Reserves hammer Newcastle for four

, 22 November, 70comments  |  Jump to most recent
Vellios sends Moyes a goalscoring message
The promising talents of Magaye Gueye, Apostolos Vellios and Ross Barkley featured in a great win for Everton Reserves at Newcastle today... The Blues ran out 4-0 winners after running the home side ragged with goals from Conor McAleny, returning form injury, Adam Forshaw, and Apostolos Vellios, who scored a brace.

Everton Reserves:Adam Davies, Tyias Browning, Jake Bidwell, John Lundstrum, Aristote Nsiala, Shkodran Mustafi (c), Adam Forshaw, Ross Barkley, Apostolos Vellios, Conor McAleny, Magaye Gueye.
Subs not used: James Fitzgibbons, Hallam Hope, Eric Dier, Adam Thomas, Anton Forrester.

Quotes or other material sourced from Official Newcastle United Website



Reader Comments (70)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Liam Reilly
1 Posted 22/11/2011 at 14:17:22
Don't really get this; surely Barkley is as likely to get injured in the reserves as he is in the first team. It's disappointing and frustrating that other than the Man U game, he hasn't really been involved since his mistake earlier in the season. As for the secret weapon..FFS.

Both look talented, would be nice to see them get some game time.
Tony J Williams
2 Posted 22/11/2011 at 14:27:30
I am sure they will be on the bench on Saturday.

Players can play two games in a week, like the Cup games on Wednesdays and then playing again on Saturday, or playing in Europe on Thursdays then again on Sunday (ahhh, I remember those days)
Jimmy Sørheim
3 Posted 22/11/2011 at 15:25:37
I am baffeled that Stracqualursi isn't in the squad along with McFadden, those are the two with most need of match fitness. Or maybe they will be trained more intensively to get them ready for Bolton and Stoke.

Moyes has signalled in the Echo that he will revert to power and work ethic rather than good looking footie. I take that as a signal that Stracq will be playing a part in both games as a sub at least, or the whole game against Stoke.

I agree with Liam, both Barkley and Gueye should play instead of Cahill and Coleman. I ask myself how long will it be until we see them in the first team? Next season or close to never?

Seems with the youngsters Moyes always thinks ahead, the big picture... well, the current picture is grim and in need of some color and paint, as it has dried up with the old history of what once was a good team.

Looking at the game against Wolves, I was baffled at how poor our passing is, and how little the team actually creates when it comes to real goal chances, we are abysmal at best. I can't remember seeing a more toothless side then this, even in the Walter reign I thought we created better goal chances than we do this season.

There needs to be a change in how play, Moyes is right on that one, but we cant afford to have Gueye, Barkley and Vellios on the bench; they need to play, if for no other reason than to learn the game they really do need game time very soon, or their potential will rot away along with that bench.
Tony J Williams
4 Posted 22/11/2011 at 15:42:32
"I am baffeled that Stracqualursi isn't in the squad allong with McFadden, those are the two with most need of match fitness" ? Or maybe they are both bubbling bags of wank?
Tony J Williams
5 Posted 22/11/2011 at 15:43:37
"I agree with Liam, both Barkley and Gueye should play instead of Cahill and Coleman." ? I have given him loads this season but Coleman was probably our best player on Saturday.

What has Gueye actually shown anyone to prove he should be starting ahead of Coleman?
Wayne Smyth
6 Posted 22/11/2011 at 16:45:07
Jimmy: "Moyes has signalled in the Echo that he will revert to power and work ethic rather than good looking footie."

I really hope that quote is from 10 years ago when Moyes first walked through the door, because if the shite that is served up every week to us is "good looking footie" then we're more royally screwed than I suspected.
Alex Kociuba
7 Posted 22/11/2011 at 16:56:35
Tony, that sentence could be rephrased to "What opportunity has Gueye actually been given to prove he should be starting ahead of Coleman?"
Tony J Williams
8 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:05:31
Alex, if he was good enough, he would be playing
Andrew Ellams
9 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:02:24
Alex, fair point but Tony's point is fair too. I can see why people want to see these youngsters given a chance, but really can't see how they are so definite that they are going to work some sort of miracle when they have seen next to nothing of them.

