prices may not be as high as some, but we certainly are not the cheapest.... KEIOC have done a full analysis of matchday incomes for your comparison, so I think you'll find that they are very well-informed on the subject, and not fantasists at all. They back their assertions with facts, and not vague insinuations and nonsense, you'd do well to read some of their articles before writing on here.
COYB


Alan Williams
60 Posted 22/11/2011 at 08:32:19
Tom, why are you getting personal? You more than most are normally constructive.

KD was a disaster for EFC and one that we may never recover from but it?s easy for you to blame control as the reason why we lost KD; it?s not that simple. Gregg wanted the control not just of EFC but the site under SFX, whilst EFC may have had a stadium the board rejected losing so much control for a £30 million guarantee.

The Grantchester?s had the wealth and refused to back the club. BK has never had such wealth, that?s why he failed then and continues to fail because he is simply out of his depth, that?s not me saying that but the man himself. We can?t re-write history and all you do is post what could have been done with the use of hindsight which basically is easy and lazy.

At the time of KD EFC had little resource at all and the big Sky money wasn?t available until several years later. We were finishing in the bottom of the PL every year, as a business we had nothing to offer the banks, hence why we fail all the time. BK has failed to deliver what he and we want, that?s not in question, but he has also presided over a club that is in a better position now than when he took over, especially on the pitch, so it could have been a lot worse than what it is today.

BU need to look what?s ahead not what?s behind otherwise you too as an organisation will split and fade away. Both parties need to swallow pride and come together regardless of past issues, there is no mileage covering over your or my version of what we think has happened.

BU need to be inspirational, innovative and embrace the match-going fan along with the Custodians of our club. There is a place for a fans group at EFC, I honestly believe that, but not as it stands now. Take the lead and show what you are made of, offer an olive branch to the board. COYB
Eric Myles
61 Posted 22/11/2011 at 09:27:09
Alan "BK has never had such wealth that?s why he failed then and continues to fail because he is simply out of his depth, that?s not me saying that but the man himself."

All the more reason for BK to put a reasonable price on the club and let go if he loves it.
Phil Bellis
62 Posted 22/11/2011 at 09:26:36
Alan,

You say Everton Football Club, an institution before the gunfight at the OK Corral, with a captive customer base of 10s of 1000s is "knackered" for the lack of £5/7 million per year.

Do you, as a reasonable, sensible person think this is a problem beyond the wit of a normal, professional Board to overcome?
Eugene Ruane
63 Posted 22/11/2011 at 09:30:31
Alan Williams ? you put forward the stupidest of suggestions ('put the prices up') then whine when people point out it's... the stupidest of suggestions.

The fact is you' belittle' yourself.

Apart from the fact that attendances are already down (repeat: DOWN!) you're suggesting ways to find extra money to give to people who have PROVED they are fucking useless with/not to be trusted with money.

Genuinely interested to know which part of this you're not getting, it's like reading "My mate's a hopeless alcoholic and I think a good way to get even more bevvy down his neck would be..."

You continue...

"BK has failed to deliver what he and we want that?s not in question but he has also presided over a club that is in a better position now than when he took over, especially on the pitch, so it could have been a lot worse than what it is today".

Well I have no doubt there are a load of Sky-stats (or some bollocks) to illustrate just how much better 'on the pitch' we are now, but for those of us who prefer to believe what we SEE ? under Walter we were predictable, had an average squad who were, in the main, shite to watch and they won fuck-all.

Under Moyes?

Erm...

(nb: appreciate this is subjective, but whatever you believe, we're hardly talking about the difference between the 1980s Wimbledon side and the 1970 Brazil side).

But let's say you ARE right on this 'point' ? so what?

If one side is crap, it's NO consolation if another side was slightly crappier (especially if the manager of the crap side is paid...)

Oh...COYB.
Tom Hughes
64 Posted 22/11/2011 at 11:07:48
Alan,
Not personal at all.... it's known as humour.

Whatever you think the reasons for the loss of Kings Dock, the fact that you accept the magnitude of its failure negates any excuses for BK. I actually attended all the AGM's before and after its demise.... and not once could he offer any answers or excuses, because he knew that Gregg and LCC would've sued him in an instant. He played the boardroom politics and his True Blue credentials won him the day, and lost us our future!

Only a year after losing KD we sold Wayne Rooney for practically the cost of our whole contribution. No-one in football could explain how just £30m for a £2-300m stadium was not achievable.... several club chairmen commented how they would've loved the same opportunity.

As far as hindsight is concerned, I think the fact that practiaclly ALL other clubs (I don't know how many times I have to repeat this) have had the foresight to plan ahead and deliver refutes this argument completely. Everyone else has delivered, why haven't we? This mistake alone should have sealed BK's fate.... yet he's presided over repeat performances?

As far as being better on the pitch now, I'd say we probably are (although now we have the smallest squad in the league and have sold every asset we had to get to this point), but I would put that down entirely to Moyes's efforts on the lowest budget of any of our peers. The board's job is to help provide the manager with sufficient funds to compete by amongst other things providing the infrastructure to generate the revenue streams. In this respect this board are bottom of the league.

As regards olive branches, we are at this point because the club as refused ALL offers/advice. DK illustrated the complete ineptitude with little sign of change.... there's only so much lip-service and poor excuses..... the club has come close to meltdown (in their own words).... none of that is because of the BU!
Alan Williams
65 Posted 22/11/2011 at 18:00:15
Eugene, great reply made me smile as, the more you pass insults, the more you all look stupid, thank you for your response.

Phil, in normal business I would have to agree with you 100% but in football it's not reality when 85% of income goes on your staff then it's a hard one to call. EFC have chosen to pass the money to the players, is that correct????? Big question... if we stay up every year then the answer is yes.

Tom, you need to sit back a bit, he has made mistakes but my post is trying to move forward not back and that?s what BU should be doing, looking forward not back ? it?s the only way for all of us to unite. Both sides need to swallow pride if ever there is going to be harmony.

You will never succeed in your current form and the truth of the matter is you all know that! COYB
Jay Harris
66 Posted 22/11/2011 at 18:40:34
Alan
Everton will never be united while Kenwright and "friends of Everton" are running the club although that in itself ia a misstatement because the one thing they are not doing is running the club.

The majority of businesses and football clubs have a plan and a goal.

Kenwright doesnt even know where £20 million a year unexplained operating costs go and that is current not history.

The cloak and dagger culture is still in evidence at the club and that is not looking back either.

This divide between fellow Blues lies firmly at the door of Kenwright.
Tom Hughes
67 Posted 22/11/2011 at 18:32:49
Alan,
Patronising in the extreme. You make vague assertions that when countered you cannot back-up, and you seem completely oblivious to the issues, and offer no substance....... "He's made mistakes?" No kidding?

Then somehow feel confident to predict the future outcome of the current unrest?

Never succeed? We'll see!
Alan Williams
68 Posted 23/11/2011 at 08:11:21
Tom just 0.8% of the match day attendance!! Your arrogance and disrespect to the rest of us fans is terrible.

BU do not stand for the fans to get us on board and show willing instead you just put your head in the sand, just amazing that you won't even attempt to liaise with the custodians. If this is your official stance then seriously what is the point of having a dispute if you never want to get around the table?

Absolutely amazing, he has made mistakes just like KEIOC has, remember the DK video scare tactics, or the first meeting aggressive shambles in the Casa, then you had people resigning early on, if my memory is correct.

If you never want to move forward then you have no place acting as a fans group, use this opportunity for good, not your own personal gripe with Kenwright, because our club will last a lot longer than Kenwright will!! That?s me done on this subject as I think the divide has hit an all time low and it saddens me. COYB
Eugene Ruane
69 Posted 23/11/2011 at 08:37:56
Alan, you appear to have learned the art of debate from PeeWee Herman. - "I know you are, but what am I?" Might I add that you thinking me 'stupid' I take as the highest of compliments. Seriously, I would be very, VERY depressed if I started making sense to a cabbage (nb: and from reading your drivel, a cabbage who got held back a year in cabbage school and put into a class with the sprouts).
Tom Hughes
70 Posted 23/11/2011 at 09:29:34
Alan,

"Tom just 0.8% of the match day attendance!!"

Yet another propagandist lie I'm afraid... You evidently weren't in Goodison Rd with people from one end to the other clapping and chanting. You also obviously haven't visited their sites and seen the literally thousands of hits. What about the thousands that have already voted with their feet, stating on numerous threads that while this lot are in place they will no longer help fund them?

You and Martin say yourselves that you accept that the majority support BU aims yet continually keep referring to ridiculous minority stats that don't stand up and are meaningless anyway... where is all the anti-BU sentiment on ANY of these threads, on ANY supporters website? It doesn't exist!

"Your arrogance and disrespect to the rest of us fans is terrible."

Respect is earned. Arrogance is responding to facts with lies/weak-insinuation, not backing up any assertion and repeating it ad nauseum regardless and without an reference to points being made. BU did liaise with the head man, KEIOC have had numerous meetings with them over the years.... it's been done over and over, and on lots of issues, your problem is you don't like what they had to say.

At no point have they said they are not open to further meetings or even open debate, but they won't be gagged or bought off like the stooges and local media recently referred to as such in the leaked e-mails, and the club know this. They have never accepted the offer of an open radio debate because they know KEIOC have tied them up in knots before. Hence their PR campaign which you have lapped up. Yet you then accuse us of having our heads in the sand.

There are articles pages long highlighting the failures of this board... all well-documented and indisputable (as if you'd even need that given our current precarious plight), yet in your opinion KEIOC are equally culpable because a Kirkby resident showed a few of his fellow residents a factual video of football violence, that is readily available and in the public domain......? ie he told NO LIES just facts.

Are you serious? If that is the level of "argument" you can muster, I doubt you will ever be convinced or really want to be (despite the fact that you supposedly agree with their objectives).

My feelings are that you probably actually support this board but wouldn't dare state your position from that stance because you know you would be laughed at.

The KEIOC meetings reference also gives your real motives away.... your own little smear campaign again based on lies. I attended ALL of these meetings, they were all reported on, and there was always plenty of passion but never any aggression. People who have left KEIOC over the years have left due to other commitments, and others have taken up the reigns..... unlike for some, Everton do not pay their bills.

As with the BU, KEIOC were vilified by the club and consequently many fans initially... but eventually they were fully vindicated. The endless stream of facts and genuine intent eventually outweighed the lack of substance and lies that was KD. If you really want BU to talk for you, why don't you attend one of their meetings and have your say?

"That?s me done on this subject"

No kidding, did you ever seriously get started?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads