Season › 2011-12 › News
Striker on loan is unlikely to return
Joao Silva not good enough for goal-shy Everton
Everton are crying out for a striker, but seem unwilling to give Portuguese acquisition JoĂ£o Silva a chance, preferring that he spend what will total two years of his three-year contract on loan back in his native Portugal. So, what's the problem? Apparently Silva was spotted by one of the club's most experienced scouts and terms were agreed with the player. The fee paid to CD Aves was reported as ?undisclosed' but is understood too be ?875,000.What's gone ?wrong' as such is that the player just wasn't showing in training the potential that had led to his signing; it didn't look at any stage that he was going to fit into the style of play required for the Premier League, despite being big and fast. There's next to no chance that he'll pull on an Everton shirt; the club will either release him or let him run down his contact.
Quotes or other material sourced from PortuGoal
Reader Comments (109)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 21/11/2011 at 14:11:22
To play right midfield probably.
3 Posted 21/11/2011 at 14:21:28
7 Posted 21/11/2011 at 15:18:54
http://blogs.coventrytelegraph.net/ladslounge/2011/11/everton-wonderkid-scores-screa.html
9 Posted 21/11/2011 at 15:18:11
If the club don't rate him they should release him from his contract rather than let him run it down, we don't need to be paying a wage for nothing in return.
Sounds like he may be able to make a decent career in Portugal, good luck to him.
10 Posted 21/11/2011 at 15:19:10
16 Posted 21/11/2011 at 15:42:59
Seriously, take the hint
18 Posted 21/11/2011 at 15:50:49
Editorial Team
19 Posted 21/11/2011 at 15:59:37
20 Posted 21/11/2011 at 16:01:31
21 Posted 21/11/2011 at 16:11:33
22 Posted 21/11/2011 at 16:11:18
ps: It?d be boring if we all agreed on the site. I hope Ian keeps posting whether I agree with him or not.
23 Posted 21/11/2011 at 16:16:53
24 Posted 21/11/2011 at 16:19:40
They've obviously been watching him in Portugal and decided that he isn't progressing enough to warrant another contract. It happens. Shame but no biggie.
25 Posted 21/11/2011 at 16:28:34
26 Posted 21/11/2011 at 16:41:16
More worried about the £9M we spent on Bily and how much of this is coming back (if any).
Lack of strikers in the squad is not the main problem, refusing to regularly start with two is, given we have no pace in the midfield.
27 Posted 21/11/2011 at 16:48:25
7 in 21 isn't that bad and he could potentially improve by playing regular competitive football. I hope he at least gets one or two chances in his final year with us. If not, we should try to get some money back rather than letting it run down.
28 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:01:14
29 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:06:27
30 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:09:55
I know we have two examples who have come through, but please where is the quality. Jack might make and so might the ocassional others but really we should be producing more by now.
31 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:17:10
Ian Tunstead, keep posting, debate is what it is about.
32 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:21:52
How many similar type players has Moyes brought in during the last 10 years? He just doesn't seem to be able to really recognize the kind of quality needed and that is why some players apart from these are actually selected and perform below par too often.
33 Posted 21/11/2011 at 18:37:54
He takes fellas with reputations then breaks 'em - just look at the Yak now he's escaped and AJ at Fulham.
Moyes is a vampire sucking the lifeblood out of forward play - just ask Arteta or Bily.
34 Posted 21/11/2011 at 19:04:48
But then again, you have proved how little you know far better than I could ever articulate with your suggestion that Andy Johnson has improved since leaving Everton. He has managed 13 goals in 74 league appearances for Fulham.
35 Posted 21/11/2011 at 19:25:50
The lad couldn't even hold down a place in the reserves, so I find it insane that Moyes is portrayed as 'seemingly unwilling' to give him a chance. He has already had his chance with us for 2 years, how much longer should he get? Or does it make business sense to pay someone wages that hasn't got a hope in hell of getting near the first team now or ever? Thought not.
36 Posted 21/11/2011 at 19:42:47
Yak is scoring for fun, like most decent players they need managing to get the best out of them ? clearly beyond Moyes as you've inadvertently pointed out.
BTW don't put words in my mouth about AJ improving I said no such thing but I've noticed little stattos like you say any shit to fuel dickhead ideas.
AJ was broken physically and probably mentally by the time Moyes had finished with him. After a long rehab at Fulham he's now playing with a smile and scoring ? ditto Arteta and the Yak.
Stop making shit up.
37 Posted 21/11/2011 at 19:59:32
Us little stattos like to back up points with facts, so that he is playing with a smile on his face so he must be better....you couldn't write that shit....oh you just have.
Arteta has scored the same amount of goals for Arsenal as he had us this season but has played 8 more games for them... damn these stats, hey?
38 Posted 21/11/2011 at 20:09:02
You just don't read what people say - if you don't see AJ playing with a smile now you're blind......
oh yeh, Arteta and the Yak too.
But fuck that enjoyment thing we fans wanna see our players walking around half interested play without any passion then go home and google some stats.
You bang the drum about players not playing don't you?
The same players are playing well somewhere else - tell me why?
39 Posted 21/11/2011 at 20:14:53
Whatever happened between him and Moyes he was not sold because he was shit. He seemed to have a falling out with the manager and only one person usually win in that scenario. Shame as he was probably the one striker who on form could really do a job in Moyes favoured 4-5-1 formation.up
Personally I was sad to see that they were not able to patch things up as I always thought he was player who will get goals. He's not old and his Prem record stands up for itself.
40 Posted 21/11/2011 at 20:33:12
He did well for the first 18 months and that was it.
As for AJ, he seriously over-achieved in his first six months with us. He then went back to form subsequently.
41 Posted 21/11/2011 at 20:41:37
It's the reason I'm dismissive of the "statto" in football as you've proven there's always another set of figures somewhere - you can't beat you're own eyes.
Notice my question to TJW has gone unanswered - no google for it s'pose.
42 Posted 21/11/2011 at 20:53:24
Tony's stats seem to suggest he has been ineffective for a while... so, to be honest, who cares if he's smiling or not?
43 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:03:04
44 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:11:42
The better thing is that he calmly turns and runs back to his half like it was something he does in his sleep!!!!
Moyes had better not fuck this one up.
45 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:08:57
I just agree to disagree on AJ because it's incidental, the main point is Moyes is a disaster for creative players ? forwards in particular; to suggest otherwise is nonsense.
46 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:20:34
As for Andy Johnson he has done nothing since going to Fulham for £11.75M from us. He might play with a smile but he is still a sack of shite.
47 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:30:58
Pienaar came here with his career in peril, turns into a fantastic player and Spurs buy him. Baines come here from Wigan and is now the number 2 left back, due to his attacking play. Arteta came here with his career in peril, and is reborn and is now thriving at Arsenal. Creative players, bought by Moyes, who have thrived.
Forwards?? Yak came here and is the only striker in the past 20+ years at Everton to score 20 goals in a season. His injury is what did him in, not Moyes. AJ made the step up and scored many goals, his injuries are what limited his playing time at the end. He in turn was sold at a profit and no doubt got a bigger payday because of his success while at Everton. Saha? Came from United where everyone basically said his career was over. At Everton, he's had a pretty good goal return when able to stay healthy.
The only thing that limits creative players at Everton is the fact that Everton can't afford more creative players, so they are more easily isolated throughout a game.
48 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:43:00
49 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:48:48
You could also add to David's list Marcus Bent, Tim Cahill, Manny Fernandes & Landon Donavan. To suggest that Moyes is a disaster for creative players is bollocks.
50 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:58:43
I think an argument inferring Moyes damages all creative players is bizarre. You use Arteta as an example, presumably because he is now playing well (and only well, no more) at Arsenal, a team both better and more attacking than us. Should reference not be made to the player Moyes turned Arteta into? Because I think you will be hard pressed to find an Everton fan that does not believe Moyes improved Arteta.
Along those lines I would add Pienaar, whose career had stalled before he came to Everton. Undoubtedly improved under Moyes and turned into a fantastic Premier League player.
With respect to the Yak, how reductive is it to point to the first seven games for a new team as credence of the mistake in not playing him? He wasn?t playing well for us, and hadn?t for some time.
And Bily? he hasn?t adapted. He is talented of course, but he doesn?t work anywhere near hard enough and often looks a liability. I would say he is not suited to the Premier League.
Of course Moyes has had some issues with creative players, as any manager has. But give us £50-100million to spend and higher wages, and I?m sure he could create an impressive attacking unit.
The whole basis of this thread is bizarre. An unprofessionally subjective article has been used as to criticise Moyes... JoĂ£o Silva is not good enough for us. He has an acceptable at best record in a much poorer league than the Premier League. He will move on, as many sub-million youths will. Stop clutching at straws just for a reason to criticise Moyes.
51 Posted 21/11/2011 at 22:06:47
52 Posted 21/11/2011 at 22:05:07
Hardly the mark of a creative or great manager, that's the top and bottom of it.
Someone mentioned 5 players, one being a fullback, as a measure of 10 yrs creativity - 1 every 2 years - marvellous.
My big worry is we'll get bought out and he'll blow the dowry - yet another false dawn.
When Walter got to this state we got a new young fella in and showed some improvement.
Moyes should have gone at the latest 2 yrs ago.
53 Posted 21/11/2011 at 21:59:05
Simply incredible statements. Suggesting that Moyes has been responsible for 'sucking the life' out of players, when we currently have three players in the senior england squad, the first time for many years. All players nurtured under the current coaching staff. Thats without discussing Pienaar, Arteta, Howard, Cahill, Coleman, Lescott etc. who are all apparently worse players following their time with us. But hey, lets ignore those points as it doesn't suit our agenda. Lets not recognise that Moyes has one of the highest points per pound spent ratios the Premiership has ever seen, lets ignore the comments from all people in the game, LMA's etc etc etc. We know everything, as we follow the Blue Onion, beacon of truth, pillar of the community, and only people in the WORLD that know how to win games by playing 0-0-10 (attackin is the best form of defense innit?) and run football clubs without any prior experience of doing so.
My life seems so empty in comparison. I would love to be able to judge football players on the 'smiles per minute' statistic, but unfortunately logic and reason always gets in the way.
54 Posted 21/11/2011 at 22:16:09
55 Posted 21/11/2011 at 22:26:06
I don't understand how a manager can be so criticised when it is clear to 95% of those in the game that he over-achieves. The problem is with fan expectation, not Moyes. We would love trophies and top four finishes etc, but those are brought these days, and our pockets are empty. Sticking another striker up front is not going to change that.
A 4-4-2 will mean we win some games we wouldn?t otherwise... and it will also win we will lose some we would have won. Moyes achieves at the very least what he should, and in the majority's opinion, more than that.
56 Posted 21/11/2011 at 22:25:27
It is easy to look like a great manager when you are spending tens of millions; Moyes is having to search the bargain basement and, when you slum it at that level, good quality is hard to come by. Alex Ferguson has spent multi-millions on the likes of Bebe for £8 million. At least spending that amount you lower your percentage chance of a complete failure, although you can always count a famous example.
For anyone ready to throw Billy into the mix, then for every Billy there is a Pienaar. Even Vellios is getting written off by some already ? give me strength; with friends like these...!
Moyes hasn't brought the trophies, but his transfer record is very good considering the conditions the two-bit chairman has provided. Anyone who slates him in that area is simply biased.
The money promised in Jan will be for more bargain basement offers that most top managers wouldn't think twice about taking the risk on ? the Moyes bashing is getting completely boring.
57 Posted 21/11/2011 at 22:34:58
Oh how many of them are creative?
Can't we count Rooney? No, he had the measure of Moyes and fucked off asap even tho "once a blue etc"
It's a joke people trying to defend Moyes over this ? he's a one-trick defensive manager no matter how much you google.
58 Posted 21/11/2011 at 22:49:19
"He'll be remembered for plodding hoofball with either one or none up front and a penchant for playing players out of position."
I think you'll find that he'll be remembered as a manager who took a team that was a fixture in the annual relegation battle, to one that qualified for European football and left it's fans whingeing when the performances dipped after the board sold our most creative players.
I'm off to bed now so don't assume that because I don't respond to any future comments it's because I can't. Good night.
59 Posted 21/11/2011 at 23:11:56
"Isn't the qualification now - breathing & English?" Good point... they really need to add "Smiling" to that list of criteria... and then watch that team go!
61 Posted 21/11/2011 at 23:35:46
I agree that Greenie wouldn't be here without Moyes. Good coup!
It's fun to get excited about players. It's even more fun to know that these young exciting one's will actually stay with us for a good part of their careers. But that doesn't happen here so lets enjoy him for the 3 seasons that he's here before he gets sold.
Rooney is a different issue that we can talk about on a different thread - this has gotten so far off base ..... ( I do remember Moyes saying he'd walk if we sold Rooney tho...)
62 Posted 22/11/2011 at 00:04:55
As opposed the demonstrably myopic who cherry-pick information to support a factually skewed agenda.
Like Trevor, who cites Yak?s traditional flying start at a new club & Arteta playing for a superior, resurgent Arsenal, as proof they?re better off without Moyes.
?Just look at the Yak now he?s escaped and AJ at Fulham,? he pleads, mysteriously declining to mention the significant injuries these 3 suffered whilst at Goodison.
So people HAVE looked at AJ, and spotted the ?statto,? conclusion that his goal-scoring ratio has dipped considerably in the 3 years since he left. Care to run that AJ point by us again, Trevor?
He bangs on in Ale-House fashion with the empirically unverifiable: ?Moyes takes fellas with reputations and breaks em?.?
If this was a universal truth, people would nod in agreement. Instead he has the FUCKIN? OBVIOUS flaw to this assertion pointed out to him.
Namely, the players signed or developed by Moyes, who arrived at the club with unremarkable reputations, who became household names & full Internationals under his tutelage. (Stop laughing at the back). Such as Jagielka, Rodwell, Lescott & Baines.
Then those who were in danger of going nowhere fast, or even hitting the skids., such as Arteta, Pienaar, Howard Saha & Cahill who all enjoyed a renaissance, again orchestrated by ?Dour Dave.?
Trevor largely IGNORES this evidence, and claims that (apparently), there is ?another set of figures somewhere.? However, their notable absence here exposes his credulity further.
Nice one Trevor! Spin tiny fragments of data whilst simultaneously avoiding the contradictory evidence to your weekly whine.
63 Posted 22/11/2011 at 02:34:47
64 Posted 22/11/2011 at 07:52:46
65 Posted 22/11/2011 at 08:34:43
66 Posted 22/11/2011 at 09:26:23
67 Posted 22/11/2011 at 09:40:01
68 Posted 22/11/2011 at 09:57:35
69 Posted 22/11/2011 at 10:26:05
This is going to be too fuckin easy.
You flounce in with this shite:
"He bangs on in Ale-House fashion with the empirically unverifiable: ?Moyes takes fellas with reputations and breaks em?.?
What you mean is you can't judge footballing ability so you're fucked. Try using your eyes or is that the problem with you and the coterie of little googlers ? you couldn't trap a fart in a jam jar let alone a ball so wouldn't know a footballer if he knocked on your door.
If you don't believe me read Arteta's recent piece referring to "footballing" matters at Arsenal and Barcelona, I never heard him once refer to the "school of science" promoted a la Moyes ? why would that be? Perhaps you or any of the other supporters of this "anti-football" manager could explain.
Then you follow up with this absolute classic apologist shite:
"Namely, the players signed or developed by Moyes, who arrived at the club with unremarkable reputations, who became household names & full Internationals under his tutelage (Stop laughing at the back) such as Jagielka, Rodwell, Lescott & Baines."
Hello, hello anyone in ... remember the word creativity... typical apologist completely ignoring the point to indulge themselves in fuck knows what.... get a grip and read before making an idiot of yourself - list me the wingers, strikers the plethora of attacking midfield players and I might give you a mark for effort.
What utter TYPICAL apologist garbage.
Try again, but remember the word "creativity" or I'll bite your arse off.
70 Posted 22/11/2011 at 11:19:40
Rooney, probably one of the best youngsters in a generation brought through, went to Man U.
Coleman, turned a right back into a winger.
Rodwell, turned a self-confessed centre half into an England midfielder.
Lescott, dwindling at Wolves... brought through to be the first defender to score double figures since Mountfield.
Pienaar (now South African captain) and Arteta, both struggling to get a look in anywhere and both were saved and brought on have moved on to Champions League teams, watch where you are biting son!
Also, I would take your computer to PC World, as it seems to have a problem, the Caps Lock button seemingly malfunctions intermittently in your posts.
71 Posted 22/11/2011 at 11:35:54
I see now why you didn't answer last time - you haven't got a clue about football have you?
What a ball player Gravesen was, and you dare to bring in Rooney as a Moyes success.
My sides are splitting.
CREATIVITY.... HAHAHA.
72 Posted 22/11/2011 at 11:45:09
The fact that you do not think the midfielder Gravesen couldn't pass completely disproves my point, I stand corrected.
I forgot Rooney didn't come through via Moyes, again I stand corrected. He wasn't a success at all. Silly me!
Your computer still has the intermittent Caps Lock problem though.
Oh I didn't answer last time because I wasn't near a computer after 5:30, but that's just another damn statistic.
73 Posted 22/11/2011 at 11:50:21
74 Posted 22/11/2011 at 11:03:38
You are all over the shop here. Here's why:
Your initial post described Moyes as a "vampire," sucking the lifeblood out of Yakubu and AJ, citing Arteta & Bily as additional proof of this claim.
Then you (correctly) asserted that Yak is scoring for fun, before stating that AJ, who is "smiling" now, was physically & mentally "broken" by Moyes... A claim that's never been suggested by the player himself. A player whose goal-scoring returns have declined since leaving Goodison.
Demonstrably, he's physically fit & playing, but exactly how mentally-broken is he, when by your own admission, he's "smiling"?
Indeed he smiled at Moyes a few weeks back, when they patted each other's shoulders whilst exchanging pleasantries at full time.
BUT... when AJ's recent stats were pointed out to you, you suddenly back-tracked, insisting that your ORIGINAL statement referencing AJ was now "incidental"!
Right...
You ploughed on with more Hollywood language: Moyes is a "disaster" for creative players. Except, he isn't.
The creative players Arteta & Pienaar provided years of creative service, before being sold to Champions League playing clubs for more than decent monetary returns.
And the others, out of economic necessity.
If Moyes had sucked the lifeblood out of these players, why would clubs be prepared to pay such large amounts of money for them?
A lesser light of creativity was McFadden, but we stung Birmingham for some very good wedge to offload him. Obviously good business; for us.
Then to the loan players, Donovan & Fernandes, who both enjoyed creative & goal-scoring spells at the club. Moyes was NOT a "disaster" for these players & they did well at Goodison.
List for me the names of players whose reputation was broken under Moyes. Then explain precisely why it WAS "dour Dave's" fault. Please incorporate any mitigating circumstances you think existed, which could help us get to the bottom of this perplexing mystery.
Where they tactically mis-used? Injury-prone? Deliberately sabotaged by Moyes? Or just plain shit?
(I concede Bilyaletdinov btw...)
Now you wish to judge Moyes by the standards of the best footballing side in the world, Barcelona. Yeah... love that one.
You also claim that Moyes "promotes" the "School of Science"... When? Where? I have NEVER heard him reference this. Please factually back that statement up.
Also, your addiction to the word "apologist" is now resulting in muddled prose: As when I compliment Moyes's sterling work in helping players step-up from relative anonymity to International class ? this IS NOT "apologism" ? it is actually just praise.
But this is typical form for you. Eschew logic for a all-encompassing, vacuous placard mantra.
75 Posted 22/11/2011 at 12:11:32
You have a valid point in that Moyes does not always play a very positive brand of football. He prefers to keep it tight and organised and likes players to stick to their defined roles. Often this doesn't make a very appealing spectacle and certainly it doesn't often lead to goalfests and huge wins.
I think most people would agree with that.
To say that he is 'vampire sucking the lifeblood out of forward play' is very over-dramatic.
He plays a certain way (not dissimilar to Mourinho) that he thinks will best bring results. Arguably he has been proven right in this. But I agree there are other ways he could choose.
He does not 'ruin' creative players nor is he opposed to them necessarily as the likes of Osman, Pienaar, Arteta, Gravesen and Rooney amongst other have shown.
To use AJ as an example was clearly a mistake. Please man up and admit so.
76 Posted 22/11/2011 at 12:38:46
77 Posted 22/11/2011 at 12:36:52
78 Posted 22/11/2011 at 12:42:14
79 Posted 22/11/2011 at 12:42:50
80 Posted 22/11/2011 at 12:37:07
This did not seem to be the case in the early years with King Kev etc but since around 2005 I think ? maybe has something to do with Cahill coming and from then on one striker became the norm ? don't know, just a suggestion.
List includes amongst others; Yak, AJ, Beattie, Beckford....(will exclude Rooney here as I think the fact that we were a gnat's fart away from financial meltdown had more to do with Rooney being sold than a falling out).
Anyway, I am willing to bet anyone that the Yak (barring injury) will score more goals than any Everton striker this season. Still think it was a shame he went but manager/player fall-outs are part of football.
Also wonder how much his falling out with Moyes affected his play in the last year or two with us ? as opposed to his injury.
81 Posted 22/11/2011 at 13:08:13
How was Rooney not a Moyes success? He played for England under Moyes at 17/18 and was England's best player. Rooney was carrying England in the European Championships and probably would have been the player of the tournament only for breaking his foot.
Along with Henry and Jayjay Okocha in their pomp, Rooney was the most exciting player to watch in the PL. In my opinion, he is no longer as exciting to watch. Ferguson tried to convert him into a left winger and now he is trying to make him a central midfielder! Who is the negative one?! Give Moyes the money to buy top attacking flair players and Everton will play attacking flair football, it's that simple.
82 Posted 22/11/2011 at 13:00:34
Without differing opinions you cannot have a balanced argument. Who is right and who is wrong in a debate like this though, 'Moyes is a black hole for creativity discuss', is going to come down purely to subjective opinion, as there is no stat in the world that will convince one person that Bily is a world beater mistreated, whilst also convincing somebody that Arteta didn't improve here at Goodison.
Effectively what I am trying to say here, if I didn't successfully get it across previously is; Quit the name calling children, I'm 19 and its unbecoming for me, let alone grown men.
83 Posted 22/11/2011 at 13:17:57
Yeah there does appear to be some truth to the suggestion that Moyes & the Yak had a falling out. But as for the others AJ, Beattie & Beckford... can't recall anything to support that view in respect of those players?
84 Posted 22/11/2011 at 12:46:58
That is the most laughable excuse I have ever heard on behalf of Moyes defense. What the heck has Kenwright got to do with Moyes buying a lot of bad players, and not the right ones we need? David controls the transfers, he controls most things at this club, so to blame Kenwright and give Moyes a free pass is just insane.
You judge a manager on what players he buys, that is the one huge criteria these days, look at City for example, Sven Eriksson bought a lot of crap and was sacked, as was Mark Hughes. Hughes did the better job of the two.
Joao Silva is just a kid yet, and some are late bloomers. However, I think he is judged on his performances, not just his goals, if he develops well enough then he will get a chance, but at this time he needs to be playing in a leauge he knows well, and therefore become a better striker.
Moyes WAS a good manager, last year he gave up because he knew he had failed his target to get CL. It does matter who we replace him with, we need a change and a manager with attacking knowledge and intent is something I long for at this club. Both Walt and Moyes are alike: too defensive, crap hoofball kind of football, and Moyes is powerless to stop it. Get him out!!!! Don't just talk about your discontent, it will not change anything UNLESS you put pressure on him.
We need a fans unrest to get rid of Moyes!!!!
85 Posted 22/11/2011 at 13:25:30
As for stats, they are all very well. However, I look at it like this. In ten years, the so called bigger, money jobs have all been available more than once: Liverpool, Spurs, Chelsea, City, Villa, even Newcastle at one stage when they were knocking around the top end. Also a number of European jobs. Not once have Everton been approached for Moyes. That says to me that despite football being a very insular, closed shop, Moyes must not be fancied by many chairmen for whatever reason.
For the stattos, he has won three LMA awards mind. Steve Coppell has won two though, so if Moyes ever leaves we have a ready made replacement.
86 Posted 22/11/2011 at 13:42:46
Coming from the same guy who recently waved an "imaginary cricket bat at an imaginary crowd," I acknowledge the Viv Richards style "pea-shooters versus cannons," type quips with a grin.
The missus is pregnant, so I'm relieved to say that at the very least, it works..
87 Posted 22/11/2011 at 13:58:45
Wonderful self-parody there Jimmy.
88 Posted 22/11/2011 at 13:57:41
89 Posted 22/11/2011 at 14:06:46
The same AJ who got his first taste of European football with us and scored a decent return (considering his last tally was about 45% penalties) and the only reason he is back in Europe is because his team decided not to tackle people and not get booked.
The same AJ who is being employed in the same position as he was with us now....is he crticial of his present employer?
90 Posted 22/11/2011 at 14:14:58
Now Andy Crooks is an apologist! Absolutely priceless.
91 Posted 22/11/2011 at 14:11:02
92 Posted 22/11/2011 at 14:21:48
94 Posted 22/11/2011 at 21:29:12
Those that shall not be named have come out of their holes in joyous celebration of the return of the Moyesiah in their droves. God help us, sorry, I mean Moyes help us.
Last point, for anyone to claim Moyes was positively influential on the development of Rooney clearly has not got a clue.
95 Posted 22/11/2011 at 22:59:00
Rooney, Radzinski & Lescott might be your role models... but no thanks. By the way, I've an old Everton shirt with Barmby on the back... do you want it?
96 Posted 22/11/2011 at 23:19:07
97 Posted 22/11/2011 at 23:29:26
98 Posted 22/11/2011 at 23:43:29
Individual players can be responsible for factors under their control, they cannot be held responsible for managerial factors.
Sarcasm aside, the logical fallacy you've implied above shows a clumsy understanding.
99 Posted 23/11/2011 at 00:18:33
100 Posted 23/11/2011 at 02:30:24
101 Posted 23/11/2011 at 03:20:27
102 Posted 23/11/2011 at 07:06:49
Listen very carefully, I will say this only once.
MOYES HAD FUCK ALL TO DO WITH ROONEY'S DEVELOPMENT.
He did though have a big say in Rooney only playing bit parts in a shite Everton team when he was clearly the best players on the pitch by a country mile, even at 16. But he wasn't ready I hear you say and couldn't possibly deal with the pressure, just like Barkley isn't ready. BOLLOX, Rooney then went on to lead England in Portugal, destroy international teams and be the centre piece, so much so that when he got injured England fell apart.
The biggest part Moyes played in Rooney's development was to drive our greatest ever talent away with his shite style of coaching and footballing beliefs and into SAF's open arms, where he played straight away.
Fuck off Moyes
103 Posted 23/11/2011 at 09:10:45
104 Posted 23/11/2011 at 10:14:35
105 Posted 23/11/2011 at 10:01:05
The subsequent incoming transfers of Beattie and Neville hardly compensated, did they?
106 Posted 23/11/2011 at 20:08:28
As for your prediction about Rooney, well done you, but you probably predicted that Rodwell was going to be the next Beckenbauer as well and Cadamateri was to be the next Fowler. Lots of young players get hyped up, it's only a matter of time before you get one right.
Rooney could have easily gone off the rails like so many talented youngsters or not coped with the hype and expectation. Moyes kept his feet firmly on the ground. Moyes probably has the best record in the league for playing 16/17-year-old local lads from the academy, its no coincidence that Moyes has that record. In the past it was Liverpool producing all the best young talent.
107 Posted 23/11/2011 at 20:21:06
And yea, what a coincidence Arsenal start playing well again once Arteta went to Arsenal, it must also be a coincidence that Arsenal spent the most money by the end of that last transfer window and brought in a few other decent players.
108 Posted 23/11/2011 at 20:26:45
109 Posted 23/11/2011 at 20:29:19
110 Posted 23/11/2011 at 21:40:11
Other players that some have identified as Moyes Turing into Jewels such as Cahill, Baines, Jagielka and Lescott were quite simply already excellent players at their former clubs, indeed their stand out players.
The success of Everton's youth system has IMHO got nothing to do with Moyes. It is run by a completely different set of people. Liverpool had a much better youth system than us for many years but mainly their success was down to convincing the best young players to go to Liverpool and not Everton, when indeed many of them were infant Evertonians, Carragher, Owen, Mcmanaman, Fowler.
Your assumption that I also predicted Cadermarteri and Rodwell as being the next Fowler and Beckenbaur is a bit disingenuous, and in all honesty no I didn't, although I do believe Rodwell with the right coaching can be a very very good midfielder you could use to build a team around Barkley, who IMHO is every bit as good as Rooney, from the little Moyes has let me see of him. Others I stated I didn't think we're the real deal included Jeffers, Jevons, Hibbert, Vaughan and Anichebe, although you will have to take my word for that as I can already hear the cries of hindsight, which is a fair enough accusation but honestly the above is true.
Barkley IMHO should be in the first team playing the full 90 minutes every game, with Rodwell to build up the centre of our team for now and the future, they need to be coached to bring out the best in their natural ability, with a positive attacking and entertaining ethos, something I believe Moyes has consistently shown absolutely incapable of.
As an aside, the Brisbane Roar have now gone 35 games unbeaten in Australia playing Barcelona football, and they have average players. They are a joy to watch and were transformed by their coach in 6 months from Everton as we are to Barcelona as they are, with no budget and no real changes in the squad. They are great to watch and guess what, it's very effective, I'll say it again, 35 matches unbeaten, a record for any team in any code in Australia.
But some will still say it can't be done.
111 Posted 23/11/2011 at 22:04:45
If Cahill, Baines, Jagielka & Lescott were such stand out players, how come none of the so-called "big" clubs got in there ahead of us?
112 Posted 23/11/2011 at 22:19:12
You seem upset and emotional so I'll just point out one thing: Rooney did go off the rails.
Do you not remember the resultant thug fest (presumably as upset and emotional as you) turning up at his house threatening violence while a Man Utd player?
Despite all this and numerous other nefarious activities, the manager has managed to keep him from not only a wealthier club but possibly a club with better prospects AND he's playing better than ever.
Because you think something ? and pad it out interminably ? doesn't make it true.
113 Posted 24/11/2011 at 01:10:28
The truth is, even if Moyes had money to spend he would never consider an attacking formation. At times we have seen him prefer Cahill or Fellaini as a spearhead... I am surprised he has not considered Tony Hibbert as a lone striker.
114 Posted 24/11/2011 at 12:27:00
He's also shite because we play one upfront (like Arsenal and United) but don't play clunge watering football.
I read comments that Moyes is also shite because we scrape narrow wins.
He's also shite because we lose to super rich clubs with a track record of being beaten us.
He's also shite because our players look totally fed up as if they know the limits of their potential and possible success.
He's also shite because he buys players and generally makes a big profit on them. But occasionally those players like to express their pleasure and joining another club.
In summary: Who gives a fuck? We won't truly grow, until the fuckers at the top move on.
115 Posted 24/11/2011 at 12:21:13
I agree that Moyes seems to make a few fundamental mistakes, playing Osman on the wings still after all this time is mind boggling, but everyone makes mistakes, even SAF, however imo Moyes makes less mistakes than most.
I agree that the buck stops with Moyes, if something bad is going on at Everton then Moyes has to take a large portion of responsibility, from the bottom up. By the same token if something good is happening at Everton Moyes deserves to take his share of the credit, including at youth level. It is he who appoints the coaches. It is he that wanted the youth to train alongside the first team at Finch Farm.
?Liverpool had a much better youth system than us for many years but mainly their success was down to convincing the best young players to go to Liverpool and not Everton, when indeed many of them were infant Evertonians, Carragher, Owen, Mcmanaman, Fowler.?
Exactly Robbie, and how did they convince them? People like Dalglish were prepared to walk the extra mile and go out of their way to make a young Robbie Fowler feel more wanted at Liverpool even though he was a blue, just Like SAF did with Ryan Giggs for Man U and just like Moyes did recently with George Green. Only that it was such a big coup we probably wouldn?t have known what went on behind the scenes and the nice little touches Moyes made that probably made all the difference.
IMO you should not underestimate Moyes's involvement at youth level.
116 Posted 24/11/2011 at 13:03:31
"Despite all this and numerous other nefarious activities the manager has managed to keep him from not only a wealthier club but possibly a club with better prospects AND he's playing better than ever.?
Who is wealthier than Man Utd with better prospects? I also thought he was much more exciting to watch and more direct at Everton and for England when still an Everton player and should have won player of the tournament at the European Championships only for breaking his foot. There was a time I would be on the edge of my seat watching him play. That has all been coached out of him at Man Utd. He was played on the wings for over season and now they are trying to convert him into a central midfielder. Now he consistently disappoints and underachieves for England. The only thing he needed to improve on was his finishing and composure in front of goal, but that was always going to improve with experience.
117 Posted 24/11/2011 at 13:38:53
Answers on a postcard please to the Etihad Stadium!
118 Posted 24/11/2011 at 14:03:19
119 Posted 24/11/2011 at 14:08:05
By the way, how do you know that 'they could have taken Rooney if they were prepared to pay higher wages'? Are you his agent?
120 Posted 24/11/2011 at 14:24:28
121 Posted 24/11/2011 at 15:09:06
As for the rest, unless you were there I'd call it pure conjecture, m'lud.
Anyway, we're getting sidetracked here.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 21/11/2011 at 14:08:42