I remember a couple of years ago when people were banging on about John Paul Kissock on this site. Enough said there...
Liam Young
10 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:12:57
Ross Barkley should be in the starting 11.

The way he can pass the ball, take on players, set up, and take a shot, nobody can argue that Cahill is a better option. Moyes will always pick Osman, always pick Cahill, no matter what, and he loves Saha, and we all know they are not performing. Maybe somebody needs to tell Moyes that... It's a shame what's happened to Moyes, he has no confidence any more, and the constant money struggles have ground him down.

We would do so much more as a team if we gave these young lads a chance, and stopped playing that shit 4-5-1 formation, negative tactics only get you so far. I am sick of watching shit Everton performances, god forbid if I say, sack the board and the manager!!

But what do you do lads? Sit around moaning for the next 5 years playing 4-5-1 and hoping to steal a goal? That's not the Everton way.
Eugene Ruane
11 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:16:17
TJW - so Yakubu wasn't played because he wasn't good enough?

Seriously though, if they're not good enough, what the flip are they doing there?
Kristi Panduku
12 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:18:15
I just don't understand why Hibbert is playing every game. Why can't we stick Coleman at right back, his natural position, and have Gueye or Barkley on the right side? With Coleman's speed we'd have another attacking option on the right, and that opens up room to bring some creativity in the midfield.

Also, I know Moyes loves Cahill and Osman, but they can't be playing every minute of every game, we can't afford to have so many attacking options that don't score.
Tony J Williams
13 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:20:38
He wasn't played because he was an overweight lazy barsteward... he still is.

Gueye is here because he was a cheap gamble, the same way Shandy Andy was. The problem being that Andy was a near £3m gamble, whereas our gambles now are sub-£1m ones...
Ray Roche
14 Posted 22/11/2011 at 16:57:43
"Maybe they are both bubbling bags of wank."

You're wasted on this site, Tony.
Tony J Williams
15 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:24:11
Kristi, it's because Coleman is not that good of a defender. Not good enough for the Premier League.....yet (hopefully).
Derek Williams
16 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:35:57
As we haven't kept a clean sheet since the old king died with our largely defensive formation it surely couldn't do any harm to pair Seamus and Barkley on the right, especially at home against the likes of Wolves. Gosh, by giving the oppos some problems of their own to contend with we might even score more and concede less goals though I accept that's a bit of a radical approach!!
Nick Entwistle
17 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:37:46
Is McAleny or Gueye playing up alongside Vellios here?

That's what I don't get. Why are the reserves playing a different formation to the first team?

Sheedy plays the youth with a front two with George Green just behind!

From the kids to the top, Ajax and Barca play 4-3-3. Anything else would be counter productive... surely?
Eugene Ruane
18 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:42:10
Having seen the 70 side and the 84 to 87 sides, I can tell you that even those who are good enough... erm... aren't good enough.
Sam Hoare
19 Posted 22/11/2011 at 17:45:36
A brace for Vellios. Surely him or Barkley has got to start instead of Cahill this weekend!!
Dean Adams
20 Posted 22/11/2011 at 18:27:23
Nick Entwistle 17

Is that what they call the Everton way then?
If so, we are really up the creek.
Michael Mcloughlin
21 Posted 22/11/2011 at 19:01:53
I think that is a pretty good reserve team they put out there. I think there will be one or two out of them will make it through to the first team as regulars. I personally don't think Gueye will be one of those who do. He has pace and a great cross and he is quite tricky with the ball. But the trickery is not mind blowing and is easily disposessed. I think we will see more of Barkley once he has signed on the dotted line in December.

What is clear with Everton is the strikers are not good enough or quick enough any more. There are enough quality balls going into the box and the danger areas but they (Saha and Cahill) are not getting on the end of them. Moyes needs really to try another partnership and maybe the Stracq and Vellios are the two... maybe, I don't know.

I do see the midfield coming together and, as I have previously stated, the 5-man midfield or 4 should include Maro, Jack and Jack coupled with Royston and Coleman. I really don't understand why people keep calling Hibbert. He is a sterling full back and to be honest his crosses are getting better.

On the defensive front the boys at the back are really quite good. Their distribution however is woeful. There I believe is where we are really lacking. If the defence can distribute properly then this gives the midfield a little more latitude to move about and start to create things.
Wayne Smyth
22 Posted 22/11/2011 at 19:38:55
Michael, I think one problem we have is that we don't seem to commit enough bodies forward when we are in promising positions.

Last weekend we got a few very good balls into the box, but on most occasions we only had a couple of players in the penalty area. In situations like that we need to see 3 or 4 players in different areas, otherwise the chance of scoring is just too slim.

If you watch most other teams, especially successful teams, they always commit numbers forward into key areas when they have the ball. No risk, no reward. Unfortunately our manager seems to favour the no risk approach.
Richard Dodd
23 Posted 22/11/2011 at 19:50:34
One of our former 'promising youngsters' ? now playing in the Conference ? told me recently that playing in Everton Reserves was 'a thankless task'. "If you play well, it counts for nothing... but if you make a mistake, you never hear the last of it!"

Sour grapes? Probably... but such a mindset may explain why so many young 'stars' fail to make progress.
Paul Colley
24 Posted 22/11/2011 at 20:33:51
Just to cheer yous up and on the subject of young starts...doing the rounds on Twitter - Everton Urchin George Green's Nonchalant-As-You-Like Backheel Volley vs Bradford U18s was a bit special... http://t.co/Xivt79Hm
James Stewart
25 Posted 22/11/2011 at 21:08:28
When was the last time the first team scored 4!!!

An increasingly rare occurrence under Gollum!

Gueye is a player I like the look of and he has done nothing but positive things when he has been given a chance. It's mind-boggling that he rots in the reserves while Osman, Cahill etc stink the place out yet walk into the team every week.
Gerry Quinn
26 Posted 22/11/2011 at 21:27:07
Stubbsy for manager - oh no, hang on he's an ex-defender, can't have that! :)
Trevor Lynes
27 Posted 22/11/2011 at 21:55:33
It seems ironic to me that our two most valuable players ie; Baines and Jags were RELEASED from OUR academy and then BOUGHT back after being developed elsewhere. We will quite probably do the same again with a few of our better kids as we tend to either release or loan out. We seem to have forgotten how to SEE talent within our youngsters apart from one or two. It really galls me to see us pay out good money for Jags and Baines when they could have been brought through by us.

Although DM is given credit for giving youth a chance, I think this is incorrect as he only uses them when he has to through injury or suspensions. Rooney was over-nursed at Goodison and we never really got enough out of him before he was let go. I really don't think that Rodwell or Barkley would have got a sniff if Pienaar and Arteta were still in the squad.

Youngsters need to feel wanted and it must be frustrating when they see half-fit Cahill and out of form Saha and Osman being played when the kids must be raring to go and show what they can do....BUT they need extended runs in the first team to enable them to blossom.
Jamie Sweet
28 Posted 22/11/2011 at 23:17:42
Derek Williams #16. Go wash your mouth out. What a stupid notion that we should set our team up to attack the opposition and make them worried about us attacking them, thus putting them on the back foot.

There is no place for this kind of positive thinking towards the game of football here. We have no money, therefore this simply isn't possible. Only teams with billions of pounds can play positive, attacking football. We must defend defend defend. Bodies behind the ball. Hope for a set piece to nick the game. Even at home against Wolves.

We finished fourth once playing like this. If that doesn't prove that this really is the only way to approach the game then I don't know what will.
Elaine Riding
29 Posted 23/11/2011 at 00:27:46
Richard #23

Spot on..
Max Main
30 Posted 23/11/2011 at 00:12:00
Yeah you're right. Let's celebrate all those teams who haven't had the players or the money but who have still gone out there and played attacking football.

Let's celebrate Blackpool last season. Yeah they got relegated but rather than sitting back and defending a lead at, say, Goodison Park, they kept going forward. Heroic. Yeah they lost, but let's celebrate them! What a great attitude!

I just wish Moyes would make Everton play with such reckless abandon and even if we got relegated at least we'd have lost a few games 5-4 and 6-3 and we could hold our heads up high!

But no, boring old Moyes is only interested in keeping us the boring old Premier League by making us do that boring old winning thing when we play with discipline and beat sides like Wolves 2-1 and stuff.

Yeah he's had no money to spend on any flair players (or any players), and the ones he has had he's been forced to sell. But why can't he just play a load of youngsters who none of us have ever really seen play but who MUST be better than the guys who normally play because...um... they just must, right!?! And they'd be all exciting cos they're so young!

Let's get Gueye into the side quick cos he's really fast and exciting. Okay, so that one time he actually played (against Wolves away last season) he didn't appear to be very quick at all, and he missed that one on one, and otherwise didn't contribute. But he MUST play ahead of Coleman. Because Coleman, whilst being one of our better performers this year, had a slightly dodgy game against Newcastle. Coleman out. Gueye in.

And Liam Young, you're so right about Moyes always picking Cahill. So right.... Except for all those times this season when he hasn't picked him. But why let actual facts get in the way of a good argument against Moyes?

Et cetera.
Phil Bellis
31 Posted 23/11/2011 at 00:49:56
Mmm...I think there's a point in there somewhere, Max..I think
Jamie Sweet
32 Posted 23/11/2011 at 02:04:01
Max #29. I love the way you use Blackpool as an example of why we shouldn't try to play a more attacking style of football.

Bearing in mind many pundits took a look at the Blackpool squad at the start of the season and suggested that they may be set to record the lowest points total in Premier League history, suggests that they probably won 20 more points than a lot of people thought they would.

And if you don't think we've got a squad far superior to the one Holloway had at his disposal then you need your head read.

Don't you think that we could play a similar style to Blackpool (maybe not quite as gung-ho) but do it significantly better?

By the same token, you would tell Barcelona not to play attacking football because "look where it got Blackpool". Your argument would only wash if we only had players that were the same quality as those at Blackpool. How utterly ridiculous.
Jimmy Sørheim
33 Posted 23/11/2011 at 02:52:32
Vellios!!!! Keep it up.
Michael Mcloughlin
34 Posted 23/11/2011 at 02:50:50
While I would love Everton to play football with gay abandon and send more players forward for attack, I am certain we would be caught out on the counter as the players don't have enough pace to get back and defend. They also tend to lose the ball too easily.
Jamie Sweet
35 Posted 23/11/2011 at 03:10:40
Michael #33. Are you David Moyes in disguise? It is that kind of negativity that permeates the mind of our manager, and is the reason we play the boring defensive shite brand of football that we do.

Yes, you may slightly increase your chances of conceeding a goal to a counter-attack if you commit a few more players forward in an attacking move. But you also significantly increase your chance of scoring a goal too! It isn't rocket science. And scoring goals is what this game is about.

I'm astounded that some people can't see what is wrong with playing a game which focussing more on not conceeding goals than it does on scoring them. It is the reason why we aren't much fun to watch these days, and I'm sick of it.
Stephen Kenny
36 Posted 23/11/2011 at 08:45:27
Tony,

"He wasn't played because he was an overweight lazy barsteward... he still is."

I agree 100%. But what does any of that matter as long as he scores goals? He's proving yet again, that he's capable. Perhaps he wouldn't close down the fullbacks?

Thomas Windsor
37 Posted 23/11/2011 at 08:41:54
I do think it is time to try and sell Cahill, he's not done it now for at least a season and a half.

He's been a great buy but time stops for no player.
Dan McKie
38 Posted 23/11/2011 at 09:06:49
Max #29, spot on about Blackpool, and those that say 'yeah but they went down' don't realise that Everton has/had 10 times the quality of the Blackpool side, especially in defence where most of Blackpool's were playing League 1 and 2 football a season or two previous to that.

If we went to the likes of Man U and got beat 5-3 for having a go, I would still be unhappy that we lost, but much happier than when we go 11 men behind the ball, don't even try to attack and wait for them to score, which they always do! We would have battered most of the other teams though.
Tony J Williams
39 Posted 23/11/2011 at 09:22:18
"When was the last time the first team scored 4!!! " - Why 4? Could it be that we have scored 3 on three occassions this season?

Why 4? Do we get more points for that?
We scored 5 on three occassions last season too.
Peter Barnes
40 Posted 23/11/2011 at 10:44:01
I would definitely support (#16) Derek's piont of view. I do understand the concerns about being stung by counter-attacks from the stronger teams but the likes of Wolves at home... Hardly! It is also true that the regular defence regularly concedes goals anyway. So why not attack more? It may actually help our defence having a little less to do.

The big thing for me though is the passing. What on earth has happened to it? Moyes has never particularly constructed a passing side but at the moment it is just woeful.
Max Main
41 Posted 23/11/2011 at 11:40:28
Jamie -

Blackpool is just an example of a team trying to play the kind of attacking football that everyone wants to see when they don't have the quality to get away with it. Everton also fall into that bracket. Only a very few teams can actually play that kind of football and be successful. Barcelona etc.

Can you name one team who have been in a similar position to us and who have been successful playing without caution?

I'm 99% sure David Moyes would play a more attacking style if he could. If he had the money that some of the other teams have and if he could buy players who suit that style. To play this style you need players of genuine pace and quality (Bale, Lennon and whatnot) but they cost money, and clearly we don't have money. Clearly if Moyes had Daniel Levy's checkbook a couple of years ago we would have signed Donovan who would have added pace and width to the side, but Kenwright's checkbook expired years ago and thus Moyes is left with youngsters and loan signings.

All I'm saying is that we do not have the players to play that style, or the money to buy the players who could play that style. So Moyes does the best with what he is stuck with.
Peter Murphy
42 Posted 23/11/2011 at 13:03:17
Tony J Williams comment 4 ? that made me laugh out loud, just snorted soup and toast all over, thanks mate!
Colm Nealon
43 Posted 23/11/2011 at 13:08:13
Max, Beattie was bought for £6 mil. Played out of position or up on his own. He needed someone up with him. Same can be said about Andy Johnson, isolated up top or right wing?

Simon Davies ? good player but didn't suite our system; went to Fulham and did great. Etc...

I like Cahill, the way he talks about the club, but i think our team is based around him and our formation won't change as long as he's here.
David Booth
44 Posted 23/11/2011 at 13:24:08
Tony (15): this isn't aimed at you personally, but I wish people would stop this ridiculous theory that Coleman can't defend...

Where on earth does it come from?

The lad's never started a game in his natural right back position and seems to be being judged on the game against Benfica away (?), when he was shoehorned-in at left back and the whole team performed woefully.

I think I am right in saying that he made his debut as a right back against Spurs and in less than half a game was man-of-the-match.

So to the contrary, I think he proved himself a fabulous defender ? completely negating Bale, who had torn us to shreds before Coleman's arrival and frightening Spurs to death when he charged forward.

Paradoxically, it is time he WAS played at right back, because he is clearly NOT a winger and needs a ball to run on to and use his pace, as opposed to it being played to his feet or behind him and expecting him to bedazzle the opposing full back with his (lack of), dribbling skills!

I think he did rather well at Blackpool playing as a marauding full back too.

So if anyone still maintains he can't defend, where's the evidence?

Please, fellow Toffeewebbers, stop this completely unfounded assumption in future.
Sam Hoare
45 Posted 23/11/2011 at 14:04:58
David, I believe people who watched Blackpool frequently suggested that in his time there he was good at attacking but pretty atrocious at defending. Don't know myself. I'd certainly be curious to see him at RB a few more times.
Tony J Williams
46 Posted 23/11/2011 at 14:19:19
David, Coleman came on in the 15th minute for an injured Yobo. Bale didn't come on until the second half, as he was carrying a slight injury.

So please David, stop this completely unfounded assumption in future.

The game where we beat them 2-1 it was Neville doing the defending and after the game he was then "trending"???? on Twatter.

I am basing my view on his defending from all the games I have watched him and he is not better than Hibbert or Neville at right back. I wish he was because he would get more space overlapping the winger and would potentially be more dangerous... unfortunately he is not.
Lee Mandaracas
47 Posted 23/11/2011 at 14:34:16
Tony J Williams : DAVID COLEMAN came on in the 15th minute...??? Did they exhume him for the appearance? "Eeeerrrrrrrr, that's extraordinary!"

Sorry, I know you have a comma after 'David' but I just couldn't resist :)
Tony J Williams
48 Posted 23/11/2011 at 14:41:37
Lee, I suppose that is just a Question of Sport.....doh!
Ray Roche
49 Posted 23/11/2011 at 16:18:46
Lee.

If he was exhumed then he must have been buried alive. He's not dead.
David Booth
50 Posted 23/11/2011 at 17:21:08
Tony (46), I stand corrected about the timings ? must be my early-onset Alzheimer's.

However, he is untried at right back and this continuing speculation ? and that is all it is, based on the evidence we Evertonians have seen ? IS unfounded.

Give him 15/20 games at right back for us and then we'll be able to comment on how good or not so good he is don't you think?

He's a popular player, but he's not a winger and he's been sussed.

Playing him at full back means he can get forward relatively unmarked until further up the pitch, by which time his pace and directness will come into play.

Time he was given a chance...
Tony J Williams
51 Posted 23/11/2011 at 17:32:11
"Playing him at full back means he can get forward relatively unmarked until further up the pitch, by which time his pace and directness will come into play" - I completely agree, just that I worry about him defensively
Brendan McLaughlin
52 Posted 23/11/2011 at 22:29:18
David #50

So Moyes doesn't think Coleman's good enough but you want him to get 15/20 games so you can judge? Yeah that's the way most Premier League managers run their clubs.
David Booth
53 Posted 23/11/2011 at 22:46:54
You're missing the point, Brendan, which is that he needs to prove (or disprove) this urban myth that he cannot defend. The only way to do that is by giving him the opportunity to do so... by playing him in his 'natural' position? The 'pacy winger' experiment is not working any more.
Brendan McLaughlin
54 Posted 23/11/2011 at 22:52:39
David #53
I rather think you are missing the point. I don't think "disproving urban myths" appears anywhere on David Moyes's or indeed any Premier League manager's job description. And rightly so.
Mike Gaynes
55 Posted 24/11/2011 at 00:49:10
David Booth... re your "urban myth"... for what it's worth, I watched Coleman in three games when he was on loan at Blackpool, including in the playoff final against Cardiff, and he was terrible defensively. He marked poorly and was repeatedly caught ballwatching and out of position. He needed that speed and tackling ability all right, because he was so frequently on the wrong side of his man.

Check out the goal he gave up late in the second half to Cardiff (you can probably find it on YouTube), when he wanders towards the ball and leaves his man unmarked in front of goal, and you'll see a player whose defensive instincts are non-existent.

You're welcome to your opinion, of course. My opinion is that the smart forwards in the Prem would eat him alive, and I think Moyes has done exactly the right thing in converting him to wide midfield.
David Booth
56 Posted 24/11/2011 at 08:25:17
Well you obviously know better ? on the evidence of three Blackpool games and a YouTube clip.

It's confirmed: Coleman is a crap defender. How wrong I was to suggest otherwise and that he might be given an opportunity to disprove it by being played at right back. 45 years as an Evertonian and that's how much I know...
Gavin Ramejkis
57 Posted 24/11/2011 at 08:41:08
David #56 did you go to any of the pre-season friendlies? Moyes tried Coleman as a right back a few times and he looked really poor ? and that's from my own 42-year-old eyeballs.
David Booth
58 Posted 24/11/2011 at 09:25:27
Gavin... a few pre-season games too. God, the evidence is damning?

Tell you what though, I've seen four of five goals that have been the direct result of Baines letting his man ghost in behind him already this season.

Perhaps he can't play full back either gentlemen?
Jimmy Kelly
59 Posted 24/11/2011 at 13:42:16
David, you're seriously embarrassing yourself here.

Your point was that people were saying Coleman couldn't defend without having seen him play at right back, you used an example of one game as your evidence that he could.

Since then the one game you quoted has been exposed as completely inaccurate and a number of people have mentioned that actually, they have seen him and he wasn't very good. And yet you continue to suggest that you would know better

I can add my voice to people who have seen him at right back and i didn't rate him there either, in pre-season, at blackpool or away at bolton for us where he played there for about 10 minutes and looked awful. I'm not saying he'll never make it at full back but I have no reason to believe Moyes is wrong to keep him away at the moment.

As an aside, it is possible for players to change positions as they come through the ranks. I'm assuming none of you would like to see Tony Hibbert play in central midfield as he was known to do in the youth team? Or maybe you'd like us to convert Hallam Hope back to left back?
David Booth
60 Posted 24/11/2011 at 16:22:39
Jimmy, no. I just think the experiement as a winger has failed and his most impressive performance of all was at right back.

He's a professional footballer, playing in the Premier League for Everton ? can he not be coached to become a better defender (whilst retaining his attacking talents) and would it be an absolute disaster (as my gainsayers are suggesting), if it didn't work?

After all, we're not exactly blessed in that department are we with Hibbert and Neville as the other alternatives (no offence guys!)?

What amazes me is this holier-than-thou attitude, that has never manifested itself to fans who go to the game like me, that 'the lad can't defend'?

Forget Blackpool, friendly games (where no-one can be arsed anyway) and You Tube ? give him the Number 2 shirt and let's see for ourselves.

Until then, no-one knows: neither those who say he can't or me who believes he ought to be given a chance.

Have any of our defenders distinguished themselves anyway this season... he can't do any worse can he?
Brendan McLaughlin
61 Posted 24/11/2011 at 20:56:25
David #60
Moyes knows and thats why he's not playing there.
Mike Gaynes
62 Posted 24/11/2011 at 21:30:28
What's with the sarcasm, David? I didn't insult your opinion, just supported mine.

Yes, it could be an absolute disaster. With our attacking problems, one additional defensive mistake per game... just one... could be catastrophic. Hibbert won't make that mistake.

And for the record, I think Hibbo has had a very good season. He's been his solid self at the back and his passing and crossing have improved significantly.
David Booth
63 Posted 24/11/2011 at 23:11:08
Let's leave things exactly as they are then ? it's obviously all working perfectly.

Coleman's the new Kanchelskis and suddenly Hibbert's the new Gary Stevens...
Brendan McLaughlin
64 Posted 24/11/2011 at 23:18:36
Yes David #63
Let's leave things exactly as they are. Let's accept that it's the manager who is best placed to decide who's worth a run of 15/20 games and in what position. If you want to be more directly involved in selection... try the X-Factor.
David Booth
65 Posted 25/11/2011 at 00:04:38
I have every faith in our manager and have supported him extensively on here. However, things are clearly stagnating on the pitch and need shaking-up.

I really like Coleman, but we have absolutely no penetration down the right. If all those who have replied to me above are satisfied with that, then I clearly am wasting my breath.

And much as I'm proud to have David Moyes as our manager, it is clear he needs to revolutionise his thinking right now. With the resources available, that means working with what he's got and switching the odd player here and there. Coleman to right back seems an obvious one, as does dropping Osman and playing Fellaini and Rodwell one in front of the other (as opposed to them breathing each other's oxygen side-by-side in front of the defence in a frustrating Lampard/Gerrard conundrum).

On the left, Drenthe seems to have some potential in front of Baines and Barkley is well worth the 'risk' in the middle. Stick Vellios up front with Saha and we've got a pacy, fluid, skillful 4-4-2, instead of the stagnant, loose-fitting square pegs in round holes that is taking us backwards right now.

However, if you chaps think Coleman in front of Hibbert is OK, then welcome to more of the cul-de-sac lack football we have seen in virtually every game so far this season.

I am not telling Moyes how to do his job. However, I am entitled to my opinion after watching my team more than 1,000 times. You would think I am suggesting we play Coleman in goal judging by the over-reaction to what was just a well-intended suggestion.

All I am saying ? so no words or inference need to be put into my mouth please ? is give the lad a chance. What we have got down the right now is predictable and containable. Better to try (something different) and fail than fail to try...
Mark Wilson
66 Posted 25/11/2011 at 07:34:21
"Or maybe they are both bubbling bags of wank"!!!

There I was about to wade in with some pithy, well considered analysis and then I saw that Tony's analysis as above rendered anything from me, and all others, a bit, well, dull ! Mind you, I'm now having a game in my head considering Everton players past and present who might be awarded the accolade of "Biggest Bubbling Bag of Wank" and it's actually quite difficult as sadly there are a fair number of contenders.

Still, onwards and upwards to the next "bubbling bag of" performance... COYB !
Brendan McLaughlin
67 Posted 25/11/2011 at 23:52:44
David #65
I would realy love for you to be proved right about Coleman but untl then no hard feelings...COYB!
Gavin Ramejkis
68 Posted 26/11/2011 at 00:14:57
David a quick question for you ignoring what I and others have said having seen Coleman play at right back and that your perceived wisdom suddenly lands at the foot of Gollum and he drops Neville and Hibbert, who would then play up on the right wing?

My personal view is that Hibbert is a better right back than Neville as a defender but woeful going forward, Neville has the edge on Hibbert going forward up the pitch slightly but loses out with an inability to find a blue shirt when he does cross the ball. Coleman is a one trick pony, Forrest Gump like; head down and sprints, not great but better at going forward than defending as his positional sense as a right back against pacy wingers is poor.

He may learn the skills needed later but right now my money would be to leave him where he is.
Michael Winstanley
69 Posted 26/11/2011 at 00:29:48
Coleman will get better with age. The more he plays the more he'll learn and the better he'll get.
Experience is all that matters for him right now. He's only in his second season in top flight football.
I hope at some point he does become our right back but now is not the time. Maybe once we hit 40 points Moyes might start to swap players about as he looks towards next season.

My main reason for not wanting Coleman at right back now is I think we'd have to play with two defensive midfielders which means Neville would be on the pitch.
Mike Gaynes
70 Posted 26/11/2011 at 01:03:02
Agree, Gavin and Michael... Coleman's a one-trick pony, but it's a good trick. His confident willingness to attack off the dribble will grow increasingly valuable as he learns when, and when not, to take on two defenders. And with Drenthe on the other side, this is the first time in years we've had two wing midfielders with the stones to run at anybody. I'm enjoying it a lot.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads